A Quiet Place: The Worst On-Screen Apocalypse
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 06. 2024
- Subscribe to help me reach 200k!
In 2018, I think a lot of us were shocked when Jim from the office, yeah, this guy, was making a horror movie called A Quiet Place The premise seemed interesting, he was acting with his real-life Pam, so I was on board, going to see it opening night with managed expectations. What I didn’t expect was the single greatest theater experience I’ve ever had.
0:00 - 2:08 - The Best Theater Experience
2:09 - 7:39 - A Quiet Place
7:40 - 16:02 - A Quiet Place: Part II
16:03 - 20:34 - The Worst (or Best?) Apocalypse
20:35 - 23:40 - The A Quiet Place Cinematic Universe
Become a member of the Channel!
/ @thethriftytypewriter
Join My Discord!
/ discord
Arkham Asylum footage: • Batman Return to Arkha... - Zábava
The babies born into this world may never learn to speak vocally, but they do learn to use language - they'd be signing.
True. Deaf babies even "babble" with their hands before they are able to start signing properly.
god ASL is such a cool language
@@picahudsoniaunflocked5426damn that’s cute af
@@HamzurgerLiterally beat me to it like, OH MY GOD ❤️
@@plusefrie4170 asl isn't the only sign language 😭😭
I’d drop something by accident, say “oh shit” and then fall down trying to pick it up. I’m deader than disco in this world.
Yeah probably not great for clumsy ppl or those with ADHD 😅
Stubbing your toe would just be the worst
@@mickieg1994 I’d stub my toe and one Tom and Jerry scream later, the monsters are ripping me to shreds.
I swear to god, id die in the lamest way possible. I'd make it to day 3 and just hiccup or something the very day I forget to bring my water bottle to the junklands
Disco isn't dead
I'm coping
A Quiet Place is literally impossible to survive
You take every precaution, and boom. You fart while on the toilet from the chili you had earlier.
Goodbye 🤷🏻♀️
LMAOO you aint wrong tho
How many died on the first day cuz they were in the toiled and didn't see the news on time
Just need to build your shelter next to that waterfall.
Imagine shitting and an alien bursts through your wall
Noise pollution is huge issue here on earth, half these aliens would be in pure agony just existing here. The premise is honestly absurd
Silver lining to living in this world would be a relatively quick death unlike being eaten alive by zombies.
Or raped and tortured by a Crossed
Or raped and tortured and enslaved and eaten by the Cannibals of The Road
I agree, I would rather die by what is essentially a lethal "batman fear takedown" from the quiet place monster than be mauled by zombies
Honestly? I think I'd rather be torn limb from limb slowly than being bitch slapped out of material reality. These monsters are incredibly disrespectful.
Even worse, getting eaten alive by a family member 😳😟
That’s because they don’t want to eat you but instead they just want to eliminate any noise possible.
the start of the sequel is very forgivable considering krasinski didn’t want to make a sequel he was very happy with the first being one and done but the movie studio of course, will always try to milk the franchise. so i’m fine with just accepting that they either handled all of them back to back or we just gonna ignore it .
i just saw a trailer for a 3rd one and i kept thinking no way this is a sequel, are they really ripping off a quiet place and nope, its another sequel and a prequel which feels like a slap in the face but also a fun time🤣
like the 1st one was so good on its 1st watch you want to no more, and the little intro in the sequel makes u want more no way the studios could ignore it🤣
I think this will be a universe where i dont mind at having more sequel even if it’s bad. You can do soo much with this
I’d say to that “you should’ve expected that when you left a cliffhanger”, I 100% expected a sequel after finishing the first
@@wyattcole5452 not every director wants to do a sequel. that’s just pushed by studios
Idk if I'm optimistic but it would be cool seeing the quiet place aliens in a world war z type setting (a big city) in the up and coming movie. Like seeing what lengths they would go to catch something such as climbing sky scrapers and jumping just to get a helicopter or plane and other stuff like that.
There is a stark contrast between Cinematic universe and a franchise
True. It's like saying Final Destination is a "Cinematic Universe" instead of a franchise lol
I see what you did there
@@wzwzwzI’m still waiting on that final destination resurgence sequel that they announced like 2 years ago
Yeah, that’s like saying the Purge/Conjuring movies are a cinematic universe
Bro, Thrifty, you need to change your title, got me deleting an entire essay 😂
😂😂😂 I’m sorry I don’t know how else to put it 🤷🏻♂️
@@thethriftytypewriter”why a quiet place is the most terrifying onscreen apocalypse”. or “would be the most miserable onscreen apocalypse”.
if it gets clicks it's a good title
@@ThaliaGeckono it’s a better title as it is. Draws more views, and raises engagement when someone prematurely comments without watching the video and it garners many responses (usually in defense) from other viewers of the channel. Although inadvertently, it’s a genius play.
Oh my god! I've experienced that pain before and i have to say, it's death levels of emotional pain 😱😱😱😱😱 deleting your 15 minute made comment is the worst feeling anyone will get on CZcams
The universe created by A Quiet Place doesn't really need sequels to our protagonists but instead an expansion to the entire world focusing on different characters living this apocalypse with occasional homages to characters appearing in previous films.
