The Newshour Debate: Racist Shame - Full Debate (16th Oct 2014)
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 10. 2014
- In another instance of violence against Northeastern people, three youth from Nagaland were allegedly thrashed and injured by eight persons for refusing to have drinks with the attackers at Sikenderpur in Gurgaon Wednesday (Oct. 14) night. While two Naga youths sustained severe injuries on different parts of their bodies, the other suffered minor injuries. One of them identified as James, a call centre employee, had his hair cut by the attackers, police said. According to the Station House Officer of DLF Phase 1 Police Station, the James, his call centre colleague, whose name was not disclosed by police, and Aayug, an unemployed youth were living in a rented room at Sikenderpur. Eight youth belonging to Sikenderpur village got into a heated argument with them when the trio refused to have drink with them. They then beat up the Naga youth and cropped Jamess hairs, he said. The Naga youth were admitted in Gurgaon Civil Hospital where they underwent a medical examination this morning, said the SHO. James, alias Alato, has been referred to Safdarjung Hospital in Delhi for further treatment. The police lodged an FIR on the basis of the medical report and the victims' statements. The SHO said some of the culprits have been identified and "we would soon arrest all of them." Expressing concern over growing incidents of assault on northeastern people, Home Minister Rajnath Singh said he would take up the issue with concerned state governments, particularly Karnataka where three northeastern students were assaulted for not speaking in Kannada, for strict action against the culprits. "I will talk to the Karnataka Chief Minister. Action should be taken. No one can discriminate against anyone on the basis of caste, creed and sect," Singh told reporters in Manesar near Gurgaon. The Home Ministry wrote to Haryana government seeking a report on the incident and the steps taken to apprehend the accused. In a communication to Haryana government, the Home Ministry said steps should be taken immediately against the guilty and the report detailing the incident should be sent as early as possible.
In a debate moderated by TIMES NOW's Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami, panelists -- Priyanka Chaturvedi, Spokesperson, Congress; Nupur Sharma, Member Natl Exceutive, Bhartiya Janta Yuva Morcha; Binalaxmi Nepram, Social Activist; Dr Alana Gonmei, Founding Member & Secy, North East Support Centre and Helpline; Rahul Easwar, Social Activist; Ritabrata Banerjee, MP Rajya Sabha, CPI (M) -- discuss whether #RacistShame is a big blot on urban India.
If racism is not real, then how come i face it everyday while trying to get an auto?
I love NE people ..they r most decipline ,patriotic and very stylish ...
Yes we are❤️🇮🇳
@XYZ What do you mean?
what you're?
@XYZ we are patriotic 🇮🇳❤️
I feel safe n i proud my self that i born in NE here girls can walk even in night no judgements on their dress ,we don't use acid we don't spoil a life
Well said👏👏👏
proud of being from north east..... and proud of arnub
Darpana Dutta love u northeast
Arafat Tonmoy atleast we don’t look like a slave n we don’t smell like shit n also didn’t ur parents teach u anything or just teach u how to call ne people racist or is ur parents like u
Really Arnav is a true Jounalist. I Appreciated him.
If you can see our northeast keep their calm... Give me a thumps up
They called us junglii bcoz most of our states are hilly plus we've lots of forest and all ... but our peoples don't shit on railway tracks like other Indian peoples so i guess they're the junglii who lives in city 😜
Head shot bro👍
the guy who is rasing his hand is so cute lol. He is the best. 😂 Its like he is in a class and the teacher is just ignoring him when he raises😂
🤣🤣🤣
He raised his hands quite long and many times LoL
I am from NE i love my country not my government..
I find North poeple lovely and decent .very easy going people they are .my boss is also from North east..he is such a humble person
Very feel proud of my state lady binalskhsmi
Arnab is also from Guwahati
not becouse arnab is from gauhati fight for racist but a sense of humanity.
Arafat Tonmoy you go to hell owl eye
h l u t e a p a u t u , Armando is a sheet
India is a dustbin country...and a blaming country....indian people are working only in a blaming each other brand factory...lol
I am proud to be from Northeast region......
I like Arnab Goswami for taking up this debate...bless you
I m proud to be an Indian.
But I am more proud to be a Northeast Indian. Cuz not a single being from delhi, bengaluru etc ever died after racist attacks on North East India. We just pray lighting candles and marching for what we had lost. No, We also pray for the foolish people to wake up for the sake of humanity.
Nupur n priyanka are are messing around the healthy debate.. Thankful To Binalaxmi for your poignant, egalitarian, reasonable n scientific points..
Arnab ji sir, I always respect you and you have potential to fight with any issue in our country.so fight against racist and discrimination against NE people. Because we are Indian not Chinese and we have right to speak and travel any part within the country.
