2024 Tesla Model Y vs. Mustang Mach-E | The Shocking Truth Exposed!
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- Use my referral link to purchase a Tesla product or schedule a Demo Drive and get up to $1,000 off and other exclusive benefits.
www.tesla.com/referral/jeancl...
In this video, we compare the Tesla Model Y to the Ford Mustang Mach-E.
Which car is the right EV for you going into 2024?
Watch till the very end to see what our impressions are of both vehicles.
Video Outline:
0:00 - Introduction
1:35 - Mustang Mach-E Exterior
2:20 - Tesla Model Y Exterior
3:03 - Mustang Mach-E Interior
6:55 - Tesla Model Y Interior
9:30 - Frunk Comparision
11:10 - Charging with CCS vs Tesla
13:10 - Final Impressions
Instagram:
/ chargegogroup
TikTok:
/ charge.go
Twitter:
/ chargegogroup
Facebook:
/ 100085123881950
Snapchat:
/ chargego
#MachE #ModelY #Tesla #Mustang - Auta a dopravní prostředky
I bought a mach e a few days ago. What sold me was incentives and 0% apr for 72 months. I did get the premium with extended warranty. Plus we get to use tesla superchargers moving forward!
Very fair and unbiased comparison. I think I would choose the Mustang as well.
My sister who has been driving a Model 3 for 4 years got a Mach E after driving the Y, the Volvo and the Audi. After listening to her thoughts (she is not a huge car person just likes a nice car) my conclusion is that the Ford is a better CAR from the casual drivers point of view while the Tesla is generic feeling, noisy, and Tesla has the reputation for exaggerating their actual mileage which bothered her, but also the leader in technology. One thing the legacy automakers have going for them is they have been building cars for quite some time and know how to build a car where Tesla is still figuring that out. She paid a lot more for the Mach E GT than a Tesla Y Performance so there is that. Anyway, I wonder if Tesla will hit a wall with buyers. I drove her car and it was premium feeling compared to a Tesla for sure. I do think Juniper will help address some of the concerns I heard from my sister.
Legacy automakers have no clue how to build an EV. It's a completely different product than an ICE car.
Audi in 2016 after analysing Model X: "It's hard to admit, but they did everything right."
Volkswagen in 2018 after analysing Model 3: "Compact, upgradable, fully integrated and modular, easy access, great protection and safety, cheap and very clever designed in a lot of details. We could have never built a car like that."
Toyota after analysing the Model Y last year: "Taking the skin off the Model Y, it was truly a work of art. It's unbelievable."
Super helpful. Thanks for your comment.
@Tschacki_Quacki lol. Yet ford did it better
As a Mac e 2022 owner, I have absolutely no regrets ❤ ( I wasn’t paid to write this lol)
u were probably paid to wirte this
@@jishnujishnu1467 tells a man who owns nothing
Im a first time EV owner and looked extensively into the Model Y. The simplisticity of the Model Y, cheap build quality, and cheap feel was a "No Go" for me. I love my Mustang MachE GT. Ford put together an awesome EV. I have over 20k miles and dont have a complaint.
The Mustang frunk got hot because the car has black paint where the Tesla has white paint. Black paint absorbes a lot of heat where as the white paint reflects it.
Good thinkin
The only truth is , that ford is not a Mustang.
I test rode a Model 3 Performance and a Mach-E GT... The Mustang was noticeably slower. Like, a lot. The Tesla was scary fast, and the Mustang was good right off the line, and then... meh... Nice car, but for a $72k sticker price, I couldn't justify it...
the battery issues fix via software may have something to do with it.
As a '22 Model 3P owner, I would say the Mach E has objectively better build quality and feels a bit more upscale inside. My bro in law had one for a little over a year until it bricked and Ford couldn't fix it so they bought it back...another story for another time...but in terms of which car I'd rather drive, that's easy. I'd take my M3P over anything else in its class, in spite of it's minor flaws and shortcomings. It's a hoot to drive, easy to live with, has way more power (Mach E GT is comparable in power but can't compare in performance to the 3P, esp at higher speeds where the Mach dials back power considerably) and looks better, IMO. Looks are subjective, but I prefer the low-slung rocket-egg profile of the 3P. It goes without saying that Tesla has the best charging infrastructure available. Now that they are allowing other mfrs to use their chargers that's less of a selling point for Tesla, but I still feel very happy with my choice and would not take the Mach E or anything else in this price range over the 3P.
