IAS, Addl Chief Secretary, Pay Rs 50,000 fine ! Patna High Court Order
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2022
- IAS, Addl Chief Secretary, Pay Rs 50,000 fine ! Patna High Court Order #law #legal
In this Patna high Court proceedings, The Addl Chief secretary appeared before the court as the case was leading to contempt of court.
Delay by executive is a serious matter. In this case there was delay of over a decade.
#Lawchakra #law #legal
#advocate #judge #India #Supremecourt
Watch the full video and keep supporting the channel.
In another court proceeding, how the High court of patna turned out to be the savior for the petitioner where his appeal in from of the bihar govt was laying idle for decades. If not judiciary what would have been state of affairs and the extent of executive excesses.
Don't know the meaning of OSD😂
Your judge 😂kuch nahi krte woh LLB krte hai
How can you edit and put headlines to the video? Have you taken permission from the High Court Registry ?
@@dipjyotichakrabortyadvocat1382 i think it comes under educational purpose sir.
@@dipjyotichakrabortyadvocat1382 how can you put comments in his channel,have you taken written consent??
@@cricksteer17 don't comment rubbish. That lady doesn't know English and did not pronounce properly. That's why, other one said in English
Hats off to the patience of the Hon'ble Judge
One single question was not answered properly
Quality of Lawyers also a cause of worry
Honorable courts need to come heavily on the functioning of the babudom. Untill the responsibility is not fixed and they are allowed to let go scotfree this casual approach will continue unabated. Please fix their responsibility, impose costs on them and initiate disciplinary proceedings against them ; only then you can expect them to behave and save the time of courts.
Rip senior IAS officer and the people who glorify them with power of IAS and IPS in media..
only chhapri youtubers glorify them
No one is above the law
Law is Supreme 😊
Those people are not ias or ips they all are youtuber without paid cameraman😂
ptaa nhi kyu yeh dekh ke judge hi bnne ka mnn kr raha ias ips chhodke. 😂
Lawyer: My lord, this is my submission.
Judge: Your submission is rejected. 😂😂😂😂Instant kill.....!!!!!!
Me lord, me lord😅🤣 Judge- You yourself think u r a lord 😅 Your submission is rejected 🤣
@@bhagyashreebhargavi8373 are you an advocate
🤣🤣
The incompetence of the State department is staggering.
Eye opener.
The level of corruption in state government is alarming...it's been 20 years and they still cannot furnish few documents...it shows how busy they are in gobbling up public's money....wow.....
Ahhh, bahut thandak mil rahi hai kaleje ko.
these IAS in connivance with politicians treat poor citizens like football kicking from all sides.
May Allah bless the judge.
I really like this judge. All IPS and IAS offers just Quavered in front of him
@@masteryoda9044quaver matlab quwari ladki ki terha
People who are commenting Hon'ble justice P.B. Bajantri for selecting english as mode of communication need to know he has been transferred from Karnataka High Court to Patna High Court. His first and second language is Kannad and English, he is not good with Hindi so it's his necessity to ask lawyers to communicate in english and that's one of the reason till date High and supreme courts choose their language as english yet judges who understand local languages let lawyers to argue in which ever language they are comfortable with but only orally.
I am fan of this judge ❤️😊🙏👍🎉, all politicians and DMs shld be brought in front of him and made to give report of their work for poors and middle class and where tax payers Money was spent
when judges start punishing govt officer..50% cases will b automatically solved..this is how based on facts and evidences cases shd be disposed quickly ...better way to dispose 5 cr cases ..
No.... The executive cannot function independently like the judiciary. They are corrupt politicians elected by corrupt voters. Make executive independent like judiciary 90% of the problems would be solved
I am always surprised at the quality of some of these lawyers and IAS officers who appear before the court. Do they not prepare themselves before appearing? Such basic facts also they are unaware of and unable to answer. How these people reach the top of bureaucracy i dont know.
The power of South Indian Judge 🔥
Honble Judge needs very precise answers. And always the officers take charge only in the last minute and are ignorant about details. A case hangs for more than 20 years. Thats how Govt functions.
Great job by the no nonsense jugde.
