Sanjaya Baru Exclusive |"Who Wants 370 Majority? Not even BJP Leaders"|Barkha Dutt LIVE From Mumbai
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 15. 05. 2024
- Join us as Barkha Dutt engages in a conversation with Sanjaya Baru, a political commentator and analyst, discussing his recent article in the Indian Express titled "Who Wants a 370 Majority? Not Even BJP Leaders," published on April 29th.
#sanjayabaru #loksabhaelections2024 #pmmodi
Become A Mojo Story Member Nowđ
/ @mojostory
Welcome to Mojo Story, where storytelling meets truth-telling in its purest form. Led by renowned journalist Barkha Dutt, we're dedicated to bringing you narratives that transcend time and format.
From succinct 60-word snippets to immersive videos spanning up to 60 minutes, we explore the spectrum of human experiences and current events through a lens that prioritizes authenticity and integrity. In a world divided by polarization, we stand firm as a beacon of non-partisanship, refusing to be swayed by agendas or affiliations.
Here, you'll find content that goes beyond the noise, beyond the rhetoric, and beyond the confines of bias. We're neither 'Chamcha' nor 'Morcha'-we're advocates for the truth, champions of #PeopleFirst storytelling.
Join us on this journey as we navigate the complexities of our world with curiosity, compassion, and an unwavering commitment to the facts. Subscribe now and become part of a community that values truth above all else. Welcome to a space where every story matters, and where the voices of the unheard are amplified.
Subscribe to us for more updates:
Follow us on Twitter:
/ themojostory
Like us on Facebook:
/ themojostory
Instagram:
/ mojostory.in
Disclaimer: The views of guests who appear on Mojo Story, as well as the views of interviewees or speeches by public figures or those in the news, are their personal opinions. At no point do they reflect the views of the organization.
I donât understand what problem Sanjay Baru have. Let BJP win or lose it would be peopleâs decision not Sanjay Baruâs.
he just wants attention we all know modi is coming
What an absolutely absurd opinion; you perform you get voted or voted back. If INC is destroyed from its high of 415 seats, it is only because of extremely poor performance / governance. Modi coming back with higher majority and from all states is testament to the delivery by this govt. Nothing Baru said made sense or rang true. Just a rant of someone made irrelevant
he is a leech ..now leeches dont get access to mantries and pmo he is just butthurt
steal if you cannot win chandigarh model. scare and grab if you cannot win surat model. harass and grab if you cannot win Maharashtra model. break and grab if you cannot win mp model.
@@ravi-it3vj there is no justification for the mayor election fiasco but donât blame the BJP for the hapless and poor-performing opposition, an unholy alliance of opportunists desperately trying to stay relevant. They cldnt find a common face, a common voice or a common agenda to take to the people beyond defeating the BJP. The less I speak abt INC and its decimation, the better.
âââthe irony is the opposition did perform and win in Chandigarh , and here you are denying and falsifying it YET AGAIN. BJP IS #OVER PARTY, dear friend, the sooner you accept it, the better off you'll be. Today's INC is not the INC of 2014. Most ndians don't have another decade to spare on temple constructions, we are running out of life, not just time, and don't blame this on anything but BJP'S PERFORMANCE DEFICITS AND THE GOLDEN OPPORTUNITIES IT WASTED.
#BYE BYE BJP
ââ@@gshankarnarayan762DON'T LIE. SC said opposition united and WON FAIR AND SQUARE in Chandigarh, BJP councillor tampered results, therefore the results were overturned by SC. My God, you BJP APOLOGISTS ARE LIARS OF THE FIRST ORDER, DOES IT HELP YOU TO LEAD A PEACEFUL LIFE?
Baru is jobless and frustrated
He is also unemployed Like pappuđ
Yeah you guys think he had only a job at the prime minister's office but he was a well known economist, professor of economics at University of Hyderabad and editor of well known business magazine the "Business Standard", just because he is saying the truth you guys are calling him frustrated đ€
This person writes a biography saying PM is silent and now says too much power with PM.
He must have been angling for a post in the PMO which he was not offered so his frustration
His argument for not having a strong PM is utterly ridiculous.
Barkha, can't you invite someone who is not biased.... Sanjay Baru is frustratingly biased against Mr Modi ...
Given that Barkha herself is a prejudiced creature, only birds of her feather flock together in Mojo.
But so is Barkha! She is being true to form. This is her hoping that if she amplifies this hope during the elections, maybe the people will make it come true.
