Why Didn't the Allies Get Rid of Franco After the Second World War? (Short Animated Documentary)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 18. 08. 2020
  • Given Franco's preferences during the Second World War (despite his official neutrality) along with his government's ideology, why didn't the allies get rid of him after world war 2? To find out watch this short and simple animated documentary.
    / histmattersyt
    Patreon: www.patreon.com/user?u=4973164
    Merch: teespring.com/stores/history-...
    A special thanks to all of these Patrons below, without whom the show wouldn't be possible:
    Kevin Sanders
    Ian Jensen
    Mickey Landen
    Kevin Phoenix
    Richard Wolfe
    אורי פרקש
    Robert Brockway
    Can’t Think Of A Name
    Mr Sandman
    SirAlpaka
    Connor Glaze
    D. Mahlik
    Björnosaurus
    Porkmeister
    David archaeologist
    jdk
    anon
    sharpie660
    Dragan
    Mcfeld
    Andreas Mosand
    Qi Xiao
    Ainar Garipov
    John Bisges
    Southside Mitch
    Wolf
    Rod D. Martin
    Dexter_McAaron
    Jeremy
    Ryan Haber
    Chris Fatta
    Adam Stalter
    Mantodea
    Andrew Niedbala
    Riley davidson
    John Garcia
    Andrew Patane
    Nathan Perlman
    Paul McGee
    Bernardo Santos
    Heytun
    SkyEye
    Yick Chung
    Tristan Kreller
    Mik Scheper
    Jane Sumpter
    Chris Dolan
    Christopher Godfrey
    Warren Rudkin
    Nicu Merge Prin Soare
    Robert Woodward
    Erik Martin
    Chris Hall
    Perry Gagne
    Joooooshhhhhh
    Danny Anstess
    Shaun Pullin
    Darnell Barbour
    Alen
    Magdalena Reinberg-Leibel
    bas mensink
    Henry Rabung
    Joshua A Bishop
    Caelen Hadwin
    Tsar Roman II
    Clay Carroll
    I'm Not In The Description
    Vilelmus_veliki
    William Wold
    Noremac_Cameron
    Gregory Priebe
    Joker 54
    FF Nelly
    Chach
    Cap
    Mark Ploegstra
    Liam Gilleece
    Blake Dryad
    Craig Cunningham
    Sytze de Witte
    Ciege Engine
    JAY ALAN EDELMAN
    Luke Robinson
    Haydn Noble
    Jeffrey Schneider
    Kinfe85
    Alteredcorgi
    Matthew O'Connor
    Chrisaztec
    TooMuchWaterYouDie
    Thomas Wang
    Spencer Smith
    Josh Cornelius
    Harley Raptopoulos
    Piotr Wojnowski
    The Roger Luna
    Colm Boyle
    HelloAgainThere
    Phillip Gathright
    Björn Wittmann
    Dakota Brunell
    Arthur Hosey Jr.
    Alex Adorno
    Colin Steele
    Serius_Loyola
    SmythProductions
    Konstantin Bredyuk
    Dennis the Cat
    Richard Manklow
    Franco La Bruna
    Donald Weaver
    Matthew Hogan
    mohd
    Liam Mahon
    Alan Romero
    Steve Bonds
    João Santos
    Christian S. Trenk
    Pierre Le Mouel
    Christine Purvis
    Seth Reeves
    Sources:
    A People’s History of Modern Europe by William A. Pelz
    Beyond War Crimes: Denazification, 'Obnoxious' Germans and US Policy in Franco's Spain after the Second World War by DAVID A. MESSENGER
    An elephant in the garden: The Allies, Spain, and oil in World War II by LEONARD CARUANA and HUGH ROCKOFF

Komentáře • 5K

  • @andreischipor38
    @andreischipor38 Před 3 lety +16627

    Franco about Germany in 1939: Cool guy!
    Franco about Germany in 1945: Never met this man in my life!

    • @Alusnovalotus
      @Alusnovalotus Před 3 lety +339

      How trumpist

    • @silverhost9782
      @silverhost9782 Před 3 lety +752

      @@Alusnovalotus yawn

    • @zombiegameruk
      @zombiegameruk Před 3 lety +463

      @@Alusnovalotus People like you got boring after the first week he won, now it's just sad tbh. Go find something constructive to do.

    • @goatman9998
      @goatman9998 Před 3 lety +621

      @@Alusnovalotus npc response.

    • @libertylovin2359
      @libertylovin2359 Před 3 lety +138

      @@Alusnovalotus Trump 2020

  • @SDZ675
    @SDZ675 Před 3 lety +7839

    Allies in 1945: Anyone anti Fascist is a friend.
    Allies in 1947: Anyone anti Communist is a friend.

    • @muesliman100
      @muesliman100 Před 3 lety +14

      @CodingCrusader1095 the royal families? How so?

    • @lemat579
      @lemat579 Před 3 lety +193

      Well.
      Whom both fascism and communism oppose?
      -they oppose international capitalism. And that is whom rules the world.

    • @darthrevan3342
      @darthrevan3342 Před 3 lety +341

      @@lemat579 Errrrrmm nahnahnah fascist don't oppose inetrnational capital they start fairly protectionist but start getting imperialist the moment they run out of options. AKA they all ened up wantig to be what the U.S.A are today XD !

    • @lemat579
      @lemat579 Před 3 lety +123

      @@darthrevan3342 Hi.
      national socialists in Germany invented kind of National Capitalism thing in 1930's.
      Spain of Franco went into "autarchia" - isolation and self-sufficiency. Italy of Mussolini, Fascios were combat small troops allied with local big owners and capitalists.
      What I want to say is that Fascism easily goes along with national capitalism. National.

    • @darthrevan3342
      @darthrevan3342 Před 3 lety +16

      @@lemat579 Importing people from africa to be treated as secondary citizens that could be exploited ! Because they to concurence Jewish Palestine in furnishing the reich with oranges so nazi could make their Fanta.

  • @CitroenGS
    @CitroenGS Před rokem +296

    Franco didn't enter the war on Axis side thanks to Wilhelm Canaris. The Admiral talked a lot with Franco. One of the times they talked, Franco expressed his fears of a German invasion to Spain in 1941, and Canaris told him to forget that, because in late 1941 Germany will be invading the USSR. This is why Franco could delay entering on the war.
    After Canaris was executed due to the July plot and the war ended, his wife moved to Spain and was given the pension of the widow of a dead admiral. I think that Franco knew Canaris was an anti-nazi.

    • @user-nr5tp2jo3u
      @user-nr5tp2jo3u Před 7 měsíci +5

      You lie because blue divison bsieged Leningrad.

    • @johnroscoe2406
      @johnroscoe2406 Před 7 měsíci +39

      @@user-nr5tp2jo3u That was a token "volunteer" force that amounted to nothing.

    • @johnroscoe2406
      @johnroscoe2406 Před 7 měsíci +7

      @CitreonGS The pension for Canaris' wife was provided by the US, don't know if you knew that, or decided to leave that part out.

    • @CitroenGS
      @CitroenGS Před 7 měsíci +20

      @@johnroscoe2406 what I knew is that Spain payed the pension. If she got another one from the U.S., good for her. But she moved to Madrid after the war.

    • @JeffEbe-te2xs
      @JeffEbe-te2xs Před 26 dny

      Token
      Wasn’t there long

  • @SteveEdwardCooper
    @SteveEdwardCooper Před 2 lety +52

    The ghost of Napoleon advising against invading Spain was next level funny.

  • @oswald7597
    @oswald7597 Před 3 lety +5292

    Of course the French didn't like him. The 19th century taught us that Franco-Franco relations are distrustful at best

    • @quasar4780
      @quasar4780 Před 3 lety +176

      Okay you got me there x)

    • @jacquesmorin2597
      @jacquesmorin2597 Před 3 lety +182

      That's an excellent joke that I'll happily make more popular in my baguette country

    • @JLvatron
      @JLvatron Před 2 lety +38

      I wonder if Franco from Seinfeld was named after him?

    • @hello-cn5nh
      @hello-cn5nh Před 2 lety +20

      Franco did nothing wrong

    • @lastguy8613
      @lastguy8613 Před 2 lety +5

      Well done..

  • @michaelrizka
    @michaelrizka Před 3 lety +9769

    I love it whenever the "diplomacy" scene shows up it always a character happily walk in a flower garden as if their diplomacy succeeded

  • @shannonmikko9865
    @shannonmikko9865 Před 3 lety +102

    0:27 I love the image of Franco physically charging into battle against Germany

    • @whatischeese4179
      @whatischeese4179 Před rokem +8

      Right? I was expecting a soldier of Spain, but there Franco goes! Into the bloody conflict

  • @randomobserver8168
    @randomobserver8168 Před 2 lety +226

    1. An alternative Spanish government might have skewed pro-Russian. They were already worried about France and Italy going that way. Why rock the boat?
    2. Franco was willing to cooperate with the US. Again, why rock the boat?
    3. If there was the slightest chance Franco's Spain would have resisted and required an invasion, why expend more American or British lives or resources for no gain?
    The Allies went to war with Germany and Italy because they attacked things and threatened British, American and wider interests. Franco hadn't done any of those things.

    • @Necroskull388
      @Necroskull388 Před rokem +36

      Indeed, it’s almost like international capital is perfectly compatible with fascism so long as the fascists are polite enough not to touch their things.

