Israel-Hamas War 2023 Summarized | Animated History
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 03. 2024
- WATCH FREE FOR 1 MONTH: "UNCENSORED100" (case sensitive)
Sign up for Armchair History TV today! join.armchairhistory.tv/4arTJoE
Uncensored Video: armchairhistory.tv/supporters...
Merchandise available at armchairhistory.tv/collection...
Android App: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
IOS App: apps.apple.com/us/app/armchai...
Armchair Historian Video Game: store.steampowered.com/app/16...
Support us on Patreon: / armchairhistorian
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / armchairhist
Sources:
docs.google.com/document/d/1q...
Music:
Armchair Team Credits:
docs.google.com/document/d/1s...
WATCH FREE FOR 1 MONTH: "UNCENSORED100" (case sensitive)
Sign up for Armchair History TV today! join.armchairhistory.tv/4arTJoE
Uncensored Video: armchairhistory.tv/supporters/videos/40225
Merchandise available at armchairhistory.tv/collections/all
Android App: play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.fourthwall.wla.armchairhistory
IOS App: apps.apple.com/us/app/armchair-history-tv/id6471108801
Armchair Historian Video Game: store.steampowered.com/app/1679290/Fire__Maneuver/
Support us on Patreon: www.patreon.com/armchairhistorian
Discord: discord.gg/thearmchairhistorian
Twitter: twitter.com/ArmchairHist
Clicking the uncensored video link prompts me to sign up and provide my credit card details. It's setting up a recurring charge, isn't it? That's not what "free" means in my world.
it was captured on a residents cellphone video, where sderot police were shooting any cars driving around - perhaps assuming that they could be enemies,. Theses videos were posited on social media by pro israelis sayiing that the police pinned down (behind a dark suv) were hamas), but they were actually the local police. the same group were in other videos, one where a red hatchback was lit up by the group. Those events were wrongly attributed on social media to the palestinian millitants. @6:40
i like your content, good thing CZcams ignores you and my preferences and instead constantly tries to suggest pseudoscience, misinformation and conspiracy theories instead, cuz you know, like, free speech and clicks and all that
Can you make a video about the Tigray War (2020-2022) in Ethiopia, please?
Radical Islam: This is Jihad, Hezbollah, the Taliban, Hamas. Their ideology is an extreme religion and they believe that the Jews must be destroyed for their very existence. The false politics they spread is so twisted. And they certainly succeeded in fooling the entire Western world. They laugh in your face. Hamas will not change its ways. I wonder how many innocents will be murdered until the West, its campuses and the media understand!!!!. The Palestinians in the eyes of their leaders have no value, they use them for their own purposes in moves that inspire horror and disgust. Israel will never surrender, has history taught you nothing? Every enemy of the State of Israel of the Jews will end up extinct!!! Israel will stay here forever.
I think it's stupid that CZcams is censoring stuff like this. Like bro just let them teach.
You can only teach state approved propaganda
100% agree
*papers please theme intensifies*
Even if that were true, are you saying you would rather them not teach any history? Is that worse then presenting a potentially biased perspective?
Let him teach! 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥
1 hour later : this video was deleted due to violations of youtube community guidelines
Imagine
CZcams has decided this is not promoting zionism and therefore is in violtation of the deep state messaging.
14 more mins.
@@ElizabetFlores-qg4kkmight aswell record this just incase they remove it
54 minutes into the upload
"What is Jerusalem worth?"
"Nothing. Everything."
Salahuddin quotes give shivers
That’s the point hamas/Palestine have nothing to do in Jerusalem of course they are welcomed in their but just how the quote says “nothing everything”
??@@1The_Cilencer1
@@1The_Cilencer1 muslims have things to do with Palestine and Jerusalem since al Aqsa mosque is in Jerusalem
"I am not THOSE men. I am Saladin. Salah ad-Din."
