Society, Politics & Existential Philosophy | Syed Muzammil's Full Talk in FAST University Lahore
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 05. 2022
- A detailed question based discussion on many social and political nuances of the Pakistani society, held in FAST University Lahore, last week. The discussion entails existential and absurdist philosophy at the end, followed by the Q and A session with the students.
Hello, people. I know it's utterly idiotic to anticipate that in the modern digitized age, people would listen to a talk that goes over an hour and 40 minutes. But let's be an optimist with this one, since it'd be a test. What's positive is that more and more campuses are sending us invitations to come and talk to the young minds there. This might be the start of a tradition of tolerating critical commentaries on Pakistani campuses, which a nation deluded by dogmatic and pseudo motivational speakers of our likes, is in dire need of. More than learning, we need to unlearn what has been fed to us in the prior decades. We need a Renaissance of our own and let's hope we contribute in providing our countrymen with its initial drops. Cheers.
-SMO
I got to listen something which is more worth than a 2 hours long movie. 🌼 🌸
@@mansoorahmad8275 great
🖤
Yes, let's hope ♥️
Will divide this in parts, maybe complete in 5 to 6 sittings.
Bow to the King. Boy who exactly are you? A lone warrior against odds, A spark of light in dark, a drop of rain in a dessert, An intellectual mind, a maverick. God bless you and save you from evil eyes.
@Jamal K what doesnagrisiyat mean?
@@abhishekbhardwaj5272 wtf are you talking about? Even Hindus and Sikhs in Pakistan are pakistanis and don't like to be called Indians, you are saying that Liberal pakistanis or atheists would call themselves Indians?
@@abhishekbhardwaj5272 I'm fan of muzammil but sometimes he too falls for Indian conservativism.
Pakistan and India exist, unlike some religious figures whose proof of existence is debateble between people.
Pakistan is a nation, so does India. Yes we had things in common and still have commonalities but this doesn't mean indans and pakistanis are same ol Indians.
Pakistan is a very synergistic country deriving it's ethnicity, language, culture, religion from many different parts of the world.
We have commonalities with India, Afghanistan, Iran, Arabs, Turkey, Central Asia, and Anglophone countries to some extent also.
Ethnically too.
But this doesn't mean we are Arabs or Indians.
Pakistan was created for a large minority with distinct geographical concentration, in general terms. Specifically speaking pakistan was created for Muslim minority of British India.
{tbh; from psychological pov, If someone from India likes to call Pakistanis as Indians, he considers pakistani as a superior fellow Indian who doesn't like to be called Indian.
On the other hand, if a Pakistani likes to be called Indian, he considers India as superior nation.
It's just like people's distancing from their poor relatives but boasting about their relation with rich and successful one's even if very distant one)
@@noob_donate_plz826 no not really. Plenty of atheists in Pakistan, far more than India for sure in terms of ex Muslims. Me, on the other hand, kinda confused
Wo wo wo wo man don't make him a hero bcz they die too early
This guy is really one of the greatest social scientists Pakistan has ever produced. Being an Indian, I want his thoughts should be perceived by all sane minds in my country in order to rationalize our social regard more and more.
Many appreciations from 🇮🇳.
Agree i from India too trust me he is a gem of a person born in pakistan pakistan as a nation need more of people like him.. Apart from the boundaries i can listen him for hours....
@@AbdulSamad-jw6xq apne dimaag ka ilaaz karwao bhai doctor na mile toh India aa jaao muft ilaaz karwa doonga lol
@Jamal K bhai India me religion per sawal utha sakte hai 😅
@Jamal K modiji india ke culture ko promote karna chahte hai jese America karta hai apni soft power se movies ke through games ke through
@@AbdulSamad-jw6xq ek intellectual ka naam bta jisse anti national declare kia ho?
There were times when universities used to invite Maulana Tariq Jameel as a guest speaker, good to see things are improving and headed in the right direction
So according to you Tariq jameel's speeches are not guiding us towards right direction?
