Do white Irish people have a "privileged status"?
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- "I would emphasise the fact that it was a draft": Arlene Forster, the head of Ireland's national curriculum body, defends a proposal which would teach white Irish and male students that they have a "privileged status." Question by Ben Scallan.
#gript
Support us: gript.ie/membership/
See more at www.gript.ie
Follow our socials:
Facebook: / griptmedia
Twitter: / griptmedia
Instagram: / griptmedia
Patreon: / griptmedia
Our Podcasts: www.gript.ie/podcasts/
#gript
I love when privileged people tell me how privileged I am
Spot on
100%
This sort of ideology is so demeaning to our young Irish children
Making us hate ourselves and our culture makes it much easier for us to allow it to be replaced.
The demonisation of one group or groups and the canonisation of others based on nothing more than characteristics they have no control over.
@@jumblestiltskin1365 well said
2 pieces of truth removed
These disgusting people
Irish people need to get them out of office. These ministers are ashamed to be Irish and absolutely hate the Irish working class.
Remember the French Revolution was captured by the upper middle classes who envied aristocrats and despised the great unwashed.
Jesus never mind the privilege crap ,where did she get that suit ? Looks like she is going to a Caribbean wedding lol
These people sort of look normal but speak Gobble de Gook.
Be good if they could lay eggs or Something Useful?
No one voted them in
@@smythharris2635 Mussolini springs to mind, remember how he ended up.
Get that monster out of government and away from children.
They expected to get away with this blatant slur on 50% of Irish people.
Well done Ben!
We need to call it what it is, she is racist.
they will get away with it because its not there decision its EU orders end of story
What do mean 50%??
I meant the male 50% in particular; however "white Irish privilege" would make it 100%. @@vancouver9928
50%?
Im white Irish and me and my children are facing homelessness whilst refugees are given modular homes built with my tax money.
I must be very privileged
Aren't you the privileged white irish family!! But in all seriousness I'm sorry for what you're going through and hope you're not left homeless!
Praying that you and your children keep a roof over your heads, anyone can become homeless now - whilst refugees enjoy warmth in hotel accommodation and hotel food. What 'privilege' are these people talking about?😢
God bless you and your family🙏🙏🙏🙏
What gets me is you literally get made homeless allow the grifters to move in and do nothing about it sounds pretty cowardly to me.
Just to add some context:
-Lease ends in February and nothing to rent on market
-Earning too much for council house but no where near enough to get a mortgage
-No savings so cant afford the 10% deposit needed for local authority loan or help to buy scheme
-Contacted multiple tds who said they cant help
This country has gone to crap for the working class
To make things worse was on council list for 10 years before wage went over the cap
@@haralamcI'm so disgusted that you are being treated like this, in our 100 yrs out of 800 yrs of English tyranny, people always had a roof even if it was a tenement room, in fact I think people were better off then because the mothers could stay at home and tge fathers brought in a wage later on one salary could pay a mortgage maybe even a car and a little holiday. My how Ireland has fallen under fin gal fin fail and Shinners, useless lazy free loaders🤑🤑🤑🤑
The Irish government is meant to represent Irish people, not stigmatise and oppress them
Indigenous White Irish are rightly premium Irish citizens.
Same as for all Countries native peoples.
Thousands of White Privileged Homeless Hungry Hard Working Class people She must be talking About
You are referring to British there.
I am gobsmacked at the audacity of these people. A lot of us grew up with holes in our shoes. I'm sick of being labelled, shamed and gaslit by these people. The eyes of the world are on Ireland now and this government are being shown up for what they are.
Reasonably good clothes for going to school and immediately when one got home taken off and replaced with short trousers held together with patches so one could carry-on with climbing--- taking short cuts etc
And sometimes saving my runners by trying the laces together and hanging them on my shoulder.
Throwing this in fo a bit of balance ------
And newspapers cut to line your shoes
Agreed. Shame on this horrible eu run Govt
This is how pol pot and other evil commies got started.
Orwells 1984 is alive and in full swing
We have the privilege of paying 50% tax on anything over 40 grand, the privilege of paying to sit on the m50. while the government outbids us on houses for every waster with a sob story
we should have privilege we are in our native land
Much of world history doesn't think so.
@silveriver9 Definitely, these people are suffering with the liberal mind virus. Wishy washy bollox. Do I have white privilege if I moved to Nigeria or Indonesia😂 do I F
@@silveriver9I do 🇮🇪💪
Exactly these woke freaks are infecting Ireland with there crap
Well said.
