Hors de l'eau - Animation Short Film 2018 - GOBELINS
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 12. 2018
- Subscribe to the GOBELINS CZcams Channel : bit.ly/YTgobelins
Through the eyes of a macaque mother, a group of snow monkeys has to face the strict rules which govern their community.
Directors : : DUONG VAN HUYEN Simon, DURAND Joël, LECLERCQ Thibault, LUCAS Valentin, SITARI Andrei
Contact : hors@gobelins.fr
Musique / Soundtrack : Eliott DELAFOSSE
Année de production / Production year : 2018
GOBELINS, l'école de l'image, Moïra Marguin : mmarguin@gobelins.fr
Contact festivals : Miyu Distribution, Luce Grosjean - festival@miyu.fr
Société de distribution : L'Agence du Court Métrage
Site internet : www.gobelins.fr
Facebook : / gobelins.ecole
Twitter : / gobelins_paris - Krátké a kreslené filmy
The part when the mother tried to go after her baby but was stopped really made me feel the fear and anger, like a pain in my chest
Oh well then you should Adopte a kid who his/her mother did the same sh1t
supp8 I’m sorry, what do you mean?
@@supp8 lmao do u have some unresolved trauma or smthn. calm down
@@supp8 What the heck did you say?
You can't just forget what happened and go away just like that...I can't understant you budy >:|
@@bogarin8287
I just want attention >;v
The fact that this is based on a real troop of macaques just makes it that much more amazing
What's the history you're referring to?
Macaques are the species of monkeys in the video
And sad.
the fact that worse is happening to humans in Yemen today and this reminds you of macaques makes me wanna rip my own heart out from anger and sorrow. what good is internet and media when no one knows about the pains that people on this planet go through.
Is this a scene from an actual documentary or something? If so which one?
i want a world where everyone gets the warmth
Sadly there is a world where some get warmth and others freeze to death
@@dreamergamer1872 Very true. But the thing is, there are way too many people who hog the entire pool and do nothing with all that warmth, letting others freeze. Deliberately.
your wish is being granted rn
C-c-communism
@@bonnierae3144 no, global warming
It is extremely surprising to see how many people doesn’t know that this is how the actual hierarchy works for these snow monkeys. I recommend for the people who found this interesting to watch some documentaries. It is much more fun and interesting than you think.
I have studied many animals but not monkey species and I was wondering if this was how it worked for their society, and that’s good to know. Super sad but now I def will watch some documentaries!
I tried looking for some documentaries about them but the ones I did said that there was no hierarchy and that everyone was allowed to use the hot springs regardless of rank
@@crazyhorse8936 Here is here is can not those video watched
and it's stupid not to let even the lowest level bask it doesn't help the species survive
how is it extremely surprising that many people didn't know this again? snow monkey is not that common of a species, heck they live only in japan. If many people didn't know chickens live as flock, that's 'extremely surprising'
@@crazyhorse8936 czcams.com/video/mFK-zH233xk/video.html here a link (it’s in French and it’s really short and not developed but it’s the only thing that I found, and by the way, it’s really weird cuz there was a good french documentary that I watched about these monkeys but I can’t find it anymore)
I didn't realize the background was live action until a quarter of a way through the film.
I’ve watched this film 3 times and I just found out because you told me
Same..
It was the most distracting element of the film. I would have preferred full traditional animation to have been used for the backgrounds.
i only realized it after i read ur comment xD
What do you mean? Live action?
I love how it feels like a first person animation omg this is brilliant
Thanks you !
perhaps you meant first person game? because yes, like the others have mentioned this is a first person animation
totally brings you right into it
It is a first person animation
tb holiana KNOWS it is, they're just saying they're appreciating that it feels first person... guys stop saying "because it is," obviously they know that *facepalm*
I FELT the pain of being that mother.
