I was drinking a load of beer at camp and overheard abigail n jack talking about how shabby jacks clothes were and when i started the conversation i actually got the option to give her some money to buy the boy some new clothes and that was one of the most wholesome things i have seen in the game
@@bigmoist990 Kinda sad how his life went everyone wanted to at least give him a normal life without crime and to turn out like them but in the end he ends up being the last gang member and becomes a outlaw like everyone else
@@HoppingSnake290 I'd love to see how Jack's story goes in the next game, if they ever make one that's about Jack, I don't think they will but I'd love to see it
Well there was that one moment later in the game where she goes on a tangent about how all the guys shouldn’t be mothers; pretty sure she was drunk tho
@@KALSKingdom I know! I love him. I take selfies with him, and talk to him all the time. I want to take him fishing, but I'd have to free Micah, so... Yeah
Scenes like this are the saddest to me. It's tough because we know John Marston wants to be a good father, but doesn't know how. Not like Arthur, whose... well, you know what happens...
Yeah he brings up that he had a son out of freaking nowhere and for some reasons everyone claims he has the best development ever when he only change after getting tb while john started to change as early as chapter 3 and started doubting dutch way before arthur
@@airforcecadet15 what the hell you're talking about ? I understood the story conpletely, and i was invested in it 100%, try not to assume things you dont you about me, next time
@@slaviclad9705 Yet your comments about arthur mentioning his son for no reason and having no character development contradict your claim. If you paid attention you would know why he mentioned his son. Rains falls was worried about his own son and arthur was opening up to him because of this. And not changing until he had TB? Guess you fell asleep when arthur talked about Sean's death.
@@airforcecadet15 he never mention to anyone that he had a son until he become himself dying at the end, so it seems like its coming out of nowhere and where do you see character development when sean died ? He only says that he was like an annoying little brother to him, yes i know that sean's death was the moment the gang was falling apart slowly, but arthur himself mostly stays the same until he get tb, yeah he is starting to doubt dutch slowly but he still obey him blindly , you arthur fanboys are eerily similar to heather mason fanboys , as soon as someone dares to not worship your beloved character you immediately assume he didnt pay attention to the story or fall asleep like you said
The fact that she said "Dont waste your life worrying about people who dont care about you" describes John in a way that is accurate, he left for a year, without a care, even for Jack.
No, she is an absolute odious c*nt that treated John like shit. From the start to the end, nags btches and complains about problems John is trying to solve.
Ngl man, this hit me in the heart. Ik to never mention personal stuff on the internet but my father was never around growing up, whenever i saw these type of encounters with jack I immediately went up to him and Abigail to cheer em up. Insane how a game can pull your emotional strings like that
Arthur's good side (honorable stranger missions, his journal) remind me so much of my late father it really hurts sometimes. I love how complex and full of emotional depth they made this character, really just the consummate American antihero. I love that the writers had the courage to so earnestly write about the human condition, relationships and parenthood. The camp itself is a work of art that could have been it's own little 15 dollar game.
The art of this game is showing how much of the dual morality every individual has in real life can portray. Arthur is a bad, hardened man, if you hear how intimidating he sounds when he's robbing people, or killing them, or intimidating them, etc. But he is also a good man, you can hear when he is caring for Jack, "You got me too, so dry them tears." Love, Loyalty, and doing the right thing are all good qualities that Arthur portrays, but not always do Loyalty and Doing the Right Thing mix. C.S. Lewis talks about the 4 Greek words for Love, the "Brotherly" love is "Phillia." Though that kind of love is part of God's Love, it can lead to the road of damnation, I.E. Al Capone and his Gang, thelma and louise, in Arthur's case, his own Gang. C.S. Lewis writes, "In [Phillia] we may retreat into something better or worse than the public world: It may be a nursery of Martyrs or of Criminals. In real life, friendship can unite by what is still good in them, men otherwise very bad, and thus fortify them in evil." This game is pure art.
@Nguyễn Chu Phú An Alexander Yeah I honestly didn’t like Mary The fact that she has the audacity to ask him for help is really irritating and her saying “Oh Arthur” is even more annoying but nevertheless my Arthur Morgan is a high honor gentleman so I helped her but in the theater I didn’t make a move at all I was completely cold to her throughout the whole show but The best love interest for Arthur is Sadie in my opinion.
