BEFORE YOU BUY - Red Wing 875 vs 1907
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 07. 2024
- Use this link: www.shopify.com/roseanvil to start building your own business today! Thanks again to Shopify.
Rose Anvil 3 days 30% off Black Friday sale email list sign up here: forms.gle/oqPQAy91C7YfkLSMA
Buy here to support the channel::
875 - bit.ly/3J1THrH
1907 - bit.ly/43HdINE
VIDEOS MENTIONED:
Moctober 22/23 videos - • Why People Are OBSESSE...
Everything you need to know about Moc Toe boots - • Moc Toe Boots - Everyt...
Alden 405 Indy Boot Review (Cut In Half) - • Why the Indiana Jones ...
Unboxing Alden Indy Boot - • Giving $900 Alden Indy...
Red Wing Iron Ranger Traction Tread Resole (ASMR) - • [ASMR] Upgrading the R...
Red Wing Iron Ranger Traction Tread (Cut In Half) - • Why People Are Pissed ...
Kino Library: Iron Worker Video - • 1960s, 1970s Chicago, ...
ROSE ANVIL LINKS:
CZcams (Rose Anvil 2) - / @roseanvil2
WEBSITE - roseanvil.com/collections
INSTAGRAM - / rose_anvil
PATREON - / roseanvil
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 Intro
2:22 History of Red Wings Moc toe
3:35 Leather details
4:27 Snakebite test
5:30 Inside the boots
6:02 Outsole details
7:00 Construction differences
8:25 Cut in half
9:18 Analysis and Comparison
10:38 Are they worth the money
#redwings #redwingshoes #redwingheritage #redwingboots - Jak na to + styl
Get a high quality wallet, belt or MORE in the Rose Anvil shop here - bit.ly/44jXLNu
I actually own both model boots, 1907 in size 11D and 875 in size 10E2. From day one, the 1907 was much easier to break in than the 875 and the 1907 feels way more comfortable with the cushioned insole. Regardless of the differences, I enjoy wearing both boots equally. So for those people with wide feet, you definitely will need to purchase different sized boots in order for your feet to feel comfortable in them.
I have the 875 they have them in wide.
So the 875’s come with no insole? Just the leather?
@@NAdamO-xt4ht watch the vid he explains it
When I got my first job in an industrial setting I went and got a pair of 1907's because I wanted a boot that would last and would be able to get resoled, 2 years later I got the resole and they're still the most comfortable boot I own.
Found a decet pairof 1907's at my local thrift storefor$20 today! I'm going to clean them up and wear them this weekend for my girlfriends birthday!
I'll be here to say it. Keep the videos long. I love when you take your time to explain everything
Love my 875 EE's. No break-in needed whatsoever.
40 years ago I had Irish Setter moc toes that took a month to break in but when that was accomplished , they fit perfectly.
Thanks for your post and assessment of Redwings which I agree with whole heartedly!
i really appreciate you making this video and all other videos that i have seen. i was looking into buying the 1907s and this helped a lot on my decision. again thank you for the videos and keep the boots coming
Hell yeah. Moctober is never over
Great breakdown. I do think it possible that the Norwegian ridge (not quite a welt) serves like a fin, or a ring of lifeboats. It lifts above the water, fighting off flooding with sheer style and attitude.
Lol yes brother 🤣
Awesome that you made this video. I was in between both of these and decided on the 1907s since they felt wider and a tad more of my style. Thanks for breaking them down. I didn't know that it had a "fake" storm welt. Oh well.
I have had my 1907s for about three years now, wear them regularly and can say I'm quite pleased with them. I have three other pairs of Red Wing Moc Toes, but not the 875, oddly enough (navy, black and Slate Muleskinner). Can't beat the quality, not too bad to break in and they always look great. I might shy away from the 875 given they're narrower since my foot is on the wide side of D width. Great video as always!
I bought the 8138 model a few weeks back and wear them almost daily. It was my first pair of dressy/casual boots and I just purchased the 1907 since I really wanted that style/color originally. Excited to own both pairs and wear the hell out of them over the years. I wear a 10 and in both boots I got a size 9E2 and they fit perfect. I have a narrow foot and heel.
I started off with the 1907 then added the 875 as a second pair. I still own the 1907. The extra room just works better for my feet. I wear them without the added leather insole. I bought the 8883 after getting rid of the 875 and other than the Concrete Rough & Tough taking longer to break in they're now just as comfortable as the 1907.
Awesome videos. Thanks for chopping these boots in half to let us know which brands are skimping out on quality and which brands making them right.
