Imamate Doctrine of Ismaili Shia Sect II Comparative School Course II EP-05
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 01. 2024
- #ismailia #ismailism #ismailishiabelief
اسماعیلی شیعہ کا عقیدہ امامت
۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔
This video explores the Imamate Doctrine of Ismaili Shia Sect and their differences from Twelvers Shia Sect.
I am born Shia and never read or studied about our faith history. And due to this podcast I am learning and got good knowledge about the history of all Shia's sects and splits. I hope in future you will expose more about the Shia's faith and their different sects. Very good podcast.
اللہ پاک آپ کو اور ہمیں ہدایت کی توفیق دے اور صراط مستقیم پر چلنے کی توفیق عطا فرمائے
آمین
Don't think that information in the lecture was credible in fact some of it was out right lies.
If you are not a paid person to comment then I guess the purpose of PODCAST is served by Dr sb
@@Mr-ONjo jhoot han un ko dallel sa sabit kro
@@subhanallah6 Hafiz sahab ne kharjion ko shia bana diya😂. Shia lafz or Shia firqe ko aik hi keh rahe hain
پہلی بار ایک مدلل، متوازن اور پرمغز تقابلی بیان سننے کا اتفاق ہوا۔ سلامت رہیں۔
I am Ismaili Shia Nizari Follower
Corrections:
Dai Hassan Bin Sabbah was follower of Imam Nizar عليه السلام and Imam Hadi afterwards Imam Nizar dai of Almut you put him in qarmatians which is different sect of Ismai'li Sh'iasm became after the split among the Mubārakiyyah came with the death of Muḥammad ibn Ismā‘īl (ca. 813 CE).
The majority Ismā‘īlī missionary movement settled in Salamiyah (now in Syria) and had great success in Khuzestan (southwestern Iran), where the Ismā‘īlī leader al-Husayn al-Ahwāzī converted the Kūfan man Ḥamdān in 874 CE, who took the name Qarmaṭ which is called qarmati movement which is not linked with DAI Hassan Bin Sabbah عليه السلام who is warrior of Islam Alhamdulillah you need more study about dawr of Ismai'li Sh'iasm.
WE DO NOT NEED TO CORRECT , LOOK. THEY NOW COMPELLED TO DISCUSS AND COMPARE THERE SELF WITH ISMAILI CONCEPTS AND BELIEFS.. DO NOT ENGR , TAKE HIM POSITIVE .
WHAT YOU COMMENTS , I APPRECIATE, GOOD DONE .
Baki b to kha h wo b sun Lyn aur Hassan Jin sbbah aik shetan tha
@@alexa360 Qaramis are different form ismaili or fatmid
@sardarabdullahsardarabdull5270 if Hassan bin sabah was shitan then what is your opinion about you Salah Uddin Ayubi. Moreover, if any of our dhai was shitan or something else, then let me say that there is no momin or Muslim in the entire Muslim history including your dear Tahmia and whatnot. So, before putting your nasty thoughts into words think a thousand times.
You are right dear, he need to study more about Hassan saba
Very nice analysis. You are having a very balanced analysis.I am an ismaili muslim and i want to answer one question which you asked at the end of the video at (1:27:30 second) both side have their own opinion but One thing is very common that Allah shows his truth by the lineage or progeny. The family of Imam Ismail AS continued without any break or pause. But yes they had same concealment period ahead also, but there were always people under the Imam known as Hujjats and Dais who were constantly in touch with Imam and the guidance was reaching to all the Ismailies living all around the word that time. So i would say that Allah ka wada is tarha poora huwa k imam ismail is aulad khatam Nahi huwi aj tak. Aur Insha’Allah will continue. God bless. Salam.
His lecture has lot of mistake read waji din from pir nasir kushrow, it seems you did not listen other scholars of Shia his book was strictly nasbiyat references which was wrong may imam bless and give you more knowledge
@@kenissa5890 you are right sir, i haven’t read wajh e din. I could not find it online. I am also in search of other books. If there’s any way you can help me. It would be great help. Aameen. May maula bless you too. Thanks
ماشاءاللہ بہت عمدہ کام اللہ تعالیٰ نے آپ سے لیا ہے ❤❤خوب ایسے ہی حق بیان کرتے رہیں اللہ آپ کی حفاظت فرمائے ❤❤
I know Nizam College of Hyderabad. It is a very prominent school. Dr Zahid Ali was from Ismaili Bohra community and he started as Prof of Arabic and retired as Vice Principal of Nizam College. A very distinguished and learned person and Nizam of Hyderabad respected people of knowledge and didn't discriminated based on religion only selected people on merit.
Mos....
1) Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever czcams.com/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/video.html czcams.com/video/OIiNePgctF8/video.html (Zakat & Ring story).