Seems like thats what the next film is doing
I really want to see what happened in the big big cities, like would the creatures find you in an apartment??? I also want to see how the creatures react to factories and other places with a lot of noise
@@n4n4sh1_That’s literally what Day One is gonna show
@@viacrucishector1821yeah what about other continents like Europe or Australia where they're not confirmed to be there
@@sonic176yt7who cares
22:45 Bro spends so much time consuming the walking dead media that he said the Everett family intead of Abbott. Lee Everett the goat
He also does it 2 minutes in lmao
He also does it 2 minutes in
Funniest part is how he mentions it 2 minutes in rofl
did anyone else tell you he also did it 2 minutes in
@@illuminaticonfirmed1389 Not sure. Just in case, hey @depa3129 he says it 2 minutes in!
"Incredibly short" - my man that's the normal length of a movie before marvel came along lol
Marvel movies have sort of ruined what is supposed to be a normal movie runtime. 90-100 minutes used to be the standard for most movies, now we all think anything less than two and a half hours is short.
marvel movies didnt invented 2 hour movies
@@cesar6447 They popularised them so much that they became the new norm, though.
Tbh when an episode of a show can be 1hr, I don’t think 1.5hr should be the “normal” movie length. Really 2hr feels best but it really depends on the movie. Doesn’t truly matter what the length is if the movie is good
@@hata6290ok? No one cares what you think. Some movies should be 90 minutes
First I was a bit confused, but now I get what the title really means. It's not saying that the movie franchise itself is horrible, but rather how the apocalypse displayed in the movies is the worst one to live and survive in when compared to other apocalypses which are fairly easier to survive in. You can makes tons of noise if you want in the latter, but you can't make even the slightest sound in the former.
Edit: Dang 1K? Thanks a lot guys!
Honestly I still don't think the world would have fallen at all. Even if the monster armour was somehow made of vibranium or something, the military would surely experiment with sound since that's what the monsters use to hunt.
@@thunderspark1536Sure, but it’s just a movie. Some suspension of disbelief is required. By the way, maybe there were other reasons like - aliens changed, were far more at the beginning, other calamities came in junction, misuse of nukes, etc.
The premise is cool and really thought provoking - what kllls it for me tho is that so much with the worldbuilding just doesn't make sense. I just can't buy that these creatures would be able to overcome the biggest army and the most armed population in the world so easily, when they can be killed by a farmers shotgun to their face.
Sure, they have armour, but we see from the news articles in the house that we knew they were sound based creatures pretty early. If the media was still around when we figured out that, the military likely was still around too. The US army already has soujnd based weaponry used mainly for crowd control today - they'd be blasting every frequency known to man at the creatures withing minutes of figuring out they were sound-only. If the basic equipment on a farm can produce a sound strong enough to stun them completely then they'd be absolutely stomped by the US military.
Also while we're at it - shouldn't these creatures be really susceptible and vulnerable to naturally occuring phenomena like thunderstorms or hurricanes? Those are loud, REALLY loud in fact, nature can easily produce sounds like those that puts any concert to shame. How do the creatures cope with that?
It's details like these and so many more that just breaks my immersion - and what is a shame is that it's one of those settings that the more you think about it, the less sense it makes. A shame because the premise itself is really cool and unique, and the movies themselves are quiet entertaining.
@@IronFreakVI guess we'll have to wait until the prequel movie fully comes out, maybe it goes more into detail of how the military couldn't stop them. Also considering that movie, shows a different countrie, I can only imagine how many of them came to earth worldwide as a whole.
@@LilacSreyaI cannot suspend my disbelief past them not just living by the waterfall. They literally show you in the first movie that you can scream in that place and it won't be heard all of the nonsense with the baby and the soundproof coffin is dumb because you can just live by the waterfall. Wanna play monopoly? Waterfall. Wanna eat pizza rolls? Waterfall. Wanna listen to Weezer? Waterfall. I can't suspend my disbelief past people being so incredibly stupid during that movie. Even if you want to disregard the fact that people would've killed the monsters in seconds, you can't disregard that they knew about the waterfall
Wind chimes and land mines: Allow me to introduce myself
Man I can't believe I didn't think of this
They will hear you carrying the wind chimes
@@nevadamareno3713 probably
@@nevadamareno3713 they are silent if you hold the pegs still right?
Maybe possible to die it with rope. Pull it off and step back.
But I dont know what you would use them for. They can break every trap
Windchimes at the edge of a cliff.
If you look closely during the beginning of the second movie when Evelyn is going up the stairs you see the other two aliens dead behind her
So thry killed them off screen
I though that was obvious
The creature in the water in the first film was more so walking underwater. The water in the basement wasn’t deep like it would be in a marina.
If they can drown how can they survive in space
Doesn't have to be dead. He could be blindly moving across the bottom lost with no sound. They probably just avoid water because it's totally new to them. If they were on an asteroid they would have never encountered liquid water so they avoid the new environment of water
@@ninjahammers bro was struggling really hard to stay up I think it’s more than that and the other one wasn’t like that when encountering water and sound travels better through water
@@full0fpestilence250 It's because the first one was walking along the floor of the basement, not swimming in the water. Whereas the second one couldn't swim and also had no hard surface it could walk against whilst underwater.
My question is why even crawl underwater if you can’t swim at all. Just walk normally. Usually an animal that can’t swim wouldn’t be comfortable in water, even if it was shallow, and definitely wouldn’t want to submerge itself in it.
The biggest problem with the movie is that no one thought that the creatures with hyper sensitive hearing would be susceptible to certain high frequency sounds, makes the whole thing very unbelievable just like most apocalypse movies.
Show Primeval has similiar creatures in last episode of first season and that exactly turn out to be it's biggest weak spot that's used to defeat it.