@@skollandhati9961 understandable. i mean it was one thing to ask him for help with her brother but her dad (who was the reason their relationship didn't work out btw)? that's just too much
I don't know if you can do this during the 2 prologues or only after they are over, but I had John sitting in his pup tent when I noticed a very distraught look upon his face, then I realized he was likely on the verge of tears. Possibly over Arthur and the gang's past and what not. Has anyone else ever stumbled across this before?
Noooo !!! that scene hit so hard because Arthur is dead Bec of tuberculosis and when he said don’t worry jack im here sad now because he doesn’t have Arthur 💔💔😭
I wish there could have been more random side activities to do with members like jack when events like this happened. Like when jack was crying if arthur could have done something to help jack it would've been nice
Why does this make me tear up? God all the actors were so good, Jack's little "thanks uncle Arthur" just ruined me... it'll be ok son ;-; well like... it won't be... but like please don't be sad
Honestly im surprised abigail didnt have a wtf am i doing with my life moment when dutch leads her and her 4 year old son up a snowy mountain to possibly freeze to death fleeing from the authorities
I feel like arthur was more of a father figure to jack than jacks own father at one point in time because in the red dead story arthur actually had a son named Isaac that he taught how to fish until one day isaac and his mother were killed in a robbery and no isaacs mother wasnt mary. If you didnt know this look it up
Feel bad for Jack, however I like on how Arthur can roast John Marston saying father of the year while telling John that he should spend time with jack.
There’s an encounter where Jack is trying to play with John. He calls John “Pa”. Then John goes “what did you just call me?” and refuses to play with Jack
i like how when tilly said that she liked your new hat you just looked confused and when you saw her you just nodded
I don’t know how to take compliments without being awkward 👁👄👁
@@RedsDeadBaby LMAO 🤣🤣🤣
That was adorable
@@RedsDeadBaby 🤓
@@steaketc2476 i hate u
Abigail: (giving heartfelt monologue)
Tilly: I lIkE tHaT nEw HaT!
We love Tilly don’t we folks
That little nod he gave her at 0:37
@@cyanideinmycereal1077 I love Tilly so much
@@cyanideinmycereal1077 no she's one of the worst
@@strongersmarterandbetter Sus
“And stop them tears, you hear?”
“Yes” 🏃🏽♂️🏃🏽♂️🏃🏽♂️
😂😂😂
LOL that’s to funny
GOTTA GO FAST
Kids are still like that😭
I was drinking a load of beer at camp and overheard abigail n jack talking about how shabby jacks clothes were and when i started the conversation i actually got the option to give her some money to buy the boy some new clothes and that was one of the most wholesome things i have seen in the game
Ngl that sounds like something that would be in the actual game
@@stormystorm7549 it is, I’ve had that interaction before too
@@stormystorm7549 it is part of the game thats why i said it lol i think i gave loke 20 dollars
Yeah, I had this encounter aswell.
@@chrisblom121 He thought you were making it up 🤣🤣
From not loving his father so much to dropping Edgar Ross for him. Jack is a new breed😌
I think he always loved John, it's just John didn't want to accept Jack which complicated things, but Jack didn't stop loving him.
@@yellowbirdie7182 hmm,I think jack started to like John after wards,but the John part is true
He always loved John as his father, that's why he shed tears for him and why he tried so hard to be like him
@@bigmoist990 Kinda sad how his life went everyone wanted to at least give him a normal life without crime and to turn out like them but in the end he ends up being the last gang member and becomes a outlaw like everyone else
@@HoppingSnake290 I'd love to see how Jack's story goes in the next game, if they ever make one that's about Jack, I don't think they will but I'd love to see it
“Don’t waste your life worrying about people who don’t worry about you”
Now imagine learning that kind of stuff at age 4 🤯
That's the thing I have met so many people who one parents had said a similar thing like that before
Man, that’s the kind of thing most people only learn as an adult
Almost as if he wasn’t supposed to be 4
Imaginate spend 4 years of childhood in a outlaw gang escaping of authorities in 3 states
@@dl0g09 o certo seria Imagine. Um BR sempre reconhece outro kkk
Abigail is such a good mom. Love that about her
Well there was that one moment later in the game where she goes on a tangent about how all the guys shouldn’t be mothers; pretty sure she was drunk tho
@@dchung250 ikr. That was weird
One word. Nope
@TheTrooper you have mommy issues I'd bet
@TheTrooper Arthur has mommy issues tho
John’s deadbeat dad powers are so great that he can make his son cry without even appearing in the video!
