💥BREAKING💥Karen Read: CW does NOT want to Q Jurors re: acquittals💥w/ Mark Bederow, Esq.
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- The Commonwealth has filed Opposition to Defendant's Post-Trial Motion to Dismiss regarding the Jurors who have come forward indicating the jury had reached a unanimous acquittal on Counts 1 & 3, and were only deadlocked with regard to Count 2, and it's a doozy! Attorney Mark Bederow joins to dissect & discuss!
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @attorneymelanielittle
WAYS TO SUPPORT:
VENMO: www.venmo.com/...
BUY ME A MATCHA: www.buymeacoff...
CASH APP : cash.app/$Atty...
#karenread #johnokeefe #norfolkcounty #freekarenread #canton #massachusetts #commonwealth #justiceforjohnokeefe #fbi #bostonglobe #aclu #firstamendment #mistrial
#lawyerreacts #lawyer #legalanalysis #truecrime #law #lawtube #crime #criminallaw
I have been receiving so many inquiries regarding my on-camera makeup, skincare and haircare that I have listed them all in my
AMAZON STOREFRONT: www.amazon.com...
WARNING: Some of these products may be life-changing. You're welcome. Oh, and I may earn commissions if you happen to buy anything.
FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL: Instagram: / the.melanie.little
MY IMDb: www.imdb.me/me...
NOT LEGAL ADVICE: This video is made solely for the purpose of commentary for entertainment and educational purposes, and no attorney -client relationship is created through comments or interaction with this channel. All suspects are deemed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
She acted as if it all was a huge inconvenience for HER. Absolutely disgusting for a judge to act the way she did
Agree. This judge is a disgrace to the bench. Her judgement is too poor to be considered the honorable bev
She kept rushing the defense.
Yes!! It was just a woman's life on the line. How dare everyone who took this serious!! 🙄 Bev is just the worst!! She's a disgusting human being.
Ditto to all the above.
PETITION NEEDED SACK THE JUDGE
this is corruption, not crankiness, not just being uncaring.
100%. And it just so happens that her brother who is a lawyer represented Chris Albert in a hit and run manslaughter case back in ‘94. And during a correspondence with Aiden Kearney, a.k.a. turtleboy, one of the McCabe’s said he had a direct line to the judge and referred to her as Auntie Bev.
I agree. I am very, very interested to see if Auntie Bev retires in the next few months. That's seemingly the go-to move of apparently corrupt government employees. Retire with their precious pensions before they have a chance to lose them. It's the most aggravating thing to witness and seems to happen a lot. Kinda like Brian Albert. He gets $8k a month according to the Canton city payroll.. a 6 figure yearly income until he kicks the bucket. Frustrating.
They remained silent bc the judge talked right up to the point where she said “Mistrial, have a nice day.” She didn’t even take a breath. So shady!!!!! Grrr.😖
Yeah, I went back & watched it. There was no opportunity for the CW or defense to say anything. It was purposeful. She's so evil.
I watched it in real time and it didn’t sit right with me at the time. It felt very rushed.
I did notice she didn’t address either set of attorneys. What really stood out was how she didn’t come up for a breath as she addressed the jurors and declared a mistrial. It was glaringly obvious she was rushing
I think that they could have said something but they were under the impression that the jury was hung on ALL counts. They should have been polled in private.
Exactly
Yes! As the judge SHE knew the law and procedure, and she did it that way on purpose. This is on her!
As a juror I would be furious, Lally blatantly suggests that they are lying. 9 weeks of torture, and now they are called liars according to Lally?
The 12 of them need to call a press conference on the front steps of the court and tell the world the truth.
@@Lolabear00press conference is not good. They will likely be dox. Best to recall to court to testify without cameras.
Still respect the jurors privacy.
I’m sure an attorney will offer to represent them. That’s what happened in Murdaugh. It was for opposite purpose, but I think the endgame will be same.
He is such a gross human being. I have to be respectful to Melanie's channel but there's more that I would say about my feelings towards him. Just vile & imo corrupt.
Lally lied 227 times during his closing.
Judge Mary from the 3day Baldwin trial puts Auntie Bev to shame as a judge. Prosecutors screwed up in Baldwin and judge did the right thing.
