@@CantDraw-bq6pj And TTO, the songs are amazing but the fart sound effects ruined "you gotta go" like TGWDLM, firebringer (unpopular opinion) and TTO have the best Starkid songs in the imo
RavenclawProud For me Twisted has the best music by far. All the musicals have great music, but I could watch Twisted on loop and love each song every time.
@@6idiotslover2711 I agree with Firebringer having some of the best music being an unpopular opinion!! I think so too, I could listen to those songs forever and never get bored
paranoid android yeah like tbh he sounds the best in Show Me Your Hands and America is Great Again bc he uses that same lower to mid range that makes him sound so good in Twisted and TTO...America is Great Again needs more appreciation tbh.
Whoooaaaaaaaaa, I think the duet between Sirius and Harry in AVPS is one of the best in the show. Not the best definetly but definetly not the worst. And "Hideous Creatures" as the worst of Starship!!!!! My heart is broken. "Kick it up a notch" is definitely the best tho
In my opinion, show stopping number is an okay song, I feel lile it's overrated and people just see it for their love of Robert, they don't look at the song itself, people skip past good songs like join us and die or let it out
Show stoppin number is my favorite starkid song. The dancing how good Robert sounds working boys. Its a perfect song and I love it so much I can not even express myself
Show me your hands is my favorite from tgwdlm, most people who love show stopping number is just into it for biased reasons. It's a good song, just not my favorite song
It's interesting, watching this, and seeing just how different people's opinions can be. I guess I don't have favorites or least favorites, but I didn't realise how many of the songs I truly loved, until I saw them as "Worst." Regardless, I respect your opinion, and *edit* love your videos :)
@@frameturtle I literally love those songs with my whole entire heart. Twisted is just pure perfection. Happy ending is stunning, the harmonies and the vocals ugh and if I believed is absolutely stunning and his voice literally makes me cry every single time
yh, this i why twisted in my fav too, but the song twisted has always been my top, there's just such a perfect shift between hilarity and OMG I'M CRYING NOW YES DYLAN
I thought I could leave Robert's hip swings. They just keep coming back... O.o Kind of sad that "Wagon on Fire" wasn't the best but hey "Speedrun" was hilarious to listen to for how meta it was.
Lmao the song you put as worst in Ani is basically the only one I know and I love it. Also Get in my mouth is a bop, I definitely remember it better than This school is mine, I was low-key sad you didn't put Going back to Hogwarts as one of the best. I think When you gotta go isn't a bad song, but oh boy those sounds effects. My fave from TTO is Wagon on fire but this one's great too. Other than that I mostly agree, thanks for putting Dream a little higher and Show stopping number as best bcs they deserve it
As someone whose first exposure to Starkid was AVPM (as it was for a lot of people), Going Back To Hogwarts will always be THE Starkid song to me, in a way, because it’s the one that started it all. Lol now I’m getting emotional 😭
I agree with this list, except I wouldn't put those voices last for avps or hideous creatures last for starship because I love them but I don't know what I would have put instead :/ this must have been really hard to make
@@anonymouscolorguardsoloist1159 the thing is, without those noises it would be a beautiful song, especially Laurens version as she is classically trained and a soprano, the fart noises sorta ruined it TBH
I was so surprised to find out that everyone hates Those Voices!! That was so touching, especially when I first saw it, and the "la la la la la" part is so beautifully haunting
Katie Schulz I was actually just thinking that if I made a ranking like this I might put Voldemort is Going Down as the worst for AVPM... it’s not a bad song but I don’t think it’s one of the show’s strong points. Still catchy though!