@@theman-wq1jt I mean Tariq Jameel literally said the Covid-19 is our divine punishment and that it was the fault of immodest women.
Quaid e azam university me hoodbhoy kisi islamic preacher ko aany nahi dety thy. Ab nahi hy per phir bhi uska assar baqi hy
@@theman-wq1jt no
@@muhammadansarahmed6039 Quaid-e-Azam ne pakistan Islam ke naam pe banaya pr islamic scholar ko University mein allow nh krte the irony.
Damned this man will create fully unemployment situation for maulanas of madarsas in Pakistan which is good for Pakistan prosperity ❤️🇮🇳
80-90% audiance of this guy r Indian..
Why r Pakistani people r not following him..
He is such a gem.. i watched his Every video From Day 1..
He has answer of every single question with an appropriate example !!
Such a Great Intellectual 👏👏👌✌️
They r following him on facebook
We, Pakistanis only like to follow movie and drama celebrities. SMH
Bro, we are following him and watching him as well on a massive scale, youtube is not the only medium for us Pakistanis to watch and listen to him. He is on our national television as well unlike India.
Pakistani yeh comments nahi krsktay" love from india" to ic ka yeh matlab nahi k pakistani icay suntay nahi. Yeh banda Lahore ki ek sab sey bri university mein baat kar raha hai to ic sey pata lagta hai k Pakistani log icay social media pr bhi suntay hain
Where do you think that talk was held? At a Pakistani uni obviously, we refrain from commenting in general because of the patheticly dangerous environment here.
You are most respected Pakistani for me ( being Indian & Hindu). You are exceptionally brilliant and you deserve to be in top position for betterment of your country.
Yeah these type of guys we want more in our society both for India as well a pakistan so that there will be peace between us
If pakistan just eradicate the terrorism towards India then peace prevails very easily
@@ankitsinghbisht2902 ❤️
@@ankitsinghbisht2902 there can be no peace as long as islum exists
@@randmht9976 Pehly apny india ko to theek karo jo rss ky brahminon kutter extremist ky haton nafrat ki aag me jal raha hy minority ko mara ja jaha hy unky against nafrat phelae ja rahi hy
For me and world their can be no peace till ganduism exist gobarism exist. Ganduism = hate terror
Boss kya ho aap... Philosher..., Writer, teacher, thinker, influencer, leader, thinker, think tank... Whistle blower... What... ?? Next level.. awesome.. effective discussion.. 🙏 love you man .❤️ Truth deep analysis knowledge.. I m speechless 😶
ایسے سیشنس ہر کالج میں ہونے چاہییں اور بار بار ہونے چاہییں جب تک کم سے کم انہیں سننے والے پیدا نہیں ہوجاتے پھر وہ بولنا بھی شروع کرینگے آہسنتہ آہسنتہ ۔ These sessions should be held in every college, university of Pakistan and again and again many many times. It is need of the time.
This guy is really one of the greatest social scientists 🇵🇰 has ever produced. Being an Indian, I want his thoughts should be perceived by all sane minds in my country in order to rationalize our social regard more and more.
Many appreciations from 🇮🇳.
Harshit Saxena
totally agree
Kuch bhi vo jihadi hai
An Intellectual who always shed light on basic problems of our country
Bro, I wish if Pakistan has more minds like u, we would be at the top of the world.I live in America and what ever he said about it s 100% on point.May God Bless u
Thank you for sharing it here. Thoroughly enjoyed your critical commentary.
