QIM 043 Did Imam Bukhari not read this Ayah of the Quran?
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 08. 2023
- QIM 043 Did Imam Bukhari not read this Ayah of the Quran?
#islamic #allah #hadith #quran
Please support our channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
Banking Details
Name of Bank : First National Bank
Account Number : 6208 489 7358
Branch Code : 220 926
Swift Code : FIRNZAJJ
Allah has promised to protect the Quran, not the Hadith of men.
You are right. Thank you for your comment.
Salaamun Alaikum. A very interesting channel. This just shows us how many people claim to be Muslim without knowing the Quran. Thank you for bringing this out.
You are most welcome. I am doing my best with the little knowledge I have. Thank you for your comment.
@@QuranInspiresMehave you heard of a messenger of Allah, Rashad Khalifa?
Salaams. All I can say is that Thanks to Allah for guiding us to this education.
Salaams. You are most welcome. Many thanks for commenting.
Salamun Alaykum. Thanks for the wonderful explanation. After watching the video I also came to the conclusion that the Quran is Hadith
Salaams. Yes, you are right and thank you for commenting.
Great video as always brother! I have concluded that whenever the Qur'an makes mention of 'Allah AND His Messenger' together, this carries ONE and SAME meaning! Take a look at the following verses:
- War from 'Allah AND His Messenger' {2:279 & 5:33}
- emigrant to 'Allah AND His Messenger' {4:100}
- spoils for 'Allah AND His Messenger' {8:1}
- those who lied to 'Allah AND His Messenger' {9:90}
- respond to 'Allah AND His Messenger' {8:24}
- do not betray 'Allah AND His Messenger' {8:27}
- help 'Allah AND His Messenger' {59:8}
Ask these Bukariyoon the following questions if they dare to answer them: Are these verses above referring to TWO seperate wars? TWO seperate emigrants? TWO seperate spoils? TWO seperate lies? TWO seperate responses? TWO seperate betrayals?? The list goes on...
At the time of revelation, how EXACTLY did the people of Muhammad (a.s) obey Allah in the first place? How did they obtain the Qur'an in order to obey Allah? Was the Qur'an available through anyone else other the Messenger?? Then how can obey Allah and His Messenger mean TWO seperate obediences when the Qur'an was ONLY OBTAINABLE via the Messenger?
If 'obeying' Allah was only ever POSSIBLE by 'obeying the MESSENGER, then what does it mean to 'obey' the MESSENGER?? 😊
Salaams Brother. I thank you for the info and I thank you for commenting.
Now I understand why Muslims are in such a dare situation across the world. Thank you for answering bothering thought.
I agree, and glad that i could be of some help.
God bless you. Keep going.
God bless you too Sister.
Very good my brozer. You are verry okkey.
Thank you for your comment. Much Appreciated.
They forget the Quran is not only Allah's best hadith (ahsanul hadith) but also the utterance of the Prophet Muhammed, therefore making the Quran his sunnah also. And where these wahabi scholars fail is when they realize that the earliest hadith which is Bukharis, came 150 years after the prophet! And they casually slander him by saying he said so and so with a bogus "chain of narration". If "obey the messenger" meant the hadith, the prophet would have made his companions write down his sayings aswell as the Quran, but guess what? he didn't, because he knew that idiots would come and make his word higher than the Quran which is exactly what these Wahhabis do!
Thank you so much for your comment.
Makes a lot of sense
My brother your work is fantastic. Keep on saying the truth we will suppport you.
Salamun Alaikum, Shukran for your comment and your valued support.
Kareem don’t give up go deeper and deeper!
It is your own people who will erase you!
The death of someone never came from the ennimy outside but the ennemi hidden inside disguise in friend!
Salaams. I am not going to reply to every comment of yours as there too many, so I am saying Thank You for all your comments.
@@QuranInspiresMe I understand!
No one can reply to Al comments otherwise yiu will stay on CZcams forever, or hide a secretary for you to read and write and reply!
Read some of the comments are also beneficial too,
I like reading peoples comment too in your channel but few people really go deeper it is ok!
I like the color of video too!
Keep it up!
Keeps it up!