Masterfully done. It was beautiful
the thinness of the frame makes it feel way more claustrophobic despite it being set in the mountains and i love that holy shit
Honestly, having the film in first person is such a brilliant idea. It personally helped me connect with characters and dispise others. (Spoiler) Like, when the baby monkey was thrown away for being in the water, I personally felt hurt and angry like they'd thrown *my* child. I felt pain when I saw them get hurt and became so full of spite when the other monkeys laughed and refused to let the perspective protagonist and the others join them to stay warm.(end of spoiler) It's such an interesting concept that was executed so well!!! And the art style was absolutely beautiful!
"Some" monkeys? How about "the *male monkeys* refused to let the females and young monkeys join them and stay warm".
@@qmbikerider4583 not just male!! most primates, including these mountain ones that we see here have strict family hierarchies that dictate everything from what, when and where you can eat, sleep, live...etc. typically older FEMALE monkeys will uphold these hierarchies and hold the most power. you can see it in this video too - the baby wanted to go into the water because it saw the other baby monkey - whose parents are likely higher up in the hierarchy, playing in the warm water.
Nature can be so cruel, but this was beautifully sad. Thank you.
Thanks to you Dodly !
I would say that humans can behave the same way.
That is not nature, that is our society
gtfo
gypsyco lab pretty sure its more on class structure and hierarchy than sexism and patriarchy but ok
I usually dont like these kinds of animations bcuz they make me feel horrible and makes me sad. They are so realistic and they reveals some of the deepest darkest things of the world, my heart just can't take the harshness of reality.
Me too, but my curiosity is just too strong and I watch these videos. I feel very sad afterwards and I hate it.
that's the point of this short film. its showing you the real world.
Art is the safest way to familiarise yourself with the full range of emotions, so you wouldn't be shaken off your feet when you get to experience them in real life.
Ancient greeks used to say that comedy and theatre could make a man get a correct soul, strong and well made. It is exactly what is happening to you, do not fear it.
This makes me really want a game where you play through the pov of a ape
It's called....
I forgot
Ancestors that's what it is
You should play Ancestors
An ape
What like ancestors that’s a ape based game also these are monkeys not apes monkeys have tails apes like us lack that feature
I know some animals with high levels of intelligence have different social structures to those of humans and that we can't judge animals the same way we can judge people, but this animated short shows that animals can evolve to the point of showing cruelty and kindness. Also, even if this animated short isn't accurate about the social behaviors of these apes, I really like the storytelling and the animation techniques.
Actually this animation is extremely accurate, the mistake most viewers are having is thinking this has some sort of symbolism about humans when really this is how these specific primates act. It's cruel but beautiful animation does an amazing job at giving us a perspective of the animals.
Astro Chillin The parallels with humans and class hierarchy are kind of unavoidable. A tiny portion hoards well being, the rest gets left out struggling in the cold.
@@alexeru6154 There is the Incan empire.
I heard different groups have different rule and standard. So not all snow monkey are like this.
It's very simple, intelligence means higher levels of love, and higher levels of cruelty as well, both things compliment each other, there's no way a kind of being, species, etc can only be capable of one of them. That's why this animals act like this, that's why we act like we act.
This was so incredibly sad. And to not understand why they couldn't be inside the hot water is heartbreaking. Seriously sad and beautiful
@@mont-lo3001 ?
@@htoodoh5770 What is your question ?
statuses and hierarchies
your understand is wrong
you guys don’t understand that I don’t understand
It strikes me that the we actually get to see Her face at the end. The cam stays focused on her as if to say "...and now you know why"
Its also eerie how apathetic the "in-crowd" monkeys are as long as the status quo protects them... especially in contrast with the protagonist, as shee clearly shows the species is capable of deep emotions.
Well done.
"Go back, I want to be monke" they said...
Hoo hoo haa haa
Pour monke
First person AND a mix of real imagery and animation? Looks sick
It's not real, it's a setup we built and we filmed inside with a camera :) (soon a making of to explain it)
@@valentinlucas4712 would love to see that!
@@shaheenyes waiting for it you can go on our Facebook page Hors de l'Eau where we put a lot of pictures yet :)
It's impressive!