I've said this before and I'll say it again, if a hearing aid back feeding can send these creeps off, then there's no way in hell they'd survive a mile within fm radio broadcast towers. They can accidentally turn their brains into jelly going into caves, wake up and scare a swarm of bats, congratulations, that's 5k ultrasonic sound emitters going off at once.
I dont think they really had enough time to come up with a solution. People may not have even figured out the creatures have super sensitive hearing, or that that was an exploitable weakness until the moment of their death. They fell all over the place all at once, and just started slaughtering. By the time someone who had the knowledge and resources to build something effective, everyone was probably already dead.
They could easily wipe out an entire military base in minutes, before they even knew what happened.
Seriously.
I think its just a matter of having
A. People to think of it
B. Have those people be able to test that theory
And C.
Have those people be willing to teat that theory
The Asian Jim gag is very funny
wait, Jim is Asian?? wow, I never noticed before!! but I guess that's what I get for trying to watch the video and dig my stapler out of this jello at the same time (multitasking is hard)
It just hurts they keep using my man Cho.
He did enough time in the CBI to deserve better.
"you never get a good look at the creatures"
proceeds to show multiple detailed close-ups of them
I never really got how the creatures dealt with tanks or armored vehicles. No amount of armor will protect the squishy bits from the physical trauma of taking a tank round or rpg to the chest, and there are a lot of those out there.
Sure large weapons can probably kill them. But I think the overall problem is that they invaded across the world, or at least the USA in what we can assume are huge numbers across major population centers all around the same time. How can you defend your cities with tanks and airstrikes without carpet bombing indiscriminately? Social fabric breaks down immediately and the supply lines to fuel, service, and transport those tanks becomes logistically impossible within a matter of hours if you are trying to defend the entire landmass of the USA. The roads are blocked, airbase are overrun, etc. There just isn't enough ability to defend all that land if it were to be overrun like that in a surprise attack that fast.
Best case scenario the military/government of the USA has secured a much smaller quarantined zone and is defending that. Worst case the entire government has collapsed. Entirely possible when so much breaks down all within a few hours across major population centers.
Military vehicles are thirsty, and need regular maintenance and resupply. Plus, they're designed to take on other military vehicles. A discarding sabot round would for sure obliterate one of the creatures but once they're close (and they're fast), cannon is useless. A gunship could hose a few down but it has to land eventually, and the creatures would be there waiting. Those things wouldn't have to physically defeat combat armour anyway, logistics would be the weak spot and they would absolutely wreak havoc on support elements. Wouldn't take long before everything is grounded or abandoned. Militaries aren't laid out to tackle threats like this, there'd be chaos so quickly.
@@0lionheartyes and no. If a bunch of those hit earth we would have either been either many fob across the USA and some high recruitment rates maybe if they consider it a world wide threat without knowing aliens would be on there first. Yes they would commit enough casualties but eventually with all the surveillance we would eventually find a way. You forget we literally develop stealth fighters that travel up to mach 2-3 with complexed engines. With all the recon and surveillance with drones etc they would eventually find out their weakness is sound but the aliens could be in the millions so it's hard to say but many weapons would harm these things just because of brute force that attacks flesh directly unfortunately there will still be many dead humans trying to kill them with their own guns so eh.
@@0lionheartbut those engines are also loud as fuck. Itd probably kill the damn things by just being on
@@jeffbrownme2 we have these things called drones that fly in the sky and shoot big missiles very accurately, no need for tanks, they are outdated even in our world today, look at Ukraine lol
It took this video for me to realize that Cillian Murphy is Emmett in the 2nd movie. That’s crazy
Same
Everyone usually calls him Oppenheimer because of that movie recently.
@@King-lb4pi well I’ve only seen him from clips on CZcams from Peaky Blinders, the tv series. But he looks very different with a beard and an American accent, almost didn’t recognize him
@@aedenflores3947😆lol Well, I do. I knew him from 28 Days Later, this, and Christopher Nolan films before Oppenheimer came around.
@@King-lb4pi I knew he’s worked with Nolan before Oppenheimer, I just haven’t seen those films yet, I’m working my way through my watch list of movies I haven’t seen yet. But it’s good to know he’s got an extensive filmography. Cillian is a very excellent performer.
Traveling to the pharmacy, they looked for drugs. Since the boy is sick, there is a good chance they are looking for an anti-epileptic. It's only a matter of time before the drugstore runs out, and Pharmaceuticals are no longer manufactured. It's upsetting, knowing the future of the characters. They take a lot of effort to get you emotionally attached to the characters. So, it's sad to know the end.
They prob survived
What makes you think it was anti-epilepsy meds
Do you mean Antiseptic?!? Not anti epileptic 😂
Anti-epileptic? Just grow weed on the farm, problem solved.
Now you just need to cover up the sound of fat bong rips
An hour and a half is considered short for a movie? That used to be the standard length for a feature film. I really miss those days.
I feel like it still is lol. Idk what hes talking about
@@cngotham4111I don’t know man most movies nowadays are 2 hours plus
@@nhandinh7404for sure I haven’t seen a movie in a minute that was even close to being under 1hr 45
@@nhandinh7404that’s not necessarily a good thing
@@lukethelegend9705 How? There's nothing bad about longer movies. I like that they've gotten longer.
If it's good, you get more of it. If you're wanting to do something else, you pause it. If it's bad, you turn it off.
All you need for survival in a quiet place is some speakers set up by the government so they can kill the aliens.