Beautiful distributions of Powers ... Whether a normal sub Inspector can arrest a Judge and other side a Pm is also same as normal people in Court , in the eye of Judge ... Beauty
Judges of all rank are immune from arrest. They can be arrested only under the direction of Chief Justice.(Delhi judicial officers association case). They also have complete immunity for acts done in office, whether civil or criminal. Exception from arrest in civil process (through order of court) is limited to the time when they are exercising duty..
@@vishnumtech5247 Who gave these false information to you guys? Only governors and president are immune not judges. You guys don't even know the basics of constitution. Judge can be arrested but information of his arrest should be given to district judge or high court judge. For taking him to police station permission of district court or high court is required. These are the guidelines of SC.
@@vishnumtech5247all judges can be arrested. regardless of how senior they are. Even by a sub inspector.
Court must be held superior to beurocracts. If they will be weak how can we protect ourself from the tantamount and red tapism of beurocracy. 🙏
Yes. Thanks for watching
Court is superior to bureaucrats.
They are.
Courts are already independent and thus superior to bureaucrats...
Man😂 is this how your state officers working 😂😂😂😂😂 I thought politicians are like this but even officers seems to be dumps 😂😂😂 judge is rocking 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
It seems there is no transferency in the whole state.
Judicial reform is the need of the Hour, it is most poor performing wing of Indian Democracy
Thanks for watching
lol judiciary is the most efficient among all wings
@@sriram8027 That is your misconception it is the worst and most failed system of all wings anything that this country needs to be changed Or reformed is the judiciary system it is a joke
Judge reminds me of my viva day..
I like how the judge is dealing with this IAS officer. The day people start dealing with public servants as they should be dealt with, India will actually start developing . People need to have some knowledge of law and understand that these are SERVANTS.
People need to ask the government for vote waapsi , dhan waapsi, gun law and jury system.
Try solving old question paper of UPSC then you will know how much tough competition of IAS is shamefull person
@@cherrycj3525 competition ? What competition ?
You want to enjoy rest of your life doing nothing wasting tax payers hard earned money. Doing tons of corruption.
Then obviously you need to do RATTA bro. Ratta is not tough once you get used to it. One more thing phone you are using is made by engineer, the medicine you Take prescribed by doctor made by biochemists. The road you use made by engineer. The electricity you are using all done by engineer. Do you know how much brain is required to get things done. And you calling RATTAABAAZI tough. Grow up slave.
Servant of india not some chappri people like u
@@cherrycj3525 ^So? Because they cracked a tough exam gives them arbitrary powers to disobey the judiciary and hence the law of the land?
@@anuran.chowdhury law k upar mein saare corrupt baithe hue hain
Our judge rocks👍👍👍
So this type of people running our states🤣how can india become superpower with this type of ias official
Sir Judge U are A genius. If only we have 10 Judges like U this world 🌎 will be A Better place to live in. God's grace and blessings 🙌 will always be upon U and your Family.
good judge.Appreciated.
This is the example how the Bihar Government works
I am noticing by listening most of the cases, all are much busy in turning pages... time is weasting by turning pages...
we need judicial reforms
Reform in what shape and sense you didn't mentioned yet. While you are suggesting something must be with thorough clear cut, not that hit and run.
Need of the hour
I pity the petitioner. He was dismissed just a month before his superannuation meaning his pension is gone to dogs for the sake of one month.
Excellent judge hats off
Great Hon’ble Judge
This honorable person should be CJI. His words like double edge sword.
The way he says "Judge-aa"🤣🤣🤣
“Speak English” ..That was a badass move !
Judicial reforms needed...
Absolutely. It is needed.
Sare bihar ke nhe. And judge is from South. Judge doesn't understand hindi others don't understand english. 😁😁😁
Superb
Thanks 🤗
We know India is corrupt BUT this level of corruption 😮
This Hon'ble Judge is Too Good..
Bhailog aise IAS OFFICERS ke sath yahi hona chahiyeh
Yeh log janta ki baat ni sunte h or Hon'ble Judge inki baat ni sunte h 😂
How irresponsible people become Secretaries
Even c doesnt know the full form of OSD..Officer in Special Duty..
OSD-OFFICER ON SPECIAL DUTY..
Great judge having ciarity on d case n uncompromising on bureaucuratic lethargic attitude.
Why AP high court is not imposing such hefty penalties on erring senior officers in contempt cases ? Why special treatment to AP IAS officers?