For those who want to know the titles or just want to see the list quicker, here is the list from the video (with some commentary of mine, I could not resist, sorry). AVPM: worst - "Dragon Song" (I don't agree, I like it, it's cute... the worst is clearly "Cho's Song" - yeah, I know it is supposed to be cringey, but it does not change the fact it is cringey) best - "Voldemort Is Going Down" (I don't agree, it's good, but not even close to "Goin' Back to Hogwarts", also I feel that "Different As Can Be" beats it by miles)" M&MD: worst - "I've Seen You Around Here Before" (Pretty much agree, it's not the most cringey, but sadly it's the most boring.) best - "Finale" (I can't agree, because "Ready to Go" exists, but certainly it's an amazing song too) AVPS: worst - "Those Voices" (I agree it's overrated, but I think it's still decent, while there are some much weaker songs there. Personally I think that "Let the Games Begin" is the worst.) best - "Harry Freakin' Potter" (Sadly I can't agree, It's awesome but "To Have a Home" is criminally underrated and in my opinion deserves this spot.) Starship: worst - "Hideous Creatures" (Picking the worst song from Starship is like picking your least favorite child, I think none of the songs from this show are weak... but yeah, I think I can agree.) best - "Kick It up a Notch" (I don't see anything else on this spot, pure masterpiece.) HMB: worst - "Robin Sucks" (I agree - it sucks, in my opinion it's a tie with "Dynamic Duet" though.) best - "Rogues Are We" (I love it, but I can't agree - there's still "Dark, Sad, Lonely Knight".) AVPSY: worst - "Get In My Mouth" (I don't agree , I think "I Was" is the worst, however it's still not bad, just meh and the delivery isn't the best.) best - "Tonight this School is Mine" (I completely don't agree. From the 'best' choices so far, this is my least favorite. I think the true best song from this show is definitelly "Always Dance".) Twisted: worst - "Orphaned at 33" (I don't agree, If I were to point the least interesting song from the show, my pick would be "Sands of Time", however this one isn't that good either.) best - "Dream a Little Harder" (Again, sadly I can't agree. I'm totally in love with this song, it's in my top10 for sure, but this show has "Twisted" in it...) TTTO: worst - "You Gotta Go" (I don't agree, it's not the worst - it's the most disappointing one. If it weren't for these fart jokes, it would be a beautiful piece of music. "Caulk the Wagon" is worse.) best - "Speedrun" (I like it, but: "Pays to Be an Animal", "When the World's at Stake", "Wagon on Fire" and "Naked in the Lake" are better.) ANI: (well, I don't listen to ANI songs that often to compare them.) worst - "The Force (You Got It)" best - "Back on Top" Firebringer: worst - "Ouch My Butt" (I agree, as much as I hate "We Got Work to Do", maybe it's indeed even worse, just not as overplayed.) best - "Climate Change" (I don't agree, it's one of the good songs in the show, but I would go with "Into the Night" as the best one.) TGWDLM: worst - "You Tied Up My Heart" (I agree, It's not bad by any means, but I always expect Jeff to compose something better than generic love song.) best - "Show Stoppin' Number" (Sadly, can't agree - I think that in terms of the song itself, title number deserves the spot and also "Let It Out" is better. Rob Manion is a king of delivery though.)
finally someone puts tied up my heart or whatever at the bottom. it’s always low but like it’s really my least favorite and it deserves to be last, especially over what do you want paul which always gets last. i kinda like that one. and america is great again bops too.
Jam_Jam_Gelatin0108 yeah idk it’s not that it’s bad and it is fun but i think in terms of song quality it’s lower. but it’s really all subjective, yknow
I'm glad we agree on the best song for AVPSY. I can agree that You Gotta Go wasn't the best live (except for Lauren's and hers was even better with the album recording). But my least favorite for TTO was When The World's at Stake, and The Grind, but that's my personal opinion.
I agree with most of these, but whAT THE HECK, HIDEOUS CREATURES, GET IN MY MOUTH, AND TIED UP MY HEART ARE FRICKIN BOPS HOW COULD YOU DO THEM SO DIRTY 😂😂
I swear to god tied up my heart is a GREAT SONG AND I WILL DIE ON THAT GOD DAMN GRAVE EVERYONE CAN FIGHT ME Anyways other than that this was a wonderful list I very much enjoyed it
I feel like if You Gotta Go didn't include the fart noises, I'd like it more. I agree with that because I thought you were gonna put Caulk Your Wagon haha But yes!!! finally someone who appreciates Speedrun!!
Am I the only person who is obsessed with Orphaned at 33? Like it is literally the third or fourth Starkid song I sing when I'm trying to get someone else interested.
I think You Gotta Go would be the best song if not for the sound effects. I get it for the narrative, but at least release a version without. Also thanks for appreciating Speedrun instead of automatically picking Wagon on Fire. It’s my favorite song, but I can agree it may not be the best.
