1999 Caroline Benson 37-Carly and Robin Finally Come to A head!
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2024
- Robin says that she has insinuated herself into Jason's life and she is sorry to disappoint Carly, but she is as common as dirt, selfish, lazy, and greedy and not fit to make Jason's bed, let alone lie in it. She then tells Carly the only reason Carly thinks of love is to use it as an excuse for the inexcusable things that she does. She lies to him, takes advantage of him financially, and emotionally. It’s how she manipulates Jason into thinking that he can’t be a man of his word unless he does exactly what she wants him to do. Carly calls her "little miss perfect going off to Paris to punish him Scorpio". You pout, and think that'll teach Jason a lesson. If I want something from Jason, I tell him. You manipulate him, and made him quit a job he loved to fit into your Martha Stewart knock off cabin, where he was miserable, but finally deserving of you. She then tells Robin she is nothing, but an icy emotional bully. She says that Robin has no one to blame but herself, and to take her sanctimonious butt back to Europe and leave her and Jason alone. Carly tells Robin that there was a time that she wished to be like Robin, well educated etc. But she is so over that. Robin says that what hurts her is that Carly is hurting Jason and Michael. When you got pregnant, it was the biggest tragedy in the world, you would lose Tony, your figure etc. She says that Jason fell for her ploy and fell in love with Michael while she was gone. Jason will never fall in love with you. Carly says that Jason, Michael and her are family, and Robin can't hurt them. Robin says that she will do what she has always done for Jason, love him. She leaves Carly with that thought and leaves. Carly stands there looking worried by Robin's words.
! Uh Oh!!!
Sarah brown was the BEST Carly!!! She was outstanding!
Oh totally agree. She was the best
She’s better than Claudia zaccara
Period and the acting was top tier
I prefer Tamara 🤷🏽
Sarah Brown and Laura both are my favorite. It took me some time to get use to Tamara but I still feel like u didn't see their bond the same way. Sarah and Laura bring out the bond between Jason and Carly have
These were the days to watch GH. Dynamic performances and can't miss episodes.
Robin makes it clear here, her issue isn’t that AJ isn’t involved in Michael’s life, it’s that Carly is involved.
Exactly. She was happy to raise ajs son when Jason & her were in the cottage house & Carly was in ferncliff. Honestly if aj & the q's raised Micheal he would have been much better off than in a mob world in a coma shot in the head then went to prison & got raped. Then he finally connected w/ aj as a young man & sonny couldnt stand it. Micheal was finally calling aj dad. I loved it when Micheal dropped sonny for murdering his dad in cold blood & Carly knew as it was his last words to her. So when Micheal found out he was finally an awesome character in his own right. He changed his name back to Micheal Alan quartermain sadly after like 6 months he ran back & apologized ! Then Micheal again for a long time was just still an appendage to Carly & sonny. Carly even had another baby I think Donna was the Same age or younger than her grandson. Even Micheal & nelle was all about Carly. Sadly it was more interesting cause they totally made Micheal a bore. Last I watched was before covid & I think nelle was pushed off a cliff or ran off & Micheal's story was being obsessed w/ wiley. I have no clue what's going on cause the show was so unwatchable. It was a tad interesting when Brooklyn came back but then more baby stories. Maxie was pregnant w/ her 3rd kid by a 3rd guy & Brooklyn took the baby in some deal. Anyway Micheal did wind up back w/ the q's last I saw. He had been living in the mansion & was a high ranking ceo or president of elq. I think Ned was back too & the very last interesting story was Tracey returning & Monica covered for her committing some crime against Alexis & she took off to Europe. So the point is its sorta funny how the only stability Micheal found was back at his bio dads family & company. He was a mess through the Carson years as a kid to 18. So the people she fought so hard against cause it was all about her libido first w/ Jason then w/ sonny in mob world. It was really sick how the show kept trying to say being an alcoholic was a far worse father figure than gangsters. Aj messed up when Robin blew the lid off the secret. Instead of trying to make Carly a wife & socialite he so could have gotten full custody of little Micheal. Jason was not his dad Carly defrauded the qs by putting Jason knowingly as father on a legally binding document. I recall Jason saying if Robin had just waited less than a year Jason could never be challenged as his legal dad no matter what once the child turns 2. Would not be surprised if Robin knew that & once she saw that Jason loved her but chose micheal& Carly she bounced. I'd have had more respect for Robin if she blew the secret immediately instead of after Jason made his choice. Jason I get had brain damage & did start adapting to a more normal understanding of the world. Like he really thought he Carly Robin & Micheal could all live together. Once he finally got it that Robin understandably was not OK w/ Jason saying " I love u but wherever Carly & Micheal live is where I'm gonna be " I do think Jason if he really was micheals bio dad would have dropped Carly. He def knew that Carly would run to aj if he didn't keep including her in his life. When Jason & Robin have it out he Said it " do u think I'm stupid. Don't u think I knew their was a chance Carly would run to the q's for her own reasons. " this was such a mess. All from a drunken one night stand Carly wrecked so many people b/c it was sick whomever she wanted to be with was gonna be micheals daddy. Aj got to be his dad for less than a year. Obviously Carly only did that cause Robin told. Granted I get Carly was young & a pycho lol & got pregnant while obsessed w/ Tony but she never loved him it was about taking something from poor Bobbie who did nothing wrong. She was a child hooker & gave her up to have a life she could not give her. If she didn't Carly could hsve wound up a ward of the state if a child prostitute w/ no home had an infant. If she was at least honest w/ aj & Said look u may be this baby's dad instead of lying to Tony he was the baby's father. What she did to aj while pregnant was unforgivable.