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any Proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran czcams.com/users/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So, show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
2) SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
3) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
Buhut ehtaram ka sath. Dr sb ap ke majority information ghalat ha ya ap na itni study nhi ki ka poori philosophy smjh sakay. Bayan krna ya lecture dena ki position ma ap bilkul nhi hn.
Sasti mashori aur youtube views ka lia ap log kuch bhi kehto ho.. even basic information theek nhi ha..
Ye ziaadati ha ka ap logo ka belief ka baray ma misinformation dn, jo hame Quran pak aur Nabi Saw ne krna na mana farmaya ha.
جی بہت زبردست۔۔ ویسے بوھرا حیدرآباد سندھ اور کراچی میں بہت ہے۔ یہاں ان کے نام سے بازار بھی ہیں بوھرا بازار ۔
جزاک اللہ خیر ڈاکٹر صاحب بہت زبردست معلومات ( علم ) دلیل کے ساتھ شعر کیا اللہ پاک آپ کو اور آپ کی ٹیم کو اپنے حفظ امان میں رکھے اور اس کا صلہ دنیا و آخرت میں دے اور ہمیں سنے اور ہڑھنے اور عمل کرنے کی توفیق دے آمین
استاذی یہ سوال جواب سیشن آخر میں رکھیں الگ سے بیج میں ڈسٹربینس آرہا ہے،جزاک اللہ۔
Ustaz students ko fail hone liye tyar kar rahe hain jis tarha parha rahe hain inhe😂
زبردست علمی تحقیق
Excellent learning experience! Alhumdulillah All praise is due to Allah Ta’ala
Proud to be ismaili allhamdulliah
Subhan Allah!
Sheikh e mohtaram Allah pak apki Umar mn barkat ata farmae,
Humein buhat kush seekhne ko mil raha hai, warna aj se pahle to hamein pata hi nahi tha k "nasibiat" bhi shia mn se he nikli hai,
Jazakallah!
MashaAllah...So Comprehensive.
May Allah reward you abundantly...
مستعلیہ کے ذیلی بہت ساری شاخیں ہیں ان میں سے ایک بوہرہ ہیں۔ پھر بوہرہ کی بہت ساری ذیلی شاخیں ہیں جن میں سے داؤدی اور سلیمانی بوہرہ آ ج بھی موجود ہیں
جب کہ نزاری کی ذیلی شاخیں بھی ہیں جن میں آج کل آغا خانی موجود ہیں باقی شاخیں ختم ہو گئیں وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ
نزاریوں کی ایک شاخ حسن بن صباح کے پیروکار بھی تھے جو اب شاید موجود نہیں۔ حشیشین کے نام سے یہ مشہور تھے
corrections:
1) Dunya may aik waqt may aik imam hota hai is leeya dunyave leeyaz say imam Hussain(as) imam thay na kay Imam Hasan(as).
2) Syedna Hasna bin sabah nizari ismaili thay aur unhoon nay koi jannat nahee banai thee, Ismailia may jannat ka wo concept he nahee hai jo sunnio may hai kay wahan hamay hoorain milaingee aur khob ayashee hogee is leeya ya sab jhoot par mabnee hai. Saljuk Sunni hamaree jaan kay darpay thay is leeya apnay deefa kay leeya unhoon nay fidaeen banaya thay. Sunni ismailio par kufr kay fatway laga kar hamay zibah kar rahay thay. Agar syedna hasan bin sabah na hootay to molvi hamay khatm kar chukay hotay.
3) Ismaili khufia is leeya hogay kyonkay sunnio nay hamay har jaga zibah kya, Is leeya hamaree kitabain bhee kam hogaeen. Aaj kal bhee molvi isee chakar may rahtay hain kay koi kufr ham par laga dain.
4) Jo log kharjee banay wo Hazar Ali(as) kay saath zaroor thay laikin un ko imam man kar un kay saath nahee thay balkay wo muaviah kay muqably may Harat Ali(as) kay saath thay.
Right
U batawo hmra is waqt ka fadia in ka is waqt ka Taliban 😅
Kitba mela ghe kha sa imam nizar a.s ko dokha sa fansi Daka qaira ma fir sab sa phla saludin ayubi na hmre Al azhar university k libary ma agh lagya aur wo in ka hero ha saludin ayubi Jo muslman ho ka dosro ke kitabo sa darta ha saleebi jango ka Waheed muslman aur sab sa zyada shia qatal keya is maloon na aur suni ka Nazar ma hero ban gya phla hmra imam a s ka nokar tha aur yahe waja ha ya imam a.s sa door aur muhbat is sa krta ha Jo imamo ka her waqt khalaf khada Huwa ho chah wo Jo b waqt ho aur Hassan bin Sabah ke banye gye janat ka ek be sahe koye bat laya waha morcopol ke kitab pad ka in ka alam din leekhta ha aur morcol polo ka opar futwa nahe lagata
proud to be ismaili Allhamdulliah❤
❤
Hafiz sahab ka ilam Masha Allah
❤❤
Dr sb, In Ismaili school of thought Hazar Hassan has never been declare as Imam. First Imam is Hazarat Ali a.s and 2nd is Imam Hussain a.s. Please do correct yourself.
