Harry Potter - All Movies Reviewed and Ranked (part 1)
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 12. 2020
- Thank you to @x_cixra_x and @SeigiVA for the cameos!!
Patreon: / cosmonautvarietyhour
BUY A SHIRT: teespring.com/stores/cosmonau...
Twitter: / cosmovarietyhr - Zábava
I know I pronounce "Rowling" wrong. I'll pronounce it right when she learns what the word transphobia means :^)
Dead body reported
Oh hell yeah Marcus.
No no, he’s got a point.
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Well that’s going to be awhile
“Damn this movie is good but it’d be way better with racism.” -Cosmonaut 2020
"Why would you say something so controversial, yet so brave"
@@AryanSingh-yy9mw “never before have I been so offended by something I 100% agree with.”
-D.W. Griffith, 1915
I wish someone was being oppressed right now, so that I could chime in and say how not-cool that is.
@@g.e.o.r.g.e... Donald Trump is being oppressed
It’s actually so hilarious that Lucius was just about to straight up murder Harry right outside Dumnledore’s office 😭😭
Tbf, I’ve heard that was just the actor ad-libbing a random spell for the scene
@@TheAlienGangster ironic the spell sounds so similar to Avardacadavra
@@andross2058 the actor just read goblet of fire and so they asked him to do any spell and avada kadavra was the only one he remembered
@Mid Quacker yeah it sounds weird
@Mid Quacker Making the killing spell sound like another way of saying abracadabra is stupid.
Funniest thing about HP is that Voldemort lost so badly to Harry in his first two years at Hogwarts, that he didn’t even bother to try anything in the third year. He just decided to take a break that year.
bro had his horcrux killed without harry even knowing what it is, on top of cheating death for a 2nd time and killing a giant snake with insta-kill eye contact. if i were him, i'd take a break too
"Yk what, this is a Me day."
@@inazumarai7690all while Harry was literally still 12 years old
Not that he could have done much if anything since he didn''t have his physical form and his ability to interact with the physical world was severely limited and requiring external help in order to do so. Quirrell was gone and so was the Philosophers Stone, His diary destroyed so by PoA he had already exhausted most of his available options until Wormtail found him the following summer
@@vikkran401 Exactly. To add to that as well, Voldemort didn't even know the diary had been destroyed until after he was reborn and found out Lucius no longer had it. Voldemort says that after the events of the Philosopher's Stone he had pretty much given up until Wormtail found him.
Avada Kedavra is basically just a gun with a 100% fatality rate.
…if you really mean it
That also hurts you when you use it.
@@elitemook4234 Goddamn the recoil on that thing.
well, not 100% wink wink
But think of how many shots you could get off in the time it takes someone to say 6 syllables. Even if the first one doesn't kill them it'll probably stop them from forming words
My therapist: "White Marcus isn't real and can't hurt you."
White Marcus: *"W H E E E E E E-"*
ORORORORO!!! I spend half of my day sleeping! ORORORO!!! Then I sometimes get up and tell you that I am a famous content creatorORORORORO!!! Please don't sleep while driving, dear mania
he's doing whiteface
for a second I thought that was just some unfortunately harsh lighting. holy moly
@@AxxLAfriku HOW MANY TIMES DO WE HAVE TO TEACH YOU THIS LESSON, OLD MAN
What are u talking about?
"He called me a *BLEEP*"
"HE DID NOT"
That sent me.
It sounds like she began to say motherfucker. Killed me!
Mud blood
Bro I've seen this video a few time, and that part slays me EVERYTIME it is such a minor edit and it's so funny
N-
The end of Prisoner of Azkaban is a glorious film. The ending where Harry thinks his dad is coming but he has to step up himself is simply brilliant. As someone who lost his father at a young age, its a very emotional scene.
i used to dislike azkaban because it meant their world was deterministic, but I've come to believe free will is only an illusion so i like it a lot more now.
It’s also made by the best director out of the bunch.
At the point where he thinks its his dad he doesn't know Hermione is time traveling. I think I have that timeline right in my head. I love this book so much@@teamrocketsslowpoke2773
his dad came?... hot ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
and i like the fact that we magically forget about timemachine in later movies. Mb reverce time and save Dumby or Snep? Why bother.
The marketing for movie 4 was so good. They hyped the movie itself but kept images of Voldemort completely under wraps. It made the reveal so much better than if we’d seen months of publicity shots.
"Do you think we'll ever just have a quiet year at Hogwarts?"
"Ron, our friend fucking died" LMAO
That made me cry in laughter 😂
Ron : I mean he wasn't MY friend, but whatever I guess.
Ron: “Please let this be a normal field trip!”
@@smallandstressed2364 With a Dumbledore, no way!
Can someone explain to me why this matei mihai guy starts writing gibberish mangle that i don't understand?
Edit: Oh never mind he is gone now.
Harry Potter: and the cutesy adventure
Harry Potter: and the racist snake
Harry Potter: and the furry
Harry Potter: and the Tournament arc
😂
Next up
Harry Potter: and the bitch in pink
Harry Potter: and the stupid romantic subplot
Harry Potter: and the phylactery fetch quest
Harry Potter: and the Big Bad boss battle
Next up : Harry potter and the non canon story
Harry potter : but its a prequel
Harry potter: but its a sequel to the very bad prequel
Harry potter : But it seems we are lacking him
Harry Potter: and the bitch in pink
Harry Potter: and Alan Rickman
Harry Potter: and the Fetch Quest
Harry Potter: and the Final Boss
Note that it's Harry Potter and the *Anime* Tournament arc.