No matter what your ideology or beliefs or history, intentional attacks on civilians are absolutely wrong. The amount of people who seem to have forgotten that is terrifying.
that's why israel is accused of genocide
@@TheNazemisrael is accused of genocide because they're jews.
You took a blind eye where 30k - 200k lives has lost by *israeli* airstrikes before and after oct 7.
dehumanization working too well
@@Moon___man dehumanization of jews and glorification of jihadist fascists
The comments here are 95% people saying how bad the comments are gonna be, and 5% actually incendiary comments
I love democracy
As of scrolling down this far yeah wow. It feels a bit like a mexican standoff everybody just waiting for the other to make a move haha.
The Jedi were traitors. You were in the right, Senate. Mace Windu violated the Jedi code:
From what I saw its 95% people saying how bad the comments are gonna be and 5% saying theyre watching this video before its removed lol
Sort by new then
“I’m sure this video won’t cause anyone to DIE!” Oversimplified
Armchair's last words
@@DanielSilvalol xd fr
Free PALESTINE
@@pensadorideias7176yes free Palestine from hamas terror!!!!
@@DanielSilvalolYou know he’s right though
The holy land rightfully belongs to Peru 🇵🇪💪
Exactly
Real
Nuh uhhhh, Jerusalem belongs to Indonesia🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
@@musicphilex2124screw that, give it to the swiss
No Mexico 🤠🇲🇽
Me when im in a being pointless competition and my opponent is the United Nations human rights council: 😧
Same could be said for any part of the United Nations tbh.
@@GrandTemplarVigilant nah, the peacekeepers at the very least kicked ass and others like the weapons inspectors actually made an impact at some points. Human rights councils dont do jack
@@therealgeneralMacArthur they're easy to corrupt too.
@@therealgeneralMacArthur only when the peacekeepers were working in support of the US.
@@sameerahamed6198 which is a significant improvement
So I noticed this pattern that when people constantly talk about how bad a comment section is going to be it doesn’t become that bad so everybody comment about how bad the comment sections gonna be.
Now this is genius
Oh dear, these comments are going to become a toxic cesspool.
Why is this true?
It's only been an hour since upload. Give it a day.
sort by newest then you'll see how bad it is
Brave of you to keep comments enabled
that is intentional and strategic. more divisive comments = more commenters = more user engagement = higher in the algorithm this video climbs.
people that are edgelording about this video being imminently taken down by youtube have no idea what they're talking about
He has only ever disabled comments once, on the life in N@zi Germany video
im sure hes having fun banning the fascists in the comments. I know I would...
Glory to freedom of speech
@@deforged there's little controversy on this topic, most people, especially those who have read a history book, are actually pretty unanimous on it except Americans who love arguing with each other and having terrible takes.
Thanks for making a video on the conflict. I am thankful for you covering a recent military issue.
14:25 “contentious and widely debated” why even bring this up if you’re going to pretend like it wasn’t some dumbass pointing at a calendar?
@@ariaugust928
Can you source this?
I would like to see it for myself.
@@sissipartio5721 czcams.com/video/S8a0t1YGEko/video.htmlsi=fsGdTLIyvYsS_vtz
@@sissipartio5721 sent a link on CZcams just google cctv footage hostages al shifa
please show this.@@ariaugust928
@@ariaugust928Please send a link to the video
I like how because everyone commented on how toxic the comment section is, the comment section is no longer toxic. Big brain mode
Nah hamas simp so ignorant of October 7 they wouldn't want to see it here xD
@@NekomiyaTH1. Haifa Massacre 1937
2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3. Haifa Massacre 1938
4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
5. Haifa Massacre 1939
6. Haifa Massacre 1947
7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947
8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947
11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
12. Jaffa Massacre 1948
13. Deir Yassin Massacre- 1948
14. Qibya massacre -1953
15.Tantura Massacre- 1948
16. qibya massacre -1953
17. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
18. Jerusalem Massacre 1967
19. Bahro Al Baquar in 1972
20. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
21. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990
22. lbrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
23. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002
24. Gaza Massacre 2008-09
25. Gaza Massacre 2012
26. Gaza Massacre 2014
27. Gaza Massacre 2018-19
28. Gaza Massacre 2021
29. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing
SO DON'T LET ANYONE TELL YOU IT STARTED ON OCTOBER 7th OVER 75 YEARS OF PALESTINIAN OPPRESSION
It changed. The new comments are all just people coping. Rip
Yeah, and comments are literally a war zone than the conflict itself tho
Biggest brain move
Oh boy, here comes the flame war
I just checked the top comment (in terms of likes) and I already see a free Palestine message
@@The_whales it’s free? How do I collect?