Yeah, the dialed down power after 75 mph is very noticeable. I wouldn't mind if it was 110 but 75 is ridiculous
I couldn’t agree more with this review about the Mach E, I test drove the Mach E and my sisters Tesla model 3 & Y and compared the 3 and the Tesla is built cheap, ugly and boring. Although the charging infrastructure of Tesla is on top, I would still consider the Mach E. I’m just waiting closer towards the end of the year to see what other deals Ford can offer before I make the move.
0% APR right now for 60 months. Ends October 2nd.
@@patricktravica3335 I noticed that, however the consumers bonus cash is less now. They always find a way to reel you in 😂
@@micks209 Actually, the consumer bonus is more now. The 0% APR is gone. I am just waiting for Tesla to offer something similar.
Nice review. Well done. Not too long, impartial, natural presentation style. Great job.
Drove them both, and my views align with yours.
The only thing I wonder is why you can’t charge with super chargers, in Europe all the chargers are fitted with ccs converters and work like a charm.
Thought that was also the case in the us by now.
you summarized it well about the unreliable non tesla charging options. It seems they work well in the beginning when all incentives are paid out but then later they brake and maintenance is poor. It is probably because most non tesla owners rarely use a charger other than at home or near work for "free".
There is a video from another Tesla centric channel where he interviewed one of the senior engineers on the Mach E team, and he said they originally planned on it being an Electric Explorer, but they realized they were not going to be able to make enough of them, so they chosenthe Mustang for great heritage and the fact they sell similar numbers in Mistangs as they planned on being able to build Mach Es. So you can see where the styling and sizing of the vehicle would be perfect for an Explorer.
Thanks for sharing!
We have both the electric Mach-E and the Explorer in the UK.
Nice comparison. Totaled my M3. Now looking at Mach E Premium. Mach E can now use Tesla superchargers...Yay!
I was cross shopping the MME and the MYLR.
The MME definitely drives great and feels very premium, especially on rougher roads, where the MY feels pretty unsettled at times.
That said, the combination of price, performance (the MYLR is way faster than the MME AWD extended range) and the charge network really sealed the deal for me. Especially because of what seems to be an extended rollout of the V4 chargers that will accept payment and allow other manufacturers EVs to change on the Tesla network.
once you see what the fix for the battery contact melting issues was you understand why MYLR acceleration is better.,
Since I made the mistake of buying a new 2012 Ford Explorer without looking at consumer reports, it was in the shop more than any other vehicle I have ever owned, I am going to stick with other brands. The Explorer looked good, except for some of the interior trim fit, and drove very well but wasn’t worth the aggravation.
The Mach-E styling is kind of funky and i really like it, all except for the bulbous round part on the front that has the ford logo. I think they could do better.
Just sold my Mach e and bought a MYP. The Tesla is such a better EV experience. I agree the Mach e has better exterior and interior styling (and that's why I originally bought it over the MY), but that is where it's advantages end IMO. Tesla is less expensive (which it wasn't when I bought the MME), handles better, much more efficient, app is way better, and charging is a breeze. 150 KW seems like a decent charging speed for the Mach e until you charge at 253 kw and realize what an advantage that really is on a road trip. The Mach e is like dating a hot girl with a horrible personality, fun to show off but awful to live with. The MY is maybe a little bland, but is great with everything else. The MYP is a bit spiced up and the performance just blows the MME away. I took a bit of a bath on the MME, but I'm so glad I made the switch. I'd do it again in a second. There is a reason MME are piling up on dealers lots and Tesla sells every Y they build.
Which trim Mach-E did you have?