This is really good writing! They are both right and wrong😂
It's funny, Jason and Carly can lie, but noone else can.
Robin a bigger backbone here. Love it!
My fav Carly "speech"
the writing used to be so awesome
"Martha Stewart knockoff cottage"
Seriously LMAO!
I always loved that cottage set but the way Carly describes it is so true lol!
who knew Robin can throw down..."Your as common as dirt" LOL
Love it!! She's a Devane-Scorpio my girl Robin knows how to be scrappy when she needs to be
I dont even know what that means lol I should look it up in a dictionary....
@@Ashleyludwig901 meaning she can dish it out
“You’re as common as dirt!” 😂
“Lazy and selfish and greedy” I hollered
Robin gives up easily. she could have held onto her relationship with Jason. Jason can't be manipulated by Carly. even with Michael. he won't sleep with her and he won't see Carly anything more that Michael's mother and his friend.
Robin didn't care that Michael was A.J's when Carly was gone she got play happy family with Jason.
Yeah she's the one who is using Michael not carly
@Draper Scott Go back and watch when Jason brought michael home to penthouse and they cared for michael
@Draper Scott She told A.J because Jason and Carly were getting too close.
The only reason saint Robin told PJ was to spite Carly....plain and simple....her petty self was jealous because she couldn't manipulate Jason anymore....Robin was in the wrong here....and I think she knew what hell she was bringing on both of them....the time to "do the right thing" had pass long long time.....this was just payback.
@@sandrajohnson4778 thank you. She had all the time in world to tell him
@Muirmaiden Nobody ever calls Robin out, except Carly. Most everybody else lets St. Robin off the hook. It's disgusting & discriminatory. She was not perfect, nor was she all sweetness & light. She could be devious & manipulative & controlling and when Carly would call her on it I would stand up & cheer. The funny thing is Carly's POV may be off sometimes, but she reads ppl very well. SO when she'd say something about someone's character she wasn't often wrong. Although sometimes exaggerated.
Robin didn’t make any sense here. She didn’t want Carly to hurt jason by taking Michael away. But that’s *EXACTLY* what robin did by telling the secret that wasn’t her place to tell.
She didn't want Carly and Jason to be together. She thought if she told A.j he could claim michael Carly would follow and Jason would be free to leave sonny's business
It’s ironic that when she told Aj he’s Michael father he kidnapped him and when she told nikolas about spencer Helena kidnapped him.
@@ashleyfinchludwig5228 and the only reason she told Nikolas that he was the father was because she thought Carly acted alone in keeping Spencer's paternity a secret.
Robin was right to tell AJ
@@maureenmeagher6415 Nutjob Robin told Nik bc it was the right thing to do
I hate to say this but Carly's right about Robin leaves town all the time and she demands Jason to leave his job where he is happy with...It is all pretend.
I didn't know getting an education was a crime 😳
No, Carly threatens to take Michael if Jason doesn't do what she wants.
Tell her, Carly! Always hated the Wee One.
Tell her Carly
This was MY Carly 💕
As evil and manipulative as Carly was, she's right. Robin did try to control Jason. She saw him as a pupil she needed to teach to become a person and when he started to think for himself and didn't need her to explain everything to him anymore, she had to find other ways to control and manipulate him and running off to Europe every time Jason didn't do something she didn't want is how she did it. Robin was incredibly passive aggressive then. And she told AJ the truth because she was jealous.