Seriously! There were so many things the CW didn’t turn over to the D. Chloe’s location, for one! Yet Bev didn’t care. She rules from emotion, not law.
This Judge is THE WORST........PERIOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes!! Overtly Biased and Corrupt. Seems as if Bev wanted them to find Karen “guilty!” no matter if Karen was innocent on any count!!
Yes! Alec Baldwin's case just got thrown out because the prosecution withheld evidence..... It's overwhelmingly evident that lollygag and Morrissey and everyone that has been railroading Karen Reed is getting away with b******* and I don't understand 😭😭😭😭😭😭
After watching many trials and having been involved in trials myself ( to the point once being told by the judge I was in contempt of his court - yer made me cry)
No one no judge lawyer police no one has ever made me angry
The bench of baloney has changed that
She takes the cake on that with one of her decisions literally making me furious
Nope. She's worse than that. Her haircut is the worst too. Who wears a damn hair helmet like that in 2024?
Agree
Mark is right. It’s going to be denied. This judge has shown time and time again that she doesn’t care about KR’s rights or doing things properly. She cares about doing things her way. Her silence after the motion was filed is deafening, and I’m almost positive she’s going to put on her usual pissed off tone of voice and dismiss the defense condescendingly.
How can the judge break the law
I expect nothing but poor judgments from this faux judge
I’m really glad they got a different attorney to argue this motion to demonstrate to the public that the disrespect towards the defense is just a weird, petty personal vendetta.
I think the FBI needs to check her phone logs and computers to see who she communicates with !
My gut has always thought she’s buddies with some of these god awful people!!
The ENTIRE jury needs to come forward. Please!
Totally agree…as Melanie has stated…Karen Read can be anyone of us.
@@kabbystevens5167 The STATE has worked against Truth from the beginning to protect STATE ACTOR'S that killed a man. This cabal will never let them, and those who helped to cover it up, face Justice and could care less what PERSON becomes their patsy. Wake up folks and never forget what they did to the three Kennedy brother's
@@MissesCakes YES, all jurors please come forward! Do the right thing. You could be in Ms. Reads shoes one day…
We don’t know if any jurors contacted the courthouse.
@@amherstanne1219True, they contacted the defense attorneys. Because if they contacted the courthouse or Lally, they would bury the juror’s story. Corrupt!!
Bev had ONE question to ask the jury.
“Have you come to an impasse on each count?” There were several charges!
She didn’t ask, she didn’t confer with the lawyers. She was way out of her league.
She doesn't seem to want to know the result and rather mistrial the case so cw can do it all over again.
Waste of resources
”Dishonorable” Judge Bev, made a deal with the Devil…… just saying……
@spacecadet76
💯 waste of resources!
If I were a citizen of Norfolk County, I’d be protesting against trying her again! Nobody wants to hear Lally drone on for another 10 weeks, spending the tax payer’s money on trying an innocent woman for a second time. I want justice for Officer John O’Keefe but the DA is looking in the wrong place!
She was TIRED😂😂😂
She wasn’t having anything but a guilt verdict!
Why is the commonwealth refusing to uphold the constitution
Because they can
@@michaelcalland801 Just because you can doesn’t mean you should
😂it’s the state of mass Psychosis 😂😂😂voted 49 recently almost bottom of barrel for commercial business
Who's Judge Bev accountable to, besides seeing that a defendant gets a fair trial. Cause she's failing!
She’s accountable to no one.
The DA.. Morrissey..who wants Karen read behind bars@@michaelcalland801
The Governor
her behaviour attitude and most decisions were biased against Karen. No regard to justice.
they should appeal to the Governor then🤷♀️🎯
I followed this trial as if I was a juror. Did not know anything about this case. I really don’t know why this jury was divided. It was obvious the CW did not prove this case beyond any reasonable doubt in ANY of the counts.
Absolutely agree 100%!!!!
I started following it in the middle and as soon as i saw the autopsy photos I thought ok, this guy was attacked by a dog… how anyone could look at that picture and think a taillight broke on his arm and scraped it is beyond me. And that’s a full stop- no proof she hit him.
I saw it in the early days and wasn’t interested. I was 💯 Guilty! I had a week off work and started watching the trial because I was bored. Now I’m frigging OUTRAGED!!! And Bev is as twisted as they come! FBI WHERE ARE YOU! Something needs to give cos this shit show is a mess
America! The land of the free! Fucking stand for malpractice. Stand for your Rights and stand for each other!!! ❤️ 🇬🇧!
