Professor Avi Shlaim says Europe exported anti-Semitism to the Arab world
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 02. 2024
- Professor Avi Shlaim , a British-Israeli historian born in Iraq, says Jews lived peacefully in the Arab world before Zionism and Europe exported its anti-Semitism to the region.
Subscribe: trt.world/subscribe
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
X (Twitter): trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/instagram
Threads: threads.net/@trtworld
TikTok: / trtworld
WhatsApp: trtworld.com/whatsapp
Telegram: t.me/trtworld
Visit our website: trt.world
Thats the history lesson that nobody at school gonna teach you that , thanks avi for speaking the truth
From iraq , with love
It's a bit sad. How much hidden history gets swept under the rug and is forgotten.
it's hypocrisy by Avi and by Arabs. Avi: "Jews don't do anything wrong and don't deserve Arabs being angry at them" (meanwhile in Gaza... nothing to see here, move along). And Arabs: "oh these are just Palestinians, let's prioritize trade and money, what if Israel has strong army we are afraid..."
@@AdamYusuf-3 it's hypocrisy by Avi and by Arabs. Avi: "J3ws don't do anything wrong and don't deserve Arabs being angry at them" (meanwhile in Gaza... nothing to see here, move along). And Arabs: "oh these are just Palestinians, let's prioritize trade and money, what if Israel has strong army we are afraid..."
@@AdamYusuf-3 it's done on purpose by the people who wanted to divide and concur
Most history today is easily found on internet .... most unrest is also caused by internet .... Islamic rallies like in London today are organized thru internet .... without the improper use of internet there would be a lot more peace in the World.
Much appreciation and respect too Avi. This just proves that Iraq is extremely diverse and wonderful. Iraqis aren’t just Arabs. There’s Jews, Chaldeans, Assyrians, Sabean, Yazidis, Kurds, Sunnis, Shias, etc etc. It’s unfortunate what conquer and divide has done to the country.
i wonder why sunni and shia include there. afaik, it isnt a tribe or race name, it was like arab version of US democrat and republic. it was political movement.
Why is Sunni's and Shia's there? Doesn't make sense lol
I think you are mixing ethnicities with religions. Good points though.
What you mean by arab?
So what happened to all of the jews? Used to be more than 200k today none
Thank you for speaking the truth🌹
Real Jewish man not a Zonist.Thank you.
Every time the people of God forsook the wisdom of God, they were punished by God and even expelled from Israel. Was God therefore an anti-Semite? There was neither the New Testament nor the church at that time. Do you understand what I say? All people - both Jews and non-Jews - should wake up as quickly as possible to the *Incarnate Wisdom of God (Yeshua=Jesus)* and accept the *New Testament* in which there is no violence!
@@alom4093are you kidding me it's full of violence
@@Uk.wildman Yes, your anti-Christian and pseudo-Christian versions of the faith are filled with violence, but the *True Yeshua haMashiah* and *his true apostles* (all *true Jews* ), there is no violence, even when *Yeshuah (Jesus)* died for all of us. Do you understand that, my brother? This is not a joke, this is *The Truth.* *The salvation* of the world comes from the *True God,* whose *Eternal Wisdom* became *man in Yeshuah (Jesus)!*
@@alom4093you talking about the book that Paul wrote? Someone that never even met jesus. Amazing that you actually believe that
@@dukedizzy *The Perfect and Eternal Word of GOD,* which became man in *Yeshua (Jesus),* is infinitely more and is before every angel, every prophet, every book, every believer, ...!
Can you understand this? *The PERFECT UNITY of the Eternal GOD,* *His Eternal WORD* and *His Eternal SPIRIT* is the *PERFECT TRUTH* before which all true angels, all true prophets, all true believers, ... bow down!