Lies
@@lahdi6844 Amen!
What makes Carly’s way of manipulating better? At least Robin never used her kid. And Carly smothers Jason. No outsider was allowed to be with him unless she approved. He was never allowed to live his own life. Unfortunately Sam had to learn the hard way. At the end of the day who did the most damage?
@@iacobus4227but Jason did not mind....that's the fact.
@@sandrajohnson2741 he didn’t mind w/ Robin either, but you’re missing the point. We’re talking about who did the most damage in manipulating Jason. And it’s Sonny and Carly no question.
Team Robin all the way!
Absolutely
Robin said Carly is as COMMON AS DIRT! FACTS!
One of Robin best moments
Actually, I've always thought that about Robin.
When I want a fur coat, I say, “Hey Jason, I’d like a fur coat, please” 😂
Robin had this thing about changing Jason into the person she wanted to be. Also, i would have a problem with this chick defending Tony kidnapping Michael.
Here's what Carly fans don't realize... Robin, unlike Carly, knew who Jason was before and after the accident. Jason showed her kindness before and after the accident. So it's unfair to say Robin was trying to "change" Jason, considering the fact that she was trying to integrate both Jason Quartermaine and Jason Morgan into one. Carly couldn't handle that. Carly only knew Jason Morgan and that was the only one she knew she had control over. She resented Robin's ability to know a part of Jason that she wasn't ever able to know, herself.
You mean the man that she called Uncle? The man who bent over backwards to help Stone when he was sick? Or how about the man who was already emotionally distraught over the death of his daughter and Carly cruelly ripped away another child bc she prefers Jason to be his daddy? Robin understood that he didn't need prison just help. And the very fact that Bobbie bought Lucas on the black market and fought dirty to help keep Lucas from his aunt is right up there with Bobbie telling Robin to move aside for a fake family to appease her trash daughter. Carly's been jealous of Robin since day 1, the moment she realized Robin was Jason's girlfriend she's had it in for her, she's crossed boundaries she's had no business crossing. JnR's relationship had zero to do with Carly but she made it her business. But you go off... Defending Tony was nothing compared to the many times Carly's gotten off for premeditated murder, identity fraud, cheating men of their children bc she feels she's oh so entitled. She's vile and obnoxious. Robin may be bratty at times but she has the love and support of the town, whereas Carly's on her knees begging and manipulating to get what she wants.
@@taraherren223 Oh my word thanks for saying this, I couldn't have said it better.
The only thing Robin was right on the nose about was Carly and Jason would never be together. They tried and it just didn’t work out because Carly was and will always in love with Sonny.
Carly was in love with Jason.
Yeah they threw her at sonny I think because they saw some chemistry. Carly and Sonny didn’t really interact until before that point they slept together
Carson happened because SB was leaving and VM had left. The writers pivoted from Jarly to Carson as the supercouple because Carson became so popular. Then, Jarly became roadblocks that the writers could add for Carly’s and Jason’s relationships. What’s funny is that everyone complains about how Carly tries to ruin JaSam, but Sam is really a Carly knockoff.
Yeah, Robin used this fight with Carly to screw up her courage to go to AJ and betray Jason. Robin had ZERO problem raising Michael with Jason when Carly was in Ferncliff. She betrayed Jason b/c she couldn't stand the fact that Jason, Carly, and Michael were going to be a family, hypocritical little shrew that she is.
Agreed.....so frigging true.
@@sandrajohnson4778 -& yeah, every time she said "I did the right thing," I wanted to slap the Pwincess right out of her.
@@kaitykaity 🤣🤣🤣seriously.....that was just an excuse.....I couldn't understand how or why some people agreed with her.....that was as petty a betrayal as any.....if she was so perfect, why didn't she stay and face the music.... a coward she was.
Jason was Michael's Uncle
@@ediamonds366 - Jason was more of a father to Michael than AJ ever was.
Carly was right for once. She never lied to Jason. She always told him the truth when it ca.e to Michael. That is something that Robin and Sonny never understood. They thought Carly was using Michael to control and Manipulate him and that just wasn't the case. They never understood Jadon and Carly's relationship. They made there own judgements about what they thought was going on and both Sonny and Robin tried to Manipulate Jason into letting Carly go. Robin by telling Aj that he was Michaels father. And Sonny by seducing Carly. Both of them betraying Jason. At least Sonny admitted his mistake and was Sorry but Robin standing on her moral post declaring how right she was instead of being honest. She wasnt even honest years later when she went to see Jason In 2006 and told him that she was right for telling AJ. But the truth is when she saw Nicholas months before she was honest she said she didnt do it for AJ or Michael she did it because she was jealous of Carly and she wanted to keep Carly away from Jason.