Using gender and skin colour to measure a persons level of privilege in society *_is_* judging a book by its cover.
This would be like me moving to Dubai and then complaining the people from there have privilege and should check themselves. I've never heard such nonsense. Do we just copy everything going on in America now. So every native Irish person is now a privileged person for living in the place their ancestors are from? This is complete madness.
A homeless Limerick man in London had cold water and bleach thrown over him by one man, while a second man tried to block bystanders from filming and a third man then accused the victim of causing trouble. All three of the men who targeted a harmless Irish man without provocation were black. If that had been the other way around we would be haring about it as a "racist" incident
I saw that. I didn't realise he was Irish, with all the privilege that entails🙄
That's how these people treat white people
He must not have realised he had white Irish male privilege!!
Scumbags abusing the power on the vunerable. Some privilege, McEntee uses the word scumbags, so we can use it, hypocrites.
These traitors pushing this agenda would look you squarely in the eye and tell you he still had white privilege. They hate us.
I guess they consider paying to be invaded is a privilege.
Firstly good work Ben. White Irish privilege? What leftist bs. It still baffles me how people like those are in their positions of power and privilege.
I'm a Scottish unionist, and I could think of many words to describe, white Irish people, but privileged certainly isn't one of them, so what she is saying is that the Irish, should think themselves lucky, that there politicians are , giving the land they fought so hard for away , face it the current crop of politicians , are doing more damage to the emerald isle , than the Brits ever did 🏴✌️
There's not a damn thing wrong with being white
Apparently it's a privilege. Next time a bill comes tru my door I'm bringing it to the post office and showing them my milk white arse, telling them I don't want to pay it, because I'm privileged.... Don't ya know.
Nice one
Shakespeare never thought of that line ---
It’s left wing Marxists implementing the Kalergi plan in western Europe.
Every other race is allowed to be proud but these morons who are in every country don't want you loving your own white kind .Shout from the rooftops ." We love our White race, our culture and our customs and we will never trade then in or change for anyone or any evil ideology "
I'm glad that I chose to be born white. It's a scientifically proven fact that white skin produces way more vitamin d than black skin because it's been demonstrated that low vit d blood levels are positively correlated with poor covid19 outcomes
Home schooling for my kids now, iv had enough of this absolute nonsense from these complete narcissists looking for fake moral points
same
Us too. This is sick stuff
Lots of online resources to support it, it can be done.
So all the white privileged Irish politicians should help the less privileged white Irish people by not pocketing our taxes? Ok, sounds good to me.
Strength is not a privilege, it usually follows overcoming suffering
I'm a white irish person & I can tell you I'm f##king far from privileged, what a shocking statement from a government minister 😡
As a white Irish man, I lost my last 3 jobs to immigrants an I can't get social welfare, you tell me where the white Irish privilege, come on Ireland wake up 🇮🇪💪✝️
Terrible. 2024s elections must see the back of these traitor creeps.
All the factories near me will only hire ukranians because apparently they get some grant for hiring them.
@@steven6979 not many Nationalities would put up with the abuse and many betrayals by their Govt. Irish do!
@@Prodrive1 in fairness we are trying to discuss and reason peacefully but the civilised option is being prohibited.
@@steven6979 7500euro for each immigrant the company gets
Look at their faces, do they actually expect us to swallow this BS
Definitely swallow bs.
I couldn't look at them that long. I was eating.
Afraid so mate ,these bints are every where in the west
Watch them squirm when confronted about their ideological bullshit!
They'll never have to 'squirm' as long as these formless slime merchants are ELECTED or chosen by the corrupt ELECTED.
Demons
Traitor creeps
That smirk says it all. The arrogance of the elites.
Politicians seem to have quite a lot of privilege and have a lot of power over under privileged indigenous Irish people
Who votes for people like these. It’s time to understand the Irish community have always welcomed all people to Ireland. We the Irish people who have travelled the world and settled in many countries have faced and dealt with discrimination in our way by getting on with our lives working, education, being good citizens and won our rights without any laws being forced on indigenous people. Time for the nanny state to take a step back and allow all people to get on with their lives.
Are you aware of how many anti Brexit Brits have acquired Irish citizenship? They lap this government's message up like mother's milk.