    • @black-uh1df
      @black-uh1df Před rokem +13

      ​@@Necroskull388 Then explain the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact or the KPD's cooperation with Hitler

    • @REALASUNDER
      @REALASUNDER Před rokem +2

      ​@black-uh1df you mean the alliance between the two state capitalist nations?

    • @fortusvictus8297
      @fortusvictus8297 Před 11 měsíci +12

      @@Necroskull388 There were several other fascist counties post-WW2. Argentina, Peru, at one point Chile come to mind. Additionally, there is a pretty good case that modern China is more fascist than communist in its structure at this point.

    • @elitefencer777
      @elitefencer777 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@fortusvictus8297 Don't forget Brasil! It's facista lasted juuuust long enough to see Brasil through the war. And then be immediately deposed. In part because some felt Vargas' fence-sitting had isolated Brasil and cost it opportunities on the global stage.

  • @jackfitzgerald2955
    @jackfitzgerald2955 Před 3 lety +7770

    Britain decided to finally conquer Spain later on through the use of tourism.

    • @alejandrop.s.3942
      @alejandrop.s.3942 Před 3 lety +607

      Indeed, the British veterans have a stronghold on Benidorm whereas the unexperienced paratroopers have seized Mallorca, setting their HQ on Magaluf.

    • @alejandrosotomartin9720
      @alejandrosotomartin9720 Před 3 lety +689

      Germans and British are still fighting WW2 in the beaches of Mallorca.

    • @chefboy1980
      @chefboy1980 Před 3 lety +20

      This.

    • @ln6373
      @ln6373 Před 3 lety +153

      yep.
      they go so fucking wild, holy shit. before this pandemy they would appear on the news every so often and it would be quite embarasing, though we kind of need them because our economy really depends on turism
      (no hate, they're nice but need to chill at parties)

    • @kingt0295
      @kingt0295 Před 3 lety +201

      @@ln6373 when your country is a boring rainy shothole ig it’s understandable they go hard when they get the chance away lol

  • @jesusf.bravog.3777
    @jesusf.bravog.3777 Před 3 lety +3782

    Franco mastered the skill of moving so incredibly slow, he became invisible

  • @warhawk94PT
    @warhawk94PT Před rokem +92

    It's well documented how Antonio Salazar from Portugal helped draw Franco away from the Axis. Strange to not see a reference to Portugal in your animation. If you want documentation just tell me or search a paper by Maria Inácia Rezola.

  • @franciscopadilla4844
    @franciscopadilla4844 Před rokem +379

    Nunca pensé que vería hablar de Franco a un canal inglés, pero sorprendentemente esta muy bien explicado

    • @Alfonso88279
      @Alfonso88279 Před rokem +28

      En España la peña sigue traumatizada culturalmente por la guerra civil, no hay huevos para hablar del tema. Pero visto desde fuera la situación era muy simple, o como mínimo no requiere tanta delicadeza.

    • @DarKodama
      @DarKodama Před rokem +7

      Y aquí dices lo mismo y dicen que son inventos de los "social-comunistas".

    • @amcespana2150
      @amcespana2150 Před rokem

      El avion que trajo a Franco a España lo puso el servicio secreto ingles. Los "aliados" respaldaron el golpe de estado, de que de hecho se fraguo en Inglaterra. Lo demas es propaganda de guerra.

    • @_MiniBoss_
      @_MiniBoss_ Před rokem +10

      En España si no dices que estaba loco y era malvado eres un facha. Se ha dejado el raciocinio para otros países.

    • @Fqnd0lNasay
      @Fqnd0lNasay Před rokem +16

      ​@@_MiniBoss_ no sé qué entiendes por malvado, pero bueno no era xd. Así que sí, si no dices que era malvado eres facha 👍🏻

  • @Jefrings
    @Jefrings Před 3 lety +1657

    Franco: Maybe if I don't move, they will forget about me...

    • @mumblerapper1105
      @mumblerapper1105 Před 3 lety +131

      It worked

    • @spk1121
      @spk1121 Před 3 lety +40

      Jurassic Park tactics!

    • @harddrivegamesHDG
      @harddrivegamesHDG Před 3 lety +32

      more tha 40 years later, same tactic worked for ex president Rajoy to stay in charge for 8 years. -_-"

    • @user-uw3fi2zg4t
      @user-uw3fi2zg4t Před 3 lety +4

      @@harddrivegamesHDG i doubt they were going to get invaded back then

    • @TimeG37
      @TimeG37 Před 2 lety +7

      Well that worked perfectly

  • @JamesGhee3
    @JamesGhee3 Před 3 lety +4073

    "The French hated Franco for many reasons"
    1st: "He existed" LOL

    • @cameraman502
      @cameraman502 Před 2 lety +58

      Typical French.

    • @DeclinedMercy
      @DeclinedMercy Před 2 lety +59

      That's classic Franco for ya

    • @gerardsotxoa
      @gerardsotxoa Před 2 lety +71

      De gaulle Hated Franco, but Franco had many fans in France. The French legion still salutes Franco because he earned the ''Legion d'honnour'' and the french goverment ordered to create a movie to honor Franco in 1927.

    • @ajarofmayonnaise3250
      @ajarofmayonnaise3250 Před 2 lety +17

      Based French.

    • @johannsanchocuevas7854
      @johannsanchocuevas7854 Před 2 lety +30

      When you realize that the name Franco is another way to say France

  • @Moose-iz1uo
    @Moose-iz1uo Před 3 lety +17

    History has never been so much fun to learn. Gotta love the animation and the the grammar used.

  • @ianlloyd6812
    @ianlloyd6812 Před rokem +3

    Useful, simple, easy to grasp, historic explanation. Thank you!

  • @LedosKell
    @LedosKell Před 3 lety +1514

    Franco: "We killed a lot of Commies, and I mean a lot of Commies, a few years ago."
    UK: "Seems like a stand-up guy."

    • @joseanl
      @joseanl Před 3 lety +49

      in the end, its the brits, always the brits...

    • @alienlife7754
      @alienlife7754 Před 3 lety +33

      The only good commie . . .

    • @CrimsonPhantom88
      @CrimsonPhantom88 Před 3 lety +62

      Chile: Hold my helicopter

    • @RageSondrayy
      @RageSondrayy Před 3 lety +7

      @Paul Judkins you wanna kill people??

    • @minotauros13
      @minotauros13 Před 3 lety +9

      Yes, well... The vast majority of the armed opposition to Franco did not affiliate themselves with the Communist Party at all... Granted, the vast majority were of Marxist ideology, but they despised the Commies just as much as Franco did...

  • @weirdshibainu
    @weirdshibainu Před 3 lety +4203

    Franco:" I'd like to thank the Germans for assisting in my consolidation of power.
    Also Franco:" I'd like to thank the Allies for allowing me to remain in power.

    • @PolishBehemoth
      @PolishBehemoth Před 3 lety +208

      It's called smart politics.

    • @alexporter7379
      @alexporter7379 Před 3 lety +122

      Not alot of allowing was done. The Allies knew that with the USSR taking the East, they were gonna need all the friends they could get. And the Spanish really hated the Communists. Turns out it worked for the best, as Spain was a middle man in Operation Paperclip, which put a man on the moon.

    • @PolishBehemoth
      @PolishBehemoth Před 3 lety +116

      @Spartan 506 I believe it. I studed the spanish civil war very much. The socialists were killing christians for no reason and stealing peoples property they had for generations. Franco and the nationalists were way better in every way.

    • @danielboone8256
      @danielboone8256 Před 3 lety

      Why do you have a satanic profile picture?

    • @danielboone8256
      @danielboone8256 Před 3 lety +5

      @Spartan 506 I'm in the New Covenant with God through Jesus Christ.

  • @18pablo88
    @18pablo88 Před 3 lety +5

    Funny, informative and brilliantly put together. Love Francos wee worried look

  • @mlc4495
    @mlc4495 Před 2 lety +109

    There is an argument by historians that Mussolini could have survived WWII had he done like Franco and simply been neutral during the conflict. I'm not sure it's the same situation though since Italy was far more strategically relevant in WWII than Spain but it's an interesting hypothesis nonetheless.

    • @Tortellobello45
      @Tortellobello45 Před rokem +22

      As an Italian, yes.
      Before he decided to join the war, the Allies admired him(except the Liberals, they’re tol based).
      Mussolini hated Sh|tler, but eventually he had to either be neutral or join the Axis, as the Allies wanted to embargo him.
      Italy was very useful for Germany to avoid Britain’s blockade, but the Germans were so selfish.

    • @Tortellobello45
      @Tortellobello45 Před rokem

      @Ferbujosbe yeah, upon signing Versailles the British only thought about their gain, ignoring Italy(which didn’t gain their territories as in London secret pact),Russia(which was engulfed in a civil war)and France(which wanted a divided Germany).
      Also they still could’ve invaded Germany when Churchill made it clear that Sh|tler was rearming

    • @wimschmied3800
      @wimschmied3800 Před rokem +7

      @@Tortellobello45 Mussolini and Hitler admired one another. What are you talking about?