Carly told the truth to Jason about Michael being aj quartermaine she didn't lie to him
You mean like when she told the truth about how Michael was conceived and what she did to Aj?
Carly ruined Jason’s life. All his relationships failed bc psychopath Carly was always there to contaminate them
@@littleasskicker4293 She didn’t tell AJ his real daddy
@@ashleyfinchludwig5228 Preach!
" I had to watch while he fell in love with you. While he gave you his whole soul." Well what do you expect Carly? shit she was his girlfriend before you came in the picture.
Common as dirt was right on the money
agree
what does that even mean....I need a dictionary
@@Ashleyludwig901 Google is your friend.
maybe if she didnt left town that time Jason met Carly this wouldnt have happen
oh, poor delusional Robin. She really did think very little of Jason. First, Carly moved into the Brownstone, she didn't tell Jason to come by every night, or suggest it - that was HIS choice. Then Jason said the three of them should all move in together, when Robin broke up with him.
Robin really wants a life with Jason and Michael and would love if Michael was kept away from his Mother, but Jason completely disagrees with that!
I agree! She had no problem not telling AJ he was the father of Michael as long as it was just her, Jason, and Michael. But as soon as Carly came back around after being in Ferncliff, Robin just had to tell AJ the truth, a truth that wasn't hers to tell. Carly once asked Robin, "Just because it isn't safe for you to make a baby with Jason are you jealous of mine?" Now that was harsh, but I believe Robin was jealous of Carly. Robin always acted like Carly was a puppeteer that controlled Jason and Tony, but that was never the case. Jason and Tony knew their own minds.
People were really mean to people who had ppd back then.
glad robin told time to break up the CarSason nonsense that has ruined GH
3:48 Robin, the doctor, she’s talking about Carly‘s post partum like a joke Isn’t she supposed to have some sort of code as. Doctor
I love Robin. I hate listening to her go on and on about how awful Carly is. Find a new way to deal with her.
I love Carly! Then and now. I loved watching Robin grow up but, Carly is and always will be badass!
PHD is not a vacation , it s hell on earth but years latter she wanted everyone to kiss her ring when she had PP after having Emma
I had PPD with my oldest son, and it's horrible :(
Carly and Jason already kept Michael from AJ and his family and intended to do so for as long as they could so the Q's would just be fighting dirt with dirt.
No, Carly, you wanted Jason in that position so you could throw his name around to intimidate people
Sing it!
Love Robin short cut
I hate what the writers did to Robin and Jason. The breakdown of Robin over time was painful to watch and the writers made her out to seem as tho she snapped. Jason cheated on her and choose Carly time after time even when he said he loved Robin. The 90s was the best era for GH.
Robin was so cute with her short little haircut!
She was ugly still is though
@@jarlymorgan there's absolutely nothing ugly about Kimberly then or now
Shauna The Bibliomaniac yes she was
Carly and Robin both screwed Jason over, first chance they got. Jason should have taken that kid and his yellow floppy hat, and hightailed it to the island to be with his bff Sonny. Lol!!
Sonny takes advantage too, he betrayed him first chance he got as well, with none other than Carly.
There was some truth to what Robin said to Carly. And like 99% truth in what Carly said to Robin. 😅😅
@jasoncarly I disagree... I think this was a set up... If not conciously, then subconciously. Robin had been singing the "Tell AJ" song from day 1. When she fell in love w/ Carly's family, she added the full custody & joint custody garbage in the mix. But all along this is what she wanted, but she was too much of a cowardto own up to her true motives. So she hid behind righteous indignation, and came to Carly's knowing she'd get the fuel she needed to follow thru. She just underestimated Jarly!
Robin is 100% right.
agree
The biggest lies
beatrice ITA
Carly was common as dirt and still is.Carly used Jason like nothing because he loved Micheal.
truth
You cannot use someone who was a willing participant.