Thanks as always to Ben for putting it up to them. White privilege is not something I have. I was a white irish female born in Ireland over 65 years ago and there were very tough times. We were brought up to work hard for what we get....nothing was handed to us for free.
How dare they.
In a film decades ago the late great Barry Fitzgerald (I think it was) covered it with one word----- Traitors and I'll add on ignorance--- we haven't solved the problem up north--- and these simple minded folk want to create a new minority--- one that has the word Jihad as its slogan and that carries with it several interpretations depending on the flavour of the confrontation.
Piece of truth removed
Agreed. How dare they say we are privileged. The Irish suffered horrendous amounts of poverty and colonialism over the centuries. We worked our asses off just to survive. This disgusting Govt must go in 24.
@@RufusToots420 That's real white privilege for you. So O"Gorman sends out invitations around the world to come to Ireland and get Keys to your own home? Meanwhile Irish people are living on the street! They are such idiots.. Well there's no white privilege for the working class in Ireland. Plenty for illegal migrants. Most do not boost the economy as we've discovered.
My father walked to school in his bare feet how dare she
Join and vote for the Irish Freedom Party to put an end to this anti-Irish nonsense.
❤
Amen
Who are there leaders and what do they stand for?
@@robertdennehy7948 they are against irish being second class citizens in their own country. Hermann Kelly and Michael leahy are the two head members search them up and see do they win you over
@@robertdennehy7948dereck blighe Ireland first vote and hes the man
Irish, English, Maths, Geography, Science, French, History etc etc. This is what parents send their children to school to be 'taught'. They don't send them to be indoctrinated by political ideologues masquerading as teachers.
Teachers should be given strict guidelines. Teach academic subjects ONLY. Parents, family, friends and community will take care of all other socialisation skills required. We all know George Orwell's most frightening prediction - that the State would program children to spy on and indict their own parents. The State does not own the minds of our children. Nor does it own Language. In these proposals it seeks ownership of both.
This is getting embarrassing. Whilst Rome burns, she fiddles.
These people are dangerous and deluded, they need to be held accountable for their crimes against the Irish people and locked away for a lenghtly time with zero privileges to boot 🇮🇪✝️🇮🇪
Absolutely. T-Exiled. there the bottomless pit of Traitors. God Bless You and Your's. 🙏🇮🇪🙏
@@carmelhegarty9829Thanks Carmel you too, if I'm not talking to you later have a wonderful and peaceful Christmas, God bless you and yours always my friend 🇮🇪✝️🇮🇪
How easy direct questions expose their corruption and treachery...
Get them out, this is madness.
Time to take our children out of this horrendous system.
The idea that 'White, Irish, Male (or Female)'' has privilege in these current times is the most oxymoron comment (and that is a low bar) if there ever was. Has the Minister walked around the tent cities popping up in Ireland (especially Dublin) has she spoken to the 'White Irish privilege' people in those tents, NO, not a chance, she is utterly risible in any context.
Exactly correct.
Yes no work or money there for them.
They aren’t even Irish talking like that they are globalist a very insult to all that is Irish is what they are!
I don't think I have ever heard such waffle.
It's completely morally wrong to take a person's skin colour in this case "White Irish" and conclude that I or anyone else has a privilege based upon this fact. I would be very concerned what is being thought to our children and it needs to be challenged. They themselves are creating a two tier society based on gender and skin colour. Infact it's them that are the racists.
"Creating," the two-tier society already exists. They see you as superior and themselves as inferior.
They have been brainwashed into hating themselves and now wish to inflict it on the young and impressionable, the scary thing is that they're in positions of power to be able to do so. Reform the education system and rid it of all the insidious guidelines that crept in through consultations with charities and consultancy firms. Even the menus on school dinners have never been so sad. Look at the rubbish they're feeding them these days.
💯
absolutely 100%, it's completely daft and discriminatiory, life isn't fair, it's complete and utter rubbish.
Perfectly put.
Heroic work Ben. Thank you. Legend of a man.
Well done again Ben. What nonsense comes out of their mouths.
An a London born person of Irish Catholic parents I never imagined how disgusted I would be at Ireland's moronic and easily hoodwinked political class. I also never thought I would be so closely aligned to the Ulster Unionist in their struggle against this stupidity in the North. God help Ireland and its young.
Don’t let them off the hook saying they were hoodwinked. No, they took money in exchange for betraying the people they were to serve. 👃
Yes I agree there. @@paddymurphy-oconnor8255
Leo came through the WEF young leaders program....he doesn't work for Ireland.