@@qmccall0328I've come to realize that. I'm in the forensics field and watch these trials neutral and look at the evidence. My friend is in the legal field and she jokes that jury trials are "vibe based". Our predictions are typically completely opposite and she is more often correct 🙃
Like most I heard the media fake version. Then later I heard the FKR version. I chuckled about dog bites being such convincing proof of him in the house in a human fight. The McAlberts can’t escape the implications of the animal involvement. Defense should prove the dog isn’t in Vermont if necessary. Some of the 10% against KR would change sides imo.
HOLY CRAP- It just occurred to me- Lalli is arguing the wrong thing in his motion to dismiss.
By citing Blueford he’s arguing that there’s legal precedent which says the jury’s possible acquittal is irrelevant (Blueford v Arkansas). But the motion Jackson and Yanetti filed ISNT ARGUING to reinstate the acquittal- they haven’t gotten to that point yet! Rather, they are simply moving to hold a HEARING and the jurors brought back to ascertain whether they indeed intended to acquit or not. And if you read Blueford in detail, in that case the court DID IN FACT bring the jurors back to have such a hearing.
So actually, Blueford is confirmation that the judge should GRANT the motion to hold a hearing, bring the jury in, and ask them what they intended to do.
AFTER that hearing, if we find out that the jurors did intend to acquit Karen Read, THEN it might be appropriate to use Blueford as case law to argue that it’s too late or it’s irrelevant or whatever (although it still looks like there are some major differences). But for the moment, the only thing on the table is the motion to hold a hearing, and Blueford only confirms that YES they should hold a hearing.
I hope Jackson and Yanetti realize this and use Lalli’s own argument to shove it up his….
Very Good
Lally doing prebuttal even in his motions
I hope the defense responds and includes THIS! Great catch. Obviously you have more forethought than Lallygagger.
@@transient_man He has spent basically this whole trial doing prebuttal and playing defense against Jackson, Yannetti, and Little. He was so focused on cutting off their theory he is missing the forest through the trees.
@@ESPHMacD
The whole DA’s office wants to pretend that trees don’t exist and then stuck their fingers in their ears so they don’t hear anyone saying “We can all see the trees right there!!!
Wherever Mark bederow goes, I go, 😆 I watch every show he's on specifically because of him ? So keep getting him on ?
I really bothers me that that the CW doesn’t want to explore this? It’s an insult to the jurors who raised this concern. The CW’s response is so insensitive to the jurors just so the prosecution can score a point against the defence. Total BS.
@@jtjones4081you have no idea how the law works. you’re commenting on a video that’s two hours of two highly qualified lawyers discussing the law in regard to this issue.
this is an unanswered legal question because the judge didn’t bother to ask the jury if they came to a verdict on any of the charges enough.
no judge in this country has made a mistake so obviously preventable and now neither side can cite a case with the same fact pattern as this one to give them an understanding of what to do.
Great point! The jurors and Karen Read. The law is literally based on this situation, to find TRUTH AND JUSTICE. it's infuriating.
Thanks to Proctor's testimony whenever I see someone use the abbreviation "CW" I immediately think 'C- word Wackjobs'...
You think the state wants fairness and justice... no, they want convictions
@@auntijen3781😂
Bev doesn’t care about justice
Why can’t the CW just say, “oh, we had no idea that the jury was confused about this. We need to do something about it.” It’s just ridiculous.
Cuz they're corrupt.
Never shouldn't been brought to trial to begin with
I believe because they set things up intentionally to be confusing for the jury. Including the judges instructions that were hard to follow and the fact she would not allow the instructions to go back with the jury so they could refer to them.
Calling this a hearsay issue is calling the jury liars, or even Karen’s attorneys liars.
Lally salad all this time. Bev is underhanded, and has not been trustworthy the entire trial. Should have recused herself.
@@stepheningves4713totally agree with your comment
In New Mexico, we just saw a judge with moral and ethical integrity dismissing a case with prejudice because it was the right thing to do.....hard to compare with judge Bev. Where is the moral and ethical integrity?
