New NCERT textbooks | One big change apart from Mughal history | TV Newsance 208
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 04. 2023
- In this episode we take a deep dive into what specific parts of #NCERT textbooks were removed, what these changes mean, and why they matter. Some changes to the reality of why Godse killed Gandhi have been removed which makes us wonder what children will learn at school. We also saw Arnab Goswami cheer as we found that the NCERT has made key changes to political science and history textbooks when it comes to Mughals and Islamic rulers - a story broken by the Indian Express. Certain chapters and parts related to #mughalempire were removed from these books, which led Arnab to ask why anybody would even want to know about them?
We also take a look at what the official and unofficial spokespersons of the governing party have said about the Mughals in the past. While Arnab was finding innovative ways to take a dig at the 'Innndian' Express, the internet was flooded with memes and cartoons.
Reading material
* Purged from NCERT Textbooks: Hindu extremists’ dislike for Mahatma Gandhi, RSS ban after assassination
indianexpress.com/article/edu...
* In NCERT Textbook Trim: Mughal era, Delhi Sultanate, Emergency impact and 2002 riots
indianexpress.com/article/edu...
#TVNewsance is Newslaundry’s weekly media critique and political satire show. We watch Hindi and English TV news so you don't have to! If you like what we do, don’t forget to subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscript...
Also, get a chance to interact with Manisha Pande and the team. Join us on Telegram for exclusive updates on #TVNewsance: t.me/TVNewsance
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscription?ref=newsance
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
थोड़ा बहुत मसाला अंधभक्तों के लिए के लिए भी कुछ मसालेदार गोबर भी रखा करो 😂😂😂
How are you burning? How's the burn librandu news channel? How much money are you getting?
Have some chilli and some burnol.
கப்புரானா? காலி தோ?
கீமத்து, கீமத்து, லஃகு பஃகு?
கஹானி குஹானி, சுன் லியா கின் லியா, காட்டு தியா கீட்டு தியா?
Kuch saal baad syllabus Kum karne k chakkar main, puri kitab gayab karke "Bal Narendra" ki kitaab pakda denge.
hahahahaha sahi bola bhai
czcams.com/video/zIK1UKboYVo/video.html&ab_channel=StudyIQIAS
Have a look what actually NDA govt has planned.
I feel out of the habit to criticize Modi u guys have become andhbhakt to non Bjp appealing media. ( Think deep about it, u look aged and u dont wanna get bashed by 19yr true liberal citizen)
Actually you guys are andhbhakt who never know the impact of the history what tough to children.
@@bdabda1602no history was interesting for us . For future generations it would be boring
@@rifasvlog I know you are the example of andhabhakt, I am talking about the impact of studying that our ancestors are being colonized again and again... And not even telling us truthfully how much atrocities happened at that time. And etc.
The front page of IE that day was a shocker. It took some time for me to realise what it was all about. Kudos to IE for exposing those history manipulators.
I want you to kindly do your own research on how gandhi ji was a hypocrate...he was actually a muslim community pleaser(understand i dont hate a particular community..but hating one community (hindu) while prasing the other(muslim)...i wont call it an idle behaviour)...cbse was actually white washing his intentions..i wont blame them coz many are in india...
Read Moplah shocker sometimes
@@redlobstering you must like drinking Gau mutra
@@redlobstering do you have any facts to back your claim that Gandhi "hated" Hindus?
The worst part is that they've deleted some parts out of the book and didn't even enlisted them.
I've bought ncert books to start my upsc preparation and unfortunately some of them are rationalized ones. Now I thought it's ok, I will add the old one's myself by looking at the list ncert had released for the changed syllabus, but now I got to know that they've ommited some of them and didn't enlisted it, it's a headache and actually irritated me. If they've deleted it why aren't they've informed the public about all the deletions, they should never have rationalized the book at all, they should have just given iut the list that ehat topics and chapters they want to exclude from the syllabus and are not meant to be studied by students whose studies are affected by the covid 19. And come on man, they've not even added a new chapter about and hinfu ruler, just ommited some sentences and names from here and there.
Looks like they are not interested in actually helping the students. Not just this, school students are compelled to buy new books as literally some words and sentences are omitted from here and there in the whole book, while some who can't afford it used to rely on second hand books. And neet and jee students are also affected by it.
Looks like this change have increased the headache of all types of students rather than easing them.
Those who tried to delete history, got deleted in history...
Abe gobar le dimaag ke reduce hua hai delete nhi
বেঙ্গলি কে এই জন্য গালি দেয়
নিজের ঘর না দেখে পাড়ার বাড়িতে কি হয়ছে দেক।
আমাদের ওয়েস্ট বেঙ্গল যে সাম্রাজ্য গুলো ওই গুলো জানিস।
বল ল্যাওড়া কিন্তু মুঘল দের কে জানতে হবে যারা আমাদের কে লুট পাট করতে আফগানিস্তান থেকে এসেছিল
বালের বেঙ্গলি সালা তুই
এই জন্য তোদের জন্য আমাদের মতো নরমাল বেঙ্গলি দের গালি খেতে হয়
Don't know, some who burnt down any entire library. Their history is not deleted, so your argument is null and void.
Convert kab horaha hai?
Yes specially Congress 😅
The sad part is Majority of the people even don't know something happened with books
You can see the students going abroad for studies increasing every year. Content is one of the things we have to look at when it comes to increasing the standard of education in India. 🙏 Please don't politicize education as it is going to affect our own kids only 😢😢
Isn't that a good thing? More seats available for people who don't want to study abroad
How is speaking about Real History, Politicization ?