Ong
I love how this was presented from a mother macaque's perspective - quite literally. She and her infant were basically peasants amongst the group; not allowed into the warmth of the pool due to their low social status. A bit like a chamber maid and her illegitimate child being kept outside in the cold streets while the duke and his noble friends enjoy a party inside a warm ballroom.
It is interesting to know that the concept of social hierarchies isn't just exclusive to humans.
c'était un beau film. Les différentes textures et couleurs de l'animation étaient sublimes. Quelle belle œuvre d'art cinématographique !
This was just.. amazing. My first thought was how incredibly ANIMAL this animation was. Seeing the events through the eyes of the animal was a fantastic choice on the part of the animators.
As the short went on, it struck me how human it was. Not, NOT animal. Just animal AND human. Which is a pretty fantastic thing to pull off. This was absolute art.
Harrowing and painful to watch.
The symbolism (if you will) at the end was heartbreaking yet incredibly powerful. It's amazing to view media through the eyes of an animal, let alone in a species controlled by a harsh social hierarchy. It's refreshing, and I could feel the pains and emotions that the protagonist and their' fellow monkeys felt. Otherwise, I'm speechless; what a film.
The brilliant score, ambiance and FX added amazingly to the surrealistic animation and beautiful environment design. I admire your work, and the level of quality you produce. Well done Gobelins, on your final student production for your 2 years! You have truly saved the best for last. While I am sad it is over, I am glad it was all released in the level of quality and uniqueness that makes your school the top.
Thank you very much for the kind words!
We appreciate it very much!
Now I can't say anything that wasn't said here.. 😅😐
Amazing!
r/Im14AndThisIsDeep
Couldn't agree more
@@minecrafteliza4887 Finally someone with the same name! 😀
Taken in a journey through the eyes of an animal. I don't think I've ever seen something done in such a realistic, gut-wrenching way. Those 8 minutes were filled with significant shots that flesh out a totally alien world to us. Beautiful but chilling. Amazing work, you guys. ❤
Thanks you Mina !!
Chilling huh,
yeah, real chilling
ba dum tis
Uhm I actually think that the monkeys represent our society and that this short film is filled up with symbolism, so it's not an "alien world" to us. And I was shocked and had a lot of emotions coming to me watching this... it wasn't really chilling to be honest. Yes, the animation is great (I love it!) and the storytelling is awesome but alltogether, it is t meant to be chilling.
@@merets9800 i was about to say if you think this is a world totally alien youre the one in the hot pool
Hot Pooler..
Moral of the story: mountains are made of frozen monkeys
Jaja
Oh god😂😂😂😂😂
LMAO 🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
It's funny for a moment, but then you realize how dark and meaningful that is, and makes you wonder if you will be left among the piles from others pure want for a hoard. Will you become a mountain of dead bodies when you die?
This was amazing! I cant help but think the message was more heartwarming than what one might initially think, that those who face the greatest difficulty are the ones who leave a long lasting impression on those around them. The ones that were forced to endure the cold, suffering the hardships, while passed, left behind a legacy while the others who were givin the easy life left nothing, and I think that is such a beautiful and strong message
I'm not sure what moments had me more on the edge of my seat -- when the haunting music swelled in suspense, or when there was that pregnant silence...
Incredibly well done. I felt every emotion that these snow monkeys felt, and I loved the 2D animation on top of the 3D background. The entire execution was genius.
preganant silence?
@olivia
LMAO bro I think it means just a large expanse of silence considering the fact of a woman’s uterus to be expanded with a baby inside.
Live action background, not 3D ! :)
Valentin LUCAS oh whoa, even cooler!! Thank you for correcting me! I admire your work so much
I always get so excited when gobelins posts but now I'm crying into my taquitos
Could I get one? Lol
"crying into my taquitos" what a mood! 😭
Me: * enjoying the animation *
Coca cola add: *hello there friend :)*
I never knew how effective viewing this in the 1st person perspective, would make me understand the character even more or even push it further to make me feel like I'm the character. Amazing 👏
OMG, Gobelins released the last Student film, the best for the end probably!
Benoit Berthe why was it that last student film?