Thanks dr sahib for your good explanations ,you are great personality,you are creating love
بہت خوب
اسماعیلی اور شیعہ کیمونٹی کے مطابق امام نبی کے حقیقی وصی کو کہا جاتا ہے۔ اسلام کے دوسرے بڑے فرقے اہل تشیع کے دوسرے بڑے گروہ اسماعیلی میں ناطق، وصی اور امام کی اصطلاح نہایت اہم ہے۔ یہ ایک الہی عہدہ سمجھا جاتا ہے۔
اسماعیلیوں کے ہر امام کو اسماعیلی فرقے اہل بیت کی ایک فرد اور اللہ اور رسول اللہ محمدﷺ کے بعد صاحب امر سمجھتے ہوۓ ان کی اطاعت کرتے ہیں۔
اور ان کو الہی فیض کا سر چشمہ جانتے ہیں۔ صرف پہلے چھ مستودع اور مستقر اماموں تک اثنا عشری شیعوں سے ان کا اتفاق ہے۔ ان میں امام ظاہر اور امام مستودغ کا نظریہ ہے۔
اسماعیلی اور شیعہ اثنا عشر یہ ان چھ آئمہ کو مشترکہ طور پر مانتی ہے .
علی بن ابی طالب۔۔۔۔امام مستقر
حسن بن علی۔۔امام مستودع
حسین بن علی۔۔۔۔۔امام مستقر
زین العابدین۔۔۔۔۔امام مستقر
محمد باقر۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔امام مستقر
جعفر صادق۔۔۔۔۔۔۔امام مستقر
اس طرح امام علی علیہ السلام سے لیکر امام جعفرصادق علیہ السلام تک اسماعیلیوں کے پانچ مستقر یعنی سلسلہ نسل بہ نسل جاری امامت پانچ ہیں۔اور عرضی امامت یعنی جو نور مستودع امام پیر حسن بن علی امام ہیں۔
یہاں سے اسماعیلی نظریات اہل تشیع اثناعشریہ سے الگ ہوکر اسماعیلی اماموں کا آغاز ہوتا ہے۔
اسماعیل بن جعفر
محمدبن اسماعیل المکتوم
محمد بن اسماعیل کے بعد فلسفہ اسماعیلیہ میں دورستر کا آغاز ہوتاہے۔اور امامت مستور یعنی پوشیدہ ہوتا ہے۔ امامت سلامیہ نامی مصر کے شہر میں نامعلوم جگہ پر مقیم ہوتا ہیں۔یوں اسی زمانہ مستور کو یعنی امامت کی پوشیدہ ہوجانے کو عقیدہ اسماعیلیہ میں ۔دور ستر کا زمانہ کہلاتا ہے۔اس زمانے میں ایک گروہ ساتویں امامت پر رک گیا ۔جنہیں سبعیہ اسماعیلی کہلایا گیا۔ان کا عقیدہ تھا کہ امام بھی سات ہوتے ہیں اس سے زیادہ امام نہیں ہونگے۔
سبعیہ یا ہفت امامی اسماعیلی، اسماعیل بن جعفر الصادق کو آخری امام جانتے ہیں اور ان کی غیبت کے قائل ہیں۔ یہان ایک بات یہ بھی ہیں کہ عام طور اسماعیلیوں کو بھی سبعیہ یا ہفت اسماعیلی اس فلسفیانہ نظریہ امامت پر بھی کہلایا جاتا ہیں کہ اسماعیلی امامت میں ہر ساتواں امام کے بعد نیا دور شروع ہوجاتی ہے۔یعنی چھ چھوٹے دور کے اماموں کے بعد اخری ساتویں امام بڑے دور کا امام ہوتا ہے اس کے بعد پھر سے چھوٹے دور شروع ہوجاتی ہیں۔اس طرح یہ سلسلہ ہر سات دوروں کے بعد گھومتا ہیں جیساکہ ہفتہ کے دنوں کا سلسلہ ہیں۔اس لئے بھی سبعیہ یا ہفت امامی موجودہ نزاری اسماعیلیوں کےلئے بھی کہلایا جاتا ہے۔اور نظریہ باطنی میں یہ سلسلے کو دور کبیر اور ادوار کبریا کہلاتا ہے۔موجودہ نزاری اونچاسویں امام سات بڑے دوروں کے اخری امام ہیں ۔یعنی 7×7 =49 : اور دور نبوت کے زمانے میں صامت یعنی خاموش ائمہ کی تعداد بھی اونچاس ہی تھا۔جن کا آخری امام بھی مولا علی علیہ السلام ہی تھا۔جو امام مقیم ابی طالب علیہ السلام کا جانیشن اور مستقر امام تھا۔جبکہ دور امامت کے پہلا ظہور امامت کے دور کا امام بھی مولا علی علیہ السلام ہی تھا۔جو آخری نبی محمدﷺ کا جانیشین اور وصی تھا۔۔
اور مولانا مرتضی علی کی نسل سے ہمارے حاضر موجود امام شاہ کریم الحسینی اسماعیلی عقیدے کے مطابق 49 حاضر موجود امام ہیں ۔۔۔
