Trek Roscoe 8, The Good, The Bad & The Ugly - 6 month review.
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 06. 2024
- After owning the Roscoe for 6 months I have picked up a few niggles and decided to do a review of the things I love, the small irritations and the outright annoying issues of this Trail bike.
- Sport
Good review, your bad list is mostly bike maintenance...
1- dropper issue, after wiping the bike use some suspension spray on the dropper post.
2- Spongy brake- depending on the conditions you may have not been modulating and they overheated or your body position is too far forward. You may need the reservoirs top off or a fine adjustment.
3- derailleur issues- probably a limit screw+cable stretch issue.
4- You could run a higher pressure on the road, use a different tire with a different compound, or get a set of 29er’s?
5- bike rack issue- use a hitch mounted bike rack?
6- Pedals- does anyone actually use the pedals that come with a bike? Lol
Also, scratches- it’s a more recent Trek paint issue, my older Treks still look pristine
The derailuer issue probably has to do with your limit screw. There are two screws that limit how far up and down the derailuer can move. Adjust the upper one and you should be fine.
My nx was garbage. Took it to my local bike shop and they replaced it for an sx for free
@@jinsungpark6410 the sx is the model below nx
@@jinsungpark6410 you downgraded. The nx is a solid derailleur, you just need to set it up correctly. That wasn’t very cool of the shop to do that.
@@Iheartdgd oops. I know my derailleur was an sx but they upgraded to nx my mistake
@@jinsungpark6410 ah, then in that case that was very cool of them! Safe travels my friend.
Had a roscoe a few years back but after watching your reviews I've gone back picked up my new bike yesterday and loved it . Thank you
I was thinking this would only cool one room, but it does well at cooling the entire floor.
Great video. I agree with the bad points. I have a Roscoe 6 2021 for commuting to work, It's great on the trails but the lack of top speed is so frustrating!
Great video. I have also had mine 6 months, however I ugly you missed is the bottom bracket. Had to replace mine after 800 miles of wet, dirty winter - just lets a great bike down having to change it that soon
I recently upgraded to the trek roscoe 8 2021 in the black /marigold fade. Such an amazing bike and gives me so much more confidence on the trails than my old 2018 specialized pitch sport did. Keep uploading those videos, much appreciated 👍🏻
Yes, that's what I find as well, confidence!
Good pointers. I just ordered mine and it will be here in August. Can't wait. I think i might put a clear wrap on mine
I've got the 2020 version of this bike and it's nearly identical. I've put it through it's paces in AZ, Texas, Oklahoma, and Arkansas. It's performed very well in most circumstances. When I got it I was weighing in around 285 lbs. This is a tad heavy for this bike but it handled it pretty well. I'm relatively new so I'm not doing jumps on it... yet... but by the time I do, I should be nearly half the man I started out on it as I'm over 20lbs lighter thanks in part to the exercise I get riding this thing.
The one thing I've noticed after a year of riding in all sorts of conditions is that the cassette seems to be wearing a bit. Some of the cogs are already creating clicking sounds. I lubricate nearly every time I go out and clean the bike regularly so I don't think it's that. But this slight clicking equates to the occasional pop when trying to change gears going up hill. And yes, I not only have had it adjusted professionally, I personally did a better job than my LBS did, yet it still does it. After careful inspection I've noticed some of the teeth are not perfectly straight. So I'm already considering upgrading the cassette and derailleur.
Oh and those original pedals were awful. They were exactly the same quality of pedal as what I had on my GT Aggressor Pro... which is pretty sad. Some RaceFace pedals weren't that big of an investment and now I have the shin scars like everyone else....... 😁
Over all, I'd buy this bike again. Only paid $1350 for it last summer during the peak of the bike buying craze so I can't complain!
And yes, it scratches bad. I often have to store it with my wife's bike and you can tell where our bikes rub each other even though we're super careful. This is not to mention the scratching from bumps and bruises when out and about... and no, I've never actually crashed it yet.
Man... that area looks stunning!
I see you rockin GMBN race top! nice!
My Marlin 7 scratched up really quickly, doesn’t put me off I still love it.. the Roscoe is my next upgrade....
That was exactly my upgrade 2.5 years ago hahaha
@@samy_akrouh do the chunky tyres make it harder to ride on roads ?
@@harrywilliams5859 i had one, not really it feels nice even on roads
Going from an entry level cross country bike to the Roscoe is a great feeling, you're going to love it :)
@@harrywilliams5859 I just upgraded from a marlin 5 to the Roscoe 6. The marlin has better acceleration and top speed on pavement but the Roscoe is superior on trails and climbing trails and pavement too. The thicker tires build momentum once you get them going.