@@ameiar7145 The last of our promotion yes ; next will be next year !
@@kamilagrzes4164 haha no worries Gobelins has beautiful years in coming ;) it's just this year there was 14 films, and our is the 14th !
Valentin LUCAS you guys did WONDERFUL! this is just simply amazing
@@kishinumaayumi Thanks a lot 😁
By the end of the video, all I could hear was my heartbeat.
what a powerful animation film
I love how they used a live action background, it really adds to the realism, almost like watching a live video. Hats off to you guys :)
The shorts this year have been so amazing! Not only the animation but also the freaking storylines and themes, they just leave you breathless!
A truly moving piece, I could feel the cold, the panic, the desperation, the helplessness, the camaraderie of the lower class in this hierarchy
Top-notch story, animation and camera work. You can really see the amount of animal study that went into it.
Out of the Water is where I'll be,
While the wealthy wade
Through their blessed spree.
Low Class
Snow Class
With stiffening hands.
Each fiber freezing over from crown to gland.
And with the loss of that dream,
To join those above,
I will be buried for I am-
Too ugly
Too Poor
Too Stupid
To be lucky or loved.
So me and my kin
With tremulous breath
Huddle together below the mountain,
To await our death.
Shian Dixon wtf. It explains everything (sorta). But I’m still confused. Why are the monkeys discriminating amongst each other?
@@fredaasante2593 I'll dumb it down for you... It's less to do with blunt discrimination, and more to do with the established hierarchy that separates the powerful (those more worthy of survival and more likely to create beautiful children) from the weak (those that are less capable of surviving and will make useless, uglier children). As you can see, those that were allowed to pass looked a lot healthier than those that did not didn't they? If you were observant. But more importantly... this is just a poem based on what was just watched. What's your deal?
There's no deal, it was an honest question. I didn't understand why they were against the other monkeys as well
@@shiandixon2201 ill dumb It down for you, your poem is like a low-key made in seconds rap. I dont think the monkeys would let you get in the hot tub. But i wouldn't have told you if you weren't so full of yourself.
And the low class/snow class
Rhyme made me laught my ass off. Thanks
Well the symbolism is everywhere , even in the wild ,
It was really so sad that they freezed there on the mountain , while the others having a warn place ._. ;-;
This was brilliant. The animation was gorgeous, the perspective was unique, and made suspense out of a simple, yet very real and heartbreaking premise. Great job.
I knew I needed my cup of depresso in the mornin.
That aside, the style of this is absolutely phenomenal. Such a treat to see 2D handled in this manner.
I could feel the strong sense of tension throughout the whole video thanks to the first person perspective. Beautifully animated!
If you watched this with headphones, I love how the sound is portrayed, drawing so many levels of emotion
Even in the wild, a mother would still use herself to keep her baby warm. especially with the help of other mother's.
This is really good representation ab human society as well. We are no different from each other but we create differences with hierarchy. The ones at the top of the poll are no better than ones at bottom.
@oldedude51 wtf are you talking about?
@oldedude51 thank you so much i never knew the solution whas there all along, i just have to start being privileged, that's all, wowwwww (this is sarcasm)
@oldedude51 ok boomer, listen up.
People at the top get away with a lot more shit, like crimes. That doesn't make them better ppl (just because they're not caught and).
I've got many privileged and non privileged friends and I can honestly say that my NON privileged friends are some of the most warm, happy and hard working individuals I've ever met.
My privileged friends, however, are much less socially capable and seem to be disconnected from reality. They're not hard working and can be narcissistic at times. They didn't even understand the real world.
Our hierarchy is needed for structure and for society to function effectively, however there's no doubt our society still needs to be improved :)
And its how these animals actual act! Im sure you can find actual videos of it
Love how every one keeps mentioning hierarchy. It’s not racism, or prejudice, huh? The sin of spin will alway be yours.
Extremely accurate and extremely brilliant on the animator's part to capture it. Deserves awards and accolades.
C’est magnifique comment tant de chose peuvent être dit sans mot.
