Landing in Bad Weather - DISASTER BREAKDOWN
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 01. 2021
- This video went out to my Patrons 48 hours before going live on CZcams:
Sources:
www.ntsb.gov/investigations/A...
web.archive.org/web/201606251...
www.erh.noaa.gov/gsp/tdwr/info/specs.html
www.avjk5022.com/avjk5022/publ...
web.archive.org/web/201602040...
www.rapoportlaw.com/verdicts-...
www.cad.gov.hk/reports/main1.pdf
www.boeing.com/resources/boein...
www.dailymotion.com/video/x6u...
This video went out 48 hours earlier for my Patrons on Patreon. You can join here from £3 per month: www.patreon.com/DisasterBreakdown
Am now a Patron
@@MarieInnes Thank you so much.
@@BrainScramblies Please feel free to critique my grammar and everything I really want to improve my presentation. I really should know better as I am English and should know my own language but constructive criticism is welcome, whether you are a Patron or not :)
The videos do go out early to Patrons and I have found myself having to amend something here and there before it publicly goes out.
Thanks, Anthony.
Great work as usual & very informative , thanks for your dedication , time & hard work .. cheers ..
@@MarieInnes who r u
Who else is addicted to watching planes documentary 😅
Yes
I take a break for sinking ships and footage of natural disasters sometimes!
Have been addicted for around 3 years, to the point of critiquing different videos of the same crash!
@@MarieInnes me too
@@BrainScramblies Love that channel
Stories like these are why, as a passenger, I never gripe when my flight gets delayed or rerouted. I’d rather get there late than not at all.
Great job as always! Very informative.
I’m the exact same, better to be safe than sorry
@@BeingMeXOX won't have a chance to be sorry
It depends on why the flight gets delayed. Weather, yes I’m understanding. Catering running late? I would rather be hungry than arrive late!
@Chaz Elechia love this comment lol
This.
Seeing the video of 642 I would not have guessed only 3 people died. Terrifying footage.
I like the fact that you took the trouble of defining a few words. Some of us are not pilots and appreciate less jargon, or at least appreciate explanations.
I'm literally shocked that only 3 people died in that second crash. Given the size of that fireball in the video, I assumed it was a total disaster. It's frankly a miracle.
Cuz the Fire station was extremely close to the crash site, the fire fighters and ambulances were there in minutes, however one of the casualties onboard died cuz he/she decided to not buckle his/her seat belt
I'm of the impression that because of the weather combined with the proximity of the Fire Station, the fire was dealt with in a short matter so it effectively minimized the amount of casualties that could've happened.
Maybe we have all become too gung-ho, expecting technology to beat the elements in getting us wherever I want to go, when I want to go?
No aircraft can outfly thunderstorm microbursts/windshear safely.
A favourite saying us pilots have goes: 'Better to be down here wishing I was up there, than up there wishing I was down here.'
Absolutely true. Another thing to remember regarding the tech we have is that we fly the weather we find, not the weather that's forecast.
@@CarterHancock Ooo yeah! I learnt that one the hard way on my 2nd solo navex in training. The forecast for Canberra was ok but the real situation was a trap for this beginner. I was on top of 7 oktas of cloud over Canberra with no experience, cloud in front of me and a with microphone failure as well.
@@MrKylehornsey Ooo ouch that's a tough one. Mic failure certainly didn't help I imagine. How'd you get out of it?
@@CarterHancock Full power, no clearance but climbed over the cloud anyway, found mic on the floor (PTT switch was u/s) then controller gave me change of runway too. Phew! Never so glad to stand on terra firma.
@@MrKylehornsey Awesome, good pilot decision-making. Haven't had any weather encounters like that but I lost a radio while inside the SFRA around Washington, DC... yeah they don't tend to like that
Without meaning to disrespect the passengers and crew who died, this is an extremely well made and professional mini documentary. Thankyou.
Thanks so much for your comment, I appreciate it.
Michael Origel, the FO for American Flight 1420, is still flying with AA today. China Airlines had publicly disputed the final reports of virtually all their fatal accidents in the 90's and 2000's as an attempt to save face from their poor safety record. The disintegration of Flight 611 in 2002 finally made China Airlines to swallow their pride and made necessary changes behind the scenes, even though they also disputed that accident's cause at first. There hasn't been a fatal crash involving China Airlines ever since.