What is read by our Childrn is in-fact Fraudulent History promoted by Communists . Theories like Aryan Invasion Theory which has no Proof or Basis in reality, is taught to our Children who grow up believing its true.
@@Someone-zs5xrbrdr it means no one wants to stay in india, the moment they get an opportunity to leave they do never to come back
Fearless news maker, I subscribed.Salute NL.
Thanks!
थोड़ा बहुत मसाला अंधभक्तों के लिए के लिए भी कुछ मसालेदार गोबर भी रखा करो
Lauda mera
@@manishapande4184 digest this .........46' - 47' election result which paved the way for ppartition ------mmosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% vote goes to M. League , Madras Province 100% , Bengal 95% , Assam 91% , Orissa 100% , Central Province 93% ...so on so on ....)
Why she should feel fear ? It's not Indira Gandhi government right now ... Loosen up 😂
I would really wish that some one in some corner of this nation will archived these books as a proof that there was a India that had different thought process before facism
Bhai CZcams internet pe chlate ho ya gas pe
@@urrasscal8380 pretty sure everyone opposed the partition of bengal in 1905 .
Welcome to world's best democracy.
@@jerven1128 again oppose when w. bengal is partition by the jjihadis or better introduce sshriah law oppose just like hhindus in ppakistan do.
@arwind sawant what is vedic math? if mathematical concepts formulated by indians are vedic math does that make calculus christian math and algebra islamic math?
"Utho anarkali ab hum out of syllabus hai" was very creative 🤣🤣🤣
"You need to pay to keep new free"
Free from being biased, free from any political or billionaire's pressure, free from any kind of one sided news, free from being fake
Keep the news free
This is biased that's why har baar modi modi modi
@arwindsawant8538 You must know about your past your history whether it was bad or good. You read about Hitler and his cruelty that's why world got lesson from it and not to repeat thier mistake again. If you never heard about those cruel rulers you never gonna know about those people who raised their voice against it and sacrificed their life for all. "They fought for those who couldn't fight from themselves". That's the whole point of our history it tells/reminds us not to repeat our mistakes which we've done in past. That's is the beauty of history. As I always says
" modified History isn't History"
they are funed by FB.
@@dc-ayush1115 What do you mean by modified history? Choosing to omit certain details about certain people or events reflects a historian's bias. And every human has a bias. There is no neutral history. There are few facts. But their interpretation and other details always remains debatable
@@lazyporch yeah as you said above modified history is the one which you want to show others . A specific event or individual. History never can refer to or from one individual.
If you ever observed BJP hates Nehru to the core...but BJP and Modiji(who himself jailed in emergency) never or criticise ( very less) Indhira but go very fanatic on Nehru... because wants to be Indhira and love her dictatorship....Indhira is very close to BJP dictatorial tendencies which Nehru was quite opposite....
Smtym BJP bcom little secular their bhakts bcom angry and start abusing modi and say indira gadhi hoti toh abhi tak sabak sikha deti🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@tony-pc4kd Indhira Gandhi is secular....or pluralist is the better term...unlike Nehru who wanted to keep religion our of politics. Indhira is more of letting all religions be into politics equally...
He wants to be like Nehru, rather surpass him. Nehru jacket, chooridaar pyjama. Only rose is left to be pinned
@@withloveforall I don't think nehru can ever be replaced....But it is just a tragedy of Nehru and Gandhi ....I heard one of the scholars said.."In the Bible it was said that the sins of the father are visited upon his next successive generations..but in Nehrus case it is opposite sins of his next successive generations are visited upon him"....I mean I understand nehru sin of giving birth to Indira....But Gandhi had nothing to do with Indhira Gandhi (her name is a fake name as Feroze Gandhy was a fan of Gandhi he changed his name as Gandhi because his Persian name can be written in both ways) but still for having his name associated with fake Gandhis even he is suffering
Because Indira frred Bangladesh
Scary truth about tomorrow and unfortunately yesterday is " Who holds power , writes the history"
in the same congress and british wrote the history according to their convinience
@@student0329 maybe instead of supporting BJP blindly you should criticize their BS and misuse of power.
@@DragonOfTheMortalKombat How come bjp came here? Just saying histoy is always a propaganda and ncert too. Don't you think children day Nov 15 is a political tool to remember nehru. First to point out bjp tell me how blindly read your history without any research or do you think entire history is written without biases. after 50 years your children thinks this is the true history
@@DragonOfTheMortalKombat
Gandhi and Nehru got VVIP treatment in jail ... In case of Gandhi i hear British offered him vegitarian meal ( special ) ...
Nehru struggled a lot because his regular Madame's cunt was not available in jail ...
All around globe Gandhi statues are getting dismantled like it's some sort of trash ...
Gandhi said Indias should gape their anus wider infront of foreign intruders in name of ahimsa but same Gandhi done recruitment for British during world war 2
So still you think British ran for their life in a midnight because of Gandhi ?
Ever heard of sipahi lahala and INA of Subhash Chandra Bose ?
So you weren't scared for the last 70 years
Whatever wrong is happening is due to the poor choice of people who vote for the wrong ones and pay the price by way of suffering….
cons of democracy
It's you who are poor not Indians
Democracy is dead in India.