THE JURY NEEDS TO STAND UP. Come on people you can do it!!!
EVERY juror, this exact scenario can happen to YOU in Massachusetts!!
This is INSANE!!!
Imagine all the people they have already done this to.
Right, I wish everybody would understand that. I was watching another show like this and an FBI agent said I would rather let a guilty person back on the streets than an innocent person in jail. And I will forever feel that way.
Imagine being the next defendant the day after the mistrial. The cops, the DA, the judge are all doing the same crap, the jury is just as dumb, your lawyer is 1/100th the cost, and no one gives a crap. Lol
Auntie BEV HAS AN AGENDA!!!!!!!! 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Auntie Bev is involved in the cover up ! Period full stop
Its so obvious. Start bringing it to light.
Yep and it is to protect the Alberts and the McCabe as she is a family friend. Her brother represented Chris Albert when he killed someone in a hit and run manslaughter case in 1994. Also one of the McCabe called her “Auntie Bev” and said he had a direct line to her in a correspondence with turtleboy.
I hope the jurors speak out, they don't have to give their name or show their face. The news will not show who you are if you don't want it to be known. Please, this needs to be righted 🙏.
Shame on you Commonwealth
But who is gonna hold bev accountable?
Bev will deny the motion. She would rather have a defendants Constitutionally protected rights violated than ever admit she screwed up. She’s not just a bad judge she’s also a garbage human.
🎯 BINGO!! 🎯
Same can be said for Lally!!
Hot Shot Jackson screwed up. He had his chance at the end of the trial...now we have hearsay.
💯 in agreement ❤
@@George-cl6lt BS. wont be hearsay if they poll the jurors. prosecution doesn't want that. hmmm.
And she is, as Mark said, perpetually grumpy, casually dismissive and improper!
FBI needs to investigate this judge. Her actions with the jury seem intentional.
The judge was so lazy. Remember when she said “I didn’t read all of it, I was tired”
Bev herded the jury to get a conviction anywhere, and when she realized she wasn't going to get it, she called a mistrial and rushed the jury out. Could have sworn the witch trials ended centuries ago but it seems Bev wants to revive them again. I've given up that the FBI is going to step in and stop this train wreck...
There's still time for that to happen. 😊
The FBI is still doing an active investigation.
She did NOT have adequate time to raise an objection!!! Auntie Bev saw to it that there were no objections raised before she sent the jury out. The blatant lies😡🤬 I’d be so embarrassed if I were that prosecutor or the judge but they have no scruples. Abolish qualified immunity!!! Everyone should be held accountable for their decisions!!
I would LOVE to know if any of the jurors said anything to Bev or if any called the prosecutors!
I think they told her in chambers and she'll deny that, but the jury thought she would go make this right and when she didn't the next day they started coming forward but those that have have to make the other 8 come forward now and just keep the pressure on!!! Hopefully they now know any all the corruption from auntie Bev on down and will step up and speak out. They should go to the steps of the courthouse call the press and make the announcement of what their decision was!!!
@@gagecarlsen3872 the prosecution was saying that KR’s defense should have said something before the jury was sent away and I was saying that they didn’t have enough time. Bev declared a mistrial and it was over! KR’s attorneys absolutely raised it as soon as it came to their attention, you’re right!
EXACTLY!! It was over in less than 5 mins. She read the note, declared a mistral & dismissed the jurors before anyone knew wth was going on!! I had to go back& watch it three times
Good idea@@Lolabear00
@@Troe76 Agreed, abolishing qualified immunity would end a lot of the corruption we are seeing in so many cases from coast to coast. This judge and CW are very blatant with their unchecked and unaddressed corruption. Why, no consequences!!!
If Karen has to retried and found innocent she needs to sue the whole CW and company! Unbelievable!
She can't. That's not how it works, all of them have qualified immunity
You know what the most amazing thing about the KR trial has been? The discovery of Mr Bederow. He's box office gold. 😁
Justice for Karen and John
Jurors! We need you ALL to speak out!!
When you listen Bev giving jury instruction, she specifically said that after jury finish deliberation, they will be called to the courtroom and the foreman will read the verdict. They were never given that chance, they were immediately excused and the mistrial was declared by Bev.