Lmao Harry’s scream has a British accent.
I was thinking this exactly 😂
Fred and George had that map for a while and never thought it was weird some guy was sleeping in Ron's bed every night
Maybe because it shows everyone it would show a lot of names in the dorms so maybe they might have missed it?
The censor when hermione said mudblood killed me lmao
The man himself
Two kings meeting
@@cielcanterville1834 inabber a king 😂😂😂😂😂
SAME lmfao
lol
Marcus: Movie 3 is when the movies get good.
Also Marcus: Movie 4 is when the cracks start to show.
It lasted for a full movie at least...
Ehhh it makes sense. It really gears into the grand story that completes the franchise and what makes it so great, but the story isn’t flawless and these flaws naturally show as the story gets grander.
Both things are true. Basically only movie 3 is really good.
@@4203105 That's what happens when you hire a competent director instead of...*sigh*...David Yates.
@@4203105
7 and 8 are too
I had rewatched all of the films recently with my mom and one thing that I really like about Harry in the movies is how he really doesn’t let Malfoy get away with bullying him or his friends. He almost always immediately stands up to him and Malfoy quickly cowers like the little weasel he is. I think it was a good way of showing both Harry’s bravery and how he cares about his friends.
Voldemort never told anyone about his horcruxes he just gave the book to Lucius to take care of it and keep it safe. Lucius just wanted to get rid of it because the ministry was making house raids to find illegal objects in wizard families. So Lucius didn't know what he was doing. One of many mistakes Voldemort made because he never trusted anybody.
i didn't care about cedrick that much in the movie either, but his dad's actor crying for real teared me up a bit, that cry felt like he really lost his son, props for the actor
I tell you, i've watched his death so many times, and I literally don't care one bit, but when his Dad starts screaming? Like, OMG kill me now ...
Oh his dad crying is absolutely heartbreaking.
I watched it when I was like 7 so I was pretty attached to the character
I just love how Harry comes back with dead Cedric and everyone is cheering, the band is playing, and no one really notices for the first few moments that Harry is hunched over a dead body.
Mate, Amos Diggory absolutely STOLE that scene. Incredible performance. He knew he only had a couple scenes and had to make the most of it, but still didn't 'over-act' it, he smashed it perfectly. Really gave that scene the emotion it needed.
So, JK Rowling has admitted that she very strongly considered killing off Ron in book 4. My personal theory, and this is a little tinfoil hatty, is that in her original draft, Ron was going to be selected to be the Hogwarts champion, then when Harry's name comes out of the goblet as well, that's why Ron loses his shit at Harry. It's a much stronger motivation, because after all these years, Ron finally has a chance at glory, and Harry has to swoop in and steal the spotlight yet again. Then they slowly make up over the course of the book, and at the climax, it's Harry and Ron who seize the cup together as a symbol of their renewed friendship... Then BAM. Graveyard. Ron is fucking ICED. Voldemort's back. And this catapults us into the darker, more adult section of the series.
However, JK probably didn't want to put her readers through that shit, so she took a minor character from book 3 and elevated him to main character status and sacrificed him instead, and that's why Cedric feels so underwritten and out of place, and also why Ron's sudden falling out with Harry feels a little out of left field. Honestly, even as a child, I got over Credric's death really fast. Again, this is a tiny amount of fact combined with a large dose of speculation, but I think it all fits.
Edit: for this storyline to be possible, there would have to be no minimum age requirement, or the minimum would have to be 14.
This makea sense. I remember in book three or four or five (?) Ron did show some jealousy. In book 1 didn't he see himself in the mirror as a quidditch player? Something like this would have worked a lot more.
That’s too bad if that’s the case. I think it definitely would have raised the stakes of the story a lot more and then Cedric could have, as Marcus suggested, come in and be even more chummy with Harry and help Harry through a potentially cool character arc and we wouldn’t have the cringeworthy Hermione/Ron romance. What a wasted opportunity.
It wouldn’t make sense for one reason. It doesn’t make sense in terms of all the movies. These movies were mystery movies. You’ll be taking away from that if you do that plot
@@malfaroangel3896 How?
@@Beastinvader Ron shows his jealous nature the first time he meets Harry on the train.
Voldemort didnt give him the Horocrux to give to Ginny, he gave it to Lucius for safekeeping. Lucius, assuming Voldemort was gone, passed it onto Ginny to frame her father for having dark artifacts. Lucius was never aware that it was a horocrux.
Also it IS established that the Time Turners can only go so far back, except for black market illegal ones, which are confiscated and destroyed.
its weird that he keeps referencing the books for certain parts so he's clearly read them, but then points out plot holes and calls JK an idiot but those plot holes aren't in the books...?
Ah yes, the illegal black market time turners that are so illegal and so black market that they simply *must* be destroyed and absolutely *cannot* be used to destroy the greatest threat to the wizard world and humanity at large ever. Because they're black market. And illegal.
@@AMVmushroomthe time turner is a plot she established though. In thr cursed child its shown time turners can take you back decades.
Yeah, the point was that Lucius was nervous of his house being searched, so he wanted to frame the Weasley’s so they would be searched instead. This backfired because after Mr Weasley learned about the book he put in an anonymous tip about Lucius that got his house searched
@@AMVmushroomexactly 😂
When people started recommending Harry Potter to me, I always heard about Harry being in a relationship with Cho, or Herimone, or even MALFOY. Not once did anyone mention Ginny, and I was genuinely confused when I found out she was to be Harry’s love interest
The drarry ship shouldnt even exist
@@benluka1811heh it’s ok.I’d prefer it over some of the cannon ships in HP.