@@jasonwiltjer9 premium ext range
my mach-e came with a free tesla adapter .. and blue oval that makes it very easy to charge to any charger from the onboard screen
Ford hasn’t figured out how to produce an EV without losing tens of thousands of dollars per vehicle. Neither has Chevy.
Not correct. The issue has been that demand for GM and Ford model EVs has been weak. However, they both make millions on ICE automobiles. Bottom line is that Tesla (using GM’s discarded EV technology) was the “first mover” in capturing the mid-tier luxury vehicle market for EVs. GM miscalculated thinking that the market segment did not exist. Over time, the EV market will become crowed with other successful manufacturers besides Tesla - this is just the nature of business. However, ICE sales will remain strong for decades to come.
Mach E is nice, but Tesla supercharger network is what won me over. I hate electrify America, doesn’t always work, more expensive, and limited stalls.
The big three all make the same type of vehicles with different styling. the problem is they needed to make their own version of the Model Y/3 and not their "better" version which turned out not to be better.
"The latest Ford probe comes after NHTSA in August said it was investigating the automaker's handling of a June 2022 recall of nearly 50,000 Ford Mustang Mach-Es after new reports of power loss" Not ready for Prime time!
Always something with FORD.
they are cons
The Mach E is better the casual consumer. It is by the far the easiest transition vehicle for gas to electric.
Styling, I have to give it to the Mustang Mach-E. They did it so well
For the Mustang, can the back seats fold down for more space?
Yep
I’ll take my Mach E over a model Y any day. I rarely use public chargers and I think the model y is ugly af! Just my opinion
I agree with you on the public chargers
Always something like you said
Broken or had to plug it several times or call support to charge my Mach-E
I own a Mach-E and my adult son owns a MY long range. Your review nailed it -- the Mach-E is the better car in almost every respect until you have to charge it on a road trip. Then it simply sucks, or, more accurately, CCS charging sucks. I do 99% of my driving around or near my town, charge at home, and have 10.8 KW of solar on my roof. I have charged the Mach-E from public CCS chargers a total of 8 times, and they were always slow -- usually delivering only 25-45 KW either due to their design limitation or due to being de-rated down from the listed 350 KW. Also, at every stop 1 or 2 of the typically 4 chargers were inoperable. I was just about to sell the Mach-E and buy a used Model S when Ford announced that I could start using Tesla Superchargers (with an adapter) after February, so I will hold off my decision to sell until I see how well that works.
By the way, I think a more apt comparison is between the Model Y and the Mach-E in Select trim rather than the Premium trim. The Select is a closer match to the Model Y with respect to interior materials and price.
Warranty and AC not good
When I bought my MME the Model Y was more expensive and did not get the tax credit. One thing that really annoys me with the Tesla model 3/Y is poor paint quality. Looking at Teslas in my work parking lot made me not even look at them when i ordered my '22 MME back in October 2021. Another negative of the teslas is that hey charge $1k for freaking blue paint and other colors as well.
Hello, kindly reminder for replying email for CCS adapter, thanks
I ❤ my model Y, I use it for work purpose only and added to my Mopar collection (Challenger, Ram, and my SRT Durango 2022 my late husband bought me before he passed away) I’m living and enjoying life !that’s what he would have wanted me to do ❤️😁
Jersey Shore here calls the model Y a "cheap mom car". Oh boy. ... I traded a Ford for mine.
I have a Mach e and I do love it, but the ccs charging does suck.
Agreed, thankfully Ford recognized that and are making the switch to NACS
The reason why I would buy a Tesla Y because of the Tesla Supercharger…. Third party chargers SUCK!!!
Well said
The Mach E and Ford EVs now have access to the Tesla charging network
The Mach e continues to have that cheap typical American rental car interior. Why would you want a heavy frunk lid, heavy doesn’t equate to quality and is actually the opposite and requires more braking energy and decreases range.
Tesla door shutting sounds like a hollow tin can. Definitely no solid thunk you would expect.