This is perhaps one of the most powerful pieces of short film I have EVER seen. Beautiful. I wish the artist(s) the best of luck in their careers
hey arnold
This is astounding. By far my favorite animation yet with how chillingly real it is. Absolutely amazing
Damn the symbolism is wild in this. Seeing a reflection of our own humanity in such a dehumanised and dissociated way... it’s crazy
Actually that’s just how nature is rude nothing special on this video just an animation of real life, not the unicorn and rainbow you’re used to see, but you people are so disconnected of reality than you think animals and nature are better and more ethical than us, when actually you are just a bunch of disconnected idiots.
You think it represents our society because this is the only thing you see and know, when that’s our society you see actually it’s just the fact that we are animals and part of this rude nature.
@@laitdejabot9890 👁👄👁 okayyyyyyyy
@@laitdejabot9890 I have come to the conclusion that animals are no different than humans. We humans just think of others hurting/destroying more seriously but in nature it happens all the time. Birds killing the smaller ones for food and it also happens to fishes. Animals would do anything just to survive and isn't that also how we are.
@@nebul1269 That's pretty much it. We also an animals we just happen to be "learned" more tricks to survive than any of other species on this planet. If it happened to birds first, they would made the same "mistakes" as we doing right now. Although those aren't actually mistakes but completely "normal: part of the evolution and survival.
People who spewing stuff like "it's cruel and it's only related to humans" don't understand what nature and instincts are and why they exist.
I still go back to this animation. Beautiful.
That was amazing! you don't see these amazing creatures represented in too many works, so this was especially a great treat to see!
It is extremely surprising that most people don't seem to realize that this behavior by males very much parallels most human societies. I can't imagine that the filmmakers were not aware of this.
This was absolutely beautiful and harrowing. Holy smokes.
one of the best animations ive seen in a long time, edge of my seat
People I know aren't favorable towards first person, but I love it. It's the ultimate immersion. Well done.
I think about this animation a lot and year after year I always find myself revisiting it..
Having this film forecasted from the first person perspective is GENIUS!!! Love this. Makes all the actions on screen that much more emotive. The combination of like 2D drawing/painting and that realistic stonework on the rocks is really dope. Love that touch of 2d/3D blending.
The most beautiful animation I've seen in years! Thank you for this!!!
That was on of the most beautiful crafted suspense sequences I've seen in a long time
MY HEART :(
the narrative was amazing but now i cant stop crying
This made me appreciate the warmth of my bed and blankets 😭
I love the combination of the detailed animation with the real background footage.
Found some footage of the custom build sets online, it's incredible.
I would love to see what else you could do with live action footage and some smart compositing.
It's true glad someone made an animated short film on it.
Whoever made this is gonna achieve greatnesd
Wow! Thanks you !
.......yeah they going to be better than me any ways
One of the students who worked on this is actually a storyboard teacher in my school
where is your pfp from?
It seems the smarter animals get the more cruel they become..
Nah, it's just part of being alive. You'd see the same kind of behavior even on insects. In the wild you just want survive, even if it means the death of someone else.
Only the fittest survive in this life or death tournament known as Mother Earth
This should be awarded. It shows that The Life is so Unfair "❤
It should, it shows reality
the combination of 3D backgrounds with 2D animation is mesmerizing.
That finishing transition was spectacular
So cool that someone made an animation about this I’ve always found the hot spring thing interesting
Cool how she lowered her look as soon as one of the other apes looked at her. Really amazing movie
Wow very unique animation you are camera that is like you were their to see very emotional too
-sorry bad english
it’s not just about nature, y’all. someone wouldn’t spend likely months upon months hand animating something that they didn’t have a deeper meaning for.
we don't know that, and it doesn't matter, it's art, you interpret as you want and you can't asume the artist's real intention unless it's literal or too clear
People hand animated some stupid shit for month of end, trust me, it’s not uncommon.
Hentai
I mean they probably would.
Why wouldn't they? Nature is nature.