@@The88Cheat claim your god promised it to you, take it by force then if anyone is critical say they are antisemetic.
🍿
@@sasquatchpatrol9317 oh just like the Palestinians did
12:27 a little mistake here
This is the Syrian Eagle in the flag not the Egyptian one
The difference one has its wings folded while the other more a bit spread
no it's jsut a completely different eagle, one is the eagle of salah el din and the other is the eagle of quryash (im 90% sure)
Damn nice catch!
When a corporate news outlet covers an ongoing conflict: Very good content. Lovely work you're doing.
When a non-corporate entity even briefly mentions an ongoing conflict: I want all the algorithms we have to fire on that channel.
Normies: “Oh my God, think of the comments for this video!”
Me: Wait till he does a video on Kashmir.
Oh boy. Ya'll are not ready for Indian internet trolls
@@aimanmarzuqi4804 I still see their comments everytime I close my eyes... You guys are lucky to not speak Hindi/Urdu
What about a video on Kosovo
@@aimanmarzuqi4804 you speak like pakistan does not have any trolls
@@aimanmarzuqi4804faced one of them in Kashmir video similar to this the counter argument is just keep professional and they'll look like total idiots
What a non-controversial video on a topic everyone agrees upon.
😂
What do you mean by a topic that everyone agrees upon?
@@testaccount9531it’s sarcasm
@@urmum3560 Whats the sarcasm though?
After all, hes running a business
Funny how now most comments are about how most comments are talking about how most comments are talking about how toxic this comment section is, when it isn't anymore.
So thankful I saw this before it eventually gets taken down. Liked and subscribed
Viewing this now before CZcams takes it down.
And before a whole battle is in the comment section.
@@ElizabetFlores-qg4kkthe calm before the inevitable storm
And before it gets demonetized
You guys always say this
CZcams isnt gonna take it down, all they do is demonetize controversial subjects
This video was fantastic. I hope that one day you do an earlier history about this. Maybe starting around 48 or even earlier.
14:39 they didn't say it was a calendar, they said it was a list of hamas agents
can you read arabic ? thats what i thought hahaha
@@khaledreal7546 yes
انا مصري
True... This video got this point completely wrong.
Keep exposing the Zi0nist lies.
That is true, those soldiers couldn't read arabic
Actually they said both, they said it was a list of shifts for terrorists to watch the hostages
SELLING COLD BEER TO THOSE WHO CAME TO READ THE COMMENTS
Thanks
🍻
Oh dang, nice :3
🍻
Here’s some food🍔🌭🌮
I love how everyone is so respectful and informative about this topic. Also surprised it hasn’t gotten taken down yet
“War is cruelty, and you cannot refine it.”
-General Sherman
"But is also sometimes necessary for a better world" -me
@@Goffs20are you sure?
@@khaaan7905 yes seeing as my own famliy members died in the 7th of October along side 1200 other innocent people, this CANT happen agian.
@@Goffs20 Let me ask you a question? Will you carry arms in revenge? What if you kill innocent more innocent people, intentional or not?
@@Goffs20I'd say if I was in the district that some idiots that killed some of your loved ones and I was murdered back 10 fold (not even aligned with the murderers at all) I feel that is also just as unjust as your loss.