    • @Tortellobello45
      @Tortellobello45 Před rokem

      @@wimschmied3800 Sh|tler admired Mussolini, but Mussolini hated him.
      He was about to ratify the Stresa Front with the Allies, he massed troops on the Austrian Border after the Anschluss and took a pacifist stand in the Munich agreement, gaining the respect of the Allies, but he wanted to rule the Mediterrean and Britain was an obstacle, while Sh|tler wanted Italian help in the war against UK in the colonies and wanted to avoid Britain’s blockade which costed the Kaiser’s Germany WW1.
      It was only during the Spanish Civil War and after the accords which led Germany to renounce their claims in South Tyrol that the relations improved

    • @wimschmied3800
      @wimschmied3800 Před rokem +10

      @@Tortellobello45 Incorrect. Mussolini adopted many of Hitler's policies and had they mutual respect for one another's abilities. Italy and Mussolini was saved by Germany multiple times. E.g. The Greek war and the North African front, Hitler even sent men to rescue Mussolini out of loyalty and respect even though Mussolini had lost all official power. If they hated each other to the point you claim, they never would've been on the same side. As you said South Tyrol was recognised as Italian, Italy respected and accepted the anschluss. Hitler and Mussolini were arguably the most connected nations and men in Ww2 consisting their proximity and similar ideology and enemies. Calling Germany selfish is wrong considering it had to sacrifice valuable divisions to assist Italy in Greece even though it didn't even want to fight Greece for example.

  • @Salty-Doggy
    @Salty-Doggy Před 3 lety +2408

    Napoleon's ghost would not advise a war in Spain. I wonder why?

    • @pussinjordans8800
      @pussinjordans8800 Před 3 lety +371

      Laughs in Spanish guerilla**

    • @kidsmipad8324
      @kidsmipad8324 Před 3 lety +240

      Peninsular wars flashback

    • @TheFiresloth
      @TheFiresloth Před 3 lety +46

      Where are the ghosts of Soult and Suchet when we need them ?

    • @MichaelSmith-ij2ut
      @MichaelSmith-ij2ut Před 3 lety +57

      Ghosts are known to be wise sages with access to Spooky Wikipedia.

    • @juanmola2000
      @juanmola2000 Před 3 lety +71

      @@MichaelSmith-ij2ut You missed a massive opportunity to call it Spookypedia.

  • @sergiovarela8724
    @sergiovarela8724 Před 3 lety +4786

    Ok 3 things to point out:
    1. The decision of declaring war to Japan was also heavily motivated due to the masacre of almost all of the spanish population in the Philipines by the japanese forces (burning then alive in churches and stabing with bayonets those who had taken refuge in the spanish embassy.
    2. The Soviets had also quite a resentment against Franco due to the "Blue division", a spanish military force sent to help in the invasion of Barbarosa which fought in the siege of Leningrad.
    3. The suport of the british to Fascist Spain was also influenced by a really god
    relationship between their aristocrats, noblemen and businesmen. It was common for spanish wealthy familys to sent their sons to study to England where naturally ended up forming friendships.

    • @shashwatsinha2704
      @shashwatsinha2704 Před 3 lety +120

      Can ypu tell me more about the Spanish-British relations or point to a source?

    • @PolishBehemoth
      @PolishBehemoth Před 3 lety +386

      Stalin tried to take over Spain during revolution! Franco had every reason to hate communism and send the division against him!

    • @DISTurbedwaffle918
      @DISTurbedwaffle918 Před 3 lety +171

      So basically, Spain was the good guy in WWII.

    • @saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014
      @saguntum-iberian-greekkons7014 Před 3 lety +35

      I never heard about japanese killing Spanish citizens in the Phillipines. I don’t think its true

    • @sergiovarela8724
      @sergiovarela8724 Před 3 lety +110

      @@shashwatsinha2704 In books: Paul Preston in his book about the Spanish civil War when talking about the international relations at the start of the war and also in his Biography about Juan Carlos i think there were some comentaries also but the book its quite big and i am not really going to search for the page quite a big book and just like the Romanov by Simon S. Montfiore i regret not having put markers on the books i read i started after that last one.
      In the sources its more dificult to point especifics since its generally something that comes out of diaries, albums and that sort of thing.
      Then there is tv documentals, sadly enough all in spanish.

  • @End-Result
    @End-Result Před 2 lety +13

    I'm glad you covered this. Also impressed you used the works of the late William A. Pelz as a reference point. Very nice.

  • @espanasectaria2818
    @espanasectaria2818 Před 2 lety +1

    Thanks for the video. Greatings from Spain!!!

  • @pakhmu
    @pakhmu Před 3 lety +1792

    Franco in 1941: **sends Division Azúl to the eastern front**
    Franco in 1945: uuuh ... i can explain

    • @sho3003
      @sho3003 Před 3 lety +175

      Azul doesn't have tilde

    • @nicosmind3
      @nicosmind3 Před 3 lety +125

      They were voluntary as far as i know, so a good way of giving support without giving support as it wasnt government sanctioned.
      Almost like how the Irish do things cause they send troops to fight in both sides, then hope no one calls them on their bull

    • @FKaps16
      @FKaps16 Před 3 lety +96

      There were Spanish volunteers on both sides of the war.
      The first unit to enter Paris when it was taken back from the Germans was also Spanish.

    • @Mrkabrat
      @Mrkabrat Před 3 lety +87

      @@FKaps16 Republican ones too. It was funny because they joined De Gaulle because he promised them that he would move into spain next and overthrow Franco. He didn't fulfill his promise

    • @wolfsden6479
      @wolfsden6479 Před 2 lety +12

      He hates communism

  • @peruamorrortubarrenetxea5300
    @peruamorrortubarrenetxea5300 Před 3 lety +2505

    It might be interesting to note that there was an armed attempt by the Spanish National Union (UNE), a group sponsored mainly by the PCE (Spanish Communist Party), to militarily invade Spain with the aim of provoking a general anti-Francoist insurrection among the population. Up to 6000 "guerrilleros" invaded in October, 1944, in what was called the "Invasion of Val D'Aran", but it was an utter failure, since the expected general uprising didn't occur. This further convinced many that Franco's regime was strong at this point and that it faced no widespread internal opposition, and made the Allies think that removing him would be more costly and detrimental than not to.

    • @alejandrolaguna203
      @alejandrolaguna203 Před 3 lety +241

      Hmmm, almost as if people didn’t want to fight two civil wars in arrow🤔 how quaint

    • @RyoKasai25
      @RyoKasai25 Před 3 lety +274

      To be fair, many spaniards were tired and sick from the recent civil war, it's not hard to believe that your average Alejandro wouldn't be part of an armed uprising, even if it was to depose the dictator.

    • @GeneralBlorp
      @GeneralBlorp Před 3 lety +3

      lmao what a bunch of idiotas grandes

    • @rohunsaigal2576
      @rohunsaigal2576 Před 3 lety +58

      also the Spanish Marquis was active in Guerrilla campaigns and hiding in France until around the end of WW2, so Franco did have some experience in putting down rebellions by that point

    • @peruamorrortubarrenetxea5300
      @peruamorrortubarrenetxea5300 Před 3 lety +112

      @@RyoKasai25 We should also take into account that most of the people that had been politically active in favor of the Second Spanish Republic had by that point been killed in war, executed, vanished, imprisoned or forced into exile, both internal and external, and those who remained were either hiding or too afraid to challenge the statu quo, so no wonder that plan failed miserably.

  • @mhuston7355
    @mhuston7355 Před rokem

    Thank you. I had been thinking about this sometime ago and now it seems clearer to me. Thank you.

  • @paulcoulthard8654
    @paulcoulthard8654 Před rokem +1

    Fascinating - I did always wonder about this - and now I KNOW. Muchas Gracias.

  • @GreatRedMenace
    @GreatRedMenace Před 3 lety +2064

    Correction: Spain WAS NOT neutral in WWII. It was "non-belligerant", meaning that they sent troops to aid the Germans without formally declaring war.

    • @DISTurbedwaffle918
      @DISTurbedwaffle918 Před 3 lety +308

      They mostly only aided in Operation Barbarossa, as Franco viewed the destruction of Communism to be a worthy effort.
      Despite this, he also advocated for the Allied war effort against Japan, while also personally being opposed to German expansion.

    • @Angel-wo8gv
      @Angel-wo8gv Před 3 lety +51

      Yeah but Hitler wanted to build a military outpost in the Pyrenees and Franco said "Fuck you" sssssooooo....

    • @JarrodFrates
      @JarrodFrates Před 3 lety +172

      Spain started as neutral because of Germany's alliance with the communist USSR, but changed to non-belligerent status when Italy entered the war on June 10, 1940. In October 1940, Spain signed the Protocol of Hendaya, which included joining the Steel Pact that Germany and Italy signed in 1939. This meant collaboration with Germany and Italy but not a formal joining of the Tripartite Pact. Germany pushed the latter, which the Allies feared because it could mean closing off the Mediterranean to Allied forces, so the Allies reduced trade sanctions that were hampering Spain's economic survival and prepurchased Spanish goods to keep them out of German hands (and British cash bribes to key Spanish elites helped).
      At the same time, Germany started having trouble paying for Spanish goods it did import and having trouble fulfilling promised exports that Spain purchased. With the start of Operation Barbarossa, Germany's attention was diverted and they didn't push Spain so hard on the Tripartite Pact. As Operation Torch got underway in North Africa, internal government opposition in Spain saw even more reason to stay out of the war because it looked bad for the Axis. By October 1943, Spain had returned to a declared neutral status, though Franco still had clear leanings toward Berlin, as evidenced by his protection of German assets and refusal to limit German access.
      Spain didn't entirely act like a neutral country, and its pro-Axis overtures clearly violated basic tenets of activities of neutral nations. But it also wasn't treated like one. Germany held sway over it both on the basis of historical assistance and threat of military action to try to force an alliance, and the Allies used economic actions and threat of military action to try to force neutrality, all of which violated basic tenets of treatment of neutral nations. It's hard to look back on them and assign a binary good or bad label because much of what they did was playing for survival.