Intially, the judge told them "not to fill out the verdict slip until they came to a unanamois decision on the chargeS" I rewatched the video of the trial. Clearly, the jury or the appointed Lead Juror did not fill out the verdict slip due to not unanamois on count 2. Not to mention Count 2 issues not having not guilty was brought to the attention of the courts. Obviuosly Count 2 was written poorly at the least. The judge should have confirmed they not unanamois on all counts, she is the gatekeeper of the trial. Shame on this judge and this CW, they clearly do not respect the law or the jurors.
@@lboitano67 I thought exactly the same thing! She was confusing. The forms were confusing. And of course the defense wouldn’t object or ask more questions-they had no clue about what happened in the jury room. As far as they knew, hung jury was hung.
I live in a small town at the very northern point in NJ. Today I saw several ladies with shirts that say Free Karen on the front and a Turtle 🐢 on the back Iv never seen these women but those shirts started an hr long conversation and a lunch date it’s a small world and EVERYONE is watching
This judge Bev knew exactly what she was doing hearing it up. She’s no good. She’s corrupt as the rest of them. It’s her fault. She’s the one in control of the courtroom. She knows the law.
Absolutely positively unequivocally I agree.....✅✅✅✅✅✅ Auntie Bev rushed them right out the door 🚪 deliberately
@@Whattupp-b7b She does know most of the law. She sure has shown some incompetence and bias! Should have definitely recused herself! She’s in bed with all these criminals.
That’s exactly what my dad said, and he didn’t follow the case or understand all the details. He said, “that judge knew exactly what she was doing “ at the end. 😡
I don’t get why they don’t let this go. This is blowing up in their face. There’s shade on this judge already and this is only going to increase scrutiny. And IMO they’re hiding something.
How? There’s no downside. No risk of losing an election, it’s a 1 party state. 1% of the population is paying attention and 30% of those vote.
The Judge in this case set the precedent that when notes come from the jury, she would read them to counsel without jury present and hear from the lawyers and than make her decision... she did this each time before... Than went rogue and chose a mistrial without hearing from anyone. Now, in hindsight her chosen path of procedure squashed KR 's constitutional rights! ALL charges should be found NG... she did NOT hit him with the car! Sanctions should be brought against this Judge.
It's ANOTHER cover-up, by the court this time
We need the feds to bring charges to the real / obvious culprits.
I’d dig enough I’d find corruption on Aunt Bev
I wish!
You don't have to dig far
Her brother is an attorney and represented Chris Albert after he was involved in a hit-and-run manslaughter case in 1994. Yeah, she refused to recuse herself. Also one of the McCabes said in a correspondence with turtleboy that they have a direct line to the judge and in that correspondence referred to her as “Auntie Bev”.
@@stepheningves4713 yes I know
And she looks like Morrissey enough to be his twin??? FBI is listening to EVERYTHING (DoJ & state attorney briefed!) Patience folks!
Jackson intimidates her!!! Grow up Auntie Bev!
Well KR's lawyers are experienced and I'm sure they know what to do ... Hopefully
Love Melanie & mark
Thank you for explaining this bs from commonwealth
I couldn’t bring myself to read BS! So sick of this judge & commonwealth. The world saw today what happen in Alec Baldwin case dismissed! We need that judge in Norfolk she is an honorable judge!
The hand picked foreman who is a former cop was selected by this judge with her speaking so highly about the note. I have a feeling there’s more to the story with why she picked that guy to be the foreman.
Exactly!
This is from the Kim Jung-un playbook, direct from North Korea!
Please don’t insult Kim Jung-un
They're buying time for the culprits
They really want to double down on the corruption I for one want to see if all the witnesses can keep their story straight for a second time 😂😂
The jury was probably scared that they would get yelled at by Bev on national tv, by saying they were agreed on 1 and 3.
Can one image if ONE juror while being ushered out of courtroom stated…”but Judge what about the charges we did agree upon??”
At one point Judge Auntie Bev told the jurors not to dicuss with anyone what she said to them.
Massachusetts Criminal Procedure Rule 27: Verdict Subdivision B - This rule also provides that the court may declare a mistrial in cases where the jury is unable to reach a verdict. However, it must first receive and record the verdicts which the jury can agree upon. See ABA Standards Relating to Trial by Jury §§ 5.4-.5 (Approved Draft, 1968); Rules of Criminal Procedure (U.L.A.), supra, Rule 541.