Awesome video and list. I just picked up a black 2021 last week and I’m in love. Stunning bike. I’m also a beginner at mountain biking but wanted to start with a good hard tail and work my way up.
Let us know how you get on! Trusting you will have an absolute blast!!
I have a 2019 Roscoe 8 and I find the brakes to be outstanding. My only complaint so far is the paint seems fragile.Great review!
Good run through, man. Appreciate the review. I noticed you were wearing ON shoes. How are those on MTB rides? Which model did you get?
I recently got a Trek X-calibre 7 as I wanted something that could do a bit of everything. Light single track, commute, carrying luggage on racks etc. I have also had problems getting mine to shift into the lowest gear and it’s a 46T ring. It just seems too big! Mine is the same blue/ grey scheme and I was also surprised how easily it scratched and chipped. Compared to my 2013 trek hard tail it has less scratches after multiple years use. I am keen to get a roscoe 8 to run next to the x-calibre for heavier trail use and bike packing. Having the matching paint will look pretty cool! Thanks for sharing
I had the same problem with mounting my bike on my bike rack until I bought the Thule Frame Adapter. I would recommend you get one. Game changer.
Bought a trek Roscoe 8 2018 (grey)
Replaced rear hub, brakes, seat, bars, stem, pedals, forks, and drivetrain to shimano slx.
I like the bike now 👍🏼
For the derailer not going to the largest cog, get it fixed at your trek shop. It probably needs to be tuned.
Great Review! I have the Roscoe 6 (2021), which I love, but hated the fork that came with it. I have just upgraded the fork to the Rockshox Reba RL, which changes this bike from great to AWESOME! Thanks and new subscriber...
Same here! I put a Rockshox Revelation on and it completely transformed the bike!
I love my 2022, even tho it’s not the new design frame, I’m not a super hero, the bike still outclasses my abilities.
I put a Marzocchi Z2 on it, tubeless tires and good pedals.
This thing climbs and descends like buttah, and smooths out all but the roughest desert sections, and even then, with 13-15 psi out back and 18-19 up front (Minions), it cushions real nice 😊
Sure it sucks on the pavement, but did I get this bike for pavement?? Hell no!
Nice review
I upgraded to a Trek stache 7, 2-1/2 years ago , and iv upgraded everything over the years and ill never let go , its so much fun
Stache great bike , look after that beast 3.0 tyres the king of trail hard tails
Hey Rookie! How do those minimalist mudguards work for you? Also, do you do any bikepacking? Would be curious how well it would do in that capacity. Thank you!!!
I just got my 2021 Specialized Fuse 27.5+ a week ago. Hey, what brand are your mudguards?
Thank you for a great review. I am looking into getting one of these bike and to have a review done by someone who is also on the Isle of Man that is great.
I have a 2020 Roscoe 8. My first MTB and I love it. The thing is a beast
tha care of this Sram derailleur, it can break easly
@@Miri50 My wife managed to bend hers fairly quickly. I'm starting to think we might need to upgrade the derailleurs and cassette pretty soon. It used to be so smooth but even mine, which is not bent, is starting to make noise. Have to figure out what will fit best on this setup.
Thank you so much, you helped me a lot to chose my bike and i think although there are a few bad things i will buy it.
Keep it up and greetings fromm Germany🇩🇪
All good points, I have Silverback Trail that is very similar. Mid fat tires really are slow on gravel roads. Fixed the brakes by putting 203mm rotor on front, moving the 180mm to the rear, and paying particular attention to bleeding and topping up fluid. The ugly you missed was no 148 boost rear.
@@Wetdogsmells Think about it. Depends on the situation. For high end brakes with heaps of power, you may not notice any different. On these low end brakes you certainly do, and that is my experience. Also, why do manufacturers put different size rotors front and rear, then?
I had the Roscoe 8 for about 2 years now and had them convert it to tubeless before I took delivery. My dropper post been fine so far. Brakes are adequate for the area I ride. Gear changes, so so. Needs a new chain already. Handle bars always seemed too wide for my liking. Makes the bike uncomfortable and hard to get around tight spaces. I plan someday to have them shorten them up. Bike seems "heavy" to me. Like I'm peddling a tractor trailer up the hill. But that gives me more exercise (workout). The tires are nice and bike performs well on most all terrains. Had it on dirt, mud and snow with good luck. On ice, it didn't do so good, but everything would have had trouble on that trail that day.
Good review. I think the main thing with any bike is "Do you really ride it?". If you can honestly answer "yes" then its a good bike for you.