The *True Shehada* of *The Perfect Messianic Islam* is: *La illahe il Allah, fi Yeshua HaMashiah!*
*Mashallah, Mashallah, Mashallah!*
Europeans basically did a blunder and pushed it onto ARABS and they're still punishing them for thier own crimes 🤦
You mean that Europe and America are still practicing their immorality against them, so they created this so-called entity Israel to exercise its interests and use them in the Middle East region, and our Jewish brothers, our cousins, the children of Ishaq, Ismail’s brother, accepted this cheap game with the West, and accepted the role of the victim, and that the Arabs are the real enemy, despite The long history they lived with the Arabs in lasting peace and coexistence
Not All Europe countries only 3 Roman Empire, Hitler Nazis Germany and Ireland, Roman clearly chess Jewish from Israel 300ad to 600 BC to much suffering from hunting but Jewish chose by God couldn't denied
@@ichardviecent6334Ireland? What are you smoking 😂😂
They always dump their garbage ways onto other regions & call themselves champions of humanity!
Every time the people of God forsook the wisdom of God, they were punished by God and even expelled from Israel. Was God therefore an anti-Semite? There was neither the New Testament nor the church at that time. Do you understand what I say? All people - both Jews and non-Jews - should wake up as quickly as possible to the *Incarnate Wisdom of God (Yeshua=Jesus)* and accept the *New Testament* in which there is no violence!
@@alom4093the semites includes Arabs and Christian’s from that region anyway. They’ve literally changed the definition of the word since I was child to now mean anti Israel. When it used to mean anti anyone from that region
@@doubletapthatdotty4597 *Correctly!*
We are constantly brainwashed by the Mammonist and their overpowering media, which includes Holywood too!
Interesting explain more please@@alom4093
What do you.mean, the 2 other monotheistic religions?
Thank you for this truth
Every word he said is true
Exactly 1000/. Truth…. Thank you Avi!
Well said! We Moroccans also don't have a problem of co-existence with Moroccans Jews.... that a west problem and they try to convence us: "we can live in peace together" when the prophet Muhammed itself live with them in Saudia.
It’s the ignorant people trying to convince us that the issue is religious to get people to side against Muslims when in fact it’s a political conflict. They’ve been doing it for 100 years. 🤷🏻♀️
You should be proud! Morocco is to me the closest thing to paradise on this earth. lt is a magically beautiful place with the most beautiful Brothers and Sisters🤗 Alhamdullilah
Sure you can say that cuz since israel created most jews came from morocco to israel. Most moroccon people have jewish roots or are related.
@@ELHOOMOO That's blatantly wrong.
Most Moroccan people have Amazigh roots.
But I heard Morocco don't like bláck people and play rácism on any black skinned person. How true is this?
Spread the truth
This kind of voice will not heard or shown by wertern media. Bcs it is true and peacefully.
right ✅️ and most never heard nor would they ever second guess what they heard on T.V
This gentleman is correct. As an Iraqi American Christian, It honestly hurts. Hearing about the suffering my homeland had and still has. In Iraq you go back in history but your in the future. I love my ancient homeland and my people despite everything we've been through. I wish Iraq stayed secular, and pan-arabism with corruption haven't taken over.
Iraq would have stayed secular afterwards if Saddam was over thrown instead of America bombing and killing off a million Iraqis.. then stealing and illegally forcing iraq to sell off huge amounts of their oil to be sold to American companies that to this day run their oil industry. Iraq as a country still has enough oil to replenish the economy back to what it was but its being sucked dry by the US… I’m saying all this as a Kuwaiti who’s family experienced the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait..
The history of coexistence and peace is from a past where the government wasn’t secular either. It is the aftermath of both world wars and European imperialism that changed the entire region drastically
After corrupt USA invaded Iraq … there is only corrupted people left in Iraq …
@@NiceIndeed The Iraqis and other peoples, as long as they don't take Arab Islam so seriously, it's good to live together. If the Islamists, Salafists and other Islamic zealots want to move closer to the model of Arab Islam, then the greatest catastrophes will happen because the origin and model of Arab Islam is bloody and not clean. That's a fact, my brother!
