Drummer reacts to "Supper's Ready" (Live) by Genesis
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 12. 2023
- So my first "Supper's Ready" video a long time ago was pretty shitty... and I was told the live performance was so much better. So, here we are. Let's get this journey through the end of the world started. Are you with me?
Link to original content (Please support the artist! I'm just giving my opinion, go get the real deal.)
• Genesis - Supper's Rea...
If you’d like to donate to the channel or just show your appreciation, all the details are below. All donations and tips that come from you, go into my daughters college fund and a fund for channel equipment. I created this channel for her so she has videos of her father talking and doing something he enjoys(listening to music and talking about it) since I don’t have any of those of my father. I decided that all funds that might come from this will go to her as well :) thank you again for your generosity guys, I appreciate yo all more then you will ever know.
Your name will be added to the Thank you supporters’ video that plays at the end of every video and you get to pick a video for me to react to. Thank you so much!! If you donate and pick a song, I will get to it in under 72 HOURS
▶️ PAYPAL◀️
www.paypal.me/L33REACTS
@L33Reacts
🔴PATREON🔴
www.patreon.com/L33Reacts
🔶️CONTACT ME 🔶️
L33REACTSYT@GMAIL.COM
IF YOU ARE IN A BAND ARE INTERESTED IN BEING FEATURED ON NEWSDAY, PLEASE SEND YOUR BEST SINGLE AND A PICTURE OF YOUR LOGO TO L33ReactsYT@gmail.com
All rights to this song belong to whoever they belong to, this is just a video containing commentary on the song and falls under fair use
#genesis #petergabriel #philcollins #stevehackett #tonybanks - Hudba
well... this one was a doozy for sure. Peter Gabriel is one of the greatest creative minds and voices of this generation.... Which is insane because there are so many. He brings so much to the table... vocals... instruments... creative writing... lyrics... props and costumes... what else can he do??
Thank you so much for watching y'all! It means the world to me, it really does. If you want to help support the channel, please consider liking this video and subscribing to the channel.
If you would like to make a request or just send a request or donation, here's how!
www.paypal.me/L33REACTS
WWW.PATREON.COM/L33REACTS
Thank you so much. A donation of any amount will get your named added to the supporter video that plays at the end of every video.
He is in my top 3 all time
i love the version better with phil collins live 1976
@@yvesthivierge5706 Both amazing. I too like Phil's a lot.
@@rogerwebb7501 Lucky you. 15' away! I've seen the Bataclan video but a long time ago. Have to check that out again. I saw The Musical Box perform 'Watcher of the Skies' in Nov. and was stunned by the visuals. I see how very avant-garde Genesis was. Very effective. I don't know how they did it. Primitive by today's standard, but still stunning.
@@rk41gator Not that lucky! The post you answered seems to have mysteriously disappeared! The truth about this 'live' video seems unpalatable.
No computers, no autotune, no shit, just five master musicians doing their best. Perfect!
Hardly 'perfect! Most of what you see (and, especially, hear) is mimed/dubbed! BTW the 4k version that The Genesis Museum has put out is.....well, less imperfect!
@@rogerwebb7501true for the video, But the audio underneath Is from an unaltered live performance (even if it's from a different date). The new 4k version has the original audio, But it's basically a live in studio performance, so that version is actually mimed, But still Is a mix from different live takes.
Yessss
Capolavoro
Insane brilliance
The best live performance of this song, for me, is the one on "Seconds Out."
I heard it's amazing! I'll have to check it out.
you should its amazing for some best album live of all time @@L33Reacts
When I need some Genesis I listen to Seconds Out
The build up to the crescendo gets me every time. Peter, Mike and Tony, met while at Charterhouse school, boarding school. This track is always spectacular.
Cant believe this is 50 years old ; they were in their 20s and clearly way ahead of their times
In those days, there weren't complex mixing boards, so it took several minutes to program the guitars and keyboards. Peter came up with these stories to bridge the gaps between songs. Great reaction, Lee.
