‘Ill-prepared’ Labor ‘caught off guard’ by Coalition’s nuclear energy plans
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 06. 2024
- One Nation Chief of Staff James Ashby says Labor has been “caught off guard” by the Coalition’s nuclear energy plans.
“They are so ill-prepared, Labor, for this announcement that they are being caught off guard,” he told Sky News host Paul Murray.
“And Labor really don’t have an argument against Peter Dutton’s very sensible plan for stability.”
Why should Dutton state costs. Labour has not announced their costs yet and they have been spending taxpayer money for over two years with no transparency.
Rules for thee; not for me.
Exactly
Precisely, and Labor don't just not tell people the cost of their rollout, they lock the costs up in NDAs citing commercial-in-confidence. They are spending taxpayer/our money and not allowing anyone to tell us how much.
Labour’s management of money should be scrutinised aswell- that would make for good debate!
Actually I believe it has been estimated at 1.2-1.5 trillion taxpayer dollars
Tanya Plibersek epitomises what is wrong with Australian politics, she is simply nauseating.
High maintenance waste of space. Australian politicians are either the dumbest craziest out there or they are doing what they are told by their donors and handlers
And an old bat
And she loves the drugs 🤠
Take a look at who is leading the labor party. Enough said.
Tell that to the clowns who voted for him!
UMM, that would be the WEF,.....
Keating was a shit of a PM and I still don't trust him.
He was/is a narcissist, like most alp leaders.
Paul Keating would not give a damn that you dont trust him.
Fabian socialist
@@paulchilds9137exactly. That's why he shouldn't be a politician then ...this is the problem. They don't give a damm what you think and that's not how it should be
@@paulchilds9137 ''Paul Keating would not give a damn'', true. He never gave a damn as PM either.
WELL we DONT Trust YOU Tanya. Wheres Your Costs you Refuse to give us.? And you have had over 2 YEARS.
tanya makeusick has just verbalised more labor hypocrisy, last time I looked blackout hasn't told us what his renewables fantastical idiocy costs?
A VOTE FOR LABOR IS A VOTE FOR CHINA 🇨🇳
In that case, a vote for either party is a vote for nuclear power stations; Dutton's or China's. 🙂I would prefer Dutton's.
I think you'll find many LNP politicians are invested in China. And who sold all that farm land and leased the port of Darwin to China? I think you will find Scomo's signature on that document.
Don't you mean Chyyna, you know Chyyyna hahaha
Bowen got rammed on ABC TV over nuclear power and he crashed
😊
Yes!! Go Peter dutton. The country is watching.
oh ok Yogi.
Peter Dutton's nuclear plans have turned the Liberal Party's free enterprise ethos on its head.
When has labor in the last 2 1/2 years been focused on productivity.
Sleazey was looking forward to the juicy juicy sales commission for spending 2 TRILLION DOLLARS on TEMU
Renewables
This Labor government a embarrassment to Australia...run bu fools
labor does not have clue full stop
Tanya when has a government ever started a program like RE without costing it and knowing that we can afford it. She is such a hypocrite.
Full costings of renewable transition has not been formally announced.
A referendum style failure is coming and it will result in Labor sitting on the opposition bench.
Labor no costings & lies nothing to see here.
Where are Labors costings ?????
Question is: do politicians give a toss what people feel -voice =example-still being pushed via states after 450 million already wasted
No, they don't care!!
How much is 28,000 km of new high voltage transmission lines going to cost? Expensive unreliable renewable energy projects like wind turbines and solar farms that need to be replaced between 15-20 years. Nuclear reactors with a lifespan of 80-100 years.
How much is land acquisition and compensation for all those transmission lines going to cost also? Let’s not forget the compensation we will be paying to the indigenous people for building on their land also
and need to remember that Bowen apparently has an undisclosed slush fund of $60 Billion that is not in any costing, but to be used as he sees fit!!
They weren’t ‘caught off guard’, labor were counting the days before Dutton released his announcement, Kristy is right.
It would be very revealing to see Dutton and Albo debate face-to-face the costs of their respective plans. Of course, Albo would refuse because the cost of his plan is many times more than the cost of Dutton's nuclear plan to achieve the same net zero emissions target. Even the Greens in Finland now agree with a mixed renewables and nuclear path.
I would assume that any of those opposed to Nuclear Power Plants will not be going to France for the Olympic games, as there are 56 operable nuclear reactors in France. Athletes that are opposed to Nuclear Power Plants surely will be cancelling their trip to the Olympics. The anti-nuclear Teal, Z a l i S t e g g a l l, when she was skiing, she lived in France for a number of years, and not once back then complained about nuclear, and she probably still visits France nowadays; an absolute hypocrite. Also, I would assume that no Labour and Green members from here on will visit any countries that have a nuclear reactor.
