Paul Keating goes on an ‘abusive rant’ about Opposition’s nuclear energy plans
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 06. 2024
- Sky News host Chris Kenny says former prime minister Paul Keating reverted to his other well-known characteristic, which is “sharp personal abuse” when discussing the nuclear energy debate.
Mr Keating has issued an explosive response to the Opposition’s nuclear energy plans, claiming it was driven by “manic denialism” of climate change.
“Keating’s statement about nuclear even had an abusive heading, labelling Peter Dutton a climate denialist and peddler of danger, making him sound like a pantomime villain,” Mr Kenny said.
“Really, Dutton is the first political leader, Liberal, National, Labor or Greens, to provide a plan to get to net zero that is actually plausible under proven technology, and Keating says that’s denialism?
“And the abusive rant continued ... this typical Keating invective just doesn’t make sense.”
Peter Dutton was right the prime minister is a little kid in a grown up body
Tell that to all the clowns who voted for him!
@@EdBenji I think most of those voted against ScoMo rather than *for* Albo - if so I'm confident they won't repeat that mistake.
Little children don't bawl as much as the crybaby Albanese. Grow up Albanese. Stop stoking antisemitism. Why did you and Wong stop the 75 years of bipartisan support for Israel, our traditional friend ? Because Albanese has always been a supporter of the PLO. Wearing his yassa Arafat headgear on his Kon tiki tour of the world when he was a student.
@@jiminverness I voted against scomo because i never want a conservative leader like him again.... And i would again because liberals have no backbone. Vote One Nation first then maybe liberals since Albo is another...
@@jiminverness we can only hope
The fact is there is no climate “crisis” the only crisis is that labour is in power
Countries including China are spending Trillions of dollars a year on a con job?
You do know that Australia isn't the only country that has a climate?
Correct. The carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels are actually beneficial. Benefits include greening of the planet with increased agricultural yields (main effect) reduced winter heating costs, fewer deaths from hypothermia and postponement of the next glacial maximum.
The current mean annual surface temperature of Earth and the current atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration are suboptimal. Deaths from hypothermia greatly exceed those from heat stroke.
We should withdraw from the Paris accord and use the most economical energy resources available.
@@turnerfamilyinozi " Really "!!, that is your answer? Do you know that not all of Australia has the same climate. And explain to the world just why should Australia that produces less than 1.3% of the pollution go into economic melt down while many countries do nothing.
@turnerfamilyinozi
Nothing any climate change peanut has ever said has come true.
PK is the start of labor's fall. He is full of BS. Never voted after he shafted Bob. Shame on labor. Albo is the university activities that has not grown up. He has never had a real job. Shame on labor. Shame.
Bob shafted PK. Remember the Kirribilli Agreement? Bob broke his word.
The fact that Keating is against nuclear by verbally abusing Dutton is more indirect proof that Peter Dutton is right. And Mat Kean has always been Laborlite so he's in the right job
The flack gets thick when you're over the target. In this case, VERY thick.
@@Lost_on_stage_again Flak barrages were always placed well before targets. What's the point of letting bombers fly above their targets? They can let loose their entire payload, damaged or not.
I can tell you how much money 💲💵💵💵 it will cost the public of Australia trillions of dollars,most Australians will not be able to afford to pay for power ???????,IF you won't to find out how much a nukler Power station Cost ,Ask a country that has One how much it cost to build it .
Keating has verbally abused literally everyone since he was first an mp, why do you think dutton is special? lol
So Paul Keating is against Nuclear. Makes me want it even more.
Any pro-CCP commentator is against Australia having cheaper energy.
That'll lern him.
Me too
i have never voted labor, but bob hawke was right on the money all those years ago. albo and bowen are both failures.
Bob Hawke was the last leftist PM that I regard as actually having a balanced approach. Today, he would be regarded as a far right nazi by today's left. However, I consider him a usual idiot, who falsely believed that the left is about what it promoted it'self to be about. If Bob was alive and young today, and entering politics, he would be joining the Libs or Nats, or an independent. The fact is that all leftist roads lead to communism. All versions of leftism, socialism or call them whatever else you want, are just communism lite smoke screens and deceptions to gain support. They are nothing but preludes to Stalin's Russia, or George Orwell's 1984.