Which would have been discovered almost immediately. It's a great concept but I think given the creatures weaknesses it never would have gone to full apocalypse levels. And as I mentioned elsewhere concussion grenades are pretty common and someone would have used one and seen the effect and a myriad of clever tactics would result
@@daviddiggens8841My theory is that everything happened so quickly that everyone just got overwhelmed before they could mount a proper response.
@@aaroncabatingan5238
👌🏾
@@aaroncabatingan5238 too bad its entirely implausible for at attack of that scale to happen without any warning.
@@joeyfridays cinemasins has ruined you 😂
I went to watch this move when it came out and happened to have bronchitis at the same time. I had no idea what the movie was about before it started. Once it did I slowly realized in horror that the movie was gonna be silent, and heavily regretted my decision. It was absolute torture trying not to cough too much. If anything however, I quickly realized I would not survive this movie at all if I was as sick as I was in their universe. Movie didn’t make sense at all.
You got that 4D experience lol
Who goes out to the movies while sick, noisily sick at that
@@nindybear946 I was always out and studying 24/7 with no choice, and never home bc I was in nursing school at the time. I went after a day at the library with friends bc I hadn’t had any break in forever. I figured if anything came up there were loud parts to cough, but I wasn’t that lucky. That being said I’m stupidly highly conscious of not bothering others so I did a great job with little coughing and learned I can push myself through heavy discomfort ✨
What do you mean it didn’t make sense? Yeah, if you had bronchitis and coughed in that universe you’d probably just die. The good thing is the risk of getting sick would be considerably lessened due to there being pretty much no one to catch illness from. Anyone who coughs too much is probably going to die, simple as that
@@lukethelegend9705 Do you think illness only comes from people? Why do you think so many plants have antifungal and antibacterial properties? Germs are ubiquitous
Love these movies and this was the first Apocalypse that I would actually opt for death over trying to live. Also love the office reference at the start with “jim”😂😂
Hyped for Day 1 🙌🏻🙌🏻
I don't think a horde of creatures will hunt you down from the other side of the world for dropping something or farting. There were probably many times the family could've made as much noise as they wanted to and nothing would happen because the nearest creature is 50 miles away and cant hear you.
The thing is you don't know where the nearest creature is, it could be 50 miles away or sneaking around 50ft from your house so in the end you have to be cautious and try to mitigate your sounds all the time.
I honestly think the thing that would do a lot of people in is the mental strain.
I think a ton of people would die due to their stomach making sounds when they're hungry
Im so deprived of new cloverfield movies that I convinced my mind that A Quiet Place is a part of the colververse🙂
I remember seeing A Quiet Place in the theater. I felt like I couldnt breathe. I mean I dont even think I made a sound above a deep breath. The death of Lee is on my top 10 list of most heartbreaking film deaths
They filmed some of the movie in my home town it was so cool 😭😭 then the opening scenes were shot about 40 min from me in my aunt/uncle’s town…we auditioned to be backgrounds but we didn’t get it…still such a cool memory!
cool, what was the audition process like? did you have to act?
Little Falls? If so I was there too! My cousin got to run into John and Emily at a store. I went to the college nearby and my friend who was a film major got hired on as a temp PA but didn’t have a car so I got to drive him and some of the other crew around set! John and Emily I think paid for tickets for locals to see the film too I’m pretty sure!
I think the thing with the monsters not being able to swim was explained already. They are like hippos.
Hippos can't actually swim, they just hold their breath and bounce off the bottom of the lake or river.
I've heard theories that places like Japan or the Philippines may actually be completely fine during the movie's apocalypse, and that's how they'd explain humanity being able to continue.
Basically the whole of Oceania would be completely fine unless the sound whores land there
My fiance doesn't enjoy horror at all, he finds it predictable and boring and he always complains about characters making dumb decisions.😂
He took one "for the team" following me along to the cinema to watch this piece. And hallelujah- afterwards, he actually said this movie "wasn't that bad" and he actually had enjoyed himself. From him, thats a huge compliment for a movie in this genre.
well, its not a horror movie, so thats that
@@Exel3nce Ehm, yeah, it is. Look it up.
@@missautumn764 I wouldn't consider this as a horror movie.
your husband sounds like a tool. horror movies rock
@@Exel3nceI think it’s a different type/style of horror - if anything horror-thriller.
I'm in tears that you called that man 'Digimon'. 😹😹😹
The story logic just doesn't make a lot of sense with the creatures. If they are constantly attacking what makes noise what about birds? Rain? Wind? Thunder? Leaves on trees? Insects like crickets, mosquitoes, grasshoppers? The ocean is constantly making noise... Wouldn't the creatures be constantly hearing noises everywhere and would be nonstop reacting to things?
Animal noises. And yes, we see creatures getting attacked.
…yes
Ppl are coping cuz they like the movie
Poor things :
What happens when you use a dog whistle on your dog. The longer you keep that tone going, the less interested the dog becomes. Once these creatures realize certain elements of this world are loud AND unsilencable, they'd behave like any other wild animal does towards a threat or stimuli they can't directly interact with: avoidance
The first thing that occurred to me with these monsters is like
Why couldn't you just make some loud sounds, lure all the monsters into some spot
then nuke it
Couldn't have possibly taken more than like an hour for the government to come up with that one, like come on, bulletproof doesn't mean indestructible, get creative with it
Obviously a dumb nitpick, but it's where my brain goes with apocalypses
I would agree too, but these guys have been riding asteroids for god knows how long. They are definitely accustomed to extreme climates and conditions. Sure the explosion might burn them but considering the were in the vacuum of space of an uncertain amount of time exposed to insane amount of radiation, a nuke would probably not be too damaging. Furthermore, while the heat of entering the atmosphere of earth isn’t as hot as a nuke, they have been exposed to extreme cold and heat for years. Maybe we’re thinking too hard here and trying to make sense of a fictional story but that’s my “armchair scientist” take.
