1948: Creation & Catastrophe (Full documentary)
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 07. 2024
- Through riveting and moving personal recollections of both Palestinians and Israelis, 1948: Creation & Catastrophe reveals the shocking events of the most pivotal year in the most controversial conflict in the world. It tells the story of the establishment of Israel as seen through the eyes of the people who lived it. But rather than being a history lesson, this documentary is a primer for the present. It is simply not possible to make sense of what is happening today without an understanding of 1948. This documentary was the last chance for many of its Israeli and Palestinian characters to narrate their first-hand accounts of the creation of a state and the expulsion of a nation. Hear stories from the Israelis and Palestinians who personally lived through events in Haifa, Jaffa, Dayr Yasin, Acre, Jerusalem, Ramla, Lydda and more. These shocking and dramatic events reveal the core of what drives the conflict today.
1948movie.com
For a bibliography, visit 1948movie.com/research
1948movie
Note from the producers:
This documentary is ten years in the making. We collected dozens of stories from fighters, refugees (many still living in camps) and survivors of the war. Their stories are powerful, heart-breaking and shocking.
On top of those interviews, we conducted a mountain of research (over 20,000 pages of history), painstakingly fact-checking every statement made in the documentary. Our team gathered photographs and film from archives across the globe. We retrieved copies of military orders from Israeli archives. We translated dozens of Arabic and Hebrew interviews as well as secondary documents. And we interviewed and consulted with some of the most respected historians in the field.
This has been a colossal amount of work. We sincerely hope you get something out of it.
Andy Trimlett & Dr. Ahlam Muhtaseb
0:00 Introduction
12:14 Partition
19:37 Plan D
23:11 Dayr Yasin
31:32 Haifa
36:22 Jaffa
42:16 Declaration
47:44 Acre
51:14 Ramla & Lydda
58:39 Negba & Nazareth
1:01:43 Beersheba
1:04:30 Preventing Return
1:09:35 Design
1:14:23 Villages
1:16:35 Statehood
1:20:24 Returning
1:22:32 Conclusion
in addition to this docu, there is also a 18min docu (here on YT) by the Balfour Project - called: "Britain in Palestine 1917-1948". Please search for it (links in comments often get removed, hence i won't include it). In the 18min video, the earlier history is outlined w/ more details&dynamics of the betrayal/conflicting promises at the base of this bloody and heart-breaking mess. - Thank you.
Thanks for the suggestion.
As an Indian who got their Independence in 1947 among many other countries during the post WW2 period, it's crazy that how this tragedy is not spoken about much in the mainstream. While we got freedom another group of people lost everything. Feeling guilt for one religion doesn't give you the reason to excuse them to carry out the same atrocities that they have faced throughout the history. It's as if we learned nothing from the history. It's a shame to call ourself humans when such suffering takes place anywhere in the world. It feels as if the word human is a curse on us. Much love to the Palestinian people and Jewish people who're caught up in this tragedy.❤🩹
This film omits pre 1948 history that accounts for what happened. To me it looks like the post war Arab world rejected partition and prevented the Muslim population from self determination. They declared war on Israel before it was even a legal State.
The Arab Muslims refused to negotiate. They refused to make room for holocaust victims fleeing post war Europe. I think at least 50 percent of the displacement history was self inflicted, based on what I've read.
And we can refer to the Syrian displacement of FIFTEEN MILLION of their own citizens due to civil war between Muslim people and ethnic minorities to understand how multiple forces create these tragedies. Arab and Islamic extremism is the atomic core of present-day conflict.
Thank you for your kind words. You are correct. We should all be ashamed of ourselves and what some of our governments are doing and have done in our name. Be it Americans, Israeli's, or anyone else. We're all complicit.
Yes perhaps the thing that is most astonishing is that the Jews enacted upon these Arabs exactly the same torturous events which had just a few years prior been enacted upon them,
@rotkatzeredcat4284 how can you even say that? Six million Jews were murdered throughout Europe and were subjected to ghettos and pogroms for generations. Nothing like the genocide of Jews ever happened to the Palestinians.
Gazans have been crossing the border into Israel for work. Israelis left their homes and businesses in Gaza , so Palestinians could settle there. They receive billions in aid.
They are very close to full national status. They do not want peace, they want Israel.
The Israelis, are basically dealing with a people who refuse their right to exist. This is the barrier to peace sadly and it is the ordinary people both jewish and arab who suffer and pay the price of their leaders, who make bad decisions on their behalf. Israel has its faults, but it has never denied the right to exist for the arabs.
I'm nearly 70 years old and I've studied WWII and the Bible before I was even 10 and this is the first time I'm hearing about this! It's unbelieveable that they would do to the Palistinians after what the Germans had done. It doesn't make fighting, hatred or pride right. I'm sorry when any people die for greed and this is what this is. Why would the Palistrinians have to leave their land and their homes? That's not right especially after the Jews had their homes and businesses taken away. I blames this on the UN. There was no reason that the Jews could not have assimilated and live peaceable with thier neighbors. They could have built homes, started businesses. There was nothing stopping them from doing that. Why did Palistine lose their country? So unfair!! I'm ashamed of humanity. I find this all so unbelievable. When the Bible prophesied about Israel becoming a nation again, I wonder if God knew they would act like this. Humanities history is really disturbing. OK, I'm done!!
Israel isn't God's chosen people. They are the Ashkenazi Jews the Synagogue of Satan Rev 2 9:10, & 3:9 .....in the book of John Jesus told them they are of their father the devil. Jesus also told them they are not of the seed of Abraham or they would have known Jesus Christ was the Son of God the true Messiah. They deny Christ Jesus. & Jesus Christ told them whither He goeth they can not come ( the Kingdom of God) they turned from God, & started Baal WORSHIPPING, worshipping other gods, statue's etc....they had Christ Jesus crucified by the Roman Soldiers. If you read their Talmud they Blaspheme Jesus, & His Mother Mary. They want power, & control over the entire world. It's not the NWO but the JWO....they are very evil, racist, & full of hate. Their religion Judaism one must deny Christ Jesus in order to convert. Their Noahide law's is death by decapitation Rev 20:4.
They are building the third temple for their false messiah the antichrist.
they are Lucifer's disciples.
Yet for generations, & generation's we were lied to by tv Evangelicals, pastors etc.....that they are God's Chosen People.
If you research all tv Evangelicals, pastors, media, all presidents in the white house ( ALL PRESIDENTS), Hollywood, LGBT, etc....etc....they control. People have been asleep for generations now. But God through the Holy Spirit is waking so many up Spiritually.
Jesus Christ of Nazareth warned us of them all through the New testament. They hate Jesus, & they hate white people period. The white population is the target. They believe white people are from the devil, & needs to be destroyed. They claim God hates white people ( their god Lucifer does) but then again he hates everyone including them. But they are deceived 😥💔
May God have mercy 😥🙏
Please don’t be offended when I ask this question. Why are you reading the bible as if it’s a historical facts? That text was written thousands and thousands of years ago and you don’t know under what circumstances those texts were written (meaning written under oppression, raids, wars, etc.). In my opinion we were brainwashed to read the bible as historical facts when it should not be. You see with your eyes what’s happening and your eyes will never deceive you.