It comes down to a miscommunication with the jury not understanding Bev's horrible instructions, which is not their fault. The defense assumed they were hung on all charges & so did the C.W. so C.W. can't blame Karen's lawyers.
Bingo !
The judge in Baldwin was having none of the fuckery whereas Bev seems down for it 🙄😡
So on point! 🎉
Bev can never be in the wrong even when she is.
I was surprised and disappointed by the judges behaviour, I have not seen the likes of it before. Seriously unprofessional and blatantly unfair, so many times I was left open mouthed
How can people be so evil?
You've got to wonder about Judge 🚩Cannone's other trials, and how many of their outcomes were determined -- not by the facts and the law, but ultimately by her temperament and lack of composure.
edited to add:🚩
or corruption.
@@BondJames-vz5wk -- or corruption -- yes.
After this slap in the face response, do you think the jurors who voted guilty on count two will finally get it that justice and fairness is not an interest of the CW? That this case has been bull from the jump? We all know Bev is going to side w/CW here. When she does I don’t see how more people won’t see her bias against the defense. This is getting frustrating.
My husband is on standby to fly up there with me for the protests. And it’s beyond frustrating.
What are the charges they deadlocked on?
Charge 2. But what is it again?
@@teresawarner689 2 is the manslaughter charge. It can still carry up to 25 years in prison. If Bev does nothing I bet jurors will give damning public interviews and hopefully the FBI will interview them as well. The McAkberts knew about the acquittal on count 1 and the split on count 2 prior to the end of deliberations. MSP is in charge of the jury. Hopefully phones are tapped. I wouldn’t doubt it after finding out the FBI tapped Morrisey’s phone.
@@Dewey32 that is so fantastic to hear. I wish I could go. Thank you for doing that because it’s desperately needed. God bless you. 🙏🥰💕
We are outraged!
This is 15 pages of F U to jury.
Exactly. It's like saying, we don't care about the jurors' verdicts.
I think Bev will have to entertain this jury and their decision. Not bc she wants to, but just like she reached out to people above her once before on when she changed the form to the way the defense requested. It's obvious Bev changed the form but never told the jurors they were required to mark off boxes. She wasn't expecting to have the jurors talk about her not giving this instruction that she is going to be forced to entertain the jurors' decisions on each case. Bev only does things for her selfish mind or her friends within the system until she is uncovered.
The argument isn’t that the jury needed more time to deliberate or should have been sent back out. The argument is that the jury had two verdicts, didn’t know how to communicate them to the court, and weren’t fricking asked because Bev, true to form, had already made up her mind about something and didn’t want to know if the lawyers had anything to say about it.
I think Bev is going to blow this off.
I suspect worse things might happen to her if she allows the motion. The judge does not seem too concerned about justice which is strange (understatement).
Karen Read has got screwed every step of the way! Infuriating!
It's unbelievable 💔
Look at what happened yesterday with Alex Baldwin...crazy things happen and I hope the defense has something up their sleeve for the 22nd
Karen needs to sue if they bring to trial and she is found not guilty again on charge one and 3!!
Karen needs to sue regardless of anything else that happens. Her rights were violated and not just at trial. We just need FBI Agent Levy to hurry up.
Did the rest of the jury see the foreman write the note? Wss it read to them before it was given to the judge? I doubt so.
This is making me sick seriously
If I was juror I’d be mad. CW accusing that I was lying and judge applying that my work means nothing for her
Mark: they didn't check NG on 1 and 3 because the final jury instruction told them not to fill out any verdict slips until they had decisions on all 3 counts. Bev totally messed this up by not asking if they were hung on all 3 or just some of them. Travesty is this isn’t given full review. Hopefully Bev will set oral argument on the motion and more jurors will come out before the hearing.
Can’t believe the CW is this arrogant. How can they ignore the law and the jurors? This is getting more ridiculous by the day. The 22nd is going to be crazy.
Disgusting. The Attorney General or Governor needs to step in and say enough is enough - stop this lynching trial. Wow. I watched a real Judge today in the Alec Baldwin case - she was amazing, fair, and unbiased - and KNOWLEDGABLE. And now back to this ridiculous mess. Wow.