It’s because of the movies. Harry is very interested in Cho until after the Tri-Wiazard Tournament.
He never had any crush for Hermione, the movies just made it look like they had potential for something other than friendship
@@Mialikesthings Honestly, half the students make for a better pairing with Harry than Ginny. I'm somewhat partial to Luna x Harry but even Neville would be an improvement to what we got.
To this day I'm upset that Hermione is the one who explained being a mudblood and not Ron. Because Ron isn't stupid in the books and his role in the trio is supposed to be the one talking about wizarding culture
They did Ron so dirty in the movies, I'm still pissed off about that.
Yeah...Hermione’s a great character, but a lot of the terminology and know-how that Ron explains got cut out
Well, if the wizarding world is really as racist as it’s made out to be, I feel like Hermione would be familiar with the word at this point...
@@wandanemer2630 same with most of the Weasleys
As Snape said she's " an insufferable know it all" can't get more accurate than that
I know Cedric's death scene wasn't that powerful
But you gotta admit that when Harry and Cedric return from the maze and the band plays the upbeat music
It's super eerie when everyone slowly figures out what's going on whilst such a happy tune is playing
Yes! And when you hear his dad go “my boyyyyy!” And running down the stands to him just makes me so sad..
Fleur being the first one to figure it out (besides Dumbledore 'cause, y'know, he knows everything) and screaming in horror was what got me.
@@bcash1994 dead ass it's almost made me cry multiple times
@@CJCroen1393 yeah me too!!!
that scene is hard for me to watch. it’s quite well done.
3:22-Philosopher’s Stone
10:03-Chamber Of Secrets
18:17-Prisoner Of Azkaban
25:46-Goblet Of Fire
Oh my God. "He's shooting him with the power of evil-- why isn't that illegal?" (32:02)
I fuckin' love that quote
Prisoner of Azkaban: “Now this is when these movies get good”
Goblet of Fire: “This is when the cracks really start to form”
Fr lol
Bro prisoners of Azkaban is my favorite HP movie
Honestly, Goblet of Fire is just as good, if not better than Prisoner of Azkaban. Order of the Phoenix and the Half-Blood Prince are completely worthless, though
@@TAJMofficial goblet isn’t on the level of prisoner. Only hallows pt 2 can even contend with it.
@@mattfromwiisports4911 Are you literally just restating the opinions of Cosmonaut. Also, I don't need to know what "is" as good as Prisoner, it's my opinion so don't be annoying
I absolutely love the scene where Snape comes out of the Shrieking Shack and is angry at Harry and about to scold him before seeing the danger and instantly switching into a defensive mode where his only priority is protecting the kids. It really helps to show how layered his character is.
Too bad it never happened in the books tho. Movie Snape tends to be drastically more sympathetic then book snape
@@anyanon3849 yeah a lot of movies fans don’t understand that Snape literally terrorized and antagonized his students in the books that wasn’t show in the movies
@@atribecalledlen3567 yea the guy literally threatened to kill Neville's frog and the explanation people give to that just makes him even more awful. Usually it is said that he antagonized Neville because he could have been the chosen one and if he was the one then Lily would have stayed alive and that's just a fucking sick thing to do. Especially to a clueless child.
@@youtubestayatyourrootsforfsake yes definitely
@@atribecalledlen3567 well why would they, they didn’t read the books
"I think Harry's kind of dumb, and gullible, and he does whatever anyone tells him to do". Wow it sounds like he's a child or something
Well he could be a smarter kid…like I don’t think Malfoy wud be like:
Come to u?…okay
A really dumb child
That’s also why it helps to read the books so you can meet the real versions of characters instead of just the movie counterpart. But bc the writer has politics Marcus doesn’t agree with every work said writer does(that isn’t even political might I add) is automatically bad.
@@hunterthompson7605 Marcus doesn't claim the books themselves are bad, he finds J.K. Rowling's views as a TERF troubling, making him uncomfortable revisiting the series. He also takes issue with her reported narcissism and inflated ego.
“Why did Voldemort want to sabotage the Quidditch game?” He was clearly trying to kill him, dude…
Students fall off their brooms in Quidditch matches all the time, we literally see one dude faceplant on the sand and be fine. Even if the broom takes Harry 200 meters over the ground before letting him fall, Dumbledore can just Arresto Momentum his ass like he did in PoA.
@gaiusjuliuscaesar8450 in the books none of that would of happened without a penalty. Trust me once you read the books you'll realise that the movies aren't that good. (Except for POA and OOFP. I still like these two.)
I was trying to be productive today, Marcus...
Do was I
Oh hey Antoine I love you're ATLA/LOK videos
I love crossovers
Same fam. I literally just got off for the semester.
you surely can take a 30 minutes break 😂✊
“A story being more complex does not mean it’s better”
Christopher Nolan: 😐
*Laughs in Interstellar*
Dark Knight Trilogy: Masterpiece
applies to that guy too
To be completely fair, most of his films are engaging because of the complexity, so he kinda gets a pass
there's much more to his films than complexity, but I get the joke
The British made Lord Of The Rings and Harry Potter. You don’t flex harder than that
Prisoner of Azkaban has always been my favorite for reasons I could never explain or identify. You hit the nail on the head with your review.
"And I hate how she acts with her eyebrows."
I can never watch an Emma Watson movie and not notice that now. Thanks, Cosmo.