But unlikely Baru and Barkha get their wish
Nonsence ..he wants policy paralysis..
What is wrong in having a strong prime minister Mr. Baru. We do not want a Man Mohan 2.
Nehru never groomed a future PM though he was in control for almost 17 years.He could have selected a leader when he touched 70. An totally anti modi view
Burning for this fellow , that Modi is goingvto be PM for third time... use burnol
He admits he is not on field, and he is sitting at home and thinks he has found something great. Ideal mind sometimes is a fools paradise.
Modi is grooming younger leaders, which baru is missing...
The guys like shivaj chauhan, vasundhara, khatter, have had their time, so allow the younger guns to come forward..
Modiji is a aspirational individual ..He set high targets for himself, his people and his country.. Those with low aspiration have a different mindset..Example : Nehru gave up the UN Permanent Member Seat to China, FREE OF CHARGE, calling the country "BIG BROTHER"
Aspirations or only me my myself ?
@@Maiazaadhoonthatâs your opinion and left to your self
@@drlgkrishna yea itâs my opinion đ
Sanjay Baru, Your comments sound bitter. A person of your stature and a good author must give constructive criticism of the government. Your criticism of Modi is shrouded in elements of your own unmaking. Modi will win or lose on his own merits as perceived by the voters. Why donât you write a book on what makes Modi a successful politician and statesman. Hoping in doing so you will find a balm to heal yourself. With love and regards.
And how may I ask is PM Modi's track record as PM make him a "successful" stestman on any index? His accomplishments are restricted to being popular with the electorate, not necessarily because of development delivery.
One leftist (opportunist) taking interview of another leftist (opportunist).
Hope Sanjay Baru reads all the comments and gets his analysis correct.
With due respects to Sanjay Baru sir, Modi is from RSS, he can be objective, but will be detached and can give up without any hesitation without 2nd thought which non RSS person can never understand, though I am not connected to RSS, I have 1st hand experience with RSS, and many people can fit to Modi"s shoe, very quickly, I am sure Bharka will recall this message some day
He wants a PM who can be instructed only by A lady and the Children of that lady and the PM patted at the back for obeying the family with these guys dictating the PM who must be in their cabinet. What a Nonsense of an argument
That's not his argument. The present PM's style is not delivering, so it has to be adjusted. Modi ji won't change now at his age, so someone else must come.
He does not talk about the work done by modi during the past decade. There is too much negativity. People have benefitted from the development. Bjp.may lose power in the future but it happens to all parties.
đ What "development"? BJP was elected because of lack of good competitors, not because of it's own performance record.
BJP has failed on every metric. The scoreboard is 0000000. The opposition has now strengthened and outdone it.
Like they say, in order to escape a hungry bear, you don't have to be the fastest runner, just faster than the slowest one i. e. BJP
#BYE BYE BJP
Where is the public interest in this argument?
Baru... I am from kerala.... Auto rikshaw driver.... Baru you are giving authority of certain area to a particular person.. Only because they are part of certain political parti..... Modi deliver governance...
There is a tendency among english speaking elite that the 2019 mandate was all about pulwama.
Though I am a Modi supporter, I actually agree with Baru and fear for BJP post Modi era. Except for Yogi and Hemanta, no state leader has emerged.
Why not?
Fadnavis.....tejasvi Surya.....annamalai......
@@kannaiah7693 none of them are currently CMs. Unfortunately Fadnavis got himself de promoted.
@@kargreat anyways..let's support modi ji now..Time will show another leader..
@@kannaiah7693 I will always vote for BJP, I declare that publicly!
Baru compares Indira / Rajiv with Modi... however there's a major difference.. Modi doesn't have the lust for power that the Gandhis had...he's here to work and serve people..the RSS culture
Yes. Modi is totally different from Congress leaders.
đ€Łđ€Łđ€Ł Great material
Sanjay Baru made a lot of money by writing a book, lambasting former PM and his boss, Manmohan Singh ji, for taking orders from Sonia Gandhi to run his government. Now he feels sad and depressed as why PM Modi ji does not have the same flaws.
From whom was Baru taking his orders? Sonia Gandhi or Manmohan Singh?
From me.
@@rijzone No wonder!!!!!!!!!!!!
19:00
Leaders MPs & MLAs don't bring people to the booth, but ground last mile political worker.
And who do you think he is doing it for, Modi.
This lady is not popular any more.