@AdamYusuf-3 Every time the people of God (Israel) forsook the wisdom of God, they were punished by God and even expelled from Israel. Was God therefore an anti-Semite? There was neither the New Testament nor the church at that time. Do you understand what I say? All people - both Jews and non-Jews - should wake up as quickly as possible to the *Incarnate Wisdom of God (Yeshua=Jesus)* and accept the *New Testament* in which there is no violence!
True words said ❤ Thank you Avi
Absolutely, true!
so well explained
C'est tout à fait vrai. Mes parents sont du Maghreb et ils ont toujours vécu fraternellement avec leurs voisins juifs. Ils s'aidaient pendant leurs fêtes religieuses respectives et au Maroc et en Tunisie, ils partageaient même la commémoration de Saints communs.
Jamais mes parents ne prononçaient d'insultes antisémites ni même racistes. Ils étaient très respectueux des gens et avaient un grand sens de l'hospitalité.
Mais les juifs ont beaucoup trahi les musulmans au maghreb.
Lovely comment ❤
There is beauty in the Truth.
Tears come to my eyes, when i saw what invaders has done in iraq in 20 years, and destroyed this beautiful country.
History is a.series of conquests and invasions. Muslims have conquered by the sword 57/22 states
And Saddam wasn’t extermination Kurds and creating mass graves. Yeah right.
Thank you for the truth bless you cousin ❤
Respect for being honest
People of the book. Massive Respect.
love the humility in the way he speaks - Masha'Allah
Thank You Sir For Spoken Out 🫡
Lovely man. God bless you, my friend
Owesome people.. ❤❤
Believe his understanding. He is saying what he understands and knows. It's not many that had seen the past enough to say they loved enough and others filled the animosity .
My stolen identity is being used here to silence me while I'm not able to speak out at all. I don't feel anti anyone , ever.
I will try to remember your name in case I see any nasty statements purporting to be you.
@@keirfarnum6811😂😂😂😂😂
How is someone else sharing their experience, understanding and history silencing you? You too have the opportunity to speak
@@keirfarnum6811 Every time the people of God (Israel) forsook the wisdom of God, they were punished by God and even expelled from Israel. Was God therefore an anti-Semite? There was neither the New Testament nor the church at that time. Do you understand what I say? All people - both Jews and non-Jews - should wake up as quickly as possible to the *Incarnate Wisdom of God (Yeshua=Jesus)* and accept the *New Testament* in which there is no violence!
❤❤❤ Truth
Thanks for truth
Thank you, Professor Avi..
I am so happy the real Jews are speaking out, like this distinguished gentleman, and also esteemed American professor , Norman Finklestein.
They will provide the true story of this tragedy happening to the Palestinians.
PALESTINIANS must have their own country, exactly like the United Nations declared in the 1940s.
Yeah, your leader Haj Amin Al Husseini ruined that. Blame him. And yourselves, not anyone else.
@@yiddisheideasah yah the people that’s fighting of an illegal invader and occupier are the ones to blame🥴🥴
@@doubletapthatdotty4597 who invaded? And when?
@@yiddisheideas Israel. 1948. Nakba. That land wasn’t the land you were given in the British mandate. It was land you chose to invade. Doesn’t matter what you say. It happened. It’s part of world history.
@@doubletapthatdotty4597 never happened. Jews never invaded and the British didn't give anything to the Jews.
In 1948 The British moved out and the Arab Armies moved in to kill all the Jews and ethnically cleanse the land of Jews.
Now you try to rewrite history?
We have to apologise for successfully defending ourselves?
The Land of Israel is the ancestral homeland of the Jews. Backed by the continued presence of Jews in Israel for 3,300 years and the abundance of archaeological and historical evidence of such.
Jews didn't steal land. They lived there all along. European Jews came back to the Land of Israel, then under Ottoman sovreignty and PURCHASED back their ancestral homeland.
Lands were paid for in full cash. The Jews were fair and honest, paying extra, more than the real value. This is all recorded in the Ottoman Tabu property registry, which still exists today.
Jews purchased vast lands on the Mediterranean coast line, Jezreel Valley and Jordan Valley.