If it stops one person from watching the Beauty and the Beast remake, then his job is done
@Greg Mehlin I personally thought it was one of the better Disney live action remakes, but then again, that’s not sayin much.
@@jeremiahvaleska8464 I feel like the only decent one was Aladdin. It was actually inventive the new parts that were added, and the new songs were pretty good.
I don't get why people dislike it. I find that very cute, just like I do with Emilia Clarkes "eyebrow acting".
just like Shaq does
"Fast and Furious is an anime"
"Fighting Games are anime"
"Goblet of Fire is an anime"
Godammit Marcus
I mean yeah?
I hope this means he'll do another anime vid soon XD
Everything's anime !
anime is an anime
He’s right though
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is a really good movie. Not just a good Harry Potter movie, but a good movie. It's well directed, it's shot good, it has amazing visuals and the acting is great. I was suprised when I found out Alfonso Cuaron was the director, but quickly realized how this movie is literally his vibe. So yeah. I like it.
3:32 "in his New York apartment" I died 😂
Harry Potter 3: "This is where the movies start to get really good."
Harry Potter 4: "This is where the cracks really start to Show."
tbh later movies do get both parts lmao
@@shinkamui *ptsd flashbacks to HBP
@@shinkamui true. Prisoner of Azkaban is still the GOAT HP movie tho
Lmao but the fifth the best
@@blupoppy facts.
Remus Lupin's name is double on the nose. You caught the "Lupin=wolf" thing, but he's also named after Remus, brother of Romulus, the mythical founders of Rome... who were raised by wolves.
Sometimes Rowling is rly great at giving her characters thoughtful and meaningful names
and then sometimes she goes and names a character fucking Cho Chang like wtf
@@theduh1011 Goldstein the Jewizard
I am waiting for her to announce that all the characters are gay and spend their free time...........
JK Rowling names shit like this. What's the most obvious correlation to this character in english? Switch it to Latin, BOOOM. I mean sirius black LITERALLY MEANS BLACK DOG
Hell, the codename Lupin gets on Potterwatch is literally "Romulus". It's perfect.
Aragog is such a good effect in Chamber of Secrets, he still scares the shit out of me to this day
Dumbledore explained in Half Blood Prince that Voldemort told Malfoy that the diary had the power to reopen the Chamber of Secrets, but not that part of his soul was in the book. It's kind of a stupid thing of Voldemort to assume Malfoy would be more careful with the book, without telling him why it's important.
"People say this scene is sad but I don't really think it's that sad" - This is the experienced cutting edge critique I came here for.
He gave a justification for that opinion and I agree with him. The book and movie could have benefitted from more characterization of Cedric.
@@porsche911sbs The book Definitely had more characterisation of Cedric.
@@atharvadeshpande4749 yeah, but still not to the point where I, reading as a kid, felt genuinely sad and shocked when he suddenly died, instead of a general, "oh damn, shit just got REAL" feeling.
He definitely was more fleshed out in the books, but making him a bit more sympathetic with more dialogue would've made the emotional impact so much better.
As someone who only saw the movies, even as a kid I didn't feel... anything, when Cedric died. I don't think I felt sad in the slightest. To me Viktor, Fleur, and Cedric all felt like disposable background characters who were just there for this one movie to advance the plot and that's about it. The movie really wanted you to despair at the death of Cedric, to a degree that you'd only ever actually feel if it were Ron or Hermione that died. But since it was just this lame character we barely knew, the level of sadness they wanted you to feel was completely unjustified and unearned. Cedric was always disposable.
I think its just more of an "oh shit" feeling then a sad feeling scene.
Also the Hogwarts Band is funny af in that scene.
“This man is gay.“ -- Cosmonaut 2020
That killed me.
Yaaaassssss queeeeen 👑 💅🏳️🌈
@AnAnonymousUser go home
@@finnthepotatoprin Snape was in love with Harry's mom, so maybe bi?
@@ntnwwnet well sure, but I don't think Marcus meant it in a literal sense. Just like, ~vibes~ in general
Oh god, now I'm imagining Harry leaning in towards the wall only to hear a snake incessantly mumbling the n-word.
Voldemort's real name being an anagram would be cool, but it's just the fact that it includes the "I am" that cracks me up.
The racist snake part killed me. Didn't realize how complicated Lucius's plan was and what fucked up stuff Ginny did.
Perhaps you didn't read the books?
@@pjbpiano I didn't lol.
oh how i despise ginny
@@rorysaurusrex_ I mean she was being mind-controlled
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 I understand why you'll agree with this video if you didn't read the books which clearly explained everything.
I'm glad someone else sees the Harry Potter movies as "Christmas" movies.
Yeah, they've always felt christmassy to me
For me they're christmas movies because ABC Family always did a Harry Potter marathon as part of their "25 days of christmas". Now ABC Family is Freeform so I don't even know if they do that anymore.
If Die Hard counts, so does Harry Potter
They’re fall and winter movies for sure the color pallets are perfect
I think the 5th movie is the only one that doesn't feel like a Christmasy-movie!
Love this video, I keep finding myself coming back to watch it as well as part two. Thanks for making these videos.
I always wondered why my interest kinda dropped off after the 3rd movie.
I always thought John Williams stopped scoring the movies and that broke the magic for me, but sounds like I wasn't crazy for thinking 3 was where it was the best.
And I was one of the fans who showed up to the midnight book release parties for 5-7
WHY IS HE WHITE
r/cursedimages
Tom cruise cosplay
Why is your reply 16 hours ago
👁👄👁
That is the most cursed opening...
I swear, Marcus has this gift where he can explain literally any movie in existence and make it sound like the dumbest fucking thing imaginable.