I felt the same way about Judge Marlowe Sommer. She was a breath of fresh air in comparison to Auntie Bev!
@@y2ksurvivor - What a difference. The Judge in the AB case, whether anyone likes him or not, was following what the Constitution calls for, something that Massachusetts has no concept about - obviously.
Oh yeah thank god there’s an honest and totally legit judge that served proper justice and honored the rights of a member of the upper elite of the imperial ruling party. Faith RESTORED.
Another great comment!
What an absolute disgrace the judge and the prosecution lally and the fat controller are. I feel so sad for the people who are being persecuted by these corrupt court officials. I think every person who has been charged and convicted by this rabble should have their cases investigated. This town stinks to high heaven
I thought the Commonwealth of Kentucky was bad...but Massachusetts puts the icing on the 🍰
My grandfather was a bailiff for 20 years for his retirement career in another state. Now he was in a place that’s been known for corruption and had some bad things happen. One thing I know is bailiffs answer a lot of questions. My guess is a bailiff knew they’d reached a verdict on two of the charges and were deadlocked on the other and told the judge and possibly Lally. My grandfather was the best man I ever knew. He was honest to a fault. But I found a lot of what he said happened in court happened/happens in most courts across the country. Someone knew. Hopefully there will be someone who works in courthouse who isn’t beholden to Bev or Morrissey who will come forward.
The smart thing would be for Morrissey to just dismiss the whole thing. But I don’t think he has the decency to do that.
The real problem with this case is the DA’s office has made this more about convicting Karen Read than true justice for John O’Keefe. They are making it too obvious there’s bias. Lally repeated what was in Jen McCabe’s burn book in his closing.
Judge Aunty Beverage does not embody our idea of a partial or fair judge ! What a discrace in Mass
As I sit here with my crochet hook, working on the blanket, I am a palled at the very idea that Karen read may very well end up serving time for a crime she has been acquitted of. I can’t believe what I am hearing. Not only that, But I recognize that this kind of thing could happen to any one of us.}] The whole thing has been a nightmare. As a former paramedic, and first responder, I nearly fell off my comfy couch when I saw those specs of blood nestle into the same red solo cups that I keep in my very own kitchen. Even a casual watcher of crime shows knows better than this. The whole thing never should’ve happened.
Judge 🚩Bev can't handle it. Anything that doesn't go exactly the way she envisioned throws her into an upside-down tizzy of a mess, and all she can do by way of response is lash out. Always needs extra time to process and recompose herself, if she's self-aware enough in the moment to take a moment to cool down. So unskilled. So unprofessional.
You've got to wonder about her other trials, and how many of their outcomes were determined, not by the facts and the law, but ultimately by her temperament and lack of composure.
edited to add:🚩
MA gave too much discretion to judge and she had been getting away for however long she get... also bet she never get a case this big, complicated and high profile. But her ego can't let her admit she's nervous.
@@dpoopie Maybe. Or maybe it's just that the judge's mom and the D.A.s wife were years-long co-workers.
Great comment!
There needs to be a huge investigation into the judge.
All her little "doing things her way " are going to get her.
Brian/Colin Albert should never have been allowed in that courtroom on the last day. That was obvious intimidation.
I agree! Paul Okeefe solidified this in his interview. I forget if he said they invited them or if they asked if the Okeefes minded. Either way it was intentional. The jury even came out later and said they felt intimidating. In the motion to dismiss the juror said Brian Higgins intimidating them. They meant Brian Albert.
This is beyond disgusting. I don't want to be too harsh as I am from the UK and our justice systems work differently but I am beyond embarassed by the CW, the judge and all the law enforcement involved, and I am also sad for the victims family- they deserve a competent and fair system. Whether Karen is guilty or not.. as a juror on this case..I would move state because the hell am I paying taxes for that shit show.
PROSECUTORS ARE SUPPOSED TO BE SEEKING THE TRUTH. NOT POWER GAMES♦️♠️❤️♣️
So true!
I think (well, one of the problems) is poor system design, - bear with me! Everyone should be working hard to design a system where the self interests of the police, the defence attorneys, the prosecutors and the judge etc. are best served when the innocent are found innocent and the guilty are found guilty. Unfortunately, for example, some prosecutors will advance their careers by winning cases where people they know to be innocent are found guilty. There are many people of integrity but they are struggling within "the system".