Yes, great point Daniel! That’s the bottom line. Do you like the bike!
Great review! I went from the Marlin 6 to the Top Fuel 7. Love it- Roscoe is amazing as well
The SRAM Derailleur you have has a known spring tension issue that prevents you from shifting into the biggest cog. You could try to get it replaced via warranty. Though if you had the components many people just replace it with Shimano Deore or go up a level with SRAM.
I have a 2020 purple Roscoe 8 and orange pedals, grips and helmet just like you.
I have upgraded recently handle bar(40mm rised) , BSA bb with Sram NX eagle dub crank set (165mm) and Line Comp 40 rear wheel with 3 extra paws
I absolutely love this bike
I do agree with brake power but I realized that my brake levers was close to grips so I changed both levers to move further from grips and now I feel my bike's brake power is much much stronger
The Ugly: 141 QR on rear
I have a 2020 Roscoe 8 and love it. I swapped out the bar and stem for a set of Race Face 35's in 780mm wide and 40mm length, much better handling now.
My bad: keep an eye on the fork pressure, if you notice a significant decrease, quit riding and have you local bike shop notify Sram. Mine and apparently many others had faulty internal seals and eventually the negative chamber will have a positive pressure and blow out the wiper seal.
About the slow dropper, check the set screw on the lever, mine had come loose and the cable had slipped.
That’s super helpful!! Thanks John!!
Your rear mech saying not hitting the 50T it's just basically gear cable tension, as after a few rides the cable will stretch, just dial it in and get the tension right 😉🤟 I have the Trek Roscoe 7 and love it, but just wished the hubs were sealed bearings as I stripped mine down and greased them and set them properly, as when I got mine I was on Trek Roscoe group page on Facebook, and there were big issues on there hubs , failing after 3 to 6 weeks, so when I got mine I checked the spindles and found that front and rear were so tight they wouldn't turn at all.. and that literally they'd fail after a week, so luckily me being in the know how to fix these issues, sorted them as on checking them , they had no grease either .. so sorted with high performance grease for bearings and been running smoothly since July last year . 👌 great vid and good info especially for beginners... dropper post I usually add some grease inside the lock ring , unscrew it of then add some grease underneath it and screw it back on .. this stops grime getting in and keeps it running smooth 😎👌
I got a 2021 Roscoe 7 and the hub spindles were also insanely tight. I can’t believe a shop assembling these bikes wouldn’t notice or care to properly tension the bearings like that.
good to now about the Hub, I want to change it in my Roscoe some time, any info about thos awful SRAM NX derailleur, I'am asking becouse after first ride shifting completly gave up, and after changing to Sram GX Derailleur, it is awesome
I'm between the roscoe 7 and the specialized Fuse 27.5. I use the bike to hit the trails but also to commute, so I'm not completely sure what is the best. Personally, I like the Fuse (esthetically), but doesn't have air suspension and only is 9 speeds with 27.5 wheels. As you said, the roscoe is not a commute bike because of its wider tires, but for the price, the roscoe has much better components
Picking up one tommorow just checking out the reviews
Wouldn't it have made more sense doing reviews then decide on the purchases ?
I'm a little surprised you didn't go with SPD peddles/shoes. They really help getting my Roscoe up some very steep hills. With that super granny gear and SPD's, it will nearly climb a tree. I once forgot my bike shoes and couldn't even make it up this one steep short hill.
Just ordered the 8. Unfortunately not arriving until January. But stoked nonetheless!!!!!!
I used to own a Giant Talon 0 2014 27.5 till about 2 days ago - it was stolen in Bristol ☹
Now looking at a Roscoe 8 and having a look at reviews 👍🏽
Have them same bike 2023 model and the tires are so slow on tarmac, thinking of changing the front sprocket and getting downhill tires.
Ordered one Oct 2021, original delivery date march 2021. Trek kept pushing the delivery date forward 4 times, and after promising the 4th delivery date would really be met. Trek decided to stop producing the 2021 model and cancelled my order two weeks ago. Without letting me know of course, had to inform at the bikeshop if the bike was finally delivered...and this was the news they gave me. Not so nice.
I own a 2019 Roscoe 8 and recently purchased a 2021 Roscoe 8 for my son. The bikes are very playful and fun both on trails and local street riding.
Is there a difference between the 2019 & 2021 models?
@B2theM 1 i hit 38km/h with mine on flat
The dropper, brake, shifting issues you have are mechanical faults arguably on setup of the bike. The shot of your dropper post coming up for instance is very slow. Get it a proper tune and enjoy the bike.
That’s helpful. Thank you!