I love this channels historical breakdowns but I also think it's incredibly important that videos like this are made. I'm sorry YT is the way it is
I'm not, why are you apologizing?
worst thing about the 2020's is that Israel - Palestine and Russia - Ukraine looks like only the beginning
Sadly thats why you need a big military so if a country invaded you well that country loses everything.
Taiwan vs china coming soon
@@weingkham4033Philippines too
@@weingkham4033Pre alpha
@@weingkham4033Azerbaijan vs Armenia too
Periscope - Check
Hazmat Suit - Check
Gas Mask - Check
Oxygen - Check
Med Kit - Check
We're ready... *goes to the comments section*
don't forget your anti-rad pills
and your popcorn
@@shalthepal6513but it'll be dangerous to even consume it tho.
@@Matthew.__ it's stored in a radioactive resistant container.
@@ye_rightbud2959Don’t forget the Vodka, and light/matches for a campfire. Good hunting Stalker.
Thanks for making this content to help explain the mess that is this conflict
Real I had no idea what everyone was talking about before watching this video lol
Thank you for all your hard work to inform us
That wasn't hard work it was sloppy
If you review comments regarding al shifa hospital or language used it shows either bias or poor research
You can have whatever opinion you want on this conflict but one thing you must agree on is that it is a very sad situation for all involved
Eh not that sad for the Zionists in power. Innocent Israeli civilians? Absolutley. But the government of Israel are war criminals. Hamas are too, but my tax dollars don't support hamas.
It's like a pair of toddlers fighting over a cookie who won't listen to anyone who suggests that they quit with the temper tantrums and just share
@@vikkimcdonough6153cookie fight ended once again after one toddler decided to commit countless war crimes. Don't expect to be greeted with love
@@GameOver._. Don't act like it's just one side committing war crimes
@@captainrex8762 You know deep down that Israhell is the only one commiting war crimes because it's been massacaring palestinians since 1948.(there are even more massacres before that)
Oh boy, a video on the Israel-Palestine conflict from the Armchair Historian.
WHAT CAN POSSIBLY GO WRONG?
I love your comment section to your message.... however good joke.
“turns out, everything” ~oversimplified
All the terrible things done in WW2 mentioned on this channel are just as bad but this is so much scarier because its happening NOW.
"The interpretation of the calendar was widely debated". Man it is a literal calendar, with days & stuff
Comment section sorted by newest comments:
Pro-Palestine supporters: “this is biased. He didn’t talk about x thing. He’s clearly a Israel supporter”
Pro-Israel supporters: “this is biased. He didn’t talk about x thing. He’s clearly a Palestine supporter”
Real
Fr bro. You know this video is not biased when both biased sides see it as biased.
Real
@@noahniskala That's normally a good indication, but it's not an absolute.
@@SafetySpooon Yea I know but that for sure shows how a video is not biased when you got both sides which hate each other hating the video because they believe its propaganda about the side they oppose.
This small piece of land has been occupied, attacked, claimed, attacked, and reclaimed many times over.
All in a day's work being the Holy Land.
@@Global-yt I find it pretty funny that is was the holy land of Christians znd Jews, and Muslims were like 'Not mentioned nowhere in our holy texts but lets us join in the fun too' and just decided to claim it as their holy land too hahaha
@@neoromanempire Just thank God Max Fosh's Sillyists haven't joined the hypetrain...
@@neoromanempire You just pulled that out of your ass didn't you 😭😭
Yep even though its crappy land with no oil and barely arable
Its weird and jarring that in our age, casualties of war which from what I’ve seen and heard are in the hundreds or thousands is considered a tragedy, which it is, but we’ve come a long way in making war much less destructive and deadly as compared to the past casualties back then were high
Im sure there have been wars in the 21st century that match the casualties in the past but they’re very few so it shows that we’ve come a long way in making war less deadly thou I do wish we just stopped wars.