Why involve the Germans 14 million Germans were evicted by force from land that had been German for 300 years This happened in 1945/7 2 million were killed over 2 million German women were raped Churchill Rooseveldt and Stalin were in agreement with these crimes
Im guessing HAMAS got their revenge on Oct 7th.....
Robot
I have so much respect for Ilan Pappe because i am familiar with his work. This documentary shows that there are many jewish historians who are against zionism and are not afraid of saying that Israel is a terrorist state.
There is enough blame to go around terrorist on both sides no? I believe in peace babies woman children being killed ....you can not murder babies and justify it either side this is no one's land but gods
@@user-gc3nt8gs5n For zioNazis; check CNN & BBC news. Investigation says 7 oct party shooting was done by an isreali airplane that aimed at hmas fighters and didn't care for the club.
They always doing DARVO... Deny Attack Reverse Victim and Offender... They actually just a bunch of psycopaths who failed to use their own critical thinking and their heart...
jews r ok......not zionists
@@user-gc3nt8gs5n YOU ARE DELUSIONAL
Please, add Polish subtitles!
This documentary must be shared, especially with Polish citizens!
Thank you for that shocking historical context of a conflict we are a witnesses until today...
Peace and love for all of the people around the world.
Hope the truth will be at least reviled to publicity one day.
Why do you want it to be shared with Polish citizens?
You can translate it into Polish and contact the uploaders to have them added.
@@MargaritaMagdalenapourquoi ça vous dérange de partager cette vidéo c'est fait pour partager dans le monde pour ceux qui ignore les crimes sionistes et le génocide d'Israël le monde voit en live qui ils sont
@@Userx4566 Il dit *"surtout* avec les citoyens polonais", donc je suis curieux de savoir pourquoi il pense que les Polonais ont besoin de voir cela encore plus que les autres nations.
The Polish were not always kind to the Jews, the Jewish rent collectors for the nobles were not always kind to peasants. The Silesian Germans weren't all Nazis. Some Jews weren't always kind to the Germans, buying up businesses with money from Jews outside of Germany during the Post WWI inflation. Slava Ukraine and Stepan Bandera weren't nice to Poles in Galicia1943-44. Velodrome d' Hiver 1942. Tal al-Zaatar, Sabra and Shatila.@@MargaritaMagdalena
I have watched several documentaries on this subject recently, and have been watching the events in Israel from various main stream media and citizen journalists points of view, but the question in my mind that keeps bothering me is how can a people who were persecuted by the Nazis not recognize the many atrocities and cruel treatment of the Palestinians resembles what some of them experienced. Hearing about the man and his baby being thrown in the oven was especially shockingly similar. The Palestinians have suffered for far too long.
As with the Hamas Iran ISIS propaganda, lies, being 'sold' today to a gullible press, so this video is cunningly constructed. You have here the carefully constructed Palestinian version of the story.
Too long 😢
I can’t stop crying
I've also asked myself that question. It's no wonder they are so unpopular around the world. No-one wanted to take them in before and during WWII, is it little wonder? It seems that they didn't learn a thing from the holocaust... except how to lie, cheat & steal. My heart breaks for the Palestinians. The jews were given more than a very fair deal with land, but they have just been greedy for more ever since, because they have still been forcing Palestinians off their land and out of their homes, so that they are forced to watch Jewish families moving into their homes, from tents! Is it any wonder Hamas has grown? I'd do the same if another people wanted to steal my homeland!
Never heard of that. Horrible
These Jews and Arabs hate story going all the way back to the 7th century in the Arabian peninsula in the city of Yathrib (today Medina). I'm not arab nor jew but i know the story. The residents of Yathrib were mostly jews and christian farmers. Mohammad the prophet of islam escapes from Mecca his birth place to Medina to seek refuge from angry Meccans who didn't except him as a prophet. Mohammad stays in Medina for 13 years and tries convert jews and christians to islam.
Medina's residents didn't like that and they kicked him out of Medina. To make the story short, he comes back with his army for revenge and Medinans were all farmers couldn't defend themselves or couldn't fight and he persecuted 800 jews in one day and the same day he changes the city's name to Medina. 3 of Mohammad's wives were jew war captives from this battle, battle of Khyber. Their problem is not about lands it's about religion. The Dome of the Rock and Al Akhsa mosque in Israel are another problem that muslims say "our prophet traveled here in his dream so we own them", and jews say "we don't care about your prophet's dreams, these are our forefathers Solomon and David's temple and we own them".
“It was not war of the soldiers , it was war of the people of children”
💔
Unfortunately, to this day, the atrocities have yet to stop
They sound proud of their crimes! Not even a word of regression. What a shame! I feel like im watching hell dwellers
What you are hearing here is quotes from Jewish people presented as a mix of careful editing and outright deception, lies. Today you can see and hear Hamas doing exactly the same to manipulate International media.
💯 correct
Heartless souless demons, no compassion, hard to believe but true! Psychopathic narcitistic devils
The Bible gave them a "green light," hahahaha.
The irony of becoming what you once hated is real
Israel is a wonderful dream. Well, isn't it?
Was Oppressed before and now become oppressor
@@vbforgeIt should never have existed.
karma is a bitch@@vbforge
@@eviken1982 then the question comes is what to do with all of the refugees of the holocaust for it was the trigger for the flood of Jews into Palestine. And if you are wonder I too now am starting to come around to the idea that the creation of Israel is a historic wrong and must be corrected. That is the only way now to end this conflict. Way too much blood has been shed to go back to the fanciful idea of the two state solution. And for the one state solution...neither side will like it at all and the hate is too much for them to live together. Also add in religion.
As an American trying to undo the ignorance that has been foisted upon me by my country, I am very grateful for this equally illuminating and sobering documentary. Even better that it's free. Thank you, to whoever is responsible for that.
🖤✊🏼🇵🇸
You might want to look up the history of this conflict before you choose a side to support. Its obvious you dont know this fight has been going on for over 3000 yrs, since before the Roman Empire conqured those lands, when those lands were known as the Kingdom of Israel(also referred to as Judea). Look it up instead of trying to blame America for your ignorance, you sound like a college kid
@@easbreid9879 So if that land belonged to the Jewish people since 3000 years ago, what were all those Palestinian people doing there when the UN used its colonizing authority to fabricate a nation out of thin air and build it on top of an already-populated area? Get your head out of your ass. This is Manifest Destiny horseshit all over again. "God said it was ours, and then Britain said it was ours, and now the UN...oh wait, even the UN who began this shit when Britain handed over control to them, even the UN is now condemning Israel's behavior. Grow up.
@@easbreid9879 This answer is illogical and makes you look bad. They deny the existence of the Palestinians 100 years ago, and cite the existence of the Jews 3,000 years ago. Whoever said that the Jews who were in that place did not become Muslims or Christians after that, you are ignoring all the events that occurred over 3,000 years of the emergence of religions, the establishment of empires, and the demise of empires. Wars and agreements, and you say that the land of the Jews has existed for 3,000 years as if it were yesterday. There is a state called Palestine that was under Ottoman rule in which there were Jews, Muslims, and Christians. Then they gained independence from it after the First World War and became under the rule of the British Mandate, which was keen, since 1922, to encourage the Jews. In Europe and the world to immigrate to Palestine and grant them the Balfour Declaration to establish a state for the Jews in Palestine, and the United Kingdom is the one that encouraged them to choose Palestine to protect its interests. There was more than one option to establish their state. The British Mandate provided them with many facilities, aid, training and weapons until they reached the year 1946. Britain handed over Palestine to the Jews so that they could do what they could to displace the population from their villages, including massacres. There were many details after that, until 1967 borders were set for the two states, but of course Israel was not satisfied... …..