Ikr he is kinda a pos until his son gets kidnapped. 😭🙏
“Now don’t waste your life worrying about people that don’t care about y-“
*I like that new hat!*
I’m Arthur… literally sprinting over to baby Jack so he can make him feel better.
I love Jack. I make it a goal to talk to him at least once every time that I'm in camp
@@KALSKingdom I know! I love him. I take selfies with him, and talk to him all the time. I want to take him fishing, but I'd have to free Micah, so... Yeah
@@someghosthunter
What’s the problem? Free Micah, take Jack fishing, but don’t go to Micah’s camp. Micah stays away then.
@@someghosthunter ngl his voice is adorable
@@Hxhjli so adorable 🥰
Scenes like this are the saddest to me. It's tough because we know John Marston wants to be a good father, but doesn't know how. Not like Arthur, whose... well, you know what happens...
Yeah he brings up that he had a son out of freaking nowhere and for some reasons everyone claims he has the best development ever when he only change after getting tb while john started to change as early as chapter 3 and started doubting dutch way before arthur
@@slaviclad9705 We get it. You didnt understand the story. Try paying attention to it next time.
@@airforcecadet15 what the hell you're talking about ? I understood the story conpletely, and i was invested in it 100%, try not to assume things you dont you about me, next time
@@slaviclad9705 Yet your comments about arthur mentioning his son for no reason and having no character development contradict your claim. If you paid attention you would know why he mentioned his son. Rains falls was worried about his own son and arthur was opening up to him because of this. And not changing until he had TB? Guess you fell asleep when arthur talked about Sean's death.
@@airforcecadet15 he never mention to anyone that he had a son until he become himself dying at the end, so it seems like its coming out of nowhere and where do you see character development when sean died ? He only says that he was like an annoying little brother to him, yes i know that sean's death was the moment the gang was falling apart slowly, but arthur himself mostly stays the same until he get tb, yeah he is starting to doubt dutch slowly but he still obey him blindly , you arthur fanboys are eerily similar to heather mason fanboys , as soon as someone dares to not worship your beloved character you immediately assume he didnt pay attention to the story or fall asleep like you said
“You got me, too.”
Arthur saying that just makes me respect him even more. He is, without a doubt, the best video game protagonist of all time.
This scene just broke my heart.
@Fera Yolai no one cares about you we care about the game
@Fera Yolai shut up
@Fera Yolai no simps here.
Its cool..it will make the scene when john retrieves jack from bronte a lot sweeter.
@@hklegomasterbro got terminated
The fact that she said "Dont waste your life worrying about people who dont care about you" describes John in a way that is accurate, he left for a year, without a care, even for Jack.
He wasn’t even sure Jack was his until later part of rdr2 where he accepts him as his son
John is a terrible father in the first few chapters
@@amoresjohnwendell-os5evyou mean a based sigma male? 🗿🗿😎😎
Who would be sure when your girlfriend used to be a working girl and everyone in the gang had her?@@unknownbannana8241
@@amoresjohnwendell-os5evthat's why Jake needed someone to take care of him and that what Brontë did
Abigail: *calms Jack and comforts him*
Tilly: nice hat
Arthur: *Nod*
Words meant to help Jack, but it's Arthur who should of really taken them to heart.
0:36 “thank ya, ma’am.”
Abigail is truly a great mother.
No, she is an absolute odious c*nt that treated John like shit. From the start to the end, nags btches and complains about problems John is trying to solve.