Mainly to cover the gaps as the 12-string guitars were tuned.
Great reaction! I saw Steve Hackett last month with his band, and they performed "Suppers Ready." He plays an incredible solo at the end of the song that brings the house down. He's new tour is featuring selections from the Lamb album and additional early Genesis tracts. Check his website to see if he'll be in your area. Great concert for Early Genesis fans.
Hey John thanks man! I appreciate it. This was utterly magnificent. I know the audio is a tad worky compared to the studio but the visual performance more then makes up for it. I would love to catch Steve's band. I'll keep an eye out.
Thank you for your information. About a month ago I saw the tour dates, but not the program. Steve continues Foxtrot at Fifty in the USA in March and ends in Mexico in April.
The new tour The Lamb Highlights+solo is coming in July, starting in Belgium, 3 concerts in Holland are already sold out, Denmark, Germany and the UK, new dates may be added.
Lee-- there are other updated vids from the classic Genesis /Gabriel era on y-tube. They've been remastered and 'revamped'--the visuals and presentation are fantastic. Search 'em out,guy! :-) T@@L33Reacts
Your awe reminded me of my first time seeing Genesis -- It was just before Peter left the group during the Lamb Lies Down on Broadway tour -- I had never seen or heard them before -- I didnt even know they were a thing -- I just went to a local college concert hall and I had never seen anything like them before or since -- the WHOLE concert from start to finish was one non stop song that reached inside me and changed the way i experience music forever -- you could hear a pin drop with no clapping or cheering for the entire I believe it was 1 and 45 min -- I remember that I could not take my eyes off Peters preformance -- I do remember too that the rest of the band seemed to blend into the background and were never once highlighted -- when the last note was struck the entire crowd sat there for a couple moments like we were held in a spell then exploded into deafening appreciation for what we had witnessed -- I eagerly went to the local record store the next day and to my surprise and delight I discovered that they had so many other albums already there for me to enjoy -- I ended up with all of them ---
Remember this is 50 years ago, amazing time :)
And these guys were barely 20! Like what??? Does not compute lol
I love Peter. This sounds exactly like the album. If you get a chance watch this whole show.
Imagine I saw this as a 15 year old in 1972 wasn’t sure what I was witnessing just magical. One gig in 73 At the end Peter was suspended from a high wire amazing 👌🎶🎹🎤
the joy on your face as you watch the craziness is heartening. it is incredible that it's all on film. we're so lucky. (these guys were kids... it's incredible. in the states, they'd still have been on their parent's health insurance.... they're so young. peter was 22 when supper's ready came out.)
look for the live "the musical box", also. it's out there.
I saw Peter Gabriel last October in Detroit. New album. He hasn't lost a beat. His songwriting and his showmanship are on par with the best of them..
I'm gonna have to try and catch a show of his... I need too while I still can.
I was there at LCA too - very good show!
Hello to Dave and Scott from Grosse Pointe. I was at the amazing LCA show also.
UNBELIEVABLE....there's nothing better
You should definitely check out "Genesis on Belgian TV 1972" on youtube. Its a 45 minute video of them playing live in a TV studio. The version of Giant Hogweed is fantastic.
I'll check it out! Thanks bro 🙏
I can't think of anyone, other than David Gilmour, who plays his guitar with such emotion and expression as Steve Hackett..
Andy Latimer
do not be deceived, there is more going on than you might imagine, This whole story resonates with the pre christian bonding between the Lord and his people. where the supper begins the Sabbath. sheer joy. The two thousand year longing is being fulfilled in our day. The ending is so angelic and majestic. A prophecy fulfilled at last.
wow j'avais jamais vu Tony Bank jouer de la guitare!
The fella who edited that video was Phillip Howe. The brother of Steve Howe from Yes.