    • @GreatRedMenace
      @GreatRedMenace Před 3 lety +33

      @@DISTurbedwaffle918 He wasn't personally opposed to German domination at all. His admiration letters to Hitler are proof enough for that.

    • @GreatRedMenace
      @GreatRedMenace Před 3 lety +20

      @Jonathan Williams Except no. They participated actively in war crimes at Leningrad.

  • @heidi7151
    @heidi7151 Před 3 lety +1527

    Franco was anti-Soviet. That's the main reason. Also, Churchill (also anti-Soviet) was pro-Franco in the Spanish Civil War.

    • @nickbell4984
      @nickbell4984 Před 3 lety +73

      Yes Churchill was anti-soviet, but Churchill hated Fascism so I don't know about pro-Franco but I see your point.

    • @nickbell4984
      @nickbell4984 Před 3 lety +4

      @@Davidromasantavazquez oh ok

    • @nickbell4984
      @nickbell4984 Před 3 lety +59

      @Spartan 506 Yes he was

    • @piperjj4486
      @piperjj4486 Před 3 lety +3

      @Spartan 506 "Dictator" Churchill? XD You've mixed your facts up bad.

    • @plak77
      @plak77 Před 3 lety +32

      @Spartan 506 National Catholicism is the answer you were looking for

  • @whitestriderable
    @whitestriderable Před 3 lety +108

    Franco has been wiser than Mussolini, didn't join WW2 and lived more than him and Hitler. In the end Franco probably knew that although nazi Germany was powerful it simply couldn't win against half Europe, USA and URSS combined. Or simply he wasn't too ambitious, he didn't even try to invade Portugal or France.

    • @xiangonzalezbello5305
      @xiangonzalezbello5305 Před 10 měsíci +2

      O Andorra.

    • @karlheisenberg2857
      @karlheisenberg2857 Před 9 měsíci +7

      When most of the negotiations between Germany and Spain took place (mid till end 1940), France was quickly defeated, USA was not in the game and USSR was allied with Germany. Franco surely did not knew Germany was losing. He did know Spain would lose at the very least most colonies and the canaries to the British if Germany would not help with gigantic amounts of ressources and fortifications. Which Hitler again wouldn't do.

    • @shuepsx652
      @shuepsx652 Před 8 měsíci +4

      Spain joining the axis and Portugal joining the alleys would have been mutually assured destruction

    • @johnnotrealname8168
      @johnnotrealname8168 Před 5 měsíci +1

      @@karlheisenberg2857Most of his economic aid was coming from the Western allies so he had no reason to rock that boat, add to that the split in his coalition domestically (The Traditional Catholic side were not fond of fascism, at least not enough to join the War.).

    • @AhintofChan
      @AhintofChan Před 2 měsíci

      Or he realized his "regime" was a joke at the time and would have barely been able to maintain even the first month of an offensive war. He liked to say he was strong though which was adorable

  • @Irochi
    @Irochi Před 3 lety +58

    Interesting note: In Spain we are told in school that Spain was not "neutral" but "non belligerent" during WWII.
    We did send the "Blue Division" to Russia to support the Germans after all ^^;

    • @Maidaseu
      @Maidaseu Před 2 lety +15

      And Franco used the German bombers against the republicans

    • @commisaryarreck3974
      @commisaryarreck3974 Před 2 lety +15

      Volunteers
      I still see that as neutral, especially as it was basically just paying back a debt to the Germans

    • @meanmanturbo
      @meanmanturbo Před 2 lety +5

      That was the same status Sweden declared in the Winter war between Finland and the Soviet Union.

    • @duran3d
      @duran3d Před 2 lety +7

      In practise "non-belligerant" equals to neutral. It's true that a small group of Spanish volunteers helped Germany although they only fought in the Russian front vs the comunists (also some Spaniards fought vs Gemany on their own).

    • @MrPakurfulo
      @MrPakurfulo Před 2 lety +6

      There were also volunteers who fought for the allies, in fact more fighters than the blue division. Although it was against the wish of the government, of course.

  • @primuspilusfellatus6501
    @primuspilusfellatus6501 Před 3 lety +346

    I read "Allies" as "Aliens" in the thumbnail, and i was like: Now we are answering the real questions

    • @claypidgeon4807
      @claypidgeon4807 Před 3 lety +5

      Yeah, be careful around that Tsukalous guy, his hair might crawl off his head and attack you.

    • @monroevian
      @monroevian Před 2 lety +17

      I'm just imagining a legion of aliens in their UFOs descending upon Spain and abducting Franco

    • @burakmuslu3061
      @burakmuslu3061 Před 2 lety

      It is possible to do this in HoI2 but i cannot guarantee they will stop afterwards

  • @ominosentenzioso5100
    @ominosentenzioso5100 Před 3 lety +1352

    Andorra: "Why USA havent eleminated you?"
    Spain:"They didnt like us, but they disliked USSR more"

    • @nerdomatic2489
      @nerdomatic2489 Před 3 lety +12

      @mPky1 Welcome to the real world. You and I can't change this in no way, so move on.

    • @bcy4551
      @bcy4551 Před 3 lety +13

      @mPky1 democracy does not equal freedom, look at south america

    • @QWERTY-gp8fd
      @QWERTY-gp8fd Před 3 lety +7

      @@bcy4551 how south america is democracy? if its not free then its not democratic. simple

    • @dovidsokol380
      @dovidsokol380 Před 3 lety +2

      Well Played

    • @lemat579
      @lemat579 Před 3 lety +1

      Hmmm. No. Roosvelt used to love Stalin.
      And was in, for granting Anything to Stalin, only if he decide to attack Japan in Manchuria, and by so doing, relief American effort in pacific.

  • @CyberneticOrganism01
    @CyberneticOrganism01 Před 2 lety +1

    Thanks for the concise explanation 👍

  • @thepoliticaljockey
    @thepoliticaljockey Před 3 lety +3

    Thanks for this video. Never thought of this very obvious point why Franko wasn't removed after WW II. Now cleared

  • @quickrat3348
    @quickrat3348 Před 3 lety +2493

    A Spanish scholar of WW2, Florentino Rodao, wrote a book on this issue, claiming that Franco's regime had not a double but a triple view on the war.
    1) War against communism, in which Franco supported the Axis.
    2) War against Japan expansionism, in which Franco supported the Allies. In fact, Japan carried out a genocide against Spanish speakers in the Philippines, and even invaded the Spanish embassy.
    3) War against German expansionism, in which Franco decided to be neutral.
    These triple view outraged almost everyone outside Spain, but was an intelligent decision in order to avoid war yet getting a good result from any possible outcome.

    • @BigBroTejano
      @BigBroTejano Před 3 lety +242

      Pragmatism.

    • @silverhost9782
      @silverhost9782 Před 3 lety +351

      It's easy to shit on Franco for his obvious faults but as far as totalitarian dictators go he seems fairly reasonable

    • @Uberkatze-
      @Uberkatze- Před 3 lety +123

      @@silverhost9782that's caude he wasn't a totalitarian dictator

    • @bobing1752
      @bobing1752 Před 3 lety +58

      @@Uberkatze- Yes, but still a dictator

    • @Chinaball-fx7gi
      @Chinaball-fx7gi Před 3 lety +306

      @@silverhost9782 he was not a totalitarian dictator, he more resembled that of a conservative military dictator, which is not too much better, but hey, atleast he had not gone to the levels of Stalin

  • @lowenwelle1044
    @lowenwelle1044 Před 3 lety +1532

    "
    I'd rather have four teeth pulled than negotiate with Franco again..."
    - Some weird Germany-Boi from Austria

  • @imperialfish454
    @imperialfish454 Před 3 lety +11

    Franco's strategy: "The Allies' vision is based on movement. If we don't move a muscle...they can't see us."

  • @nik65stgt60
    @nik65stgt60 Před rokem

    Fascinating content!

  • @darkphosphorus330
    @darkphosphorus330 Před 3 lety +734

    Franco didn’t have James Bissonete there to fund his military interests

    • @FirstnameLastname-cw8ok
      @FirstnameLastname-cw8ok Před 3 lety +8

      Shut up

    • @raghaviyer3065
      @raghaviyer3065 Před 3 lety +22

      Very True

    • @julianusvictor327
      @julianusvictor327 Před 3 lety +28

      @@FirstnameLastname-cw8ok Someone get this guys mum he's having a temper tantrum.

    • @legowagfles7287
      @legowagfles7287 Před 3 lety +3

      Be quiet. And that’s not how you spell his name

    • @selleneus
      @selleneus Před 3 lety +1

      Oversimplified and history matters both new videos, my favorite British history channels.
      Edit:
      Enjoy the video glad we talked about Argentina and often less talked about nation in history. I'd love to see more videoson other nations history and there's current position on the world stage keep up the good work.
      Maybe one on why not all British colonies are in the Commonwealth, or the Indian revolution aftermath/ post world war 2

  • @pacoramon9468
    @pacoramon9468 Před 3 lety +14

    0:41 Franco knew about the danger of weeaboos.

  • @olivierfouassier6495
    @olivierfouassier6495 Před rokem

    Did learn something here. Thanks.

  • @cageybee7221
    @cageybee7221 Před 3 lety +425

    TL;DR: franco played his cards right and the allies really couldn't be arsed.

