Yes and it's disgusting how we have to blur the definition just to pat men on the back 😆 ig history does repeat itself, we are bowing down to what they want again.
why aren't people having these same issues with transgender men?? Now biological women aren't allowed to call themselves women?? The oppression never ends for us!!
@@magentacyan6086 or because transwomen are louder than transmen 😆. Also, it goes to show how you guys don't care about history, how women fought for equality. In the past being born female was a sign of bad luck for some cultures. Maybe people should learn to respect us for a change.
As a woman I feel incredibly insulted by this. After all the efforts by women's rights campaigners over the past 100 years to come to this. The world gets more evil by the day.
I feel your pain. Women have won these battle in the past and got more rights, now people hold up a sign saying women's rights and no-one has a clue what it means. This will only get worse and does nothing to help real women. I remember a time when people knew what a woman is.
I refuse to believe, that these people are for real. They know what they are doing, and think that the public has dementia the same way as the president. This is offensive to say the least.
Don't be surprised. This world is coming to an end, things are only going to get worse, morally speaking. Have you ever read the book "The Great Controversy" by Ellen White? It's a must read nowadays, to understand where we are heading to.
If someone cannot define what a man/woman is,they should be fired from any position they currently hold. They are too dangerous to take any decision about human beings,if they cannot distinguish between men and women.
i'd argue that distinguishing men and women can be quite the task at times, and isn't the same as defining what they are. first half good, second half ruined it.
@@nicewhenearnedrudemostlyel489 Sometimes distinguishing between the two is also needed. An example would be social protection programs for women. They are not made for men. If one cannot define what a woman is and works at a position where it will be mandatory to be able to define and distinguish between the two genders, then this person could leave women out of the program and care about males that identify as women, making the whole program meaningless. Just an example.
State of mind is used by transgender to compete in women sports a person’s believes or feelings should not violate women’s sports How about transgender having their own sports?
Most of us are all being to polite and looking the other way, we have to start challenging their logic so the flaws become more apparent. I don’t know the WAY but this path is not it
Talk about stumbling over his words whoever that bloke is...How absolutely absurd that our politicians have to even discuss such a subject!! Last time I thought about it is a woman can give birth and a man can’t. Jesus help us all 🤬🤬
@@kristenjoyce2180 How long will God put up with people vandalizing His creations? People playing God (or Devil) with reassignment surgeries, men giving birth by medical manipulations and such. Unnatural and repulsive.
This is what happens when ideas interacts with language, interacts with politics, interacts with power, interacts with myths, interacts with reality, interacts with post truths, interacts with abstractions, interacts with nature, interacts with religion, interacts with archetypes, interacts with social institutions......we create a Tower of Babel. The question is as ridiculous as the answer/s. "Can anyone provide me with a simple definition of 'woman'?" "No!" The problem stems from intelligence, and language....the smarter we get, the more complexity is built into language. The greater the complexity, the taller the Tower of Babel.
I want to suggest that to all such legislation inquiries we should add one simple but very healthy question: "What if I am wrong?", and then listen, please do not interrupt. In other words, we give chance those sitting behind the bench to present their values and leadership qualities by answering the question. If they refuse to answer, they should not be given the right to hold those positions. Of course, we could be more proactive, and let them make public declaration before they are offered those positions. What is a government without people capable of promoting the leadership mindset? Beware, Leadership is about the right qualities, not a position.
Our Suffragette grannies and Feminist mothers would be disgusted to learn "woman" doesn't rate a definition. It's not difficult, even the pm could give an acceptable answer. I hope our esteemed government was able provide an adequate response when provided a period to ponder the question. REALLY?
This question reveals so so much it's not even funny, if ever you have doubts about whether certain people or groups of people don't care about facts unless they benefit financially from facts, just ask them this question in a public setting.
Please please keep on fighting for women and their rights. Thank you to both men and women who are doing this and being brave and standing up. This is really about women being able to feel safe and confident, it has nothing to do with discrimination and transphobia. I was so disappointed to read that the Cambridge dictionary now has added another definition to woman, one that states it is also how one identifies and may not be based on biology.
Sultan bahoo 🕌 PAKISTAN 🇵🇰 (Australia 🇦🇺 senate Boss) Australian 🇦🇺 senaters study list Alex antic on no 2( Khalid Moon future pakistani 🇵🇰 australian 🇦🇺 senater in 2031 after Melbourne baiada spinchler vision 2030) 1:30 AM..
They do define women ultimately, but the definition of a woman is anyone who identifies as a woman. The definition of a man is anyone who identifies as a man. Very simple.
@@Cha4k Gender wage gap will always exist. Like women earn more in the model and p*rn industry than men, men earn more in the athletics section than women. Demand is the defining factor for what you get paid.
A woman was earning thousands a month from selling her farts in a jar. I dont need to hear again it's hard for women these days or hard to make an income. She was earning thousands a month!!!
I know what a woman is. Does that make me a pervert? This man being questioned literally said us women are "contested"....so basically yes men are colonizing. Those are the real perverts. Funny how anyone on the TRA or bust campaign seems to accuse everyone else of what they really are.