@@easbreid9879 Shame one you! No such a thing as Israel. How can a fake torah be an authority for anything? Those land were inhabited by the Canaanites people much before these fake people so called Israelis popped up in History.
@@easbreid9879how is peace so difficult to understand? What has happened for 3000 years and still to this day is absolutely ludicrous‼️
Love one another and stop the warmongering that has always been a rich man’s trick
"Imagine yourself, if you are living in your home, suddenly you find yourself only with a shirt, nothing more. Your past is denied"
Happening again 2023.
Eye opening. An excellent documentary rich in original sources. Being able to directly hear from the perpetrators is particularly chilling, given the current context.
Only if you are fan of Adolf Hitler and admire falsification of history.
The title should be “The Nakba, how to go from being ethnically cleansed to becoming the ethnically cleanser.”
Have you ever heard of the Ottoman genocide of Armenians, Assyrians, and Christians conducted by Sunni Muslims? Do you understand what happened in the Nazi holocaust. Noting like that happened to Palestinians.
I thought you were suggesting Palestinians are doing the ethnic cleansing for a second
@@chrisperez3614 I’m suggesting that some survivors of the ethnic cleansing during the holocaust then go to historic Palestine and commit ethnic cleansing themselves. If I’m not mistaken they don’t even say the word “Nakba” in the whole damn thing which kind of rubbed me the wrong way
@@stephenkeddy6849You do hear it in spoken Arabic. I don’t remember the time but I know I heard one of the interviewees say it. The translation has something else though.
@@marshallsweatherhiking1820 yes, (Catastrophe)
The current Israel/Palestine conflict brought me here because the mainstream media fails (once again) to do their job properly. Thank you 🙏
Indeed, on every topic. Denial and falsification.
When I want to know what is happening in the world I go straight to youtube and independent journalism.
1:04:15 I have had to pause this several times to gather myself after each shocking tragedy...but this moment...these 10 seconds...absolutely stunned me, ripped my heart out, gutted me, and left me speechless. That sweet, tiny little voice telling the story about how she sent these poor people to their life long prison...where "they are in Gaza until today"...This honestly made me so nauseous.
She struck me as happily soul-less from the get go, and she stayed that way to "the bitter end "; and we need to come to terms with the fact that many Jews, whether Zionist, or not still think and/or act that way, and I've found that some of the "progressive" Jews still live in that house of cards.
1:08:15 the way this man smiles as he talks about murdering someone is so cold and nonchalant its eerie 🤦🏽♂️
"He didn't blame himself, he didn't have any feeling of remorse". It was "a very strange experience" nevertheless.
I felt frightened by his smile and can not understand how a human can become so evil and cold,
@@mariyambhayat4528 Lack of empathy towards anyone outside own ethnic group. Common among Ashkenazi Jews, whether inborn or due to long history of being ostracized idk.
Shameless warcriminals.
An entire apartheid colony built on the blood of the indigenous people of Palestine, declaring themselves the only democratic place in the Middle East.
That’s propaganda for you. It’s edited that way.
This and Tantura are the 2 best documentaries about the history of Israel and Palestine. Its really important that people understand the true history.
Do you know where I can locate Tantura? Preferably without a pay wall.
@@gonzalogonzalez4220 its on youtube
@@gonzalogonzalez4220
czcams.com/video/novoSE1rwg4/video.html
But then out of fairness, you should also watch documentaries about the 1929 Hebron massacre and many other committed by Arabs of Palestine on Jews (as well as Muslim massacres of Jews outside of Palestine). This was not a one way street at all. Jews came to Palestine, Arabs there didn't like it and tried and sometimes succeeded to murder them. I can understand why they wouldn't like a flow of immigrants coming near where they lived. But would you want to murder them all? They called other Arab states to help them do exactly that.. and they failed!! And now they claim to be victims. Yes there were horrible crimes on both sides but if Jews hadn't stopped the Arabs they would have been slaughtered. Second, it was not really Palestinian land. They were a majority in Arabs in parts of it but it was under the Ottoman empire then the British mandate. The UN tried to solve the problem by voting a partition of Palestine which Palestinian Arabs refused to accept. 76 years later, they still want to claim that land that they never had to begin with. Those who really owned land and had to leave should get financial compensation. They can't get their land back because someone lives there. You can't fix an injustice by committing another injustice. But they should get money and memorials and a chance to tell their stories. But they can't go back in time like they say they want
@@NicoleBL2now say it without crying 🤣
And after fifteen years studying this conflict you guys come up with such a fresh unseen , untold documentary to blow my Irish socks off.
My writing arm is cramped after taking down twenty pages of notes from this sublime work. I have saved it and I will recommend it in each and every post I make online.
Ilan Pappe is along with Noam Chomsky and Norman Finkelstein a giants on this topic. At such an important juncture in the conflict when Israeli tanks and troops are ammassed on the outskirts of Gaza ready to destroy what little is left there, works like this are invaluable in telling the world of the true nature and true cause of this seventy five year old conflict. Notice that I refrain from calling it a war.
LMAO!
You just made our day. Thank you so much for your kind words. We're so glad you got so much out of this documentary.
Anyone who believes Chomsky is an authority on anything but linguistics is a fool. Chomsky is a fraud!
If you believe this pod account of the 1948 events you'll believe anything !
Try looking at news from the time & reading more widely?
You might start with the offer Ben Gurion made during the inauguration ceremony for the State of Israel.
This is fresh? It is the same old tiresome and inaccurate propaganda. Please find a better source or balance it with other accounts of these incomplete and distorted stories presented here.
One of the best documentaries i have seen about the actual facts...Thank you.
Thank you for making this free during this terrible time for palestinians, it is important to spread the true historical context to combat all of the disinformation.
True but its not spread its hidden. Onkly those who look find it. And thats if u no about it to even start looking. Those who are just scrolling will never see. And most will never open there minds to the truth. Alot just want to be led.
@@user-yg9gb1xk2snice to know that when people talk about how much they love pancakes, you randomly ask if they hate waffles.
Everyone in Israel has a terrible time. Jews, Arabs, everyone.
Look at the people who control the US Congress the media and much the entertainment industry
This documentary was needed,
at such a time were the media spreads lies from one side and not presents the Palestinians side,
also to present interviews of people who "lived" what happened in 1948 from both sides.
I hope this spreads and is pushed through the algorithms.
Getting the truth of this conflict has been extremely difficult to do because of the stranglehold the wealthy American Jews have on American newspapers, magazines, TV shows and the movies. There have been hundreds of movies made in Hollywood about the Holocaust, but not a single word about the Palestinian Holocaust which they named Al Nakba.
With such one sided reporting and TV coverage is it any wonder most Americans are only now learning about the details of this seventy five year old conflict. I don't call it a war because for a war to happen you need both combatants to have weapons. In this situation one side has an arsenal of nuclear warheads plus billions of dollars worth of state of the art military armour, tanks, mobile howitzers, anti tank anti aircraft emplacements, rockets missiles, troop carrying vehicles, jeeps, heavy armoured vehicles, and intelligence sharing with all the most powerful nations in the west. Then on the Palestinian side you have a ragtag mob of schoolboys throwing rocks and old car tires. Some "war"
Must Share
You believe this pod account of the 1948 events ?You'll believe anything !
