Dhara Shah vs German Child Welfare: A mother's fight for rights to get her daughter back | WION
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 02. 2024
- Germany is keeping a 28-month-old Indian baby from her mother. Baby Ariha was taken away from her parents in Berlin when she was all of 7-month-old. German authorities have placed the baby in a facility for children with special needs. But Ariha is not a special needs baby.
#arihashah #germany #dharashah
About Channel:
WION The World is One News examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim is to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to world politics. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalized united world. So for us, the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs and personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for the latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Business:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps: bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
We Indians stand together strong for this Mother and want Ariha Shah to return back to Home 🏠 where she should be because that's what her right is and her mother's right is
These European nations don't focus on geopolitical issues but want to interfere in the real life problems of common people 😡😤🤯
This is such a heartbreaking case. How can the German authority keep this child? It is so unnecessary and cruel. I pray that the child gets united with its parents soon.
We want Ariha back .....😢
Being a mother i feel her pain
May Gov do something as early as possible.... Good Luck 🤞
German first should solve thire prblm like teens are being distroyed by drugs etc then they sould takecare of world... & Return her child plz
Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway
The infant had severe vaginal injuries and stitches were neede. Something is not right. Many other injuries also found on other occasions. So this case is a but fishy. Dont be emotional just listening to the mother's side. They said the vaginal injuries were accidentally caused by gramother's nails while changing diapers. Can anyone believe that? They also sent away the grandparents to India before the police could question them.
I can give you the whole timeline:
Ariha was kept diaperfree as much as possible for that whole week as she had developed rashes due to diaperwear. A 7 month old baby is constantly trying to get up and falls, that normal! The chances are very high that Ariha fell on a sharp toy on that fateful day. The grandmother who first discovered the blood too tried to treat it her way - which our elders do, which aggrivated the wound!
16th sep 21: Dhara discovers blood in the diaper.
17th sep 21: she takes Ariha to the pediatrician for check up. Doc lets them go saying everything looks fine, it could be haromanal bleeding. Nothing to worry.
21st Sep 21: Dhara takes Ariha voluntarily for check up. This time doc says it is external perineal injury. They send the baby for examination to the hospital around 11:00. A surgeon is involved. Then multiple docs come for checking who keep arguing over if or not to stitch the wound. Then at 7pm the treatment actually begins (then she got stitches for the wound). On the 21st the mother and child stay in the hospital.
After one whole year of pleading with the hospital, Dhara finally got the reports of what the doctors actually tested for! The surgeons did too many inspections (Cystoscopy, vaginoscopy for example) which actually aggrieved the wounds! Such tests should be avoided on babies and children this small.
On 22nd sep 21: Child services enters the scene. An interpreter (Pakistani male) comes into play who translates everything on behalf of the parents. The parents are questioned in detail. When Dhara says the child was throughout with the family (wo humare saath thi), he mistranslated it saying the child was continously with the mother (hum is main in urdu). So the child services believed that the child abuse was conducted by the mother. Police is now involved.
It takes the family 3 days to find a lawyer who informs them that Dhara is accused of child abuse and police case has been registered on her and her husband.
After 3 months in Dec 21, the same hospital who called the child services, gives their medical reports and rules out child abuse. The reports say the wounds were external and not internal, which could have been accidental. Police, based on this report, close the case and does not charge them.
Now child services takes the case to family court. Family court asks for psycho analysis to be done of parents to see if they are fit to be parents. 11 hrs of questioning happens by the appointed psychologist. They wait for the reports which come 12 months later in Dec 22!
Reports are in favor of parents and suggest that Ariha should be given to parents and kept under child services supervision.
A cultural expert too is appointed by the court to observe parents bond and behavior around the child everytime they meet. This report too is in parents favor.
Mar 2023: court hearings go on for 2 days straight. In that around 9.5 hrs are given to cultural expert and psycologist who speaks in parents favor. Only 2 hrs are given to parents to defend themselves, however tare not allowed to defend on how the child could have been injured.