I bought my 1907s first about a year ago and I absolutely love them. The most comfortable boot I have. I just got a pair of 875s a few days ago and still breaking them in. I put the 1907s through hell and I wouldn’t trade them for anything.
Well I need to look at that welt when I get home. I was told exactly that, that it helped with water protection. And I was told that it's a little roomier. But 4 years later I still love them.
Third wearing of the 1907’s. Each wearing the boot has gotten more comfortable (easy break-in). The support is great. Thanks for cutting these boots in half. The information gained gave me confidence to make the investment.
Red Wing's 2440 boot would be a great addition to the channel. They're a good blend of work and heritage from what I can tell.
I have a set of Red Wing 213 boots from 2012 that I love. They're an oxblood colored 875 last with pink neoprene soles. They have held up just dandy over the past decade.
Love watching your videos and don’t mind if they’re long. Fun to watch.
Love the context between the two! Definitely want a Moctober board that spans years, though - need to line up 1907 vs 875 vs Whites, etc. for a true ranking (so long as the Perry's and 1907s are still sold).
Another great and honest video, keep them coming!
Thanks, Weston! It was worth every word!
Great video Rose Anvil! Thank you!
I'm actually thinking of getting a pair of 1907s in the next couple of weeks, so this was invaluable. Also, I think Red Wing makes an 8876 which is basically an 875 with Copper Rough and Tough leather.
I own both, and really am liking the structured appearance of the 875. The 1907 just seem to be getting floppier and floppier. I enjoy the classic rigidity of my 875!
Bought mine in 2019 still , going strong and so comfortable.
Thank you for comparison. It needed to happen !
Perfect comparison!!! Thank you so much for making this one for everyone trying to learn the difference between 23 and 45 last. The Norwegian "like" welt has been a mystery from the start, but I think they at least partially added it to make the profile of the toe box appear to be lower profile.
Your videos are great, don’t worry about the length of them. Sometimes good honest information takes a few extra minutes to disseminate.
This was 12 minutes long but eh I did not mind. Love listening to your "ramblings" in the morning with my cup of coffee. Again great informative video!
Great comparison!
I have the 1907 and I really like the color over the 875, plus you get leather laces too, that's my biggest difference between the two.
Man your jackets always look spectacular
Great timing on video. I just picked up my first 1907 boots last week. I already owned the blacksmith RW boots and found the 1907 to be significantly more comfortable these first few days.
Are both models the same size?
@@matttherrien9608 the 1907 felt wider when testing both and the video confirms that I wasn’t crazy.
@@eddiet2729 I'll get myself a pair and tell myself I'm as cool as Ryan Gosling.😎😂🇨🇦
Thank you. Great job as usual.
I put about 8 years of wear into a pair of RW 1907s before upgrading to some Nick’s travelers. The first thing I thought was that the new pair of 1907’s is absolutely unrecognizable to the pair that I have in the bottom of my closet!
I got mine on Amazon, and was intending to get the oro but ordered the 1907 accidentally, which was good because i have a wide foot and I love them and wear them to work daily.
Great video!! I own the 1907, a beautiful boot, maybe the nicest I've ever owned(?) I love the copper rough and tough leather. Tip: If you do get these, break in without the insole, wear your foot into the leather footbed + break in the leather upper. Then, 1-2 months later, put in the leather insole. Initially a tough break in, but now I really like them. I do not wear these on the jobsite, though-- too nice. ... I purchased the 875 for my GF, who wears it all around plus on the jobsite-- a great boot as well. As in the video, I think the 875 last fits a touch thinner than the 1907. In the 1907 I can wear a 12D, in the 875 I wear a 12E. Nice products.
Bought a pair of 1907 about a month ago. Im a GC and wear red wings virtually every day. Usually either the 1907 or the work chelsea. Sofar really liking both.
I want to say that in the 5 and a half years I've owned my 1907s, these have definitely been the best boots I've owned. I love that they come with the insole (on my 2nd pair of insoles now) and I definitely like the snuge feel with it in. I've had them re-soled 2 years ago with the Vibram heavy lug *as seek on the ice breaker. Didn't add anything for comfort but you get used to it. I mainly wanted the sole for the grip and longevity. I've also had the heal pocket repaired by Redwing, it's just a 1-1.5mm price of black leather they glue and stitch into the rear of the boot. My opinion they are definitely worth the money.
I just thought it was a different color leather and I even tried these on, with my really wide feet no wonder the 1907 was what fit me better
I absolutely love my 1907s. Was wearing them daily until my Nicks arrived. On my 3rd sole now. Each resole lasts a year and couple months. Highly recommend.