Try looking at news from the time & reading more widely?
You might start with the offer Ben Gurion made during the inauguration ceremony for the State of Israel.
Please share and educate people. The corporate media does it best to deceive everyone on this topic.
Links are deleted by the tube's bot, but try look for the genocide laboratory under more at peace is better than war....
This is a revelation. How horrible. This has been kept so well hidden. Thank you for this important informative documentary.
It's very one sided. It wants to present one point of view, and it does. I worked that out in the first 5 mins as it omits some very important facts.
Ignore the Israeli IDF hasbara trolls. They get paid to spread pro-Israel misinformation.
One-sided, huh?
Half of the speakers in the documentary are Israeli, and some of them recount real events. The documentary presents facts, which scare the Zionists the most.
I agree the truth will be hidden because the truth can set one hundreds thousands even millions free
@@neoepicurean3772do you ever ask yourself why we're we ever showed this side in our mainstream media?! we know everything about the Israeli side at least now we can hear what the palastenians have been saying and screaming for so long
My heart aches the more I learn. I’ve always had knowledge of the apartheid and constant murders of the Palestinian people, but the deeper I go into the details of all events since the start of this occupation, the worse it gets. Someone, something, God, help free Palestine from this terrorism they’ve been living under for 75 years.
4000 years, all manners of people, civilizations, and cultures without any postal service, internets, telephones, etc. were antisemitic for no reason at all.
That's their story.
At the same time, the jooz are claiming these exact atrocities are being committed against them... they cry-out in pain as they strike you.
Everyone says that they feel sympathy for the Palestinians and yet no Arab nation is willing to help them.
@@grantsmythe8625Arabs did fought for them but lost, not just arabs any people who has a conscience and ethics should always stand for them
@@grantsmythe8625 5 million Palestinians are living in present day Jordon ... including Jordanian Queen rania whose family fled during 1948. 5 lakhs live in Egypt. 1 million lives in Lebanon.... Some 7 lakhs live in European countries....so shut up....
You have built your country over the families blood....
The suffering of the Palestinians children never ends . 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 injustices forever
Amazing thank you so much for giving us such a powerful beautiful documentary I bet it took much effort and time.
Thanks you so much for this documentary. Whenever I'm tired of arguing, frustrated and sad to feel misunderstood (in behalf of the palestinian people) or just short on words, I recommend this movie. I hope many many people will watch it and get to the core of the conflict.
Yes, thank you, me too. The world needs to see this. It is amazing how history keeps repeating itself without the peaceful leadership we desperately need. May the rest of the century be dedicated to loving and respecting all people of this world. Stay well.
‘The core’? What about the pogroms of Bnei Yehuda, Tel Hai, Metula (1920); Kfar Saba, Kfar Malal (1921); Kfar Uria, Ruhama, Hartuv, Hulda, Motza, Poria (1929); and Beit She’an (1936)? I aren’t they causal also?
@@freedahlogic8368 well did you ever see those massacres in any context ??? Obviously not. Do you know what the leading Zionists of this time did ? Do you know about their terroristic actions against the British mandate and against the Arabs ? Why do you think it was suddenly not peaceful anymore ? Jews and Arabs lived very peacefully before Zionists decided to take more and more land. I know it’s complicated because Jews werde harshly discriminated at that time esspecially in EUROPE, but that was not the Palestinians fault who lived there !! It was not a land “without people”. Have you watched the documentary at all ?
This is toxic one sided propaganda
@@thehenchman. Interviewing both sides is propaganda? It's propaganda because they didn't lick israel's shoes enough as the Hollywood and MSM does all the time.
I had been researching christian nationalism which lead me into learning about zionism. Then the war broke out. I am so glad that this documentary was made. It is very well done, unbiased and extremely informative. Thank you so much. I am shocked at how the people who lived through the Holocaust could treat people the way they were treated. I am ashamed to have ever called those people...God's people. They are not.
I have been ruminating on this for the past couple of weeks. I hate to be thinking this because it goes against everything we have been taught from as far back as I can remember...but at some point, I feel like the question has to be asked why the Nazis and the Russians were both persecuting the Jews at the same time? Why European countries were so reluctant to take in Jewish refugees, and why the Nazis felt so strongly about one group that they would go so far as the holocaust. We have always been forbidden from even thinking it but the past 2 weeks has completely broken my mind on this subject and I am now wondering if they have always treated people like this, if they have always had this idea that they are the chosen people and entitled to what does not belong to them.
It is hard to square the gentle intelligent people that they were portrayed to be with the horrific bloodthirsty supremacists who are spewing vileness and hate and attacking anyone who dares say that killing children is wrong. ANY PEOPLE who do not believe killing children is wrong are an evil people. I know that there are large groups of Jewish people in America who do embody the intelligence and gentle nature that we were told was a trait of the faith, but by their own admission they are the minority and they are berated and belittled by the majority of Jews. My entire world view has been upended.
What about the Bible ? Read what about Abraham ....promise from the most High God. Be enlighten+
This is such a foolish presumption! You REALLY think that the European Jewry provoked their own extermination?!? Are in your right mind? Have you heard the phrase, "To place the cart before the horse"? How twisted is your thinking? Israel provoked Gaza by having given them full control in 2005? How foolish...
I suppose you’re people are perfect, never did anything wrong and when you fart it smells of roses?
Lol, Christian nationalism. The thing progressives started talking about two years ago or so. Disregard the fact that it's an extremely tiny, fringe ideology.
It's heartbreaking to listen to this.
Because of the events of October 7, I think a lot of people like myself decided to start learning about the history of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict. This is about the tenth full-scale documentary I’ve watched, from different sources, because I didn’t want just one point of view. I’ve also read a multitude of news articles from past to present. I wonder how many people, also like me, have been shocked to discover the atrocities committed by the Zionists, how they forcibly removed Arabs from their homes not because they were a threat or were there illegally, but because they wanted Jews living there, how the Hamas of today had its Jewish equivalent in the Irgun of yesteryear. The Palestinian people have been criticized for not rooting out and dealing with the extremists who oppose compromise and will seek to sabotage any effort at peace, but how have the Israelis dealt with their own? 1:07:52 - Despicable piece of humanity to have no remorse for killing the former villager and even chuckling about the “poor fellow’s” fate.
I envy your ability to focus. You've watched 10 full length documentaries. Hats off. I have the attention span of a stir-fried shrimp. 😅
It is possible that you have only read one side of the story.
@@Madmen604Like the film “Tantura” this film includes many Israeli soldiers talking, so it could never be one sided.
"Despicable piece of humanity"? How then would you describe Hamas?
Did you consider whether the Hamas of today could have been the Arab League or Arab Liberation Organization of the 1940's? These latter groups led and mobilized the early Palestinian attacks against Jews entering the country. Jews escaping pogroms, ghettos and real genocide. The Palestinian people never experienced anything of that magnitude, not in their 900 years of occupation by Arab and Turkish empires.
@@ksw7974 It would be possible to do a geo therm scan of the alleged mass grave. I guess there were no birth or death records or photos of the place.