I miss the Original Carly, robin looked really skinny back than, Jason looked so young too, Jason’s True Love will always be Sam, Sam is the love of his life Jasam
Carly played right into Robin's hands. It's clear to me that robin went to carly to get the adrenaline & steam to go tell aj. She sat back & listened to carly rip her apart all so she could get herself mad enough to blow carlys life apart. Since robin was angry & bitter over losing Jason, carly really should have played this one better . Maybe being fake nice & sorry they broke up. I mean if someone had info on u that would blow yr world apart ( thanks to jason telling robin overestimating she was some saint that would never betray him ) maybe dont attack them and low blow them. Maybe robin was going to tell aj no matter what bit I find it interesting that after her break up with jason she went to see carly , whom she figured would gloat & dance on her & Jason's relationship in ashes. Robin is so full of it. She did not tell aj bc it was the right thing. When carly was gone , Robin loved playing house with Jason & Michael. She even talked future plans with him. About how they would all go to europe someday or when Jason said " carly said we should get Michael a Cat " & robin said " we could have one for him " he only replied " yeah maybe " that told robin Jason was really seeing him Carly & Michael as a unit & she was on the sidelines. It also flipped her out how she saw the comfortability jason carly & micheal had. And she did start to get jealous of Micheal taking her spot as number 1 in jasons life. She made comments that shut jason down from her. Like when sonny joked " I see it's all about ur dad " & robin with sarcasm dripping " u bet " or " michael will wake up demanding another chapter from his book " years later she said to carly " u ruined our relationship when u came along with ur bastard son " that was shocking. And finally telling Jason that she told aj bc she didnt want carly to tell aj & hurt jason yet she did it first. Jason did call her out on that making no sense. Plus they broke up so jasons life & carly 's were not her buisness anymore. She also told the secret & blew town so she didnt have to see the aftermath of what she had done.
I will say carly should have acted all feeling bad & been nice to robin. It's not smart to shred someone who has a secret that will blow u out of the water.
Oh yeah I remember when Robin made the bastard son remark to Carly, I was shocked, considering Robin supposedly loved Michael, yet she would call him a bastard. I don't know why Carly didn't just punch her out for that alone!
I think I sided with Carly because there was an honesty about her that spoke to me. Robin had some good points but she was NEVER honest about her motivations. She wanted Jason to be who she wanted him to be and not who he was. Carly had so many flaws but she was honest in her motivations. Even with all of her many lies and plotting. So looking back I get why I sided with her and could not stand Robin. Especially after Robin outed Michaels parentage. She did this for the most selfish reasons. She never respected any of Jason’s choices and wanted to control him under the guise of protecting him. Sad because I think this is what ruined Robins character for me and I never liked her ever since then. Love these actresses though. They are so amazing,,
Boom Carly and you never got in Jason bed again.All you got was his friendship.By the way he is still loyal to Robin than any other.
That's because Steve left the show in 99 and they put Carly with Sonny.
Yep. Steve leaving was the whole reason for the HateSex and getting S&C together. As much as I'm Jarly4Ever, it does make perverse sense. We have the Jason/Carly/Sonny triangle to this day.
What if courtney was around that year do you think he would choose courtney over Robin like he did with Elizabeth?
Jason is loyal to Carly above all. Even the actors and actresses know it. You robin fans been in denial since she was in Jason life
onelifetolive agree, good point.
I love this speech from Carly to Robin - of course, the latter had to blab to AJ - but in doing so, she destroyed what she and Jason had. Jason and Robin were never the same after this and they were never romantically involved again. Jason has remained close to Carly (despite some intervals where they didn't speak), but no so Robin.
Robin was right to tell AJ the truth
@@TheLuscious Her motives - and timing - were suspect.
@@TheLuscious Absolutely correct.
Personally, I cheered when Robin told AJ. I don't care if it was for spite or if it was to protect Jason they had it coming. Imagine your boyfriend letting your entire town think that he cheated on you and had a baby with another woman. a woman who's disrespectful and hateful. Who has been lying to the people who you grew up with is going to be moving into the house that you all share together. I would have made an announcement over the PA system at General Hospital
I wasn't watching then but have an idea. I know Carly was manipulative and a bitch and a little evil but, in the end, Jason was Carly's touchstone and the one who truly loved her despite everything she did. Somehow, although he had that awful accident and his life was changed, he had that goodness in him and sometimes he only showed it to Carly. It was these early days of struggle that forged them together as soul mates. Not in the traditional lover soul mates way, but the soul mates that are so close that not even death could separate them.
@jasoncarly Thanks! I LOVE your channel b/c I've always been a fan of SJB's Carly & Jarly 1.0. It was Carly & Jason that got me hooked on GH in the first place. Your channel is the best!! I used to be a psych major & the depth of character Carly has was built incredibly by SJB. So being able to go back to these episode gives me greater appreciation for the character. Besides Carly is so relatable. Jarly is one of the best relationships on TV. Jason & Carly are two of the best characters. Thanks!