Dynasty is certainly the most reliable & consistent cargo carrier at my field. Back in 2013 a 747 (cargo) lost a set of inboard flaps - which fell into a lady's house. It's the only hiccup I can recall! Interesting about Origel!
CCP always trying to make everything bad that's happened under their name to disappear. Constantly
0:08 well I didn't expect getting jumpscared by Disaster Breakdown 🤣
pretty annoying actually, 1st one ok (way too loud) but the 2nd and 3rd time it gold old in my view
I just binge watched all your videos, you’re on to something here, keep them coming I wish the best from the bottom of my heart.
Thank you. I'm glad you like my videos.
His work is some of the best on the subject. Very well researched and a good amount of information. I wouldn’t mind of the videos weee even longer, delving into some more of the minute details even.
Slight correction: An ILS does have a localizer but that only gives lateral/horizontal guidance. The ILS has another system, the glideslope , for vertical guidance.
WAIT!
Only 3 fatalities out of 315 passengers?!
WOW
This is why I personally monitor the weather, if it's really bad along the flight path, i rather stay home or wherever i am and not take chances. No schedule is worth more than my life.
Very nice Disaster Breakdown! I've been following you for 1 month and you're doing great! Keep it up!
Thanks so much, I'm glad you like them
@@DisasterBreakdown Literally the best plane crash videos on YT.
@@MarieInnes True
@@MarieInnes - Agree 100%
I'm amazed there were only 3 fatalities! That's a miracle. But still a tragedy
I flew to Florida last year during a hurricane. let me tell you, I will never do that again!!!
sounds scary 🙁glad it went well and nothing happen
Well I've been watching your videos for two straight days now. This is the first one that struck home, hard. I've flown that Dallas to Little Rock AA flight 100s of times in the past few years. I know that flight like the back of my hand, we always land on 22L.
These videos are so interesting and you make them so well! Thank you for keeping us entertained 🤘
Thank you, I'm am thrilled you are enjoying my videos
Been watching your videos tons while recovering from a major health problem gotta say very well done!
Oi! Why did you get me fascinated and addicted to stories of metal birds!!!?? I’ll never forgive you!!
Damn, this is why I don’t complain if the schedule changes. Rather arrive than not at all tbh… It’s also interesting to know how in these two incidents pilots were able to survive. It’s seems to me that for the most part, when there’s a plane crash, the crew in the cockpit almost never makes it to the end. ):
I've just watched about 10 of these in a row. This is great content. Keep it up dude!
I definitely remember American 1420 and, last year, I heard a story from someone who was sitting in their sunroom watching the storm and heard the crash. Sometimes, I see the part of the runway where the overrun occurred and just get a chill.
Great videos, I can see this channel getting much larger. Keep doing what you're doing!
Like Wendover or ColdFusion.
I was there when this happened. there are so many shameful things that happened within the hour or so after the crash. there is so much more to this story.
Absolutely love your narration and editing. Lots of great timings for sound effects. Keep up the good work!
It's appalling that aircraft are permitted to fly in dreadful weather. Better a delay than lose so many lives
Totally addicted to your channel now after binging all the videos in a day, keep 'em coming and I'll never leave! :D
Love that you are uploading very regularly at the moment. This is my favourite channel to see in my subscriptions, keep up the great work mate!
As always great video and story telling, we'll be waiting for next breakdown.
I absolutely love this channel. Great work in breaking down what happened.
Liked before watching. Love this channel
Me too
Thank you, I appreciate it.
Love this channel thankyou for uploading these awesome vids. Can't wait for more! 👏
Fatalities were so low! I was sure none survived on 2nd one.
Loving your work so much, another awesome video ✌🏼
I am amazed only three people died on the Mandarin Air flight. Horrible no matter what, but I was expecting so much worse.
Great video as always.
The storm that was the contributing factor in the crash ended up being the biggest lifesaver that day. The torrential rain quickly extinguished the post-crash fire which prevented the flames from penetrating the cabin.
so am i.i saw that plane the next day on its back,wheels up in the air right in front of the passenger terminal.fuselage blackened.when you think it happened at night and flipped over and there was fire its amazing so many survived.
