Ckrookshanks is half kneazle. Kneazles have an ability to recognise bad people. And half kneazles have this ability as well. So that's why he attacked Peter so much
I heard another side to the filch cat theory that mrs Norris might be his wife... either she stays in animagus form only when she's out in public and stays human when she's in private with filch, or she's stuck in that form kind of like how rita skeeter was when hermione caught her. I think filch is too miserable of a character for the first one to be true though haha. it's kind of my favorite theory not because I like filch but it definitely makes you think a lot. and the concept of animagi is one of the most interesting wizarding world things to me.
I've also heard the Mrs Norris being his wife theory, not that she is an animagus but that she is a maledictus like voldemorts snake Nagini. So eventually Mrs Norris wasn't able to turn back into a human and was stuck in her cat form forever
The last one I think is *impossible*. We didn't just see things from Harry's perspective, we also saw things from Snape's perspective at moments and bellatrix. Also, the fantastic beasts movies wouldn't exist if that's the case. Sure, some don't consider them canon, but they were written by Rowling. So there's no way that's what she had in mind. If this is all Harry's imagination, how come we see things Harry doesn't experience? Sorry, I've heard that theory so many times, I had to release my anger 😂
Ckrookshanks is half kneazle. Kneazles have an ability to recognise bad people. And half kneazles have this ability as well. So that's why he attacked Peter so much
Oh that is good to know. I didn't notice he was a Kneazle...like the ones in Hogwarts Legacy 🤦🏻♀️
Ckrookshanks couldn't be Lily's cat because in the book Hermione states that the shop owner told her that the cat had been there for over 100 years
It's been a while since I read the books. I have to go back and give them a re-read.
I heard another side to the filch cat theory that mrs Norris might be his wife... either she stays in animagus form only when she's out in public and stays human when she's in private with filch, or she's stuck in that form kind of like how rita skeeter was when hermione caught her. I think filch is too miserable of a character for the first one to be true though haha. it's kind of my favorite theory not because I like filch but it definitely makes you think a lot. and the concept of animagi is one of the most interesting wizarding world things to me.
Honestly that just makes me feel bad for Filch. Maybe that's why he loves Mrs Norris so much 🥹
I've also heard the Mrs Norris being his wife theory, not that she is an animagus but that she is a maledictus like voldemorts snake Nagini. So eventually Mrs Norris wasn't able to turn back into a human and was stuck in her cat form forever
@@kenzieellis4615 lol I forgot that Maledicti were a thing 😅 that makes a lot of sense to me actually
The last one I think is *impossible*. We didn't just see things from Harry's perspective, we also saw things from Snape's perspective at moments and bellatrix. Also, the fantastic beasts movies wouldn't exist if that's the case. Sure, some don't consider them canon, but they were written by Rowling. So there's no way that's what she had in mind. If this is all Harry's imagination, how come we see things Harry doesn't experience? Sorry, I've heard that theory so many times, I had to release my anger 😂
Yes I refuse to accept this theory as anything but impossible 🤣
I've heard theories that Mrs.Norris was a Maladitous not an Animagus.
That would be such a great back story for Mrs. Norris.