Books recommended:
Pakistan: A Hard Country by Anatol Lieven
Amusing Ourselves to Death by Neil Postman
Leviathan by Thomas Hobbes
Jakob Burckhadt’s book explaining the evolution of renaissance post barbarism. He didn’t mention the name but could be The Civilization of Renaissance in Italy
The Open Society & Its Enemies by Karl Popper
Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari
The Murder of History by KK Aziz
The Origins of Totalitarianism by Hannah Arendt
The Prince by Niccolò Machiavelli
Other readings:
Social Contract Theory by Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau
United States Bill of Rights
Study Maslow's hierarchy of needs
History of Russian Gibraltar
Treaty of Hudaybiyyah
Red Shi’ism by Ali Shariati
English, American, and French revolutions
Direct Action Day in Calcutta
Thanks mam🙂😇🙂
@@SonuYadav-yx1lm You are welcome :)
I'm taking screenshot of your comment. Thank you very much from the core of my heart ❤. Thank you 🙏🏼
@@abhishekbhardwaj5272 Glad to be of any assistance :)
@zunaira: Thank you for the effort.
Man I'm so so so proud to see people like him In Pakistan. He is a beam of hope. Indians are mostly his audience which shows they have reached that level quicker than Pakistanis. But its ok little by little we will reach there. He is wayyyyy ahead of his time for pakistan
We've such a gem 💎
Syed Muzamil is something to be listened and agreed with
Thanks a lot team for dong this talk. You all are amazing!
One suggestion though. The whole setup looks very intimidating and Muzamil sounds like a judge sitting on a throne 😂
Thank you Syed Muzammil. Pakistan is lucky to have such an intellectual like you. I am an Indian- American and I always look out for content from you. The space for philosophical debate is narrowed everyday and people like you need greater audience to change minds everwhere.
I hope Muzammil bhai’s efforts will normalise critical thinking in our country, which is labelled as a taboo.
I live in US and do clinical research and also from India but I don't know why I am watching you 4am.
Very brave and open discussion with facts sir. Hope you keep recording more and more discussion. God bless you!
its just a treat to ears to watch intellectual and rational person like you..
Absolutely i agree ❤️
I waited desperately for your views on the current political turmoil and you didn’t disappoint. Even if you hinted indirectly and in small doses palatable to the masses but to those who can discern the deeper meaning, I am really thankful to you for being the sane voice.
Glad to see universities inviting intellectuals like Muzammil for talks, maybe there's still hope for this country, who knows!
Your videos are eye opening for this mislead nation. You are creating awareness through your content.I would just thank you for this. Keep up the good work.
Thank you so much Muzammil for educating us all on so many levels -
This guy will revolutionize Pakistan.....
Best I have ever listened, Actually I have listened to Muzammil's all talks of hours and still I wanted their lengths extended more in time. Its never enough. Thank you for educating us in a real sense and have to unlearn the knowledge that factory model of schooling has taught us. Establishment is the real problem!
Muzammil Sahb....I would only say- you're "a truly beautiful mind". Your thoughts directly affects one's deeper intellect. 🙏
Knowledge is the ultimate power and that reflects from him words, his confidence, his command on himself. His literacy makes my eyes bigger and mouth opened, I myself tries hard to become that strengthened. I'm a PhD Scholar in medical sciences but also follow geopolitics on regular basis. I'm very much interested mentally, emotionally and ideologically in Indo-Pak relations and have adequate overview on things happening. Sir, you're a great inspiration for me to keep myself engaged in such deep scenarios. I can listen you whole day.... Respect from 🇮🇳
More power to you SYED MUZAMIL.
Thank you the gem for nourishing with great views which what this jerky society need. Keep visiting institutions 🙏🏻♥
اگر آپ کی یہ پوری کلیپ ہفتہ ایک اور 39 گھنٹے کے قریب بھی ہوتا تب بھی میں دیکھ لیتا، آپ نے بڑے پیچیدہ مسائل پر بہت خوبصورتی اور تاریخی دلیل کیساتھ تمام سوالوں کے جواب بہت خوبصورت جواب دیئے، اللہ پاک آپ کی زندگی سلامت رکھے، خوش رہیں
How many books you recommend...
First 30 minutes 4 books ....