Baru wants PM out so that he can get something outside of his homeđđ...Poor guy has been sitting at home for too longđąđąđąđ
That should also go for all powerful leaders like Mamata, KCR, Jagan, Lalu, Maya, Stalin, Nitish, Naveen et el. Why single out Modi. Let's accept indian politics has always been like this.
True. Indira Gandhi threw away Up's Chief Minister Bahuguna because he was gaining more popularity.
Seems Sanjays mental abilities r reducing at a very fast pace ????
Sanjaya Baru is not even listening to F.A. Minister S. Jaishankar who has been deplomate all his life, who is happy to be working with NAMO. EVERYONE is happily doing their job as ministers.
Let them hate as long as they follow. Maggie Thacher.
Frustration of a person out of power & limelight.
This gentleman was economics profess0r at hyderabad central university he left many phd students in between the thesis and went to delhi to exonomic times he was not a commited teacher
Mr Baru ,You are in touch with and dealing with 20% of special interest group of people. Our Maharaja deals with 80% of the citizens of which 50% are Hindutva Sanatani Hindu rock solid behind their Maharaja. Rok sake to rok le !
Baru wants to be in limelight. Sorry, no chance.
Yeh lifelong sarkari babus that too of Congress and UPA coalition era will always think only like a sarkari babus. Modi is way ahead of their thinking
How much ever you cry Mr Modi will win minimum 370 seats
A frustrated Baru whose last true job was defending a rubber stamps is also giving an opinion nowđđđ
When all the fake narrativeâs have dumped by public đ
Sanjay Baru makes a good point. Granted many may want Modi to be weakened. But how is it in fact going to be achieved? As they say, hope is not the same as a plan.
It's such a ridiculous argument, no logic at all. Please interview someone who makes sense, irrespective of their view for or against the current government. Please go to West Bengal and see what dictatorship is actually.
Guys common I am reading many of you criticizing Mr.Baru - but honestly do you think one man can do everything for this big country? Modi has really made every other minister a rubber stamp minister. This is not good for a country of this size. During Vajpayee era we had many great leaders in his cabinet. Today except Amit Shah everyone else are a big zero.
Study about Asian Values debate by Singapore PM Lee Kwan and others.
@@ArabianPocso I read his book "From third world to first". I know how he transformed Singapore in 30 years. But Singapore is a city state with hardly 5 million population in 734 Sq KM land area. Don`t compare with India which has 1.40 billion population with 32 lacs Sq KM land area. We are a too complex country for 1 leader to understand and fix all the problems. Look at his Land Reforms bill, Demonitization, Covid handling, Farm bills & Labour Reforms. In all of these things he failed even though he has absolute majority.
@@rameshsamineni4805 ahh the typical big and small country argument !!! Its not just Singapore, Taiwan, Malaysia, South Korea also took same perspective- the asian values perspective. Even China. China didnât develop due to communism. But because of dictatorship and capitalism..
@@rameshsamineni4805 just because you read a book of his doesnât mean you understand what you have to understand. Google âthe asian values debateâ.
No. No rubber stamps. They work on their own but under certain policy with loyalty and accountability.
Think ! The fellow has received some George Soros fundsđ
Because of your bad ideas and advice Manmohan Sing lost his respect.
Why more scam asked by one reporter. Manmohan replied simply because of Coalition compulsion.
This guy is clueless and jobless...
What a stupid argument made by Baro.
Bakha always brings these sore losers to her interview so she can feel a ray of hope that Modi will lose. This is why her Congress party is dead. She is in deep pain. ALWAYS
We need more Sanjay Baru's in the country. Hope what he says happens. Great. Would love to meet him.
Baru didnât quite get the style of working of Modi. While local leaders are free to rise within their own space or state, when it comes to national elections, it has to be PM leading from the front otherwise the general public gets confused as has happened with opposition alliance.
Sanjay baru Saab is having lutyens mindset. He doesn't understand à€à€Ÿà€°à€€.
Who the hell are you pushing your wishful thinking?
Even he cant understand what he is saying... so confused..... đđđđ
Meanwhile Barkha Dutt.... Are bhai kehna kya chahte ho......
Sanjay Baru expected a bigger reward from BJP after Accidental PM. Now, he looks frustrated, obviously.
Weak prime minister(Manmohan Singh) we saw what economical can do with UPA rule. No better roads, railways and airports. No public health insurance and private employment growth during UPA. Better to have PM Modi and BJP next 10 years.