Oh no shit really?? That's crazy. What a small world lol
I never listened to 70s Genesis until several years ago. Imagine my shock after thinking Genesis was just a Pop Rock band 😱
That must have been quite a shock. I know it was for me too. Abacab was the second song I did i think... and to my surprise that was.... nothing compared to what was coming lol
@@L33Reacts it was crazy to hear Firth of Fifth and Suppers Ready.
So maybe we can chat on your channel.
Are you an Old School Gamer?
I've only played 1st and 2nd edition D&D. The first time I played was 1980, Freshmen year in college. I knew nothing about the game. We played until 3am, and all I wanted to do was keep playing.
How about you?
Imagine the disappointment of someone into Genesis since Nursery Cryme, then they went 'Pop'. I've never forgiven them!!
@@lemming9984 Phil Collins knew what he was doing. He followed the money.
“There’s no Genesis song that would’ve sounded anything like it did if I hadn’t been around,” Banks says later. “If you don’t like Genesis, I’m what you don’t like.
Stunned that I have this to look forward to! Another revelatory (!) song from my mid-teens. I hope to join you if the kids are down. The song is of course phenomenal ❤❤❤❤
I hope you can make it! It was a fantastic performance.... and when Peter sheds the darkness at the end... wow. Just wow.
@@L33Reacts Among my top prog songs, this, CTTE, and Gates are tied. This was the first among those to touch my heart from the 3 12-strings (Tony plays one!) at the start to the apocalyptic keys and the final guitar fade at the very end. Pure magic ❤️
Great reaction to an amazing performance! We are so fortunate that this was filmed and focused on the band! My son and I saw Steve Hacket's band perform this a year ago and Steve included an extended solo at the end. Spectacular! Then we saw Peter perform 2 months ago and here he was 50 years later performing at top level. No Genesis pieces, but a very memorable night!
The Genesis Tribute band "The Musical Box" has been doing the Best Genesis tours for over 20+years know I've seen them about 13 times now and the do "Exact" tours with Gears, Stage set up and set list !! Tony Banks helped them many years ago to all the master tapes and filled them in on how they did it all in every way, the found and bought all vintage gear or had it made. Rickenbacker made them a Dbl-neck and early on Hackett loaned the Guitarist his vintage very rare Eco-Plex tape delay until he found his own !! So many things like this. Their home page has changed over the years but all the Gen member endorses what they do and Hackett and Collins said once the do our song "Perfect" and our line up was only together some 5yrs TMB has been around 20 years and perfected all our song !! Steve Peter and Phil have all brought their kids to their shows when the were young and sid this is what your Daddy did years ago !!! Lol
The have many video on YT and I have the best ones save, just let me know I'll post them !!
Over the years the do tous like they were so one years the would do the complete "Foxtrot" tour another "The Lamb" tour, then go back to the "Nursery" tour or "SEP" the are Just Amazing and it's just like I remember from 1973-75' like going back in time !! 👍✌
www.themusicalbox.net/
www.themusicalbox.net/bio.php?lang=en....
www.themusicalbox.net/dates.php?lang=en...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Musical_Box_(band)
A flower?
Great reaction man. Truly brilliant music that has stood the test of time. Great to see young people connecting and appreciating this masterpiece. Supper's Ready is the epitome of 70s Progressive Rock. You must check out more Genesis, Firth Of Fifth, Ripples, In The Cage, Afterglow. The live performances of these are off the scale. Enjoy your discovery of more of music's true brilliant bands, Timeless.
A just brilliant performance by Genesis!
Excellent choice! This is definitely my favorite live version of the song 😃
Glad you enjoyed it Haley! I had a great time with this. Probably one of the best songs I've ever heard. Paired with this insane performance.... wow. What else can you say?
We'll end with a whistle,
We'll end with a bang!
And all of us fit in our places..."
-"Pythagoras with the looking glass reflects the full moon,
In blood he is writing the lyrics of a brand new tune....And It's...
--Hey babe with your guardian eyes so blue...