Hi. I have Xcaliber 8. I dont have the red ring in fork suspension. Do you have? How do you adjust the fork? Only with pump and down with turtle?
I have just ordered a Roscoe 6 so can’t wait.
Where in SA are you from?
Beware the awful rear hub. It's crap and will break.
I went for the roscoe 7 while it was available, this video was one of the defining reasons so props where its due.
I hope you enjoy that Roscoe like crazy!
@@mtbrookie596 It's dope especially after adding some mudguards, nukeproof pedals and a little air to the forks just gotta get over that saddle sore and I'll be sweet 😎
Has your rear hub broke yet?
I love this bike. I ride a ton of urban areas and it goes down staircases with ease
Hi mate what type of mudguards do u have ?
I’ve the same bike but I did upgrade the handle bars peddles and grips. The bike is amazing and definitely worth the money.
What handlebars did you get?
If you fall off it’s going to scratch that’s a no brainier.
The positives totally agree, negatives-and ugly don’t bother with them.
It’s a great bike 👍
Could someone with more knowledge tell me if there is a possibilty to change the tyres for sometimes more suitable for commuting? I'd love to get this bike but I want to do both rough terrain and commuting on asphalt.
I have a 13 miles commute each way from south London to east London. considering the road condition, the shortcuts, the traffic, the canals, these tires are absolutely fine. the bike runs smoothly. But if you are not sure you can always find suitable 2.8 road tyres on CRC
Moto X 2.8 are perfect
I'm also an IOM rider. I have the 2018/19 Roscoe 8 with the matt grey colour scheme. The paintwork was disappointingly fragile on that too. I think most of the points you raised as "bad" are likely to be set up or maintenance issues.
Hola..amigo
Compré una roscoe 8..es espectacular....me encanta la comodidad y el diseño..😍
Saludos desde México
Im still trying to buy a matte black one somewhere
See I want the 2022 Roscoe 6 29er but the colors r not for me. I love that blue you got so much, I wish it was available in that. I would even consider spending the big money for the roscoe 8 just to get the blue but that one does not have the rack mounting holes. Rack mounting holes r super important for me, as I would like to do like short 5-10 mile commutes to work sometimes. Such a shame, I think even the purple is nice but I keep my bikes for 10+ years, I would like to LOVE the color instead of just "meh".
Thanks for the video, a friend might buy one... I love my Trek Slash 8 2019... try a dually... cant go back...! :)
Minor point with #4... I don't think the shifter is a 'Shimano SRAM NX Eagle'.
Hi What size are you riding and also how tall are you ? I am 183cm and riding the 21.5inch XL
Hi I am also 183cm but my local bike store measured me up for the L frame!? Seems to be going ok...
@@mtbrookie596 Thanks for letting me know. I just feel that I look big on my bike... so im not sure but the bike fit feels perfect.
By far the biggest problem having owned one for a year and a half is the the quick release rear dropouts at the back. It’s an outdated standard and a weird combination with the boost spacing that causes a lot of problems with the overall stiffness of the back end. Still a great bike though
I believe the 2022 has a through axle and 140mm travel. I have a 2022 X Caliber and the QR in back is my only real gripe, maybe 100mm travel on my X Caliber could be better but forks are so expensive.
X Caliber 8
What kind of grips do you use?
You know you can fit 29 wheels as standard
I agree with most of your points
Agree about the paint. I’ve got the (2018?) grey version, and the paint on inner side of chain stays rubbed off on my second ride from just a bit of mud stuck on sides of tyre. Also the rear hub is shit to be honest. There’s clear movement on the rear axle, no way to adjust. Even my lbs recommended to upgrade to Hope. Love the bike tho
Did TREK ever respond to the "scratches easily" issue? Your opinion?
Didn’t hear a thing!!
What is “Shimano/S-Ram NX Eagle”?
Where did you get you Captain America shield from?
Use this search criteria in Amazon: Bicycle Headset Top Cap Cover with Bolt 1 1/8", Bike Stem Cap Aluminium Alloy Star Design Captain America
Brake awesome mt500 , one finger app and powerful have you contaminated the brakes .. try fork lube / cleaner on the dropper post . Gears try adjust the barrel on the shifter - seem most your issues my be learning to maintain your bike ... maintenance is just as important as learning to ride all best
on my Roscoe I got rid of that NX Derailleur(never again buying a bike with those) , bought a GX, and it's a gamechnger, next are those really bad breaks
OK, so that's been my biggest concern. Did you have to replace your cassette too? Mine is starting to have very slightly bent teeth and makes a very quiet clicking noise even when pedaling by hand on the rack. I'm not happy with the non-adjustable clutch on the NX either... seems it wouldn't have been that hard to make it adjustable.