This really hit me it hurts my heart some have to live like that fighting for live and there young ones... but this is a real good animated film
One thing satisfied me is that movement of the camera ❤❤it literally looks like 3D , i think it takes some little efforts
Beyond amazing the feels this short is able to produce. Stunning work
I guess you could say that was
chilling
The puns man!
Merry Christmas btw!
TOO SOON
GAH
Wooowwww well done
*Chiiiillllll : )*
the realistic background made the experience so much more captivating, i love the style and the fluidity of the animation. i know this must have taken quite a lot of time with the tracking shots. your team did incredibly amazing. fantastic pay off !!
I see it over and over again, FANTASTIC!!!
A very clear and concise telling of the pitfalls of a dominant leader in an animal pack. Could also be an analogy of prejudice.
Beautifully done.
This is not animal behavior. It's human behavior. Do not mistake this for a documentary. Its plot is as "real" as Disney's brother bear. Nowhere near real, in other words.
Only this short is missing significant abstraction and stylization, visual guides that help divide reality from fiction, so its not clear.
@@Froggy-Frogs This IS animal behavior...... Do not mistake this for fiction. The Japanese Macaque (or snow monkey) actually bathe in hot springs for stress relief and to survive the winter. Lower ranking females and their babies are sometimes not permitted to bathe with the higher ranking individuals. Not every troop is this extreme (especially in designated area's specifically set aside for the monkeys), but there have been documentations of outsiders freezing to death, possibly due to their position in the hierarchy (or maybe other reasons we couldn't see).
Obviously we can interpret more than just animal behavior from this amazing animation, but saying this "isn't real" is simply false. Check out some video's of them bathing in pools! You can really see how astoundingly realistic this animation actually is, and maybe learn yourself something.
I was thinking Capitalism 🤦🏽♀️
so sad😔💔they wouldnt even let the young ones come in
Kaliyah Stevens well this is how nature is cruel and yet fascinating.
@@brianisme6498 thats how reality works
The animation is stunning, the first person pov very unique and its a reminder that nature and its creatures run by its own rules and aren't always kind.
This hits very close to home. those with, and those without, but still in the social order to either endure, resist, or accept it. it hurts everyone in the end
Definitely my favorite and one of the most intense animations I've seen in a long time! 🤘🤩🤘
It's doubly impressive that (aside from audiences drawing parallels towards our own heirarchical/classism issues) the extra fact that many species of animals also act like this, which makes it a great reminder that humans are animals too. It's just easy to forget sometimes!🤩🤩🤩🤩
You aren't really saying anything
@Daniel Reynolds
Looking back at this comment, it is a little more long-winded (writing structure-wise) than I thought at the time. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯😅
The TL;DR point is that the video made me connect some animal behaviors with some human ones.
@@Scarshadow666 the real story here is that humans have anthripocentrically tried to separate themselves from other animals, based on influence from religions for a long time.. the reason they weren't connected before is because people reinforce the idea that God made us special. It challenges their world view..
Google "anthropodenialism" if you find all this interesting..
Humans always separate themselves, and that is the basis for exploitation.
If you see yourself differently than someone with a disability, or more melanin in their skin, or their sexual choices then you open the door to exploiting them...
If we "relate" with animals, it challenges the narrative that we are better than they are, and puts a hole in our justification of needlessly exploiting them..
So when I say "you aren't really saying anything" it's because there is so much to say about our juvenile behavior
@@Scarshadow666 do you know what speciesism is?
Le mépris d'autrui et de son besoin, considéré comme normal au point qu'ils finissent par faire parti du décor
Corentin Bendelac ici ça été simplifié pars peau noir peau rouge
The Russian Comrade, Oui
The Russian Comrade « Disregarding others and their needs, so much so that it becomes the norm. »
I love silent stuff, the story always feels more deeper than you would otherwise get with speaking.
I could feel panic at certain moments, I even shook my head to the baby looking up at the camera. Damn this is good
Modern Society in a different context?