@@jeffmoore4266 There's an (in)famous post-crash photo of this accident, with an other Mandarin Airlines plane passing in front of the wreckage of Flight 642:
www.airliners.net/photo/Mandarin-Airlines/McDonnell-Douglas-MD-11/44640/L
Amazing that 312 people survived this crash.
Absolutely crazy that more people didn't die. The explosion in the video looked horrific. And the plane even flipped over!
But it seems that even though the wings were destroyed, the fuselage stayed intact for the most part. Combined with the rain helping to put out the fire and people being strapped in their seats for the landing, that probably saved many lives.
I really enjoy your videos! They are extremely informative and your narration is spoken in laymen's terms and very calming to listen to. Great job!!!
Amazing only 3 people perished out of 315 in the second accident shown. That fireball looked like it could have been much much worse.
I know. I was shocked! I'm sure the fast response contributed to that but its still amazing.
Love your vids. Hoping your channel will grow soon!!
Who could have imagined that an even more modified version of the DC-10 had massive design flaws. Thanks for clearing all that up for is 😂
"There's gonna be casualties!"
_ya don't say_
Great video dude, keep it up, this is the type of content that you get big... if anything add more visual animations of the stuff you’re describing... Not only does it help visual what you’re saying but following along is way better
I was on a plane landing in New York during a violent North Easter. I can remember the pilot was basically sideways to the airstrip and I was looking out at nothing but white caps on the ocean. I'm sure he was pushing that plane as far as it could go. I'm absolutely terrified of that kind of Landing now.
So well done! Should have 500k plus subs!
Damn seeing that second plane explode I fully expected there to be no survivors, I was shocked to see so survive.
Thanks for sharing. 😉👌🏼
The problem with the MD-11 was because of its modified tail from the DC-10. It is smaller, so the plane requires a higher landing speed to keep it stable. If speed isn't maintained, , it lands hard and begins to bounce, or porpoise. The pilot then makes the fatal error by fighting the bouncing. He's supposed to let it continue, as it will straighten itself out. Instead, by fighting it the plane can invert just off the ground, as seen in those FedEx crashes.
Consistently producing videos of a high quality 👍👍👌👌
This is a great video man, Keep it up! :)
i have had the luck of flying as a pasenger aboard dc9 up to md 80/82
both on austrian airlines and on scandinavian airlines.
i love the dc9 and the md 80.
my favorite one is sas md80 and dc9.
👍👍👍🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪
again.. an awesome video!
Thanks so much.
That lightning strike scared the 💩 out of me😂
Due to the smaller tailplane of the MD-11 compared to the DC-10 made the MD-11 want to pitch up more. This meant the MD-11 needed to land at higher speeds to counter this pitch up. Crews were instructed to increase thrust just before touch down to slow the aircraft's descent. The stretched fuselage also gave crews the illusion the plane had its main gear firmly on the ground if it for some reason bounced causing them to push the nose down increasing the stress caused by the second bounce to damage the plane's structure.
Flying the MD-11 was like walking a tightrope. It was a stretched DC-10, which was already temperamental to land, not unlike its DC-9/MB-80 siblings.
Your videos are very good. You deserve more subscribers
Just discovered your channel and love it! Subscribed.
The DC-9 and DC-10 families are some of the crashingest damn planes around…
ATR aircraft are even worse
Yes these are great and such a nice polite person doing them!
isn't she
First video I've seen talking about that crash (Mandarin Airlines Flight 642) I've come across in multiple crash compilations. This is probably the most visible example of that video I've seen as the others were genuinely hard to see the accident as it occurs.
1420 should never have taken off, should never have tried to land. Stupid accident. What a waste. Rushed landings are so often a catastrophy.
Little Rock National Airport (Klit) ....they should come up with something other than "Klit". lol.
I did not understand why when AA changed the plane, the allowed working time for pilots extended?
2:50. I love a good crab landing in the morning. Actually morning wind is worse here in FL. If it’s windy in the morning it’s going to be windy all day
I always love your videos and am sure it was great. I wish you would have put flashing light/strobe effect warnings at the beginning of the video alongside your content warning. I have light-sensitive epilepsy and this triggered an episode- I dont want to guilt you I just want you to be aware of this potential problem! Please consider adding these warnings in future videos🙏🙏🙏
Your tower pictures are looking like the tower od Dusseldorf Airport
Love the use of LTR's music c: at least I believe its their music since Its been so long since I heard, but the song at the start certainly sounds like their work!