On 13th june: verdict is out. Court gives full custody to child services.
They now take 2 injuries as the reason. One was a head injury child happened while Ariha was 4 months old. Second is the vaginal injury. When Ariha was 4 months old, Dhara was oiling her like its traditionally done in India. After a nice oil massage, Dhara takes her to the bath tub and Ariha slips from her hand while putting her in, causing an injury. Anyone living abroad can understand how difficult it is to bathe babies in bathrooms with bathtubs, especially when one has to do it alone!
Dhara and Bhavesh have been consultad an external doctor from the US regarding the vaginal injury. Firstly the injury is external, not internal, secondly the injury has been aggrivated by multiple examinations conducted by the doctors in the hospital and thirdly, there are at least 30 reported cases with external perineal wounds worldwide which do happen on diaperfree babies.
Most importantly, by putting Ariha in foster care - moving her for the 4th time now (next in May 2024), how is the child services doing any good to Ariha?
Ariha is an Indian citizen. She now speaks only german, her parents can't speak the language. How will she communicate with them in the future or even manage in India?
This is my take on the matter.
Its been hearings after hearings! Whoever meets Dhara knows instantly that she is lost in the system and needs urgent support.
If Germany decides to apply law of continuity, Arihas citizenship will be changed to German and India will then on be able to do NOTHING! We have then lost a daughter.
You saw it ....Indian govt is already involved
@@SD-wk5qlGood details. one question. Wasn’t the baby speaking Gujarati in the video?
are we missing something in this reporting?
where is the German side of the story? if I remember correctly, previously somebody reported that the child was found injured twice.
what happened? where is that part?
A judgement is not complete without knowing the both sides of the story.
The Western Child Welfare System is flawed. You can easily review the reports from European activists who handle these matters, or you can look up the cases against these organizations in the European Court of Human Rights. In Europe, there is a growing movement to amend the laws that oversee the Child Welfare System. The court give judgement based on the current legislation. Although the activists argue that the laws themselves need revision.
To gain an understanding of the severity of the issue, I suggest you read the work of lawyer Suranya Aiyar, who practices in New Delhi and was recognized by the Nordic Committee for Human Rights for opposing and rejecting Western child protection models and educating policymakers worldwide about their detrimental effects on traditional family structures. She is even recommending that the Indian government ignore the advice of Indian social science scholars who are slavishly attempting to import and reproduce the Western model into India.
They tried hard to seek answer, but no official statement has given until now.
The case of injury is already closed without any charge. Why will Germany show his mistakes ????
@@JivanandClinic have you live in Germany or are you living now? They will definitely send a letter of allegation, they cannot confiscate a child like that. now that's another matter that the letter may contain false allegation. it might also possible somebody has framed these couple out of jealously, Germany has a record in it, i think many cases goes unreported.
Child had injury in private part. Had bleeding and hence needed stitches. This report is not even half truth.
It wasn't even blood. In fact, it's mostly the so-called brick dust sediment. It's caused by uric acid crystals being excreted from the kidneys in the urine. This is usually a matter of a few days and is both harmless and painless for your baby. In Germany there are hired professionell in every area, including doctors, teachers, in kindergartens, in courts almost everywhere they specifically work on the children to get the family out. First of all, the doctor writes that the mothers are psychologically abnormal, which is why a family assessment should take place. At the end, the experts specifically write that the parents are "incapable of parenting" because of "a lot of love for their child or because of their past or as always.The result is always the same,take the children from their family household.I studied thausand cases ,the same method,same way,same result.The children taken out of families will mostly delieverd to the Pädophile families fosters
U pls speak abt why did your mother in law hurt the child dat it had to put stitches… ur talking abt taking care and love now?? Was in Germany all these while now she is so concerned abt Bharath.
Western society is very sick. I am in Canada. god Bless the child and parents.