Jew invested infinite funds into the infrastructure, and laboured hard to make these lands inhabitable and bear fruit.
Jews endured severe poverty and diseases for the merit of rebuilding the ruins of their ancient lands. All done legally and recognised officially. It wasn't easy, as all to often they were restricted and forbidden to buy lands (Apartheid huh?)
The Ottoman Empire collapsed during WW1, with no association to the Jews. World War One had to stop. So who gets sovreignty over Ottoman lands? That was the question at the time. The San Remo surrender agreement acknowledged the Jewish presence and their investment in the lands.
Of course the Jews who lived there and owned land legally seeked self determination and governance. Why not? Isn't it their right too?
They didn't seek to colonise lands owned by Arabs, neither did they seek to govern Arabs. Their rights were recognised in the treaties made to end WW1, and was signed by all sides, recognised by the International community.
Sovreignty wasn't served back then by ethnic groupage. See Iraq, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt etc.. Sovreignty was served by political activism, victory at battle and national alliances.
The Jews legally owned the majority of the lands allocated to them in the 1947 partition plan. The Arabs were to get way more than the Jews. They did already, 80% of British Mandate Palestine was given to Jordan. But even the 20% left, was to be divided in the favour of the Arabs. But the Arabs didn't accept any type of Jewish presence in the land, and reverted to terror and murder in order to negate the Jews of their private lands and any type of autonomy. Why??? Isn't that grand theft? Isn't that discrimination? Isn't that ethnic cleansing? Apartheid?
The "Palestinians" together with the Arab League armies launched a coordinated campaign against the Jews in 1948, attempting to annihilate them totally. The Arabs invaded, not the Jews. The Arabs tried to ethnically cleanse the land of Jews. A real genocide attempt.
Jordan invaded, so did Egypt. They took Judea & Samaria and the Gaza strip. They evicted the Jews who lived in those areas. Stole there homes, stole their lands and destroyed their synagogues.
The newborn state of Israel managed to defend itself and to hang on to their lands. Israel granted equal rights and citizenship to the Arab population within its borders. So now we are invaders? You kidding?
The Arab League countries, upset with their defeat, expelled all their Jewish citizens from their homes, taking their lands and businesses. Some 700,000 Jews who lived in those lands for thousands of years, were brutally evicted and thrown out with no right of return. Did anyone bat an eyelid? No!!
The Arab states never accepted the State of Israel’s existence, not for a moment. There was no occupation from 1949 to 1967, but see, a Palestinian state wasn’t established, because the leaders of the Arab world didn’t want another state. They wanted Israel. They didn’t hide their intentions for a minute.
In 1964 on the backdrop of a conflict over the water sources, the Arab League convened in Cairo and announced: “... collective Arab military preparations, when they are completed, will constitute the ultimate practical means for the final liquidation of Israel.”
Two years went by, and then-defense minister Hafez Assad, who went on to become Syria's president, declared: "Strike the enemy’s settlements, turn them into dust, pave the Arab roads with the skulls of Jews.” And to erase any doubt, he added: "We are determined to saturate this earth with your (Israeli) blood, to throw you into the sea.”
Back to the Palestinians. The so called "Palestinians" themselves are and were squatters and migrants, Nazi collaboraters and antisemites. Trouble makers. Since when was the land theirs? They never had sovreignty over any parts of the land. Never. They never were a unified collective society. Within their artificial groupage, they don't share the same heritage, ethnicity or culture. Many didn't intermarry or have social interactions. The various families and tribes came to the Land at different times, and under different circumstances. Never did they have anything in common. Quite the contrary, they had frequent battles, fueds and rivalry between them.
Why would anyone think of giving them sovreignty?? On what merit? That's why, as mentioned, the Jordanians, Syrians and the Egyptians kept the lands for themselves after the 1948.
War has consequences, so don't start them. You can't rewind the clock of history, neither should we try to re-wire a geo-political time-bomb.