The calendar I rember being immediately ridiculed because everyone who could actually read it saw it was just a regular calender and not some secret list like they claimed
Why was it titled Al Aqsa flood and why did it start on Oct 7 🤔
Yeah, if I recall the IDF translation didn't match the photo with several "mistranslations" that literally wouldn't be possible coming from an organization that has spend its entire existence locked in series of Defensive Actions from, Attacks Against, and Colonial Occupation of a Arab speaking Majority region. All intel starts in Arabic usually, not Hebrew or English, Mossad at its peak seemed to have being multilingual as a hiring requirement.
If you look at the calendar closer, you can see the names repeating every 7 days. It's read right to left, though, as it's in Arabic.
@commandercorl1544 uhmmm.. you mean the names of the days of the week??
@@d.s.4952 counting the days of war what wrong in that
To everyone saying that most of the comments are how toxic the comments are gonna be, search comments by newest not by top
Thanks for the tip. I'll take a quick gander on the comments. Wish me luck.
CZcams censorship is really shows how authoritarian this "Private Platform"
Ah yes, the enternal war that choosing a side immediately puts you on the 'wrong side'. I think I'll just chill from the sidelines. Prayers to the innocent people stuck in between it and don't want nothing to do with it tho🙏
CZcams, do not take down this video
Man you have some balls to cover this topic on CZcams.
No he doesn't. He said he's moving to his various paywalled alternatives back in January so he doesn't care all that much if he loses this.
So true
Not really. He started it off wrong by calling a genocide a war. So that's already ceding ground to the Israelis, who for some reason have high support.
@@tofu1608 ur rly stupid aren’t u
@@tofu1608 I mean no harm and I currently have no opinion on this war/genocide whatever you call it what genocide are you talking about? Against who???
Absolutely awesome yall!!! Keep up the great work 😂
This well-balanced, neutral, informative video has caused an untold number of convulsions and widespread havoc.
Well done with the vid. Hope it doesnt get taken down
Here before CZcams decides to be CZcams and removes the video.
same
Only when the Chosen Ones notify CZcams about them not being portrayed as holy and innocent.
They’d more likely demonetize it tbh
No
Wait why?
Well done covering an exceptionally difficult topic.
I love this channel. Great work+
Ngl there are many content creators I enjoyed but when I went to their comment section I was disappointed at the community. Yall are pretty civilized and everyone so far I see is genuine and honest which gives me hope. Love to be part of the community!
Same
@@di71m0s yea like I don’t mind having difference of opinion as long as we are talking in good faith with empathy. There is much to learn from conversations like that but unfortunately in other channels majority comments had 0 empty and it became like a football game of cheering my side no matter what and that dehumanized actual lives to just stats and cost of business.
@@Munthasir123sounds like what Israelis and their supporter do. Dehumanizing palestinians children by making them look as potentional terorist in the future
14:26 That "list" was days of the week in Arabic 🤣
And why was it titled "Al-Aqsa flood" and started at the 7th of October? Coincidence?
@@TheOriginalTProal-aqsa flood is what arabs call the conflict.
@@TheOriginalTProthe idf spokesperson said the days of the week were the names of Hamas members. Lol
@@TheOriginalTProAh yes, Abu Monday, Abdul Tuesday, Muhammad Wednesday, Amir Thursday and Al-Friday
@@TheOriginalTPro bros on crack
no mention of the Israeli hostages??
Yeah he did 16:12
Listen close
also he missed a lot more details like how many died in israeli side
He briefly mentioned it, but he’s omitted a lot of info too
Barely
Great job on this video.
Always a good day with Armchair Historian
I think a channel about history like yours should recognise that calling this a Hamas offensive is too simplistic. This operation was carried out by a lot of palestinian militant factions like PIJ, PFLP, DFLP among others.
While that is true, Hamas is the main militant faction, so it’s still reasonable to call it a Hamas offensive.
You're right, but it's not wrong to say it was Hamas. Kinda like when we talk about the German invasion of Russia in WW2. They were joined by many allies militaries, but they lead the invasion and bore most of the fighting.
Interesting how half of the more recent comments are calling this video pro-Hamas propaganda and the other half are calling it pro-Israel propaganda.