Don’t reply in all my comments only those you feel like…
Great work my brother!
Much appreciated and thank you for commenting.
Salaams Akhi. 1 Thing for sure is that these Persians were very intelligent. Their plan worked wonders with the Sunnis.
Salaams Akhi, thank you.
Salaamun Aleykem. Masiya Allah. Great education. Keep up the fantastic work.
Thank you so much for commenting.
Salaams. When people are set in their ways, it very difficult for them to see logical facts.
Salaams. I agree with you and thank you for commenting.
Salaama Brother. Even after all this education, they do not wish to follow Al Haadi. To them Bukhari is Al Haadi.
Salaams Sister. You are right. Bukhari is their god. Thank you for commenting.
Your doing agreat job brother ayuob Kareem. ❤❤❤
Thank you for your comment.
As salamu alaikum
As a revert, I picked up on this right away message, statement means hadith in Arabic
I have seen you on telegram
@@Kim_Jong_Un_. Probably
Good explanation..tq sir..i'm from Malaysia..🌷🌷🌷
Welcome to our channel and thank you for commenting.
Great video thanks. I have some basic understanding of Arabic, but it’s enough for me to clearly see that translators have done a terrible job translating the Quran, they haven’t translated the Quran correctly, rather they’ve inserted their own interpretations into the translations. Now we have a heavy work of going through the Quran as if there is no translation to rely on. But what better to spend our effort on?
I am glad that you enjoyed the video. We cannot reply on the English Translations. Many thanks for commenting.
❤
Thank you for your comment.
I don't mind longer videos. Just now, I listened to a near 4 hour video titled "DHUL QARNAYN & VATICAN JESUIT PRIESTS" uploaded by EndGame Islam, you might find what they present from their Quranic investigation very very interesting!
Thank you for your comment.
I am fine with videos that are hours long, even if they are 6 hours long
What is the recommended English translation of the Quran?
Salam
Alaykum salam akhi
Salaams my dear brother,
(7:185:20)
ḥadīthin
statement
-100% right
Thank you. I appreciate your comment.
Salaamun Alaikum. I think they read these verses, but they also had agents on the inside and knew axactly how to manipulate the muslims.
This people are more jahilun than the enemies of the Prophet
Salaams. And they did a perfect job in manipulating the people. Thank you for commenting.
Salamun alaykum. The meaning of rasol and nabi is clearly different.. rasol mean the person recieved a messagge ( book) but nabi mean the person carry out and practise that messagge.
Obey allah obey rasol meaning obey alquran that have been send down to prophet muhamad saw.
Was Salaamun Alaikum, Thank You for your comment.
For example the letter J was only invented in the 15th century could be wrong but I don't believe the name Jesus should be translated from Isa to Jesus cuz that name couldn't of existed when Isa was born
Salaams. Many thanks for your comments.
Bukhari is not a messenger
Kareem leave the comments of those who don’t agreed with you, that is how we learn too..
Don’t delete their comments.. no matter how nasty and disrespect they are , it is good to know your opponent and why they hate you and oppose you..
Tel
Them express their frustration and angers!! Like they do on Facebook,
If their don’t do it how are you going wiser your learning???
Let your ennimy talk then yiu will know where you are going and where you used to be and do as well!
The comments you are referring to, were deleted by mistake. I am sorry for that.
@@QuranInspiresMe ok!
Quran does not say follow hadith .hadith are not prophet words.the only sunnah found in quran is Allah sunnah not prophet
And that is the only Sunnah the Prophet followed.
@user-gw9hr9kq4p was quran not his own words
Correct and I thank you for commenting.
@@user-gw9hr9kq4pso according to the Quran only, how should we burry our dead? Did the prophet not explained to the sahaba the unclear messages in the Qur'an.
I am christian but study a lot by listening and examining verses.
I had clearly be ome surprised that hadith so called are part of divine revelation and explains the Quran.
These 6 were not messengers but have tsken idlam by storm.
No standard muslim speaks without using hadith.
This is so in Christianity
Standard Christianity took up men created ideas like
Trinity
Jesus and the Spirit are God
But no bible teaches that.