Dude. Thank you, you brought up so many good points about the mustang Mach E on how it looks so much better than the Tesla but. For convenience, you can’t beat the Tesla charging systems. I’m going to wait until Ford Porsche and the other auto maker switch over to the Tesla charging system👍👍
Thanks! And I agree, I’m gonna do the same
If you never owned an electric car. Get a Mach e it resembles more of an actual ICE vehicle. Come with a ghetto key. Instrument cluster. It’s more like a car.
Interesting take… for me the Tesla has taken a minimalist approach which is similar to MB and BMW’s. Your comment about not needing the space in the Y is funny since you’re probably a single guy and all you have to carry is your tennis racket! Most (married) people need the space as you will eventually find out!
Cool vid … I have a 2023 Mach-e performance extended range … white. I love it .. I had a Tesla cheap quality…
Ford and Chevy have agreements with Tesla to use the Tesla Super charger system, starting in 2024 and will be giving owners adapters to allow it. All but a couple manufacturers will be building EVs with the NAC (Tesla) Charge port, starting in 2025. For now, an adapter will allow it at some stations.
the pricing is the killer point 😅 want to get a mach E but dont want to drop that much for it and having to deal with the dealership vs ordering one through tesla app
I traded in a Mach-E GT for a Model Y. Which is better is up to what you care about, the Mach-E build quality is without question better. The safety, technology, cargo space, and charging network if it’s important to you are all Tesla. As a daily driver you can’t go wrong with either one, but for a family car I prefer the Model Y.
Thanks for the review! I'm currently in the market for a new car and this is the most unbiased review ive seen about both these cars im cross shopping. Usually, i see Tesla bros or Tesla haters so i just dont know. But my biggest issue with tesla is just they are not "nice". I've never been in a Tesla where i thought, "Wow, this is really nice." Its always techy but doesn't feel "nice". Test driving the Mach-E this weekend tho so maybe i can cross it off the list then, but coming from a Q7 and really wanting an EV near 300mi range, i have a feeling i might have to compromise.
That cover isn’t protecting anything the Bay. They’re busting that joint out just in case there’s something back there unfortunately
Yup :/
Great review but missed a critical point - how does one drive vs the other as ultimately that is the deal maker/breaker!
I sold my $100k Tesla Model X for a Mustang Mach E and even with a $100k Tesla Model X the parts seem flimsy as well as thin paint and the car squeaked and rattled a lot compared to my almost 3 year old Mustang Mach E which still drives tight like brand new and higher quality materials.
Also, many Mach E owners started receiving their Tesla charging adapters and now use the Tesla Superchargers nationwide. Another thing you may not know is that the Ford Mach E phone app has a Frunk Button to remotely open the front frunk without pulling the interior handle to open.
Who’s the Freemason? I noticed the logo on your car. 😊
"Is there a recall on the Ford Mustang Mach?
That is why we are issuing a safety recall for some 2021-2022 model-year Mustang Mach-E® extended-range and GT models built between May 27, 2020, and May 24, 2022. A key component of the vehicle's battery system may not be able to stand up to heat generated from multiple DC fast-charge and wide open pedal events."
I got this recall on my ‘21. A quick fix, the dealer had another mach-e waiting for me, it took a couple of hours. 50,000 km now, a great vehicle.
I’ve been considering going to Mach E from my Tesla! Preciate….. Travel Light
Thanks fam 🙏
Build quality you can-not compare the Tesla to the Ford. We get the teslas as trade ins at the Ford dealer i work at.
Just junk 🤷
Nissan Juke is the frog 😂
Yeah that is true too lol
Can’t you charge this with the Tesla charger with the adapter
Depends on whether or not the Tesla Supercharger knows how to speak in non-Tesla vehicles' language.
I don't think you could choose a supercharger in the app that doesn't have official CCS support to initiate charging.
Mach E better car!
It’s a great vehicle
And that's your opinion😊
@@youngchirp12it's definitely a better built car and more refined.
I got a Mach-e because of the Android Auto avaibility
Interesting
What do you use it for?
@@Tschacki_Quackithe car or the Android Auto ? AA : everything AA do,bu then I find the Ford GPS better than the AA one 😊
@@DenisBergeronPhotographe I mean Android Auto.
