Vocal Coach Reacts to Pussycat Dolls 'Tainted Love' (E.p. 2 Pussycat Dolls)
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
- **Do you want a singing critique from me?
Send me your clip:
www.wisio.com/...
**The Foundations of Singing - Online Course is NOW LIVE!
This course is ideal for beginners or those wanting to know more about the technique of singing and have a daily vocal routine.
Take the course:
www.udemy.com/...
**Let me be your vocal coach & mentor (1 x 30 minute vocal session or 4 x 30 minute session via SKYPE per month plus mentoring throughout the month)
SIGN UP: / thehonestvocalcoach
Twitter: / thehonestvocal
Instagram: / thehonestvocalcoach
I am the honest vocal coach! I have been teaching for 16 years and been singing since I was 16. I teach from my own studio and also teach and mentor via email, and online via Live & Skype. I specialise in teaching children, and teenagers pop and musical theatre but I am trained in all genres of music. I have studied every voice technique there is, including Speech Level Singing, Estill, Bel Canto, Robert Lunte, London College of Music, ABRSM, Ria Keen, Kim Chandler, Stevie Van Lange and many more. I have been around!
In 2008 I wrote the Vocaltutor Guide, 21 set lessons for singing teachers to get started, learning to teach, and produced 3 vocal exercise CD/Downloads.
#thehonestvocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts
This video is for educational purposes and is not intended to infringe any copyright.
Carmit's voice is awesome. I can't understand why they didn't let her sing more in the group. Same for Melody.
The other blond girl can sing a lot too. OMG.
From what I remember.... The Pussycat Dolls was a burlesque dance group of girls created by Robin Antin way before the band we know today with Nicole. Robin is actually one of the dancers in white in this video. Nicole wasn't a part of the group originally. The third singer I believe was the original lead vocalist. Carmen Electra used to be the one that you would see front and center when they were doing their burlesque shows. I think Carmit, Ashley, and Kimberly were original dancers from the the group.
Sunset Beach That makes sense then. They do get a bit carried away with their dancing, IMHO.
No, the third girl is Kaya Jones. She's with them for 1 performance which is this one and then they kicked her out cause she can't dance.
There wasn't any lead vocalist. They had guest vocalists such as Carmen or Christina Aguilera. Nicole was signed to be the lead vocalist.
@@windlife there's another performance of tainted love with Kaya... Carmen Electra was singing with them in this one too. Kaya is also in the music video of sway.
Carmit is in the Pussycat Dolls since the beginning...she was part of the burlesque line up and was kept in the recording group. Ashley, Kimberly and Jessica are all professional dancers and got in the Pussycat Dolls around 2000s. Nicole, Melody and Kaya auditioned for the Pussycat Dolls when they were looking for singers to set them as a recording group.
Even if it's prerecorded I'm still shook that they can even halfway sing since I've literally never heard them besides Melody.
This performance was in 2004. So very early in their career. The blond girl who is singing is Kaya Jones. Kaya Jones, Cyia Batten, and Kasey Campbell left, and then Ashely, Jessica, and Kimberly got “promoted” to have a mic aswell
Jessica, Ashley and Kim had mics here
art1ej Yes but first in the end. Plus if you look at other performances, they don’t have a mic
My love this is the old Pussycat Dolls, which they reduced to 6 girls later at that year and Nicole has trained her voice a lot since then. You should watch their lives after their first album PCD. Love you Georgina you are the sweetest 💞💞💞
The outfits are perfect. They're burlesque dancers turned pop group. Their half time dance routines are always fire.
This was very early on before don’t cha so their was tons of girls love this song and the blonde was kaya jones who was in band for a cup of coffee but love this song great analysis as always Georgina could you do GRL soon who was meant to be the next generation of Pussycat Dolls xxx
Kaya Jones is trash I’m glad she left...GRL I loved but they never really got the chance to develop their vocals really as they danced a lot and didn’t harmonise- in terms of singing Jazzy and Paula were the least vocally talented, then Lauren, then Emmalyn/Natasha and I would say Simone (RIP) was the one that had the best control and the most potential it’s a shame she ended her life she was very talented and the group had so much potential 😔
The blonde quit PCD earlier. Yes Carmit can sing but their concept is different coz they hired Nicole to be the lead singer and she write almost of the Song.