Another bastard of Mughal crying for abbu 😂
And pls tell me what's wrong in this and i will again vote for bjp proudly so please continue your crying because it makes no difference.
Mughal empire is a Myth. It was all Modi Empire and Modi Dynasty. That is why the rulers during the so called 'Mughal Empire' called themselves Modi I, Modi II, Sha I, Modi III, Modi IV etc... We finally did justice to history and art (esp. Drama).
🤣
Ye Sahi hai 👍
Brother I'm from the North East India
1.And still the NCERT curriculum and we don't even have a single history chapter of North East from 6-12 class
And I'm learning it
Do u think this is fair?
2. Regarding Indian civilization we had many kingdoms of glory like Vijaynagar, chola , Pandya, cheras, Marathas. And North Indian kingdoms too
Is there any chapter about Chatrapati sivaji Maharaj in the NCERT curriculum?
Our medieval history only talks about Mughal and there was not a single word "INVASION" in the history and we know what's the reality and their deeds.
We know the story of what Mughals did to Sambhaji , Teg bahadur and Sikh gurus
But not a single mention
They're portrayed as if they're the best. Do u think a Sikh Punjabi and Marathi person would love to read that kind of history
And ask today's student the name of Mughal emperor
They'll quickly answer it
But ask any 3 kings from Gupta dynasty
They won't even know it. Because it's out of syllabus
Do u think this is fair way learning history?
We already were the richest civilization in our past even before Mughals
During Maurya, Vijaynagar, Gupta's
And these historians like Romila Thapar is white washing our history
3. Regarding Indian independence movement
We only learn about Gandhi
But the one who contributed in this movement was Subash Chandra Bose and his INA Armys
And Bhagat Singh.
Not a proper mention of them
@@drpop_25
I don't know how messed up NCERT is but in south, we read about Gupta Dynasty avidly (we had two chapters plus one about Ashoka). We have the damn word INVASION when we read about Babur and his cannons. Our curriculum doesn't always glorify the Mughals but also mentions the bad things that Mughals did. Unfortunately for you we know that Gandhi joined the freedom movement only in 1930. We read about Lal-Bal-Pal. We have a chapter about Bose. So if North India history books are books are fucked up know that I am not the one to be ashamed but the concerned people. However, if one has such an interest in history, they could read it now. I for myself, regarded as a dry subject and was interested in European history which is more relevant in our current times. In short everything that happened before 1800 or so is of less important. Harkening to those ancient histories is happening only to awake the ghosts that makes gains for people and in the will cause a holocaust.
When it comes to north east, I strongly feel like India doesn't need NE-ppl but just NE-lands (because of the minerals) and also as the buffer lands between China. I abhor the very concept of using people like that but India is not all good as Indians believe to be.
46' - 47' election result which paved the way for ppartition ------mmosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% vote goes to M. League , Madras Province 100% , Bengal 95% , Assam 91% , Orissa 100% , Central Province 93% ...so on so on ....)
The INnovative headline was so bold and powerful! It might seem a small thing to delete few lines from textbooks of school children, but it is equivalent to erasing the values
-with which our country was created, from the collective consciousness. To think that the future generations won't be aligned to the values of the founding fathers is a scary thought.
What was the value of founding father? So the value was to protect Islamic Caliphate & that's why he was spearheading Pan-Islamist Khilafat movement while being himself an Infidel.The so called Value of founding father i:e; Hindu -Muslim unity was annihilated by Indian muslim with vivisection or Partition of India on the basis of Islam & creation of Islamic Republic of Pakistan 😅😂
@@indianstorm7366 no, the values that people with different way of life can coexist and we can actually work towards improving lives of people without worrying about whom they worship.
Removing history wether good or bad is simply shady af. And using fancy words to sound intelligent when in reality u are just saying absolute nonsense is stupid. @indianstorm7366
@@vridhijain788 The value which you mentioned is not the original value of Gandhi & Nehru but it's actually value of Indian Civilization which trace its root from thousand of years & not just from a party which was formed specially to put the British Raj further as a"Safety valve".
@@krystalgomez2300 Wherever I have supported the removing of history of a particular dynasty or Empire. I am not supporting removal of history but I would not support whitewashing the Islamic tyranny of " Persianised Turko -Mangol Mughal".I am an Atheist & an independent truth seekar. I am neither leftist nor Rightist.
I am from ICSE. From our Hindi syllabus, they removed a story called "Jamun Ka Ped" that was a political satire.
Heyyy it was also in icse. Frankly when they deleted I was happy because load Kam hogaya. But now I m against it.
Saturday morning is defined by Newslaundry 💙
😌
and Sunday by sarthak goswami
46' - 47' election result which paved the way for ppartition ------mmosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% vote goes to M. League , Madras Province 100% , Bengal 95% , Assam 91% , Orissa 100% , Central Province 93% ...so on so on ....)
@arwind sawant You Lund bhakts want a Chutputiya pahadi chuha to replace the Mughals? Lund pujte pujte sata gaya hai kya be?
@@aurelian2401 tmhari qoum 2002 hi deserve karti hai acha hota tmhare sath. Reply kar aukaat hai toh
Your content (and deshbhakt) keeps me updated about TV news buffoonery w/o watching. I pay for the time saved
They are getting paid by George Soros ... Buy peenuts for that cash and enjoy the show
@arwind sawant "I" and "We" are different
If you didn't know Ayurveda, Yoga, Vedic Math, Bhagavad Gita, it's your own fault, not "our" or "we"
And you think you get the complete picture without bias????