Which nicks you get?
@@taborgreat urban logger
@@mikealley2596 nice!
Just got my 1907 resoled with the vibram lug. Got a steel shank and crazy traction! Way worth the initial purchase
Very impressive. I like the Daily Ride styled leader board.
my first redwings 1975 was a pair of 877 high model(irish setter) lasted 20 years worn down to the midsole - my second redwings 1995 is a pair of 875 short model - resoled 2005 - in 2010 I fixed in new leather insoles - a good brushing every day and lay to dry on the side + Hanwag grease once a month throughout winter season + cedar shoe trees when not in use - so 47 years with the wings :)
From my experience I can say if you have a wide foot go with the 1907. I have an very wide foot but the 1907 in 9.5EE fit perfect. I have had mine for 2 years and they never come off my feet I use them for work I use them for hiking (I’m in south Florida so flat ground wouldn’t recommend for rocky trails as they don’t have tread) I clean them up and wear them casually they are perfect for any occasion. If you are going to buy a pair just know that breaking them in will be a long painful process but when they are good and broken in there is nothing more comfortable.
Another fantastic video 👍🏾👌🏾🤩 I have watched all your stuff on Red Wing and other Moc Toe boots and have finally decided on and purchased the Red Wing 875 Ora Legacy - Beautiful 🥾 🥰😍
Was not too difficult as live in the UK and many of the boots you have reviewed are not easily available here. In any case I think I would have gone for these anyway. - love the quality, leather and colour ❤ Thanks for all the quality content which made the purchase easy 🙏🏾
I own both. They're very similar in so far as they're moc toes, but the difference in the last makes them feel and look like two completely different boots.
I really want some 877s. They’re iconic
I love the look of a reverse welt 👍
I bet a hunting boot series would blow up! Big Views!
Keep up your content brother I love it
Very helpful! Thanks so much!🤘
I own the 877 and the 1907 ( the 1907 was my first pair of redwings), and I surprisingly find that the 877 - which is on the same last as the 875- was easier for me to break in compared to the 1907 which I took the inserts out of at the advice of a redwing employee from a stridewise video. Both are fantastic after being broken in, and these are pretty much the only shoes I wear anymore.
Red Wing may say that the 875s and 877s are built on the last, but the toe boxes are very different.
The 877s have a wider toe box, which similar in appearance to the 1907s.
If 877s and 875s use the same last, then the leather panels that make up the boots are “clicked” differently.
What are the sizes that you use ?? I got the 1907 in 8,5 and I’m trying to figure out my size in the 877 (witch is almost impossible to try in Person in Norway 😅)
The 8,5 1907 fits like a glove with a tough break in , but now I have zero heel lift and it’s super comfy
Awww man, I see ya'll have that new Grant Stone boot, but I really hope ya'll also consider doing their Brass Boot! I'd love to see that one cut in half.
Awesome video, I've just got some 1907 , thanks 🇬🇧🌟
Love both your channels
Can't wait for Mocuary 👏
I’ve been waiting for this video
I have the 875’s. A little tough to break in, but once you do they are so comfortable you won’t want to take them off.
Over the last few years I’ve learned that while synthetic foam is great out of the box all it does is break down over time.
It’s worth it to get the 875/877’s and slowly break them in…
So the 875’s come with no insole? Just the leather?
@@NAdamO-xt4ht yes. They have a Cork midsole and a non removable leather insole that will mold to your foot over time.
@@Tingolicious1 Ah ok, thanks. I have a pair of red wing chukkas with a leather insole and while nice, I couldn’t stand the little slippage it caused while walking
Thanks for this review.
I own both of these, 1907s and the Black 8849s and I also have some of the newer Thorogood 1892s with the 'waterproof' liner . 10.5D for all, and I vastly prefer my 1907s to the 8849s. I have worn the 8849s as my daily driver work boot for about 6 months before needing a resole, and ironically they have stretched out so much from work that the 1907s have a more snug fit. I'd still be rocking my 8849s but I took a chance on a different resole and didn't like the result, maybe I'll have them done again with another RW or a vibram christy. Comparing both RW boots to the Thorogoods they definitely feel more solid than the Thorogoods, but the thorogoods needed ZERO breaking in to feel comfortable. I doubt I'll get much life out of the Thorogoods like I have all of my RW boots, I picked up the thorogoods with a boot voucher from work while I am waiting for a set of Nicks Overlanders to be built.