@@happymikasa7226it's definitely a "suspend your disbelief" thing. Shockwaves from high explosives liquefy the soft tissue inside of animals they pass through if the shockwave is large enough. No amount of armor would really stop it if you turned on some thermal imaging and dropped some bombs on groups of the monsters.
The problem is that they dropped all over the country, so the only safe places would be off the coast and stuff. So you'd be needing to retake a really huge landmass with very limited resources while you figured out what to do.
Once the vulnerability frequency was discovered, parachuting a couple speakers into a minefield, or parking artillery on the deck of a ship off the coast and pre sighting them, would let you draw a bunch of monsters in and then pulverize their insides.
I think it could be fun to have an action horror military movie about retaking the US from the aliens, but idk if it'd do well with mainstream audiences.
These monsters don't have enought hearing range. You could get all the monsters from New York into the center of New York, but getting all monsters from say California or Germany into a single spot would be quite difficult. So the amount of nukes you'd need to drop to eliminate even half of these creatures would already create enought radiation to kill everything on the planet
I just gotta say this right now... If that kid was dumb enough to set off a noisy toy like that, there's no way he would have survived up until that point, he would have been one of the first to die long before the family ever established that they needed to stay silent.
It's shown that they don't keep batteries in the toys, but Reagan snuck him some batteries for that toy
@@eviltoad746 No... They take away the toy after the kid finds it in the store. Reagan took the batteries OUT of the toy, and then gave the toy to the kid... But the kid was stupid and went back for the batteries and put them back in the toy, leading to his death.
The other 2 writers are a duo (Beckandwoods) & they’re from my hometown! They just recently opened up a movie theater with a rooftop & bar in December! Cant wait to see the prequel there
Probably a hot take but I despise the logic/survival in this film. The story bits are fine but there are SOOOOO many instances of plot armor and stupidity that it boils my brain. Any instances of the characters being stupid and by every means should die from the setting presented are pretty common.
1) where do they get all their sand to walk through? With wind, rain, and erosion your paths would be gone within days. Without constant maintenance and supply of sand, the paths would literally be gone within a week
2) why wasn't there a parent in front and back at the beginning with the kids in the middle? Basic survival pack mentality.
3) how do they farm? Farming is incredibly noisy between tilling, storage, tools, and everything else involved.
4) WHY DON'T THEY LIVE BY THE WATER FALL? It is considered a safe haven so build some basic structures and set up camp there. Also you can have the baby there. Done.
I have more but that's what I can remember from seeing the film years ago. I can forgive some if the story is good, but my lord the amount of inconsistency and survival logic irks me.
I think farming can actually be pretty quiet if you do EVERYTHING by hand (including making holes). I've worked out in fields when younger and have planted some fields by hand (I'm speaking acres 😭😭), it's awful and painful but possible. Tho, I think theres an issue when it comes to watering the plants. Water can be pretty loud and heavy. How are they transporting TONS of water quietly? For us, even tho we planted by hand, machines did the watering...
I think I may kinda explain why they chose to not live at the waterfall, not a good logic, but a logic that'd be realistic for some people, the kids needs to learn that they need to stay quiet, and living at the Waterfall will make them not learn that skill. Again, still not good logic, but logic you'd probably see in real life if this happened.
Also: that fu*king nail in the stairs!!!! So stupid. I'm not a fan of the original and won't be wasting my time on anything related after it.
The biggest plot hole is how the aliens survived in the first place. The American military would easily destroy these beasts. Shit, the sound of a bird going Mach speed would probably explode their freaking heads. Premise is ridiculous, earth is loud asf
Plus sonic weapons have existed for a while for riot control.
My dude said playing a loud noise was out of the box thinking lol.
As opposed to discovered day one... Yeah lol
I think he means the usage of a high frequency noise
It wasn't a really loud noise, it was a certain frequency sound
Media literacy, ffs
Ive always loved the concept of a series that starts out as dark horror and slowly becomes more and more hopeful until it eventually becomes something like a badass action movie or something. Just the idea of a series slowly changing genres due to actual in-universe events changing the situation is so cool to me, so I really hope thats the angle they take with the future of the series
If you're aware of the SCP Foundation, SCP 1730 is exactly this concept. Most of the document is describing the horrific nature of this unnatural location and the people trapped in it, and then at the end it takes a sharp turn into an action movie
@infernyxfire4774 reminds me of the idea that if hell really existed, would man not first start as prey, but once again adapt, develop, and begin to hunt and conquer hell itself, as man does.
With humans going to hell as they die, would humans not eventually overrun hell and become it's apex predator and dominator?
People rarely combine the idea of hell with the idea that humans are incredibly badass world conquering apex predators. The closest we've gotten to this is DOOM and Dantes inferno.
Give me a movie or series about humanity conquering hell and showing the devil how terrifying mankind is.
I'm gonna quote spy kids here. "Do you wonder if god lives in heaven because he too fears what he's created?".
Great video! I would take being in TWD apocalypse in a heartbeat over this one. This has to be the hardest to survive in the most miserable to have to live in. Very hyped for a quiet place day one!
i mean, it'd take so much less effort to kill one of these things over a horde of zombies. can't swim? can't fly? attracted to sounds? i could kill hundreds with a lakeside cliff and a wind chime.