PS A l b o and B o w e n are looking like the biggest idiots in the world with their anti-nuclear stance with 14 of the G20 countries already having nuclear power, and especially considering that we mine uranium for export.
What about the nuclear-powered subs they want to build? To be consistent with the ALP's insane anti-nuclear policy, they should be abandoned. Of course, they won't be so it just exposes even more how the ALP is a party of hypocrites and liars.
Not sure how they cope NSW either seeing as Lucas Heights has been operating for decades
No Labor we don't trust you
Ashby speaking common sense. Yes, a debate in front of paywalls. South Africa is a prime example of unreliable grids.
What will netzero cost in $. Anyone know? LUCY? 😂😂😂😂
Tanya pls drop off the sanctimonious pretence!! Go away and ask Casanova your costs!!!!!
For all her faults Pauline Hanson used to be a voice for the working class. This Ashby bloke is not.
You are the troll again. Nothing of benefit to say. You would be better to keep quiet, then people would not know how unsupported your comments are.
Faith in Labour has wavered from too many failures in practical matters and Aust need for strong leadership & conviction.
Hey Tanya, it’s nice of you to complain about Dutton not releasing costings yet but you’re forgetting Albo hasn’t released the full costings of renewables yet which is even dumber.
Only vote ONE NATION!!
Plibersek cannot be taken seriously on any subject.
Tanya Plibersek you don’t give a position to a convicted criminal,drug dealer,your husband,but hey….
Tanya and the labor can't stop spending money on themselves and billions on the renewables that should never have happened. Finland just recently opened a nuclear power station and electrical costs have dropped.
Were is Labors costs on Renewable Rort ????? Solar and wind ????
Everything under Labor costs more
It's beautiful to see Albanese squirm over this nuclear issue......... Peter Dutton is a genius.
Plibersek is qualified in? Environment seriously 😮
When are Labor going to release the cost of their renewables which is going to cost trillions maybe more than nuclear? Who would listen to Tanya and her mates?
Not maybe! Astronomically more and renewable profits it won't stop and we won't have the power to pay it. We will be slaves.
F...your renewables, they dont work, blackouts, expense, my power bills have gone up
6 fold 4:07 & July is going up again
My solar feed-in & pensioner rebate doesn't make a dent.
labor, the narcissist party
A typical example of labor ignorance 😊
Well said James, Plibersek is in lalaland, where’s the costing for renewables? Oh we’ll tell you as we go 😂 not to mention the destruction of the environment and farmland which she’s supposed to be the minister 😂😂😂
"Expert" - irrelevant, whining, ashby. Staffer for the braindead, oxygen thieving racist scum ginger fishwife. 😂 Piss off.
yes labor couldn't believe this insanity
Does Zero Emissions include banning the Smoking Ceremony?
Oh Tania, where’s Labours costings 🤔
Priceless!
What’s needed is for the media to question these ministers at the press conferences! Ask the hard questions such as providing details and supporting information etc etc. Show us the detailed plans and total costs.
I’ve just had a letter telling me my electricity is going up again July Thanks Albo 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
If you don't know, vote no. Where have a heard that before?
Yep, we know what we’re getting with Dutton but still many questions with Labor
@@knight2425What you are getting - permanently negative and mashed potato recipes.
@@countyorga764 What exactly don’t you know what we are getting with Dutton?
@@knight2425 awesome, please me know the following:
How many reactors?
Design?
Manufacturer?
MW rating?
Expected running load?
Cost (initial)?
Cost (lifetime)?
State/federal regulatory structure?
Expected % of energy mix at completion?
Site for waste storage?
Amount of waste storage?
Since new wires are not needed, cost of refurbishing current transmission line infrastructure?
What benefits will the surrounding communities get to host?
If you can’t answer that, you don’t know
If you don’t know, vote no
@@LogicLost so you know the answers to the similar questions from Albo?
What is the actual full costings of the renewables plan?
How much land and water is needed to build all this renewables?
Where are all these locations?
Where are all these transmission lines being built?
How much are the transmission lines costing?
How much are we paying for compensation to land owners?
How much are we paying the indigenous communities for building transmission lines on their land?
How much power will these renewables be making every year and how much will we need to supplement with gas or coal?
How much is replacement costs every 15 years at end of lifetime?
What are we doing every 15 years with the panels and turbines that have reached the end of their useful life?
How much is the costing for recycling all the old equipment?
What are the safeguards in place for when something goes wrong with the turbines in the ocean to prevent oil from spilling into the water?