The descriptions are eerily similar to descriptions of Nazi mass killings. Which makes me suspicious right away. Are we talking about holocaust survivors attacking Tantura? Survivors with traumatic memory and flashbacks , even dissociation? Did survivors restage scenes of the horror they witnessed?
Thank you so much for taking the time to give voice to those who have been silenced for too long … 🇵🇸🇵🇸
What the Palestinians are enduring is heartbreaking. FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Why isn’t this brought out in schools???
Interesting isn't it that History is no longer taught in schools as a important, separate subject but amalgamated into a stew called social studies.
I believe it is but at University level for those taking a History Degree.@@paperclip612
Because the Zionists don't want it taught in schools
I am from Greece, thank you for the very good video Dokumentari ,I am for Palestine always.
Being for or against is what got us into this mess.
Thank you for taking the right side of humanity 🇵🇸
My greatest sadness is that I will never get to see an end to this conflict and senseless violence. If only these two people could see each other for who they really are. Fellow human beings, brothers and sisters exalting in the fragile miracle of our short lives on Mother Earth.
Very wise words.
It’s not the people. People and religions lived together. It’s the greed and power of politics.
Yessir🙏🙏❤️☮️
You are so correct.
And can you see the supreme specious as they are? creatures that think they have the right to do whatever because they was once a victim, a creature that their war heroes are the ones who killed and raped the most during the ethnic cleansing and they named the street by there names, creatures who act all high and believe that while enjoying their time by making fun of their victims and increasing the victims, it is a disgrace to humanity if such a people was called humans.
Thank you for your hard effort in making this documentary. People like you are heros of humanity who spread the truth and make it accessible for public in simple, easy to understand manner. Indeed it is a rich source of well documented information and facts. The interviews you did are considered part of documenting oral history. Thank you.
I first saw this documentary at the Chinese cultural center in Oakland, CA a few years back and it is EXCELLENT! The Palestinians offered assistance to the returning persecuted Jews and the Jews responded, "we don't want your assistance, we want your land!" How are you a persecuted people and then turn around and persecute others? Where is the response from the British? Their Balfour Declaration of 1917 created this horrific inhumane atrocity against the Palestinians still existing in 2023 and beyond...
The Jews BOUGHT land.
Former Israel in the Levant region was part of the Muslim world for about 700 years. The whole region was recreated and divided after WW2. The Jews fled to their spiritual homeland from the aftermath of horrendous genocide in the whole of Europe. Imagine if this had happened to Muslims expelled from Mecca ! You would certainly want to reclam your homeland and you would be right.
My question for the past few years is HOW would the Jews behave, in Europe and elsewhere, were they NOT historically persecuted?
@@calicocat8213 They would not have been expelled from Israel by Romans in the first century AD,
in the first place, had there not been persecution.
There would not have been a war in 1948 had there not been an Arab vow to destroy Israel.
There would be a free Palestinian country now if the Arab leagues had recognized Israel in 1948 and got on with post war reconstruction.
There is no memory of global history these days among western millenials . My Canadian parents and my city viscerally experienced WW2. I experienced it vicariously through them. Jewish families have visceral experience of the holocaust in ways Arab Palestinians can't fathom. Every Jewish friend of mine has a personal holocaust story. Every Jewish millennial has a personal holocaust story and missing people in their genealogy.
Don't make false equivalencies between the Jewish genocide and Palestinian displacement.
@@Madmen604 They were expelled over and over again through not just centuries, but nearly 2 millennia. From wherever they were. WHAT was it that made them so unbearable to their hosts, one wonders.
Really, i could only see half way through this video. It was heartbreaking. Our home is so special. So dear. However humble it may be..and to have it taken forcibly. Omg. I have no words...im grief-stricken
❤🇵🇸
Long Live Palestine 🇵🇸
God is the Best Planner.
@@R.IAmEnough Apart from not having the foresight to see what would eventuate once putting his (his?) plan in motion. But seriously, something that doesn't exist can't plan anything, leave alone foreseeing the horrors to come as a result. Of course when people continue to put their faith into illusions told and written by ancient to medieval through to today's storytellers, there's little or no hope ever to see a non violent world.
Watching this is painful. To see the current Israelis using the very same tactics their parents used. The fliers from planes telling them to evacuate. The killing of babies, the forced displacement, the talking about “go to Arab states”, the massacre of entire villages and neighbourhoods, the callousness of it all. Argh! La haula wa la quwwata illa billaah.
Yes i noted that too Same tactics....
I mean, it’s only painful if you somehow seem to forget about October 7 and how this war started.. Maybe we wouldn’t have to use the same tactics as our parents did if there weren’t so many terrorists. No October 7, none of this would be happening. None of it . zero zilch.
just like nazis did to them. it's incredible.
Worse than nazis did to them
The irony, not even 3 years after living through the worst crimes of humanity, the oppressed becomes the oppressor. This is EXACTLY how an abused becomes an abuser. Everything is cyclical, but the irony is...well, ironic. 😔 Researching the holocaust and the Hamas attacks brought me here today, but Thank You so much 🙏🏼for this VERY important perspective! 😇
You should have traveled a little bit further...
Meanwhile, the REAL history of the Israeli-Hajji terrorist conflict. Explained in one third the time - even though they took time to tell ALL the history. Including the parts these Mocumentary makers decided viewers didn't need to know in their version. czcams.com/video/dEoVzKyD_IM/video.html
Pathos and victimology gets you far more monetizing clicks in the Woke world than just sticking to the facts.
Dude, same deal with the black people that returned from the USA to Africa to create their country, Liberia. Look at their flag. Well, they went back to Africa knowing how to read and write, math, weapons and were well funded by American organizations attempting to try this course to remediate slavery. And what did they do? They enslaved the people they found over there. The former slaves, returnees, became land owners by force AND had mansions built for them that resembled.... Southern plantation mansions.
So what did your research on the holocaust and Hamas tell you?
They WERE the nazis. Their zionist rabbis worked WITH the nazis to persecute their own people in order to drive them to Palestine.
@@skiboltskieskye1238 you know nothing in history except the holocaust and Oct.7, but never bother to know why they happened.
This is great, one of the best I have watched. I like the fact it was narrated by people who were present on both sides who were very candid. I know its emphasising the Palestinian side, but for that its an amazing document as very soon now, there will be no first hand accounts left to tell as the people involved pass away.
Meanwhile, the REAL history of the Israeli-Hajji terrorist conflict. Explained in one third the time - even though they took time to tell ALL the history. Including the parts these Mocumentary makers decided viewers didn't need to know in their version. czcams.com/video/dEoVzKyD_IM/video.html
Pathos and victimology gets you far more monetizing clicks in the Woke world than just sticking to the facts.
Good honest post sir. I thought the documentary did an excellent job of highlighting the truth about how the Zionist militia actively planned the cleansing of the indigenous Palestinians. You mentioned it was pro Palestinian, if you looked at it from the Zionist perspective, you would see the same events and the same attrocities come to light "but only if they spoke the truth on the matter " Whether you wish to look at it sideways, longwayes, or upside down, the end result is that a European power, England, aided and abetted the Zionist jews to invade and occupy another people's land by means of war.