I also have a set of 10D Iron Rangers, and for my personal foot - the Iron Rangers are EASILY the best fitting boots and most comfortable. I've also had them the longest and it's like giving my feet a hug whenever I put them on.
My feet measure a whisker under an 11 in a Brannock and between a C and a D in width.
As a Red Wing Employee, I’d love to see you cut open our new GoreTex Moc. I want to know the differences with the added liner into the boot. Has become one of my favorite boots in my arsenal!
Which dept u work ? If u work there i assume you will know the boot inside and out
Loved to see the work version, 10875, in comparison
it comes down to trying them on in person as opposed to just purchasing them online..I am planning a trip to Redwing, MN to buy my first pair
I've got my pair of 875s with me still. Three years strong and probably going to need a resole soon.
After watching the video I'm glad I feel better about my decision to go with the 1907's. I got em for a GREAT price, and I have slightly wider feet so the fact they're more roomy is works out. I also much prefer the copper rough and tough to the orange looking oro legacy leather. The toe also doesn't seem to look as bulbous at the tip compared to the 975.
Thanks again for what you do brotherman!
Definitely less clown toe than the 875.
Yeah same. I have the 1907 and when I saw the thumbnail I was like "oh no..." glad I didn't have some late onset buyers remorse.
@@ianturnbow7011 right?! I immediately gravitated to the 1907’s.
@@epierce59 I carried the exact same fear but I really do just like the copper rough and tough that much more that I knew, no matter the results of the video, that I probably made the right choice. I have Iron Rangers too, which I lathered on a little mink oil to help them match my belt better which may sound silly but I’m picky and I like a darker brown. But I think I’m gonna just lightly brush my 1907’s and let them patina naturally to see how that turns out.
Thanks for the comment brotherman.
@@RirtyDascal funny enough, I over conditioned my copper rough and tough iron rangers. Still rock them tho.
I got both, and I love them
I really enjoy your videos. You are the man. My wife doesn't know it but I'm getting the 1907:)
Would love to see a comparison with the 10875 (from the work line rather than heritage). I recently went in to buy a pair and ended up going with the 10875, and I've been quite pleased with my purchase. They had my size in stock, I dig the logo, and they were even a bit cheaper.
I believe they're the same as the 875's, just a different shade of leather and different color eyelets
The 10875 are also ASTM Electrical Hazard and Slip Resistant rated, so you can get that heritage style but actually wear them at work (if your work requires it).
It’s basically the same boot
I am a big fan of the 1907’s I’ve owned 7 pairs of them.
The only down sides I have to say are
In wet conditions they soak up water through the sole.
And if you’re walking rough concrete all day the sole will burn down pretty quickly.
But still I am wearing a pair everyday for work. Construction
In me the classic needs to be half size bigger than 1907. Up front the 1907 is shorter.
Great video!
I've been happy with my 1907s. They came with two sets of laces,... the leather broke easily. I replaced the leather laces with a pair from Nicks, and added a Nick's kiltie. Problem solved. They're great boots for me. I need the extra space because I have really horrible feet. 5 surgeries... They're just right. And I like the color better. Had them over a year, keep them clean, brush them often, and have treated them so a brush brings them right back fine.
I have an E size foot, and went with the 1907 in an EE (Since E is not available). I couldn't even get my foot in the D boot with a pair of bombas on due to the footbed. But so far so good!
I went with the 1907s. I have wide flat feet with fallen arches. The 1907s broke in quickly and are now superbly comfortable. The leather laces are crap, and literally snapped the first time I tried to lace the boots. Thankfully they came with some regular laces which are lasting well. Redwing London sent me replacement laces right away.
Had the same experience with the leather laces. Replaced them and never looked back.
After 15 days of pain, I gave up on my 875s... too narrow a fit for my duck feet... so they went to the Sally Ann. I like the look of the 1907s, But those JK300s - will likely be my next boot!
You didn’t even come close to breaking them in. You have to earn the comfort. You should probably just stick with sneakers.
I've been wearing the 10875's (nearly identical, but their explicitly work boot version) for a year or so now. I'm a big fat bastard with wide feet, so definitely the EE version of the boot and the soles broke in fairly easily. Better, the soles have withstood a year of my standing on them without any problems and are still comfortable. They're not soft, but my feet also feel good at the end of the day. I don't care what color the leather is exactly, so I soak them in leather waterproofer (KG-XTREME) and they are holding up really well so far. Glad I bought them.
Red wing blacksmith would be dope to cut!
@@cincyreds62 where do you live? I’m in Texas and the stores by my area only recently started selling the blacksmith, it’s only available in copper rough and tough but it’s also still online. To my understanding the blacksmith was replacing the Beckman so if it’s already discontinued they must be selling old stock idk?