Summary, the land never belonged to the so called Palestinians. They refused countless offers for statehood, and betted on terror as a better means to attain sovreignty. They have a track record of 100 years of terror. They betrayed the worlds trust by not adhering to the Oslo Accords they agreed to. Even within their own societal fabric they are fighting for governance. Hamas VS Fatah VS Islamic Jihad VS Lions Den etc...
How can you agree to anything with anyone, if their governing body can change any day and retract their commitments. No one in their right mind is gonna trust them on anything again. Forget it.
Recheck your claims. They are simply false.
I love this man. He's got such a sweet and gentle nature, and speaks the truth
Thank you Mr. Avi Shlaim
I’ve probably met 8-10 Iraqi people in my life and they were all very nice, respectful and also highly educated people!
Apart from Israel, Muslims actually don't seem to have an issue at all with Jews. Their religion even teaches them Jews are people of God, they can eat Kosher foods and are overall praised as righteous people
Sure! There is more anti semetism in Quran than Mein Kempf. Islam is dualist do it can be misleading. Abrogation means we must deal with the later doctrine which takes precedence.
The took the most holy place for Jews and claimed it for themselfs.
Over all the centuries, millions of Jews left Muslim countries to got to Europe. Why?
Most Jews today live today either in Isreal or a western country. In Muslim countries, there are just a few thousands left.
@@epona1525the Zion did that to the Jews in Arab land. They create chaos so that all the Jews would migrate to israhell to populate. Listen to Avi from the beginning and you'll understand why.
@@epona1525two big misconceptions there. You can visit Spain where you can see Jewish neighborhoods still standing among Muslim heritage sites. The same can be found around the Arab world now. The Jews have always followed Muslims. Jews left the Arab world because the haganah (Jewish terrorist group, the idf now) committed crimes against them to get them to move to the newly established Israel. Hope I’ve answered your questions.
@@epona1525maybe check out the lavon affair or get to know the haganah to know why.
The Western colonialisation had cause a major impact not just in Israel or the arabs world but in asian countries too where we had to follow the Western system that not suitable for us in our community or our countries
Let's not forget the pre-Columbus Americas where many people co-existed with each other peacefully for the most part.
You forgot the Arab and european slaveries and after this,europeans colonizations since.1885.Divide empires and utilizes an minority to fight the majority even far from their contry,they became soldiers for them.
,
,,
@@teemadarif8243 what absolute claptrap, the 'native americans' who colonised north america by crossing the Bering Sea land bridge from Asia were constantly warring tribes comitting genocides on enemy tribes, stealing one anothers land and taking slaves. READ HISTORY NOT FAIRY TALES.
We need more people like this gentleman to speak up the truth.
Fact: the Iraqi minister of finance was a Jew very well respected personally Mr. Heskel.
The truth !!!
The truth is finally spoken, Well done Professor.
Thanks for speaking the truth
He reminds me of Abdul Aziz a Catholic who was Iraq foreign minister
Thank you Avi. Say this to the zi-onists and their supporters
Absolutely tru words, this is something u would never hear nowadays as the west would always cover this up, they always blame islam
Bravo Mr Avi Shlaim
Thank you for sharing this information, not something we would know without a personal experience. God bless you sir. I can’t believe the church would do that but I will say Judaism and Islam have the most in common and what is happening right now is Gaza is heart breaking. Free Palestine. God bless you sir for sharing.
Lindus are the only one who are not happy after watching this video
Thank you so much for speaking out and sheading light on the reality of life in the middle east
I’m an Arab Syrian and I met a Jewish mizrahi woman who came from my region. I saw her as a fellow native of Jewish faith and not just a “Jew”
Excellent thanks
gd bless this man for speaking the truth of our people.
That’s absolutely true I’m iraqi myself and my grandmother was telling me stories of their jewish neighbors they were a very peaceful family and highly respected because of theri kindness and manners it’s until the 70s or something like that where jewes start to leave the country
He seems so sweet
Hear ye, hear ye with thy heart and thy mind.
Thanks for speaking out!