The rich and the poor I see luxury greed and poverty in need
Not quite it is a story as old as time, animals fight over what they have and strive to dominate it as to not lose it to others, only humans and very few animals i believe have showed the ability to share when they have the ability to do so and even then there are those who do not. If it is within ur power to give but u do not that is the sign of evil. However that is a grey zone, do u give now while u can but not have enough for u and those u care for later? The engaging, challenging morale dilenmas just pile up. For there is no true right or wrong in this world, just painfully obvious truths which u must either overcome or embrace. Yes u may reject those truths or ignore them outright but at great risk. Ultimately it is u who must decide.
Congrats you understood the symbolism in the short
You guys really believe this was modern society? This seems more like monarchy times, when the Strong's rule be fear, and the lowest clases have to day for the king, who was a luxury life from their effort. Modern society (at least in the occident and Japan/South Korea/singapur/and other exceptions) has improved to a level that we could never imagine in the medieval times. It's even more comparable to a communist regime
rulo CASLA it’s not a metaphor, it’s quite literally how these monkeys act in the wild
Splendid animation style! Love the idea of this first-person point of view. But the ending though..
This was brilliant! I loved every minute of it!
One thing people need to know about this beautiful film is that NO IT IS NOT TYPICAL. I spent 3 days and 2 nights at the exact location in this film, Jigokudani Monkey Park. It is the only place in the world where the monkeys live above the snow line all year, as they can use the hot springs to warm up. The springs are plentiful and not so crowded that dominant monkeys need to guard them. In fact, the inn I stayed at there has its own hot spring which the monkeys of course do not respect...I used it together with the monkeys every day! They are very intelligent and not savage as depicted here, you simply have to respect their signals of dominance, meaning don't hold eye contact. Older males often help caretake the babies of the troop, and they are all very playful, rolling snowballs and playing games together. While they do sometimes play rough, I never saw a single instance of an adult threatening a baby, or of one of the troop members being turned away from warmth. This is a wonderfully animated story, but it's JUST a story.
But it happens even though it isn't rare.
I feel most of the people those who are commenting are missing the point. The metaphur, the symbolism, the context. Can't anyone of you people relate to our world. I felt connected as part of our reality. Together we stand like a mountain, eventhough we are deprived from the comfurt and luxury of this world.
ok
Can i watch one animation short without Ending up crying??!
I watched this like 7 times and I'm still watching this
Can't believe I enjoyed this free of cost on CZcams!
Tellement triste ! La loi de la jungle est si cruelle pourtant ça ressemble à ce que les êtres humains font subir à leurs semblables. Nous ne sommes pas si différents des animaux pourtant nous avons un cerveau sensé raisonner. Très émouvant.
C'est tout à fait ça. En revanche, j'ai vu il n'y a pas si longtemps un documentaire qui disait que nous sommes encore des animaux, la différence avec les autres (et comme tu l'as souligné), c'est que nous possédons une plus grande intelligence.
@@hikarinozomi2795 une plus grande intelligence. ....je ne sais pas. ..quand on vois ce que la cruauté et la cupidité de l'homme est capable de crée aujourd'hui. ...même a ses semblable comme dans ce magnifique court métrage. ...rejet, racisme, viol etc....pire que ceux qu'on appelle "les animaux. ..."
Les animaux on une plus grande âme que nous
Ils sont pas dans la jungle ?
Lukis Makis 😂 des champignons
Mais je suis totalement d'accord, je ne supporte pas que l'humain se considère différent des animaux si je puis dire ainsi, car il en est juste un
An amazing experience supported through first person, no words, and a interesting topic on which many questions grow.
...I am speechless, what a animation full of strategies, beauty, and the cruelty of nature.
I can’t believe how amazing first person point oh view is
This is such a beautiful animation I can’t even
Wow ! Incredible animation
Que c'est beau.. Je suis également dans une école d'animation et je rêverais de voir un making off!! Bravo pour ce magnifique travail..
Merci ! Alors le making of arrivera bientôt sur notre page Facebook ! Tu peux déjà y trouver pleins de dessins de pré production ainsi que des photos de la fabrication pour mieux comprendre l'envers du décors ;)
Beautiful, truly beautiful. Well done all involved.
Thanks Devon!