The apocalypse in NieR replicant is way worse than either of these proposed apocalypses.
@@comyuse9103 Good luck getting to that point without knowing how to survive them though.
The dangerous part about them is that you don't understand them until it's too late. A simple mistake like thinking they can see, could lead you to trying to run away, which would get you dead faster than standing still
The reason the protagonists knew their abilities, is because they had to watch everyone around them make mistakes and die until they understood.
Think just seeing my dog getting killed by these creatures, she barks a lot, would be enough for me to call it quitz
If your dog is the only reason you’re living you have a couple years max. Why not find something else to live for?
@@DarkLxzarus what are you talking about?? 😭
@@dasanidani She was like her dog getting killed would be enough for her to end it all. I’m saying if your dog is the reason you’re living then you have a couple years max because dogs don’t live that long.
@@DarkLxzarusi think you missed the point, a dog dying of natural causes does not have the same impact as watching your dog get killed by another creature.
@@hanniballecter7561 Yeah, but no matter how they died they’re still dead. It might be a bit more impactful but natural causes would be impactful because you know they’re going to die and can’t do anything about it.
I actually think this apocalypse, while initially devastating would be handled by militaries very quickly as people would likely form the hypothesis that high pitched sound frequencies would overload the creatures senses, that or super high decibel sounds at close range. I’d imagine tanks rolling around with speakers blasting while other vehicles take the creatures out one-by-one. Like these creatures definitely don’t have a numbers advantage. Idk I just feel like the creatures are made out to be way more difficult to deal with than they are
then you add up how many of the fuckers there are, how fast they are, you have to get a head shot while it's janking around and how strong they are. would be surprised if the military which would assemble all forces wouldn't get demolished. the thing would bulldoze through a tank. much less 1000 of them in one spot alone.
@@SobBaget602 High-pitched sounds from simple studio speakers have been shown in the movie to immobilize these creatures, how are they gonna go anywhere whilst in screeching pain from high pitched sounds like the movie shows. They become so still that its easy to line up a shot on them. Also you saw how one of those creatures was only able to barely topple a bus in the movie, tanks are much heavier, wider, and low to the ground than busses.
@@shizz3907 No, The little girl has been broadcasting her specific frequency, no other loud sound has hurt them but her. also you don't nee to topple a tank, just tear off the cannon, or block the barrel, or just take out the treads. or just sit there and wail on it, since nothing can hurt them anyway.
@@SobBaget602nothing has been shown that suggests that this is the only sound that can hurt them, it's a hearing based creature, sounds will have an effect on it, regardless of any hand waving you want to try and pull, loud sounds so damage, high frequencies do damage. Her hearing aid is not special, it would produce any genetic high frequency sound, especially with the fact that it's not using any specific sound and amplifying it, it's just a feedback loop.
And you wouldn't even need a high frequency to hurt them, they have super sensitive hearing, loud sounds would be incredibly effective at stunning or even deafening these creatures, loud sounds can hurt and even destroy our hearing, there is no reason why it wouldn't work with these creatures.
We literally have humvees that can throw out hyper sound and high pitched anti riot weapon.
My theater has powered reclining seats... Right during one of the more intense sequences, i had to use the restroom.. i tried so hard to hold it but had to go. Putting that seat back up and having the leather squeaking while everyone stared daggers at me...😳😳😳😣
My favorite theater experiences were the first film, and Cloverfield. The latter film really worked well on the big screen with a full pounding sound system.
Fun fact: The train scene in Quiet Place 2 was actually filmed in my home town on an actual abandoned train, so I have some real ties to this franchise which is why I have a real love/fear relationship with it
Im so glad i went to the cinema watching the first movie. The only part i felt reliefe was on the waterfall scene. I felt i could actually breath
During snow, noone can go outside
I wouldn’t survive a day, I poop every 5 minutes
You'll need a dirt toilet and hope they have an underdeveloped sense of smell
I think you have larger problems than not surviving a “maybe” apocalypse homie ;-;
U should get that checked out buddy
lol
I love your channel man. Every time I see you post I know I will be entertained and you will make me think. Keep up the great work!
Your right about the (Quiet Place Apocalypse) being the worst, i mean, it even tops (2011's Blood-C Apocalypse), A Quiet Place makes (World War Z) and (28 Days Later) look like a good world to live in, which is insanity considering their immense difficulty in surviving, The Walking Dead would be the least dangerous apocalyptic world in my opinion
World War Z is actually livable considering the book is a mockumentary about survivors living in a settlement and how they learned to deal with the zombies
Haven't seen these yet but i think ill get them both on dvd, never had the urge to watch these until now.
just dont expect anything great. the first one started great and only got dumber, while the 2nd one....well, eh
why buy on dvd when you can just watch online?
@@dariusdafigga because I pay once and I have a hard copy forever, plus if there's ever a shtf situation I have solar I can run a DVD player I can't make the Internet happen.
@@mortem-tyrannis yeah true, I just honestly get surprised when I hear people talk about buying DVDs nowadays
@@dariusdafigga it would be Blu-ray but I don't have a player, I try to live without a lot of tech and luxury. A simple life I guess.
this is a great video! i love these movies soo much, i went in to the first one by myself and it was so much fun to see in theatres. i cant wait for the next movie!
forever a core memory was watching this after hours in a theater during my first time being high 😂. solid movie!
Whoever decided to include that nail scene deserves to be fired.