Took off during a snowstorm in Delaware one time and I'll just say this... never again will I step foot on a plane during those conditions again. It was to the point where I'm positive the plane should not have taken off. But did I die, you may be wondering? Maybe. 👻
😂👻
Looks like the tail flexes
I'm learning how important a good Pilot is!!!!!!!!.
Another great video, and I especially like the coverage of two separate but similar incidents. Now I have what is probably a stupid question - if I go to Patreon with nothing but USD, how do I know the conversion to your categories expressed in £'s ?
There alternate landing was memphis not Nashville. I was on that flight number the day after as scheduled comming back from honeymoon. Needless to say I have a huge fear of flying. Hubby is a AA pilot. He was hoping to withhold info on the crash until I got home, but someone in Dallas let me know why we had to get new tickets. I still gave my original ticket.
HOW did only 3 people die in the second incident
I'm addicted. I like the one's that have survivors
I still have a ticket with this plane number. We were to be on it the day after it crashed coming back from our honeymoon. I hate flying and someone told me about it as American was rebooting my ticket. Needless to say my anxiety was through the roof. It was so bad they had to serve me drinks before we even took off. While about to land Mt drunk ass looked out the window and yelled to everyone on the plane- There's the wreckage! I have never seen windows close faster. And that is only a quarter of that story. Rip to the people and the ones I knew.
underrated
Flying during nasty weather is what gave me PTSD. I refuse to look outside if we’re over the ocean with turbulence. I will end up having panic attacks and lose it. It was a horrible, terrifying experience. I guess flying in the early 2000s was something else
How on God's earth did ANYONE live in that China Air crash?
My local airport was in this
New sub I had a discord buddy recommended this video
I used to fly all the time, but after watching enough of these vídeos, plus my own scary eperience the last time I flew, NEVER AGAIN. NO WAY, NO HOW. I'll take my chances vía car from now on.
I mean if you’re flying in the US there’s been 1 fatality in the last 11 years
Much more likely to be killed in a car accident; no comparison in the safety record of air versus car travel. Just look at the stats.
Ples make im new to this channel and all ready watched all the videos keep up the good work!
Make a video about the charkhi dadri mid air collision
Ripping a wing, cathcing fire, flipping on its back and only so few dead and injured… Wauw!
Wow, Little Rock sure has a spicy ICAO code! 🥵 LOL
You can see why at 62 they won't let you be a captain in most airlines. So stupid to have the answer to the speed problem on take off and then completely ignoring when in the air
I love your channel i watch your vids everyday :)
Thanks, I'm glad you like them :)
I've noticed Chinese almost always dispute investigation findings mostly where pilot error is involved.
Despite the misleading name, China Airlines is actually the flag carrier of the Republic of China (Taiwan), the flag carrier of actual China is Air China, confusing I know.
Please do one for SQ6 (Singapore Airlines).
All safety procedures are written in blood
Such a grim, but true statement
Me too
Pro-tip: If your plane crashes while landing, you can get some of the money you paid for the ticket back, as they didn't fulfill their contract fully, as that contract also included a safe landing.
Please deduct the cost of my ticket from my funeral expenses
@@NickTheFelice For example that, the relatives could ask for that, or possibly for more, depending on your jurisdiction and laws.
Well depending on cause, my family would likely get get wrongful death suit and my life insurance would compound those monies into a favorable outcome. Though, I find a lot of joy in little things like a dead man being refunded his ticket cost.
I’m addicted to her voice 😏
The ICAO for Little Rock airport activated my dirty mind 😐
I'm surprised with modern technology they don't have CCTV cameras in planes
3:43 time travel doesnt exi-
👍
Northwest Flight 710 !
The video of the second crash is horrifying. In a matter of seconds hundreds of people were gone just like that.
no they were not, watch the video
So I think this is actually China airlines but they haven’t have time to change the painting of the plane.
So it was actually China Airline 642 but with the painting of mandarin airline.