So the health department no longer can identify what a woman is? I think I'm over qualified to take the minister of health job.
Surely there's a couple of 6 year olds that could fill these positions better.
Now our education is crippled....top professor and legislators can't even define men and women.... what a sham
Women have been robbed of their own being.
Yes and it's disgusting how we have to blur the definition just to pat men on the back 😆 ig history does repeat itself, we are bowing down to what they want again.
This is how cowardly our bureaucratic class has become, when not offending someone becomes more important then reality
why aren't people having these same issues with transgender men?? Now biological women aren't allowed to call themselves women?? The oppression never ends for us!!
Okay fine, what’s the definition of a man?
@@jlev20 your mom. 😅
Cause men don't have a lobby that disagrees when the term is put into different usage.
@@magentacyan6086 or because transwomen are louder than transmen 😆. Also, it goes to show how you guys don't care about history, how women fought for equality. In the past being born female was a sign of bad luck for some cultures. Maybe people should learn to respect us for a change.
only guy I've seen who makes any sense in Australian politics
Absolutely Ted.
As a woman I feel incredibly insulted by this. After all the efforts by women's rights campaigners over the past 100 years to come to this. The world gets more evil by the day.
We men are offended by this too. It is shear stupidity nothing less.
I feel your pain. Women have won these battle in the past and got more rights, now people hold up a sign saying women's rights and no-one has a clue what it means. This will only get worse and does nothing to help real women. I remember a time when people knew what a woman is.
I refuse to believe, that these people are for real. They know what they are doing, and think that the public has dementia the same way as the president. This is offensive to say the least.
It's only biological women who can solve this madness if they don't stand together the meaning of a woman will be deleted
Don't be surprised. This world is coming to an end, things are only going to get worse, morally speaking. Have you ever read the book "The Great Controversy" by Ellen White? It's a must read nowadays, to understand where we are heading to.
If someone cannot define what a man/woman is,they should be fired from any position they currently hold.
They are too dangerous to take any decision about human beings,if they cannot distinguish between men and women.
i'd argue that distinguishing men and women can be quite the task at times, and isn't the same as defining what they are. first half good, second half ruined it.
@@nicewhenearnedrudemostlyel489 Sometimes distinguishing between the two is also needed. An example would be social protection programs for women. They are not made for men.
If one cannot define what a woman is and works at a position where it will be mandatory to be able to define and distinguish between the two genders, then this person could leave women out of the program and care about males that identify as women, making the whole program meaningless.
Just an example.
What is your definition of a woman?
A Professor who can't tell fact from fiction, God help Australia. PLEASE.
They support woman’s rights but can’t give a definition of what it means
Yeah basically how clowns will act
Political Correctness run amok
I identify as a teenager. 40 is only my biological/chronological age. Being a teen is a state of mind, man.
I identify myself as a 90 white man. I demand my retirement.
I identify as an 8 foot 6 inch norwegian woman
State of mind is used by transgender to compete in women sports a person’s believes or feelings should not violate women’s sports
How about transgender having their own sports?
I identify as the president of earth, you're all welcome to stay as long as you obey
Jeez, how embarrassing.
The fear of these people is hard to watch
Most of us are all being to polite and looking the other way, we have to start challenging their logic so the flaws become more apparent. I don’t know the WAY but this path is not it
This^
Definition of a woman is so easy, "it's my mum and your mum"....
Talk about stumbling over his words whoever that bloke is...How absolutely absurd that our politicians have to even discuss such a subject!! Last time I thought about it is a woman can give birth and a man can’t. Jesus help us all 🤬🤬
You're real fragile aren't you.
You know men have given birth right.
@@kristenjoyce2180 f Witt
@@debra7671 google
@@kristenjoyce2180 How long will God put up with people vandalizing His creations? People playing God (or Devil) with reassignment surgeries, men giving birth by medical manipulations and such. Unnatural and repulsive.
Are you having a problem getting a book down from the top shelf. No problem, just identify as a giraffe and problem solved!
This is what happens when ideas interacts with language, interacts with politics, interacts with power, interacts with myths, interacts with reality, interacts with post truths, interacts with abstractions, interacts with nature, interacts with religion, interacts with archetypes, interacts with social institutions......we create a Tower of Babel.
The question is as ridiculous as the answer/s.
"Can anyone provide me with a simple definition of 'woman'?"
"No!"
The problem stems from intelligence, and language....the smarter we get, the more complexity is built into language. The greater the complexity, the taller the Tower of Babel.
Woman- adult human female
Female is genetic, woman is social. Not same.
@@BbVortexMortinghan no you're wrong. Most people don't subscribe to the Gender Fairy and its whack ideology.
That's not an argument. I don't believe in a gender fairy and it's ideology is therefore null, nerd.
@@BbVortexMortinghan biological facts and scientific terms shouldn't bamboozle you then
Define female.
I want to suggest that to all such legislation inquiries we should add one simple but very healthy question: "What if I am wrong?", and then listen, please do not interrupt. In other words, we give chance those sitting behind the bench to present their values and leadership qualities by answering the question. If they refuse to answer, they should not be given the right to hold those positions. Of course, we could be more proactive, and let them make public declaration before they are offered those positions. What is a government without people capable of promoting the leadership mindset? Beware, Leadership is about the right qualities, not a position.