Wow Alana, solid answer: u take my face, I’ll take your face and we will go out and see how we feel like to be. Amazing
Come to the Northern states specially in Nagaland u are more safer than ur own states#Trust me,a punjabi friend of mine once told me
"only in Nagaland u can roam anywhere even in the middle of the Night"#just ask any outsiders who have visited Nagaland#
@@iTachiUchiha-nh1km same to you
Bina lakshmi we need more ppl like u
Rahul Easwar being a Kerala brahmin should be the best authority on racist practices practiced by the brahmins of Tamil Nadu and Kerala. No wonder he does not want to hear the word "racism". That could op[en a pandora's box.
justin natarajan all Christians are racists so you don't think so look at the racial segregation in all the churches around the world.I'm a Brahmin and I have people of every ethnicity in my family so please you umbrella statements prove you sir are racist and classist.
wow Christians are racists how you fell when i say all brahmin are racists
In whole india high rank in social status don't talk about racism, casteism
arnab u r true journalist
For your information...he had worked for 22 years for this profession ...so I think you understand now what kind of person he is.
Arnab sir is very telented news anchor in all over india
Yes but sometimes he doesn't like others speak
Tripura should not have joined India in 1949 , it was tremendous mistake on our part to joined India instead should continue as independent country as it was.
Yes. We feel the same way. Sikkim should not have joined India. It should have remained has independent country.
Yes even Nagaland!!
It is so good for india also because we don't want to see Chinese 😂😂😂😂
@@pratimamoktan4244 Sikkim got huge money for joining India. My father lived in Gangtok and worked in State Bank Gangtok branch for 4 years and told me all this. If Sikkim would have not joined India its condition would have been same as Tibet. Sikkim has nothing, they buy all essentials from West Bengal using money provided by Central Government.
If you can’t see the problem, You can’t fix it.
Rahul Easwar is the main problem to racist....... He should learn a lot many things.
The Racist mfs can't accept the fact there is Racism. God bless Arnab Goswami for always fighting for the truth fearlessly. Arnab the pride of Northeast and India as a whole.
Seriously if central govt. can't handle our northeast problem then they should let us free...feeling sad
That's idiotic really...as a north eastern I will never aggree with this.
We enough BJP and Congress,, enough enough enough enough!!
Arnab you're the one, thank-you for opening a platform like this one but debating will not be a solution, we need the govt to punish all the racists n enact a strict law against racism n a on the spot helpline numbers for such incidents.
I salute that new channel
nly 29 likess.
people dnt like us
thy dnt like the 8 sisters .
Lol ye to jabardasti hai...ppl from 8sisters and rest of 21states are equal and should not be treated differently.
I personally like or dislike ppl based on there personality not from which states they belong.
@Living On The Edge LifeStyleDude think before you speak up...
Sorry bro it is 7 Hills state.
Give a sec, Arnub. Let them Talk! but still great JOB on the debate. Long live NE.
17:43 keep blaming each other 🤣😂😎
I just wonder what will be this interview like if, it happens today, after the Corona related abuse on NE Indians in Delhi, Ahemdabad and other places in India. What will be the great journalist's response?
Everyone I meet in south India asks me, "are you from China"
Cause you look like that , what's their fault , why don't you easily tell them where you actually come from
@@sattwikmohanty3272 seriously man 🤦♂️. Get well soon
Am sorry ignorance is too much and it should addressed
The question should be like this, " are you from north east?"
@@omkarbalashi5204 i agree with you.. but i also believe we have to mature past the point where we have to ask where they r from...
Am from North-East watching this laughing 🤭🤭😂. Got it ?? I don't know why.
Thanks arnap congratulation
Good to see Alana and Bina Laksmi
Love this journalist
Mizoram is not part of India till British expedition, late 19th century. India and Mizoram did not share the same history till the late 19th century. During independence, we choose to be Indian. Mizoram is the 23rd state of india. Don't brought in the history. We are uniquely different. Our culture is different, our way of living is different etc. But we are Indian. Marked this
@PalePinkGeneticAnnihilationTY HeroinFentanylOpioids exactly.
@@lalramengmawia8660 sister we are sorry for your discrimination but all Indians are not racist some people did in Delhi but target the whole Indian, that is very shameful, sister India is a land of Gautamn Bhuddha.
I love your news channel
I'm proud to be a Northeast..with all the discrimination we are facing
Well said Mr Arnab. Gowsmami, my hat is off to you.