سر ماشاہ اللہ کافی اچھی معلومات ھے بٹ اسماعیلیوں کے بارے میں بیس فصد ٹھیک ھے باقی نیں کسی اسماعیلہ سکلر سے مکمل معلومات حاصیل کرنے کے بعد یہ کام اگے جاری رکھو مشاہ اللہ اچھی کام ھے اسماعیلہ علی کو رسول کا وصی مانتے ھے علی سے جعفر صادیق تک ایک ھے اسماعیل سے نزار تک اے نزار میں ایک فرقہ الگ ھوا اسماعیلہ کو نزار کے مانے پر نزاریہ کہلایا گیا پھر فاطمی حکومت بنانے پر ان اسماعیلہی نزاریہ کو فاطمی کے نام سے جانے گیے پھر اگے اکر 46 ویں امام حسن علی شاہ میں اکر ایران کے شاھن شاہ نے امام حسن علی کو اغاخان کا لقب بھی دیا اور اپنی بیٹی کا ریشتہ بھی دیا تو 46 ویں امام حسن علی شاہ پہلا اغاخان کہلایا گیا دوسرا اغاخان 47 ویں امام شاہ علی شاہ اور تسرا امام سلطان محمدشاہ اغاخان سویم 48 ویں امام اور اغاخان چہاروم موجودہ امام شاہ کریم الحسینی 49 ویں امام ھے اور امامت کا کنسپٹ یہ ھے ھر امام اپنے بعد انے ولا امام کیلے وصیت لکھ کر رکھتا ھے تاکہ بعد میں کوی اختلاف پیدا نہ ھو ڈایریک وہ اولاد اٹومیٹک امامت کا منصف سمبھال لیتا ھے اسماعیلہ امام علی سے اج تک اسی امر کے مطبق چلتے ھے
Aapne bahot acche se smjhaya hai ❤😊
جز اک اللہ
Dear Dr. Muhammad Zubair, your lectures on comparative studies of sects in Islam are very informative. I must appreciate it, However, I want to draw your attention to my following observation, unless, you are giving a perspective of one school of thought. While, you talk about unbiased approach and objective facts of the history, you have narrowed the perspective of your lecture by telling your students and general public in the end that the claimants of Imamat was a fight on the“gadhi” and adding that it was like a hereditary “madhrisa”.
Very respectfully, you have made a categorical and conclusive ending of your lecture. To me, it has made the viewers and your students biased, leaving no room for your students to further analyze and tow the facts of the history to arrive, of their own, at a better understanding.
With kind regards,
1st Imam is Ali
And present Imam is
Prince Karim Agakhan Al Hussaini
😂یہ حاضر طلباء بالکل نالائق واقع ہوئے ہیں۔ حافظ صاحب کو بار بار ٹوکتے ہیں اور ان کو اپنا موقف رکھنے ہی نہیں دیتے ۔۔۔ اللہ ان کو صبر سے سننے کی توفیق عطا فرمائے آمین 😂😂😂
بعض اوقات تو بالکل معصومانہ سوال ہر کے حافظ صاحب کے موقف کی دھجیاں اڑا دیتے ہیں ۔اور اس کہانی کے مصداق ہے کہ ایک قصہ گو نے ساری رات ہیر رانجھا کی دکھ بھری داستان سنائی ۔ صبح سامعین میں کے کچھ لوگ آکر۔ قصہ گو سے کہ ہیر عورت تھی یا مرد۔
@@outofboxtravel6276
Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well):
1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever
czcams.com/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/video.html
czcams.com/video/OIiNePgctF8/video.html (Zakat & Ring story)
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran czcams.com/users/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION;
Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
@@outofboxtravel6276
Interesting. I m an Ismaili.
Aga Khan is the title Imam Hassan Ali Shah,the title had been given by the Iranian ruler of that time, so it's incorrect to say Aga Khani, to Shia Ismaili Muslim sect.Please correct yourself if you are going to discuss any important topic.
Hafiz sahab aj k dor me ismailiya aik 'secretive' firqa he yaani apne aqaid zahir nai karte. Ap batain ap konse ismaili masadir se bat kar rahe hain
Proud to be Ismaili Shukar Allah
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
اسماعیلی بہت اچھا مسلک ہے لیکن اس میں بھی بوہرہ، سلیمانی اور دیگر بھی ہیں لیکن زیادہ مشہور نزاری ہیں۔
Un ka binyad sai hai but un kay log gumrah hai galat aqayid hai hn kay.