I'm an Irish catholic living in UK most of my life. I agree with you. Also the Irish government shunted of vulnerable Irish youth to their relatives in Britain. They done it for years. Only the Catholic Church helped these vulnerable youth.
My grandfather fought for the Republic. It appalls me to listen to TDs in the Dáil Éireann discussing white privilege when my forebears died on coffin ships going to the US. @@outoforbit00
Any chance Leo could use his privilege to give us less fortunate 'privileged white people' a dig out ?
Are you kidding, he only cares about India, and that comes from someone who knows him and his family in India, says he has no time for the Irish, he's all about India. for shame on varadkar, hypocrite and traitor to the Irish people and land, a sell out to Europe.
Please don't call him Leo as that only projects a sort of street cred.Call him Vadakar .When your having a bad day call him every explicitve under the sun
Varadaker isn't white, he has wef privilege and aint no peasant getting that
I love being white real irish a passport cant buy my ethnicity 🍀
Free Edmond Burke.
Yes- i come from a very Privileged WHITE Irish family. My Grandfather Peter Hegarty shot outside post office in Boofeenaun Co.Mayo. Hip blown to smithereens, then arrested and Jailed. Story can be checked out in the 1923 Archives Dublin. All in the name of FREEDOM for Éire. Yes- im priveledged. 😡😡😡 🙏🇮🇪🙏
❤
If their objective is to drive division and anger in society they have been singularly successful.
Keep up the outstanding line of questioning Ben.
Daddy white privilege Foley had £133000 undeclared in an ansbacher account but was vice chairman of public accounts committee at the time. The 🍎 doesn't fall far from the Fianna Failed tree. A punch and Judy show.
Do they teach the kids in Africa about Black privilege in their schools. No didn’t think so. This is just nonsense.
How are these people making decisions for us? Get rid of the whole government. Makes you so angry. Bullshit
Yep it's depressing gang of clowns
This is the calibre of what passes for a Minister for Education. You'd almost despair that we have sunk so low. Election soon and perhaps a chance to hoof out cretins and anti-Irish wretches from power.
Ben deserves a medal for having to listen to these imbecilic responses day in, day out. I dont know how he does it.
I'm white straight Christian and proud 🇮🇪 🍀
And so you should be. I’m gay and proud, and dead against the invasion of our land and all the woke bs being spoon fed to us all the time.
Good lad, don't hurt yourself 😜
Think of the bright side, your soon to be a minority in your own country.
@@pfauniversal1890😂
Then why have you a satanist as your name ?? That's a bit odd.
Shameful how the minister intervenes to “answer” Ben’s first question, knowing that if she waffles on long enough there won’t be enough time for the question to the other person to be answered fully. It makes me sick.
'Waffle waffle waffle waffle', 'white privilege', 'verbal farts' oh sorry the minister just malfunctioned, next question
I also have a question for those two.
Is the indigenous white Irish homeless person living on the streets tonight more privileged than the refugee living in allocated accommodation?
Good man, Ben, for not letting those witches away with spewing their cancer unchallenged.
The really sad thing is that they both knew they were wrong but will carry on spouting the same BS tomorrow... and the day after... and the day after that...
we are privileged to be some of the most oppressed people in human history, for almost a millennium we were under the British boot. Now because of our skin colour or gender we are labelled privileged....there's words for singling people out based on gender or colour, racism and misandry.
Wow very well said sir
Agreed
We haven’t been strong since the early nineteen hundreds. 15000 homeless “privileged Irish people” would like to have a word with her
Absolutely, thousands of Irish families wait for years for housing while our government houses hundreds of thousands of illegal migrants coming in from outside the EU... Europe is paying for its own replacement at the hand of our leaders...
I'm white and I'm far from privileged, what utter shite
Well done Ben.
I'm glad I don't have kids at school. There is no way I would accept them being taught this bigoted garbage.
Tis a scary time we're headed for
Yes ireland = north Korea 2
My kids go to a private school where none of this woke bullshit is allowed! It’s costly but well worth it for their future.
@@user-zu6qn9ux9n I'm glad you said that. I know where I'll be sending mine.
Btw, that school that Enoch burke taught at. Was that a private one? Maybe some of them adhere to the party line
Woke crap.
I almost choked on my caviar and cristal listening to them 🙉
Theses traitors need to be dealt with!