When i see judges like Frank Caprio and see how he handle cases and then see our country’s judges handle cases, i feel deeply saddened. All his verdict can be given even without being so harsh. How will people appeal if they are afraid of the judge? Reforms needed
I think that you didn't understand whole case ... Actually honble judge is strict as sad affairs of official
You want the judge to be polite to the department that decides cases in 10 years and can’t provide necessary documents even after being given 3 dates?
Khaandaani slave spotted. Pahle video thik se dekh .
@@swtyswty4264 he never talks politly
You misunderstood the judge. Watch the video again, he mentioned that despite asking multiple time for the records, department failed to assist the court thus he is being a lil strict on them and that is completely fine as these bureaucrats pay no heed to the court's orders.
Why theBihar Government appoints state counsel in High court??
One effed up bureaucracy in India and they are lawyers and IAS officers.
Long live Judiciary....
Aap ki Adalat
Bcz we still live in a Colonial state....such is the state of affairs.
lovely bro
Indian court Indian people Indian judging system fir sab q English mae baat kar raha ha?
Gulamo ki maansikta hi...
Kyunki yeh judge sahab Karnataka sy Patna High court aaye hai. Inko sirf kannad aur english aati hai to Hindi mein samjhanyenge kaise.😒
@@tejubaiyabemisaal808 unko hindi aana chayeh.. aa kya matlab hua.. advocate log ko English nhi ata hai 🤣
@@theapacherider21 kyun aani chahiye bhai.. kaha likha hai Hindi Compulsory hai. Agar hindi mein law padhne lage na to khoon k aansu rooge. Abhi idea nai hai kya bawasir hoga vo
@@tejubaiyabemisaal808 judgement hindi mae he hona chayeh so that everyone can understand common people easily
Jod job by court. Sir thoda aur fine lagayi with property attached
The Bihar Government is having strange people
I think the secretary and the advocate is not knowing anything aboit the case. The advocate himself appears for tge third time. May be Play along with petitioners and lose the case , suspecious
The lawyers don't speak proper English and even the lady who came to the microphone to speak does not speak English.
and despite of this they are still considered as highly qualified beings !
Ese kehte h asli power jugh
So loose dealing of a disciplinary case.
Have a round table conference 😜😄😄
🤣
Ye haal h sarkaari laywers
There is no governances in bihar.lessez faire.it seems.loot corruption and bribes
English nhi aati to inko waise hi saja hojayegi
It is not true. Judges do hear oral submission in other languages
@@LawChakra judge only said speak in english .. Although female was not comfortable..And she could not tell her side..
फिर special officer कैसे बन गए ?? लाख रुपये की तनख्वाह लेते समय ये बात समझ नहीं आयी कि इतनी बड़ी पदवी पे होकर भी ढंग की साधारण अंग्रेज़ी भी नहीं आती, थोड़ी न क्लिष्ट अंग्रेज़ी में प्रश्न पूछा था, बस इतना ही पूछा गया कि किस तारीख में ये कार्य सम्पन्न हुआ, बस इसीका तो अंग्रेज़ी में जवाब देना था जो कि 5वी का छात्र भी दे सकता है । अजीब बात है ।
@@manavgupta9168 then how she deputed as a special officer ?? She is an OSD and cannot answer in simple english to a simple question ! What kind of Special duty is she following ?? So strange...
What type of people administration
rubbish gov officers and gov advocate fire this mentals
Judiciary is over than ias ips
first of all..I want to say this..
my lord call is very often in north india..
less in south india ..please keep in mind..
judges are not our owners and the rest people aren't slaves
second.. govt officials may be critisized, but they too need some respect
third..some of the counsilers are idiots, can't speak, or read english ,which rise the question of qualification of them
fourth..whenever the judge feels the arguments are irrevelent, the highness threatens with fine
Sorry state of affairs of Bihar administration.
How come an officer in charge cannot speak English. How she has been appointed unpads Or bogus certificate education.
How Come This Stupid Lawyer Is Appointed As Advocate General To Appear For Principal Secretary?? I Mean As He Is Representing In Behalf Of State, I'm Considering That He Must Be Advocate General.
He is Asst. AG not AG of Bihar.
Judge should be know Hindi also for better communication.
That’s a official language most of the time in court.