Andy Beeres yep agreed and shame about Simone so much potential grl where amazing x
Jophet Levy yep that’s true carmit is better than kaya x
Justpaul thx corrected auto spelling x
You should maka a review of each girl's solo lives! That would be interesting!
This performance is from Fashion Rocks 2004 where the intro sang Marc Almond. Back then The Pussycat Dolls were a whopping 10(!) member group including singers: Nicole Scherzinger, Carmit Bachar, Melody Thornton & Kaya Jones, and dancers: Robin Antin, Cyia Batten, Kasey Campbell, Ashley Roberts, Jessica Sutta & Kimberly Wyatt. Shortly after Kaya Jones left and then Cyia & Kasey. Then Robin stopped down from being a member to managing the group and the rest is history 🤗
I've always wondered if a studio version of this live was originally supposed to be on the PCD album, instead they had to replace Kaya Jones' part right after she left the group so they added the "Where did our love go" part before releasing the album.
I think you should analyze the girls individually. Like the way you did with Spice Girls and Girls Aloud. Each one of them have a solo career, so they have live performances. I'm looking forward for a reaction of Ashley's live performances.
Melody voice❤
Nicole's voice improves a lot. And she sings live very well ❤️
This was first song I loved PCD and Carmit Bachar. How I wish Nicole would agree and speak it to contribute line amongst the dolls. Listen to Jessica Sutta - White Lies, Ashley Robert - Woman Up, Clockwise.
*Clockwork
Omg can’t believe u reacted to this video because I watched this live performance a million times for Nicole’s last verse because she killed it.
i dont think the blonde was ashley.... I think that was the memeber kaya jones?
Yes it is kaya, ashley is with the dancers in white with kimbery and jessica
Yes, Kaya Jones
In this performance.. The Group hadn't released an album yet.
at the time the group was
Nicole
Melody
Carmit
Kaya Jones- (She left group before first album)
(Dancers)
Jessica - joined before first album
Ashley- joined before album
(Kimberly hadnt joined yet)
Jordan Lake and Cyia and Kasey
Kim is there, along with Robin Antin
I was watching this performance last week and wondered if you would critique it. I love how they performed this song!!!
I love this! You should do one where you review the PCD members solo efforts live.
this was from when they had more dancers from 2002-2004 but they left before Dont Cha came out
It’s really nice to have the pussycat dolls back in recent times
The 3rd girl totally copied her outfit off Britney.
Jamie Stewart lol true
They don’t choose their outfits haha
Everyone here was lip syncing except Nicole. There is another performance all of these girls (including Carmen Electra) doing Tainted Love at a different venue. The vocals are identical .
So I think either they used the live audio recording for each solo from that one for this, or the solos were pre-recorded for both.
Hey Georgina! Loving the series so far. You can get a look from their Manchester concert which is pretty awesome, their cover for "Whole Lotta Love", their Doll Domination when each doll has her solo song. Keep up the awesome concert. I'd love it if you can collect a few videos as you did with the Spice Girls and raking each vocalist from the group. Love your analysis 👌
This was before there first single was released
All 4 girls mics were on but the auto tuned was just played with the track
They're not live. People have pointed out already the audio for the other girls is the exact same as a prior performance. Carmit moves her head around a lot while lip sycning and there's zero change in the sound, and Kaya Jones straight up misses the timing during her second part so the audio starts playing before her mouth is near her mic.
I always thought Carmits part was prerecorded. Glad I’m not the only one with good ears 😂
The blonde is maya jones and left the group right before being announced as a recording group. The other two members that were in the beginning with Nicole are in the recording group. Carmit and Melody. The ladies that are also in the recording group now and not singing in this performance are actually dancing in white as well as the PCD creator Robin Antin. There are plenty of women because they are all Pussycat doll dancers from the Original PCD lounge and show at the Viper Room where the Pussycat Dolls started. I’ll be watching these so I’ll help you lol
Melody’s mic was live
False
Hey Georgina, this is back when they had 10 girls. 4 main (which were Nicole, Kaya, Melody, and Carmit) and others were dancers/background vocalists (Jessica, Ashley, Robin, Cyia, Kasey, and Kim)...