Keen Cincinnati. They are so comfortable and had such minimal break in but I'm scared it will turn out they are made of used chewing gum and old baseball cards.
Found myself in this predicament last year, it’s probably worth mentioning that the 1907 is arguably better value as it comes with about 50 bucks worth of free accessories in the footbed and the laces. I ended up getting the 877s in the end so all was for nothing, but if I had to choose I’d go 1907
I'd love to see a review on Red Wing Moc Gore-Tex version.
I just realized today that my 1907 had a different welt than the rest of the moc's and figured someone had an explanation. Thank you 😂
I've got my 1907 in 2008 and still love them. Got them resoled about 4 times now. I've just noticed that the actual quality of the sole has been worse. Wears out far too quickly that before. Done my first resole after 3 and a half year and then almost every two years. I live in London so there's always opportunity to wear boots. Just last year I've got my first Iron Rangers and very happy with them too. My collection is growing.
P.S. I also got the suede version and they soo conformable I think I break them in in like a day or two.
Could you please review the Timberland Moc Toe?
Looking forward to Grant Stone Field boots review.
Wedge soles are also a safety factor to prevent heels getting caught on bolts, wires etc.
I’ve always been drawn to the look of the 1907 over the 875 but I don’t really have a reason why. I should just get both
I own 875s, 877s, and 1907s. I feel the 877s are the most comfortable. I wear the 875s for looks. I wear the 1907s as beaters.
To be fair to Red Wing, they do not claim the 1907s have a “Norwegian Welt”, which are double-stitched.
Red Wing advertises the boots as having a “Storm Welt”, which is single stitched.
Yes, the second stitch is decorative. But the boots are Storm Welted.
BTW, the toe box of the 877s are much wider than the 875s. 877s look similar to the 1907s.
I’d love to see you cut apart the Midas x Skolyx moctoe. They look great.
If you don't really care about the colour all that much, then I would suggest the 1907 because you have a better bang for your buck. The leather footbeds (and a pair of leather laces you get in the box) add up to way more than an extra 10 dollars in retail.
That being said, Oro Legacy is only on the 875, and it's what I wanted, so it's what I got.
I have the 1907, 875, and 877. I love all 3 boots but my favorite are the 1907 due to the extra space (width) and the storm-like welt look.
Thank you. I've been trying to decide which moc to get to go along with my Rangers.
@@matttherrien9608 yes, you’re most welcome mate.
If you do go with the 1907, get the rough and though leather. I’ve had my boots for 3 years and they look as if I’ve only worn them for 6 months. They are usually my daily to go boots.
Recently bought the 1907. Mainly for the extra space. I have wider feet so 1907 felt much roomier. I also really like the leather color of the 1907.
Glad to see you do a video on these boots. Great job
Just bought a pair of 1907’s yesterday. Will find out how good they are. I also own 2 pair of style 405 soft toe, would be interested in seeing how the Asian made red wing moc toes are built.
Alden is a comfort thing...Redwings are more work friendly and rugged. If I was working in a grocery store or on my feet in a restaurant, I'd rock the aldens because they pass as dress shoes and support is good, lighter weight....Different utility all together. Redwings would be nice too.
oh the different lacing at 5:41... love my 1907's though
I have the 875 I wear them daily. There very comfortable after the break in
Leather shoes shouldn’t be worn daily. The leather needs time to dry out between wears.
Still love to see some 2406 or 606 Redwings for the mitusa
1907’s are nice they come with what would be $50+ of extras in the 875 and copper rough and tough rough leather which is a patina monster. I use mine for work (nursing) and they are great.
Nursing?? 😂😂
You are definitely right about the 1907 lasts accommodating a wider foot. I tried on the 875's and they were just too narrow, crowding my toes. When I went to an E width on the 875's, the toe box was wide enough, but the heel was pretty loose. I tried on both my normal size and 1/2 size smaller and neither fit well for me. The 1907's in my normal sneaker size fit much better. For a $30 upgrade, the (Red Wing) store replaced the top two sets of eyelets with speed laces, which they did right there in the store. A great upgrade, IMO. I have a pair of Iron Rangers in the same copper rough and tough leather. They are about 90% broken in now and very comfortable. Warning about any non-standard insert on the 1907's - they will squeak like crazy until you break them in. The stock leather inserts are quiet. I'm going to try the talcum power trick and see if the comfort inserts get the silent treatment.
the Parkhurst Niagara would be good as a Mitusa and a Moctober boot.