@@avikmandal8578but its true that books be known for glorifying mughals.
@@kushaltiwari3668 does that mean that were neglected? Does that mean we lost ayurveda or yoga ? Mughals ruled for centuries, Delhi Sultanate before that. Still we know about them, don't we? If someone doesn't know and blames the books, it just means he was into just mugging up information to pass exams rather than exploring more to learn more
#Mughals impact is so strong even after years.
The ones who burned nalanda
@@kushaltiwari3668 Baman chutiyye, tere sapne Mughalon ne Nalanda jalaya tha?
So? Your Nathuram killed Gandhi. Don't whatabout without sense. Point of history is to learn from it. We shouldn't deny whatever happened nor hide any part of it-good Or bad. Nobody can change the past but learn from it.
@@nnyamokkonyak4661 what did your learn from Mughal?
@@jahbless1485 You can try getting a hold of old syllabus history text books from 7th standards onwards. Let's be productive and learn history today. History is history - be objective when you study and look at all events from socio- political, economic perspective from that specific time period not today. Just a tip.
I have to ensure my kids go for science or commerce to ensure they don't learn wrong history, especially about fake legacy of vishwaguru bal Narendra😂😂
@arwind sawant Do you know Savarkar was the first person who came up with the idea of partition?
@@prateepc1 they only learn things that benefit their arguments
Nice thought but they might put his ideas in science as well like badal hai toh fighter planes radar se bacch sakte hain 😂😂
@@prateepc1 Did your mom slept with muslim?
Good else they will not be hating culture like you. But hard luck putting in science stream from 7th grade. You can move to your white masters land but there they will learn maths is racist and your kids will teach you drag stories
बादशाह सलामत रहें
Baadshah is no more bro.
Just like our real history.
But now I really appreciate Indian Government to reduce some chapters of mughals ( remember reduce not delete) and add some really great kings history.
Mughals se pehle bhi bahoot purana history raha h hamara. Lekin afsos us level ka padhaya nahi jata tha school level me.
Mughal history is a tiny part of our history.
Each state have their own history. But I bet, before 1500 (when babur came), very few people know our Indian History.
@@SatyamKumar-fr1ge
थोड़ा बहुत मसाला अंधभक्तों के लिए के लिए भी कुछ मसालेदार गोबर भी रखा करो
माफीवीर सावरकर को भी हीरो बनना 🍌🍌🍌 है ,, आतंकी नाथूराम गोडसे को भी ताज पहनना है , 😢😢
Brother I'm from the North East India
1.And still the NCERT curriculum and we don't even have a single history chapter of North East from 6-12 class
And I'm learning it
Do u think this is fair?
2. Regarding Indian civilization we had many kingdoms of glory like Vijaynagar, chola , Pandya, cheras, Marathas. And North Indian kingdoms too
Is there any chapter about Chatrapati sivaji Maharaj in the NCERT curriculum?
Our medieval history only talks about Mughal and there was not a single word "INVASION" in the history and we know what's the reality and their deeds.
We know the story of what Mughals did to Sambhaji , Teg bahadur and Sikh gurus
But not a single mention
They're portrayed as if they're the best. Do u think a Sikh Punjabi and Marathi person would love to read that kind of history
And ask today's student the name of Mughal emperor
They'll quickly answer it
But ask any 3 kings from Gupta dynasty
They won't even know it. Because it's out of syllabus
Do u think this is fair way learning history?
We already were the richest civilization in our past even before Mughals
During Maurya, Vijaynagar, Gupta's
And these historians like Romila Thapar is white washing our history
3. Regarding Indian independence movement
We only learn about Gandhi
But the one who contributed in this movement was Subash Chandra Bose and his INA Armys
And Bhagat Singh.
Not a proper mention of them
@@drpop_25 that's true...
@@drpop_25 You are from NE you mf you yourself are not part of mainstream India...
To anger a conservative, lie to him.
To anger a leftist, tell him the truth.
In my experiences, it's the opposite lmao
@@DippinSauc then you are inexperienced
I am neither a conservative nor a leftist but i will always say conservatives are way better than leftists
Leftists always have a persona that whatever they do or think is the ultimate and if you challenge them or try to debate they will tag you as a bhakt
Neh its the opposite man
@@KaushikcraftAIwhat's the truth?
it doesn't make sense to cut out builder hand because it wasn't a single bulder taj was build by thousands of labours over 22 years. And it was so ambitious and expensive project that no body could replicate at that time. That hand cutting thing feels just like a legend.
It is! No historical proof for it. More an urban legend
@@manishapande4184yes gomuthra nagpur half knickers
Wo afwaah hai bas ..aisa kuch nhi hua tha in real.
information of cutting hand is not found yet for this particular taj mahal incident.... may be true may not be true ..... however in iislamic culture ccutting hand , s$x sslavery all this are very normal ...
Dude, it's just one conspiracy theory from the BJP and RSS. Sadly, these things go viral like crazy. You'll also find video with millions of views telling Taj Mahal being a Temple. There's literally zero evidence about any such thing. Also, if thousands of skilled workers got their hands cut, there wouldn't be anymore Mughal architectures in Delhi. Love it or hate it, but these Mughal architecture are a masterpiece and truly ahead of their time. That's why still standing tall whereas the substandard bridges and roads in Bjp states don't even last a few years.
I will vote for anyone who would rewrite "Godse from RSS murdered Gandhiji and RSS was banned" in the books.