Excellent Doc
I don't believe it is emphasizing the Palestinians it is emphasizing the oppressed and that just ha0ppens to be the Palestinians
It’s sad to see you are afraid to show any sympathy for the Palestinians. I find it disturbing. Realize those who are charge want all of us divided and not come together as one. Don’t be afraid to speak the TRUTH.
Excellent yet so heartbreaking!!
In Israel it is forbidden to talk about the Nakba. You can't teach that part of history at school. Imagine if it was forbidden to teach the history of the Holocaust?
To compare Palestinian land displacements to the Jewish holocaust is false equivalency. It is an error in logical thinking. Probably deliberate because you must know these events are not remotely the same, unless you are maybe not well educated or hiding under a rock. If you really desire peace , you will at least educate yourselves about the Jewish history of the Holocaust and Zionism. The displacement was first of all following an attack and war started by Palestinian /Arab forces against Israel.
And you don't have the moral high ground. Muslim countries have displaced and expelled ethnic groups for centuries and committed mass genocide. It's happening now in Sudan, Turkey. It's ongoing in Syria. Wherever there are jihadists, there is brutal conflict. What they did in Israel, they are doing in Darfur, they have done against ethnic minorities in Turkey and Iraq. They attack Kurdish and Christians . They fight Sunni against Shi'a Muslims, their own people.
If you would stop fighting and take your issues to the public and to the UN, you might get somewhere.
Nakba in and of itself is a propagandistic term. It does not simply discuss the events of 1948 but it already includes a distinct narrative and judgement. It is not suitable for use in school because it forces upon students students a certain way to evaluate what happened - they are not free to develop their own opinion. This does certainly NOT mean that the events of that time are generally not discussed. It's only this specific predetermined propagandistic narrative that is ruled out in schools. The term _Nakba_ represents an attempt to create a "counterweight" to the _Shoah,_ insinuating that both are equally bad. It's a simple method for the demonization of Israel and therefore antisemitic. The Holocaust was the single incomparably most horrible event in human history. That doesn't mean every other injustice was not that bad. But its abuse for stirring antisemitic hate while literally asking for a second Shoah and the extermination of all Jews is unacceptable. There were de facto no death camps where six million so-called Palestinians were gassed.
Also, the claim that it's prohibited to speak about the subject in Israel is a blatant lie. But hey, why would anyone question your narrative if it confirms what they would like to be true?
Besides it's very interesting how as always Israel is portrayed as a demonic country of censorship and indoctrination while at the same time there's not a single word about the absolutely horrible, terrifying things that are taught in Palestinian schools. The brutal, murderous ideology permanently forced upon young kids, even in official UN schools. Not a word about the nonexistent freedom of speech in Gaza & Co., where anyone who sided with Israel would simply be slaughtered in broad daylight. No, we don't talk about that, we don't talk about the fascistoid Jihadi ideology they implant until every child. We don't talk about not one Jew living in Gaza because they would be dead before sunset, just because of their religion. But instead we complain about the prohibition of an antisemitic propaganda narrative in schools in a country where Arab kids get a world class education and are represented in a democratic parliament. Amidst all this, the one problem we mention is that one topic in public schools.
Hypocrisy is one of the main characteristics of antisemitism. I acknowledge that not a single person here cares about being called out because they live in their solidified fantasy world where the roles of good and evil are already irrevocably set. Just do me one favor and recognize that I will not read your answers, so don't get (even more) mad if I don't reply.
You can talk about anything you want. Traveling Israel does a whole video on it.
@danocatster That's where most people get their geopolitical education these days, travel videos.
@@Madmen604 He has a graduate degree in history. czcams.com/video/P8bkqqvoGpc/video.htmlsi=7Ffm7uUrq5HBXdcM
Exceedingly heartbreaking 💔!
Every American citizen must see this!
no they bury heads in sand....like OSTRICH
Deir yassin, tantura, lod, sabra and shatella,...all of these massacres are horrible
There is a tragic irony that the Jewish people, so historically victimized themselves, should in the creation of Israel in their turn inflict a new injustice upon the Palestinian people. Father Abraham had the wisdom to share the land peacefully.
They victimized themselves, huh? Like in Nazi Germany?
Ever heard of REAL history?
People are way too addicted to propaganda today.
@@RM3MB3Rhaavara agreement says hi
Because maybe they are as flawed as any other group and maybe they haven't always treated others fairly either.
Look at what we are taught in the Torah, Joshua led a groups of elite killers into Canaan to murder all the farmers and bee keepers not sparing the women and children, claiming God had told them to do it. This was done before the ordinary Jews could follow into. A land without people, for a people without a land. This is taught to children.
The jewish "people" have never been victimized! Historically, all they have done is victimize others!
I don't understand How people think they can do atrocities and think that it will Not come back to you??? The bible says "Do not be deceived, you WILL reap what you sow!"
I love how every religion preaches this but still majority people don't want to learn from their mistakes.
The Bible says, the Bible says, what about common sense? What About Love Thy Neighbor? Do we really need a religion to have a moral compass religion is actually behind all of this if there wasn't religion these people wouldn't hate each other
Forget about what the Bible says of course they know it's going to come back to them they want it to come back to them if the atrocity is good enough it'll get you into Paradise with some virgins at that. And that's pretty sick preying on people's perversions to get them to blow themselves up how ridiculous. No I'm not trivializing the conflict but what I am calling out is why they murder or martyr themselves, same thing and what do women Martyrs get? Do they get virgins too? That's a serious question. And my next question would be are they men or women and if it's women that doesn't make sense and if it's men it doesn't make sense they've had their clitorises taken off of their body at 13 years old with a piece of broken glass by some old man with dirty hands that can't see while the girl is held down by her parents and mutilated now she has no feeling in her genitalia so why would she want virgins what's in it for the female suicide bombers? Maybe a new Burka. What a prize that would be. Now when you think about it doesn't it seem more logical that religion was formulated to control people to get them to do what you want them to do and get them to not do what you don't want them to do like well all kinds of crazy shit
@@shree203 I love how everybody gets fixated on religions and never does an equal amount of pontificating regarding what the Religion Of Atheism might have to do with its star pupils Stalin, Lenin, Mao, Hitler, Pol Pot, etc and the 100 MILLION dead CIVILIANS they and their armies slaughtered in the last century.
@@robertblake3385 Yeah, that must be it, Muslims in Hamas, Hezbollah, Fatah, the PLO, Iran's Mad Mullahs are calling for the extirpation of Jews from the face of the earth because of the two different Abrahamic religions.
Of course, they're also slaughtering their fellow Muslims i.e. the Muslim Houthi terrorists carrying out terrorist attacks on almost 100% Muslim Saudi Arabia. Muslim terrorists carrying out a string of slaughters in Mumbai India - where there's a fair number of Muslims but very few Jews.
Oooohhhh!!! And let's not forget the 9/11 terrorist attack on America (and the ones in the prior years by the same Hajji terrorists)!
Somebody needs to tell these Hajjis that very few Americans are Jews. And that America is increasingly secular, with very few people worshiping.
Once they know America isn't another religious nation, then these Hajji Muslim terrorists won't hate America anymore! And there'll be no more terrorist violence directed at America
It's all so simple now! Why didn't I think of that!
wow, it's one of best documentary film I've ever seen ! I learnt a lot from. I'm sad and angry that it's treating today. 😢 thank you very much for sharing this great film. free 🇵🇸
Incredible eye opening video!
Thank you for this outstanding documentary.