Carly has always been the absolute worst!
agree
i loved teenage thru early 20's Carly...i'm a big fan of Sarah Brown's. I also like Kimberly's haircut back then.
mj2kool310 me too
Carly was never a teen on the show
whiteshell1 exactly do u like this Carly
Fighting over Jason, never.
They look so young and awesome even when I go back I can't stand Robin but I appreciated when she got in a fight sanctimonious but great lines come out wonder if I could like her more if I watched longer
go carly
Truthfully i never liked robin and jason, i was glad when they broke up. But robin was right jason didn't love carly, carly was in denial.
Carly was RIGHT!! JARLY 4 LIFE
Carly was exactly right
Jason n Carly r still together
I luv Sara Brown & Tamara Braun played as Carly, Sara Brown came back as Claudia Zaccara & Tamara Braun came back as Dr Kim Nero great actresses as Carly Benson. Laura Wright has been the Longest actress to play Carly Benson
Only because the other actresses left on their own.
If I was Carly I would've punched Robin in the face!
Carly has never made excuses for what she does, she just does it. Making up excuses is everyone else's m.o. Robin doesn't like Carly because her life follows no form, she does as she wants, when she wants. I am by no means a Robin hater, but I know jealousy when I see it.
agreed
Are used to like Robin when she was younger But when she got with Jason she was self righteous...Carly never lied to Jason and yes Jason does love Carly and he always has us what Robin couldn’t stand or understand
Great scene! The look on Carly's face at the end there. Yeah Carly you better be afraid! :)
I love how they swear Carly lies all the time, but it's funny because I'd call it more like 60% truth/40% lies. Because sometimes what she says is 100% truth, like in this scene. Only because it's not what ppl want to hear or believe, mean old evil Carly is lying. When she's being completely truthful, her logic is undeniable, except to everyone who doesn't want to hear it. That's why ppl believe her lies... b/c it's exactly what they want to hear. She just did that to Lulu recently. I luv Carly!
@TheOnly1tonid, so true! Robin is far from perfect or a saint. I could never stand her, although now on the show I can tolerate her much better. But she's so judgmental, people say Liz is bad, but I think Robin is far worse in that regard. Liz at least, acknowledges that she is flawed (as does Carly) but how often has Robin taken a good long look at herself? I think Carly did a good job of throwing it in Robin's face here, although it's obvious she didn't take it to heart. She should have.
Robin needs to just go on to Paris and stay there. Can't stand that self righteous hypocrite. Carly right Robin tried to control Jason like her own personal puppet. Makes me sick. If you feel you have to change everything about someone then you don't really love them know do you
1:02 - 1:07 "The only reason you think of love is to use it an excuse for the inexcusable things that you do". I've never seen this clip, but that line...Robin read Carly to the nines. That is EXACTLY that bitch's pathology then and now.
Kudos, and beautiful acted. The absolute truth about Carly.
absolutely
I kind of totally agree with everything Carly just said to Robin.
Omfg! ROFL !!! Go Carly!
Yeah Robin Carly is Michael's MOTHER of course she's a part of it. She only told AJ to hurt everyone involved.
Too bad the bed hopping loser and the brother taking his brother's kid weren't woman or man enough to be honest in the first place. Jason lost me with always telling Robin that they would tell when Micheal, a kid, would be ready. That show destroying character would have been just fine. Stupidest thing on daytime. I do think that if the Robin actress had stayed the writers would have fixed this situation.
I would hope so.. also Jason and Sonny always bragging about how Robin's honesty was one of her best features yet Jason expected Robin to lie about Michael.
@@taraherren223 so true lol
Robin was so preachy in those days..
You still did t get Jason Carly even Sonny knew it
Okay but did Carly Lie???
God I have always thought the people of Port Charles(Robin included) are sanctimonious and hypocritical, I loved it when Carly ripped her to shreds and pointed out how Robin uses her HIV status for sympathy points
I'm not surprised Carly would stoop that low. Trash always shows itself in the end.
@@BLTKellys You misunderstand I am on Carly's side here, Robin is a sadfisher and I was glad Carly called her out for using her HIV status for sympathy
That was a very low blow.
But Carly always hits below the belt. Robin is a better person. She is not a over zealous female, ranting, whiney, selfish, self-centered bully that Carly always is. Robin ends up saving Jason's life. As far as Michael? Ends up kidnapped; shot in the head; sent to prison and raped. Yeah, AJ and the Quartermaines are such baddddd people!
@@BLTKellys Sing it!