Etc..."
There is no band or song like Supper's ready live. I mean Yes back then did some great stuff but still nothing like Supper's ready. All these years later & it still stands by itself.
Genesis were given the name in 1967 by an ex- Charterhouse pupil called Jonathan King who was
a singer, songwriter and producer at the time, he produced their first 3 singles and the album Genesis to Revelation, the album was put in the religious section in music stores and only sold 649 copies. unfortunately In September 2001 Jonathan King was convicted of an unforgivable crime and sent to prison for 7 years.
Those of us who weren't aware of Genesis until later are so fortunate to have this. Most of the show was released on the DVD with the surround sound version of Selling England by the Pound. Peter BSd stories to cover for Tony, Mike and Steve who were tuning their 12 string guitars (a pain in the ass).
Is that what that was in the beginning?? I was wondering what the hell was going on.
Classic Prog Royalty the Genesis "Peter Gabriel" Ers 1970'-75' 👍
And routinely voted Classic Progs Greatest Epic by Prog Magazines yearly poll 🏆🎶
Now and then Yes - Close to the Edge is voted #1 but it's always CTTE and Supper's Ready in the Top 2 spots !! 👍🎼
@@kbrewski1 Yes Supper Ready is Amazing !! 🎶
Steve Hacket still performs Genesis songs with his amazing band of musicians, if they come your way, go see them, you will not be disappointed .
They’ve remastered the Midnight Special video of live Musical Box and it’s totally worth the re-watch!
Yes, excellent, especially for younger people.
However, both performed songs. Genesis started with Watcher Of The Skies.
Great reaction. I didn't play a note on that song, but I'm pleased you enjoyed it 😊
I saw them around this time at Toronto's fabled sonic shrine Massey Hall. 'Selling England by the Pound'. Incredible musical performance only enhanced by Peter's theatricality.
Was briefly puzzled by your reference to a "touring member", an extra support player after Mike picked up the Rickenbacher double neck after having previously identifying Steve and Mike on acoustics. Nevermind, no worries. 😅😊❤
a few month's ago I atched PG Live doing his last I/O tour, he has not give in on any of his creativity, his voice is about as good as in the past. One artist who gave me so much joy and over the last 50 years, he is lonely at the top of my list man. Great video Lee. I keep pushing the Secret World Live. Keep on the good video's man.
Simply extraordinary in every aspect. A true dazzling gem.
One word. Brilliant.
L33: I guarantee you that Phil wasn't bored during the section called "Apocalypse In 9/8" where Tony's soloing for quite a while over that riff you were enjoying. But yeah, your taking it all in, the musical and visual spectacle, was great to watch cuz all the same stuff that hit us back in the day hits you. What a grand way to ease into my morning. Thanks so much for doing this one.
I had Magog as a Halloween costume in 1980, once. Worst idea. I took up too much space on the couch!
😅😆😆😆😆😆
Steve Hackett has re-recorded Supper's Ready for his 2011 album Genesis Revisited II. On this, he had different guest singers: Mikael Åkerfeldt from Opeth, Conrad Keely from ...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead, Francis Dunnery from It Bites and Simon Collins (Phil's oldest son), who delivers a brilliant vocal performance on Apocalypse In 9/8. 😊 But Steve himself also provides lead vocals on Willow Farm.
Genesis has always been a band of creative equals.
I don't think it would be fair to say that only one person was 100% Genesis.
The great thing about these guys, along with other members incl. Ray Wilson and Anthony Phillips, is that they never had a definitive album like Dark Side Of The Moon, Tubular Bells or something like that.
The writing on each album, all the way from 1969's From Genesis To Revelation to 1997's Calling All Stations, is "too diverse", to quote Mike Rutherford. And to me, having such brilliant versatility is healthy.
Peter didn’t write all the lyrics to the Foxtrot album either. Time Table was entirely by Tony, who, along with Mike, wrote the lyrics to Watcher Of The Skies. And Can-Utility And The Coastliners was Steve's lyric.