I've always loved Voldemort is Going Down, aaaa it's really not appreciated enough I also really love Those Voices, but Harry Freaking Potter is a very good song
buT OKAY okay okay i get uh, i get how voices is the worst ouT of the whole show but its so good buT HIDEOUS CREATURES IS SO GOOD and oh man okay i respect you
I started the video thinking to myself "if they don't put show stopping number as best for tgwdlm then we'll have a problem". I fell in love with some songs along the way, and experienced starkid at its subjective lows and highs, and learned a lot. It all ended with immense satisfaction.
pretty good picks... not always in agreement but usually the ones you pick are in the general area, but my above all fave from MAMD is "so ready to go". its like the only one from that show i listen to regularly. and i hate aladdin's other songs from twisted more than his orphaned at 33 song. lol. also this just reminded me that like ALL the songs in AVPS and Starship are so good. and also we seem to have very different opinions on Ani. ha. good video.
If Ouch My Butt isn’t the worst song for Firebringer I’m gonna be really sad Edit: Thank you (slightly disappointed you put my favorite Ani song as the worst and one of my least favorites as the best but besides that lol)
This just made me realize how good the music from Holy Musical B@tman truly is... Robin Sucks isn't the best, but everything else in that musical is golden. Dark Sad Lonely Knight, Dynamic Duet, and Super Friends are easily up there with Rogues are We in terms of quality, humor, and catchiness. I already thought it was criminally underrated, but now I feel that even moreso.
Actually, the best song from TGWDLM is The Beginning of Moana
Literally I have never agreed with anything more in my entire life
Uhh I think you're forgetting 'i'VE BEEN BREWIN' UP YOUR COOOOFFEEEE'.
Y’all are sleeping on black coffee I’m your coffee gal
And in the same respect, sleepin on the Circle of Life
Aly in the Bathroom at a party FACTS
It really says a lot about Twisted that Orphaned at 33 is the worst song when it is frankly iconic af.
Same with TGWDLM and Tied Up My Heart. There are no bad songs so they just went for purposely weird sounds
@@CantDraw-bq6pj And TTO, the songs are amazing but the fart sound effects ruined "you gotta go" like TGWDLM, firebringer (unpopular opinion) and TTO have the best Starkid songs in the imo
RavenclawProud For me Twisted has the best music by far. All the musicals have great music, but I could watch Twisted on loop and love each song every time.
@@6idiotslover2711 I agree with Firebringer having some of the best music being an unpopular opinion!! I think so too, I could listen to those songs forever and never get bored
@@AlicexAngel i always have climate change stuck in my head, the songs are so catchy and well written, Meredith should write songs more often
just ignore the ranking and enjoy a compilation of Starkid songs
This is the most unproblematic comment I’ve ever read
I like how you think.
the sad thing is you’ve gotta go would be such a good song if they just did it without the STUPID FART SOUNDS
I have a playlist of Starkid soundtracks but don’t have any you gotta go songs on there because of the effects
I totally agree. It’s also such a good song for Lauren because she’s a classically trained vocalist.
IKR its so pretty and they sound really good singing it but the noises ruin it
HEY Joey Richter worked hard on those noises and they should be appreciated lmao
Exactly!
Okay but for the trail to Oregon “your wAgOn is on fire” should have been the best
m a r i a m absolutely!!!
100%
yup especially when the others come out and start singing their own songs at the same time. i just luv that part so much
For your
I-N-D-E pendence
yes yes a hundred times yes
Radical opinion: there are no bad songs in TGWDLM
cringy edit: I’ve come back to this comment a year later and holy shit y’all blew this up lmaoo
Valid
@@paranoidandroid2098 Thank yooouuu. And he sings, what, like HALF the songs in that show?
That is not an opinion it’s a fact
@felix true
paranoid android yeah like tbh he sounds the best in Show Me Your Hands and America is Great Again bc he uses that same lower to mid range that makes him sound so good in Twisted and TTO...America is Great Again needs more appreciation tbh.
I'm not mad at most of these but Those Voices is fire smh
Elisabeth Denny omg thx i was so shocked
I was about to comment the same thing.