Why do you want it in a car? What do you use it for?
@@Tschacki_Quacki GPS, good music interface, the local electric company have also an app to find the charger...
great review overall!! but um no road test drive?? mach-e from what is hear is more fun to drive than modeY!
guess im buying the mach e now then
Was that a 3-row Model Y? I thought the trunk space appeared to be not as deep as the Mustang's.
2 row
So what was the shocking truth and how was it exposed?🤣
Wait, how tall are you again?
Good video man
Thanks CJ 💪
Mach E having Tesla adapter is a gamechanger
Would be or do they?
They do
@@salookie8000 would be and they do and they will.
EU here. I will soon buy my first electric car. Did a test drive with TMY and the MME. The TMY is the top of its class in terms of 1) energy efficiency (management of thermal and electrical fluxes is Optimus Prime level; check out e.g. the octovalve heat pump), 2) software and software integration, 3) ease of charging and 4) storage space . Advantages of the MME: 1) a better driving experience (❤️), 2) better build (🪨) 3) a frontal display (🛟 safety!), physical buttons (🔘 I just love the fact that with a quick grab-and-twist I can shut down the audio system) (call me old school all you want 😁), 4) far nicer exterior and interior design (🛋️). My mind tells me to buy Tesla. My heart says Mustang. But there is this one thing I absolutely cannot stand and of which Tesla has plenty: rattling noises. Happy e-driving y'all!
We’re considering the Mach E, we tried the Tesla and it seemed so cheaply built that it was a complete turn off. The Ford just feels so much better when you’re behind the wheel or as a passenger. Understand this, Ford has over 100 years of building vehicles. It should have a better interior sheerly because of the knowledge and experience in the luxury market with the Lincoln Brand. If the Tesla’s interior was on the same level as the Ford I would seriously not consider the Ford. Sorry, but the Tesla interior looks like something out of a kit car package and the exterior looks more like a pregnant Model 3.
Well said!
i love the Mustang Mach-E ...
Mach E all day long. Just glad we can use the Tesla charges now.
I love the mach e... but one made in Mexico that feel Americans... and one made in Americans that feel Chinese...
You could open the frunk from the screen and from your phone
Sick!
And from the main screen in the car (only in Park).
There are MANY unsold Mach-E’s & the tax credit end JAN of next year. The dealers would be wise to drop prices ASAP or they will be left behind.
Prices have dropped. I bought a 23 GT for 51K. It pays to wait.
unless you have a tesla you will have range anxiety all the time. Tesla's condition the battery before you even land at the charge station. That is another reason you are able to charge at 110KW rate and go from 20 to 80% IN 20 MINUTES. Don't venture on a long drive using anything than a Tesla.
Range anxiety? We have a fast charger+tesla super charger every 31 miles over our entire country, we Even have it up in the mountains and inside caves😂. Its impossible to run out of range,Even If you had a 2010 Nissan leaf😂
It's the same shit when Tesla first came out everybody was like looking and staring and shit like that now they time is done it's other EVs that came on the market
They already came? Where? In China?
Cause in the US, Tesla is selling more EVs than all the other car brands combined.
Ford 😎
Tesla also don't have grab handles by any of the seats.
True!
I'm torn, looks build quality materials it's ford. But as an electrical engineer, I love tesla's engineering of the car and their charging network is far too good and too advance compare to any competition. The battery degradation, pre heating when it's cold, like all that is seamless with Tesla which makes it hard. Also the range doesnt drop as much in cold weathers compare to any other electrical. for the mustang in Quebec, the mustang loses 100 miles of range in the winter... That's crazy and show you how far ahead Tesla is from an engineering stand point
But the one thing that would make me chose the mustang is that there are too many teslas out there and I hate driving a popular car lot more than i love engineering so that's why the mustang would win, also because you can now use tesla chargers too. If it wasn't for these 2 reasons I would go with the tesla
Great! review and great outfit
I'd go for the Mach E any time of the day.
You clearly have never done a road trip in a non tesla EV then.