It's great to see someone from a younger generation hearing the greatest song from the greatest album. You are reliving my youth.
My favorite version is on the SECONDS OUT live album. Phil does the vocals, but does a fantastic job of it. I think Tony said it was their best version. Let the music play!
Agreed!
Agreed too!
Agree, musically they were better on the Seconds Out version
@L33Reacts No touring member, just them 5. At the beginning Steve, Mike and Tony played guitars. Steve & Tony a 12-string. Then Tony left the guitar and played keys, while a little later Steve changed his. And some part Mike grabbed the 2 neck bass & guitar. Don’t remember if he played a normal bass somewhere in the song too
Live I think Mike usually added bass pedal notes while playing the acoustic (6 string), which he swopped for the Rickenbacker electric bass (twin neck) for the latter part - if I remember rightly he used the twin neck (incl. a Shergold) a bit later on. It's difficult to see whether he actually plays the bass pedals (for the first 5 mins odd) as we don't really see his legs - but you can hear those bass notes....probably this section is dubbed on from a live tape - widely rumoured to be the Rainbow concert of 73 broadcast by the BBC ( listening again to the Rainbow concert, I doubt this). One of the 'mistakes' of this version of the film is that we see Tony playing the 12 string after he has started to play the Hohner pianet N and Hammond (I think the 100L, but can't quite see)
Okay, I haven't seen this comment yet, so I apologize if it's already here. 6:06 Tony Banks on guitar. A rare sight, at least for me. It's fair that you thought an extra man was up there. I just watched your New Year video and it's so good! I hope your 2024 is amazing!
You are too kind brie :) thank you so much! I hope you have a wonderful 2024 as well. And I was so confused over that 😂 Thanks for pointing that out. What a show. I'm glad you enjoyed the new years video ☺️☺️
Thank you so much for this!.....I've seen odd clips of Genesis, back in the day, but not this ....wow!
My hands down Genesis favorite! Thanks!
Seconds Out live version 💯
The best one by far
Seconds out is gonna be a special thing I do on new years I believe. SO you don't have to wait too long for it;)
I can't wait. It's simply the best live Genesis album and in my top 3 favourite albums of all time.
Giving you a like before I even watch. My #2 prog epic behind The Gates of Delirium. Let's get started!
Thanks Dennis! I hope you enjoyed brother. I had a blast with this video 🙃
Cool react!! You got to see the tribute band The Musical Box... It's a must!
Was AT THIS CONCERT at the age of 20 with my once and always best friend...with orange sunshine of course. Thanks for your channel!
Last month I saw The Musical Box (a tribute band from Canada) do a full early Genesis concert. It was amazing. The details were crazy exact. They did the entire Gabriel's stick with all his stories. They even had the drummer wear Phil's white overalls. When they covered 'Watcher of the Skies' the blacklights, the huge projected 'eyes' above the band, the whole stage was magical, surreal, very avant-garde. That Genesis could do an entire concert by memory, including 'Supper's Ready' just blows my mind. They were truly unique.
Peter has said he never did acid. Richard Macphail said in his (very good) book 'My Book of Genesis' that he didn't (but nowhere have I seen that Gabriel didn't do mushrooms, lol) Phil has said they might enjoy a spliff before a performance or at rehearsals.
Brilliant. Glad i caught the live show. Lee, mea culpa. I checked Wiki and indeed there is speculation that Jill Gabriel had taken something. I’m pretty sure that other than his one-off disastrous hashish experience, Pete did nothing and was is a lifetime teetotaler. So you were right ❤
Supper's Ready Seconds Out
As sure as eggs is eggs ( aching man's feet) is such a great outro to an amazing quintessential Prog song.
Best live version of Suppers ready with original line up is a full length performance on French t.v.. I think from 1973? Check it out. I can see your a fan of Genesis style lyrics and progressive rock. As the germ in a seed grows we finally been freed to get back home.!!!!!