Both sides send propaganda bots that floods the internet with crap.
Both sides have bot accounts, report and move on.
It's pro-israeli propaganda because it doesn't mention the genocide israel is doing.
I don't see any suck up for the Israeli side in this video
No Israeli would like to watch this video pleased with his narratives
If both sides are offended that typically a good sign lol
Here before the comments are shut down
Yee, claiming my spot here
Airchair Historian doesn't censor.
This will be a very civilized comment section.
Only if the “ chosen” dont show up
@@checo8187 Yeh, islamists are quite aggressive aren't they?
You know their tentacles are everywhere to defend their atrocities.
It is actually
and a 'very civilized' comment section it has been so far
Very informative thank you
Also hamas rockets dont target "key israeli millitary instilations" they can barely aim them. They just lob them at cities
seems like israel’s having the same issue, you know, seen by how they continuously target civilian populations while telling the world they’re just targeting hamas members….
Make a video on explaining srilankan civil war please..
Lol no one cares about that
@@dudebro91-fn7rz maybe not you but a lot of them do
@@dudebro91-fn7rz I infact do
Sudan would be nice as well
@@Global-yt agree
Here’s some popcorn 🍿 as you scroll though these comments 😊
Literally nothing happening in the comments you little grifter
@@illyrian44 oh just filter the comments to Newest and watch a war.
@@ethon20104 Ikr
Summary: Everything was disputed, and with all evendence, we can't summarise anything meaningful.
appreciate your clarification on this confusing topic due to mass censorship.
Need a hazmat suit for the comments
*Hamasmat suit
@@ScrappyPower nah funny af
@@ScrappyPower that's cringe make better joke bruh
come here dressed like your on a trip to the chernobyl nuclear powerplant lmao
@@ScrappyPower cringe
early for another armchair historian classic
Thanks for making a video on a recent military conflict.
I would like to see his take on operation gothic serpent since there is only a few good documentaries about it on youtube
I hope this vid does not get taken down
Me as we
Me too man me too and many others
You know an ongoing conflict is serious when the Armchair Historian makes a video about it, similar to how he made a video about the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
I think you can guess that it is an important conflict without him making a video, you know...since there are more children deaths than in any other conflict in the 21st century, I'd say this is a more reliable fact to determine whether it is serious or not.
Yeah one is the most deadly war in Europe (and possibly the world) since WW2 and one is the largest Arab-Palestinian conflict in decades. You could tell they were huge by literally turning on the news at any point.
I love how he keeps citing Amnesty International as a credible source 😂
great video as always from the TAH channel, it goes into great detail of how the war was conducted and how it started though i think that some of the points given were not clarified as they should of been, the examples from the washington post posts were talked as if they irrefutably proved that there were no evidence for military activity in the hospital when in the article itself it is merely an assumption and not given as a fact, the other part the one at the start of the war where it stated that israel had been constantly warned about an impending hamas attack was also not addressed well as it failed to point out that as far as it is known to me, israel has constantly denied the claims that it was warned, overall the video does explain and express most points correctly and my points really can only be seen as nit picky, though i do feel that it is important to cover the topic to the best and most accurate ability especially when there is a lot of misinformation going around.
I Pray that this will be resolved
Kinda hard to resolve an ongoing genocide. IDF soldiers fully admitted they want to cull Arabs, Muslims, and even Christians from the land.
@@Tab1300 And Hamas and other factions fighting alongside them have admitted to wanting to do the same to Jews. Both sides have genocidal desires.
pray without actions is meaningless and now everything that zionists and the entire nato countries are doing and why they are doing it is clear
Not gonna happen, one side wants the other dead, idk who expects this to ever settle and how
@@mkzhero both sides want the other dead
3:00 correction, Hamas doesn't just oppose west-bank occupation, they consider all of Israel to be occupied territory - that should signify how unresolvable this dispute is.
This!