I thought Rahul ji apologized for the same thing 🤔
Straight up lie. Godse in his own words, explained his reasons for killing Gandhi many times. IDK why you people persist with these lies.
Bro i am not supporting anybody but even the courts of our country has disregarded such claims ,,
there was no connection of Godse with RSS (for conspiring to kill Gandhi) ,, atleast try to understand the real truth plz,, no offence intended u can have ur claims
@@Merciless960 Godse was listed as member of RSS when he killed Gandhiji, he wrote in his book why he killed him, it's natural that he will not admit that RSS directly tasked him to kill gandhiji. He was the product of the biggest cancer of this country called RSS
46' - 47' election result which paved the way for ppartition ------mmosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% vote goes to M. League , Madras Province 100% , Bengal 95% , Assam 91% , Orissa 100% , Central Province 93% ...so on so on ....) still congress didnot do popul. xchange .....never ever gonna vote for librandu congress again.
Wow! What an achievement ☺ 🤔 what next? Tomorrow in journalism studies there will be chapters on "The Empire of Yellow Journalism " ; "The Sultanate of Republic TV" et al. 🙏 God save this country. Jai Hind.
Modi govt......LUXURY GANGES VILAS VS JAMRUSHINAGAR SLUMS
GHI 107 /121
PRESS FREEDOM 126
This country is already ruined
"Who controls the past now controls the future, who controls the present now, controls the past."
Quoted by the band, Rage Against The Machine 😅
Testify
Isn't that quote originally from 1984?
@@pretensious_posse2688correct, RATM sampled it
They could have made NCERT a bit simpler but deleting chapters sections, words said, this is disturbing and feels dictatorship
@arwind sawant Before 2014 India was a democratic country.
@arwind sawant Because since 2014 India is ruled by 2 mass-murder terrorists and a terrorist organisation called RSS.
We bengalis are not as fool as you cow belt gawars.
We can delete and redistribute and give equal weightage to all
@arwind sawant stop spamming bot.
@arwind sawant go read about the leaders you talk about. They all stood for secularism and inclusiveness not like the BJP. Also it has been proven time and time again that nation based on religious nationalism is bound to fail( for example Pakistan)
Minisha is the soul of Newsance! 👍👍
The production value of the episodes have really gone up. Well Researched episode!
All that 30 Crore China money has to go somewhere..
Why people dont understand this simple fact ..
"We can not change the history .... only thing we can do is learn from it "
then why cant we learn our own history of Peshwas, Maharana Pratap, Shivaji Maharaj and other great leaders
@@kaustubhligde7672 all of them are already taught according to the extent of their empire. I know this bcos I learnt about them in my school days
@@user-fp8xx7qf1w aryan are not race u iidiot .... kaha se padh kar aatey ho.....
Gaurav
say that to saheb
@@kaustubhligde7672 I learnt about them. Probably you were in Sangh classes instead of history classes.
इतिहास के हटाये गए portion से वो लोग ही खुश हैं जिन्होंने न तो कभी इतिहास पढा है और न अब कोई उम्मीद बची है उनके जीवन में कि वो पढ़ेंगे। क्लास 12 तक का अकादमिक इतिहास अब पूरी तरह से वॉट्सएप्प इतिहास के हिसाब से चलेगा।
For example
strange and irony is that future students will always go after whatever was removed from text books.. curiosity wins
So removed many wrong doings of mughals too isn't that good.
Its wrong. We need to know what these barbarians did to Hindu Sikhs Buddhist
Lol, let's see
Ya they will come to know about those Mughals atrocities 😂
If Modiji is so hateful of Mughals, why does he addresses from the ramparts of the Red Fort ? Let him speak from Nagpur-the HQ of his mabaap, RSS !
kon sunega waha se.
also red fort is being rented out. really shameful, for destroying heritage, invader or not.
🤘👍🏽👌👏🏻👏🏽👏👏🏿
That's a clear 100% show of Shalowness and Hypocrisy.
Brother I'm from the North East India
1.And still the NCERT curriculum and we don't even have a single history chapter of North East from 6-12 class
And I'm learning it
Do u think this is fair?
2. Regarding Indian civilization we had many kingdoms of glory like Vijaynagar, chola , Pandya, cheras, Marathas. And North Indian kingdoms too
Is there any chapter about Chatrapati sivaji Maharaj in the NCERT curriculum?
Our medieval history only talks about Mughal and there was not a single word "INVASION" in the history and we know what's the reality and their deeds.
We know the story of what Mughals did to Sambhaji , Teg bahadur and Sikh gurus
But not a single mention
They're portrayed as if they're the best. Do u think a Sikh Punjabi and Marathi person would love to read that kind of history
And ask today's student the name of Mughal emperor
They'll quickly answer it
But ask any 3 kings from Gupta dynasty
They won't even know it. Because it's out of syllabus
Do u think this is fair way learning history?
We already were the richest civilization in our past even before Mughals
During Maurya, Vijaynagar, Gupta's
And these historians like Romila Thapar is white washing our history
3. Regarding Indian independence movement
We only learn about Gandhi
But the one who contributed in this movement was Subash Chandra Bose and his INA Armys
And Bhagat Singh.
Not a proper mention of them
red fort was made from jjizya money i.e. iindian money ..... what the heck are u blabbering .... breaking statue and idols temple structure & etc are iislamic culture ......
If you are so proud of Jihadis why not go to Pakistan?