You NEED to hear this live from 1977 - with Phil Collins singing. (It’s actually better - let the hate come). I interviewed Genesis in 1981. Suffice to say Tony Banks is not a fan of Gabriel’s claims about the meaning of the song. “Pete’s just trying to be mysterious. This is a simple song that equates Hitler with the Antichrist. The song is rather simple, actually. It’s full of World War II references.”
I saw them do this live in 1974 in Indianapolis. The ticket for that concert cost a whole $5.00
Fuckin a man.... I wish. Nowadays it's 9 bucks for a gallon of milk. I can't imagine how much some tickets cost for even mid level bands lol
I saw same tour day after you saw. Venue was too big. Had a theater stage and far left and right seats had curtains in way. Gabriel had crew tie back after someone in audience complained. The entire upper half of hall was closed/empty. I only heard Visions of Angels, so I was gobsmacked.
Another great reaction and great choice of recording. In some shows Gabriel was actually lifted up on a wire at the end. I saw them perform this in London in 76 with Phil on vocals and Bill Bruford on drums. The inflatable flowers exploding from the side of the stage during Willow Farm sent the audience crazy.
great reaction. revisiting this and seeing your reaction makes it impossible not to recommend a bit of Peter Gabriel solo, I just discovered this one recently. one of the weirder more atmospheric tracks off pg4 (security) in a live performance that really surprised me. great quality. search "peter gabriel lay your hands athens 1987" and it'll pop right to the top. another song with religious overtones that may resonate. anyway, hope you do it soon and have fun.
A right, proper Prog song this one and no mistake. Credit to you for reacting to such a long piece of work.
I started hearing this stuff wafting out of study windows at my boarding school in the early/mid 70s and then from little mono tape machines in the junior study room, awful sound, on cassettes donated by older brothers. After a couple of years I could finally afford to buy the records themselves. I have never looked back. I have just shy of 17,000 files on my ipod.
If I was told I had to delete everything bar one band I would keep my pre `75 Genesis. Even now after 50 years
I actually got to see them just before Gabriel left, at the Empire Pool on the Lamb tour. My friend and I were 14. So by far the youngest out of 10,000 on the night ! A bootleg of the whole thing is here on this site.
Interesting analysis. 💙🎵🎶🎶 You Rock!!
Thanks Renee! No, YOU rock :)
hee hee 🥰
'That other guy' is Steve Hackett! Not just some 'tour guy'.
Pro-tip: you DONT need drugs to have a creative mind and be able to look at things from weird angles. You just need to train your mind to do that by freeing it from shackles that tell you to "BELIEVE in this ideology".
It's an amazing tune for sure but NOW, listen to the Seconds Out live version with Phil singing. It'll blow your mind. That's all I'll say.
Thanks for the reminder man.... WTF was the right response to his costumes. As a Genesis fan I must be the only one who doesn't rank this as his favourite? except for the magnificent ending that is. Firth of Fifth of course and Burning rope are the ones for me!
Just checked out your reaction to The Musical Box. You must try the live version on The Midnight Special, the same quality, but with Gabriel's theatrics and makeup. Much less outlandish than in Supper's Ready and definitely adding to the performance. You'll be surprised!
Supper's Ready es una pieza maestra del rock progresivo, música que no se volverá a crear, por eso hay que disfrutarla al máximo y difundirla entra las nuevas generaciones...
amazing performance and some insightful comments at the end👍
Hey thanks Steven I appreciate that. And I totally agree, it's frickin awesome lol
Check out PG doing Talk to Me live - he always kept up the theatrical angle, even later on.