@@vvxjnqap log seda hoka kon sa axha kam kia ha?
Excellent study very knowledgeable series. But the students seems to be either uninterested or dumb because they keep asking stupid questions as if they were asleep while you were explaining so clearly and so well.
Good talk.Good Man.
Jo log imamat ko nai mante or khilafat k peche lage hain wo ye na sochain ki jannat me jayainge wo 200 per jahannum me hain q ki imam Allah ki taraf se hota hai or khalifa insanon ka muntakhib kiya howa hota hai or samajdar log khud samjainge ki Allah ka banaya howa mazhab thek hai ya insanon ka banaya howa
I viewed your complete one and half hour discussion, I appreciated your analysis, everyone has their own sect, school of thoughts, (LAKUM DINU KUM WALIADDIN) second thing I appreciate this sentence " I left mufti" and now I am giving my services as a " DAEE" this episode is much informative for all of us, either they belong to which sect, I requested to all brothers and sister here watched the complete episode take it informative, do not need to involved in baseless conversation. As a Shia Imami Nizari Ismaili ‘I have many arguments in this episode, but this not a right plate form we can discuss the real backgrounds, but one thing I must highlight here, This is our fundamental of Shia Islam that is (JAB GHADEER R KHAUM K MUQAM PAY Hazrat muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam NAY MULA ALI K HATH KHARA KAR K YE FARMAYA KI " AJ K BAD MAIN AP K DARMIAN 2 BHARI CHEZAIN CHOREY JA RAHA HU “AIK QURAN E MAJEED AUR DUSRI CHEEZ AHLAY BAYET, Yani Main Jis Ka Mula Hu Ali Uska Mula hai. Second Fact this is in our school of thoughts " At the time of Hazrat muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam (PBUH) was at his last stage only Mula Ali and Hazrat Ayesh (R.A) was accompanied. After buried and completed all matters, all other Islamic scholars came and said to Hazrat Ayesha R.A " We want to burry by our own hands so Hazrat Ayesha R.A said... worlds no power will dislodge Mula ALI, Because Mula Ali Was sited on graveyard with talwar like "Horse Riding " sir you have not even said any single words about this, Our history is very ancient and long So the conversation is very prolong. I appreciate if you invite us for more discussion.
ماشاءاللہ
Mashalllah great study
جزاک اللہ شیخ ❤❤
iska matlap Ismaili sirsile imamat sahi hei
czcams.com/video/GvXedBQTNW8/video.html
According to Shia Nizari Ismaili, our Imamat Zureet is as under:
1. Mulana Imam Ali AS
2. MulanaHussain AS
3. Mulana zenul Abideen
4. Mulana Muhammad Baqir
5. Mulana Jafer Sadiq
6. Mulana Ismail
7. Mulana Muhammad Bin Ismail
8. Mulana Wafi Ahmad AS
9. Mulana Taqi Muhammad
10. Mulana Razi uddin
11. Mulana Muhammad Nehdi ( first fatimeed khalef
.......
......
.....
49. Mulana Shah Karim Al Hussaini (Aga Khan 4th )
MASHAA ALLAH ASSALAMUALAIKUM WA REHMATULLAH E WA BARAKATUH
ONE POINT THAT HASSN BIN SABAH WAS NOT QARMATA ISMAILI HE WAS NIZARI ISMAILI WHO ESTABLISHED RULE IN IRAN IN DEFENSIVE MANNER.
I am Ismaili. Sir Mohammed Zubair ap further Ismaili theology and doctrines par lectures bana sakay tw banaiye ga,,,,
بے شک مشکل طریقے سے اسماعیلی تاریخ واضح کیا ہے مگر پھر بھی ریسرچ کی ضرورت ہے اس کے لئے فرہاد دفتری کی کتاب اسماعیلی تاریخ و عقائد پڑھیں تو کہ حسن بن صباح کے بارے میں واضح طور پر معلوم ہو
Allah jazaye kher de Hafiz Sahab aapko.
Baat zarasal yeh hai kay koi bhi apni islaah pe raazi nahi hai... Shiasm me jitney theological differences hain itney to Christianity me nhi hain. From Greek Orthodox to Protestants.
Agha Khaanio ko ager aap aur explain krden to bht behtr hoga. Is tabqay me generally logo ko ilm nhi hai.