Surely the ummsh of Mohamed fell into the same nif not eorse error of throwing away the words of Allah snd taken eotds of men as revelation.
Lastly
How come Allah in Quran keros saying
Allah AND HIS MESSENGER.
this to me is shriek because quran associates Allah with Mohamed
Sllah and Mohsmef over10 times..... Makes Mohamed oartner eith Allah
Wa ateeullaah wa ateeurrasool means ateeurrasool is the quran itself
Exactly, and thank you for commenting.
And do you even know the meaning of rasoorllah?
I liked Uthman but this is low.
Not only to make up tafsir, and claim obeying the Messenger now means what they made up...
But to ignore the other definitions for kaafir in the Qur'an, which fits him and his sect perfectly...
Let them keep claiming the Prophet alaihi salam is the best of creation and that no dua is answered if we don't send salawat upon him (they don't even know what salawat means... and they only say it with their mouths anyways)... let them worship the Prophet like the Christians do...
See how the mushriks will end up...
Because they internally know they are lying.
And this doesn't mean many "Qur'an alone" people are not kaafir, some want to cover up the Qur'an with their modernist agenda, this is totally true.
But not all, and it's kinda unfair to pack us all in the same, altough Allah subhana wa taala knows best who are the believers...
I thank you for your comment.
Hahaha 😂
Kareem is wrestling with God like jacob aka Isreal did!...
Kareem is wrestling with God and men.
Truth and lie..
Don't give up you are standing between God and men!..
Seek knowledge as much as you can. Because knowledge is power the Bible say..
Truth liberate your soul as well..
😂😂😂😂😂😂😢
clear here as to exactly what kind of questions are Muslims discouraged to ask
. There are certain questions that Islam discourages or even forbids from asking such as "Who created Allah", how did Allah create the universe from nothing? I refuse to believe it unless I know how! Etc. This kind of thinking
is discouraged since this causes the person to have doubts in his faith. He is asking about things, which he will never get the answers to until he meets God Himself. However, in reality
There are all kinds of questions that Muslims have been discouraged from asking.
Forbidding
any question to be asked opens the door to forbidding lots of questions. There are reasonable answers that a child can understand in dealing with "who created Allah?" When you don’t allow questions to be asked you force doubt into the sub-conscious and it doesn’t go away....
The history of Islam has been one of anti-intellectualism. Islam inherited a vast body of information from the Greeks, but eventually did little with it. The answer is found in the educational system of early and later Islam..
Very early in the history of Islam knowledge was divided into two categories: 1) "Islamic science which included the study of the Qur’an, the traditions of the Prophet, legal knowledge (fiqh), theology (kaalam), poetry, and the Arabic language." 2) the natural sciences which were called the foreign sciences. As time went on the natural sciences were viewed as "a tainted enterprise."
And Muslims become the bottom of the apple!
People who were at risk because of their studies in the natural sciences concealed their interests because they would be considered an impious person, apostate
The people who studied the Islamic sciences periodically denounced those who were studying the natural sciences.
Philosophie as kufar.,
They jailed many of them and killed many of them!
The madrasas began to appear in the 11th century and were schools of Islamic sciences and rejected the natural sciences. Religious scholars regarded the natural sciences with suspicion...
Moreover, the educational system favored rote memory rather than critical thinking. When a student had memorized, or copied, or read the manuscripts available from his professor he was given an ijaza, an approval to teach others the same content...
It was presumed that memorized statements were true and could be learned without any process of thinking about the truth or falsehood of the statements...
The history of Islam has been one of anti-intellectualism!
To cut the root of critical thinking and analysis Of what scholard tell you to do blindly!
They are forbidden because you cannot get the answer, so according to you who created Allah?
@@yusrahb4461 Muhammad is azzawajal
@@cocoalfaridah5831According to you
@ ShabierDeen. يبدو أن شبير الدين لا يعرف دينه. You claim to be Muslim? Now go and interpret this.
How can he interpret this. He does even understand the Quran.
@@user-bl8bi9mb4v there is big
Difference Between Rasool And Nabi
Many thanks for commenting.