Height of jealousy ..we have all seen UPA 2 government which put India backwards under a weak prime minister unable to take decisions.. Modi is far far better than PMs
Looks like Baru is high on desi daaru... He should mix some Burnol to his daaru and drink it to reduce the heartburn...
While I agree philosophically to Baruâs views, Italian Sonia misused her office of MP with MMS being the weak PMwith no respect.
Most pointless discussion ever!
He doesn't understand the BASIC difference between Congress and BJP - Congress is a leader (family) based party, BJP is a Cadre based party.
Mr. Baru, in 2009, could you have imagined a Modi phenomenon?? Same way, after Modi, there will be someone else.
Don't you understand the simple fact of political parties being organic entities, they change and alter over time, negative or positive. Different time, different PARTY CHARACTER.
Congress has not been same over time, neither has BJP.
SPEAKING AT THIS POINT, BJP IS LIKE A CORPORATE UNDER MODI, CONGRESS IS CADRE BASED
#BYE BYE BJP
And to answer your question, several honest Indian iberals had imagined the Modi phenomenon, look at articles and reports from that period. Several public figures had anticipated PM Modi's cult rise to power
Let them hate as long as they fear. NERO
Absurd debate
Mr Smart Ass ! Did u know when Rajeev won over 400 seats his vote % was lower than current two rounds average !!!
There was thinking that barkha dutt has changed but no " you cannot teach an old new tricks "
A country or a society getting a strong leader is a very rare phenomena and when it gets it, should be utilising it to the maximum upliftment. A country will always have multiple choices of weak leaders. Of course every aspect will have its own pros and cons.
Seems to look like ,Some uncle sitting in a corner finding faults at everything.
Uncle ji watch some movies and webseries and try to chill.
It's not necessary for u to comment at everything.
This joker was advisor of Maun Mohan Singh đ€Łđ€Łđ€Łđ€Ąđ€Ąđ€Ą
He is comparing Narsimha Rao era with Modi era completely ignoring the role of Social Media. Not a smart analysis. It's only his own pain and frustration.
First yogendra yadav now this joker. These people disappear after results.
It's amazing 166 comments and only 155 likesđ đ says it all
'i dont like him so no one likes him, hence my opponent will surely lose'
What a rational argument
Absurd opinion... In India PM can't make decision if he is weak. BJP needs 400+
Baruâs anti Modi and BJP is evident- his closeness to a few journalists and bureaucrats doesnât mean that his views are sacrosanct.Baru is desperately trying to justify his views
Baru is letting his anti-Modi prejudices take control of his brain & tongue as well. He worked with a weak, namby-pamby PM, who had no courage to even open his mouth, and he had MMS's ear and even felt himself in control. He knows that Modi would have made him as a chaprasi, hence this diatribe.
Lol đ correct if Baru goes to BJP in will make a chaprasi.. Baru Ji I hope you are getting to know the correct data from social media, that who public wants pappu or Modi Ji. We want Modi Ji Vote For BJP vote for Modi Ji. Barka Ji I hope all Baru's lies are exposed here what lies he talks. Modi Ji ki Jai ho..Vote for Modi Ji..
Each and every argument by any Modi hater begins and ends with personal glory. Personal glory for chief ministers, personal glory for gandhi family, personal glory for family run parties... Not even one argument they make takes into account what's good for the nation. That's why they lose, and that's why Modi wins.
What about Jyothi Basu, Jayalalitha, Karunanidhi and now Mamata enjoying multiple terms without any internal challenge.
This country does not like anything consistently. Mr Baru is replica of that.
Hmhm.... Lets correct Mr baru, Mrs indra gandhi which was a powerful leader don't hv Amit shah & RSS backing + Modi ji was a small karyakarta so he knows the pulse of the party & understand politics much better. When political psephologists stop thinking from thr Modi ji & Mr Shah starts thinking đ
24:05 Hello?? Article 370 was abrogated under this government only.
O dear! I can hear him no more.
Barks Ji please pass on this message to him Instead of criticizing Modi Govt which is against the people verdict let him spend time and correct the opposition
There is no convincing strategy by the opposition so Baru Garu should apply for the post of a secretary to opposition and let him give a Gyan
One big element of Modiâs personality and governance is to deliver surprises. He may for all one knows give way for a successor once he reaches 75 years.
Both are frustrated
Better watch republic tv arnab goswami debate.. Baru wont be able to answer one question of arnab goswami.
Alerts this lady is very dangerous.