استاد محترم اللہ آپ کے علم ایمان اور عمر میں برکت دے کوشش کریں لیکچر کے دوران سوال نہ ہوں ڈسٹربنس ہوتی ہے
Proud to b ismaili
حافظ صاحب میرا ایک سوال ہے اور امید کرتا ہوں آپ اگلی کسی قسط میں اسکا جواب دیں گے۔ ابھی جو آپ نے تقسیم بتائی مستعلی اور نزاری کی یہ امام مستنصر کے بعد مسئلہ پیدا ہوا۔ یعنی نزار بڑے تھے لیکن امام چھوٹے بھائی کو اسٹیبلشمنٹ نے بنا دیا لیکن اسماعیلی مسئلہ تو اس سے بھی بہت پہلے کا ہے۔ قرامطی بھی اسماعیلی تھے اور امام حاکم کو ماننے والے دروزی بھی اسماعیلی ہیں۔ ان دو فرقوں کا امامت کے متعلق کیا عقیدہ ہے یعنی وہ امام مکتوم تک کیسے پہنچتے ہیں۔ شکریہ
Kya dosray sects k pas bi Fiqh hai? jaisaey Fiqh Jafferiya kehtay ?
After fundamental sharia, some things are changed as updated with time. Now Dayee or peer replaced with instructions, like Aga Khan Hospital or University etc.
Please discuss nehjul balaga especially sermon of saskiya.
Qaari Sahab Immat k concepts se Khatam Nabowat ka Inkaar kese saabit hua? Jab app ki research aur illem is mamlay me bbut kamzorr haintou us topi5pe lab kushai nahi krna chhaiye
MAshaAllah Allah ap ko nazar badd sy mehfooz rakhein 🤲🏻
قران میں اھلبیت کا ذکر جب ذیادہ ھے تو اسماعیلی کے نزدیک امامت کا نظریہ بلکل درست ھے کیونکہ خدا وند ھمشہ ایک مقصوص نسل میں ھدایت انسانیت کیلیے پنچھتا ھے تو یہ نسل ھی کی تعریف اور زکر چار اسمانی کتاب کرتا ھے جن کو دین نبی نے اھلبیت کہا ھے
Tvm....
1) Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever czcams.com/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/video.html czcams.com/video/OIiNePgctF8/video.html (Zakat & Ring story).
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any Proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran czcams.com/users/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So, show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
2) SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
3) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
محترم زبیر صاحب۔ کیا آپ اس اسماعیلی اور بارہ امامی تصور امامت کے اختلاف پر اس پی ایج ڈی مقالے کا حوالہ دے سکتے ھیں کہ یہ کہاں سے پڑھا جا سکتا تھا؟
Alhumdulilalah shiaa imami Ismaili muslim 🤲💚❤️
Which sources/Books will you use for Ismaili? hope you will use the authentic ones
Dr Zahid Ali ki book ka name lye tarek bnao fatmya Dr shab kud ismail ty
@justinsaaf8824 Expose expose nahi khel rhey Hafiz sahab... Explain kr rhey hain. Ager aapko abhi bhi samjh nahi aaarrhi, to bhai sab ne Allah ko jawab dena hai. Yeh soch lo bas.
@justinsaaf8824
Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well):
1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever
czcams.com/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/video.html
czcams.com/video/OIiNePgctF8/video.html (Zakat & Ring story)
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran czcams.com/users/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION;
Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,………
@justinsaaf8824
Do U still believe that 28/7 = 13 ?????????
hassan bin sabah was ismaili not qrati. he was muslim leaer leader . here u mis repoted hassan bin sabah. he was as per muslims.
Bt thy are nt following 5 pillar of islam so how thy are b muslim thy change salah thy chang zakat, thy chang roza their Imam is still nt perform any umraha or any Haj.
to be Muslim, apko aek Allah aur uske last Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and Quran pak pr trust hona chahiye aur Ismaili rakhte hain, then kaise Muslim nahe huay?
Allah Pak ka shukar hai Islam K thakdar Kam Nahi hai
Great Sir. I may be Ur first follower. Following and watching ur videos since long ❤
Molna sap mai khud aek Ismail hun aap ki information bilkul ghalt Ismaili phulspha k bara mai agar aap waqi mai jana chahta hain tu aap Ismaili scholars say ruju kra apna traf say gahdai bata un say mansub krna ghalt hay
Boahat si batain asi hain jo bilkul theek nahi hain ye book in sahab k pas aye kahan say hain ya apnay ghar par chapi hain
Iss book may Kafi cheezain Sahi hay.