HELL YEAH IT IS
I was so surprised. It's a hard choice, I know, but I think I would put it at the top. I get chills every time I listen to it.
I would have put "Hermione can't draw" last. It's not really a song but neither is that dragon song.
ok i respect opinions but WHY does every single ranking account put those voices at the bottom that song is SO GOOD
lily rose it is my favorite song, EVER, out of literally any song
It's so good! omg
IT IS??? I don't understand what people have against it :c
I LITERALLT SAID THAT WHEN I SAW THE RANKING!
it’s because every song in avps slaps and even their worst song is one of the best starkid songs ever
Whoooaaaaaaaaa, I think the duet between Sirius and Harry in AVPS is one of the best in the show. Not the best definetly but definetly not the worst.
And "Hideous Creatures" as the worst of Starship!!!!! My heart is broken. "Kick it up a notch" is definitely the best tho
I personally love hideous creatures. It just has some parts that shine and that really does it for me lol.
Agreed I love those voices, it’s so great
I think this is really just a testament of how good the songs are, that even the 'worst' songs are still really great!
CosmicAfflictions exception for you gotta go. biggest freakin disappointment of my life
Status quo is a close second
Speedrun and Wagon On Fire are my favorite TTO songs, but WOF takes the first place because of Joey's fiREEEEE
My favorites are Wagon On Fire and Lost Without you
And Lauren's dancing
My favorites are speedrun and when your world's at stake
*least best to most best* songs from each starkid musical
rowan best to more best
Good to show stopping
everyone does those voices so dirty i cried when i first watched that
A very gay cherry agreed
AGREED
Agree!!!
It’s actually one of my favorites
yeehaw cowboys. It’s definitely one of my favorite starkid songs
Thank You For Appreciating Climate Change
...this sentence out of context is amazing
@@Hkihfzdchjgd lMAO YES
Agreeeeee
you’re right but also asdfghjjkll
AND speedrun
Personally,no one remembers achmed is best in twisted
Who? Isn't he a tiger or something? 😂😂😂 Joke
Most underated starkid song. Joe Walker and Robert are perfect
The whole of Twisted is the best of Twisted
TIGER FUCKER TIGER FUCKER
@@hydrahayday5090 *is* it underrated? It’s rated number one on so many videos I watch, I don’t really consider it underrated.
I genuinely don’t know how you picked for Starship, every song in that show is so good, I could never.
this is late but my love for hideous creatures runs through THE WHOLE LAND
Kathryn Miller thANK you honestly Starship is the best Starkid musical in my opinion
@@anikathu HONESTLY
Starship is so good
Al right, I respect your opinion, but those voices was one of the best songs of all the Harry Potter play series
THANK YOU
Y e s
FINALLY SOMEONE AGREES
I argue senior year is a worst song for avpsy due to how phoned in it feels
Ryan Meneo agreed and get in my mouth is a bop
I'd argue that this school is mine is not the best song, what with everything ends and when I was being options
curran stedman agreed
Get in my mouth is underrated and was robbed
I love senior year but maybe because it makes me feel so nostalgic ugh especially because I first saw it like right after I graduated high school
I swear If showstopping number is not the best song...
I was not disappointed
In my opinion, show stopping number is an okay song, I feel lile it's overrated and people just see it for their love of Robert, they don't look at the song itself, people skip past good songs like join us and die or let it out
My literal exact reaction.
@@r00dio same tbh,, I think its decent but overrated
Show stoppin number is my favorite starkid song. The dancing how good Robert sounds working boys. Its a perfect song and I love it so much I can not even express myself
Show me your hands is my favorite from tgwdlm, most people who love show stopping number is just into it for biased reasons. It's a good song, just not my favorite song
I feel like people tend to forget that MAMD had badass harmonies
Show stopping number isn’t good just because of Robert, but also because of:
Greg.
And Steve.
And Stu.
And Mark.
And Layton.
And especially...
*CHAD.*
Please do a tribute to Jeff's facial expressions
@@laurenmanion861 oh awesome! I can't wait to see it :)
My dog farted at 10:28 and it really enhanced my experience for You've Gotta Go.
