There's one moment I was a bit unsure about: The 'Faster We Go, Faster We Go' bit in Harvey To The Rescue. I think Baldwin sings it better, but Angelis conveys the tone better.
Michael Angelis, Ringo Starr, and George Carlin are my top three favourite narrators in that order. But Alec Baldwin who is my fourth favourite has quite a nice voice which gives the episodes he narrates a nice touch. I really do like the softness of Alec's voice.
@@ChampaRealLordChampa I feel it would make sense for the narrator to refer to him as Sir Topham Hatt and the characters to call him the fat controller,except when he is actually at the scene their in
Eh, I think they both have their strengths and weaknesses though Baldwin definitely nailed the more action packed scenes. Some say Baldwin wasn't as good in Season 6 as he was in Season 5, and while I agree to an extent he still did pretty well considering his investment in narrating was waning by that point (divorce with Basinger and failure of Magic Railroad and all). Angelis was better with the gentler scenes and his voice had an eerieness to the creepier stuff.
I Think George Carlin Is Better Than Ringo Starr And Michael Angelis From Series 1 To 4. And I Think Alec Baldwin Is Better Than Michael Angelis From Series 5 To 6. And Also I Think Michael Angelis Is Better Than Michael Brandon And Alec Baldwin From Series 6 To 12 Including Calling All Engines, Hero Of The Rails, Misty Island Rescue, Day Of The Diesels, And Blue Mountain Mystery. And I Think Michael Brandon Is Better Than Michael Angelis From Series 13 To 16. Why? Because I Like it!
There's one moment I was a bit unsure about: The 'Faster We Go, Faster We Go' bit in Harvey To The Rescue. I think Baldwin sings it better, but Angelis conveys the tone better.
Can you do a part 3 of this then?
0:28 "A-a-a-a and there's a fogman's coat."
"I CAN'T!"
- Alec
George Carlin is my favorite Thomas narrator.
What About Michael Brandon
@@Ptbf2002 He’s terrible. Worst narrator of Thomas and Friends without a doubt.
1:11 what a stressing voice, makes Gordon almost tired
0:41
Aggh, botheration. We're stuck!
0:45
Bothe-Ration! We're shhhthoock!
Yeeah, Baldwin did that better cause the sudden transition back to the front of the boat made it hilarious
0:42 oh botheration
Michael Angelis, Ringo Starr, and George Carlin are my top three favourite narrators in that order. But Alec Baldwin who is my fourth favourite has quite a nice voice which gives the episodes he narrates a nice touch. I really do like the softness of Alec's voice.
Same bro
I don’t give a fuck about stupid Angelis i hate him so much thank god he’s in hell
My all time favorite narrators are George Carlin, Ringo Starr, Alec Baldwin, Michael Brandon and Pierce Brosnan.
To be fair Baldwin screaming as cranky was better than angelies
I absolutely love alecs portrayal of sir topham hat, gives him so much character
1:08 I didn't expect you to use the 2005 renarration with Hartshorne.
0:08 Chris Griffin is that you
Sounds like Seth Green took over lol
Imagine if Seth Green narrated Thomas
@Anthony Robinson Seth Green would be amazing at a UK CGI James voice
@Anthony Robinson in the Thomas Robot Chicken sketch, he plays James and it sounds just like Keith Wickham James
The more I listen to it, and picture it…. It sounds just like him…. 😂
I'll be honest. Why is there even a U.S narration? The show is about a British railway.
Cultural Differences, such as changing the Fat controller into just Sir Topham Hatt. It was culturally insensitive in the states I guess
@@ChampaRealLordChampa due to overweight issues XD
@@ChampaRealLordChampa and Sir Topham Hatt has been made the character’s name worldwide (including the UK)!
@@ChampaRealLordChampa I feel it would make sense for the narrator to refer to him as Sir Topham Hatt and the characters to call him the fat controller,except when he is actually at the scene their in
Where did you get high quality cottage of Angelis’ re-narration of Gordon Takes A Tumble?
0:45 "Botheration!", said the Fat Controller. "We're stuck!" And they were.
They both are very different narrators with very different appeals. They both appeal to me in different ways.
alec baldwin have more emotion in some seasons and episodes than michael angelis
His acting in Henry’s ep is great the stutter is something that somebody would do in a situation like that
Alec baldwin was funny in this scene 0:09
0:08 Me when DJ Cook asks me if i could help him on getting jallerbo's channel deleted because jallerbo won't listen to me
The first one's definitely a good example. Baldwin definitely did better with the line, "I CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN'T!!!!!!!!"
Ringo Starr, George Carlin, Michael Angelis and Alec Baldwin have their peak moments, when they do, the episodes are always bangers.
0:08 Alec Baldwin (US): I CAAAANNNNNTTTT!!!!
0:20 Micheal Angelis (UK): I can’t…. 😢
Yup i agree mr conductor did a good job
0:55
I 848% Agreed
The last part...Michael's narration was different than the original.
Lol. Michael’s is the original because Thomas the Tank Engine has its origin in the UK.
That’s why the UK dub is better
That’s because in Gordon Takes a Tumble, he uses Michael Angelis narration with the New Music which is from a Season 9 airing.
I C A N T
Eh, I think they both have their strengths and weaknesses though Baldwin definitely nailed the more action packed scenes. Some say Baldwin wasn't as good in Season 6 as he was in Season 5, and while I agree to an extent he still did pretty well considering his investment in narrating was waning by that point (divorce with Basinger and failure of Magic Railroad and all).
Angelis was better with the gentler scenes and his voice had an eerieness to the creepier stuff.
All other Thomas narrators will always be better them both of them and Michael Brandon any day
I Think George Carlin Is Better Than Ringo Starr And Michael Angelis From Series 1 To 4. And I Think Alec Baldwin Is Better Than Michael Angelis From Series 5 To 6. And Also I Think Michael Angelis Is Better Than Michael Brandon And Alec Baldwin From Series 6 To 12 Including Calling All Engines, Hero Of The Rails, Misty Island Rescue, Day Of The Diesels, And Blue Mountain Mystery. And I Think Michael Brandon Is Better Than Michael Angelis From Series 13 To 16. Why? Because I Like it!
#AlecBaldwin
Anglies starr Carlin the three best
0:55 seriously 😒 that doesn’t even sound any close to a Lady Hatt
But it´s Sir Topham Hatt who said that not Lady Hatt
Umm thats sir topham hatt
@@cobyamador5382 Yes!, That is what i said stupid Sara Martinez! 👆
Michael Angelis will always be better than Alec Baldwin, this video just proves it
Bruh your disrespecting uk fans I think Michael Angelis and Alec Baldwin is fine
Right. It's not like there are ANY UK fans who disrespect US fans.
I don't agree with this video
U CRAZY
0:56