It literally is. Just look what's happening in the west bank. Entire houses being leveled and dudes coming all way from Boston or whatever to live in places not theirs. It's insane levels of evil.
@@Zen2k4r-it would still be their houses if they accepted they accepted the multiple 2 state solutions offered to them by israel
actually no Hamas dropped the claim on israel in like late 2000s they just want west bank to be free.
@@excrementgaming4405 IT ISN'T THEIR COUNTRY TO BEGIN WITH MOST OF THEM ARE POLISH AND HUNGARIANS YOU SMART GUY, HISTORICAL JEWS HAVE BEEN LIVING WITH PALESTINIANS SHELTERED BY OTTOMAN EMPIRE THEY DIDN'T EVEN WANT THE COUNTRY.
You are not even middle eastern. You don't know about the conflict. You just watch the news
"this isnt very baller" - Martin Luther King Jr circa 2023
"Clearly a lack of Riz" - Ghandi, 2024.
"It’s giving broke boys" - Rosa Parks 2025
Bit sad innit?
Stop whitewashing MLK.
If anyone has any questions regarding who is in the right and who is in the wrong I'd like to make two things clear:
- Armchair Historian made a very risky video that is quite frankly really good for what information he can gather (if you disagree, make one of your own or keep it to yourself)
- Both Hamas and Israel have committed several crimes in the conflict, such as the usage of white phosphorus, targetting of civilians, pretending to be civilians, bombing, etc etc
Ill be happy to debate or answer any questions too, so lemme know ;)
(I'm not trying to support any side, but i might make some mistakes - please correct me if Im wrong, ty)
Amen. I don't know why everyone in this comments section is coping this hard without bringing up anything meaningful. Shame.
Both are wrong in their own ways, there is no good guy.
@@TheHolyGopnikCrusader well said
Alright, I have a question for you: is Israel an apartheid state?
@@huizdacheeze id say probably
they are no saints by any means - and as we've seen from the east bank and Gaza, israel has done terrible things to the Palestinian people (which is why in a sense the Palestinian people's hatred is justified)
If we go by definition, "A system of apartheid is an institutionalized regime of oppression and domination by one racial group over another"
In this case, yes, Israel does fit that criteria
But it is also worth mentioning that this system dates back hundreds of years (as in, Islam v Zionism) and so both states have hatred for each other.
In short:
Yes, Israel is an apartheid state by definition - and why no action against it has been taken is a mystery to me - due to tensions from older times
HOWEVER, this 'tension' does not excuse Israel's actions, just possibly explains the hatred Jews have for Palestinians.
Hope it helped :)
Vision: Humans are odd, they think that chaos and peace are opposites... However there is grace in their failures. I think you missed that.
Ultron: You're unbearably naeive.
Vision: Well, I was born yesterday.
Thank you Armchair for this overview of a topic I didn't have any basic information. I appreciate what you've been able to inform me about.
With luck, this video will have a peaceful and respectful comments section with decency and calmness.
😅😅😅
I don't know why but I haven't seen any political comments. It's all just saying how the comments are going to be so bad.
@@ChancellorOfHistorysort by newest and you will find them
Liked the video, good as usual, but i find it a little bit unfair how Hamas' statements are taken as truth while the IDF's are always proposed as alleged.
It makes sense, people on the left tend to be extremely hostile to Israel's POV so not outright disagreeing with them allows them to get another POV
Every statement given by Hamas thus far has been truthful while nearly every statement given by Israel thus far turned out to be a lie (like the 40 babies or the Arabic calendar)thus I believe this way of approaching things is extremely fair and logical
That literally the only Thing Yale bring up about Israel lying xD
Israel corrected it asap. Also it was no official, just a Single soldier that Said it and the News who spread it.
@@YesmineMenyarthat's one of the biggest lies
The Israeli government never said that
Only a soldier said out of nowhere and the media outlets picked it up and amplified it.
