Again, many thanks to Mr. Lewis Kirt for posting these Plato's classical Dialogue. This is a treasure of teaching far beyond than many could imagine, a lifetime study and training for humanity and many others Paideia Society
OMG! An Audio Book that DARES display Synchronized Text !?! Isn't it amazing that the most obvious things seem strange or amazing when we are unaccustomed to their event (the event as collective phenomenon of synchrentous instants, vs the error of indivual stance events accumulated or collected: the former, the spheres surface or bow's aim; the latter, the sphere's origin center or arrow's mark ?)
showing the mistake with the correction says more (information theory) says more than if the mistake is corrected, removed, and whose successor is presented as the first case rather than its (now absent) place as second and (here ever after, without outside correction) absent is its precedence
It makes perfect sense. But you're right, I've not seen it anywhere else! Makes it all the more novel. There are a lot more of Plato's dialogues in the playlist. Check them out. 👍
Yes; an enthusiastic opinion. For clearly there "exist" many ways one could deviate from your perception. These infinite numbers of ways need not be named. The limitlessness would drive you to madness.
You are welcome. It’s my pleasure. If you are interested, I am planning to work through the Republic soon on my other channel. I’m a keen to share that great work. Hope you will come for the journey.
@@lewiskirk8289 hi Lewis, what is this other channel and have you started it yet? Love all of your Plato reading and have been eagerly waiting for you to release the last ones :)
@@jeroenlouwerse7454 The librivox audiobook version of Cratylus seems to be more accurate. czcams.com/video/XpHe-XqD-LU/video.html Narrators sound pretty dull and robotic on both cases I'm afraid. Regarding my first comment I would like to give bit more context. In the original Greek version of the book, Plato says "there is a natural correctness of names, which is the same for everyone, Greek or barbarian". This guy, probably for political correctness reasons replaced the word barbarian with foreigner. The listener is not stupid, he can understand that he means foreigners but accuracy to the book is vital. Especially for a book that has as a subject the importance and origin of names. Librivox seems way more accurate in that regard.
Again, many thanks to Mr. Lewis Kirt for posting these Plato's classical Dialogue. This is a treasure of teaching far beyond than many could imagine, a lifetime study and training for humanity and many others Paideia Society
OMG! An Audio Book that DARES display Synchronized Text !?!
Isn't it amazing that the most obvious things seem strange or amazing when we are unaccustomed to their event
(the event as collective phenomenon of synchrentous instants, vs the error of indivual stance events accumulated or collected: the former, the spheres surface or bow's aim; the latter, the sphere's origin center or arrow's mark ?)
rather
)
[ENTER]
?
showing the mistake with the correction says more (information theory) says more than if the mistake is corrected, removed, and whose successor is presented as the first case rather than its (now absent) place as second and (here ever after, without outside correction) absent is its precedence
Do you enjoy the synchronised text? For me it was the only thing to do.
I was surprised by how much sense it makes, so obvious and rare, ya know?
It makes perfect sense. But you're right, I've not seen it anywhere else! Makes it all the more novel. There are a lot more of Plato's dialogues in the playlist. Check them out. 👍
If you’re reading this you’re a deep Plato student :) no one else would dare go near this dialogue!
Yes, Plato is serious business, and Cratylus is right up there with the best of them!
Yes; an enthusiastic opinion. For clearly there "exist" many ways one could deviate from your perception. These infinite numbers of ways need not be named. The limitlessness would drive you to madness.
Thanks! Mr Kirk .they are amazing i listened to them all and will again!!!
You are most welcome! So much knowledge and wisdom to be gleaned from the Platonic dialogues. 😊🙏
The part at 50:30 hit so many correct points, it's crazy
Plato knew what he was talking about 🙏
Thank so so much Lewis Kirk. You are great.
A pleasure 😊🙏
This is very well read. Thank you.
You are welcome. It’s my pleasure.
If you are interested, I am planning to work through the Republic soon on my other channel. I’m a keen to share that great work. Hope you will come for the journey.
@@lewiskirk8289 hi Lewis, what is this other channel and have you started it yet? Love all of your Plato reading and have been eagerly waiting for you to release the last ones :)
45:21 Ousia Essia Ossia Estin Hestia
1:11:28 Doctrine of Motion || Flux || Becoming
Mirror mirror on the wall, who is the wierdest one of all?
I wonder how Wittgenstein would interpret this.
Hmm 🤔
"Greek or foreigner"? I stopped hearing after that.
Do you have a better translation?
@@jeroenlouwerse7454 The librivox audiobook version of Cratylus seems to be more accurate. czcams.com/video/XpHe-XqD-LU/video.html Narrators sound pretty dull and robotic on both cases I'm afraid. Regarding my first comment I would like to give bit more context. In the original Greek version of the book, Plato says "there is a natural correctness of names, which is the same for everyone, Greek or barbarian". This guy, probably for political correctness reasons replaced the word barbarian with foreigner. The listener is not stupid, he can understand that he means foreigners but accuracy to the book is vital. Especially for a book that has as a subject the importance and origin of names. Librivox seems way more accurate in that regard.