Please bare with me as I try to figure this out while also, losing my fucking mind over these 2. WHAT DA FUCK?!?!?! Time stamps available for those who just want a straight-up reaction, and for those who want to watch me fade into madness :) As always, these are just MY opinions and my interpretation of the MV/Lyrics, if you feel differently, drop some knowledge in the comment section :)
I knew she got hurt but I thought it was her back, not her neck. Either way, pain for the sake of art. Damn, the dedication! AND THEN they did 'Naughty'!
These two have never disappointed when together. There's another project by them 'Naughty' and that's even crazier. Monster is still to date one of the most iconic duo releases from a group.. And im saying that as a not very hardcore reveluv so you know the impact
Context: this was released some months after “Psycho”. Promotions for “psycho” didn’t really happen because of Wendy’s injury days after “Psycho”s release and her year long recovery. “Monster” caught everyone off guard - Red Velvet concepts can be weird and embrace horror tropes, but “Monster” was darker - lyrically and visually - than other RV releases. And the choreo and the performance really served as a wake up call to the industry/audience that Irene was not ‘just’ the original visual. “Psycho” brought me into the fandom, “Monster” and “Naughty” made me a true believer. #Reveluv
Actually, they weren't planning on promoting Psycho in the first place because at that time, they still have their La Rouge concert in Japan which was cut short due to the pandemic.
@@enluviezen9343 You don't have your facts straight. Wendy got severely injured 3 days after Psycho dropped. That was why it wasn't promoted. They did their full month long tour of Japan, which they were already contractually obligated to do, but they did it without Wendy. SM immediately stated that there would be no full group promotions after the Japan tour until Wendy was completely healed. It was very soon after that that Covid hit.
@@riffgroove Again, they weren't supposed to promote Psycho because of their concert in Japan. How were they suppose to promote Psycho in Korea if they're in Japan?
@@enluviezen9343 Psycho dropped at the end of December. Their tour of Japan was in February. A full month later. They could have easily fit in a two week promotion period the way they usually do. Except they couldn't do that with Wendy in a hospital bed.
My theory... One light, 2 shadows in the lyrics refers to 2 egos (or psyches or w/e, I'm not a psychologist) inhabiting 1 body, both vying for control. Both trying to dominate the other. Seulgi's ego is the more aggressive, more overt of the two. Irene is more subtle and manipulative. You'll notice in the scene where they are puppeteering each other, when Seulgi is in control they are facing each other, but when Irene is in control, she's behind Seulgi. Seulgi's the one threatening with the gun, but Irene is the one who will sneak up on you when your sleeping. With this in mind, if you re-watch the video you'll notice quiet a few more references that support this theory. As you noticed, in the beginning of the video Seulgi is the head of the monster but by the end Irene has assumed control is she is now the head of the monster. So, as you said, over the course of the video there is a struggle to see who is in control but Seulgi finally gives in and Irene ends up being the one in control, the true monster, so to speak.
I remember when this came out and theorists went crazy :‘) I don‘t remember a lot but there was one that this was inspired by the novella „carmilla“ aka the first lesbian vampire story written in the 19th century. I never read the book so I can‘t say much to the accuracy or storyline but I still like that theory
i was able to find a pdf online of the book about a year ago! i think during a livestream when they were promoting monster was when they explained the concept and i would agree that the music video is more about that (what they said), although i think carmilla is a VERY strong underlying theme in mv. especially with the stained glass and greenery, it makes it look like the abandoned church/graveyard seen in the book. the white dresses in the bedroom also seems very similar!
I actually forgot how good this one is... Because the next one after this, Naughty, is even better. But man, is it entertaining to see your brain melt over this :D "I'm small but dangerous" literally. Irene is pretty short at 158 cm but the power she holds is tremendous.
all simply the best sub-unit that I have seen in several years / the concept is really good and their suits very well. the choreography is incredible, the songs perfect. have seen their maturity and their very concept evolves. Looks like the perfect mirror of A-PINK's sub-unit which was also very good. the 2 two sub-units have more mature concepts but RED VELVET is a bit darker than A-PINK which remains very colorful and fun.