Not taking action against such disgusting modification is the failure of our people*
We need to preserve historical documents in all forms..!
And sometimes I believe why there's no one making "real" news and then I come here ....
Since 2014 dark Era is going on....ye gutter media ne to hadd kardi
Bad news for Whites and Pakistan fans
@@LearnWithVikram7 Congrats for supporting violence ideology
New edition will be: Modi tea selling, savarkar in bul bul, Modani, Modi as degree holder
Aurangzeb as hero
Savarkar se toh Rahul darr gya hahahaha :)
@@bhupenderrawat5922 Jo British se dar gaya usse indian koi nahi darega
Imagine sir , a tea seller is more capable than you , i feel your pain..... education doesnt give you ability .....which is clear from your life..... bill gates didint finish grad, nor did zuckerberg , nor did ritesh agarwal........
@@francisrodrigues4317 What bout gandhi and nehru who sips tea with british in the evening hahaha. Rahul darr gya savarkar se ab muuh band ho gya.
Its the Starting of New Era of NEW INDIA... How Mugals Changed the History and Civilisation of Indian Structure...We have to rebuild it... From the Scratch... and Education is the Least Level to Rewrite it...
Thank God these people are not much educated and do not know that we are using Hindu-arabic number system
otherwise they would have made maths more complicated. I still get confused when I read numbers in Telugu or Hindi 😢😢
Nice joke 😂😂😂 hindu Arabic
Islam ke pehle se hum bhartiya numbers likhnajante the
Haa lol 0 and number tho India mein Mughals laye naa ?? 😂 Get educated bro
Pls save and archive this NL episode for future gen...this is a key moment for India itself
Salute to the person who created the DP 🤣👌👍🙏
In DP, Rajat Sharma is missing!
You guys should go live @9pm with the T.V debates on one frame and counter each time someone makes a false claim or tells a lie.
Newslaundry bann hojayegi arnab goswami inki gand mardega aur woh dhruv rathee bhi.
You can fool people sometimes, but you can't fool all the people all the time.
Unless you live in this country😂
*North eastern history, art, culture, music etc have been totally neglected.* I expect an open media house like newslaundry to be non-biased, disappointed.
What do you expect from news laundary?
They are left wing news channel, while calling them self as neutral.
So, they will definitely say things which are against government
Whenever Books are manipulated to pertain to a certain political mindset, it just ring alarm bells in my mind.
Left/Marxist academics ensured that our true history was put in cold storage in the 1960's and from then onwards in the garb of the likes of JNU,and the ICHR a systemic distortion of history was carried out. The biggest example is that Mughals who effectively ruled on a vast area for not more than 170 years are given too much of importance as if they were the most influential rulers whereas we a hardly know anything about the Vijaynagar empire in Southern India which lasted for more than 350 years!
Thanks. Keep it up. Brave journalism
I never heard even a proper introduction about maharana pratap , shivaji etc🤔
Most people didn't even know that Akbar's hindu wife name was not Jodha
I am with that mughal chapters shouldn't be removed they should also taught how they looted us
And also about glorious Indian king's achievements
Good to know some people are not being brainwashed by these types of news
Thank you
@@khushigupta6238 did you watch this channel's video(a subscriber
@@nandinijodha8265 I watched this vdo and it's a pure example of being a secular hindu( whatever that means)
Actually I randomly found this video l don't know about their content
History can't be changed no matter what you do
As a parent I have decided to get other books from ICSE for my kids. I also expose them to certain other History articles. This is a scary situation for Education in India
I am sorry but I really feel there should be a basic qualification for the politicians, like their ideology regarding other religions is truly concerning. When I was in 7th grade in 2020 we were taught about the Delhi Sultanate and the Mughals and trust me that chapter is really interesting they contributed a lot to our Indian history removing them is like removing an era.
Your respect for invaders is what I don't like mughal ke vanshaj
@@rajrathore2 i appologise if i sounded that way but i never said i respect invaders what I mean is that they had given us one of the priceless historic monuments. SOME of them were secular ruleres and some one surly ruthless but making an attempt in erazing them is really foolish. They are a part of our history and should be taught.
@@d1sha88 it is not erased but some topics are removed
I want government to add Mughals in book and about what they did to india so we can learn from our mistakes
@@rajrathore2 i totally agree with you but the way the news and politicians are arguing I feel they will.
@@d1sha88 don't know about it
Witnessing the decline of our society! We no longer stand for what is right......i think history will look down upon us as a spineless society!
I literally cannot express how much I love your boldness..you literally pissed all those PPL in just a single video. Lots of love from Bihar..I just found your channel and I would love to see your more content and yes ,you are right in your every statement..❤
What is wrong in talking about the brutality of mughals and their hate for non muslims .
Pakistani love her too
@@LearnWithVikram7 bhut even bjp don't care about bhakt like you😂😂😂😂😂
@@kushaltiwari3668 if you are talking about hate just talk with facts which you don't have .....arey duniya choud bs tu hath katwane wala hi sabot de de😂😂😂😂😂
@@Atheist503 I care for my country
Thank you for saving us.
AADAAB, NAMASKAR. Aap jaise STAR PATRIKARO N ki wajah se. DESH ki SHAAN ,aur MAAN badhti hai. Keep it up.