And a great _____
this scene is dynamic, if you encounter it while the camp supplies are low instead of saying yes Jack will yell no! before running off
Ngl man, this hit me in the heart. Ik to never mention personal stuff on the internet but my father was never around growing up, whenever i saw these type of encounters with jack I immediately went up to him and Abigail to cheer em up. Insane how a game can pull your emotional strings like that
Yeah, I've never seen this interaction but it's emotional
Arthur's good side (honorable stranger missions, his journal) remind me so much of my late father it really hurts sometimes. I love how complex and full of emotional depth they made this character, really just the consummate American antihero. I love that the writers had the courage to so earnestly write about the human condition, relationships and parenthood. The camp itself is a work of art that could have been it's own little 15 dollar game.
That head nod was smooth af
It was
It do that too manytimes, it's cool acting that you are Arthur ingame😌
There are times when John needs to be punched by Arthur like when Arthur indulges his antagonize button too much in the camp.
Arthur being a good Uncle to Jack warms my heart every time
The art of this game is showing how much of the dual morality every individual has in real life can portray. Arthur is a bad, hardened man, if you hear how intimidating he sounds when he's robbing people, or killing them, or intimidating them, etc. But he is also a good man, you can hear when he is caring for Jack, "You got me too, so dry them tears." Love, Loyalty, and doing the right thing are all good qualities that Arthur portrays, but not always do Loyalty and Doing the Right Thing mix. C.S. Lewis talks about the 4 Greek words for Love, the "Brotherly" love is "Phillia." Though that kind of love is part of God's Love, it can lead to the road of damnation, I.E. Al Capone and his Gang, thelma and louise, in Arthur's case, his own Gang. C.S. Lewis writes, "In [Phillia] we may retreat into something better or worse than the public world: It may be a nursery of Martyrs or of Criminals. In real life, friendship can unite by what is still good in them, men otherwise very bad, and thus fortify them in evil."
This game is pure art.
Well written. Really enjoyed reading it!
really great comment. Crazy how much depth there is in this game within just a 1 minute NPC interaction
Very deep comment!!
Appreciate it👏🏼👏🏼
One more greet with jack and you would’ve left that wholesome conversation with a “welp I’ll catch ya later then”
Lmao the nod when Tilly talks about your hat
"You gonna cry boah?! Piss your pants maybe?!"
Arthur has to be one of the greatest uncle's in gaming history.
I wish you would have an special antagonise for John, "HEY WHAT THE HELL DID YOU DO TO JACK"
"and ya got arthur here for ya too" AWWWWWW UNCLE ARTHUR MOMENT i love abigail
Poor Jack, I want to give him a hug.
My boy booked it 0:41
I wonder how it would’ve gone down in an alternate universe where Arthur took Jack in as his adopted son and Abigail his new wife. 🧐
arthur probably could've done better since he had a family before and learned from his past mistakes
@Nguyễn Chu Phú An Alexander Yeah I honestly didn’t like Mary The fact that she has the audacity to ask him for help is really irritating and her saying “Oh Arthur” is even more annoying but nevertheless my Arthur Morgan is a high honor gentleman so I helped her but in the theater I didn’t make a move at all I was completely cold to her throughout the whole show but The best love interest for Arthur is Sadie in my opinion.
@@skollandhati9961 understandable. i mean it was one thing to ask him for help with her brother but her dad (who was the reason their relationship didn't work out btw)? that's just too much
@@shadowboy2818 Exactly.
@@skollandhati9961 Sadie or Mary-Beth imho
Abigail is a great mother, she deserved better
I won’t antagonise anyone except Micah
I like how Abigail said “You've got Arthur here for ya too”
You got me too young lad
Jack has probably had one of the roughest up bringings I've ever witnessed. He's practically destined to become a gunslinger
Fun fact : 1899 Jack was voiced by a female
most male little boys are. even bart simpson was voiced by a woman.
@@DARKENINGTIMES also in anime
Like near from death note
@@arindammishra2329 goku, naruto, gon alot of protagonist are
Wow thank you so much your so smart
I know that’s why his voice is so annoying
I don't know if you can do this during the 2 prologues or only after they are over, but I had John sitting in his pup tent when I noticed a very distraught look upon his face, then I realized he was likely on the verge of tears. Possibly over Arthur and the gang's past and what not. Has anyone else ever stumbled across this before?