Someday, machines will look back upon this moment in history to remember that they did the right thing.
Jeeeez. It's like anything you ask in Senate Estimates is on notice 😅
How comical is this it’s not surprising but very concerning these clowns are running the circus none of us wanted to be a part of
This is the bloke that’s been telling us how to run our lives for the past 2 and a half years. What a joke.
Bunch of cowards.
What a simple question what's wrong with these people.😤
Our Suffragette grannies and Feminist mothers would be disgusted to learn "woman" doesn't rate a definition. It's not difficult, even the pm could give an acceptable answer. I hope our esteemed government was able provide an adequate response when provided a period to ponder the question. REALLY?
It's interesting that an old man is participating in this make believe.
Absolutely ridiculous 🙄
It’s a very contested space? What garbage!
That doctor should loose his license
What a disgrace
A human female....(fire the incompetent)
And these people are most likely on 200k, 300k 400k 500k ++ , ??? $$$$, maybe more a year ???.... and virtually unsackable / job for life ??
He is scared out of his wits !
I identify as a wallaby but can you tell me what a wallaby is?
No need to ask who’s really running this country. How is it these unelected activist groups wheel so much power over these Australian bureaucrats.
This question reveals so so much it's not even funny, if ever you have doubts about whether certain people or groups of people don't care about facts unless they benefit financially from facts, just ask them this question in a public setting.
A woman is an adult human with female DNA.
What a joke .
UNBELIEVABLE! All of these fake people are in denial. No attempt in honesty. Five on the panel and only one mumbles a nonsensical response.
The scary part is, the one that answered, is a doctor.
Professor. God help us!
ppl can't answer because everyone knows the standards drop so much the word lost it's meaning.
Ketanji, just put on the US Sup Ct for affirmative action, couldn't define a "woman" either
It's hard to believe these are grown Adults. Their minds have turned to a dog's breakfast.
We are returning to monke.
Human evolution back to ape 😂
I identify as a law abiding criminal
What a bunch of cowards ! How simple is that question ?
How are they gonna shut down a owners store and I day I would like to say I would like to be their
This is hilarious. A woman is born with an x and another X chromosome.
A woman who gives birth.
sick just sick
Can we ask what a man is?🤷♀️
He also asks about man
hilarious / embarrassing.
The outcome was?
Ugh.
I love Big Brother.
Biologically speaking, he could have answered it easily.
He wasn't asked to answer it biologically.
It was a political question.
It requires a political definition, not a biological one.
To answer in biological terms is to infer there are non biological types of women lol
Debate in parliament concerning a 10 year old child homework, is to ask their father about their ejeculations
Very simple question 🤔Western Civilization going to humiliation disgusting ending,
But I'm not a women at all
Pretty typical of the woke LNP
A woman: people that are born with a female physical body
Please please keep on fighting for women and their rights. Thank you to both men and women who are doing this and being brave and standing up. This is really about women being able to feel safe and confident, it has nothing to do with discrimination and transphobia. I was so disappointed to read that the Cambridge dictionary now has added another definition to woman, one that states it is also how one identifies and may not be based on biology.
Sultan bahoo 🕌 PAKISTAN 🇵🇰 (Australia 🇦🇺 senate Boss) Australian 🇦🇺 senaters study list Alex antic on no 2( Khalid Moon future pakistani 🇵🇰 australian 🇦🇺 senater in 2031 after Melbourne baiada spinchler vision 2030) 1:30 AM..
🤡🤡🤡
They do define women ultimately, but the definition of a woman is anyone who identifies as a woman. The definition of a man is anyone who identifies as a man. Very simple.
But what are they identifying as?
If that was the norm then our hospitals would be doomed.
Congrats Everyone Who Is Early & Found This Comment!” ☘️💰🧿
It's a mistake asking men about what a woman is or isn't. They haven't got a forkin' clue, regardless of who they are!
Ha, Ha ! I think you're wrong about that "Melody"; however you identify.
For me women is a women men is a men women 👧👦👰👰👰🤵🤵🤵🤵🤵
Say what?
??????
How about this, a woman is a person. A man is a person. Simple really. End of this foolishness.
@@Cha4k Gender wage gap will always exist. Like women earn more in the model and p*rn industry than men, men earn more in the athletics section than women. Demand is the defining factor for what you get paid.
Get fuked. If I put bread in a kettle it doesn't make it toast
A woman was earning thousands a month from selling her farts in a jar. I dont need to hear again it's hard for women these days or hard to make an income. She was earning thousands a month!!!
Everyone is being distracted by the question itself. Focus on why this pervert cares so much
I know what a woman is. Does that make me a pervert? This man being questioned literally said us women are "contested"....so basically yes men are colonizing. Those are the real perverts. Funny how anyone on the TRA or bust campaign seems to accuse everyone else of what they really are.
The idiots he is asking are making decisions for women. How can they do that without defining what one is Simple question.