This was when they were transitioning from Burlesque to Brand and 3 of the lead girls here left before the official launch. Battan, Campbell, Jones left. 2 of them were in the 1st video dont cha .. and kim has said before that even shooting there 1st single there places wernt safe....
Shame they couldn't all sing leads back then.
Let's hope it's different on the new album!
Very odd to have 6 girls and 1 lead singer and another doing the odd adlib and not even singing a verse in any singles ....I will never understand that idea...
#2020relaunch
#react
#sharedvocals
#vocalharmoneydancegroup
Carl Leroy Official who’s places weren’t safe ?
@@chynamarie5244 most of the girls bar nicole and carmit as far as I know.
Correction: All 10 of them including Robin Antin, Kaya Jones, Cyia Batten, and Kasey Campbell were in Sway music video... not Don't Cha.
In Don't Cha music video, Robin made a cameo towards the end of the video, but the seventh girl who was dancing with them was Claude Racine, who was auditioning to be a part of the group against Kimberly who was already there 2 years prior. Claude only lasted a week in the group.
Holy guacamole! Where do they grow these women?! 😲 #flawless
Omg!! I had never been heard ... Thank you dear coach :3
These extra girls are from the pussycat doll lounge which was in Las Vegas.
Please react to their performance to Fever & Big Spender. You should also check out the other girls songs on the doll domination deluxe.
For live vocals of the other girls check out:
Melody: Cage bird sings & her medley of Aretha Franklin & etta james (it was on the morning show)
Jessica: she performed Don't cha & check out "don't you worry child." Defenitely check out Don't you worry child because it really shows off her vocals.
Ashley: check out her performance of her song Clockwork
Carmit: check out her singing the national anthem, she performed it at some boxing match
Kimberly: I couldn't find too much live vocals from her, but she does sing live on a song called Candy. Then she sings live with Taio Cruz on a song called "Higher." She also sings one of her songs called "Stars In Your Eyes", but it is autotuned a lot, so you can't really tell what she is doing vocally.
Pussycat dolls, my forever fav girl band. The Blonde girl is Kaya Jones. She's such a beauty. Actually, she was a part of the group initially and later left due to some personal differences. She can also been in the Sway music video, she was the tallest in the group, 5'11. I love her voice.
Though, the rest of the dolls can sing, but, they weren't allowed then and aren't allowed now either. My fav dolls are, Ashley, Kaya, Jessica & Kimberly!
Lol I was thinking the exact same thing! Mulling over the fact you don’t wear suspenders belts with trousers 🤔
So Aubrey O'day from Danity Kane says they toured with the Pussycat Dolls and they all shared the same in ear pieces and that when the Pussycat Dolls performed only one of the singers mics was ever on.
The blondes kaya... she left before the group took off, she didn't want to be a background dancer to nicole. Shes also recently made claims about the pussycat dolls burlesque group having prostitution involved.
She made that claim, and it was refuted. Her claim is dependent on the other members agreeing with her, but every single Pussycat Doll - past and present - have all denied those claims. This includes Dolls who aren't in the industry anymore and those who have bad blood with Robin Antin i.e women with zero to lose by confirming those claims.
@@Nocturne22it’s her experience how are you gonna say it’s refuted despite what the others have said, there’s no proof or not what really happened so please go somewhere else
Melody and Nicole were live. The other girl was Kayla who was v briefly in the group. This performance was pre Dontcha release. There’s the initial 6 pussycats with Robyn Antin the Creator and Kayla, maybe another dancer. After this it seems the group was altered for the band. With Carmit and Melody having to step back.
This performance was from before they released Don’t Cha. When they were turning the burlesque troupe into a recording act. Before Kaya Jones left.
I think Nicole may have been slightly sick or something.. Cuz Wii all know she got pipes 🎶
Everyone in the vocal community knows that Nicole is both good and bad vocalist..her headvoice is gorgeous but her mixed voice omg, no just no..
Carmit and Melody are singing LIVE , the backing vocals were just too loud. At some point you could hear Carmit was out of breath and you didnt hear her voice when she stopped singing so she was live.