Beijing wouldn’t like Australia to have energy security. Therefore, Keating doesn’t like it either.
Absolutely the Chinese hate it because it limits their takeover possibilities.
Trillion dollars counted on by China in exporting slave-made wind mills and solar panels to Australia would go up in smoke overnight !!! Also making Australia energy dependent on Communist China in perpetuity is a another benefit China desires making Australia an easier target as it builds its empire
100% correct!
Well said ..!!! What a good point ..!!
Go Keating , calling out coalition stupidity.
I don’t think Paul Keating has been on the right side of History post the recession we had to have.
He never emotionally recovered from the ‘96 election!
The trouble with Paul Keating was simply he was too intelligent for all you lot.And your hero John Howard could only manage to give us a GST.Regarding the recession,it was world wide.
@@ganneswilliams641 Keating was a humanity optimist. We wanted Aussies to be as open and caring and giving as we could be. Perhaps he aimed too high.
Howard was more pragmatic. He knew division, mistrust, animosity & envy would win him votes, and it worked.
Keating tried to take us higher, but lost. Howard dragged us lower & grubbier, and won.
@@ganneswilliams641 The trouble with insanity is it doesn’t know itself !
@@ganneswilliams641Could not agree with you more!👍
Keating has his money in renewables like the rest of them.
China is looking after PJK keeping his bank account topped up
They are a very poor investment which is heavily dependent upon taxpayer funded subsidies.
Gl0balists are trying to prevent Australia from becoming an economic powerhouse. Manufacturing would return with cheaper power.
That and corrupt money from pig farms he didn't invest in.. $ 20 million free money... ? Nothing to see there, hey , Keating? Dirty dog .
Some would call that a corrupt human being who should be investigated before he dies on us.
Maybe we should give him an award...?
How about yours Dan... ?
... Dirty KLI NTS
So, as someone ( me ) who knows climate change on a geological scale, Keating. ... How about you pull the other one, genius.
Our little egoist " Pavarotti of Treasury ".... ?
I lived through that " recession we had to have" ... matey... you know, the one that hurt working class men the most. ?
Class traitors like you, liars and corrupt cheats like you, Chinas little ass kisser like you...ignorant about all things climate, like you. KEATING. YOU get to lecture anyone about anything, how?
Sit down and shut up, Keating.
Embarrassing yourself, matey..
The Pavorotti of gaslighting ignorant traitors.
Thanks for vastly less than nothing.
Die before they give you traitor of the year ?
Competition is tough, but you could still win it.
Keating is no longer relevant
why do we have to put up with obsolete, irrelevant people
Neither is Carlson. How many times has been sacked?
@@turnerfamilyinozi Tucker is even better on his own network
@@Prognosis__the fact you believe the man😂😂😂😂
I understand why you can't debate now😂😂😂
@@Aaronwhatnow what’s debating got do do with following TC?
Old angry Chinese banker big mad.
Nuclear power is actually cleaner than solar and wind
The hardware for WIND and SOLAR is mostly made in China. That is why ALBO and BOWEN are pushing it.
How???????
Turbines and solar panels have to be manufactured using non- renewable power. When we are talking about the number and size of these renewable facilities that is a very significant amount of production. Their life cycle moreover is about a third of a nuclear power plant and so the production life cycle must be undertaken multiple times in the life of a nuclear plant. This issue is quite apart from the massive environmental destruction they cause.
HOW MUCH MONEY is He Making off Investments into Renewables and Gov Subsidies.???
Most renewable energy equipment only exists due to massive taxpayer funded subsidies.
We need to withdraw from the Paris Agreement and use the most economical energy resources available
@@johngeier8692 Exactly, and that source is clean brown coal and natural gas. I've got nothing against nuclear but its just pandering to the climate catastrophists.
Keating wouldn't know his arse from his Albo.
I admire Peter Dutton for putting nuclear power out there and having the guts to back it ,,,,at least he has the guts to put it to the people before the election so we the people can decide,,,, Albo and the greens have rammed this renewables dream down our throats with BOWEN and his clowns,, Power to you Peter Dutton 👍🇦🇺
Marxist globalism is ALP & Albozo mantra
It'd be good if he could provide costings for it though wouldn't it? CSIRO reckons it'll cost 600 billion. When Labor legislated their renewables plan it lays out the cost; 122 billion. CSIRO also says that the seven nuclear reactors that have been proposed by Dutton would only amount to 4.8% of the total energy needed in Australia, and they won't be up and running until 2037 at the earliest. Tbh I agree with the spirit of what Keating was saying; the reason Dutton has decided to run this up the flag pole right now is to keep postponing the net-zero targets.