Hi, miss intellectual. I want to say that after passing out my boards, I learned about the ahom dynasty,chola dynasty Kushan empire and all that but never in school. What I did learn was the glamorous Mughals from nearly class 4 to 9. Regarding Hindu emperors like Ashoka, we had only 1 chapter that to was reduced and made no appearance in the later courses. Talking about the south indian empire ,the chapters were reduced to such extent that we only had to study 2 to 3 pages.Our books have shown muhammad as a god guy then explain about aisha , the battles he fought and slave trade .
Ahom , chola ,maurya , these dynasty never being thought to us .
Try CISCE board
actually they are too intellectual to read the books and understand the difference
@@pratikrai7642 Arab ka dalal bc
The more recent the civilisation is, the more sources you have, the easier the historians can verify its validity and the more confident the ministry of education would be about, including it in history books, that is if we follow logic but i doubt they followsuch reasoning tbh. Mughals were the rulers of Indian before the Brits. Are u telling me it makes sense to mention ancient local civilisation like Indus Valley will help Indian students understand the India they live in today? Learning about Ancient Egyptian for example is fun but would learning about a 7000 year old civilisation help anybody understand Egyptian society today, not really.
Beta :Taj mahal kisne banvaya?
Papa: sahjaha ne.
Beta: nahi papa Taj mahal to Adani ne banvaya tha Aap toh anti national ho 😂
The coming times are really scary but I still wanna keep hoping that things will get better and we will move forward to a better India.
I read the Indian Express front page coverage of NCERT in a single breath and was baffled.
As always great video guys. Love you Manisha ma'am.
Your content is great ma'am, as always. Hats off to you and your team.
😂😂😂😂
All is good. Criticizing the ruling government is productive. But I think you guys should also cover hate speeches given by AMIM and other politics parties.
one part of media tells us about the north pole, and the other part shows what's about the south pole. So much polarization. I am avoiding everything.
A nationa that forgets its past has no future.
Winston Churchill
If we forget our we are bound to make those mistakes again and again.... The history will repeat itself without us even knowing about it.
@arwind sawant I don't know why this Hindu-Muslim thing pops up everywhere but anyways, I am not saying that students should not know about Indian rulers or warriors... I am happy as well that they all will get to study about them, all I want to say is that if you want to educate students about our history let them know about Mughals as well... They too are a part of our history.
@arwind sawant fine... You don't want to know about mughals don't study about them... But tell me one thing if we will totally forgot about them what will you say if someone asked you about haldighati war or should we just totally forgot about that as well.... Who made this red fort on which your pm hoists the national flag.... Oh some guy made it.. We don't know about him at all.
Like I don't get it.... Why do people who are barely interested in studying history just come up and be like... YoU aRe stUdYinG tHe WrOng hiStoY..... Bro you never really took history seriously until some leader came up and said whatever you all are studying is wrong.
Right. Talk about Hindu genocide
*You are right, Goverment should not remove Mughals from the syllabus, infact we should teach students about how crual were thr Mughals, how Mughals destroyed India, Indian temples, how Mughal tried to destroy Indian culture, how Mughal killed many innocent people, we should also teach of how Aurangzeb killed his own father for Power, how brutality he killed Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj, these all things should be put infront of all students, so that they learn from history.*
See no ruler was great. No hindu no Muslim .. all rulers has been cruel with some exceptions.. Those who rule has power to do whatever they please to do. Removing particular syllabus of history also shows the wrong use of power. You are telling about Aurangzeb killed his father so did Ashoka killed his relatives to be in power no! So the point is Removing history syllabus is not a bone of contention. The real issue is Government is disturbing the communal harmony. And we .. The Common man.. Will pay for the repercussions of this. Communal harmony is a basic necessity for any countries development.
The Chapter on partition has also been removed from NCERT History book part III
46' - 47' election result which paved the way for ppartition ------mmosslim constituency ( Bombay Province 100% vote goes to M. League , Madras Province 100% , Bengal 95% , Assam 91% , Orissa 100% , Central Province 93% ...so on so on ....)
Excellent journalism
Indian children deserve to have better education and not title education, let them interpret what they study.
I am not so sure if the ones making those cuts were offended by Mughals or not, but the one who penned down this script sure seems pissed by those cuts, also have to commend the swift use of interrogatives to stay in the white 😄
I think a part of mathematics can be taken out of syllabus. Algebra got the name from a person who wrote about it - Al Jabr 😂
I have seen many comments pointing out the insufficient information regarding maratha, Gupta and other kings inour textbooks. However this is not a real reason to try to destroy the truth from our books. Everything should be included, everything should be contextualised. Stop demonizing or ignoring any people❤
Gupta Empire is the golden era of India 🙌🌹
But just stop glorification of mughals thats all. Shouldn't be like 'The Great Mughals' or 'Mughal empire'.
Alf of the teachers who used to teach this social studies /history books in our schools back in 90s were basically preparing for some exam to grow in their career and teaching history was a temporary job
Great job madam ji ❤.
Just love it❤
Seriously, you guys are amazing.
Love you content and the reality.
The way you guys present the issues is magical and thought provoking.
Keep doing the good work.
(Love you guys) times infinity.
After a while children won't even need to go to school. WhatsCrap Jo hai! InnnDian Express Zindabad
that's why u need to follow ppshyco jjesus example just like him u sud commit ssuicide for the ssins committed by godi media....