@@user-bl8bi9mb4v do you understand the Quran yourself thou??
Prouve it!
What does Muslim mean though?
As you know it! Teach the world
please stop promoting the rejection of the hadith, what prominent scholar of the past had done this?
Imaam Moslem. He rejected most of Imaam Bukhari's Hadith.
@@QuranInspiresMe That does not mean we should reject all the hadith.
Assalamu alaikum Brother, I'm sure you realize that you're not the first one to read the Quran, not to mention that fact that you don't seem to have arabic as your native language and haven't studied it properly. While I appreciate the fact that you are trying your best to understand the Quran at a deeper evel, your lack of knowledge is clearly leading to faulty conclusions. Hadith literlly translates to a "saying". In other words, me telling you this is literally a hadith. Yes, Quran comes before the sunnah as a critereon, but sunnah only adds rulings and never contradicts the Quran. Since Allah said to obey him and obey his messenger, the goal of the 6 books of authentic hadith is to sum up everything the prophet said, ordered, or did, in order for us to complete the second part of the command by Allah of "obeying the messenger". There have been many arabic muslim scholars over the centuries, and clearly none of them found a problem like you are suggesting. For example: Allah doesn't mention in the quran how to pray. So, how do we pray? The answer is in the hadith of the prophet: "Pray as you saw me praying" and the other "riwayat" which is "telling" about how the prophet used to pray. However, one cannot deny hadiths as an important part of the islam. Praying is a major step, but notice how Allah specifically let it be for a hadith of the prophet to tell us how to pray, not to mention that it's a huge part of one's islam. Besides that, don't take Ayat out of context by taking a section of the Ayah and explaining that small section alone. You're cutting an Ayah off and misinterpreting what it's talking about. You need to know the context and the reasons these verses where recealed and what was going on that time to help explain the context, but never cut a part of Ayah and explain that part because it is no longer from the Quran. The prophet himself mentioned where an Ayah starts and where it ends, so you can't start in the middle of it and say look and what it says, for that would lead to various misconceptions like saying Woe to those who pray or other blasphemous phrases. And lastly, don't go all the way to call someone a Kafir because you don't know. The prophet PBUH said that whoever says someone is a disbeleiver has commited disbelief or blashphemy (I dont know the proper english translation cuz I know the arabic version cuz I'm arab). May Allah forgive us all. May Allah guide all of us, wassalamu alaikum warahmatu llahi wabarakatuh.
You said:
"The sunnah adds rulings... "
First of all, can you please define to me the meaning of 'Sunnah' from the Qur'an? Not the one defined by your Mullahs and Imams.
Secondly, did the prophet Muhammad (a.s) have authority to 'add rulings' to the Book of Allah? He did not even have the authority to make halal / haram for himself (verse 66:1) so how could 'add rulings' to others?
Thirdly, if Muhammad (a.s) had the authority to 'add rulings', then why would Allah severely warn him that he would take his life if he had made up some sayings (aqaaweel)? Verse 69:44-47. I thought everything the prophet SPOKE (qawl) was revelation?? Then why would Allah threaten him?
Forthy, does our Lord expect every human being (billions of people) to master the arabic language in order to be guided and attain salvation? Even the Mushrik arabs were masters of arabic and poetry but did their language save them from the fire?
Peace 😊
@@negeto2460 Bravo! You have successfully avoided most of the points I have mentioned and failed to provide an alternative interpretation for things like "Obey the prophet" to provide me with points based on false logic. You can't convince anyone by bringing up new points without first rpoviding an alternative interpretation for what I said.
I seek refuge by our lord from the devil
In the name of God
As a response for your poimts:
I don't rely on Imams, rather I study my own language and read things myself because I am capable of understanding what I'm reading.
Sunnah means "a way of doing something" (verse 33:62). For example, If in most days I take a shower as soon as I wake up, it means that taking a shower when waking up is my sunnah. Sunnahs are what the prophet did but not necessarily ordered us to do, otherwise it becomes a fard or obligation. For example: praying Duha or the way to clean after yourself or take a shower. We do it to sahow we are following the prophet by doing what he does. If he commands something, it becomes an obligation because got said to obey the prophet (plenty of verses).