There were soo many theories relating to this MV ! But he one that stuck out to me was the one with Lesbian Vampires that I read on Twt at that time :O
Yeah this is a monster of a song (I posted this comment at the beginning of your reaction. I should've expected that you would also make this pun. Their song Naughty is also a monster of a song, especially the dancing)
Very cool interpretation! I love it. Glad you finally got to see this glorious song & MV. The live stages of this song are amazing. As is “Naughty”! I can’t remember if you reacted to Irene & Seulgi’s other song or not, but it’s very dance heavy & probably one of the best dances ever.
First time I saw this video I had the impression that Seulgi was the monster. At the beginning you can see that Irene is sitting in the floor like a little kid and Seulgi is crawling down the mountain in four legs like a monster. I guess Seulgi possess Irene during much of her life, but eventually Irene cope with that and turn the tables. That's why Seulgi is at the back at the first monster but Irene is at the back at the last one. In my opinion this is not only a great concept and a great video but also the best song of that year.
Good review; I think this MV takes you along for the ride; is probably one of the most seductive, sexy, and dark MVs to come out of the Kpop industry. It is also an editing masterpiece. In conclusion, I think I could easily tolerate a little monster like Irene or Suelgi in my life, and yes; 'Naughty' is another classic definitely worth reviewing (Insane synchronized upper body choreography).
I just love this song, everything on it, the lyrics, the video...and the way you interpret it is just... I could not agree more.. Thank you for reacting to RV vids, you're one of my fave reactors tbh 🥰💙
Wow i loved your reaction! The depth of your explanations are soo wonderful to hear. I hope you have a chance to watch and review Naughty by Irene & Seulgi, Uncover by Seulgi, WOW THING by Seulgi, Chungha, Sin B, and Soyeon Also BAM BAM FT. SEULGI Who Are You
This whole subunit is on another level. I&S delivered one of the most unique and cohesive albums in terms of concept, music and choreography. Need you to react to naughty asap just to see how much out of the box they took that track especially on a visual level
This song and mv 🥵🥵🥵 and this is the edited version the original release date was delayed to edit out a scene that was too risqué!!! I wonder what it was!!!!!
I only have two K-pop albums and those are: Irene & Seulgi sub-unit's one and Wendy's solo! And the first one I bought was MONSTER ^^ because this is so epic. By saying that I'm meaning that this is legendary. MONSTER MV and choreo are insane and the lesbian vampire relationship to the Korean society was a HUGE shock and I loved it even more because of that. PS: You have to watch Naughty now then ;)
As I know this song the whole Was inspired by a book about a lesbian vampire ? I have read it once by someone elses comment section. And that one of them Seulgi is leading Irene on but it turns around that Irene does it back. I have read that like the year Monster came out so it is some time ago. I would recommend looking it up :D
If Red Velvet has a million fans, I'am one of them. If Red Velvet has ten fans, I'am one of them. If Red Velvet has only one fan, that is me. If Red Velvet has no fans, I'am dead. If the world is against Red Velvet, I' am against the world
I love how you didn't see this in a way what our lgbt friends see when watching this. I share the same sentiment. The meaning behind this is far beyond what normal people sees. The musically and everything is PERFECT! Irene & Seulgi is literally one 👑
If you want another kind of badass like concept from Red Velvet make sure to react to Bad Boy. It's one of their all time best songs, I would love to see you react to this. You're amazing, keep the good work !
Has someone already explained RV lore? I mean about the 9yo girl who plays with a doll called Irene which is her favourite among her collection of 5 and at night the doll awakens and controls the mind of the others? In the later MVs it seems Seul-Gi is designed by Irene or tries to overtake Irene in the mind controlling game/lore...
Lots have people have commented that Naughty, the other song from Irene and Seulgi, is crazier or better. I completely disagree. Naughty, is excellent for the chorography style called Tutting and it is without a doubt a good song but for me, nothing comes close to Monster. Whether it be the mixing, the musical and vocal arrangement, the dub step being introduced, the whole song is phenomenal. The video adds the visuals, to match the music. The chorography adds again to the overall impact. It is a 'tipple whammy' that I have not seen in any other K-pop song or video. However, i have barley scratched the surface of K-pop so I am aware there are other fantastic songs and MV's out there but as a relative newbie, there is nothing like your first time! If I were a student, I would make an entire thesis on the song and video. I have read from people far more versed in Red Velvet and the sub unit of Irene and Seulgi, that the video is based on a gothic novel called Carmilla. Here is the Wikipedia synopsis: Carmilla is an 1872 Gothic novella by Irish author Sheridan Le Fanu and one of the early works of vampire fiction, predating Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897) by 26 years. First published as a serial in The Dark Blue (1871-72), the story is narrated by a young woman preyed upon by a female vampire named Carmilla, later revealed to be Mircalla, Countess Karnstein (Carmilla is an anagram of Mircalla). So as you see, the video easily reflects this both lyrically and visually. Not that I am obsessed! 😀 Thank you for your thoughts, reaction and interpretation.