I love it.
Exactly! The way he dumbed down Chamber of Secrets to “Ginny uses the Death Note” has me in stitches.
I started to realize that when he described Palpatine’s convoluted plot of having Dooku send Jango Fett, who sends Zam, who sends a droid, who sends bugs.
And the pitch meeting guy
@@elipetrou9308 Ryan George
@@elipetrou9308 Both Marcus and Ryan George are my favorite CZcamsrs, absolutely legends at reviewing a movie
I've always had similar issues with the Mad-eye Moody and Barty Crouch Jr. storyline from Goblet of Fire--even as a child. You put it into words so well.
Yeh it’s so weird. Moody was a great character on his own. The fact that all his development in goblet of fire wasn’t even real because it wasn’t moody is so dumb. Because we now have this character who’s said to be such an amazing wizard but we don’t know him at all, because he’s barely on page after
@@davidfairweather3301 yeah moody was awesome how he showed up for Harry's 17th birthday and immediately died
They could’ve done the twist better if moody had been replaced at the end of the school year. Just randomly he starting acting more strange a little bit before the final contest.
Imagine if the story ended with Hagrid literally ripping voldemort limb from limb for framing him all those years ago. That would be great.
I can never unsee Quirrell as Jeff Bezos, that part killed me
That's my HEADcanon now.
I LITERALLY LOOKED UP IF HE WAS PLAYED BY JEFF BEZOS
To be fair, Daniel Radcliffe himself has said he's not fond of his earlier performances in the series because he was just breaking into the film industry and his acting is pretty rough.
He was a little kid so it's easy to see why
I agree. His reaction when Hagrid told him he was a wizard did not seem natural but his acting really started to improve from goblet of fire.
He still ain’t bad. Just not great
@@Othillde pretty sure it was the sixth he said he disliked
@@sonnyfox8407 that was for other reasons related to how he was dealing with fame at the time, rather than due to his acting ability
I love your pacing and humor
“This spell isn’t illegal, wtf even is this, he’s shooting him with the power of evil”
Tom dorkily writing I am lord Voldemort is hilarious
"I don't hate this movie" *Shows Fleur Delacour in a bathing suit*
He does it twice lol
Totally missed that
Time stamp pls
@@sophiebubbles07 33:35
alfonso curon should have directed the whole series, his cinematography is so good
it wouldve fixed everything i dislike about David Yates movies, who isn't a good filmmaker. just a mediocre one.
Azkaban has cool visuals but as an adaptation of the book its a bit shit not as much as gobet of Fire but still
@@JohnSmith-jh6ey in terms of adaptation, they're all equal in what they miss vs keep in
@@katie7390 most of the adaptations are good except GoF and Half-blood Prince
1. Chamber Of Secrets - it creates the mysterious, thriller affect in a kids movie but retains the fairytale like charm of the medieval castle , most of the scenes are at night with yellow lights in the castle, gives a cozy feeling.
2. Philosopher's stone - Introduction to the wizarding world, adventurous
3. Goblet Of Fire - Action filled, other schools, thrilling
4. Deathly Hallows 1 - ik some parts are boring like their wilderness quests but rest is so good.
5. Deathly Hallows 2 - Action, revelations, fun to watch
6. Half Blood Prince - The correct amount of grim and jolly , not trying to make it extra sad
7. Order Of the Phoenix - nothing much to say, just ok
8. Prisoner of Azkaban - I truly despise this movie. I know many of the so called film experts and wannabes state this as their fav, for Oscar winning Curon's direction, and brilliant cinematography. Yes I give credit there, but such a setting was not required, at all. It feels so much like the half blood Prince, if Voldemort was gone, there was no present threat of him, still the movie felt so much grim, not a single shot with sunlight, unnecessary cloudy weather all the fuckin time. Even when the dementors where gone. It Destroyed what Chris Columbus had built, A fairytale like land, nostalgic, old and dreamlike, I know a transition was needed but it was too much on the face, it just wasn't required.
I hate in Prisoner of Azkaban they don’t ever state who the Marauders actually are. It makes Harry’s patronus being a stag so much more impactful.
"why does Voldemort try to kill Harry if he needs him to be alive?"
Wasn't his ultimate goal in the first movie to get the stone so he can live on? That plan failed, so he did the ritual thing in Goblet of Fire. It's a stupid and random ritual to be honest, but it doesn't conflict with his actions from the first movie.
He also doesn’t know at that point that he cannot touch Harry. Only after quirrels death he knows that. Hence while planing the ritual he specifically chooses harry to that one enemy whose blood he’d want
I legit thought moaning mettle was played by Daniel Radcliff when I was a kid... and kinda even now
Same
Yeah, I’m never really gonna be convinced that she isn’t.
Myrtle*
The actor who played her was like 40 or something in the movie
me too. or at least his sister or something
That moment when Snape protects the Kids a short scene after Harry assaults him and tosses him into a bed is such a character defining moment.
Thats only a movie Snape move instead of a book Snape move. Personally I like movie Snape better because just because a characters more complex doesn't mean I have to like him, so I'll take my honorable Snapes any day, even if I mainly focus on the books
@@channeleditor9335 I imagine that most people who like Snape do so *only* due to his more heroic interpretation in the movies in addition to Alan Rickman's performance that was so good that Snape-lovers transpose him over the far pettier asshole that Snape actually is in the books. It's so pervasive that it even applies to Rowling herself given she admitted while the movies were going on that she had increasing trouble separating Rickman's performance from Snape in the books.