Do you need me to ask more questions because there are plenty more?
Yep, if we don’t know then vote no
Richard Miles needs to deliver what he’s debating - they had months to come up with a decent response rather than continued spending for example proposing increase to the New General Governor ! Plus Government has had 3 pay rises since being elected, millions provided to the NIA yet huge gaps in wellbeing for indigenous peoples - it’s an absolute MESS!
The ALP have no idea what to do as Klaus Schwab has retired and didn't leave any instructions.
Tanya Plibber and Albo Fibber have had 2+ years in Govt but they still CAN'T or WON'T give us the $$$ cost of 28,000kms of Transition Lines! Nor the cost of storage Batteries because as yet the technology is not available 😅.
When I was in Australia I always voted for the Coalition. However, on this Liberals appear to have lost the plot. Nuke plants are expensive and have long lead times which is a concern, and the fact that they are going to be state enterprises means the tax payer will be taking on the risk, whether they are financially viable or not. Further still, they face a lot of opposition. There are technologies available for keeping the lights on with variable wind and solar generation. These include pumped hydro and battery storage.
That being said, if a state premiere backs having one in their state and a private investor is prepared to have their own skin in the game, well okay... However, all indications are that all those planned Nuke plants by Dutton aren't going to happen.
You speak rubbish and mis-information my friend!!
@@lesblack413 Haha... righhht...go on, make a fool of yourself speaking with your tin-foil hat on!
In a land beneath the southern star,
A tale unfolds, both near and far.
Labor stood with plans in hand,
Unaware of what was planned.
The winds of change began to blow,
With whispers of a future's glow.
The Coalition, with vision grand,
Held a dream for this great land.
Peter Dutton, bold and true,
Saw a future bright and new.
With nuclear power, safe and clear,
He painted hope, dispelling fear.
Labor faltered, caught off guard,
Their plans seemed now to be marred.
Ill-prepared, they faced the storm,
While Dutton's vision took new form.
Sky News, with voices strong,
Sang praises of the future's song.
They heralded Dutton's daring scheme,
A beacon bright, a nation's dream.
Heroes emerged in times of need,
With courage, vision, and noble creed.
Sky News and Dutton led the way,
Guiding through the darkest day.
No longer did the shadows loom,
For nuclear power dispelled the gloom.
With steady hands and hearts so bright,
They brought the nation into light.
Labor watched, unsure and stunned,
As the Coalition’s plan was spun.
A future clear, with power vast,
Secured by leaders built to last.
Australia rose on newfound wings,
Embracing what the future brings.
With nuclear light and guiding stars,
They healed their wounds and mended scars.
The heroes stood with vision clear,
Their voices strong for all to hear.
Sky News and Dutton, bold and true,
Crafted a future bright and new.
OddBall
That was fkn awesome 👌. .
The last but was a repeat though. I'd either drop it or change it.
Second last bit sorry
If your child was dying in a hospital bed you wouldn’t cost the treatment would you, we are getting to that stage here under ABOnese
Paul Keating has his place but not in the energy discussion. Negativity on nuclear energy runs through the veins of influential old labour, not accounting for any advancements made in the technology. It may take time, but the future of our kids shouldn't be up for ideological dominance.i feel we need that broader focused debate on nuclear covering costs, security, and benefits without any clouding over by labours chicken little like hysteria over climate change.
Labour's B o b Ha w k e supported nuclear power. From the A B C, Wed 28 Dec 2016, "...Former prime minister B o b H a w k e's assertion that nuclear power is the salvation for a planet ravaged by global warming divided the crowd at the Woodford Folk Festival, north of Brisbane today...". "...Nuclear power would be a win for the environment and an essential part of the attacking that must be made on this grievous and dangerous global warming," he said. "It would be a win for the global environment and a win for Australia." Mr H a w k e said science also pointed to Australia being the safest geologically to store the world's nuclear waste.
First Pharma now Nuclear, from the same playbook.
What question air it's the first I have heard of
Hey Albo isn't it time you gave yourself and your comrades a another payrise?
Paul Keating: It is far better to keep your mouth shut to deny others thinking one of being an idiot than to open your mouth and completely remove all doubt.
The tax on Super will sink them. An own goal.
How could you trust labor on any cost calculating! Look at their history! Still in play! Where are the 4000 beds that were promised? Where are the 80000 homes that were promised? Where are the power cuts that wee promised! Come on , how much can an aussie take
Probably didn't think LNP would bring it up, given they were in power for many many years and didn't bring it up before. Suddenly now it's a priority. I think this is more about keeping coal and the LNP getting that fossil fuel lobby money. Would have been nice to have this debate a few years ago.