@@YesmineMenyarwhat are you talking about
Every single time there's been a major airstrike
H*amas says it was full of women and children
Later on it is revealed that there was indeed h""más militants
Can we all agree on one thing. The Armchair Historian is an amazing channel?
Very leftist
Normally yes, but this Video is tipping towards HAMAS. Although not immense, he used words like "allegedly" only with Israel and cited many biased sources when talking about Israeli situations. The Washington Post and the UN group listed are well known to be favoring anything against Israel. He also didn't mention the horrible atrocities that HAMAS committed during the opening attacks and often downplayed other instances. The Ambulance point he made was also factually incorrect. There's a video if you can find it, but it clearly shows a HAMAS drone destroying the ambulance and not an Israeli airstrike.
1000%
Here before CZcams get's angry and takes this video down. Great video Armchair
24 hours later: this video has been demonetized for violating CZcams guidelines
20 hours so far
I got 3 ads so they don’t mind putting ads they just don’t wanna pay the creator.
demonetization doesnt directly equal censorship... yes i hate youtubes censorship policies and how youre guilty until proven innocent.. but creators are more and more using it as a crutch to push their subscription services... theyre not making the content for the joy of it anymore, youtube is providing them a platform with billions of viewers the largest in the world, all the bandwith and server costs for absolutely free, but they cry if youtube wont provide them with advertisers to sponsor the content? theyre free to put an ad spot in the video like theyve been doing on every other upload.. theres lots of companies who value free speech and honest transparent reporting
Mind Begs the Question:
- If a Israel PM/Govt
- Publicly promoted funding Hamas
- To avoid 2 State Solution
- Condemns Hamas or Funds Hamas?
Overall good video, but one big flaw. You're depicting the hamas fighters in uniforms. They almost exclusively wear civilian clothing.
says who? where did you learn this?
@@rni4069 the countless videos of fighting between the idf and hamas released by both parties show that hamas terrorists almost never wear uniforms
Quick question would you consider a Hamas Fighter a normal Guy WHO picked Up an AK to defend His Home, at this Point are they Hamas or Just Humans protecting their homes/families from an enemy WHO indiscriminately ignores every human rigth
@@babapeldiacono8523 if you pick up a rifle you're a fighter
That is true. They’re not an organised fighting force, they’re a militia. They don’t have uniforms.
Clearly the Holy Land belongs to the Filipino Jolibee Kingdom due to our immigrant numbers
And thus begins the 2024 Armchair Comment Conflict...
Uh, nothing happen
YET
BRB just getting some popcorn before reading the comments 😄
Militants and terrorrists are something different..
If you ever struggle explaining to someone what the definition of meta means, I believe this comment section (my comment included) showcases this perfectly.
Im sure this comment section will be extremely respectful and not polarized at all!
You are actually right
@@jackrhino7465 very surprised
5 days later: Woah i did not expect to see peace among the viewers here.
Thanks for making this video, hopefully this wil clear up some history on both sides.
Can somebody tell me the musics on the video? Thanks.
Bro really said the IDF didn't say that the calendar was "a list of members" while showing the calendar all too proudly
Wow the Armchair Historian's followers are very civilized ! Keep up the good content, coolest history teacher ever !
I think we all should grow up, listen to everyone who might have an opposing opinion and do a civil discussion about this, only by then we can truly understand the real issue and work together towards peace
I wish it were this simple. I've studied this conflict for years, including majoring in middle east studies at university. Unfortunately the more you learn the more unlikely a true and equal peace or a two stage solution seem.
@@nedisahonkey yes, i understand this. But i think it’s as important for people who supports both sides to understand each other’s views.
@noi7531 the Israeli view: our supposed ancestors lived here 3000 years ago thus we have the right to kill,pillage and steal the Palestinians' lands and homes.
The Palestinian view:we want to liberate our lands and go back to our homes
Kindly look into the Israeli treatment of Palestinians
There will never be peace after what they've done, they aren't even treated as second class citizens, they're treated much worse
Hitting the hot topics, I respect it
We need to support Griffin so this video isn't taken down!