@@lachiegoff8036I read an article on the ABC that csiro said 8.5 billion per nuclear reactor costing $59.5 billion, how can the csiro own estimates differ so much.
@@asnail6550 yea nah ur right I read the article wrong. Turns out CSIRO does say lower estimate is 8.5 billion per reactor with upper being 40 billion. Either way it’ll still only account for 4.8% of the mix. Renewables make up 39.4% right now. Why not continue investing in renewables instead of flushing potentially 280 billion down the drain to give us a 20th of our total power?
@@lachiegoff8036 fair enough but I didn’t know Dutton had stated what type of reactors he planned to use. My idea would be use the renewables till they are ready for replacing then use the nuclear power instead of replacing the renewables every 20 odd years. Another thing is do they have to build them all at once.
Australia should have gone nuclear in the sixties. Australia needs them for the submarines and self defence.
You can blame Howard and the Liberals that Australia doesn't have nuclear energy.
@@turnerfamilyinozi And the governments that went before them....
@@turnerfamilyinozi How do you come up with blame Howard and liberals when they were advocating for nuclear? It was the greens that stopped the nuclear push, but at least Howard got the new reactor at Lucas Heights through.
@@axle.australian.patriot Only when facing the 2007 election they knew they'd lose did Howard mention nuclear power. If he had his way, he'd have the Brits test more nuclear bombs on Aussie soil.
@@turnerfamilyinoziBenjamin said the sixties Horward wasn’t in power then, before him was goof Whitlam,bob hawke and Keating.
Paul recession Keating , Albanese heading us in the same direction
Mr 17.5% needs to go back to bed.
We didn't want to hear what Keating said in the past and we sure don't want to hear anything this commo has to say now !
Who dusted off Paul Keating and all his Italian suits. Keating living in the 70s still and changing his mind depending on which way the wind blows.
At least the wind keeps blowing.
@@turnerfamilyinozi : Only out of Keatings rear end.
@@buildmotosykletist1987 There were no toll roads, which you hate, when Keating was in government.
@@turnerfamilyinozi : You claim: "ALL roads are communist".
@@buildmotosykletist1987 Is that you Trump? Incapable of talking without lying.
But you seemed to have ignored that there were no toll roads under Keating.
Chalmers finishing what Keating started a Banana republic for Australia.
Hollowing out the economy and offshoring real jobs in industry while Labor prefer to expand the public services and union-dominated care industries to add burdens on taxpayers
@@info88w11 You don't want adequate care for your elderly parents in a nursing home?
Already is a banana republic
People dont realize that society is built on energy, except those who wish to control societies by limiting that energy.
Chicken Little Albo...give us some renewal costings, he will forget them anyway ,rember unemployment, cash rate etc..😮
Keating was hated by most when in power, so many lost their homes, livelihoods and relationships because of the recession we had to have why would you even listen to him
Pull your head in Recession We Had To Have Keating ! Your a has been an really not much of a was.
Keating is irrelevant 🤮🤮
Keating and Kean must be related somewhere.
Nuclear is carbon frer...great idea to use it
The G G getting such a big pay rise is so transparent of Albos government buying support for this madness just goes to show there isn’t too many politicians who care are about this country and it’s people
Keating is the same cynical clown who gave us the recession we had to have, years ago.
Just shows you how spooked Labor are .
A traitor to the country
Did Labor have a permit to Exhume Keating.😆
He was decomposing & emitting ancient methane fart gas
That is so funny. 😂
Labor wants Australia to be , not the lucky country , not the smart country , but remain in the stoneage country . Renewables , Solar ,Wind , will never supply Base load power for industry .
As of 2023, Austria, with a population of only 9 million citizens, had 1426 wind turbines (all subsidised), yet they only deliver 11% of energy needs (60% of the energy comes from hydro). Apart from that fact, these turbines litter once-beautiful rural areas, kill birds, are expensive to build/maintain, and present a major end-of-life materials challange. That's why Australia needs nuclear power rather than Labor's Marxist rhetoric. You can do better than that Australia, lift the ban.