You should React to CLC - NO It is a song with a feminist message, of empowerment and full of pure and charismatic confidence that only CLC could give co-produced by Gidle's Soyeon and co-written by CLC Rapper Yeeun and Gidle's Rapper Soyeon, it's fantastic
Please bare with me as I try to figure this out while also, losing my fucking mind over these 2. WHAT DA FUCK?!?!?!
Time stamps available for those who just want a straight-up reaction, and for those who want to watch me fade into madness :)
As always, these are just MY opinions and my interpretation of the MV/Lyrics, if you feel differently, drop some knowledge in the comment section :)
YOUR FINALLY REACTINGTO THIS
Irène almost broke her neck during choreography training. they spent a very long time mastering it and their naughty choreography is even crazier.
I knew she got hurt but I thought it was her back, not her neck. Either way, pain for the sake of art. Damn, the dedication! AND THEN they did 'Naughty'!
Broke her back*
@@drisshansfreetime453 her back and neck watch they're mini series or reality show .
These two have never disappointed when together. There's another project by them 'Naughty' and that's even crazier. Monster is still to date one of the most iconic duo releases from a group.. And im saying that as a not very hardcore reveluv so you know the impact
Context: this was released some months after “Psycho”. Promotions for “psycho” didn’t really happen because of Wendy’s injury days after “Psycho”s release and her year long recovery.
“Monster” caught everyone off guard - Red Velvet concepts can be weird and embrace horror tropes, but “Monster” was darker - lyrically and visually - than other RV releases.
And the choreo and the performance really served as a wake up call to the industry/audience that Irene was not ‘just’ the original visual.
“Psycho” brought me into the fandom, “Monster” and “Naughty” made me a true believer.
#Reveluv
Talking about "darker..."
Read the lyrics to "Feel Good" off this album. Genuinely disturbing.
Actually, they weren't planning on promoting Psycho in the first place because at that time, they still have their La Rouge concert in Japan which was cut short due to the pandemic.
@@enluviezen9343 You don't have your facts straight.
Wendy got severely injured 3 days after Psycho dropped. That was why it wasn't promoted. They did their full month long tour of Japan, which they were already contractually obligated to do, but they did it without Wendy.
SM immediately stated that there would be no full group promotions after the Japan tour until Wendy was completely healed.
It was very soon after that that Covid hit.
@@riffgroove Again, they weren't supposed to promote Psycho because of their concert in Japan. How were they suppose to promote Psycho in Korea if they're in Japan?
@@enluviezen9343 Psycho dropped at the end of December.
Their tour of Japan was in February. A full month later.
They could have easily fit in a two week promotion period the way they usually do.
Except they couldn't do that with Wendy in a hospital bed.
My theory...
One light, 2 shadows in the lyrics refers to 2 egos (or psyches or w/e, I'm not a psychologist) inhabiting 1 body, both vying for control. Both trying to dominate the other.
Seulgi's ego is the more aggressive, more overt of the two. Irene is more subtle and manipulative. You'll notice in the scene where they are puppeteering each other, when Seulgi is in control they are facing each other, but when Irene is in control, she's behind Seulgi. Seulgi's the one threatening with the gun, but Irene is the one who will sneak up on you when your sleeping. With this in mind, if you re-watch the video you'll notice quiet a few more references that support this theory.
As you noticed, in the beginning of the video Seulgi is the head of the monster but by the end Irene has assumed control is she is now the head of the monster.
So, as you said, over the course of the video there is a struggle to see who is in control but Seulgi finally gives in and Irene ends up being the one in control, the true monster, so to speak.
no matter how many times i listen to this song it still hits as hard as the first listen
"Bad Boy" completely redefined the Girl-crush concept.
"Monster" carved it onto Mount Rushmore.
Apparently I am a sucker for talent + beauty + creepiness! This was amazing!
Indeed!!