    • @miguelarribas9990
      @miguelarribas9990 Před 3 lety +9

      If Franco had been in the Brexit talks... :-P

    • @kellyvaters1689
      @kellyvaters1689 Před 3 lety +28

      He also had a backup plan, at least on paper, to secure an anti-communist Spain after his death. By decreeing Don Juan Carlos, grandson of King Afonso and Queen Victoria Eugenie (a granddaughter of Queen Victoria) as his heir in government, he held over the Spanish people a carrot of a restored monarchy. What he hadn't counted on was that, after Franco's death, King Juan Carlos would open the country to deep political reform moved towards democracy.

    • @Frendlu
      @Frendlu Před 2 lety +20

      Franco was a son of.... but was a very smart guy. Someone stupid can't stand for so long in power.
      And in fact, I have the feeling that Franco and Hitler didn't get along so well (maybe, for that, Franco was saved after WW2). It's knwon that Hitler despised Franco, and Franco, well, he was a military, a men how earn his place (he was also teacher from a military school, and that, after gaining medals of honor from the Morroco conflict some years ago), so the difference betwen both Hitler and Franco were enormous.

    • @cageybee7221
      @cageybee7221 Před 2 lety +12

      @@kellyvaters1689 yea that was kindof a bruh moment for franco, but it ended up going decently for spain once the dictatorship ended, though of course no country is without issues.

    • @JoseGarcia-xf5gk
      @JoseGarcia-xf5gk Před 2 lety

      @@Frendlu Hitler was a soldier too in ww1

  • @Angel_Gomez
    @Angel_Gomez Před 3 lety +296

    1.Those "good relationships with Britain" weren't quite good as Churchill declared a naval blockade to Spain in hopes of drowning their food supply. The only country who didn't respect this blockade was Argentina as Peron sent tons of meat for stopping the famine outbreaks in Spain.
    2. Spain had a strong resentment towards Japan due to the genocide of Filipinos and Spanish speakers in the Philippines.

    • @alejandrop.s.3942
      @alejandrop.s.3942 Před 3 lety +10

      Podrías recomendarme alguna lectura de este periodo? Me interesa bastante, y no conozco en absoluto el genocidio de filipinos hispanohablantes. De hecho, no tenía ni idea de que Franco hubiera ayudado contra Japón.

    • @Angel_Gomez
      @Angel_Gomez Před 3 lety +9

      @@alejandrop.s.3942 Más que libros todo esto lo he ido leyendo en la sección histórico cultural del ABC (Te la recomiendo porque cada semana suben algo bueno) y en algún que otro documental de los que subía Canal Historia hace años.
      Pd: Si te interesa, te recomiendo que busques cosas sobre el genocidio filipino que hizo EEUU en 1899, justo después de la expulsión de los españoles.

    • @mikicerise6250
      @mikicerise6250 Před 2 lety

      @@Angel_Gomez El genocidio estadounidense contra los filipinos hispanohablantes lo conozco, pero lo que usted ha comentado es que Franco habría querido ayudar a EE UU contra Japón por un supuesto genocidio japonés contra los filipinos hispanohablantes, cosa que me extraña sobremanera. ¿Cuál es la documentación que demuestra que Japón exterminara a los filipinos hispanohablantes en la segunda Guerra mundial? Que sepa yo, ocuparon Filipinas principalmente para controlar sus bases navales, al igual que hicieron con Papua, sin ninguna agenda étnica particular más allá de facilitar la colonización japonesa. Las masacres japonesas se dirigieron principalmente contra los chinos en la invasión de China.

    • @warfarenotwarfair5655
      @warfarenotwarfair5655 Před 5 měsíci

      ​@@alejandrop.s.3942He didn't help. The United States defeated Japan.

  • @TheRealCharlesDarwin
    @TheRealCharlesDarwin Před rokem +2

    I've read "why didn't the aliens get rid of Franco" ;_; I'll go get some sleep.

  • @snupmadra3787
    @snupmadra3787 Před 3 lety +23

    The Spanish considered declaring war on Japan. Now that is a good one!

    • @marneus
      @marneus Před 3 lety +17

      Yes, after the Japanese massacred the Spaniards living in the Philippines.

    • @blackpowderuser373
      @blackpowderuser373 Před 2 lety +10

      Would be interesting to see Spanish troops fighting in the Pacific Theater.
      Spain: SIII RECONQUISTA EL TIEMPO-
      USA: N O
      Philippines: N O
      Spain: ...lo siento

    • @marneus
      @marneus Před 2 lety +3

      @@blackpowderuser373 do you suffer brain damage?

    • @ivanmacgar6447
      @ivanmacgar6447 Před 2 lety

      Actually, we DID informally declare war on Japan because of their massacres of Spanish citizens in the Philippines.

  • @NotAmira_
    @NotAmira_ Před 3 lety +685

    Because the Allies didn't go to the pastry section to spin three plates. They could have obtained sponsor money from Phil de Oink Oink.

    • @Nancy3
      @Nancy3 Před 3 lety +41

      I swear those Patreon names are fantastic.

    • @theinformationstation5328
      @theinformationstation5328 Před 3 lety +11

      He literally read off that name as I read this, little creeped right now

    • @USSAnimeNCC-
      @USSAnimeNCC- Před 3 lety +8

      The person who name was epicfailure make me laugh 😂

    • @jimtaylor294
      @jimtaylor294 Před 3 lety +7

      Or gained the support of Spencer Lightfoot, and Izzy?.

    • @anemu3819
      @anemu3819 Před 3 lety +9

      @@jimtaylor294 or james bizzonet

  • @RolIinStoner420
    @RolIinStoner420 Před 3 lety +489

    Franco: 'exists'
    French population: 'angry baguette noises'

  • @markstott6689
    @markstott6689 Před 3 lety

    I just love the name Kelly Moneymaker. I can't stop the video until it's been read out.

  • @Blessy.EXEreal
    @Blessy.EXEreal Před 11 měsíci +2

    Ghost Napoleon saying “would nit advise” is golden 😂

  • @jacklaurentius6130
    @jacklaurentius6130 Před 3 lety +3037

    And:
    *When you ally with communists to defeat the fascists but decide to ally with fascists to defeat communists*

    • @mattbowdenuh
      @mattbowdenuh Před 3 lety +316

      Almost like today with supporting some terror group against a regime, while supporting another regime against terrorists....politics is complicated.

    • @thethirdsicily4802
      @thethirdsicily4802 Před 3 lety +166

      Ussr 1939: *When you ally with fascists to defeat republicans but then ally with republicans to defeat fascists*

    • @carlosquintela2950
      @carlosquintela2950 Před 3 lety +127

      I don't know if it makes sense but, Spanish facist dictatorship and Portugal's dictatorship (Franco and Salazar) weren't as hard-line facist as Mussolini or Hitler. Don't get me wrong, they did a lot of bad stuff, but their facism was "softer"

    • @Jenkowelten
      @Jenkowelten Před 3 lety +44

      @@carlosquintela2950 Not "soft" fascism but corporatism

    • @thethirdsicily4802
      @thethirdsicily4802 Před 3 lety +37

      @@carlosquintela2950 Well yes, as far as I know neither were pure fascism, I am unsure about Portugals form of it but I know Franco was a Falangist, which had a few key differences.

  • @vladmihailghinea4626
    @vladmihailghinea4626 Před 3 lety +141

    We really need an episode about Salazar.

    • @soujirosasaki7570
      @soujirosasaki7570 Před 3 lety +7

      You called?
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .
      sorry i can't help it xD
      Julio Cesar Salazar at your service btw....

    • @steelbear2063
      @steelbear2063 Před 3 lety +7

      Yeah he was funny in Resident Evil 4. Oh wait, wrong one

    • @mohdadeeb1829
      @mohdadeeb1829 Před 3 lety +15

      Hitler : Why are you late ?
      Franco : I was doing stuff
      Salazar : I am the stuff .
      Franco : Salazar No !
      Hitler : Lmao Franco

    • @soujirosasaki7570
      @soujirosasaki7570 Před 3 lety +3

      @ᴇᴢᴇᴄʀɪs 305 i think there are also a video on portugal with some focus on Salazar... though there is still none about the person himself....

    • @whatischeese4179
      @whatischeese4179 Před rokem +1

      @@mohdadeeb1829
      I don't get the joke. Can you explain it?

  • @The01t
    @The01t Před rokem +3

    Franco was based. He was a cool, calm collected operator psychopath, whereas Hitler and Mussolini were crazy, angry murder hungry psychopath's. Franco hit the jackpot of the 'successful psychopath'.

  • @-JA-
    @-JA- Před 2 lety

    Thank you.

  • @greenveilgaming1149
    @greenveilgaming1149 Před 3 lety +53

    Attlee holding a sign saying: "what part of no?" Is my new favourite sign

  • @bartoszN01
    @bartoszN01 Před 3 lety +588

    My Video ideas:
    - When did Korea become christian?
    - When did the Pope lose power over Europe and when was the last time Europe listened to Pope?
    - Early History of HRE (from east francia to habsburg takeover).
    - WW1 outside Europe.
    - 7 Years War

    • @TheOstry322
      @TheOstry322 Před 3 lety +73

      WWI outside Europe is interesting

    • @-haclong2366
      @-haclong2366 Před 3 lety +24

      North Korea is mostly Atheist.

    • @bigpotato8
      @bigpotato8 Před 3 lety +52

      Wait since when is Korea Christian?