So much better than the book Alan Rickman did Snape justice more than J.K. Rowling ever did
@@athenajaxon2397 Snape doesn't deserve much justice imo. He was a 'racist' nazi who only stopped being a nazi when his crush was threatened (so not even because he realised being 'racist' was wrong lmao), then spent years abusing children as a teacher. Snape is a complex character, which is good, but he's an asshole who got what he deserved.
Also I don't really like that scene because him protecting them doesn't square with his constant abuse.
@@caoisekamay1175 yes the true snape doesn't deserve justice, the movies didn't give him justice but created a new snape, which isn't the best when making adaptations. However the past has already happened and movie Snape is more likable, which wasn't supposed to happen and misses the point, but we can enjoy simpler things like Rickman snape, and acknowledge that this isn't the real snape
i come back to these two videos religiously
I think Quirrel wasn't trying to sabotage the game, he was trying to get Harry to fall off his broom and die
I actually like that Harry and Cedric's relationship was distant and awkward, with Harry being very jealous of Cedric from time to time. Cedric is everything he's not, and you see Harry experience an inferiority complex for the first time. He's the chosen one but he feels very small standing next to Cedric Diggory, who's practically perfect in every way.
"Mary Poppins, practically perfect in every way"
@@sablepuff LMAO.
I think ur 100% on the money with the kind of relationship they have but the issue with alot of book to screen adaptations is that inner thought is hard to convey on screen. I've never read the books but I'm sure theres alot of inner dialog from Harry talking about his jealousy. Someday a film maker will figure out how to ace that translation. The movie did the best it could I'm sure.
Also Cedric and Cho clicked first so making him and Harry chummy isn't really realistic lol
The one thing that I really disliked about goblet of fire is that we are told that
fleur delacour is a really badass wizard but she get's defeated all the time and has to be saved in all the tests except the first one which doesn't matter because we cannot see her do anything.
Yea, it was really kinda sexist
Just think of the scene the French girls were introduced.
@@hulmhochberg8129 Ah yes, I'm sure the female author hates women.
Also everyone from Durmstrang was a stereotype too, but they are men so I guess it's not a problem.
yepp totally agree. I was so excited to see this elegant and badass young wizard but then she's just a hopeless girl
"Just think of the scene the French girls were introduced.
"
This is from the movie. In the books the majority of that school were just some average kids, including the boys (yes there were boys also). I mean, I get it if y'all don't like JKR, but cut her some slack. Not everything she's done was awful.
EDIT: Same goes for the Durmstrang school. Most of these guys were average joe's, not super manly athlets.
Yeah but I think the director is the one to blame on this one. In the books the schools are mixed in gender unlike the movies where they make one all boys and the other all girls.
On the note of the time turner. I always assumed they didn't use it for more intense time travel because no matter what you do you're stuck in the past until you catch up with when yourself spinning it the first time. So if you went 15 years in the past to kill Voldemort you would have to live out those 15 years.
don’t know why but I died when yours said ‘okay kids, act confused’ and a funny closeup on hermione
I think that even though Cedric is a mediocre 2D character, his death scene is just fucking tragic. First Cedric is murdered pretty brutally, and when Harry and Cedric get back (with Harry lying on top of Cedric), Cedric is dead and Harry is in a fuck ton of pain, physically and emotionally. We transition from one of the darkest scenes in the series (the graveyard scene) to everyone (including Cedric's dad) clapping and cheering, and the band playing an upbeat triumphant song. The juxtaposition is perfect. And when Hagrid becomes the first to notice something is wrong, we know shit is about to go down. The band quickly stops as they realize someone is hurt, and the adults (Fudge and Dumbledore) quickly realize he is dead. Fudge wants to keep it quiet as a deadly, suspenseful silence permeates the audience as they all try to see what happens. And then Cedric's dad, with no regard to anything, pushes through people to get to his dead son. His screams and cries of anguish are perfect acting. And when he shouts about his son, the audience realizes Cedric is dead; we pan over their reactions as they realize Cedric has been killed. The audience's sorrow then contradicts with the aesthetics of the scene: most of them are wearing colorful clothes and they have Gryffindor and Hufflepuff flags and tattoos for the celebration of the final tournament. Again, amazing visual juxtaposition. And Harry, in one last desperate attempt to save Cedric, tries to cling to his body and not let go.
So, even though I didn't care much about Cedric, this scene made me feel terrible for him and for everyone who knew him.
That scene wrecks me emotionally every time and I always tear up. It is a perfect scene to me and is just so sad.
I think the whole point of Cedric’s death was how sudden and shocking it was. He was just a regular kid. There was no buildup to his death at all. It was shocking to see a kid die just like that. It was a great introduction for Voldemort.
@@bobgenghiskhan1397 I think it also serves to demonstrate to the other Hogwarts kids that the plot has effects on people other than the main characters.
I read the first part of this comment thinking Cedric was the fucking owl lmao
I'm kinda conflicted on it. On one hand, I totally agree with what you said. On the other hand, I agree that some of that power is lost by movie Cedric not really being significant enough to REALLY rack up that emotion.
That all being said, I managed to develop an attachment to Cedric in the books (he was under-utilized there as well, but they gave enough to me to feel invested in him anyway), and that was enough to make me latch onto movie Cedric regardless, so... I cried at his death scene.
I hope that all makes sense! My wording isn't always the best haha ^__^;;
"Harry has to face off against a sexy french lady, a hard-boiled russian supersoldier, and FUCKING Batman!!"
