A Pythagorean Tuning Retune (and edit) of a 31 EDO retune (and arrangement) of a ditty from Celeste
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 08. 2024
- This is piece is from the video game Celeste (which I do not condone playing, nor video games in general).
The purpose of this video is to retune this piece based on the arrangement by Trebor Huang which he did in 31 EDO based off of the original version which is in 12 EDO.
You can hear his 31 edo arrangement here: • [31 EDO] My Dearest Fr...
I sought to see it the same or similar musical expressions could be obtained in true intonation by taking the same 31 edo arrangement and respelling and subsequently retuning the chords. I kept the rhythms and voicings of chords almost completely untouched except when necessary.
I think this video is one more piece of evidence in favor of Pythagorean tuning being the true or just intonation. As the only thing that is lost from the 31 edo version is the drunken clanging and buzz of the approximations of certain close harmonics. The Pythagorean version is substantially cleaner and clearer to the ear, with it's fair share of dissonance because of the chords chosen by the original composer and the 31 edo arranger , but the harmony does not have a falling sound as it does in 31 edo, but remains clear and present without conjuring notions of being out of tune like in 31 edo.
31 edo has many misspellings that are contrary to the naming conventions and theory history of notes and harmony, and as a result must employ unnatural accidentals and chords and chord spelling to try and muster many desired sounds that are all the more perfect in Pythagorean tuning with spellings that have been taught for over a thousand years.
More important than tuning is your standing with God. If you have not been born again by the Spirit of God, even Jesus Christ, then please, immediately look up the below verses and heed them as if your life depended upon it, for it most certainly does. God is offering life to you and forgiveness via the only way that it is possible, that is through his Son. Do not put off doing this, the KJV Bible is free online and is the most printed book in the history of the world.
1 Corinthians 15:1-8 KJV
Romans 10:2-13 KJV
Proverbs 30:4-6 KJV
John 14:6 KJV
John 14:22-24 KJV