Ari! AHAHAHAHAHAHA
I just fucking choked xD
surround sound
It's interesting, watching this, and seeing just how different people's opinions can be. I guess I don't have favorites or least favorites, but I didn't realise how many of the songs I truly loved, until I saw them as "Worst." Regardless, I respect your opinion, and *edit* love your videos :)
uhm obviously the best song from TGWDLM is the beginning of Moana how dare you?!
Dream a little harder it both one of the most underrated and the best song from twisted
I’m not the biggest fan of the falsetto in that one, but I agree most of it is awesome
No love for happy ending, if I believed, or twisted? If I believed is in my top 3 of all starkid songs
@@frameturtle I literally love those songs with my whole entire heart. Twisted is just pure perfection. Happy ending is stunning, the harmonies and the vocals ugh and if I believed is absolutely stunning and his voice literally makes me cry every single time
@@rend9624 Twisted has so many amazing songs. It's my favorite musical!
yh, this i why twisted in my fav too, but the song twisted has always been my top, there's just such a perfect shift between hilarity and OMG I'M CRYING NOW YES DYLAN
After obsessing over the rogues medley it was super weird to just hear the end of kick it up a notch without the opening music to rogues are we
I thought I could leave Robert's hip swings. They just keep coming back... O.o
Kind of sad that "Wagon on Fire" wasn't the best but hey "Speedrun" was hilarious to listen to for how meta it was.
I loved dysentery world lol
I agree with your list except for the holy musical batman one, as my personal favourite song from that is dark, sad lonely knight
Kim Anderson my favorite is dynamic duet
@@gracejennings9034 I also really enjoy that song as well, so well thought out and really good singing
Every song from holy musical b@man slaps tbh
Kim Anderson Dark Sad Lonely Knight is my fav Starkid song
I think 'I've Seen You Around Here Before' is a great song but the fact is it was terribly sung, mostly by Devin but it wasn't Joe's best either
ngl i like the way they sung it cause it kinda emphasized that they're both young and learning and awkward idk
just curious, what about devin’s part didn’t you like? i agree about joe but that’s just because i don’t care for his singing at all
Lmao the song you put as worst in Ani is basically the only one I know and I love it.
Also Get in my mouth is a bop, I definitely remember it better than This school is mine, I was low-key sad you didn't put Going back to Hogwarts as one of the best.
I think When you gotta go isn't a bad song, but oh boy those sounds effects. My fave from TTO is Wagon on fire but this one's great too.
Other than that I mostly agree, thanks for putting Dream a little higher and Show stopping number as best bcs they deserve it
As someone whose first exposure to Starkid was AVPM (as it was for a lot of people), Going Back To Hogwarts will always be THE Starkid song to me, in a way, because it’s the one that started it all.
Lol now I’m getting emotional 😭
I loved Get In My Mouth and Orphaned At 33
But honestly, all Starkid songs are bops and you gotta choose something :')
-Except Caulk Your Wagon-
:0 you don't like Caulk? :0
@@wildwolfgaming148 Caulk Your Wagon was unacceptable
:000000
Evie Howlett Caulk your wagon is an amazing song but I have to admit, it seems out of nowhere and unnecessary but it’s still a bop
I agree with this list, except I wouldn't put those voices last for avps or hideous creatures last for starship because I love them but I don't know what I would have put instead :/ this must have been really hard to make
7:13 why would you say something so controversial but yet so true
Its true and she should say it
Agreeded. That song is the best. But its not the most iconic.
hopegirl518 Ashlynn the Achmed song is 👌🏻
That and twisted are the best songs, my personal favorite is dream a little harder
No ma'am the power in me is best!
I’m in a state of distress because the person I hate most in this world is a new star kid fan and I’m gonna ree
Oh god, good luck!
praying for you
Well now you can't hate them
Ask lord Stingy to take care of them for you
bro same i used to like them thanks to that but now i just really hate them so i get your pain
Personally, I think Caulk your Wagon is the worst for TTO
Caoilfhinn Farrell how could you that song is art
But it's so catchy
Caoilfhinn Farrell I actually really like Caulk Your Wagon. Very catchy. Better than the intense annoyance of the fart noises in You Gotta Go.