@@compunomad1399 nah, all Sram stuff works together. But I will change hub and cassette eventually
We got new cradles for our traditional bike rack
I love this bike, rode about 4000km on it and I feel is the most comfortable and fun hard tail mountain bike I have had for the last 20 years. Only negative is the chainring which is too small with 30 teeth so Max. Comfortable pedalling is about 32km/h.
I've noticed this speed thing. Some folks say it's the tires, but it seemed like no matter how much effort I put in to, I could only go so fast on the flat.
@@compunomad1399 a 32 teeth chainring and narrower + lower roughness tyres should help to gain up to 5km/h on flat.
has anyone got any like like paint imperfection like tiny little air bubbbles or something like that because my trke rosoce 6 has it
is it worth it to get this or spend the extra money to get the fuel 5??
Spend the extra... BB and hubs will need replacing within 200 mile
I pick Giant Fathom 1 (2021)
Paint is terrible. Such a nice teal color on my Roscoe 7 2020 is chipped and scratched everywhere. If that bothers you well be prepared. I have 15 years old TREK 3700 just brushed aluminum color and it looks newer that my Roscoe... Rear hub boost 141 is another pain. Seat on the dropper post is wiggling around...Impossible to fix. Despite that Roscoe 7 and 8 are good and capable bikes. Would not recommend Roscoe 6. For not so large money surplus you will get way better bike.
My 2018 R8 managed my 6'3 350lb (at the time of buying) wit ease....Great bike.... shite hubs and BB
Have the same bike lovely bike to ride just the paintwork scratching so easily is a bummer wouldn’t put me of it tho 👌😁
Is this roscoe 8 2022 or 2021?
Which dropper did you purchase for this bike? I'm in the US so I believe this is the same bike as the Trek Marlin 8.
Did you watch the video?
Is a Roscoe 8 it came with it
Have rosco 8 love it
Could someone make me a recommendation, I don't know whether to buy Roscoe 8 or Marin SAN QUENTIN 3
I have an SQ2 and it is a phenomenal bike. Same frame as the SQ3 but obviously 3 has upgraded parts. The roscoe is a good bike too, it’s honestly up to personal preference. Me personally, I would go with the Marin, you could even get an SQ2 and upgrade it yourself, although the 3 comes with a RockShox revelation which is a phenom fork, but I also really dig the recon that came on mine. Good luck and good riding brother.
@@Iheartdgd thanks !!! I decided the sq3. It's a a really good frame. I love that bike !!!!
@@cristhianarturosalcedogarc2651 good for you buddy, shred on my man :)
Dude the shifting to top gear is not a niggle just have it set up , when you realise how easy it is it will annoy you ,, don’t forget this is something you’ll have to do owning any bike
What is the frame made from?
Trek calls it Alpha Aluminium!!
What size frame? And how tall are you?
I'm 6"2 and xl is perfect
I went into the Trek store yesterday in Brisbane, Australia to see if they have a Roscoe 7... They said next shipment is in 7 MONTHS :(
I have a 2021 roscoe 8 hardtail I luv it very nice bike cross country bike😎
What is your bike testing on
SHOULD I GET TREK MARLIN 6, 7 OR THIS ROSCOE 8?
I think you won’t regret it if your budget can stretch to the Roscoe 8!!!
you can easly get Marilin with shimano Deore derailleur, buy a dropper post, and the value should be same
I wonder if he knows it’s tubeless READY and not tubeless, unless he has converted it.
I wondered that same thing... my LBS converted it as part of the sale.
Changing problem isn’t to do with the bike just how u set it up
Is this bike good for long distance?
Not for road
Very good.... i use for bike packing, a tad heavy when fully loaded but comfort is 2nd to non,
Thanks
Best I find is the intro,knee down in front your baby,,,,😁👍
Is this bike good as a xc bike?
Nonono
2020 roscoe 7, you forgot the hub and bb issues boeta
The SRAM SX and NX drivetrains are garbage. I had a trek Roscoe 7 and that was my biggest complaint. I adjusted them, had them retuned and replaced, never worked worth a shit. Do yourself a favor and go shimano if you’re on a budget, they are made much better.
Says gear shifts smooth as butter, then says it does not shift all the way to the first gear!!!!!!!!!
So I'm other words there's nothing wrong with it other than maintenance and poor setup issues
Giant fathom 29
🤟🏼🤟🏼🤟🏼
Shimano sram shifters lol 😆
That's where I stopped watching