    • @csvigneshwar3390
      @csvigneshwar3390 Před 3 lety +14

      @@bigpotato8 yup they are

    • @ominosentenzioso5100
      @ominosentenzioso5100 Před 3 lety +64

      @@bigpotato8 South Korea is 30% circa christians, higher than Buddhism. Yeah, Korea has Nearly 50% of Atheists/Agnosticism, but a big result notherless. Mostly because of the christan evangelism, which were also present in China and Japan, but got outlawed for élite interests.

  • @Steamedavalone
    @Steamedavalone Před rokem +1

    Franco died in his bed because he made a deal with Eisenhower to not join Hitler in WW2, that’s why when he met with Hitler in Endaia, he told the German that he couldn’t afford another war since he just finished the Spanish Civil one, but he would offer volunteers (La Brigada Azul).
    Also, he offered to Hitler to prove his new planes bombing the city of Guernica .
    Later, Pablo Picasso would recreate the macabre act on his painting Guernica.
    That’s why nobody bothered Franco, cause the US pact with him.

  • @christian_aspen
    @christian_aspen Před 11 měsíci

    Spinning 3 Plates is truly an underrated contributor and username

  • @axelsanchez5849
    @axelsanchez5849 Před 3 lety +290

    “France hated Franco for three reasons:
    -First, he existed”

  • @BluestSoldier
    @BluestSoldier Před 3 lety +315

    Ah yes. Spain in the 20th century. A beautiful tale of "If i do nothing then i cant do nothing wrong".
    Edit: Really recommend reading the reply chain. Pretty interesting imo.

    • @kousvetkousvet4158
      @kousvetkousvet4158 Před 3 lety +30

      Well it kinda work, look at the cold war and 1973 oil thing.

    • @Kreze202
      @Kreze202 Před 3 lety +29

      @ Well fascism is all about ultra-nationalism and more, so fascism without revanchinism and expansionism is like communism without collectivization or democracy without voting, which at that point might as well just call them authoritarianism.
      Besides, a non-expansionist fascist nation is still at it's core very racist and was all about racial supremacy. International relations would not improve just because they aren't aggressive. In fact, relationship between fascistic nations are purely for war purpose. Italy, Germany, and Japan (just to name a few) were really cautious against each other and at a few occassions were discriminative against each other.

    • @Kreze202
      @Kreze202 Před 3 lety +35

      @The Nova renaissance Communism at it's very core is an economic based ideology. It's radically left economic wise, so it's only natural that left wingers, even moderate ones, would not condemn communism as much as moderate right wingers condemn fascism. Communism is an idea that can be applicable and indiscriminative across any race and nation, and it only has the bourgeois as it's enemy. Even if you're right wing socially, you can still be a supporter of communism (Nazbolism is a ridiculous ideology that reflects this.)
      Fascism, on the other hand, is a social based ideology. Even though it's naturally right wing, a fascist in Germany and a fascist in France would be fierce enemies. Fascism is all about racial purity and supremacy. The only reason Germany, Italy, and Japan were "allied" in WW2 were purely because they had the same enemies, and they realised that they have to compromise and set their differences aside for the duration of the war. Mussolini were very wary of Hitler at the early 30s, and Hitler considered the Italians and Japanese as lesser races to the Aryan race. In conclusion, Fascism is an ideology that naturally creates enemies, which is the reason why a wide range of people disapprove of such ideas. The attrocities they committed and their expansionism is just icing on the cake.

    • @Kreze202
      @Kreze202 Před 3 lety +15

      @The Nova renaissance My point is racial supremacists naturally attracts and makes enemies. Since there's no dominant race in the world, they're bound to be in the minority, and therefore have literally the entire world as their ideological enemy. The Nazis only got into power because of the hyper inflation and economic crisis plus a little bit of covert actions. Italy and Japan had a coup d'etat. The fascists had to play real dirty to get into power, and that just proves that the population doesn't support such an ideology enough to have them rule in the first place, which in turn disproves fascism "normality" in the 30s society.

    • @aesop1451
      @aesop1451 Před 3 lety +4

      @@Kreze202 But the Japanese were declared Honorary Aryans.

  • @albertwayne2323
    @albertwayne2323 Před 3 lety +5

    As a Spanish, I can say the reason why Franco wasn't ousted was the Cold War. Simply because the Gov made a deal with the USA and allowed a USA military base in Rota, Cádiz (which is still in use today) and three more bases, to control the Mediterranean exit to Atlantic Ocean, so the Soviet Navy can't go through there (it was effective, the Soviet Navy in the Black Sea had a hard time leaving the Mditerranean and they went through the Artic Ocean which is frozen most part of the year). And Franco was a hard anti-communist, something the rest of Western Powers saw as a good point in Franco's favor.

    • @anaz5918
      @anaz5918 Před 2 lety

      More like the USA paid Franco millions/billions of dollars for it aka “ humanitarian aid”.

  • @obi-wan4451
    @obi-wan4451 Před 3 lety +3

    I love how most of these videos book down to “They couldn’t” or “Doing so would have worse than not doing it.”

  • @matthewbrotman2907
    @matthewbrotman2907 Před 3 lety +137

    I like how Clement Attlee is easily recognized even though you never introduce him by name.

    • @twoscarabsintheswarm9055
      @twoscarabsintheswarm9055 Před 3 lety +2

      Where

    • @kevinc9065
      @kevinc9065 Před 3 lety +3

      Never heard of em

    • @jorgeshaft1483
      @jorgeshaft1483 Před 3 lety +19

      For those who don't know, Clement Attlee was the British Prime Minister from 1945-1951. At 1:47 he's the bald man with the long coat.

    • @attiepollard7847
      @attiepollard7847 Před 3 lety +3

      @@jorgeshaft1483 the labour party lasted that long 5 years? I thought after the war the labour party in the UK was going to have 2 terms in office with the big govt ideas being popular with the masses there.

    • @jorgeshaft1483
      @jorgeshaft1483 Před 3 lety +7

      @@attiepollard7847 Clement Attlee was a very popular PM who implemented a lot of the modern welfare state and nationalised many industries. However, Britain used the First Past the Post electoral system and in 1951, despite Labour gaining more votes then the Tories, the Tories won the election.

  • @SiVlog1989
    @SiVlog1989 Před 3 lety +113

    This sounds like a classic example of the "my enemy's enemy is my friend," logic. The Franco regime didn't see eye to eye with Britain, France or America, but disliked the Soviet Union more, so after WW2 gradually improved relations with Western allies

    • @theant9821
      @theant9821 Před 3 lety +8

      Pretty much what the Soviets did in 1941. They hated the British empire with a passion but they needed it to help them survive, and it's not like the USSR has any moral advantage over Britain at all, the opposite is true.

    • @SvobodaIliSmert
      @SvobodaIliSmert Před 3 lety +2

      actually, fascism and capitalism are the same shit with different names

    • @odim7960
      @odim7960 Před 3 lety +7

      sovnarkom communists claim that fascism and capitalism are the same
      Capitalists (liberals, conservatives) claim that communism and fascism are the same ("totalitarianism")
      Fascists claim that capitalism and communism are the same (tools for "jewish control")
      Truth is, none of these are true

    • @theant9821
      @theant9821 Před 3 lety +1

      @@odim7960 i don't claim communism and fascism is the same. I state the well proven fact that they are so different from one another like the north and south poles, they are indistinguishable from one another.
      And the fact that neither support freedom of speech, which if you don't have, you don't have anything at all.

    • @SvobodaIliSmert
      @SvobodaIliSmert Před 3 lety

      @@odim7960 history shows that Capitalism and Fascism are more keen to work togheter than to fight. in fact, they worked togheter for an incredibly large portion of their historical coexistence.

  • @Hylodatus
    @Hylodatus Před 3 lety +2

    0:32
    Everytime I see a map of Europe during World War 2 I always find hilarious how Switzerland is just vibing in the midst of chaos.

    • @luismenendez5089
      @luismenendez5089 Před 3 lety +1

      and thriving! they really benefit from it and hold many of the richest of the Jewish who perished in the holocaust

  • @cheydinal5401
    @cheydinal5401 Před měsícem

    I love that sometimes the best option genuinely is just "wait, but like, strategically"

  • @JingleJangle256
    @JingleJangle256 Před 3 lety +486

    Quick answer: Franco wasn’t fighting the allies, and when the Cold War started, another anti-communist ally wasn’t anything to cry over.

    • @rena-mq2bg
      @rena-mq2bg Před 3 lety +31

      Besides, after all the effort that UK put in facilitating Franco ascend to power while pretending they were pro democracy it would have been a shame to put him down, don't you think?

    • @gerardsotxoa
      @gerardsotxoa Před 2 lety +24

      @@rena-mq2bg The UK never supported Franco, happens that the guys in the other band became openly supporters of Stalin so UK by 1937 was cutting the help. But the Uk putted zero effort in favor of Franco.

    • @joadg6592
      @joadg6592 Před 2 lety +14

      @@gerardsotxoa they actively prevented any european intervention during the civil war. Meanwhile fascist Italy and Portugal were freely interfering. Without the British reluctances the French government would probably have helped the Republicans at some point, even if it wouldn't have mobilized the army for it.

    • @gerardsotxoa
      @gerardsotxoa Před 2 lety +9

      @@joadg6592 LMAO, this is so insane.
      France was taking all the spanish gold and shipping it to Odessa Ukraine, they allowed to gather all the soviet equipment in french soil, French army empted their 1st Reserve warehouses which hindered them badly in May of 1940, also hosted the voluntary support troops including Red Army officials. and you say the UK prevented any European intervention??? WTF
      France remained out because they thought an open support could backfire with a communist insurrection in France. As i said before, the spanish ''republicans'' were way too red for the taste of UK and worldwide diplomats. Maybe if the ''republicans'' hadn't murdered the ''burgoise republicans'' with such a pride and cockery, maybe then diplomats and politicians in UK and France wouldn't hesitate so much to aim for an open intervention.