@@anonymouscolorguardsoloist1159 the thing is, without those noises it would be a beautiful song, especially Laurens version as she is classically trained and a soprano, the fart noises sorta ruined it TBH
I was so surprised to find out that everyone hates Those Voices!! That was so touching, especially when I first saw it, and the "la la la la la" part is so beautifully haunting
What????!!!! I love the dragon song!
i dont agree with more than half of these but you redeemed youself with firebringer
I mean, even some of the worst songs are still fire.
BUT THOSE VOICES IS FUCKING AMAZING AND YOU CAN NEVER CHANGE MY MIND!
Zebricord 3234 👍
those voices is one of my favorites from avpm
I'm defending this song throughout the comments lol. Its SO GOOD
Dream a little harder is so good
Are you messing with me?
You got the force is the best song!!
Miranda Lewis I was waiting for it to be the best! It’s definitely my favorite.
I know right!! I love that song!
OHHHHHOOOOOOO YOU GOT IT YOU GOT IT YOU GOT IT
I wasn’t gonna say anything but Not Alone and Back to Hogwarts are just sooo much better than Voldemort is Going Down.
Katie Schulz I was actually just thinking that if I made a ranking like this I might put Voldemort is Going Down as the worst for AVPM... it’s not a bad song but I don’t think it’s one of the show’s strong points. Still catchy though!
Get In My Mouth is one of the highlights of AVPSY, this is lunacy.
Uhmm... Actually, the best song from Firebringer is “I am Chorn”
YES!
For those who want to know the titles or just want to see the list quicker, here is the list from the video (with some commentary of mine, I could not resist, sorry).
AVPM:
worst - "Dragon Song" (I don't agree, I like it, it's cute... the worst is clearly "Cho's Song" - yeah, I know it is supposed to be cringey, but it does not change the fact it is cringey)
best - "Voldemort Is Going Down" (I don't agree, it's good, but not even close to "Goin' Back to Hogwarts", also I feel that "Different As Can Be" beats it by miles)"
M&MD:
worst - "I've Seen You Around Here Before" (Pretty much agree, it's not the most cringey, but sadly it's the most boring.)
best - "Finale" (I can't agree, because "Ready to Go" exists, but certainly it's an amazing song too)
AVPS:
worst - "Those Voices" (I agree it's overrated, but I think it's still decent, while there are some much weaker songs there. Personally I think that "Let the Games Begin" is the worst.)
best - "Harry Freakin' Potter" (Sadly I can't agree, It's awesome but "To Have a Home" is criminally underrated and in my opinion deserves this spot.)
Starship:
worst - "Hideous Creatures" (Picking the worst song from Starship is like picking your least favorite child, I think none of the songs from this show are weak... but yeah, I think I can agree.)
best - "Kick It up a Notch" (I don't see anything else on this spot, pure masterpiece.)
HMB:
worst - "Robin Sucks" (I agree - it sucks, in my opinion it's a tie with "Dynamic Duet" though.)
best - "Rogues Are We" (I love it, but I can't agree - there's still "Dark, Sad, Lonely Knight".)
AVPSY:
worst - "Get In My Mouth" (I don't agree , I think "I Was" is the worst, however it's still not bad, just meh and the delivery isn't the best.)
best - "Tonight this School is Mine" (I completely don't agree. From the 'best' choices so far, this is my least favorite. I think the true best song from this show is definitelly "Always Dance".)
Twisted:
worst - "Orphaned at 33" (I don't agree, If I were to point the least interesting song from the show, my pick would be "Sands of Time", however this one isn't that good either.)
best - "Dream a Little Harder" (Again, sadly I can't agree. I'm totally in love with this song, it's in my top10 for sure, but this show has "Twisted" in it...)
TTTO:
worst - "You Gotta Go" (I don't agree, it's not the worst - it's the most disappointing one. If it weren't for these fart jokes, it would be a beautiful piece of music. "Caulk the Wagon" is worse.)
best - "Speedrun" (I like it, but: "Pays to Be an Animal", "When the World's at Stake", "Wagon on Fire" and "Naked in the Lake" are better.)
ANI: (well, I don't listen to ANI songs that often to compare them.)
worst - "The Force (You Got It)"
best - "Back on Top"
Firebringer:
worst - "Ouch My Butt" (I agree, as much as I hate "We Got Work to Do", maybe it's indeed even worse, just not as overplayed.)
best - "Climate Change" (I don't agree, it's one of the good songs in the show, but I would go with "Into the Night" as the best one.)