Very excited to read all the books recommended by you Mr Syed...
You just open a new world new way of thinking ...
Keep recommends books so that the listeners can read those books for better understanding of the world.
Thank you
Books recommended by you.
1. Amusing Ourselves to death
2.An Analysis of John Lockes and Thomas Hobbes social about social contract
3. Burkhardt books ? Which book?
4. Open societies and it's enemies
5.Murder of History
6.Friends not Masters
7. Operation Gibralter is this a book?
8. The origin of Totalitarianism
9. The Prince
10. Ali Shariati the Iranian Philosopher
11.to read Alber camus
12. Nietzsche
13. From audience True Detectives American serial
14. Kafka
15. English revolution
16. American revolution
17. French revolution
If I remove the TV serial you recommended a lot of books to read I don't know how many lifetime it needs to complete..reading all these.
I have listed all these by stopping the video, many many times just to note down the names of book.
Excellent recommendations 👌
Kafka I have some collection but other books I have to read by downloading or buy paperback...
Thanks Mr Syed
@@rajeshsivaraman9494 🎉
The best video 👍 Refresh hooo gya..... Born intellectual in Indus valley civilization 🙏🤝
Hi Syed Muzammil, I hope you get more subscribers and more people in Pakistan listen to your views. You have a lot to share, and a lot of sense and knowledge to impart, which actually needs a larger audience. As an Indian, I appreciate your views, and appreciate how you are trying to positively influence the intellect of the people in your nation. I wish you all the best. :)
Have learned more politics and our issues then watching countless hours on our news media. He is the only real speaker right now In Pakistan. Mashallah lots of dua and love
Thankyou so much for uploading this on the channel Muzammil!! Please keep this trend up and upload any other talks that you are invited to as well! ❤️
How much informative you are and how much stupid/ innocent our peoples are 😢 May Allah gives motivation to all of us so that we fight for our basic needs
Love and More power to you Syed Muzammil. May people start to think on their own and they start trying to explore and find their self-being.
Good to see that some one has balls to be rational and crossing the red line time and again
Pehly apny india ko to theek karo jo rss ky brahminon kutter extremist ky haton nafrat ki aag me jal raha hy minority ko mara ja jaha hy unky against nafrat phelae ja rahi hy
I always wait for your video . Your every video carrying message for society if 30% people of Pakistan listen you a massive change will
Occurred in the society. Again thank you.
Pehly apny india ko to theek karo jo rss ky brahminon kutter extremist ky haton nafrat ki aag me jal raha hy minority ko mara ja jaha hy unky against nafrat phelae ja rahi hy
Love your witty commentary on individualism and democracy. It is the first time in my life that I am watching a talk that is more than 1 hour.
i literally cannot believe k mn ny 2 ghnty beth kr koi vid dykhi ho bna ek b second skip kye
musammil you are amazing
and i hope k kbi ap sy ml sku mn reality mn
dream jsa hi hy lkin umid toh rkh hi skty hm
You are the only one who spoke state forward against the extremists,fascism,etc,...you are the true hero...
10:55 sabse bada oppression to ignorance hi hai .... This man is a gem ... We would really appreciate a man with such intellect in India ... God bless u man... ❤️ Jai hind
Edit:
17:29 Universities should ensure free debate. Issey mashere ka self correction shuru hojata hai ...
Mashallah bhaijan... Bahut khoob... We really appreciate ur intellect.. love from from India 👍👍👍
Few journalists like you are still has the courage to tell the truth.This type of bold journalists and activists should come forward to change the radical mindset of your people.Your role works as eye opener for your emotional people who are still living in a dilution.
Pehly apny india ko to theek karo jo rss ky brahminon kutter extremist ky haton nafrat ki aag me jal raha hy minority ko mara ja jaha hy unky against nafrat phelae ja rahi hy.