They were all in senior post in health org. They should have known English, in general.
I don’t know, if they pursued medical from hindi medium.
@@AmberRathour366 absolutely durust reply
Why hindi??? Is it the official language??..because the last time i checked there is no official language..kindly stop spreading false propaganda
Article 348(1)(a) states that unless Parliament by law provides otherwise, all proceedings before the Supreme Court and in every High Court shall be conducted in English.
why should only hindi?
🎉😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂🎉🎉😢🎉😂❤😢😮😢🎉😂❤❤❤tytyygghggftchhgfgggfgg
he is additional cheif secretary of health department not cs
Did anyone thought of it, the language in court should be hindi not English it's not this injustice with one's who is Hindi speaker.
What if judge is from non Hindi state
@@LawChakra then he should say translator to translate it.
@@jobsrailway8117 Thanks for giving the answer. 🙌
@@LawChakra Hope this answer is suitable for your question.
@@LawChakra toh hindi sikhe woh.
English tak nhi aati inhe.. kitne Sharm ki baat hai. Ye hai bihar ke civil servants
for misleading the public by clickbait and demolishing the honor of executives i can even file a case against you mr so and so change the title to additional secretary or within few days you will be standing in the same court
Care about the honor of common man which daily faces the brunt of executive as shown in the video if not judiciary who will be the saviour
Thanks for pointing the error though
This judge got no cool always
Working 12hours a day at 50 + years no one can be cool
12:11 kya English speaking jaruri hai
The Chief Justice is from south India he doesn’t understand Hindi properly that was the reason he asked her to communicate in English with him
Not necessarily but you need to inform the court in advance so that a translator can be allocated
Every thing was good about judgeship but when we get out of idea of "speak in english" question is why so what if any one doesn't know English have no right to speak in court. Truly british mindset
You can speak in Hindi too in courts. There is no bar for giving oral submissions that it has to be in English only. Even written can be in hindi
@@LawChakra no sir every vernacular paper needs to be translated to english otherwise you wont be able to file anything in the court.
@@PollutedMind Correct. But judges do allow.
@@LawChakra may be but the registry will not accept any file as they have to follow the administrative orders as set by the CJ.
He is justice P.B. Bajantri originally from Karnataka High Court transferred to Patna High Court. So he only understands Kannad and English. Hindi is not his forte so he always ask to communicate in English. It has nothing to with colonial mindset.
Problem with the people they know less but shouts loud.
Thotha chana baaje ghanna.
Judge kaise kisi ko English bolne ko keh saktaa hai uski apni marji hai.
He is from SOuth India how can he understand Hindui language ?
To judge ki bhi apni marzi h....waise HC me English hi official language h
OSD even don't know english
Koi neta nhi aata kta court me
Why speak in English if you are not comfortable?
Yeh kasia judge hai hindi state ka jo hindi nahi jaanta or dusri baat hindi logo per english impose kar raha hai. That's why india mei log kanun ya court kachheri per viswas nahi karte.kyonki logo ko darr lagta or pta hai ki hamare courts abhi bhi british kaal ke hai jahan angrezi mindset chalti hai or unke sath nyaay nahi hoga.
Hindi state se nahi hai woh isliye nahi bol sakta. Tamil bolega toh kisi ko kuchh samajh aayega kya?
@@PS-od2mm toh bhai english state se bhi nahi hai 😂 hindi state mei maatr hindi chalegi. Kaise wo ham per ek videshi bhasha thop sakta hai. Wo translator ka bhi use kar sakta hai bur kisi ko us ki bhasha mei bolne se nahi rok sakta. 😡😡
@@user-kv4om4bz5k ja ye baat usko jaake bol 😂
@@PS-od2mm pucha kisne tune ? 😂 To kise bolu tujhe na!
@@user-kv4om4bz5k maine nahi puchha tujhse . Mere comment ko fir se padh ke dekh le
Judge is autocrat
No
Yes very arrogant man
The judge got transferred from the state of Karnataka to Bihar. He cannot understand hindi
What is child memo?
Listen carefully....charge memo...not child memo
What is 25th of 8th 2017. What kind of a statement is this??? Time stamp 15:15 to 15:20
The face of that budda government vakkeel & IAS babu is funnier than anything in the world..!!🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