(My English aint that good)
i noticed that too, only nicole is live in this performance, as well as another similar performance of the song. trust me, no way melody would sound so well controlled if it were live
There were 9 pussycat dolls when they got the deal and started performing but Kaya Jones and Carmen Electra left before the album came out and their choreographer Robin Antin stopped going on stage
the pussycats dolls are so amazing
I really loved this performance by them I thought all of their voices sounded really cool and sexy with the higher pitch but I agree with Nicole doing that low bit out of nowhere 😂 and they all looked super hot especially Nicole here
Great video, so interesting to see them early in their career! Haha
Nicole is obviously the best and strongest singer but I'm intrigued to see where you think the rest lie. Melody is a good singer when she isn't forcing it to get into the limelight, and Carmit (the redhead) has a unique tone to her voice, she's definitely the one who takes the lower harmonies. Carmit's, the blonde one's (who I thought was the singer from Cascada lol) and Melody's parts sound pre-recorded or very autotuned.
I absolutely love this performance and I think they were awesome
Their tour performance of this song, they're actually singing live.
Nicole, Carmite and Melody were the only singers in the group and that wasnt hidden. It was a dance group beforehand anyway and you go with your strongest singer which is and was Nicole
Jessica and Ashley were singers as well: they sang before Nicole/Melody/Kaya ever joined, and were made backup signers after Kaya left as the label wanted to bolster the vocal ranks some more. The problem is, they never got the chance to sing (though Jessica got a couple tracks right when the group was ending). Kim was one of the members that was a pure dancer, along with Robin, Cyia, Kasey and Claude. Her even being in the group was up in the air until AFTER they filmed Don't Cha, since at that point all the other pure dancers had left and they weren't sure if they wanted her in the group when she can't sing.
Perfect Time Holidays are here to react to Mariah Carey’s Very 1st Christmas Album. In your Professional Opinion is there a Female Vocalist who can come CLOSE ???
to the ICON LEGEND, PLEASE and
Thank You !!! SAFE HOLIDAYS !!!
Can't you tell melody is singing live.....😐
Carmit wasn't singing live. I think Nicole was the only one singing live (not 100% sure about Melody). There were some Destiny's Child performances in which Beyoncé was singing live and Kelly was lip-syncing (sometimes Michele was lipping and other times singing live).
Wait what, the other girl's voice don't sound pre-recorded.
Yess go Carmit
I like this performance but I like the one with Carmen Electra more
That blonde one wasn't a PCD member was she? Cuz Ashley was in white & I think Kimberley was in White as well and so was Jess
luke fletcher nope! Kaya Jones is her name. When they created the group we know now, they hired 3 singers: Nicole, Melody and Kaya. The rest were dancers. In 2004, Kaya Jones decided to quit because she didn’t feel like she was a dancer. Notice how she came in later and didn’t dance at all.
Great performance actually
Okayyy but let's admit it, Nicole is the strongest and best singer.
Lucy D actually melody is just as strong she just doesn’t get the chance to show case her voice
Matthew Lapping she’s not her tome is not great and neither is her technique. Nicole is a classically good singer
@@125blondi nah, melody is good but is very pitchy.. nicole is a phenomenal vocalist
Nicole is really good! We needed to hear her more here if that was possible!
Scorpions did a cracking version of this song, yes really!
Just okay for me...that was sort of weird.
The other doesn't have to sing, the pussycat dolls was a burlesque dance group and in this kind of show, there are a group leader and the other girls follow her like chores or dancers. That's why they don't sing that much. Melody can sing but she is not chosen because of the artistic direction
sorry for my english I hope that I'm understood
Her growl was very good
Find "I don't need a man" To hear Carmit sing live. It's not much but she does sound like this video live. Not sure why they didn't let them sing live here
Not Prison inmates 😂😂😂
At this point Nicole had only been in a one hit wonder girl group and mostly spent her time singing in a rock group. Her gravely vocals dont surprise me. Maybe you need to do some background research into the videos you watch? That might add some value into your critique :)
Loved the video anyway.
That was good
i like this little symbol of czech tv station 😀😀😀
This was the firsr formation of the group, and then most of them went off the group and left the 6 we all know
I think the blond girl was kaya? Before they released don’t cha
Ali Tahsin yes
Nicole’s mic was on because she wasn’t good at lipsyncing
Isn’t the blonde girl Ashley Roberts?