@@diamondwindowseaves2264 If Elon's Tesla is the only car in the world I would take public transportation.
Enjoy the bus ride then hahaha@@muhammad-bin-american
@@diamondwindowseaves2264 Okay. Now I drink my coffee...
Great review and convinces me that the Mustang is my next car 👊
If the Mach E used NACS it would be no brainer superior to a Model Y. Teslas are built like shit and its a shame.
I couldn’t agree more
No ventilated seats in the Mach E. In hot climates that's a big deal.
True but the Model Y doesnt either
I live in Vegas and never had a problem.
@@ChargeGo Soon it will 😉
I have a Mach-E, as far as charging goes, while there are issues, I find only about 10% of the chargers I have been too that have problems. 5 months of driving every day and on trips [I can't charge at home] so I always DCFC. Doesn't seem quite as bad as you state. To say you shouldn't buy a CCS type car for now, is being a little dramatic. Just my opinion of course.
YUMMY!!! Cars are nice too
Did you just say the fob was "ghetto"?
Myself and my son in-law had EV’s I had the BMW IX he had the Jaguar ipace both great cars but the charging issues in the UK is just crap, we are both back in diesel cars after 18 months. Tesla for me are too common in the uk and a boring looking car for boring people 😉
Tesla looks like IT'S made of PAPER MACHE 😂
Waiting til 2035 or longer
Ford Mach E
I choose the Mustand Mach E as a guy car :))
Thanks for your review I’ll go buy a Tesla Model Y now 😉👍🏾
Not a bad option
It’s not too late; don’t 😅lol
Coming from somebody who works for Tesla, I can tell you that their build quality is trash. Their basic vehicle warranty is even further trash, and I can nearly guarantee any new Tesla owner will have a significant repair hit them within the 4 four years of ownership.
I’ve had a Mach E for a year and a half and I have never had an issues charging my vehicle.
Once that transition happens they just need to be more competitive on their pricing
@@ChargeGo I do agree on pricing. However, I appreciate the fact I haven’t lost my ass in equity from what paid on the vehicle a year and a half ago. I can’t say the same for my friend who bought a model 3 performance a year and a half ago for 80k. I can get the same Tesla now for $47k with a tax credit lol
The owner of this tesla likes to travel to the east...
I can't watch your video. Those quick edits make me physically ill. :-(
A nice train without rails. If you drive any distances beyond your neighborhood, Tesla is the only option, sorry.
I think all mach E cars are gettting recalled for battery issues😂😂 "better built" yeah right
It is not a battery issue. It is the contactor that connects the DC charging to the battery and even then only one car actually got stranded because of it, most just couldn't do highway speeds or DC charging once the warning appeared and still not all (like my 2022 GT Performance) suffers from that problem. But all from the targeted manufactured dates will have them replaced. And for the person above: the 0-60 is 3.5/3..7, faster than the standard Model 3 and a bit slower than the Model 3 Performance and it does have slower acceleration above 80 but it will still hit its top speed of 123 (my actual top speed) fairly quickly. The battery pack just needs better cooling (2025(?) and later models) so it can hit its top potential speed of 150 (Mach E 1400 (H.P.)).
Just curious, how many "Chinese made cars" has the vlogger driven? Drive a few at the same price point then make the comparison and comment. Until then please don't make lazy generalizations.
Tesla is still king, for now
Debatable but likely true
Only the charging infrastructure.
I like the sunglasses 😎
Thanks 😎
Seems kinda biased 😅
Tesla model 3 Highland and upcoming new model y has no rattling and removed every single negative aspect:). No panel gap,fantastic ride feel and build quality
Blind people shouldn't really be driving...
What do you have against blind people?
It's terrible to use such an iconic name for an ev car.
That being said, The Rally looks way better than the Mach-e
There is no comparison between the two. Tesla wins hands down.
The shocking truth is Tesla is the better auto.
You are not wrong, for now.
Not really! The Tesla is the slightly better electric vehicle. The Mach e is the superior car. No rattles, no cheap materials, and you don't have to get used to all the eccentric elements of it.