Oh hi there I didn't see you there it's just little old beamsey here
😂😂 what a joke listening to these 😅😅 south Africa 🇿🇦 has black ⚫️ outs because of cruption
😂look around dickhead they want you to wear a dress and get fkd by the ccp. He was partying at a family friendly pedophile parade. How much more corrupt can you get ! Read a book. 😂😂😂
If Bob Hawke was a CIA operative in the PMs chair, whose operative is in the PMs chair now?
Me thinks he is a WEF operative, as he is not taking orders from us, his employer.
So who own Albo?
Um tanya, I think we don't have to look too far, basically all of labors policies in the last election really were not costed
Wait a while Plebs - it's coming - costings and all. They will release it slowly so you have a chance to absorb the detail.
You alright my Aussie Brothers!! You seen our boy Jay??
Gotcha
Toto ate his homework
I never would trust sleezebag at anytime. He’s jst a bad PM.
to have one nation as the chief political support for this plan does not auger well for the election...have to say a lot of the coalition's base is going to waver on this ... that's how it looks at this stage
She not to bright has anybody seen there costings.but she has an arts degree
Albo is a child mentally, and this must be catchy!……In fact the only attempt at a sensible statement came from Keating, but no one listens to him…………😂
Paul - any truth in the rumour that you are Australia's Pole Vault competitor in the Paris Olympics?
Petes bank of Shanghai will take care of cost of reactors 😅
Why can we not subscribe to this in the U.K? Come on Murdoch, you can move mountains. Get hold of Andrew Neil and sort something out. Just teach the Aussies how to say "data". Don't be like yanks and bastardize the language we gave you.
100 billion for 100 years v 1.5 trillion every 20 years hahhaahahhahahahhahahahhahaha 🤡
Let’s see how many boomers get on here posting misinformation about nuclear power..Sean is the first…Jack Richardson is the second
What type of nuclear reactors, how much will it cost, and when will they come online?
watch for ill-informed labor shills with their emotional unscientific scare mongering about nuclear power that cant do math
@@user-pj5ub5cp9k your sphincter reactors..what ever is in your piggy bank and when you next fart
Is Jack back? 😂😂😂
@@Design_noyes..he replied to me on here
The left need to do WAY less complaining and more leading.
Seem like they're insecure about their capabilities 😉
What capabilities? They’re the most inept government we’ve ever had.
@@leeevans2929 you have heard of Scott Morrison I assume.
I had to delete your channel. Too much information on the Royals.🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
Ill prepared? or incompetent? Stop playing politics with my money.
"Nonsense"the nuclear question shows how desperate the Libs are
Rubbish. Do your own research, listen to the experts, and stop listening to people who do not know right from wrong!!
Nuclear Reactors use Ionizing radiation which is not immediately detectable by human senses, so instruments such as Geiger counters are used to detect and measure it. However, very high energy particles can produce visible effects on both organic and inorganic matter (e.g. water lighting in Cherenkov radiation) or humans (e.g. acute radiation syndrome).
Exposure to ionizing radiation causes cell damage to living tissue and organ damage. In high acute doses, it will result in radiation burns and radiation sickness, and lower level doses over a protracted time can cause cancer.
Yes just like the reactor at Lucus Heights
@@shaynegadsden Spent nuclear fuel stays a radiation hazard for extended periods of time with half-lifes as high as 24,000 years. For example 10 years after removal from a reactor, the surface dose rate for a typical spent fuel assembly still exceeds 10,000 rem/hour-far greater than the fatal whole-body dose for humans of about 500 rem received all at once.
@@imeagleeye1 whats your point we have been running a reactor in this country for 60 years, not only without any issues but it creates so little news most people don't even know it exists
@@shaynegadsden Spent nuclear fuel stays a radiation hazard for extended periods of time with half-lifes as high as 24,000 years. For example 10 years after removal from a reactor, the surface dose rate for a typical spent fuel assembly still exceeds 10,000 rem/hour-far greater than the fatal whole-body dose for humans of about 500 rem received all at once.
Oh shit really!
Has all of France got cancer you say?
Higher probability that your full of misinformation me thinks!
Albo is a marijuana (a slow dope). His minions are a bunch of vapes.
The coalition are all over the shop on this. It's already fallen apart
Evidence?
@@Prognosis__as usual the left have no evidence, for anything they support.
No it hasn't shithead. There's reality and there's your comments, Shaun.
@@Prognosis__ The way they keep changing their tune about consulting with communities to just ramming it through.
@@David_Beames what? 🤪
Like you and your comments are important on CZcams.
Vote for Labor is a vote for poverty