A lot of people in the comments seem very biased in their assessment of this scene. Look Robin did a shitty thing by revealing the truth to AJ. But you can have more than one reason for doing something. Yeah it might have been out of spite and jealousy, but it could also be that she felt it was the right thing to do. She grew up surrounded by lies and a part of her (I’m not saying how much) probably felt that it wasn’t fair of Michael to never know the truth. And look, she’s not entirely wrong about Carly either. I like Carly. But she’s always believed herself to be more special than she is and often doesn’t care about the carnage she leaves behind. These two have always read one another, maybe not entirely accurate in their perceptions. Robin can be a hypocrite, she’s called herself one too. One of her issues is she does what she feels is right even knowing the potential fallout. Whereas Carly often does what she knows is wrong, believing the consequences won’t apply to her. Luckily the two of them have come to a truce over the years and left behind their antagonism. Neither were right or wrong in this situation.
Very reasonably stated. IMO, once Robin realized that she wasn't going to be able to remain with Jason on the same level, Carly was not temporary the way Jason expected in the beginning, Carly was never going to move out, away, etc., cuz Michael, and keeping the secret was just delaying the inevitable, Robin saw no reason to keep the secret anymore. Robin was under no obligation to keep that secret ever. So telling AJ wasn't ending her relationship with Jason, it was already over for all intents and purposes, and why should Robin care about the fallout, the effect it would have on anyone including Jason. So maybe Robin did try to protect/enable Jason as if he were challenged or immature, (although I think she actually saw Jason's detective/law enforcement potential and would have tried to get Mac to help Jason) well not anymore after the secret was out, Jason was a grown man and he had to accept the consequences of his actions.
Robin could have told the truth earlier if it was about "doing the right thing". She only did this after Jason broke up with her and she couldn't deal with his connection with Carly. Robin's jealousy was evident when Carly came back from Ferncliff. She didn't want Jason and Carly to end up together, pure and simple.
That's Telling The Tramp Roibin👍
Wow! Talk about a READ LOL
Robin is a judgemental snob!
And now she keeping Nina away from
Her daughter again
who cares Nina only cares about is herself dont you remember when willow first came on the show Nina treated her like trash since she was Charlotte's teacher.
ain't it funny how Robin talked about Carly's postpartum depression but didn't she gave one after she had her first child Emma... wow.. isn't that the pot calling the kettle black
I meant have
You can't really call it the pot calling the kettle black seeing as how Robin had PPD years and years after Carly did. The takes the meaning out of the phrase. That makes zero sense.
Robin made digs at Carly because she couldn't understand how Carly could just up and leave. And when she came home she never spent time with Michael alone, she was only ever with Michael if Jason or Letecia was there, if not she was off spending Jason's money. She never cared about Michael until she could use him. Robin on the other hand attempted to fight her PPD and eventually got help. It doesn't make her a hypocrite. Carly used hers to her advantage to get Jason to do everything for Michael so she wouldn't have to.
@@ahseeuh and Robin actually used what she learned in therapy to actually be able to be the mom she wanted to be while still being Robin, mom, wife, doctor, friend, daughter. Carly used hers as an excuse to be the lazy mom and lazy person in general that we all know she is.
@@taraherren223 ITA
@jasoncarly Oh great! :) I'm glad you are going to put it up! :)
Martha Stewart knockoff
@TheOnly1tonid but that would only work if sarah brown came back to portray carly ...
Kim looks a lot like Demi Lovato in this video.
Love cat fight
Wow. Both of these girls are telling the truth for once. And they are both correct. How refreshing I'm glad the writers finally got it out there. They're not putting on a show for someone else they're being real. Actually they are both neither any better than the other. It's so funny. They both have Jason as a friend and neither of these women understands the relationship that Jason has with the other. But they both supposedly understand Jason. Hahahaha
No Robin is Carly just being hateful
Oh how I love them two fighting
must be nice to be Jason I wished GUYS were the same way as women do fight over men....
@jasoncarly I love LW on her days on loving too! :)
Carly is a man eater plain & simple but Jason is the one man she can’t eat. I don’t really agree with how everyone says that Carly manipulates him. He’s not an idiot he knows exactly who Carly is, can she be controlling & jealous??? Oh yeah but most of the time Jason won’t let it fly & he calls her out on it. Robin wasn’t right in telling a secret that wasn’t hers to tell nor was she right to try to tell Jason how to live his life. He’s a grown man either you accept him or you move on coz you’re not changing anyone. Jason has to make the choice to change & give up the life end of story.