Also, I find it very hard to believe that the military would struggle to take out even one of these creatures, but meanwhile this random family discovers how to use a hearing aid to mess them up... Like, they operate on SOUND you'd think that it would be pretty obvious that loud sounds could be weaponized against them.
A bunch of armored killing machine aliens from outer space: "Meh"
A single iron nail: "Wtf, dude?! This is the scariest thing in this movie"
You do realize they found out on accident right? Plus that's assuming they even know the monsters weakness, and if they aren't already dead just from setting it up
@@spencerman07the films established that people knew that they operated on sound, they had newspapers setting up that detail, so people knew well before hand.
It's like if monsters only came out in the dark, people knew they only came out in the dark, but no one thought to see if light hurts them.
@@dragonheart967 Wasn't that after humanity was already nearly destroyed?
@@spencerman07 the newspapers or my hypothetical? The newspapers would imply that there was enough infrastructure for production and distribution, all incredibly noisy, so it implies that the population, least in the places that weren't hit yet, were informed and had some time to prepare.
main thing i remember about this movie is seeing it in theatre the week i got my glasses, forgetting my glasses at home, and then theatre hopping after a quiet place was over into isle of dogs and enjoying it much more
Years later and you still can't convince me they didn't WANT that kid from the beginning dead. What did they think was gonna happen eventually, leaving the youngest to walk by himself at the back of the line?? 😅 Yeah, they mourned afterwards, but they sure as hell weren't trying that hard to keep that kid safe.
You're becoming my up and coming favorite youtuber! Love these videos. Keep going bro! ❤
For me, A Quiet Place is a type of scenario that does not work in an apocalyptic setting, for multiple reasons. First of all, in real life these monsters would be incredibly easy to defeat, just play a loud Metallica concert and bait them into a stadium filled with explosives. I will never buy them as a serious threat. Second, because the characters have to stay quiet all the time, you can't really make a grand story filled with tons of dialogue and character drama, epic setpieces etc, so why bother with the whole Apocalypse thing? This movie should take place is some remote location, like an island, an underground lab/bunker/cave (where there's way less sound, so it would be way scarier) or in like the XIXth century, so the military would be unable to attack them from the sky. Make it a small story, make it ambigious what happened to the rest of the world. For me, the whole Apocalypse thing is just wasted potential.
I think the fact that everything happened so fast is the reason they were a threat. These aliens suddenly fell from the sky, seemingly all over the place, all at once, and immediately began slaughtering everything that made a noise. Setting up a trap and luring them to it assumes you survived the initial slaughter. If they actually fell all over the planet all at once, i could easily see most of the population wiped out in a matter of days. Those who survived the first day or two would still have to be incredibly careful while they are even setting up the trap in the first place. Plus, how do people even know a trap like that would work. From the average persons perspective, its just a bunch of aliens indiscriminately slaughtering people. It would take time, and direct observation of the creatures behavior for longer than the quick glimpse you see while its killing everyone around you.
They're weaknesses aren't loud sounds, otherwise one would've fallen just from the sound of a shotgun blast
Just say you want an action movie and go on.
I think what's great about THIS apocalypse that i can't really say for all other apocalypses, is that it's ine where i WANT to see more perspectives from random characters.
A quiet place has always been such an interesting look into the apocalypse genre for me as somebody who lives on a tiny farm with a deaf younger sibling it always stood out as being a movie almost about my family and definitely for us showing much of how my family may end up dealing with such a scenario by hiring so much closer to home then many other stories do
There were only 3 Death Angels around their area, so when the movie pans over to the monitors it’s 2 different pov’s of the last remaining 2 DA’s, not 4 separate ones
I have never seen a single episode of The Office. Neither version. Yet Krasinski's final scene leaves me OBLITERATED! So it has nothing to do with The Office. Dude just nailed it 🤣
The trailer for Quiet Place Day One is truly terrifying cause there’s so many monsters in such a loud city. The monsters are literally going on whole kill streaks to unlock some advanced UAVs.
Your talk about the theatre experience of this movie is so funny to me because me and a couple buddies decided to go see this movie one day and the room was completely empty aside from us, and we were screwing around with one another basically the whole time
I saw this movie in an empty theater. Just me and three teenage girls on the other end of my row. They were incredibly talkative and made the movie so much better
I assume this is extreme sarcasm but if you mean from them reacting in fear, fair
A post apocalyptic story about a man named Lee Everett protecting his loved ones from literal monsters ultimately sacrificing himself for his little girl. This is basically telltales walking dead game lol
bird box : you cant see
a quite place : you cant talk
??? : you cant hear
??? : you cant feel / touch
??? : you cant smell
An apocalypse movie about a virus that makes you deaf would be interesting.
@@ThyFloorestFloorAlternatively an apocalypse about a threat you have to actively avoid hearing
@@abdallahhakeem5185so, a false hydra?
@@Vankodek Eyy true, would be much more interesting than the instant kill variants of Bird Box and A Quiet Place
???: you cant taste
It keeps getting sequels because people are so intrigued by the premise. I honestly can’t belive it’s never been done before. I mean, there’s been zombies that are attracted to sound for decades at this point, but for that to be the main point of how these creatures hunt is just so interesting. People are tired of zombies they’ve been so over saturated in movies since the 2000’s era, & any sort of apocalypse that people can insert themselves into and go “would I survive” gets people talking and interested. People have been wanting to see the Day 1 of this apocalypse since the first film, so I feel like we would’ve always got this prequel regardless of anything that happened.