People in the states of northeast India, including Arunachal Pradesh, whose major territory is claimed by the China as part of South Tibet, were severely discriminated against by other regions of India, since residents there look more like Chinese than Indians. The girls from northeast India, simply because their lighter skin color and their eye's often become targets of rapists. Over the years, India fails to invest any capital into these regions, resulting in their economic development severely lagging behind the rest of the country. Because of that, people from these states are always seeking independence, many of whom want to join China.
Why don’t India gives the NE part to China, so Chinese can give a good lesson to Delhi????
China should step in and take the northest indian states. Indians from different states hate each other, then What is the point to maintain one India?
northeast states should merge with China, the former for communism and cultural affinity and the latter for ethnic composition. It is enough with Hindustani rule. They will enjoy more prosperous development .
China should take over this province. They will be treated in a more civilized manner.
When china fighted with India in 1962, no one citizen was harrased by the Chinese army. People from Assam and Arunachal treated the Indian army who fled away from war at their best. Ask any any veteran from the 1962 war. But the sad part is that Indian army raped woman from 13 years old girl to 60 years old lady during battles against the local militant of NE, as if they have been told that NE is a colony of India. India always dominated North east people and India will lose northeast one day it will be a China state in future. northeast people never take China support to fight with India but the time has come.
(Azadi hamara haq hai )
+Narayan Bhamidipati bulshit!!! Racism exists in India. whole word knows! facts reveal. don't deny it.don't camouflage..
Well said .
I stand firm with Our North-East Brothers and Sisters. I too agree, We Indians are Racist, Do a High and Middle Income Family has any Place in the the House. Do Poor People touch any Decent Dressed Person and get Scape free! The North-East People are more Indian than Others. You should know Assam was never Invaded by Any Invaders and It shows their Bravery and Patriotism!
Arnab sir you are the men you really know the humanity and human value big salute sir
Please make time more for Bina Laksmi ❤️❤️🙏.
Just one question if the leader who is in debate didnt accept then imagine how will the follower be?
If India does not take care of us , we will work for China and help them .. better divide India into pieces like in 1840s where India is was rule by many kings
Is your wish or what?????
You can divide india
We are also proud as an indian our country is not china i am also from assam what is humanity l do not know.
7000 views it proves we are racist
There is needed to keep syllabus in Indian history about north east and somewhat will be reduced about this matter
I like when Arnab call Alana and Bina.. love it. This time m with Arnab
Well said Arnab
Racism is now developing in lndia, the world is now watching our racism country, north east people felling more prey, because of corona virus
Northeast bhai walo yeh indian walo ko kabhi bhi biswas mat karo yeh lok sirf muh me baat krta he kuch help nhi krne wala he isse acha hai ki china ke sath jur jao...
Kuch saal baat khutka country honga love u 4m northeast
dont make things worse by giving anti indian comments. we may have a racism problem but that doesnt mean that we should join china. wat r u saying bullshit. we r northeastern n first indian n we have no interest in joining china n dont dare to give this propaganda. it is our own countries internal mamla and we will solve it by ourselves. becoz watever we r all indians not chinese. we accept racism but not at the cost of your idea giving us you unprecious comment that we should join china. u nepal join china but dont dare say it to northeastern. we r indians n we love all our indians from any state. but not at the cost of joining china. u may be anti indian we r not. we r proud indians n we will sort it out.
North easterns are Indians
Rahul leachwar is the worst man alive in this country shameless and 54 thousand cr for NE should we laugh, there is nothing done for the people leave Shillong n rest of the states have look in guwahati no proper drainage system, no proper roads,nothing done they are spending the money in celebrating namami Brahmaputra which was a loss due to rain cr of money was wasted and making largest bridge was not that important. nothing is done for the people of NE so where did the 54 thousand cr went?
Their is no any 'but' that I can place in this comment because it is universally true that our Country is truely racist and we Indians should be ashamed of ourselves on what we do.
Government should make anti racial law. we all are indians we need to respect each other...Jai Hind
give everyone chance to speak and debate like gentleman.
People have to start fighting back.
That tie 👔👔wala is dominating...... He is preventing the others from speaking...
i dont find any thing bad with those pretty faces see they r also indian
Arnab...you did a good job
plz talk in hindi....we can understan better
This is the reason why Northeast are demanding for a different state and country or you can submit us to China at least we will be happy with them and that way in some few years help China
I proud to call myself as a proud Indian....sharrreee jahan se acha hindu sita hmreee....love from Arunachal Pradesh....dear mainlanders stop racism...
At last he spoke up.
Northeastern people should be independent. We want them in Asean. Indians will always discriminate against them.
I love my motherland Northeast I'm Proud to be North East
Whose voice is superior over whom ..The end
Well done arnab ....
they are jealous of us
Its an appeal to Arnab to kindly conduct such debate even now. Cos stil Nothing has changed!