TGWDLM:
worst - "You Tied Up My Heart" (I agree, It's not bad by any means, but I always expect Jeff to compose something better than generic love song.)
best - "Show Stoppin' Number" (Sadly, can't agree - I think that in terms of the song itself, title number deserves the spot and also "Let It Out" is better. Rob Manion is a king of delivery though.)
In AVPSY what about I Was and Sidekick!
Its only one choice for each, they cant please everyone
finally someone puts tied up my heart or whatever at the bottom. it’s always low but like it’s really my least favorite and it deserves to be last, especially over what do you want paul which always gets last. i kinda like that one. and america is great again bops too.
mediocremaddie you speak the truth
i just commented this word for word on another video. starkids rlly do share 5 brain cells
grace eddy fr. like it’s not a TERRIBLE song. it has good backing vocals. but like....it makes me uncomfortable lmao i don’t like it
Tbh I love all tgwdlm songs and tied up my heart is a fun one, but i mean whatever floats your boat i guess.
Jam_Jam_Gelatin0108 yeah idk it’s not that it’s bad and it is fun but i think in terms of song quality it’s lower. but it’s really all subjective, yknow
When Show Stopping Number comes in and you get a little sad because you know - it's the end of the video.
I enjoyed it so much.
I’m not disagreeing with your choices but.
Your TTO picks are highly questionable.
I'm glad we agree on the best song for AVPSY. I can agree that You Gotta Go wasn't the best live (except for Lauren's and hers was even better with the album recording). But my least favorite for TTO was When The World's at Stake, and The Grind, but that's my personal opinion.
Its interesting to hear other ppls opinions, for example When the worlds at stake is my fave
Lucie Radová same!!!
:o you don't like WTWAS?
Lucie Radová me too!
Full offence but
Worst song in Firebringer is paint how you see me
Best song in TGWDLM is Let it Out
I have never agreed with anything more in my life. Jon's acting is insane
THANK YOU finally someone agrees
@@CantDraw-bq6pj also the melody is great and I just love the concept
I totally agree, show stopping number is great but really overrated
I like paint me, but I agree that let it out is the best
Starship must’ve been hard cause every song from that show is fire, and there aren’t as many as some other shows
I agree with some of these. I personally feel that Naked In A Lake is the worst song from TTO. Also Hideous Creatures is a bop
HB FS i love Naked in a Lake. But hey. Its all good
I agree with most of these, but whAT THE HECK, HIDEOUS CREATURES, GET IN MY MOUTH, AND TIED UP MY HEART ARE FRICKIN BOPS HOW COULD YOU DO THEM SO DIRTY 😂😂
I loved the inflection in his voice when charlotte’s husband says “they left me here to DIE”
I'm sad you didnt make a "Happy birthday Lauren Loepz" birthday. I made it a goal to announce her birthday in every class today
omg you're incredible lol. i'm off school today, but that would've been great
well did you make your goal?
that reminded me of Lauren singing Happy Birthday in Firebringer
@@jupiterfalling4495 I cant find the clip :(
Gotta say I disagree with about 90% of this list, haha.
Get Into My Mouth is the worst and the best, I have arachnophobia, but Jeff is the love of my life
Jeff ages so beautifully. Also who else is excited and watching compilations after the Black Friday announcement?
I swear to god tied up my heart is a GREAT SONG AND I WILL DIE ON THAT GOD DAMN GRAVE EVERYONE CAN FIGHT ME
Anyways other than that this was a wonderful list I very much enjoyed it
I feel like if You Gotta Go didn't include the fart noises, I'd like it more. I agree with that because I thought you were gonna put Caulk Your Wagon haha
But yes!!! finally someone who appreciates Speedrun!!
i can’t believe that was your worst song from trail to oregon when caulk your wagon exists
Caulk your wagon is a lovely song if you learn to love it like I do
You gotta go is one of my favorites
i mean fair but caulk your wagon is better purely because of the „he didn’t grow a sail” part
I really don't like fart noises. I can't really listen to this song because od it
Those Voices as worst? Electric chair
11:36
we love making videos just to out certain bops on top
Am I the only person who is obsessed with Orphaned at 33? Like it is literally the third or fourth Starkid song I sing when I'm trying to get someone else interested.