Tum nafrat sy bhary log ho fascist extremist ideology ko follow kerny waly
Hamko lecture na do apny ap ko theek karo
Not just "his people" the people all over the world specifically India to have journalists like him.
This is Who Hassan Nisar should Aspire to become Provided he wants to Grow up 👍
😀at 70 he's not gonna change or grow any more.
@@ashishsachdeva432 Biologically-Impossible
Intellectually- Optional
Well said!
Shit, I hadn't enough time to watch and didn't know you were giving hearts to comments. Mine is a bit late. I'm a very regular member. I deserve a heart.
Btw, bravo!
I've seen you on Harris sultan's channel.
One of the best journilst who show u the real image , real problems of our society.
Yes, absolutely right comment for people of Pakistan.
Great muzammil bro.i appreciate your efforts for better ment of society.love from Mumbai India
I was observing your views on your channel and was thinking that you were a sane Pakistani. But this analysis of yours is something else bro. Believe me, me and my friends always wonder being in the same part of the world, why pakistani's are so ignorant. I'm sharing this video among my friends. You should write a book about this. I guarantee atleast 2 or 3% of indians will definately want to read it. 👍
3% of around 130 CRORES 👍👍
@@SP.05 maybe. What do you think?
Wonder about yourself first he had said clearly;
Your country is also filled with fools!
Impossible!!
@@balajzafarr So many Indians want to know why pakistani Muslims are duffle but not Indian Muslims. So, why not...
Syed I agree this is long but as always are exceptional, did not realize how time had passed. I enjoyed every second of it good learning, keep it up!
I have just one question ,
what do you think what is the perfect definition of a democracy ??
well nice to see that algorithm is promoting your videos, specially in India
good luck buddy.....
Glad This University Invited You.Critical Thinking Must Be Encouraged In Subcontinent
Critical thinking is a taboo in islam.
Indian subcontinent !
This guy is super intelligent! Way more than most other Pakistani media reps as well as Indian. He belongs in forward thinking societies, like Sweden and Denmark!!!
You have set a standard for me to see to judge more clearly any politician, tv anchors, analysts, scholars,even anyone who claims. You are only one person who speaks totally unbiased about issues.
Literally, I never get tired of listening to you, no matter what you talk about. Thanks for uploading this long lecture talk and making today's night beneficient. The saddest part is that some brainless folk prefer to watch 2-hours of a meaningless movie instead of this insightful lecture. Let reason and rationality take precedence over idiocy and stupidity.
Watching movies is no idiocy.
@@zalandnawaz4994 Certainly, but the choice of watching movies matters. Those who watch meaningless movies don't prefer to listen such insightful lectures and vice versa.
Got it
I listened to the whole talk in one go. Its always nice to listen to you.
Thank you so much for enlightening us through your deep insightful thoughts nd ideas.
why u cut off the salafism part, it's better people get to know what kind off fungus it is.
You did great by first creating a shorter video (not short enough to not be able to transmit ideas) for audience to connect with the ideas on several topics first. This gives someone a level to know the person and what he is trying to convey.
It’s difficult to have an audience with a start of 90 minutes exchange of ideas in these days. No matter how important the topic is. It takes a lot of time to collect this kind of audience . All the best . Looking forward to it!
I keep on visiting your channel every day if you have uploaded any new video. Thanks for the excellent hour upload bro
Thank you Soo much muzammil Bhai for the wonderful eye-opening video.
I wish more youths were there like you in lndia 🙏🙏🙏.Come here 🙏
Excellent session. Would love to see more of these.
Thankyou for this an hour long video❤️
Keep posting such videos 🔥
This is very educational and it is need for our oldies and youngies . Change of mind to acquire peace is necessary
Sir, very informative. Keep doing such sessions.