Baru wants BJP to argue and fight and break down so that his Pappu can come to power and he can be in circulation.
Ab ye kabar bichhu kaun h đ
In my opinion sweet spot for Cong I would be 13 seats
Perhaps the Constitution should be amended to give, in order to prevent concentration of power in a single individual, a PM or a CM not more than two terms. Will our netas glued to their chair agree for such a reform. I doubt.đ
Since when has Baru lost his sails?
Reeking of bias!!!!!
Lol. Comes from a guy who was an advisor to a PM who was taking orders from Sonia.
Sanjay comments is pathetic and unfounded.He has no locus standi anymore .Chamchagiri is gone
Rajiv Gandhi got 400+ when he was a political novice. Modi isn't one. He earned his position. He learnt a lot on his way to the top. Political savvy.
Rajiv Gandhi was going by his coterie's advice. On Shah Bano, Babari Masjid gate opening, etc. Modi thinks through everything by himself applying his vast experience.
Farm Laws will be brought back by Modi when he gets 400 seats.
Indira Gandhi pulled off Pokhran nuclear test and breaking of Pakistan into two precisely because she was powerful. She was more powerful than the army chief too, and thus India remained a democracy.
Rajiv Gandhi had powerful ministers. V. P.. Singh himself was his finance minister. Look where that got him.
BJP ministers are comfortable with a powerful Prime Minister. They are performing excellently too under Modi. Just look at Nithin Gadkari, for example. Look at S Jaishankar, who is a career diplomat brought in by the Prime Minister himself. That has worked great for India.
If a weak man would galvanize the party cadre to work hard and bring out voters to the poll booth, why isn't that happening in the case of the Congress.
Powerful regional satraps are a great thing to have? Like Sharad Pawar and Mamata Banerjee? Sanjaya Baru might wish Shivraj Singh Chouhan had broken away similarly and formed a regional party of his own, but BJP leaders don't behave in such manner.
The BJP cadre, the RSS cadre isn't like the Congress. They have a multi-decadal, a Civilizational project going. They aren't just after power for power's sake like the Congressis. They have an ideology, a higher call, a zeal to put Bharath at the top. The BJP cadre won't stop working zealously towards their goal any time soon.
Sanjaya Baru is so wrong. His whole thesis is so wrong.
I think he knows it too. He just wrote stuff to be in the limelight for a while. He very well knows people will shred his arguments to pieces. Still, he wrote this. He just wants to be talked about.
What a waste.
Barkha ma'am, autocratic leadership, centralized power is not separate from the fact of shoddy governance. These two factors are inter-dependent.
1. Sanjay is a smart sickular. Instead of saying ''Ayega to Modi Hi but with a much fewer seats'', he is saying who wants 400+ when 270+ will do as well!!! He adds BJP walahs in his list!!! 2. Modi is the supreme leader and will remain so as long as he is around. No one can come closer to him even after next 5 years. And no one minds it too, even if Sanjay wants to believe otherwise. He need not offer unasked for and unwanted advise to BJP either!! 3. Of course, during Modi 3.0, such talks will be a daily fare in the media, as there would be nothing else to do to bring or show down Modi 3.0 !! 4. Unfortunately for Sanjay, Congress treats him with contempt and where else he will go? May be he is getting old now and his thoughts reflect this!!! Also, both Barkha and Sanjay are in the same boat; they are in wilderness and are looking forward to good old days!!! 5. Be careful. To take care of low turnout mainly from middle class voters, Modi will introduce online voting by 2029. After all, if we do all our financial transactions online, then why not voting online? at least optional
I feel sorry for his disconnect
He did not say anything what Rajnath will do if he got more power but he just feel he should get it
Datt madam is very hopeful that BJP gets not above 270. She seems gleefully enthusiastic discussing this. She will be savouring this till the day of counting of votes. đđđ.
This man is giving wrong analogy. Because so far no one in BJp becomes president just based on birth or family. Modi doesnât have family member in politics. Naturally, there will be other person to lead.
In case of congress, Rahul, priyanka, Robert vadra and their son- in this order.
If there is dissatisfaction within the BJP on Modiâs leadership who is capable of staging a coup against King Modiđ?
What a joke of an opinion from the obviously frustrated Sanjsy Baru - this guy was in the PMO when files were sent from PMO to Sonia Gandhi who had no official position in the office.
And heâs talking about concentration of power? Has he totally lost it?
Barkha - even you didnât ask him about that or give him that analogy? But I guess you failed at your job long back!