Is that kaya jones? Is this performance from their perfomance before they realease fisrt album?
dadangra1476 Yes its Kaya, and yes its before their album PCD was made
Melody sings live too .
I think they’re all singing live
Eu sempre vou exaltar a beleza da Nicole, mas essa live é tão perfeita! A dança, os vocais... amo! ❤
Have you coloured your hair Georgina? (sorry, off topic)
@@HonestVocalCoach I think orange suits you.... You should go even more vibrant (like it was in your old intro) x
It’s funny how everyone always say that Carmit should have a chance to sing etc... she got a chance to prove herself but decide to use auto tune or pre-recorded her lines ...
You think it was her choice lol? When she left the group in 2008 she did a live stage show called Zodiac (find it on CZcams) and she sang live throughout and sounded great.
I wish record companies wouldn’t rehash Northern Soul tracks in a horrible way and where the original artist gets no recognition, it was bad enough when they first did the record as it ‘wasn’t Motown' ,they were poorly paid and overworked and a fair few died young, very sad indeed
My nicki is the besy..... Period.
U should have chosen a less old video, Nicole is so young and her voice as well. U know better than me how good she is
The Honest Vocal Coach I might agree but this is not even the pussycat dolls, this is a bunch of dancers plus Nicole and few pussycat...come on
hello, well to be honest there is a lot of production behind their voices, nicole according to has the best voice, in my opinion her voice is a bit forced, as always trying to show that she reaches high musical notes, and that all the time It's not good, it would be interesting to hear a more real voice more personal, and the other girls should sing more live
Out of all the girls, Nicole is the most reliable when it comes to live singing.
At this point Nicole was suffering from bulimia so she was actually very inconsistent. Melody oversang depending on her mood. Carmit was the most consistent when she was there. I think because she never went over the top, people tend to forget her vocal contributions.
Sorry, but I prefer Marilyn Manson’s version of this song 🙃. This was nothing special 😏.
“Yeth it is” 😂😂🙌🏻🙌🏻 Seems to me its cos the producers know that Nicole can sing!?
Nicole is a goddess!
Best girl bands of all time:
1. TLC
2. Destiny's child
3. The Supremes
4. Spice girls
5. En vogue
6. Pussycat dolls
7. Little mix
What is everyone's opinion?
Acordding to talent: little mix... they sing and dance all equality good... and success probably the spice girls!
Annie are you ok? Girls aloud and the sugababes ofc
Spice Girls above En Vogue?! REALLY!?
Personally I put supreme first cuz they were the first. Then the spice girls just cuz they are just like no other girl group in my opinion. Many of these groups from tlc, destiny’s child, etc. seem so similar to each other.
SUGABABES AND SUGABABES THE 1ST 4 ALBUMS
Another hot mess from PCD 'live.'
@@HonestVocalCoach I just have such conflicting feelings about this band. Some awesome tracks (song/vid for Buttons is sooo good), and when it's on point some great performances. However NS's ego and ambitions over the other girls and refusal to truly let another member shine, really really bugs me.
Btw did you ever check out Red Velvet? So so good
Ice Cream Cake
Automatic
Bad Boy
Peek-a-Boo
I'm sure you'll dig them.
we all know ns is th only one that can actually sing xxxx
Melody used to be the stronger singer amd stronger than Nicole. That's partly why she didn't return, because she felt robbed
Melody is a mess, dude, she's flat af and the tone of her voice is so nasal...
Melody has absolutely NEVER been a stronger singer than Nicole. Every performance Ive seen where Melody gets her moments she lacks control and is all over the place
Whaaat? Melody was always out of tune live.
Stronger singer?? BAHAHAHAH
@@danno1375 Yup, she's always trying to make the best of her 3 seconds by doing her crazy annoying runs
Great dancers.
Extremely embarrassing live, though.
Nicole sings well but she's so selfish and greedy... don't like her.
Again.. this was a mess. I think they work best on music videos but “live”.... NOT SO MUCH 🤷🏻♀️
What a terrible cover, that interpretation just sucks, it goes from 60' to 2000' in style.