The privilege of being in the only group about whom you could propose such a thing and not be arrested…
Some privilege that…
And telling this to children!?
Unreal
If someone is treated differently based on race (being white or non white) is unconstitutional. Anyone using such ideology or words should be fired from their public or government position. End of. Great work Gript
Yes, they are abusing their positions of privilege
This is hate speech against white Irish men and women
Exactly, hypocrites
Is there really a place in politics for toxic radical feminism?
I wonder will Minister Foley give up her privileged position of having her own Garda protection 24 hours a day.
Her home is not going to be broken into.
Don't say white Irish - just say Irish - it's the same thing.
Ben Scallan doesnt ask questions. He respectfully tackles them head on with integrity and honesty until they squirm. Mr. Scallan, you are a troubadour for truth in your field. There isnt one single person in Ireland in your profession doing it. I salute you and commend you hole heartedly.❤
If you want to find racists in Ireland here are two of them.
You teach your children to be confident.. Loving caring.. To be Strong and not to hurt others.. To be proud of our History.. And culture.. To treat others the way they like to be treated...themselves...
You don't mention COLOUR
GENDER
NATIONALITY...
Iam 75... And there was none of that BS. Around then..
@@elizabethwallace-donnelly.2356 agreed. We were at peace why are they trying their best to destroy it
Hopefully they use your question as feedback Ben.......
Thanks for representing us who don't have a voice
White
Irish
Male
I call upon the so called “White Privileged” voters of Ireland 🇮🇪 to use your hard fought freedoms and get these pathetic woke politicians OUT as soon as possible. 🇮🇪 Ireland for the Irish ☘️
In other words, we received a lot of opposition against the plan, but ay, we will just ignore the Irish opposition and lie that Ireland wants unlimited migrants
I'm an Irish white male, I work hard, pay taxes, pay a mortgage and other bills, I provide for my family, live an honest life, I get nothing for nothing and never have done. What privileges do I have?
Well said🎉
Ben what a credit you are to journalism🔥🔥🔥
Arabic is included as an option for the Leaving Cert in Ireland. Why? Doubt Irish is offered in any majority Muslim country's school exams
My God, the ideologically possessed in positions of power and influence.
Disasterous consequences following.
If it's not a question of privilege as at 0:53 then why are we being made feel guilty about our race?
New wokespeak!
Thank Ben keep up the excellent work 🙏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Thank you Ben & Gript media for calling out the discrimination against Irish men. Real media the people trust.
Well done Ben thanks 👍👍
I saw a white, presumably priviliged person this very morning crawling out of a sleeping bag in Belfast. Interestingly, it was right around the corner from a migrant hotel where those new arrivals were kept warm, cosy and well fed by the tax payer...
This is absolutely disgusting what these people are saying...
White Irish and Proud. ❤❤
SUPPORT GRIPT MEDIA 🇮🇪
I'm convinced Foley is on an away mission from the Romulan home world
True story👍
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Great journalism. Asking important questions.
Irish men and women, it’s not so long ago that black British army troops were marching in our country abusing Irish people. We owe them nothing. Éire bán, Éire láidir.
Reject the word white as a description of native Irish people. It's an American concept and it's a racial slur at this point.
It's racism pure and simple, and according to their book is a crime, these people need to go now!
Absolutely reject the word white. Total USA social construct. , when the Irish first got to the USA they were most certainly not considered white. , the Italians even less so . Whiteness only came with increased social standing over time, totally made up word
Europeans in general do not class themselves as homogeneously white. Even the English and Irish, Scottish and Welsh did not see themselves as the same race. Correct, the concept of ‘white’ as an ethnic group is an American concept.
Cheers Ben and the Gript crew. God bless
When you see such sexism and racism being taught to the young it is really criminal.
What she describes is what we learned in Catholic schools. "Treat others as you would like to be treated".
But what they mean is a deviation from that, Irish people, are inherently privileged and must wear that privilege like a shackle of shame.
God help us all.
Real questioning journalism once again, excellent !
Thanks Ben and gript media,for showing what real journalism is .
The look of fear on their face every time Gript go to ask a question lol
You are a hero. A well spoken, calm hero.
Give me ALL of this White Privilege that I'm accused of. I want it all. I get the accusations, but don't seem to have this privilege. Give me it!
ELECTED and UNELECTED homemade slime.
Evil using the language of compassion
She is so uncomfortable with the questioning