"It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. You can get tricked if you don't question yourself and others, especially people in a position of authority. Anything that's truly real can stand up to scrutiny." Carl Sagan
One Of the Best Voice in Modern Era
I can listen your voice ( your lectures) for Hours, without getting tired. 🤗🤗🤗
Food for thoughts,Mind blowing discussions ♥️
Food for Thoughts
always love to see you. please make videos once in week. I need to wait for two weeks.
Excellent session 👏 I always learn from your videos. More power to you 👍
Excellent talk! Thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it. ❤
Imran Riaz Khan has million subscribers and Muzammil has 80k.This shows the priorities of this nation.
And in this 80k subscribers almost 60%from India😂😂
Imran Riaz bohat saalo sa CZcams par hai or aik famous Chanel ka anchor Raha hai
Jab ka muzimaal bhsi ko abhi one year Howa hai or ye aik chota Chanel par aaraha hai ahista ahista famous hinge
Mujha bhi kuch din phla pra chla hai enka baara me
"The truth may be puzzling. It may take some work to grapple with. It may be counterintuitive. It may contradict deeply held prejudices. It may not be consonant with what we desperately want to be true. But our preferences do not determine what's true."
Carl Sagan
from india and ive learned more about pakistan from you than compared to all my life in india .
Just superb. You are an inspiration to me. Truly.
I have not seen any individual till today with so much clarity and gargantuam amount of knowledge and liberal thinking
You Have a Brilliant and an Open Mind Sir!! Best Wishes from Canada!!!
Finally an hour long video❤️ #highly_awaited
Thanks Ustad for uploading this ❤❤
I felt like I'm revising my Political science and International relations optional subject of UPSC😶
Do you need any guidance about psir optional?
@@thepassionate9551 something special or anything different u know?
Any key point to keep in mind for psir....then do mention...🙏😊
I am listening you from Karachi. You have shuted me out so many times because of my thoughts. But, i would not mind and will keep learning from you.
Brilliant discussion Muzamil. I wish this man should be made PM of Pakistan with full powers or at least his videos should be shown in every college or University to change young minds. Keep it up man.
Truth is bitter, Just experienced it. One thing learned over the years of my life is that It's very had and painful to accept the truth. I use to buy whatever the popular narrative was in every situation, Listened to one video of Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza and now I am here after 3 years.
Evolution.
Engr Mirza is a stepping stone towards free-thinking and atheism (he doesnt know it though).
Not necessarily
most awaited video
Huge respect man. Keep chipping away. One day people will understand and act.
Amazing talk I have to listen to him more
A great intellectual, respect allot Sir, stay blessed and keep it up 👍, just love❤️
Boy o boy first time I heard you, on some random what's up clip and you got my attention and I was wondering who is this kid talking too maturely beyond his age ha, I scrolled to something else then again after a few days came across another clip like before made even more sense this time and I forwarded that clip to my friends' group and one of my friends enquire about you and said buddy who is this kid so thoughtful that's the first time I look for you Channel and search for your name and added in my subscription yesterday, let me tell you I'm glad I did that ....love from Canada keep up the good work buddy.
The show I can't miss at any rate.
Thank you 💗 Muzammil
Love for you and your intellectual talks ❤🇮🇳
@Syed Muzammil Official
Sir please could you do a video talking about the 1971 war and sharing the details of the amount of the genocide, r*pe, m*rder of innocent men, women and children. Also could you tell us how many pakistani soldiers or other ranks actually surrendered so that it helps educate us about the real facts for our better understanding as no one really wants to be jahil. It would be so nice to see you collaborate with Alok sir from Defence Detective, he speaks highly of you and in his channel is widely viewed because of the facts he presents, so it would be very nice to see you both speak about 1971 war of East Pakistan. Many thanks
time well spend .
learning from you about pakistan and its problem
Best intellectual who shows mirror to society,,, make videos to enveil the false histories,,that people know the truth
Really interesting perspective, quite rare to see learned people like you from Pakistan
My man changing the minds 🙏.
Keep it up sir.
Great conversation ❤️❤️❤️