Accession of Junagarh to Pakistan and the the Kashmir Dispute
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
- #ishtiaqahmed
#indiahistory
#pakistanindiannews
#indiapakistanborder
#indianvlogger
#pakistani
#indianyoutuber
#pakistanifamousyoutubers
#indiafacts
#pakistannews
#indialegends
#indianmusic
#indiapakwars
#partition
#punjabi
In this episode Prof. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed talks to Jabraan Shahid on the implications of accepting the accession of Junagarh for the Kashmir Issue. We also discuss the case of Kalat State.
Sir
Some people in Pakistan have realized mistakes of past and it is time to learn from history and move forward for peace and harmony for better future. Respect from India
Prof. sb apka ihsaan hai for narrating and correcting the history that we know in Pak. We made blunders from day 1 and till now regarding handling India and Kashmir. Pak needs to move on and be in better terms with India, there is no other option.
Very little discussion regarding Accession of Junagarh
जहाँ हुए बलिदान मुख़र्जी
वो कश्मीर हमारा हैं, वो सारा का सारा हैं🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳
Tribal invaded on 22nd October 1947.
Maharaja signed Instrument of Accession on 26 October 1947 and Indian forces landed at Srinagar Airport on October 27, 1947.
Amazing wealth of historical insights. Love to listen the conversation
A case was filed against mushtaq gurmani by I think ayub khan regime As a some personal grievance The main allegation Against was him that he Advised nawab of bahawalpur AS a prime minister of bahawalpur to join India in which nawab sb went to high court and recorded his statement never such a advised was given by gurmani all allegations were baseless and He was acquitted from That case
Dr Sahab waiting eagerly for your Vedios on History and Lahore 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Pak a is like haleem, when USSR broke, why can't Pak?
England and Germany become friends why we cannot
Inshallah friendship hogi aik din dono countries mn
England and Germany both are liberal democracies run primarily by Governments that support rationality, intellectualism,civil rights and so on.
They have invested so much in education(liberal, secular, scientific) that now demagogues are not found in their polity hence little rhetorics, no chest thumping, no jingoism, no knee jerk reactions.
A large number of their population(esp. Youth) don't associate themselves with any religion.
You are comparing Indo-Pak with two very different countries.
You can choose Asian countries for comparisons don't jump to Western Europe.
We cannot be compared to countries like Germany, France, UK.
Shree istaq sir how did benifitted zinnaha to India ? I always enjoy you fruitful videos such eye opening thank you so much from India
Very educational, thank you.
Sir really liked ur videos.. Balochistan accession p bhi ek video kare plz
Misleading title. He doesn't address junagadh, it is only Kashmir.
🙏🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sir bahawalpur never Intended to join India Nawab of bahawalpur declined many offers by pandit jawaharlal nehru Sister of pandit jawaharlal came As a special envoy to bahawalpur her All offers were rejected by Nawab sb famous quote of nawab of bahawalpur sir sadiq Muhammad khan Abbasi said
Shareef Admi hamesha ghar k samne wale darwazay se dakhil hota hai or Mera Darwaza Pakistan ki Taraf khulta hai
It was Gurmani not the Nawab Sahib who sent feelers. MORE IMPORTANTLY, THE NAWAB SAHIB DECLARED HIMSELF INDEPENDENT ON 15 AUGUST BUT WAS MADE TO CHANGE HIS MIND. Please refer to the book by Dr Yaqoob Bangash, A Princely Affair, where he has mentioned that.
Sir junagadh and manavadar
Sir, balochistan history please share in a video.
The Treaty of Amritsar
The British demanded payment of 15 million rupees[11] (one and a half crore) as reparations for the cost of the war. As the Lahore Government was unable to pay the whole of this sum immediately, it ceded some of the territories mentioned above, including Hazara and Kashmir, as equivalent to 10 million rupees (one crore). The Maharaja was also required to pay 6 million rupees (60 lakhs) immediately.[12]
The British then sold Kashmir to the Raja of Jammu, Gulab Singh, for 7.5 million rupees (75 lakhs). The treaty of sale was concluded on 16 March 1846, in the Treaty of Amritsar and signed by Gulab Singh, Hardinge, Currie and Lawrence.[13] Gulab Singh thus became the founder and first Maharaja of the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir.
Jammu massacre took place on November 6, 1947.
Do you think that Pak is going to complete 100 yrs? I don't think so, no chance, Pakhtoonishtan, Sindhudesh, Balochistan, Kashmir on the road. 🤭😂🤣
😂🤣
I know that you are a historian, and you do not wish to take sides or offer solutions to the problems that are raised. The word for History in Sanskrit is Iti Hasa i.e. this is the way it happened. Like Akira Kurosawa's Rashomon, the same incident seen by four different persons, have four different interpretations. Intellectuals like you on both sides of the border must join together and campaign to have LOC ass the effective border. There does not seem to be any other solution. Historians like you tell what happened, but there are no solutions to the "mistakes" of the past. This constant anti india rhetoric in Pakistan over Kashmir does nobody ay good. Musharraf is on record saying if Kashmir is not there, we will find some other problem.
There are vested interest of our elite esp when it comes to Kashmire. We, the people want peace and progress on both sides of the border.
Interesting the tasadud by Muslims to hindu and Sikhs are normal but tasadud by hindus to Muslims in jammu is boardly high lighted in your discussion.
Why such baisness
He is very neutral.. jammu m uspe jada jor isliye diya gya bcoz hme JAMMU k bare m nhi btaya jata and second thing JAMMU m jo huaa wo state sponsered tha whereas jo Punch m huaa wo ex army k logo ne kiya..
Two German become one Germany why we cannot
Sikhs will do this
GERMANY IS INDUSTRIAL NATION .
German people didn't want to be separated.
सुभाष चंद्र बोस पर कार्यक्रम करें