I am definitely gonna be doing more solo PG stuff next month! I did in your eyes last week and it was transcendent
Another great reaction bro!🎸
You rock brother thank you so much! 🙏
If you want to feel what it was like to be at a Genesis concert, you should go to see a performance by the Genesis tribute band called The Musical Box. They are a French Canadian band that tour every year throughout the US and Europe. The band attained the rights to all of the costumes that Peter wore. Peter and Phil have given them their stamp of approval. They are awesome. You would think you were seeing Genesis back in the day. They probably come to your area. Check with the theaters where you live, you won't regret it!! I have been going to their shows since 2007.
Quite right. I've seen them do their Lamb show. Outstanding.
I am going to see them if they come by Baltimore or DC for sure. I would love to see that..
one of teh greatest song of all
I agree. Wholeheartedly. This is a masterpiece among masterpieces.
There was only the 5 of them. Mike changed up to the doubleneck.
Yeah I didn't realize they were moving around the stage LOL I was like what is going on??
Phil wasn't bored its his drumming face 👍
Audience tripping on LSD watching this, probably still tripping 50 years later 🤯🤯🤯😀😀😀
Saw them do this at the little bitty Roxy on the Sunset Strip. Amazing!
I bet it was fantastic... I'm jealous lol
No tour guy there!
Steve Hackett on the far left!
then Mike Rutherford, Peter Gabriel, Phil Collins and finally Tony Banks on the right side...
Great stuff my friend
Thank you John! I appreciate it! 🙏
As a drummer, you should check out live video of Los Endos with Phil and Bill Bruford both playing drums. The show I saw was bootlegged and sounds pretty good. I suspect technology will allow isolating these audience recordings into multi-tracked/remixes.
You finally did it...bravo!
Wooooo! What a ride it was too lol
This was good Lee for your first time you may want to even extend it a little bit in the future.. I know Scott goes an hour and a half on Sunday😊
I recommend Dance on a Volcano and Los Endos from Seconds Out. Your won't regret it.
Nice Channel.
JT
Thanks JT! I am actually planning on doing something from seconds out on new years!
The Live version is The best, with Phil Collins.
Keep Rocking,
Ronnie Scotland
I recommend that you read the lyrics and the story behind this song. It’s actually quite creepy 😅
If you want to know what he is able to do with his voice you need to listen to Rythm of the Heat from 3:44 till 4:02.
You'll often see this film referred to as the "Shepperton" concert. Back in the early 70's it was crazy hard to film indoors concerts, usually because the lighting was crap, but also where do you put your cameras? Just watch the Yessongs film from the Rainbow Theater as an example. To get around this problem Genesis' management rented a soundstage at Shepperton Studios. That way they could set up as many lights and cameras wherever they wanted (and the lighting is still not that good, but no doubt the budget was tiny.) As I recall, they invited members of their fan club in to give it some concert authenticity, plus to give the band someone to play to (and to get some cheering on tape, which was 'enhanced' in post-production.) IMO the live version filmed for the French 'Melody' TV program in 1974 is overall better than this, although it's marred by some unfortunate video effects end editing (czcams.com/video/G3IpvFXj2Yw/video.html).
This was filmed in Shepperton film studios. Was there actually an audience? The applause doesn't sound natural - overdubbed?
@@kbrewski1 Oh, OK! Usually in live films the camera does show the audience - I didn't notice any in this.
They're miming most, if not all of this....and there was no audience - the heads you see are cardboard cutout! Watch very carefully at the beginning, Steve, Mike and Tony are all playing acoustic guitars...so who's playing bass - no not Mike playing his foot pedals (although he does later). Secondly watch carefully the few 'fills' that Phil does that are shown close in, they're not what you hear! Peter's lipsync is so obviously faulty at various points too.
This film made at Shepperton was considered not good enough for release when it was made. The sound was in fact the BBC broadcast live from the Rainbow 1973 show (Edit. Listening again to the tapes from the Rainbow, I now doubt this) saw this show twice but not at the Rainbow.
@@rogerwebb7501 Aaaaah, I knew I wasn't too far wrong! Thanks for confirming.