Albo: The "cheapest form of energy" but we don't have a costing.
You love your porkie pies. Yes, we do. $120 billion, mentioned many times. Brisbane Times, Renew Economy, The Australian, Energy Council, KPMG, OFAM, Energy Market Operator,...... a shitload of other sources you can easily check.
But of course, you won't.
He's given it many times, $122 billion. Many times.
@@indiathylane2158 : Blackout Bowen has already spent more than that.
Keating should keep his opinions to himself. He was a catastrophe as the treasurer and the PM.
It's past Keatings' bedtime😅
Fantastic commentary Chris, definitely.
People of Australia are smart enough to see Labor spinning going nucler on nuclear energy policy.
Why thay are so passion about it if that is a lunacy???
Labor will get back to reality whan the people kick tham out of power at next election, definitely. ❤️🤗🌎🐖💯🇦🇺👍🇺🇸 13:42
The conversation should be over. The people will now decide.
one thing albo is NOT good at is DETAIL, remember the 'detail' for the voice it was 60 / 40 in favour at the start, by the referendum it was 66 / 34 against? so every time albo opens his mouth all we hear is blah blah blah...and don't forget blah because blah is very important
Keating should keep his mouth shut, who really cares about what he thinks.
From the man who gave us " the recession we had to have " . Unemployment at nearly 11% and 18% interest rates .
Keating.... Labor's greatest hater.
God took the wrong one out of him and Hawke
The hysteria being created by Labor is such a great point earner for Dutton and his party.
Labor can't even say how much battery storage they need or how much it will cost every decade yet they throw stones at Dutton.
Are Labor politicians really that stupid
YES
There is no fool like an old fool. I wonder weather could he be the traitor that was mentioned by Australia ‘s secret service
I dont think they know anything about lithium batteries or the danger, fire & or explosions, or the toxicity or lethality if it finds its way into our drinking. water.
Who cares what The Lizard of Oz (Keating) thinks ?
Keating, why, the reason we all want nuclear is future...
Go Duttton!
Australia has been subsidizing solar energy since 2007 ... 17 years ..... what has happened to the price electricity in 17 years .... the cheapest form of energy
What has happened to price of fuel and gas?
Labor is desperate when they resort to Keating giving advice and abuse, he needs to go back to his Chinese speech writers for something of relevance.
Well aren't they bringing out the slurs and slander, and that tells me they are losing this one, and they know it.
Keating put us in a Recession lol he was one of the worst PM’s in history 👍
The same can be said for Keating Superannuation dream
Keating, the incompetent who gave us the 'recession we had to have' should take a leaf out of Julia Gillard's book. Opinion might vary on whether she was a good PM, but she has acted with grace since no longer being PM. Keating could learn some lessons from her.
Keating the man who started the death of Australian automakers
Who is that journalist who has dug an old interview he did with Matt Kean just a few years ago, where Kean is very effusive about the future of nuclear energy, saying exciting things where happening with nuclear science and energy with the development of modular nuclear power stations and it would be a great thing for Australia, is it pure gold for Dutton!! Oh what fun, the 'three stooges, Albo Bowen and Kean!
Clueless hasbeen, nuclear is the only way forward. Having lived close to a nuclear power plant I never had any concerns and used to water ski by the warm water outlet in winter. Australia is way too late on this.
they cant know the cost because they can not control money anymore , they need treasury notes for infrastructure projects
Keating ... mr j curve, the recession we had to have himself, live, in person !
He serves to remind me every recession in Australia is driven by ALP Unionist government.
Keating we had the 18.5 housing interest when you were in charge and we had a recision that we had to have.
Labor hasn’t changed every time they get in the clowns all stand up and up goes our taxes and up goes there salaries
Im surprised Paul Keating doesnt like the Nuclear Idea, after all, China has 55 Nuclear Power Plants currently producing clean and cheap power, And Im also surprised that keating doesnt critisize China for burning so much of our Coal, Bob Hawke thought Nuclear was a good Idea as well, maybe Mr Keating should open the other eye.
Keating is resembling Muppets 'Statler and Waldorf' these days.
Howard with Keating 😂
We don't need to; we already ABSORB 6 times more Co2 than we emit. Reference a CSIRO Report from 2014 by Dr. Vanessa Haverd of the CSIRO Atmospheric Research Division.