Brave man
We're Anti-Zionist not anti-semitic
Anti-Zionism = anti-War.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Thank you for speaking the truth
I can listen to this guy all day, does he have a CZcams channel?
Just search avi shlaim
I don't think he has his own yt channel but he's being featured as a speaker in a lot of channels
I recomend a recent moving debate at the university. It also was Ilan Pappé.
Thank you Jewish brother 👏🇵🇸👏
RESPECT n thank you sir for educating the world at this perfect timing! this is what the world needed to know
Thank you, sir 🙏
Jazak allah khair for speaking out loud about this. ❤ freedom for Palestine 🇵🇸!!!
A man who speaks the truth.
Needs to be told to the world!
Respect ❤
He is telling the truth because we’re all brothers and sisters
A long history of religious tolerance in Iraq says the professor. Sure. Until the Farhoud in 1941 in Baghdad when locals went on the rampage and killed 140 Jews. Many more were imprisoned. Their properties were confiscated. By 1948 and the founding of the state of Israel it was clear to Iraqi Jews that they had to get out and they came to Israel. Today there is no Jewish community in Iraq after a presence of almost 4500 years. They may have imported anti-Semitism from Europe, but they embraced it with great enthusiasm.
I hope everyone understands as you gentleman thank you ❤❤❤❤❤🎉❤
My boys fro' is on point ... looking good while dropping the good truth
❤❤❤ thank information important
❤
thank you sir for explaining it so eloquently...
Thank you for your message.
❤❤❤
Thank you, Sir.
For your information about jews in Arab and in Europe.
Dr. Shlaim 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
I’ve always known that and I’ve always said that as well.
Absolutely right
A professor! He makes the same mistake of antisemitism accusations.
Semitism doesn't mean jews, it means the nations that are the descendants of Shem.
Arabs are one of the Semitic nations.
But ashkNAZi are the descendants of Japheth.
So this accusation isn't real, and not true.
He is Semitic because of his ancestors.
zioNAZī invented this accusation while they aren't Semitic at all. Above that for them it means language even though Arabic is Semitic language. It is not an exclusive title.
@@huseyinates1367 The Iraqis and other peoples, as long as they don't take Arab Islam so seriously, it's good to live together. If the Islamists, Salafists and other Islamic zealots want to move closer to the model of Arab Islam, then the greatest catastrophes will happen because the origin and model of Arab Islam is bloody and not clean. That's a fact, my brother!
History is evident that Muslims had always safe jews.
A❤ BRAVO
Arab jews must be brought into peace talks between palestinian arabs and Israelis. Jews as a whole are very good people.
Arab jews in Israel 🇮🇱 they says its pelestine we r pelestinian not Israeli 🇮🇱 !
The majority participated in the 1948 Nakbe and still participate in the current genocide. Unfortunately, they were convinced to leave Morocco, Iraq , Yemen etc(despite living in peace there) to become Zionists in Palestine. They are Zionists, no peace with Zionists.
@@sheiksaleem3790i don’t understand what you mean
Well speak sir,
Thanks for the truth
Merci pour ce rappel.
Abraham was from Iraq , the city of Ur when Iraq was called Chaldea, he was an Arab .
ooof, as usual, euorope is the main problem...
Yes, and yet the arabs muslims like to emigrate to europe.
Muslims are very kind misunderstood forgiving people on the planet ❤❤❤🎉
Well said, Sir 👏
Nothing but facts here!!
And who is going challenge this PROFESSOR??
I raise my mango juice glass to you Sir!!
Cheers!!
I'm. Flabbergasted. Not.
And yet. If you ask the average American, he'll say this has been going on for centuries.
An honest talk .
Thaaanks for telling the truth about arabs
Thank you sir for the True.
Perhaps you should tell that to millions of the Jews who no longer live in Arab or Muslim countries. Apparently, they never got the memo.
The Levan Affair would like a word with you.
Truth
Brilliant man I Love him ❣️
A verdade liberta.
Precisely 💯
Well said 👏🏻