@@kbrewski1Yes, you're right about the 4k version being better, but I'm still not convinced by the audio. I've compared versions of 'live' Supper's Ready, and although the tape from Rainbow 73 broadcast on Radio is very similar, it differs in some respects - this Rainbow tape is often said to be the basis of the Shepperton audio track. The Genesis Museum (who claim only 50% is from the sound recorded at the sessions) says that Charisma (Genesis's record company) provided tapes of live concerts to use in conjunction with the film...but they don't say which.
BTW There is abundant bass on the acoustic guitar intro, and having listened to several live versions, I think Mike normally plays this part on his bass pedals - it's hard to see even on the 4k version whether he is actually playing them, but they are certainly there....probably from a live tape.
In updating the film, The Genesis Museum has taken out some of the obvious mistakes.....but is it in anyway Genesis 'live'?To see that, we either had to be there...I was 5 times in all!
Or, take a look at the remastered 16mm Bataclan French TV concert of '73....all, more or less in close-up, and all more or less 'featuring' Peter!
@@kbrewski1 I'm not claiming it's all mimed - in fact The Genesis Museum claim only 50% of it is mimed. And I'm certainly not claiming the Bataclan concert was....in fact I said that concert gives a true picture of what Genesis was like live back in 1973 - the first year I saw them in concert.
I cannot see how anyone can watch this version of 'Shepperton' and think that it is not in many instances, another sound recording, just replay it and wait for the snare 'fill' in the episode after Peter sings ' I know a fireman who looks after the fire', you'll notice Phil doesn't 'play' the snare 'fill' at that point. This is but one of many examples of the miming (when I say 'miming' I don't mean to suggest that the band weren't 'playing', merely that the sound used in the edit was not that sound made when the band were filmed). Many of the most glaring 'mistakes' don't appear in the 4k version, (eg. the snare fill above) and to a certain extent is more 'believable' .
I touring member !!!!! 😳😲😖 WWWWhat !!!!!!!!!! Come on man Lol
Lee at least learn the history of the Best band Ever on Wiki , Okay ☺✌
Gabriel/ Banks/ Hackett, Rutherford & Collins ..... The Greatest of the Great !!! 🎶
A Musicians Band 👍
Have you reacted to a plague of lighthouse keepers live yet?
El video es genial, pero deberías haber reaccionado al sonido original del concierto. El falsete de Gabriel en el nuevo sonido editado no termino de digerirlo hasta el día de hoy, después de haber visto como mil veces el vídeo con el sonido original
More Phil?
Check out Disco Suicide by Brand X.
JT
13.43 Probably to do with the neon lighting.
Actually, those guys were deep deep deep in debt. The pound didn't go very far back then. They only got out of the red after Peter left, after Trick of the Tale tour.
Geez.... the life of an artist is always hard and full of struggle. But that's what makes the art so good. They pour that frustration and confusion into their craft and infuse with a dash of tragedy.
Well, that's how they used to do it. Now all you need is one tik tok to go viral and your RICH LOL
It was not because Peter left that they got out of the red. It takes time not only to build your fan base but also for record sales to be calculated and the record company, managers, etc. run their sticky fingers through it.
@@janewells5970 Just a coincidence they all got richer after they split.
@@L33Reacts Genesis was fortunate to have signed with a great label. Kids today don't have that kind of backing. They have to keep hitting something akin to a lottery. It ain't sustainable.
Lee, I rummaged quickly to the lead Entries, regarding this Concert to see if anyone mentioned, and offered to you, and to Others here, that this Song, and this very Concert, was released here in a Remastered 2023 4K Version within the past two months. - And here it is. Belated Merry Christmas !
czcams.com/video/sr5xcISnkDU/video.htmlsi=gh2ZXef1seqbAZ04
@@kbrewski1 Thanks
It was great to see the live perfomance. You should still give the studio version a listen from Foxtrot. Stunning.
They are wearing white to stand out in the blacklight.