OMG I really liked Rahul Eeshwar....but now 😖😖
Go ahead... Put the blame on each other's.. Keep on fighting
Arnab can we have civilized discussions please.
It's a civilized debate but you can see the uncivilized one who cant accept racism here.
18:40 OMG 5 persons speaking at same time, who should I be listened to.
This is still a serious issues....
Good Arnab...kindly adress that people from Darjeeling also are being targeted...we are very good frns with the North Easterns and are being a victim of racism when we leave West Bengal
21:57 Bina Laksmi ❤️❤️. When she's talking, no one has the gut to crossfinger because she knows what she is taking about & has larger views ❤️❤️.
Good job arnab sir👍
We are proud to be northeastern.... And those who don't want to believe that we are racist.. Middle finger salute for them maksudai bilak
Bina Laksmi laughs when she got the point. I like that 🤭🤭❤️❤️❤️. We think more than talk 💖💖.
Vry nice...... blaming each others 😂😡😡😡😡😂😂
It's about in big cities. Think about in small cities and villages.
Benalakshmi nepram you rock
@18:00 whom am I listening to?🙄🙄🙄
My question is what is racism according to Rahul issore
Hi Firstly understand what is racist & racism Hello Miss. why did NE People always thinking of NE People or theirself only why don't don't they think others.NE are not only one who face such a problem & they are not complaining to others like you NE people do now see how I would say that Indians are not as racist as you think, but that is only by a technicality. Being racist essentially means that you discriminate people on the basis of their race (which is often by colour). Now there is discrimination alive in our country on the basis of colour. Anyone who watches T.V. will have seen the 'Fair & Lovely' ad (or the more recent 'Fair & Handsome' ads), not to mention those numerous classifieds where bride is described to have 'wheatish' complexion (because heavens forbid that they be dark!). So while we are certainly fixated on 'fairness', the kind of discrimination that you face is less. And I won't even bother starting off on the manners we dish out to our North Eastern states (I have often felt that they are the sanest people in our Nation!).
Now if we decide to chuck the technicality, I am ashamed to say that we are undoubtedly VERY racist. We treat people from different states differently. I have been at the receiving end. I was discriminated by Kannadigas because I am a Malayali (a mallu as commonly known). Now if we go to the northern regions, both of us are discriminated as 'madrasis'. And no... we are not the victims alone. You can ask a mallu what their take on any North Indian or Tamilian is. You will find an equally discriminatory answer. The sad thing is that while our fixation with colour never leads to isolation all that much, the fact that you are from a certain state will certainly lead to that.
We crack jokes on 'Sardars', put down Biharis, say 'Madrasis' are uncouth, think 'Nexis' (our college term for people from NE) are full of loose women and that 'Gujjus' are money-minded misers, think... Yes folks... Welcome to Incredible India!
The only way to overcome these thoughts is to actually get to know different people. You will meet some of the most intelligent and proud people among the Sardars. A Bihari can make you laugh with their jokes on Lalu! A Madrasi will teach you that KFC is not the only cuisine that is 'Finger lickin good'. A Nexi can teach you on how you need NOT live in a metro to be forward in you thinking. A Gujju can teach you how to follow a passion (a certain Gujju still owes me a proper treat though!). Yes folks... Welcome to Incredible India!
When we interact with different types of people we develop understanding and is the only way to stop discrimination.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY THERE IS A HUE-N-CRY OVER ON RACISM WHICH IS ACTUALLY NOT IN REALITY NE PEOPLE SHOULD HAVE CHANGE THERE MENTALITY FIRST. EVERY PERSON U FIND RACIST IN INDIA NE ALSO INDIAN CITIZEN WHY DID NE PEOPLE DENIED IT WHY WHY ?" I REQUESTED TO U DON'T SEE ALL INDIANS IN A ONE VISION EVRYONE KNOWS THAT WHAT IS HAPPENED IN USA WITH BLACK PEOPLE DURING OLDEN DAYS
Primodial beings from an ancient society or is it disfranchised wisdom of an ancient society gone wrong?
I am also from Assam.
If we northeasterns start the same back home then it will be worse.
Jack Yanlem please never !!!!
Let's join hands to fight it together as Indians.
This u not a debate.
Be like human learn to be live humanity.we r all people what kind of people there r .if they r humans who did this must understand
Hats off to Arnab Goswami.👍
This is how NE Indians behave. They are not cross talking...
Wao.....Arnab is the true leader.......he is patriotic man....
What do we really in freedom in this Country to live as we like. if not then...
Half to b filled glass
Arnab: oh god😂😂
Sadly 7 years later racism still exists
I have seen you more than 2 times today on North east racism related videos
Yes it’s frustrating