The regret in face of the vetrans of Israel for what they were ordered to do it powerful.
The individual survival accounts are unimaginably brutal.
Fondamentaly wrong.
I see NO regret,only indifference.
1m35seconds .. " it's such a grave injustice " ....
That sums it up ... fantastic documentary. Justice for Palestine 🇵🇸
A lot of thanks for this poignant and honest documentary
1:18:51 this part💔a group of people willingly chose to close the eyes, just so that their goal can come true with the price of Palestinians. It's truly a shame and an even bigger shame, with the people who had gone through it, giving the same experience to others.
Hard to imagine people believe the lies to cover this up and Gaza now is a repeat of this awfulness.
Thank you for this presentation. The sad truth is much sadder than I realized.
We become like our enemies.
We either become bitter, or better.
What a fantastic well-made documentary. Many from the 1948 generation are still alive who can still account in great detail what occurred in the invasion of Palestine and subsequent expulsion of Arabs from the region in 1948 and 1949. The invasion of Palestine is one of the most recent examples of settler colonization. Can anyone in the world imagine what the indigenous of the Americas, Australia, Asia and others endured at the hands of colonizing Europeans when the camera didn't exist to record the atrocities committed? It must have been horrendous. The most repugnant evil human behavior ever. The indigenous wouldn't have the words to describe the evils done to them. We are a species the gods would never miss when our demise came.
Many alive can also remember the Arab pogroms, killings, and expulsion of Jews that happened at the exact same time as 1948. And, after the Balfour Declaration in 1917, between then and 1948 those Arab pogroms, killings and expulsions.
Oh, you didn't know about that part of the story? Maybe because it was just barely touched on in this one sided documentary? Or maybe none of those events happened, committed by Arabs against Jews not just in what is now Israel, but also in the surrounding Arab countries?
But yes, the pure indigenous tribes of the Americas, prior to the arrival of The Evil Europeans!
Let's see, wars of conquest to take the lands of other tribes, genocide of other tribes, raiding other tribes for slaves for both drudge work and sex... anything else??? Oh yeah! In some tribes, human sacrifice and cannibalism!
Then them damned Europeans showed up to teach those pure indigenous tribes evils like wars of conquest, etc!
History is so much clearer now that it's explained like that!
you're a babbling brook of emptiness. Nothing you say measures up to history taught by academia. The Jews have a history of disobedience and impatience with God. He used the Romans to send them into exile until they acquired some manners. This was done by decree. Only God can end the Jewish exile, not any man alive can. As long as the Zionist try to hold onto Palestine wars will be a constant reminder they broke God's covenant. The Jewish people have to live among the nations including Palestine until God says the exile is over. @@AirborneMOC031
Most of those who suffered as a result of the formation of Israel have moved on. The descendants should find some peaceful way to reconcile. All this fighting against one another will only continue to cause sufferings to themselves. Nobody gains through all the violence. We only destroy each other in the end.
Middle Eastern people have long memories. They hold onto the past instead of allowing for man's flawed ways, so the blood feuds get passed down through the generations.
The Lavant wasn't Arabaic. It wasn't Ottoman. It wasn't Muslim. It was Christian and Byzantine. Remember that.
A moral dilemma perhaps - but Europe and my homeland are ultimately the perpetrators.
I am very shocked that these same Israeli soldiers are talking about the horror of what they did. But I feel that they have an ounce of remorse, otherwise they would not have had the courage to admit the filth of what they did in front of the whole world.
i thought this video was unbiased compared to the 100s I have been watching lately, there was a well balanced mix of jewish and arabs sharing their stories.
That is exactly what this video wants you to think. You have here the carefully constructed Palestinian version of the story.
@@gordonfrickers5592oh be quiet and stop whining
@@gordonfrickers5592There are too many like this with film evidence that can't be refuted!
@@gordonfrickers5592 bro its not the only news outlet i watch, i watch multi from all different angles, just as the zionist media tells you there story, im not an idiot, i dont have national loyalties to either party
Based on zionists ideology, people with copper skintone own the entire planet .
Mind blowing
It’s the he hard relentless work of such people that history and facts are not forgotten
Nor the right of people which were invaded to return home 🗝️
Please keep on sharing this important documentary.
Tantoura documentary is recommended. Please watch it and widely share.
It is time for humans to embrace humanity ..that is something that all religions could embrace without judgements attached
Hearing some of the Zionists recall with a tone of righteousness is disgusting! It's terribly sad to say but I don't believe these people had souls!!
Well! That certainly justifies the declared intent of Hamas, Hezbollah, Fatah, the PLO, Iran's Mad Mullahs to exterminate every single Jew and the butchery they carried out two weeks ago!
Also helps to feel that way towards those Israelis and not Arabs on the other side when this documentary carefully omits paying an equal amount of attention to the pogroms, murders, riots, massacres and expulsions carried out by Arabs at the same time. Not only in what is now Israel, but also in the Muslim Arab countries surrounding Israel.
Nor mentioning that the Arab's Grand Mufti Of Jerusalem spent the later half of the 1930's and all of WWII in Berlin with Hitler, repeatedly asking him to get that Final Solution happening in the Jewish territory freed in the aftermath of WWI.
Very important to just concentrate on only what the Zionists did. Theoretically, there was no Hajji type terrorism against Jews until 1948, whether in Israel or in the Muslim Arab countries surrounding Israel.
I believe hamas doesn't have souls either
@ragein😡🤬😈🤮tothelight
@@rageintothelight why?
And they accuse the Palestinians of being terrorist?
They wanted Palestinian to be quiet,stay calm,accept colonialism wholeheartedly..😮🙄
#FreePalestine
#FromTheGreedyThievesZioNazi
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Every colonial project called the natives something: savages (american indians), n-word (africans).
I’m not sure why some people called this “propaganda”. Every event described is verifiable. On top of that, the events are corroborated by both sides.
Because it won't confirm their biases. When they can't argue with any intelligence they scream epithets.
Because this is propaganda, deliberately leaving out several essential things. For example, the fact that there was also emigration of the Arab population. Arabs doubled their population during the Mandate of Palestine, mainly through settlement. There is information that over 50% of the land was given to Jews, but there is no mention that the majority of the land in the south is a desert (open a map and check for yourself). In fact, Arabs received most of the agricultural land...
@@kacperkowalik153 bombing of baghdad 1950 (forced expulsion of iraqi jews by jews), yemini jewish children genocide by israel.
The double of palestinian population in the mandate was because the expulsion from what is known as "israel" to live in the ghetto camps.
@@kacperkowalik153it doesn't matter 🤡. How can u give them over 50% of the land when they were the minority? And they were welcomed to this land when nobody wanted to take them in. Their goal well before 1948 was to expel the people indigenous to the land. And the atrocities committed were far worse than those committed by the nazis. No comparison. The "chosen people" were burning men and children alive. The devil's chosen people.
@@kacperkowalik153 they aren’t interested in such facts. They just want the propaganda to suit their narrative..
Thank you for your time and efforts about Palestinians land occupied by those refugees thinking their own land and killing Palestinians. So sad and heartbreaking. Thanks again.
Why are these Israeli veterans walking free?
An ex israeli soldier participated in 1948 went to gaza 4 months ago, he was singing to the other soldiers a song about killing your arab neighbour, hamas killed him during the invasion.