I remember when this came out and theorists went crazy :‘) I don‘t remember a lot but there was one that this was inspired by the novella „carmilla“ aka the first lesbian vampire story written in the 19th century. I never read the book so I can‘t say much to the accuracy or storyline but I still like that theory
I have seen that particular story mentioned A LOT in comments for reactions to this video. I would LOVE to find that book and read it! :)
i was able to find a pdf online of the book about a year ago! i think during a livestream when they were promoting monster was when they explained the concept and i would agree that the music video is more about that (what they said), although i think carmilla is a VERY strong underlying theme in mv. especially with the stained glass and greenery, it makes it look like the abandoned church/graveyard seen in the book. the white dresses in the bedroom also seems very similar!
@@elaina560 COOL!
I actually forgot how good this one is... Because the next one after this, Naughty, is even better. But man, is it entertaining to see your brain melt over this :D
"I'm small but dangerous" literally. Irene is pretty short at 158 cm but the power she holds is tremendous.
all simply the best sub-unit that I have seen in several years / the concept is really good and their suits very well. the choreography is incredible, the songs perfect. have seen their maturity and their very concept evolves. Looks like the perfect mirror of A-PINK's sub-unit which was also very good. the 2 two sub-units have more mature concepts but RED VELVET is a bit darker than A-PINK which remains very colorful and fun.
There were soo many theories relating to this MV ! But he one that stuck out to me was the one with Lesbian Vampires that I read on Twt at that time :O
NAUGHTYY NEXT
Yeah this is a monster of a song
(I posted this comment at the beginning of your reaction. I should've expected that you would also make this pun.
Their song Naughty is also a monster of a song, especially the dancing)
I love this song. The whole EP is great but I was obsessed with this song when it came out.
Very cool interpretation! I love it. Glad you finally got to see this glorious song & MV. The live stages of this song are amazing. As is “Naughty”! I can’t remember if you reacted to Irene & Seulgi’s other song or not, but it’s very dance heavy & probably one of the best dances ever.
Ma boy.... always love to see new videos from you.
It's a little Masterpiece!! Just like Naughty Part 1 on bottom right of your screen. Please react. Thanks for appreciating Irene and Seulgi!
your interpretation was on point, or at least I remember most reveluvs saying similar things about this MV
Yep, that’s red velvet members alright. 🤩
Thank you for reacting to more Red Velvet!!!!
As always, I loved your analysis!
FINALLY
This MV will still be top 3... it's haunting, artistic, the choreo fits the lyrics...
First time I saw this video I had the impression that Seulgi was the monster. At the beginning you can see that Irene is sitting in the floor like a little kid and Seulgi is crawling down the mountain in four legs like a monster. I guess Seulgi possess Irene during much of her life, but eventually Irene cope with that and turn the tables. That's why Seulgi is at the back at the first monster but Irene is at the back at the last one. In my opinion this is not only a great concept and a great video but also the best song of that year.
yess monster
2:25 same lol same
Good review; I think this MV takes you along for the ride; is probably one of the most seductive, sexy, and dark MVs to come out of the Kpop industry. It is also an editing masterpiece. In conclusion, I think I could easily tolerate a little monster like Irene or Suelgi in my life, and yes; 'Naughty' is another classic definitely worth reviewing (Insane synchronized upper body choreography).
Masterpiece... ♥
I just love this song, everything on it, the lyrics, the video...and the way you interpret it is just...
I could not agree more..
Thank you for reacting to RV vids, you're one of my fave reactors tbh 🥰💙
Thank you so much Anne, you just made my day! 🖤🙏
The true queens! Irene and Seulgi are really special. Visual and vocal goddesses
WOW, I love your breakdown of the lyrics. Great job!
About the sampled songs it's from Freddy Krueger "One, Two, Freddy's Coming For You"
Dont forget to react to irene & seulgi naughty ep 1
YOU NEED TO REACT TO NAUGHTY IT’s unbelievable good and the choreography is insaneeeee
Wow i loved your reaction!
The depth of your explanations are soo wonderful to hear.