It is better to research about child and family welfare services before moving abroad especially in Western countries.
Why Germany is not giving the child ? Even indian government is seeking the kid ?
Is there any hidden agenda of Germany?
Why report is so incomplete. Child had injury in private part. Had bleeding and hence needed stitches. This report is not even half truth.
After seeing your comment I actually checked on the facts of injury to the child and case of sexual harassment to the child ....
So the same hospital which reported suspect of child sexual harassment reported later on the court that bleeding was due to some medical condition and the case was closed in 2022 ... And now it is 2024 and the kid is still in child welfare custody...
It is terribly sad
Why are you posting same comment....are you investigating on behalf of Indian govt
A True Friend is the One who stays with his Friend till the End.
A True Brother is the One who stays with his Brother till the End.
And a True Wife is the One who stays with her Husband till the End.
Selfish Cheaters on the other hand only cares about themselves.
We want Areha back to India...we support you...
Where is the father?
Please support this mother and baby and bring her back to India. Ariha Shah belongs to India. I am praying for her safe return to her parents and it will happen soon.
It's too sad how an innocent child is taken away from her parents
Very sad for both child and parent
Returan back Ariha we will always with you
We are frome srilanka
The child welfare system in the West is not perfect. Advocates such as attorney Suranya Aiyar, who received recognition from the Nordic Committee for Human Rights for her refusal to accept and oppose Western child protection methods, are teaching decision-makers across the globe about the harm these models do to traditional family systems. I hope the Indian government heeds her advise and disregards the social science researchers in India who are slavishly trying to bring in and replicate the Western model.
I am also jain I wish to God ki ariha vapas aaye ❤❤💅🏽
We want ariha back to India
Yes there's something that German folks might have seen . Hearing from her interview how can a baby get such injuries. Something is fishy. However I hope they get justice or the kid wherever truth is .
Indian govt already involved in investigation
We want back lovely baby Ariha❤
CRUELTY GERMAN GOVT
Why Indian government is not trying.. Please back her daughter
In my opinion,It wasn't even blood. In fact, it's mostly the so-called brick dust sediment. It's caused by uric acid crystals being excreted from the kidneys in the urine. This is usually a matter of a few days and is both harmless and painless for your baby. In Germany there are hired professionell in every area, including doctors, teachers, in kindergartens, in courts almost everywhere they specifically work on the children to get the family out. First of all, the doctor writes that the mothers are psychologically abnormal, which is why a family assessment should take place. At the end, the experts specifically write that the parents are "incapable of parenting" because of "a lot of love for their child or because of their past or as always.The result is always the same,take the children from their family household.I studied thausand cases ,the same method,same way,same result.The children taken out of families will mostly delieverd to the Pädophile families fosters
Such a thing would not require stitches to suture the wound would it ??
@@AzuraShad0w exactly,A problem like that doesn't need stitches and that's why the parents were sent home without further ado. After a few days, when they went there voluntarily out of precaution, the stitches were done to creat a Reason(a reason to take children out of familiy,this Mafia do always such taktik). Although on that day the seargeon didn't want stitches either Other doctor insisted and the ignorant mother allowed it.
everbody wants to run away to foreign countries as there is no called 'scope' in India, but when we have to follow the foreign rules, we ask India and Modijis help?
Before one relocate plese read and understand law and children's rights laws of the county.
Pls help concerned authorities.
This is the problem in west…
The staff just want to retain the budget of their departments and so they have made this child a scapegoat.
This is horrible and nobody should go through this.
We need to teach germany a lesson. Without any proof of sexual abuse, they are holding on to the child…. Just to save themselves from embarrassment.