    • @hrotha
      @hrotha Před 2 lety +1

      @@gerardsotxoa Yes, the Brits did prevent meaningful intervention on the Republic's side by keeping up the farce of the Non-Intervention Committee while turning a blind eye on the super obvious involvement of Germany and Italy

  • @jackwilkes4188
    @jackwilkes4188 Před 3 lety +311

    “One thing I am sure of, and which I can answer truthfully, is that whatever the contingencies that may arise here, where ever I am there will be NO communism”
    Franco

  • @floxy20
    @floxy20 Před 2 lety +3

    I've read a bit of history and honestly this is the first time I have even heard of this. Spain had just finished a civil war between two odious sides and wanted nothing to do with a world war. Who would decide what type of government would replace the existing one? How could it have any popular or unpopular support? Powers only start to worry about other countries when they begin to show tendencies to invade other countries.

  • @quadcannon
    @quadcannon Před měsícem +1

    The Napoleon ghost was 🤌 perfect.

  • @Jayako12
    @Jayako12 Před 3 lety +141

    Franco did not put non-Falangists in the power to please the Allies, he did it because the Falange was a problem for him. He tried to reduce its power narrower and narrower since the late civil war.

    • @Edmonton-of2ec
      @Edmonton-of2ec Před 3 lety +25

      Yeah, he was never really a huge fan of them. But the only other large conservative faction that was even remotely acceptable to him were the Carlists, but Franco wasn’t going to restore the monarchy while he was alive, so he just need ultra-conservative ministers

    • @ClawedAsh
      @ClawedAsh Před 2 lety +14

      I mean that sounds like a case of killing two bird with one stone, consolidating his power while simultaneously pleasing the Allies without sacrificing much

  • @OSFSMDRHFN
    @OSFSMDRHFN Před 3 lety +40

    Laughed hard when I saw Napoleon I as a ghost and just: "Please dont, not a smart choice..."

  • @jessicakorte
    @jessicakorte Před 2 lety

    I do love the little signs.
    Please add captions to your videos. The automatic ones are insufficient.

  • @user-vv6bw7cn6q
    @user-vv6bw7cn6q Před 3 lety +45

    Franco remarkably escaped twice, once when he didn't aloud Germans to attack Gibraltar , twice after the war! For a military man , he was a very capable politician !

    • @carmugon
      @carmugon Před rokem +9

      Mabey he was caplable, but he was actually a dictator, and he also made concentrations camps, and made like 700.000 spanish people die from hunger.

    • @vpowerization
      @vpowerization Před rokem

      @@carmugon In reality, all types o Governments need a type of Democratic allowance! You can't run a Country you and few hundreds of your friends its impossible! In Democracy you get this allowance by voting, in Dictatorship you get it by the collaboration of the key players in State mechanisms and the fact that people in general stay quiet . More importantly when you examine Dictatorships which stayed in power for decades. I of course condemn Dictatorships, I believe its better for the people to have Democracy but on the other hand I can't accept that a dictator who managed to stay in power that long wasn't a good politician! His long stay in power made him politician even if at the beginning was just a Dictator and nothing more. And one more thing. Even capable politicians are committing crimes, the fact that he was capable politician doesn't make him innocent for his crimes.

    • @requiem5151
      @requiem5151 Před rokem +9

      @@carmugon Franco is still based -From a Spaniard

    • @Samthebritishgent
      @Samthebritishgent Před 9 měsíci +3

      @@requiem5151as a brit all I can say is he seemed a damn sight better then the alternative so he may as well have led

  • @rebel7234
    @rebel7234 Před 3 lety +162

    Another key moment was the defeat of the Allies in Paris. The company that had spearheaded the Allied advance against the Nazis in France was made up of exiled Spanish Republicans and later enlisted in the French Legion, known as the Lecrec Division or "La Nueve". They hoped to count on the allied apollo to liberate Spain from Franco. His motto in fact was Paris, Berlin, Barcelona, Madrid indicating that this would be his war route. I do not remember well but I think it was Amado Granell, one of the leaders of the company, who, when attending a meeting between the Americans and the French, soon realized that the allies had no interest in Spain. According to his words, Patton said that he did not understand why those Spaniards were on his side.

  • @stuff9680
    @stuff9680 Před 3 lety +97

    Franco: "If I stay very still the Allies won't see me as a threat"

    • @drlca6601
      @drlca6601 Před 2 lety +1

      condensed history says yes. Franco is Alan Grant of early 1940s.

  • @yewisemountaingoat528
    @yewisemountaingoat528 Před 3 lety +10

    Just a bold guess without having watched this video: Franco was "useful" in that he kept the number of communists down in Spain. That's certainly how a whole slew of military juntas in South America were given a carte blanche in regards to their own internal politics. Let's say that totalitarian regimes such as Franco's and others were more than just condoned during the Cold War.

  • @Mod-rw9cw
    @Mod-rw9cw Před rokem +1

    There had been enough war and death and people couldn’t stomach anymore

  • @Zymemaru
    @Zymemaru Před 3 lety +30

    Franco: Oh mighty conch shell! What must I do to remain in power
    Conch shell: Nothing
    Franco: The conch has spoken!

    • @Zymemaru
      @Zymemaru Před 3 lety +4

      @@helend7542 what? never seen classic spongebob?

  • @Ralphieboy
    @Ralphieboy Před 3 lety +32

    That question never arose in my mind for the very reason you gave: Franco was a bulwark against the spread of Communism.

    • @Ralphieboy
      @Ralphieboy Před 3 lety +1

      Spain remained a right-wing dictatorship well into the 1970's...

    • @alejandrosotomartin9720
      @alejandrosotomartin9720 Před 3 lety

      Except if there was a Communist dictarship full of Soviet naval and terrestrial bases in the Atlantic, the Mediterranean and controlling the Straight of Gibraltar.

    • @alejandrosotomartin9720
      @alejandrosotomartin9720 Před 3 lety

      @Вхламинго One of the eternal whises of the russian powers, the access to warm waters. Whichever it is in the Mediterranean or in the Atlantic ocean behind all NATO allies, controlling all the trade and oil that passes towards the Straight and in front of Britain.

  • @cb2291
    @cb2291 Před 3 lety

    Best history clips

  • @USSFFRU
    @USSFFRU Před 3 lety +2

    There's that 1 Spanish Guy in Spain that's named Fransisco Franco alive and was denied by the French Government to enter their nation

  • @vmarvel3415
    @vmarvel3415 Před 3 lety +25

    The Most underrated history channel on youtube!!!
    Greetings from Tunisia 🇹🇳

  • @WildwoodClaire1
    @WildwoodClaire1 Před 3 lety +11

    I believe that head of the Abwehr, Admiral Wilhelm Canaris, played a crucial role in ensuring that Spain remained neutral despite Hitler's overtures. Canaris, who spoke fluent Spanish, was a longtime opponent of the Hitler regime and a close friend of Franco. He was forced to retire in early 1944 and arrested after the failed attempt to kill Hitler in July 1944. He was executed on April 8, 1945. His secret diaries would probably have been one of the great sources on German underground opposition to Hitler had they not been discovered and destroyed.

  • @oellappen269
    @oellappen269 Před rokem +2

    You can hold any opinion about Franco you want, but you can not deny that he was very smart and his diplomacy paid off.

    • @nouhowlmao2809
      @nouhowlmao2809 Před rokem +1

      His diplomacy is not that smart literally any leader outside of dumb fanatics (mussolini) would have avoided joining ww2 half of the minor axis members were forced to join by germany out of threat of war

  • @adsyoffinch
    @adsyoffinch Před rokem +2

    He also wanted to keep good relations with Britain because during the civil war just before the start of WWII, a lot of British soldiers had gone over to help his enemies. Officially they went of their own accord but there were a lot of them and they were well tooled up!

  • @familygash7500
    @familygash7500 Před 3 lety +101

    *VIDEO SUGGESTION:*
    How did the other European powers react when Napoleon III became The Emperor Of France and founded The Second French Empire? Weren't they at all worried that he would do the same things that his uncle did, and start a repeat of The Napoleonic Wars?

    • @clementlefevre5384
      @clementlefevre5384 Před 3 lety +12

      They were, but Napoléon III whole reign was basicly trying to prove to everyone that he was a good guy.

    • @elharvey5032
      @elharvey5032 Před 3 lety +9

      @@clementlefevre5384 By bringing Liberal reforms while remaining a traditionalist, Conquering Africa, invading Mexico, losing to the Prussians, and so on

    • @roadent217
      @roadent217 Před 3 lety +7

      @@elharvey5032
      I'm pretty sure losing to the Prussians ended Napoleon's rule...

    • @FrancoisMarchant
      @FrancoisMarchant Před 3 lety +7

      The main reason is : he was nothing like Napoleon.
      He prefered proxy-wars, helping the rise of other allied nations (Italy, and failed Mexico) than personal conquest (which is a smart move). He switched from authoritarian empire to liberal empire (mainly because France was a shitstorm), and he seemed much more concerned with the developpment of economics and industrialisation than military conquest. He was, overall, not very intimidating to the neighbouring nations (Victor Hugo called him "Napoleon the Small", but i believe he actually had a positive impact on his country, unlike his "great" predecessor).
      That being said, he brought some new territories to France (Nice and Savoy), which if i recall correctly were given to him by the new Italian king as a thank you gift for helping him win the italo-austrian war (and remaining neutral concerning the italian-papacy conflict, which was crucial for the italian unification).