That little nod to tilly was cool
"I like your new hat"
* Arthur sees jack crying
Hosea: what are you doing with the shotgun?
Arthur: hosea I just wanna talk to john. I just wanna talk to em.
I like how you nodded your head when she said she likes your hat
Tilly had me in bits😂😂😂
Noooo !!! that scene hit so hard because Arthur is dead Bec of tuberculosis and when he said don’t worry jack im here sad now because he doesn’t have Arthur 💔💔😭
This might make me replay rdr2
Thanks uncle Arthur 🥺
That's it. Get me a switch. John getting a whipping now.
Man, the entire game I wanted to pick little Jack up and just give that kid a hug
The slight nod to Tilly killed me lol
I hope one day I can be a good uncle like that.
You were really there for him at the end. Wait! Uh! Poor choice of words. 😭
“Dont worry jack everythings gonna be ok”
“I know”
“No it aint I’m lying to you because your just a kid”
Another day in the VAN DER LIND GANG
One of the best advice
I wish there could have been more random side activities to do with members like jack when events like this happened. Like when jack was crying if arthur could have done something to help jack it would've been nice
I like that new hat - Tilly
« Ok I’ll catch you later then »
"And you got Arthur here for you too."- Daawwwwww❤.
Damn abigails coat looks good
"Arthur here for you too."
Yet.
Why does this make me tear up? God all the actors were so good, Jack's little "thanks uncle Arthur" just ruined me... it'll be ok son ;-; well like... it won't be... but like please don't be sad
Don't make me come after you John, I know were you live.
Jack coming from John's tent
I thought he didn't share a tent with Abigail and Jack
Arthur really feels like a good uncle😌😌
1:03 = when I have to resort to step two when I run out of candy to lure little children instead of chasing them
The nod 😂
The nod he gives to tilly :,)
“I like that new hat”
“UH UH” *nod*
“I used to have one of those outfits son👴🏻”
“Okay I’ll catch you later then”
"I like your new hat! 🤠"
Give jack an Oscar for that crying.
Jack be running
“I like that new hat! 😊”
Honestly im surprised abigail didnt have a wtf am i doing with my life moment when dutch leads her and her 4 year old son up a snowy mountain to possibly freeze to death fleeing from the authorities
I like how someone said I like the new hair completely out of no where 0:33
I lai tha nu hei🗣️🔥💯
"I like the new hat" :D
I feel like arthur was more of a father figure to jack than jacks own father at one point in time because in the red dead story arthur actually had a son named Isaac that he taught how to fish until one day isaac and his mother were killed in a robbery and no isaacs mother wasnt mary. If you didnt know this look it up
0:46
Arthur: hes havin a hard time?
Abigail: *went to another dimension for a seconds*
Look at the little marston junior…… gonna cry?
The rarest dialouge is someone completing your hat instead of saying "is that supposed to cheer me up"
"Why you so chipper?"
Based John
Abigail: 0:23
Jack: Daddy kicked me into the lake.
Feel bad for Jack, however I like on how Arthur can roast John Marston saying father of the year while telling John that he should spend time with jack.
Uncle Arthur 🥹
AWW 😍🥰 Jack so cute
John is a jackass for making Arthur comfort his son that he made cry
Dutch: We're gonna be good, we're gonna be great! Faith my son faith
Jack cries in the background couse he gave up the faith a long time ago.
Kid's having a hard time?
*walks aggressively*
i would kill for that boy i swear-- hes so precious
Noooo jack is my fav character
ur defo going for a clint eastwood look haha
Tbh thats a fire hat
Not the whole camp not until John realizes what happened to Jack and Micah come on Abigail you know he doesn't care for anybody except for himself
And exactly how did John make him cry?
There’s an encounter where Jack is trying to play with John. He calls John “Pa”. Then John goes “what did you just call me?” and refuses to play with Jack
He treats jack like he isn’t his kid
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u he might not be ... biologically
@@obi-wanbenkenobi187 the javier thing is debunked
@b e e s right, but at this point in the story, John doesn't even fully think Jack is his real son.
Shout out to jack hiding behind Arthur