Bahi jan es k bari mi Hami pata b nihe ya Zahid kon hi es NI jo leka bkwaz hi ya Ismailion ko bad nm krni k leyi leka hi
Assalam U Alaikum dr sahab 1 episode me sirf rawayat ki detail batain ta k hum kahi note kr lain maslan book name page num or volume wagera sb rawayat ka
بہت اچھی بات ہے کہ اسلام کے اندر مختلف نظریات کا علم تمام کو دینا چاہیے۔ جس موضوع پہ آج بات ہو رہی ہے اس میں کافی حد تک درست بات کی جارہی ہے لیکن جس طرح نطقاہ کے تصور پہ بات ہوئی ہے کہ اول ناطق آدم علیہ السلام اور چھٹا ناطق حضرت محمد صلعم ہیں۔ یہاں تک بات درست ہے اسماعیلی فلسفے میں ایسا ہی ہے لیکن ساتویں ناطق کی جو بات ہو رہی ہے یعنی محمد بن اسماعیل ساتویں ناطق ہیں، ایسا نہیں ہے۔ کیونکہ محمد بن اسماعیل نطقاہ کی اس سلسلے میں نہیں آتا بلکہ آپ محمد صلعم کے بعد دور مہین ( چھوٹے دور) کے ساتویں امام ہیں جبکہ آدم علیہ سلام سے جو دور نطقاہ کا ہے اسے دور کہین (بڑا دور) کہا جاتا ہے جس ہر ایک ہزار سال بعد ایک نیا ناطق آنے کا تصور ہے یعنی چھہ ہزار سال میں چھہ نطقاہ آئے ہیں جن میں چھٹا ناطق محمد صلعم ہیں جبکہ ساتویں ناطق ان گزشتہ چھہ نطقاہ کے شریعیتوں کے ادوار مکمل ہونے پر آنے کا تصور ہے جسے قائم کے نام سے پکارنے کا بیان آتا ہے۔ لہذہ محمد ابن اسماعیل کو ساتویں ناطق تصور کرنا اسماعیلی فلصلے کے مطابق درست نہیں ہے۔
❤
Dr sahab boht achi maloomat lecon aap asool kafi ki farishtey ka sharbat lana imam key mathey ya kandho ya pusht per kalmaa kun aur khatna shuda paidaish wali jhuti rawaitey bhi bayan kardey kionkey agar ye nishanian sachi hoti to shio ka imamo pey ikhtalaf khatm hojata jis mey ye nishanian wohi imam khatna dekho wo hi imam aur asul kafi ki allah sey bhul hogayee wali hadees bayan karna bhul gaye shayd studendents zayada intercept kartey hey
Very good knowledgeable lecturer
Muhtaram, yeh baatain Jin Ismaili kitabo se Nikal kar aap ne bayan ki Hain, Kindly, UN kitabo ka reference dijea ga!
Sir,,,, you are mixing all sects,,, apke nazdeeq IMAMIYA and ISMAILIA alag alag hy,,,, jab k IMAMIYA k under hi two major groups hy,,,, first ITHNA ASHYRIYA and second ISMAILIA,,,, baqi small groups alag hy,,,,
Second ye hy k ismailis ka FATIMIDS ka period IMAM ABD-ALLAH AL-MEHDI se start hua,,, ye imam 11th imam hy ismailis,,,,not 12th....
And apne ismaili doctrine k baray me bataya,,,,wo new information thi mere liye,,,, appreciated,,,,
Allah sab shia ko hidayat dae. Allah inhe islam k raste pa lae aa. Allah sab shia ko hidyat aur islam ki roahni atta kr. Inhae NABI Pak PBUH ki talimaat pa lae k aa na k stories whimes or twists par
الحمدللہ رب العالمین آپ بہترین کام کر رہے ہیں اللہ تعالیٰ عمر خضر با صحت و آفیت عطا فرمائے آمین
@justinsaaf8824
Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well):
1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever
czcams.com/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/video.html
czcams.com/video/OIiNePgctF8/video.html (Zakat & Ring story)
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran czcams.com/users/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION;
Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
2) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,………
u v good study.
salam alikum...sir aap ke student kuch zaida hi chote hain...ik ik chez ka matlab pooch rahe hain
jannat wala concept ghalt hain plz do more research on it. or ya qarmati nahi tha
wrong \
Qarmatians is a sect of Ismaili
As a ismaili.
I once again emphasis you don't rely on any individual wriiten book, you can contact the shia Ismaili schoolers, because they fully represent the sect as appointef by imam of the time.
But imamat Hazrat Ali to now continue, and there no questions of any break in imamat in this world, but imamat continues in Hazrat Ali generation.
ڈاکٹر صاحب آپ کے سامنے بیٹھے لوگوں میں چند ایک لوگ ہیں جن کے لیے یہ گفتگو فائدہ مند ہوگی باقی سب کے اوپر سے گزر رہی ہے ان کے سوالوں سے پتہ چل رہا ہے.
Ye un logo k ilawa hamary lia b h ap tension na lain. Search krain apni kitabo k bary ma.
@@abdullahsiddiqawan9100
Hmari konsi kitabe bhai?
Hasan bin Sabah was not a qaramatian he was a Nizari ismaili shia muslim. And plz student the history of Hasan bin Sabah from both sides (from ismaili source and from non ismaili source).
All the blame on Hasan bin Sabah are wrong.
Let me clear:
Natiq quran hota hai. Aasas imam e zamana hota hai.
i think Dr zahid ali is a bohra ismaili. But kindly understand the importance of imamat from the nizari source as well.