I hope you have a chance to watch and review Naughty by Irene & Seulgi,
Uncover by Seulgi,
WOW THING by Seulgi, Chungha, Sin B, and Soyeon
Also BAM BAM FT. SEULGI Who Are You
This whole subunit is on another level. I&S delivered one of the most unique and cohesive albums in terms of concept, music and choreography. Need you to react to naughty asap just to see how much out of the box they took that track especially on a visual level
i like the way u are breaking down the mv
This song and mv 🥵🥵🥵 and this is the edited version the original release date was delayed to edit out a scene that was too risqué!!! I wonder what it was!!!!!
as I've herd this song and MV is based on the book Carmilla. It seems very likely to be so, as the plot of the book is so obviously reflecting here.
I love this reaction!
VOCAL QUEENS ARE COMING!💖🧡💙💚💜
Yes. To all of this just… yes 👏🏼👏🏼
I only have two K-pop albums and those are: Irene & Seulgi sub-unit's one and Wendy's solo! And the first one I bought was MONSTER ^^ because this is so epic. By saying that I'm meaning that this is legendary. MONSTER MV and choreo are insane and the lesbian vampire relationship to the Korean society was a HUGE shock and I loved it even more because of that.
PS: You have to watch Naughty now then ;)
THIS IS THE BEST DUO IN KPOP!!! 💖
As I know this song the whole Was inspired by a book about a lesbian vampire ? I have read it once by someone elses comment section. And that one of them Seulgi is leading Irene on but it turns around that Irene does it back. I have read that like the year Monster came out so it is some time ago. I would recommend looking it up :D
You should watch and listen to Naughty it is AMAZING. I really luv the song and dance.
your face during the whole reaction:😶🤨😕😮🤨😮😶
If Red Velvet has a million fans, I'am one of them. If Red Velvet has ten fans, I'am one of them. If Red Velvet has only one fan, that is me. If Red Velvet has no fans, I'am dead. If the world is against Red Velvet, I' am against the world
I love how you didn't see this in a way what our lgbt friends see when watching this. I share the same sentiment. The meaning behind this is far beyond what normal people sees. The musically and everything is PERFECT! Irene & Seulgi is literally one 👑
The beat reminds me alot of Pony by Genuine
If you want another kind of badass like concept from Red Velvet make sure to react to Bad Boy. It's one of their all time best songs, I would love to see you react to this. You're amazing, keep the good work !
Reaction to seulgi and irene ep 1 naughty mv and ep 2 and ep 3.
Has someone already explained RV lore? I mean about the 9yo girl who plays with a doll called Irene which is her favourite among her collection of 5 and at night the doll awakens and controls the mind of the others? In the later MVs it seems Seul-Gi is designed by Irene or tries to overtake Irene in the mind controlling game/lore...
please react to irene and seulgi - naughty
Lots have people have commented that Naughty, the other song from Irene and Seulgi, is crazier or better. I completely disagree. Naughty, is excellent for the chorography style called Tutting and it is without a doubt a good song but for me, nothing comes close to Monster.
Whether it be the mixing, the musical and vocal arrangement, the dub step being introduced, the whole song is phenomenal. The video adds the visuals, to match the music. The chorography adds again to the overall impact. It is a 'tipple whammy' that I have not seen in any other K-pop song or video. However, i have barley scratched the surface of K-pop so I am aware there are other fantastic songs and MV's out there but as a relative newbie, there is nothing like your first time!
If I were a student, I would make an entire thesis on the song and video.
I have read from people far more versed in Red Velvet and the sub unit of Irene and Seulgi, that the video is based on a gothic novel called Carmilla. Here is the Wikipedia synopsis:
Carmilla is an 1872 Gothic novella by Irish author Sheridan Le Fanu and one of the early works of vampire fiction, predating Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897) by 26 years. First published as a serial in The Dark Blue (1871-72), the story is narrated by a young woman preyed upon by a female vampire named Carmilla, later revealed to be Mircalla, Countess Karnstein (Carmilla is an anagram of Mircalla).
So as you see, the video easily reflects this both lyrically and visually.
Not that I am obsessed! 😀
Thank you for your thoughts, reaction and interpretation.
recomendación personal, happiness de red velvet
💖💛
You should React to CLC - NO
It is a song with a feminist message, of empowerment and full of pure and charismatic confidence that only CLC could give
co-produced by Gidle's Soyeon and co-written by CLC Rapper Yeeun and Gidle's Rapper Soyeon, it's fantastic
Please react to DUMB DUMB and One of these nights 🤗🤗🤗
Whoever made this beat has issues, in a good way.
Word!
Please react to "be free" by KB and "begin" by yoojung from onlyoneof
..........?