Thank you for this wonderful eye-opener. I have a Palestinian friend whose family was displaced and his father killed. I didn't know many aspects of the tragedy, I am ashamed to say. You cannot isolate what happened on the 7th of October from the broader story of Israeli brutality and forced occupation of the land. The Palestinians have every right to their homeland, although I think there must be a cutoff date to accommodate for the presence of Israel. Too much time has passed to right all the wrongs in this devastating nightmare.
The Israelis sacrificed security for expansion !
A long enough time does not make a wrong. What was wronged should be righted
Seriously, you believe this pod account of the 1948 events ?
You'll believe anything !
Try looking at news from the time & reading more widely.
You might start with the offer Ben Gurion made to his Arab brothers during the inauguration ceremony for the State of Israel.
An offer that was, still is rejected.
@@stratospheric37 Do you mean Israel should continue to exist? if so you must be kidding.
It's never too late to provide justice.
A terrific piece of work, essential viewing by anybody interested in history and particularly those who seek to learn about the tragedy that surrounds this land.
I am watching the white haired elderly Israeli talk about it all and in some parts he almost sounds sympathetic but then quite blatantly says he shot the Arab point blank who hugged him, but then says no regrets. The mind just boggles.
These are evil satanic baphamet worshippers, they hate God and any goodness in the world!
Cold blooded killers
Isn't that called ethnic cleansing?
Yes. And it's still going on to this day. 10,000 Palestinians in one month. .
I hope the Israelis never know peace until the land and all its resources are returned in full to their rightful owners; the Palestinians.
Agree. They will reap what they've sown.
The worse part is_ still in 2023 civilized western states like Germany, UK, Sweden, France, Switzerland won't recognize this fact that "Nakba Is a Real event", still they won't recognized the sufferings and misery and the wounds Palestinian refugees had to go through, still it is forbidden to commemorate "Nakba" in Germany, UK, France. Holocaust is commemorated with ardent solemnity in those countries and we have no objection to it, but what hurts us most is, the populations of those so-called civilized countries are hardly aware of or believe in "Nakba".
These countries had done far worse in africa, east Asia, india, Australia, north and south america. But they want you to think they are the civilized and you must fear from immigrants and muslims.
How did they "justified " deer yaseen or Haifa massacre? Did they say they were looking for Hamas!!!!!!!!!
"Human shielde" excuse were not very popular that time.
Very educative and important documentary on Israel - Palesine issue. A must watch. Palestinians have been wronged for so long. They deserve justice. They deserve their rights.They deserve their homeland. May Palesine get it's freedom soon 🤲
Very well done. Thank you
Well done! Thank you for this informative honest documentary ! I have been wondering how and why this war has been going on and your documentary answered both questions. It changes my view of Arab and Palestinian people completely. I had no idea what the truth was until I came upon this documentary. Again, thankyou.
Thank you so much for your kind words. They mean a lot.
Thanks for posting such a documentary
Why was such violence from a people who were on the receiving end of the holocaust & the NAZIS? One would think that their experience of being marginalized would bring forth a different approach
It seems to me that the Jewish people were doing to the Arabs what had been done to them in Europe and Russia. I didn't realize how this situation began. Furthermore, both sides should be more angry with Britain for this half solution.
I am in tears ... I've no words to describe .. I've been an anti-Israel and anti-zionist activist all my life, I knew of a lot of this, but this is so well done! To relive, relearn, hear the testimonies, it's just too much! It's devastating! All this was not even for refuges of war etc, it was a pretense, it was all for the British empire. (which still exists and supersedes our Govs) to have a nuclear military base in the ME, close to the oil, and riches, close to Eurasia ... And now, the massacre unfolding, all for gas extraction, pipelines, resorts on the beaches of Gaza, and a canal to rival Suez .. it's really sick! entirely sick!
If Balfour loved them so much, he should have given them a part of Britain and not someone else's homes and farmlands. What kind of justice is that???
Because the Jews have lived in that part of the world for thousands of years since the 2nd millennium ,when Israelites emerged as an outgrowth of southern Canaanites,During biblical times, a United Kingdom of Israel existed but then split into two Israelite kingdoms occupying the highland zone: the Kingdom of Israel (Samaria) in the north, and the Kingdom of Judah in the south.Until it was conquered by the Neo-Assyrian Empire in 722 BC.
@@guvnormcfc66 did you not hear them SAY THEY CAME FROM POLAND AND RUSSIA? these are europeans THEY ARE NOT THE REAL JEWS THEY ARE COLONIZERS too bad Hitler was interrupted
@@guvnormcfc66before 1948 the current state of Israel was mostly Arab not Jewish. It's forced migration paid for by my taxes
Where did I say that there were more Jews than Arabs before 1948,I didn't say that did I??making stuff up,how old are you,you must be nearly a 100 years old if you've been paying taxes since 1948.
@@guvnormcfc66 it's like the whole world started in 1948. That's all they care about. Never mind the Jews being oppressed and occupied by Romans (Rome) two thousand years ago in Israel. Not a religious story but fact. Or about the Jews who fought alongside the Muslims during the invasion of the Christian crusaders into Jerusalem before 1105, and when the Muslims surrendered up to the Christians, the Jews (who didn't surrender) were all burnt alive in the Shul. I am so tired of this narrative about "The Jews" stealing Palestinian land. And all this rhetoric about the 7th of October has nothing to do with the Palestinians or Muslims. It is all antisemitic chatter that is getting louder by the day. None of these people (protestors or otherwise) have said one bleeding word about the Uyghurs who are in actual concentration camps disguised as "re-education camps"
"It was very ugly. After these things, I didn't know if a was a Zionist... "
Very ugly, indeed
People often rely on perception rather than perspective, and this keeps the wars going on and on. You who do this are just as responsible as the wicked leaders who partake in war for sport, power, and cashflow. Nevermind that always the people, all the many people around the world are always the ones sacrificed for the whims of the powerful.
This is very sad hearing how the Palestine suffering 1:06:00 atrocities and cruel for many years from Jews
Before and now
As Nietzsche said: "Be careful when you stare into the abyss, because the abyss stares back at you..."
When you play the victim (to he clear, Israel) long enough, it eats away your soul. Then you believe you have a right to treat others as you were treated.
This is excellent! Educational, very beneficial as I now have a better understanding of what actually happened. Thank you for all your hard work in collating all the information and showing the world the reality
Excellent documentary.
So heart heavy...never seen a human-suffering-focused work on the issue before...Much appreciation... Thank you very much.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Very good! Extraordinary!
Thanks for the history on this subject.
This was very enlightening but also very sad. I was struck by the apparent sense of entitlement of some of the Israeli interviewees and, in one or two cases, the lack of any shame - it really didn't have to be that way - I understand a lot more now.
I don’t condemn the terrorism, from either side, but people get tired, get hopeless, get angry, when you are pushed, abused, and misplaced the way they were. We don’t learn! 😢
The title should be "Creation of a Catastrophe."
Wow
A documentary on the Israeli occupation of Palestine 💔
The happiness of a people can't be built on un-happiness of another people!
How it can be???!!!
Hey, people, if it continues like this, the entire world will be un-happy soon!
God's patience will run out!
Shalom Aleichem!
As-Salamu Alaykum!
Peace on you!
Pace voua!
They became what they once hated. Shame on them!