Can the Defense go to the State Supreme Court to overrule the judges biased response.
Judge in Alex Baldwin case threw out charges with prejudice. Due to evidentuary issues. Great judge. btw I am not a baldwkn fan. i also believe he was negligent.
Totally agree!
I wish Judge Bev would be like the judge in Alex B trial.
I second this!
I didn’t see any proof that KR dropped off JO. They said black SUV not a Lexus
Saying that the Defense was ready for a mistral and got it is like saying someone confessed to a murder even though all the evidence proves they didn't.
Who the cares what the Defense wanted if the JURORS actually found her not guilty on those charges?
It constantly chaps my ass how our system will throw you into a meet grinder because "that's how we've always done it" if it means the system MIGHT have an issue functioning while it sorts out it's bullshit.
It's like a perpetual motion machine that CANNOT be allowed to stop, even if it how it's running is detrimental to those it's designed to serve.
Melissa Hendricks is 🎯when she said the plan was to confuse and convolute the case & the jury all along, it was not about truth and justice and never will be. 1:40:24
God I love Bederow’s analysis! So thorough & explains things so eloquently-could listen to him all day! ❤️❤️
Pre trail motion hearings were waaaay worse on the defense than the bias she showed the world. Thank God it’s all there on CZcams to go back and watch forever.
For the next trial Alan Jackson can start off with saying that John O'Keefe was never hit by a car.
I agree. I think the argument about read being framed was just too much for people to understand and grasp
Move to suppress everything. There is a mountain of improper evidence and it should be a slam dunk dismissal especially considering what we just witnessed on the Baldwin trial.
Agree
Someone suggested that Jackson should say you may not believe that someone in the house did it but the prosecution did not prove their case.and that is what must be proved and it was not proven by shoddy police work. Also maybe even debunk jenn Aand how they changed their testimony.
You guys are owed a HUGE thank you from all of us! Thanks for taking your time, unpaid, to explain in detail, every last thing having to do with this case. THANK YOU! ❤️
I wouldn't say unpaid.... This content creators get plenty of money through their followers...
This is like a slap in the face for the jurors, who literally did what they were told and did it well.
“Just look the other way” is EXACTLY what Judge Cannone (&CW) is doing right now.
Like, bye jurors, we don’t need ya now! 👋🏼
😠
Isn’t that double jeopardy to try her on the items she was found acquitted on?
Can the 12 jurors collectively file a suit against the commonwealth for not honoring their decision?
I don't know, but it seems like it's a violation of their rights as jurors to have their vote or verdict validated.
There was NO verdict. Nothing was written down no proof.
@@Joh605 They did reached a verdict. If the form was not written on, it's on the Judge. The form should be filled out, no matter what the verdict is. Not guilty on counts 1 & 3 and not unanimous on count 2. That's the verdict and it needs to be validated.
@jamkoti3088 on the verdict sheet for counts 1 and count 3 there was an option for (guilty) and (NOT GUILTY) neither were filled out so there for NO verdict. And on COUNT 2 at the top there was (NOT GUILTY) AND (GUILTY) option and if you checked NOT GUILTY then leave the 2 lesser charges BLANK!!! And if you find her guilty then check the 2 lesser charges guilty as well VERY SIMPLE INSTRUCTIONS
@@Joh605 Again,they were not filled, because the Judge instructed them not to fill it out, unless the verdict was unanimous.
I hope Karen goes to the higher courts on that nasty Judge
What recourse is there for when bev rules in favor of the CW? It’s like judges can do whatever they want w no punishment.
CW opposition is unacceptable.
I'm truly confused, isn't the prosecutor supposed to find the truth to ensure justice? This is bizarre to me...
Totally bizzare!
How did Sean McDonough’s source know on Thursday that the jury was deciding on Charge 2? The implication is the the VFW celebration was because they expected KR to be found guilty. We all need to be thankful for her protection. Thoughts?
Turtle boy exposed the truth very early on and Bev tossed him out & mandated he wasn’t allowed to speak on this. Another violation of his constitutional rights.
This is clearly falling on the shoulders of the judge, she was derelict in her duties, and as a result, this woman’s life is going to be altered because of the judges mistakes! What a frightening concept, are we still in the United States of America?