I love how Robin told Carly off lol
@jasoncarly Yeah the 1999 stuff is awesome! :) Hey don't worry I will watch the Jagger and Karen stuff! I love Jagger and Karen! :) We can have some fun! :)
I admit Robin was wrong as hell for telling aj about micheal but carly just can't come and ruin whats robin and Jason has. Classic trashy carly. But i will always love Sarah Brown as Carly!!!.
I think they both had eachothers numbers. Robin is an icy emotional bully and carly did use love to excuse the inexcusable . Remember when she sent the custody papers to Bobbie and she cried to tony I did it bc I love u so much. Please she wanted Tony to hurt Bobbie. She got over him in 2 sec when she went to jason. Then she went right to aj slept with him while stalking jasons life and spending the q money the sec age got jealous seeing him just dancing with liz she ran and offered herself to sonny. Used her uterus again to get the 4th meal ticket sonny . Good that carly is rich now bc shes most likely done using her womb to trap Rich men her last mark was jax
How is Robin the icy emotionally bully...
Carly threw Robin's HIV into her face , putting her down that she cannot give Jason a child
@@fomalhauto she bullied jason by when he did not do what she wanted. She punished him by going to Paris. Then she tells aj about michael. She did that to punish jason again. She was totally fine with the lie when she played family with jason & michael. Once Jason put michael & carly first she dumped Jason than ran to aj after a year.
@@natalieps2387 going to Paris was never about punishing Jason. Jason was shot and gave two shits about his life and Robin wasn't about to stick around and watch him die after she literally watched Stone fighting for his life only to die in her arms. The second time was after Jason told her he was moving out and in with Carly and Michael, but he wanted to keep Robin on the side..uh hello, hell no. They broke up. Her heart was shattered and she knew that once Carly got Jason alone his promises to never touch Carly again would be broken and no way was she going to watch that..Paris was never about punishing Jason although Jason marrying Courtney in Paris on Robin's birthday was cruel.
@@taraherren223 how bout when she went to italy when carly got back. She said to jason " I dont know why I always leave u etc " so she was putting Paris & italy in the same category then her telling aj was total revenge
@@taraherren223 I don't think jason expected robin to be his side piece. He said he loved her but " wherever micheal & carly are I'm gonna be " he never said " but I still want to date u" I think that was his way of ending it w/o saying the words. Robin made a decision in 97 to dump Jason & move on to paris. Jason was brain damaged he still loved her but he wasnt gonna change or beg her either. Robin returned & would have gotten back w/ jason if he did not have carly & micheal living w/ him. She thought jason 'a life would not change in the many months she was gone. He agreed to help carly & things took on a life of their own bc carly got ppd aj was dumb & did not do a dna test he just assumed bc the babys blood type matched Jason's it was his. Tony had to rule himself out knowing the blood type did not match carlys or his nor the letter or rh sign. Aj stupidly did not talk to his doctor parents that the letter b Micheal had matched his only he got the (+) sign from carly so he gave up. So the plan was unknown as carly & jason were playing it out until tony or aj claimed Micheal. That did not happen. Then carly had ppd & left town. I agree it was wrong to just dump her newborn preemie with a heart defect who barely survived surgery w/ jason but she had no mom or anyone to help. Her adopted mom had a stroke & she decided not to tell Bobbie & she was suffering. She is very lucky she went to jason bc of shes didnt & left that baby would have went to foster care & seeing how tony obsessed he would have taken Micheal legally I guess that's all moot bc if Jason threw her out she was screwed. She would have had to tell aj I think. Jason actually suggested she tell aj when she told him she was leaving. But she begged him to take Michael & he agreed. He was not ok w/ all this from the day carly showed up. Then while carly was away & jason was alone he bonded hard core w/ micheal. So when robin got home Jason's life changed dramatically. So in a nutshell robin had to at least consider Jason could move on to a new situation that became impossible bc of his vice like grip on Micheal & it was frustrating as hell for robin bc the baby was not his so she had this info that could change things for her & get rid of carly. Maybe if she told aj in april jason may have forgiven her but she waited til over a year to tell so jasam bonded w/ time to where he was starting to lie. After his big soliloquy to carly that he cant lie he was getting good at it like at ferncliff. He was lying all the time & coming up w/ whoppers. I think that made robin nuts too that jason was changing. He was able to lie for Carly & imo that in a way was a good sign that his brain was healing bc he was picking up things. Yea u hang out with a pathological liar like carly ull start lying too. Plus robin could see that Jason was now more comfortable w/ carly.
@jasoncarly Hahaha! What year of Jagger and Karen are you going to put up?