Dr. Hafiz Saheb as I understand your lecture mostly depend upon Zahid Ali's book. Mostly Sunni and Shia writers have given twisted account about Ismailis. Imam NEVER lie about NASS. Banu Abbas used the name of Imam Jafar Sadiq and Ahl e Bait to defeat Banu Umayyads. When followers of Imam and general public demanded that Caliphat is right of Imam Jafar or else from Ahl e Bait that annoyed Abul Abbas " AsSaffa" the first Caliph of Abbasid. He turned against Ahl e Bait and declared himself as Caliph. Imam Jafar Sadiq in his life time had nominated his eldest son Ismail as Imam and had taken Baiyat for Ismail from people of MEDINA. When Imam Jafar came to know that Abbasid spies are looking for Ismail to assassinate him he secretly sent Ismail to Syria. From there Imam Ismail and his son Muhammad Al Maktum moved to Faras and from there to Azarbhaijan.
Ismaili don’t consider Hassan (AS) as Imam he was khalifa it was Imam Hussain AS directly after Imam Ali considering that Muhammad ibn e Ismail is 7th Imam.
I think ismili do mean the imamat as oolil amr as described in holy Quran his work is time tested ijtehad
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Dr Sb,
Qaramta was defected section of Ismailis. You can not say Qaramta part of Ismailis. Please correct your study.
I just want to add some more knowledge to you sir. Ismailism ma zaruri nahe bara beta imam ho. For example, imam sultan Mohammad shah na apny bety salman ko imamati nahe di. Balki apny pooty prince Karim agha Khan ko imamti di. Imam bary ya choty ki base pa nahe hota. Imam khud apna janishesn(next imam) chunta hai. Same happened in Daurah Ismail. Imam Ismaili was choosen by imam jaffar bin sadiq not because he was elder but because he was meant to be Imam of that time.
Sir , are Ahle-Bayat( rehmullah) themselves Shia or Sunni !
Neither shia nor sunni
@@Sigma_Coder
Sir, I am confused because many imams like Imam Zaid, Imam Yahya, Imam Nafse Zaqi etc confronted with Ummayad Khalifs and got martyred. What did they fight for ?
Because Imamat v Khilafat is the basic cause of division.
@@user-xv3xl3mt7n yes of course. Imamat is the base of division.
@@user-xv3xl3mt7nto take over government.
ismaili in sindh & Gujarat called khoja please correct your interpretation.
امامت کا عقیدہ ،ختم نبوت کے خلاف پے۔ امام باقر اور امام جعفر صادق نے تو قران میں بھی شبہات پیدا کئے ہیں۔
Imam her zamane me mojud hota hai jo imam ko imam nai mante wo kufur kar rahe hain or is me koi shak nahi ki wo jahannum me hain
Dr. Sab Jab Nas aik dafa hota hy tu wo reverse nahi hota, is liye Imam Ismail pay Nas howa tha. Nas aik dunyawi amal nahi hy bilki aik ruhani power app transfer karty hean.
روٸۓ زمین پر جہاں اچھاٸ ھے وہ دین ھے اسے ھمنے اپنی تہزیب کے مطابق شکل دینی ھے یہ شرعہ ھے
حدیث پاک ہے کہ "میرے بعد اسلام کے 73 فرقے ہونگے جن میں سے صرف ایک ناجی ہوگا جو نجات پائے گا " اب وہ ایک فرقہ کونسا ہے اسکا فیصلہ اللہ نے کرناہے۔
پوری حدیث کم بیان کرتے ہیں ۔حدیٹ ماانا علیہ واصحابی۔۔۔۔ترتھر۷۳ میں سے جو لوگ میری سنت اور میرے صحابہ رض کی سنت پر عمل کرینگے۔وہ کامیاب ہونگے۔
Bhai ye imam keh kr nhi 4th khalifa k sath they sheyan e Ali a.s wo thay jo khalifa bannay se oehlay se hi Maula Ali a.s k sath thay ap dhiya tareekh batatay batatay sunniayat r muaveyat r yazideyat me chalay gayea r pata nhi kia oonth patang batay krnay lug gayea ap agay chalay peechay na jayea wahan garh barh he plz sheyat me rahe ya apni tableegh he jari rakhay
ap ko knowledge nhe hai to bkws q karty
Ali (599-661)
Husayn ibn Ali (626-680)
Ali ibn Husayn Zayn al-Abidin (659-712)
Muhammad al-Baqir (676-743) * Offshoot of Zaydiyyah.
Ja'far al-Sadiq (702-765) * Offshoot of Twelvers.
Isma'il ibn Jafar (721-762)
Muhammad ibn Ismail.........
Hazrat comments bhi padh liya kijiye
SO it is permount to save wabehakey .
No Dr, Sahib your totally wrong Mohammad Bin Ismail is 7th Imam not 7th Natiq some of information is okay but most information is not from Ismaili is not form Ismaili Sources