I died right there 😂😂😂
ikr
28:46
I remember someone else saying suggesting something with the killing curse and time turners where the curse is the one thing that's immune to other spells or something like that. It makes it so some characters can't come back to life, and it gives the spell itself more weight/makes it feel more dangerous.
this is literally my 6th time watching this series, this is literally my comfort youtube channel north
"Marcus, did you call me a useless piece of shit?" asked Dumbledore calmly.
MARCUS DID YA PUT YER NAME IN DA GOBLET OF FIYAAAAAAH
"Harry Potter 3 is fucking awesome."
You're goddamn right.
It's the furryest of the saga so it makes sense
@@gaiusjuliuscaesar8450 yes officer, this comment right here.
@@ozzyman0446 Tell me I'm wrong
@@gaiusjuliuscaesar8450 words of wisdom right there
If you liked this, go check out my Harry Potter video BRAH
32:26 my favorite part lol 😂Mahalo Marcus for always making my day 🤙🏼
Talking about the prisoner of azkaban film, the long takes are so good and effective, and i feel like the reason for that is that the director uses long takes as just a film technique instead of a gimmick.
I think harry being rude is fine, is more realistic than a goodie two shoes.
Book Harry is actually pretty rude, especially to authority figures. The goody two-shoes hero would be Neville
I guess it makes sense considering his dad was kind of an asshole.
@@09dindaayularasati65 Harry: "Yes"
Snape: "Yes, Sir"
Harry: "You don't have to call me sir, professor"
Book Harry was a savage
"FUCKING LOOK AT ME"
yep! i think the same. I love his sassiness honestly
Quirrel wasnt trying to ruin the quidditch game he was trying to throw Harry off his broom because it was seemingly a convenient way to kill him while making it look like an accident rather than a straight up murder
@@user-vz5lw2pu8t u know what.....ive never thought of it from that pov lmfao
I think its more the movies fault for this not your point since yeah that's what was happening but I think if Wood got smacked by a hard af bludger (that massive ball) hits the pole (I think) and falls off his broom I think Harry should be good Xd
@@LimeDida he doesnt need Harry alive at this point. All he wanted was the Stone. If I remember right the only time he needed Harry alive was during GoF when he needed his blood in order to regain his power
@@TheShankPimp I believe that is correct as well, and I think the main reason he needed his blood was because his first method of resurrection, the Stone, failed.
@@TheShankPimp In GoF he didn't need Harry's blood, he only wanted to use it because it contained the magical protection given to harry from his mothers sacrifice, and voldemort thought, if he also had this protection he could harm Harry. Voldemort didn't know about this magical protection until the end of Philosophers stone, when quirrell couldn't lay his hands on Harry.
I think we should treat Rowling like we're doing Lucas. He used to be a visionairre while he was making his early works, but in the sequel trilogy, he was treated like a Master Artist no one could contradict. And we all know the results.
The whole book series she made is legitimately good, especially if we treat it like a series of novels about growing up, not an infallible fantasy-science fiction. Not in the least because she was making them literally FOR LIVING. So she has to work with editors and take their advice to improve her books and make them more consented internally.
But then she became a "celebrity", an authority figure, and her flaws have been corrected more rarely since then.
And we got "Cursed Child" and all Fantastic MF Beasts. Which are incredibly bad in terms of story-telling.
The first movie and the second one will always have a special place in my heart, and I really liked the fourth movie, but there is no doubt that the Prisoner of Azkaban is the best of the series, due to its development, those sequence shots and that wonderful direction by Alfonso Cuarón while highlighting the wonderful soundtrack by John Williams makes it perfect.
Fun fact Lucius Malloy trying to kill Harry was just him forgetting his line and saying the first thing that comes to mind
Actually it was that the script said he was meant to say a spell but it didn’t specify, so he improvised and used the Killing Curse. Which honestly is pretty in canon with his unstable character. He’s also an incredibly talented improvisational actor!
@@Hobbitbot3000 he actually was beginning to say vera verto but he made it sound like avada
Source
@@vintheguy if you watch the hbo Max series they reuploaded with subtitles you can see him start to say it. Also if you really listen closely it doesn’t really sound like “Avada” but more like “Vera”
@@paulfriebe1824
Not him saying it! I'm talking about a source for the fun fact
Underrated line
“Hermione gets to be smart, Harry does his broom thing, and Ron… dies.
Dude your Doctor Who references were ON POINT, can’t wait for a video soon.
I'm rewatching some of your review series' and I have to say a separate video on Prizoner of Azkaban would be sweet. It's definitely the best of the bunch and would be worthy of the extra attention.
I actually really agree with the Cedric part. Cedric should've been Harry's new 'best friend' while he was estranged from Ron. That would've hit harder at the end since it would've shown that this type of thing could easily happen to Ron & Hermione, also showing to Harry that he can't always protect his friends. Goddamn, that would've been cool.
Looking at their relationship, this seems really close to being set up, but then it just never really comes together. They're set up as rivals even before Goblet of Fire, since they're on opposing houses and quidditch teams. In the tournament, they're not just competing against each other. Cedric believes Harry cheated to enter the competition, which causes even more conflict.
All the factors that made them rivals; however, could have contributed to them being really good friends. They have similar interests and values. They start to burry the hatchet and help each other, but they it never grows beyond each person performing a favor for the other.
I agree that it would have been cool but it would not have worked in a realistic sense. Cedric is this cool, popular jock like kid who is 2 or 3 years older than Harry. Harry is hated by all of Hufflepuff house (aka Cedric's house) and is a joke to everyone else because he's a scrawny little 14 year old who's the fourth contestant in a TRIwizard Tournament. Those two wouldn't be friends.