I had to watch this review after seeing the trailer for the new quiet place movie coming out, can't wait to hear your thoughts on that when it releases!
“True and through” and “quote on quote” is giving bone apple tea vibes. 😂
Thrifty not gunna lie you had me fucked up with that title for a second 😭😭 had to watch for a minute before I commented
I mean waiting to actually see what a video is about tends to be better than commenting with your first gut reaction in general
When I first watched this film, I was actually never scared, give or take a couple of jumpscares. The reason being, in my eyes, the monster wasn't scary. I wasn't scared by the monsters/aliens, and once I figured out they hunted by sound, which was fairly quickly, I began getting annoyed at the characters, always saying 'why don't they use a high pitched noise.'
This wasn't the filmmakers fault, as the nightmares I had of this type of creature had already run its course for me. I grew up watching the British show, Primeval. And anyone who's watched that knows of the Future Predators, animals evolved from ape and bat DNA to become the ultimate predator. Those things were terrifying. They were fast, agile, and any noise you made, they could detect, even your heartbeat, but their weakness as well as a way to detect them was high pitched noises. I had been fearing these creatures for a decade before A Quiet Place was released, and that's why I wasn't scared of the monsters in this film.
love to hear your thoughts on a wide range of topics
Did anyone else notice how in the 1st movie the monsters seem to be able to swim in water without an issue but yet in Pt2 they were literally drowning in water.lol I’ve always wondered about that
If you mean in the basement flooding scene the waters waist deep and the monster isn’t really swimming it’s wading through the water but in the ocean/lakes the weight of the monster or its lack of buoyancy made it begin sinking
@@Brvmley Thank you for kindly explaining!. I thought maybe that was just an overlooked writing error.
@@ashleykathleen85 yeah no problem, it still could be a writing error, that’s just how I chose to rationalize it
It's also worth noting that it's one thing to jump into the water when you know it, and falling into water you don't know is there. Remember, they're blind!
@@AlyssMa7rin ahh good point!! In the 1st movie the way it just went down under water in the basement gave me the impression those things had special aquatic abilities and then in part 2 they immediately drowned lol I’m like wait I thought they were ok with water 💧
To be lore accurate we shouldn’t even be talking so “🤫”
Completely agree with the theater experience being super fun and unique, it felt like everyone was extra invested lest they get surprised and make a bunch of noise 😂
8:33 it’s so small, but what I loved about the flashback sequence as a whole is how much they made it look like the town from the opening of the first film, despite filming it in a completely different town. It’s cool to see the contrast between the busyness of the town in part 2’s opening verses the town in part 1’s opening.
I know they can use headphones, but if I couldn’t listen to my vinyl records, loud and proud, I would not want to live.
00:18 " identity theft is not a joke Thrifty! Millions of families suffer every year"..😂😂
something about hearing the dead of the night round change perfectly captures how internet culture blends so seamlessly
I personally loved both movies and looking forward to the next one. 😊
When you talked about the water ya i thought that to
the point about snoring got me! I snore, i guess I'm out !
I haven't seen anything for the prequel, but you keep showing the poster and I am *terrified* for that cat.
I watched them back to back a few weeks ago and i loved them.
I don’t think this apocalypse is loseable we got sound weapons like the LRAD and the ps2 loading screen if the military wasn’t off screened I’m sure we could win this one
Worst apocalypse? Try Threads. And that one's probably really just over the horizon for us.
I know this is weird but this review had me crying because it was the last movie I watch with my mother before I had to walk away from her completely. Those were the last good moments we shared , one that she could care less of but we watched all of this movie togther
9:06 holy shit, the monster hiting the car synced with the music was so good
See this video essay was great until i finally got a better look at the picture of Lupita and Joseph and THEY HAVE A CAT and now im terrified how this poor kitty is going to get offed for purring. 😿
I don't think we're ever going to get a quiet place movie that's not 10/10
Careful there. I said the same of the conjuring 😔😔
I legit paused the video because I hadn't seen the second movie yet, i just got finished and it was great. I hope the next movies are just as good because I know they'd make for some killer theater experiences
I can suspend disbelief if the characters are well-acted, the emotional stakes are well-presented, and the overall direction is this good.
The Road is the worst apocalypse you could live in
Metro 2033 has entered the chat.
@@watchmehope6560 read or watch the road, it’s not really even close lol. Plus Metro is a game
14:04 bruh that’s shallow water compared to a lake.. ofc it’s gonna seem like an “OlYmPiC lEvEl oF sWiMmInG..”
I think the point is that the way it slipped into the water implied that the creature was very comfortable in it.
A creature so comfortable with going under the water like that probably knows how to swim.
The issue I have is that somehow no one else figured out that the creatures with very sensitive hearing wouldn’t like loud noises
I was just happy Part 2 had Cillian in it. Was totally surprised and happy when he showed up. That man just elevates every actor around him.
This movie got so much hype. I finally watched it 2 weeks ago and thought it stunk.
I could defeat these monsters in one afternoon. Lure them with a sound trap. Loud noise attracts them, spray them in gasoline, light on fire, end of movie.
Military somewhere would've definitely tried sound frequencies, but I'm cool with them all just being wiped out too fast. You could also argue they were terrified to try sound as a weapon.
If they had enough time to group up & figure it out. Seems things went downhill very quickly
Great video!
Hearing you say "The ending is great" for the 2nd film hurt me a little. I actually shouted at the screen to get it over with. It was so slow. Made me so angry. The boy trying to act tough was just too much for me to handle.