Follow the money. Reducing renewable rollout would mean some big businessmen would lose money so of course they would rubbish nuclear.
I had a friend who was a Purchasing officer for State Rail. He told me about all the graft and corruption that went on in government...
I just cant believe I ever voted for them ..
You finally woke up .
Renewables mean renewing every 10 years with lot of money going to Ccp aka Labor bosses
Why does the ABC turn off all comments to their CZcams propaganda posts when they're a publicly funded broadcaster?
I never liked Keating anyway. I always thought he was for the elite and quite arrogant.
Keating may have been a big shot once but he is just a has been looking for attention. Labor has in the past 40years all but buried Australian industry. GO AWAY!!!!
paul keating signed agenda 21/30 within the UN outside of constitutional law - there is no debate there is not 1 singular commonwealth government official in parliament
Keating would have had the same stream of bile for Peter Dutton if he had proposed a chicken farm.
I’m no fan of either side or nuclear but when the Australian people sacked Keating without remorse all those years ago we were kind of hoping to never hear from him again.
If Keating said nuclear is bad, that really means its a brilliant idea.just he never thought of it, 😅
No argument & personal abuse is Labor’s specialty.
Who in their right mind would listen to Keating, a member of the red shoe brigade.
I know exactly what you are talking about. However, many of us will be dead before the truth is revealed.
There should be a royal commission into the names of all those that have vested interest into renewables, I bet half of these politicians have their money grubbing hands indirectly into it, that's why they go all feral when someone mentions any other form of energy.
There is only one way to sort the chaff from the hay, and that is to remove government funding from the renewables industry and see who puts there hand up!
Keatings money must be involved in WEF. Not very Australian
Thank John Howard you're not in prison.
Mr Howard once famously played the Climate Delusion off against the Nuclear Power is Unsafe Delusion.
Nuclear solves green house gas problem...
I am so glad, that despite Sky Propaganda's best efforts, their viewers are starting to realise that climate change is a huge problem.
LIVING PROOF ALP energy transition preferring only wind solar and battery back-up technology and banning alternative superior technologies with much higher density energy output as in Nuclear was an ideological decision all along
Since when is some additional greenhouse gas a problem.
The carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels green the planet with increased agricultural yields, reduce winter heating costs, reduce deaths from hypothermia and postpone the next glacial maximum.
The main problem is the politicians screwing the public over it especially when our contribution is like pissing in the ocean. What a huge impact we are going to make to the environment while we go broke doing it 😂😂😂
@@johngeier8692 Hyperthermia?
Keating like a bad smell never goes away.
Put it out to tender from other nuclear powered countries to build it for discounted uranium
Keating said something else about Dutton a few years ago and god I always loved Dutton's response, 'Paul Keating inspired me to join the Liberal Party'. Just, perfect....
It's almost as if everyone forgets just how bad Keating was. I don't, and neither does my husband who ran a business at around the time interest rates were 18% during the 'recession we had to have'.
Even Hawke, for all you could say about him, was actually intelligent and had at least some common decency. He also could relate to the average Australian. Keating had none of that.
Howard,Keating stay out of the debate,please.
Howard is speaking sense
The mention of the word 'nuclear' has got the ALP to sit up and take notice!
Nobody cares what keating says apart from of course himself
Making us trust Peter Dutton more and more.
Keating is a demented old man - it’s time he gave the game away
It would be nice to know how much Labor is going to cost us with there renewable
Over the lifetime of a nuclear power station the entire wind turbine grid will need to be replaced about 4 times. "renewables" being the cheapest form of energy is demonstrably false.
Oh please get rid of this very scary government 🙄
the man should take a leaf from the actual nuclear physicist what Mr Kean is not saying, only the Albanese Rhetoric
Lost all respect for Keating. Once a power house, now a bitter and sour old man. Go play Bingo.
Has Australia's flag been replaced by the Indigenous and Torres Strait Islander flags???
The solar panels on my house roof generate massive amounts of energy. 5.6 mWh over the past five years.
PM must think the Sun only shines in Australia bwahahahahahah hahahah.
Your Wright no climate problems the only problem is the 2 major parties And there chuvavas barking till the last breth of there miserable days
The debate about nuclear energy, should not be political.