Of course you can make the argument that that hanging out with the guy his entire house hates is what would make Cedric the nice and likable guy whose death would impact us, the audience. But then, the age difference is still an issue. A 16-17 year old just randomly hanging out with a 14 year old in school is kind of weird.
@@hittingyouoverthehead I don't think any of that's an issue since if they made this a goal of the story, it would be altered in whatever way to suit it. Like it is currently to suit the plot they went with, you know?
@@terryqokov6999 I assume you've finished your schooling? Can you imagine any situation where a 17 year old kid has just casually hung out with a 14 year old at school? Unless they're siblings or someone like a teacher asks one to tutor the other, have you seen them willingly just hanging out together? Does that seem realistic?
If you're trying to say that Cedric can be made into a 14 year old to make this come through, then again,
1. He'd be in the same year as Harry so he wouldn't be so popular. Harry kind of steals the spotlight every time.
2. All students in the school (including the 7th years) fawning over him wouldn't make sense
@@hittingyouoverthehead No that's exactly why they'd have to change it to fit the new situation. You seem to be thinking they'll keep the current structure of the story but you can legit change it to work in whichever way you want.
To add to the "things Rowling added later that fucks with earlier stuff" pile: If Hogwarts did not originally have plumbing, then why is there a button on the sink to open the chamber of secrets? And what was covering the way in initially?
it was covered with magic
And who was the one that built the sinks? Because they had to have seen the hole and they had to go “Oh yes, a secret hole, I’ll make this sink a cover up that is accessible to anyone who figures it out!”
Apparently the Gaunts infiltrated the construction crew.
The guy that retro fitted the castle for plumbing must have found the chamber and been in slytherin.
Obviously wizards invented plumbing.
Or the Romans.
Yo this made me laugh like a crazy person thank you
"D'you ever think we'll get a quiet year at Hogwarts?'
"Ron our friend fucking DIED."
Im so glad that someone else thinks about young tom riddle sitting in his room with his diary open, writing out "I am lord..." And then trying to figure out which anagram of the rest of his name sounds coolest. Because I think about that every damn day
I think it fits his personality, before he became the dark lord, he was the edge lord
@@quicklittlesnail1616 he really is that dude who never grew out of his edgy phase , like holy shit ! His emblem is a snake and a skull ,
That's exactly why he had to kill the rest of his class, basically eliminating any chance of anyone remembering what a tool he was
The only cool thing left about Voldemort's name is that apparently Rowling didn't intend for the T to be pronounced. As soon as I read that, I translated it from French and got "flight of death." I feel like this should be more prevalent information, but she's kind of bogged down a lot of cool things with the weird convoluted and plot-holey shit.
"I am lord Moldovert!" just doesn't have the same ring to it.
MERRY CHRISTMAS! WWWEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
Didn't expect you here 😂
Hey drew
bruh moment
Yooo what😂😂
dude, I see you everywhere now.
Drewski, the new Justin Y?
ohboy sorting comments by new was a mistake
The Barty Crouch thing is like 15 times more complicated in the book. The film had to cut all of that crap, but it leaves the obvious plothole re: Azkaban and how one escaped inmate causes the wizard authorities to freak out so badly that they put soul sucking monsters in the school, but a second escaped inmate goes completely unnoticed for like a year.
I thought Cedric’s death was handled really well, the music still playing as Harry teleports back with his body, the normality or everything until his body causes disruption, very realistic and how I’d imagine how a crowd would react to a dead body.
This scene honestly shook me to my core
The father's acting during that scene still breaks my heart.
agree. still think they cold've spent more screen time on him to make his character more releatable and deep, tho. just like the video suggested.
when me and my buddy are drunk we will sometimes reenact that scene, immitating the music from the marching band and everything. It was a great scene and definitely super memorable.
@@jfklsw1298 Damn I feel bad for you.
3rd movie: “This is where these movies start getting good”
Literally the next movie: “This is where the cracks start to show”
lmao
and thats harry potter for ya, Astonishingly good at some parts, and horrifically bad at others.
@@iswiftyfox8997 Unless you read the books*
@@cameronmcphee8224 I mean 5 is a pretty sharp low point imo
@@bobbyshewan4229 I love all of the books, but 4 is my favorite (and maybe the best book I’ve ever read?) so in the books that’s not where the cracks start to show.
I wish 4 had a better movie...
the goblet of fire book is pretty good. but the movie adaptation is kinda weak
A youtube masterpiece truly
Another interesting note about Remus Lupin that I didn't realize until the other day. Remus is the name of one of the brothers that were raised by wolves in roman mythos. In the story there were two brothers Remus and Romulus who were raised by wolves. Romulus kills Remus and founds the city of rome.
“this is like a shonen tournament arc”
I love marcus, so much
he is a weeb, just like us
You're like me, I thought I was the only one
Yeah I relate to him a lot too
Same. Weebs unite!
Same I don't really care about the reviews but his soo so funny I can't
"She keeps inventing new characters and new villains, just to get rid of them after one story"
A Sonic series moment
i miss the babylon rogues man.
I had Fantastic Beast 2 Vietnam flashback when he said that. No seriously, what was that gigantic cast all for...
@@justalostlocal Prepare for 3 Ginderwalds.
If you liked this, go check out my Harry Potter video BRAH
Hi there ! i think the last shot of the 3rd movie is quite clever (25;06). It's a parallele between the pain that the dementors caused to harry, and the joy he finally feels at the end