What great work Jaya Bahaduri is doing that her pic is shown here....no contribution towards anything constructive
Shame German authority
Indian government please uski maa se bachi Ko Mila do Modi ji🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Ariha 2024 mein parents ke sath Indian ajayegi
1000%
I can give you the whole timeline:
Ariha was kept diaperfree as much as possible for that whole week as she had developed rashes due to diaperwear. A 7 month old baby is constantly trying to get up and falls, that normal! The chances are very high that Ariha fell on a sharp toy on that fateful day. The grandmother who first discovered the blood too tried to treat it her way - which our elders do, which aggrivated the wound!
16th sep 21: Dhara discovers blood in the diaper.
17th sep 21: she takes Ariha to the pediatrician for check up. Doc lets them go saying everything looks fine, it could be haromanal bleeding. Nothing to worry.
21st Sep 21: Dhara takes Ariha voluntarily for check up. This time doc says it is external perineal injury. They send the baby for examination to the hospital around 11:00. A surgeon is involved. Then multiple docs come for checking who keep arguing over if or not to stitch the wound. Then at 7pm the treatment actually begins (then she got stitches for the wound). On the 21st the mother and child stay in the hospital.
After one whole year of pleading with the hospital, Dhara finally got the reports of what the doctors actually tested for! The surgeons did too many inspections (Cystoscopy, vaginoscopy for example) which actually aggrieved the wounds! Such tests should be avoided on babies and children this small.
On 22nd sep 21: Child services enters the scene. An interpreter (Pakistani male) comes into play who translates everything on behalf of the parents. The parents are questioned in detail. When Dhara says the child was throughout with the family (wo humare saath thi), he mistranslated it saying the child was continously with the mother (hum is main in urdu). So the child services believed that the child abuse was conducted by the mother. Police is now involved.
It takes the family 3 days to find a lawyer who informs them that Dhara is accused of child abuse and police case has been registered on her and her husband.
After 3 months in Dec 21, the same hospital who called the child services, gives their medical reports and rules out child abuse. The reports say the wounds were external and not internal, which could have been accidental. Police, based on this report, close the case and does not charge them.
Now child services takes the case to family court. Family court asks for psycho analysis to be done of parents to see if they are fit to be parents. 11 hrs of questioning happens by the appointed psychologist. They wait for the reports which come 12 months later in Dec 22!
Reports are in favor of parents and suggest that Ariha should be given to parents and kept under child services supervision.
A cultural expert too is appointed by the court to observe parents bond and behavior around the child everytime they meet. This report too is in parents favor.
Mar 2023: court hearings go on for 2 days straight. In that around 9.5 hrs are given to cultural expert and psycologist who speaks in parents favor. Only 2 hrs are given to parents to defend themselves, however tare not allowed to defend on how the child could have been injured.
On 13th june: verdict is out. Court gives full custody to child services.
They now take 2 injuries as the reason. One was a head injury child happened while Ariha was 4 months old. Second is the vaginal injury. When Ariha was 4 months old, Dhara was oiling her like its traditionally done in India. After a nice oil massage, Dhara takes her to the bath tub and Ariha slips from her hand while putting her in, causing an injury. Anyone living abroad can understand how difficult it is to bathe babies in bathrooms with bathtubs, especially when one has to do it alone!
Dhara and Bhavesh have been consultad an external doctor from the US regarding the vaginal injury. Firstly the injury is external, not internal, secondly the injury has been aggrivated by multiple examinations conducted by the doctors in the hospital and thirdly, there are at least 30 reported cases with external perineal wounds worldwide which do happen on diaperfree babies.
Most importantly, by putting Ariha in foster care - moving her for the 4th time now (next in May 2024), how is the child services doing any good to Ariha?
Ariha is an Indian citizen. She now speaks only german, her parents can't speak the language. How will she communicate with them in the future or even manage in India?
This is my take on the matter.
Its been hearings after hearings! Whoever meets Dhara knows instantly that she is lost in the system and needs urgent support.
If Germany decides to apply law of continuity, Arihas citizenship will be changed to German and India will then on be able to do NOTHING! We have then lost a daughter.