I also disagree with the best one for Trail To Oregon
ALSO for best song.... for AVPSY...... sidekick.....
Ross Geller is Trash yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyes
I think You Gotta Go would be the best song if not for the sound effects. I get it for the narrative, but at least release a version without. Also thanks for appreciating Speedrun instead of automatically picking Wagon on Fire. It’s my favorite song, but I can agree it may not be the best.
Why does everybody hate on You Tied Up My Heart?!
Jeffs voice is annoying but the recorded version is amazing
Get in my mouth is a jam
I've always loved Voldemort is Going Down, aaaa it's really not appreciated enough
I also really love Those Voices, but Harry Freaking Potter is a very good song
buT OKAY okay okay i get uh, i get how voices is the worst ouT of the whole show but its so good buT HIDEOUS CREATURES IS SO GOOD and oh man okay i respect you
YES someone who agrees that Climate Change is the bwst Firebringer song
Ok tbh my favorite song from TGWDLM is “Cup Of Roasted Coffee” it makes me laugh so hard and the vocal harmonies are LIT
I love that one it’s super underrated imo and it’s prob my 1st or 2nd favorite
oof the Trail to Oregon choices really hurt me.
Get in my mouth is a masterpiece and no one can change my mind!
SPEEDRUN AS BEST IS SOMETHING I HIGHLY AGREE WITH.
I started the video thinking to myself "if they don't put show stopping number as best for tgwdlm then we'll have a problem". I fell in love with some songs along the way, and experienced starkid at its subjective lows and highs, and learned a lot. It all ended with immense satisfaction.
9:54 why are you booing them, they’re right (I’m sorry it’s just... the fart noises guys)
those voices the worst??? sacrilege.
this is an unpopular opinion, but i think not your seed is the best song in tgwdlm, but i still love showstopping number!!
How dare you! Get In My Mouth is fabulous!
pretty good picks... not always in agreement but usually the ones you pick are in the general area, but my above all fave from MAMD is "so ready to go". its like the only one from that show i listen to regularly. and i hate aladdin's other songs from twisted more than his orphaned at 33 song. lol. also this just reminded me that like ALL the songs in AVPS and Starship are so good. and also we seem to have very different opinions on Ani. ha. good video.
Finally!! Agree with all of them, and I’m glad you gave ‘Tonight this school is mine’ some credit, no one ever does!
Honestly without the context and the constant fart noises, You Gotta Go is actually a pretty good song
I really love Hideous Creatures but I'm not you so live and let live I guess
Oh my god yes! I thought I was the only one who had This School Is Mine at the top of their AVPSY list!
If Show Stopping Number didn’t get best, I was gonna SCREAM!
If Ouch My Butt isn’t the worst song for Firebringer I’m gonna be really sad
Edit: Thank you (slightly disappointed you put my favorite Ani song as the worst and one of my least favorites as the best but besides that lol)
The fact that none of these songs are actually bad shows how great Starkid is
I actually really like Hideous Creatures because of the weird jerky-swingy vibe, but I do not dispute the fact that Kick It Up a Notch is the best
I always feel that 5:38 “WERE RISING UP FROM THE unDERGrounD! “
Curiously, the best song of Avpm was made two days before the show
The further I got into the video I realised that I just love all the songs
get in my mouth is one of the best avpsy songs
The amount of people defending those voices gives me hope for humanity TvT
Show Stopping Number is number one of all the number ones and every time I hear it I'll be singing it for at least 3 days.
This just made me realize how good the music from Holy Musical B@tman truly is... Robin Sucks isn't the best, but everything else in that musical is golden. Dark Sad Lonely Knight, Dynamic Duet, and Super Friends are easily up there with Rogues are We in terms of quality, humor, and catchiness. I already thought it was criminally underrated, but now I feel that even moreso.
YES, YES, YES!!! Tied Up My Heart is a really awkward song and is low key really gross and Show Stopping Number is what I live for!!!
At this point the only song I listen to is Show Stopping Number. Its therapeutic