    • @BobBob-eb4io
      @BobBob-eb4io Před 3 lety +4

      @@FrancoisMarchant im pretty sure napoleon (the predecessor one) also had a positive impact on France like where would France be if it kept that ineffective government it had before his rise to power i also imagine napoleon had a big impact on French national pride

  • @monikhadka
    @monikhadka Před 3 lety +149

    Allies: be gone Franco
    Franco: uno reverse card
    Hitler: And that’s how we won world war 2

  • @tomh8141
    @tomh8141 Před rokem +82

    You left out the part where the UK helped Franco seize power and supported him during World War II as detailed in the book Franco’s Friends by Peter Day. This is from the review in The Guardian:
    But it was not until the second world war that Franco really started coining money out of his British friends. The British could have tried to profit from the fact that Franco's government was full of jealousies and faction-fighting. Instead, Churchill's policy was to keep Spain out of the war by lavish bribes to key people in Franco's government, including Franco's brother-in-law and perhaps Franco himself. A huge slush fund was administered directly by the British embassy under Sir Samuel Hoare, and the regime, which was corrupt as well as brutal, made itself rich and unassailable at the expense of the British taxpayer.
    Western capitalists always hated communists more than Nazis. Just check out The First Casualty by Phillip Knightley.

    • @bocatadepann
      @bocatadepann Před rokem

      😂😂😂 if u believe a single word from The Guardian u are just dumb enough to defend what u just posted here, mate.
      The Guardian has always been against Spain and it's History. It's just ridiculous propaganda.
      Even Spanish communists admit Franco seized power despite the british, french, soviets, canadians and the US, which all them fought against Franco through the Brigadas Internacionales and the Makis. It was long after the 50's where they decided to stop isolating Spain since it was an anticommunist country, and without a single loan from abroad nor invading any lands, Spain escalated up to 8th World Power in 10 years.
      Dude, stop reading The Guardian and start reading books.

    • @bradhombre6912
      @bradhombre6912 Před rokem +21

      Except that they allied with Communist Stalin against Nazi Hitler. That undermines your assertion that they always hated communists more. A more reasonable conclusion would be that they hated both, but were willing to tolerate whichever they thought was the smaller threat at any given time if it helped oppose the bigger threat.

    • @crimsonfire6932
      @crimsonfire6932 Před rokem +14

      @@bradhombre6912 they might have allied with Hitler against the Soviet Union were it not for the fact that Hitler started fighting them first. But generally your consensus is right. Post WWII and to this day, communism was the bigger threat because nazism lost the Second World War. It could’ve been the other way around, and perhaps we might even say it should have been. Hard to really decide which is worst, but I’d say communism is worse than nazism because it has actually been more successful.

    • @Necroskull388
      @Necroskull388 Před rokem +8

      Or the even more relevant and more problematic fact that Stalin and the capitalists allied in undermining the anti-fascist side of the Spanish Civil War. George Orwell details this quite neatly in his Homage to Catalonia, which chronicles his personal experiences in war against the Spanish fascists. The most effective fighting force against the fascists in the civil war were the anarchists, and international capital opposed them because they of course had no respect for the property rights of foreign investors, and Stalin opposed them because… well, a lot of reasons, all of them having to do with Stalin being a piece of shit, but particularly involved with Stalin being fully opposed to worker control and revolution to that end - much like the USSR in general post-1921.
      What the Spanish situation shows us is not only that liberals are more scared of socialism than fascism, but also that “communists” are more scared of socialism than fascism. Stalin, Lenin before him, and every “communist” leader in the world today are LARPers who have no intention of either advancing socialism themselves or even allowing others to advance it for them.

    • @admiral7043
      @admiral7043 Před rokem

      That sounds like a good idea to me.

  • @FakeAssHandsomeMcGee_
    @FakeAssHandsomeMcGee_ Před 2 lety +5

    The whole France trying to get the US to overthrow Franco's regime was kind of funny.

  • @zaraiwzara
    @zaraiwzara Před 3 lety +44

    Allies: *win the war
    Franco:
    ...
    *i respect you*
    *I like you*
    *I cooperate with you*

  • @Jim-Tuner
    @Jim-Tuner Před 3 lety +108

    There was heavy pressure on Spain in the immediate postwar period. Spain was not even allowed to join the UN until 1955. There were multiple attempts to create an effective insurgency in Spain sponsored by countries like France after the war, but they all failed. The French attitude was largely driven by the influence the French Communist Party had in the government in the immediate postwar period.
    Franco attempted various measure to improve the situation. He marginalized the actual fascists (the falange) in his government after the war and replaced them with more traditional conservative politicians. He also moved to (in theory) restore the monarchy eventually.
    There was always uncertainty about going too far with Spain. There was a belief that no insurgency would be strong enough to actually overthrow Franco in a clean way. That any support for an insurgency would effectively lead to a resumption of the civil war and quite possibly lead to events that would be difficult to predict or control.
    What changed everything was the outbreak of the Korean War. US Policy changed in the direction of supporting any country that seemed friendly and useful.

    • @shashwatsinha2704
      @shashwatsinha2704 Před 3 lety

      Does your surname "Tuner" signify anything?

    • @a6s3
      @a6s3 Před 3 lety +27

      "There was a belief that no insurgency would be strong enough to actually overthrow Franco in a clean way. That any support for an insurgency would effectively lead to a resumption of the civil war and quite possibly lead to events that would be difficult to predict or control. "
      Lessons that the west recently forgot with their adventures in Lybia and Syria

    • @Jim-Tuner
      @Jim-Tuner Před 3 lety +8

      ​@Underdog History The French Attitude in the later 1940s was very much influenced by the role of the French Communist Party (the PCF) in government. The PCF was regularly drawing a quarter of the French national vote. The PCF was generally the largest party within the coalition French governments between 1945 and 1947. Supporting the overthrow of Franco was one of the major priorities of the PCF at that time.
      The entry of 146 Spanish soldiers into Paris the night before the rest of the allied formations entered paris in 1944 was of no significance.

    • @Jim-Tuner
      @Jim-Tuner Před 3 lety +1

      @@shashwatsinha2704 The name is an alias I created without very much thought a long time ago. Its effectively meaningless.

    • @shashwatsinha2704
      @shashwatsinha2704 Před 3 lety

      @@Jim-Tuner Oh, that possibility never crossed my mind.

  • @digargo
    @digargo Před rokem +1

    Well, the U.S.S.R had a third reason to demand Franco's defeat. More than 30.000 Spanish soldiers participated in the siege of Leningrad (Causing more than two million civilian deaths), they were called "Division Azul".

  • @Jako1741
    @Jako1741 Před 2 lety +36

    I could explain this even in simpler terms: Franco remained because he outsmarted every other leader of his time.

  • @maklo7198
    @maklo7198 Před 3 lety +135

    So Spain was Fascist, West wanted it to be Democratic, East wanted it to be communist, but they decided to bring back Monarchy.

    • @Ander-5187
      @Ander-5187 Před 3 lety +43

      Parlamentary monarchy, so technically the west won, sorta.
      But yes

    • @morsecode980
      @morsecode980 Před 3 lety +34

      @@Ander-5187 Parliamentary monarchy that joined NATO, so yeah the West won

    • @esclavodelsistema9783
      @esclavodelsistema9783 Před 2 lety +2

      Spain doesn't have anything to do with the rest of the West

    • @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki
      @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki Před 2 lety +3

      and all the former Nazi's resident in Spain (along with a lot of others wanted for war crimes in WW2) basically got a PASS, or a route through the rat line to Argentina, with Spain as a backup plan. Nice. We can that the western alllies for that??

    • @JoseGarcia-xf5gk
      @JoseGarcia-xf5gk Před 2 lety +2

      @@Dwightstjohn-fo8ki And the communist war crime?

  • @hamzaharoon6336
    @hamzaharoon6336 Před 3 lety +201

    Just a thought:
    When you hit a million subscribers, how about celebrating it with an interview with James Bisonette? (Not sure if I spelled his name right.)

    • @theemirofjaffa2266
      @theemirofjaffa2266 Před 3 lety +9

      I know, right?

    • @PANZERFAUST90
      @PANZERFAUST90 Před 3 lety +13

      because he's the only one that matters right?

    • @houssamassila6274
      @houssamassila6274 Před 3 lety +38

      @@PANZERFAUST90 no. All lives matter! Phil the oink oink, gustav swann, marcus aznar, kelly moneymaker, rashid ali, is he? , david silverman, and list goes on.

    • @PANZERFAUST90
      @PANZERFAUST90 Před 3 lety +17

      @@houssamassila6274 DON'T FORGET MOE! 🙌🙌🙌🙌

    • @timmyp38
      @timmyp38 Před 3 lety +6

      How bout 600k subscribers and we hear from Kelly Moneymaker?

  • @0rL0cK55
    @0rL0cK55 Před 2 lety +11

    It is also important to note that Franco and Pétain helped the allies by refusing access of the Maghreb to the germans forces

  • @vincentcarmine8731
    @vincentcarmine8731 Před rokem +1

    I remember I. The 1960s Franco still had German ME 109s in his airforce

  • @sapphyrus
    @sapphyrus Před 3 lety +45

    He had mastered the art of standing so incredibly still that he became invisible to the eye.