History is always a mixture of Dark and light. In NCERT History books both in modern and Medieval many incidents are super highlighted where some other importants characteristics or personalities have got a maximum one para, one liner or one word mention. It is true that Mughals have dark chapters but there contribution in many areas (e.g art and architecture, certain rulers administration) cannot be overlooked. At the same time we must have learned more about Shivaji or Prithviraj, Ahom dynasty. Modern Indian history have only mentioned the name of a few freedom fighters without even minute details where some are not mentioned like Binay Badal Dinesh, Arabinda Ghosh, Khudiram Bose, Matangini Hazra, Desh Bandhu Chttaranjan. There were a dozen reknowned Social reformer of that time but a many are not mentioned (no I am not saying detail, but just the name). My personal feeling after reading Modern History was Netaji is less mentioned when Gandhi ji is considered to be the only person for whom we got our freedom. If Mughals are striked out then many other require changes too.
I am neither in support or in oppose of this video. But one thing I must agree with you -- we do learn every good or bad from our leaders ideologies. Hence alteration of chapters could have been done more carefully and more vigorously of it was intended to happen in such way.
What about Ram Navami violence?
The list of rationalised content Includes deletion of an entire class 12th biology chapter named , environmental issues , I’m wondering what Mughal connection did they arrive at while deleting this chapter .I’m certain the rationalisation committee that ordered such deletion was as educated as our pm .
To use it as political weapon
It might have been done to legitimise the saying, " Ye global warming nhi hui hai, logon ki sehne ki kshamta km ho gayi hai."
@@aviralsharma1174 maybe .. 🥲
u guys are......... just minimize the syallbus as much as possible & in terms of environmental topic u don't need a chapter one or two page is enough ... & for history is concern the mmughals were iinvaders & they brought ( not the first one) one of the most disgusting rreligion of all time.... what iisis did to yazidis the same things mmughals & other iislamic dynasty did to nnatives ( hhindus)...
Yes minimising the syllabus removing RSS ban after Gandhi's death and that Godse was Brahmin hindu extremist, it did decrease a lot of work load of students right. 👍 Don't fool yourself you fool.
Simply superb....like always 👍👍🙏
Great episode as always. Would have been great if you credited the cartoonists explicitly on the screen.
गोदी मीडिया की डिबेट हम आपके चैनल पर भी देखना पसंद नहीं करते मगर यह हमारी मजबूरी है
to kya librandu monologue pasand karte ho????
Weekend is here 🎉
I had read the news about cuts in 2020 but it sounds more disturbing knowing full extent of what is cut out. Its a good thing I have the old books. I'll keep them safe.
Honestly Gandhi getting so much credit for independence is just not good. We all know it was not possible through non-violence to get independence.
In foreign, books apne itihas jayada detail mein batati hai aur sath hi invaders ke bare mein bhi required information deti hai
Par hamare priy Indian liberals ko mughlo aur britishers ke bare me padne me jayada acha lagta hai
My salute to you all liberals 👏 🙌
that was our so called itihaas is.. I think we as Indians should know our past and learn from it. Now, the next time students will go to see the art and architecture in Agra or Delhi, they will be like... 'ye kya hai'?
@@iamshree7652 mene ye nahi kha ki mat padhao , itna padhao jitna require hai
Log apne kisi raja ke bare mein toh dhang se jante hi nahi
I am sure mujhe bhi sabhi ke bare me nahi pata
Par apne ancestors ke ithihas ke bare me ache se janti hu
Bataye bina toh logo ko ajkal date nahi yad rehti toh apne ancestors ka naam hi nahi sunege toh puchenge yeh kon hai
Fir tum bataogi
I am with that mughal chapters shouldn't be removed they should also taught how they looted us
And also about glorious Indian king's achievements
Jodha and Jadu got me there😂
As you people are there, journalism still exist. It gives us pain to see the other side. It's really a grim situation. It can be defined as extremism in journalism.
Thank God my kids won't have to read the biased incomplete history my generation had to. Kudos to the government 👏
Why isn't anyone talking about whyy to learn about the mughals and not other Maratha, Rajputs, Mauryas and other leaders who has actually contributed alot !!! Why to learn about Aurangzeb?? When all he did was destroy everything which came in front of him while expansion all the temples were burnt and Destroyed, killed Chatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj for not changing his religion... Seriously who are you guys supporting ???
A nations calibre can be gauged by it rulers and media
The magnificent calibre our India held was of the Old India...now it's like there is no calibre for our India...
Great job, Manisha and Team! 👍
Thanks for your explanation about indian history
Someone should invent idiotic index, I think our Godi media will be in top of the list.
Even that ;idiotic i dex' will be so false and incorrect. when people like arunab goswami are ,leaders of godi media ...
librandu media is at the top.... godi media needs to do much more to catch up to librandu media.
Add Jihadis
NCERT has full chapter about mughals in class 7 history book but not a chapter on Marathas 😅. Lets talk about this too
This lady is doing selective analysis. And the worst part is that people are praising her in the comments
As a resident of Taiwan I am surprised to find Mahatma Gandhi is not related to the Nehru Gandhi family leading INC
"Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past"
-Orwell in 1984
Pagal baat hai
Our country was such a beautiful place
When bro?
@@subodhoraon7988 before 2014 😢
Absolutely...thank you that you were particular
to use the PAST TENSE...
@@rishabhgautam2723 b4 1948..
Before invasion
WhatsApp university से ली गई डिग्री को मान्यता दिलाने के लिए सरकार द्वारा सराहनीय कदम
Babranama ... source of WhatsApp uni
Thanks for your nice talk which was very enlightening.
Great work 👍👍