Secondly, excuse my wording. I should have said "elaborate" on rulings. and Yes, because god said that whatever the prophet tells us not to do we must avoid (verse 59:7) which is in line with obeying the prophet. The verse you cites is a question and not an order, and in arabicv, these are questions meant to catch one's attention and have the tone of not supporting the act, like asking a kid why they hit the other kid or why they broke something. You are not looking for an answer. The verse you mention says "O prophet, why do you prohibit what god has made lawful for you...". Whatever the prophet said or commanded was from our lord, for god said that he doesn't speak off of his own desires (verse 53:4-5)
Are you suggesting we mustn't do what the prophet said? We "do not have to do what he did", but still, we must follow his commands. The goal of hadiths and riwayat is to sum up all he said and all he did and not just the do's and don'ts.
For your third point: God did not warm HIM, rather he was telling the disbelievers that the prophet wasn't speaking from himself and attributing it to the lord since otherwise got would take his blessings from him and cut his aorta. Again: CONTEXT!!! Look into why the verses were brought down and when.
For your last point: Obviously he doesn't. It's enough for you to know what to do and dont and follow his commands. However, if you want to make your own interpretations and reach deeper conclusions, your must learn the language and the history of Islam to understand the context upon which everything was put. And no, as far as I remember, all mushriks reverted to islam in the end after peer pressure was done and islam became the norm. THey weren't stupid for worshipping idols, they were just misguided by what they experienced. That's why Surah 1098 was revealed: They asked the prophet "why don't you worship our godsa year and we worship yours a year, this way if you were right, we would benefit from your lord, and if we were right, we haven't lost the blessings of our gods", then suraH 109 was revealed. This shows that they followed logical thinking and were just misguided.
You cannot make interpretations if you don't understand the language and context and don't change contexts to explain things your own way. Master the language then you'll understand a lot. However, knowing the fact that Arabic is the oldest language to exist (oldest text contains arabic), its wide vocabulary and the biggest number of language roots and bridges (over 12500, when most languages have merely 2000-4000 roots into one another) (many languages took from arabic the names of their objects and slightly modified the names), and the fact God chose Arabic, of all languages, for Quran to be in, and descibes Quran as being without bents, without deviance (verse 39:28), it makes sense for it to need a language that has no bents for it to fit in, along with many other facts suggest that Arabic was the original language of Adam AS and the mother of all languages should give people a reason to be interested in learning Arabic, besides just interpretation of the Quran.
Thank you for your time, and peace! :)
@@mohamadhammad2433salaam,
Could you please show me a single verse that says 'obey the prophet (atee'u nabi)'? Instead, we find 'obey the Messenger (atee'u rasool). Why obey rasool instead of nabi? This is significant and you should study into this.
And you still haven't defined to me what 'Sunnah' means according to the Qur'an. Show me a single verse that mentions the 'Sunnah' of Muhammad, or 'Sunnah' of Nabi, or 'sunnah' of Rasool.
And you talk about CONTEXT rite? Could you please quote 59:7 starting from the first verse? What exactly is this talking about? And could you also quote 53:4-5 starting from verse 1 all the way to 18? Let's see if the CONTEXT of these verses matches your false assumptions.
@@negeto2460 I'm not sure what you're talking about as your points are invalid. I did define Sunnah as "The way of". That's how it's mentioned in Quran as the Sunnah of Allah and the Sunnah of those before. If sunnah was mentioned in the Quran to be followed, it becomes a Fard and not a sunnah anymore.
As foe the verses I mentioned for context, I know exactly what I mentioned and I know the language I'm reading and the story behind these verses. The context doesn't change regardless of whether I start from the beginning of a surah or I don't in this case. I know what I cited and what I'm talking about and your response is devoid of logic. You are the one who have to read properly, as you still failed to tell me what is mean by obeying the prophet as it is mentioned in the quran. I told you that it means to obey his commands, hence hadiths that contain commands are musts. However, the rest of the sayings and the stories that tell us how the prophet used to do things are sunnah because they are his way of doing things, hence they are not must dos. You need to make a clear distinction between a sunnah and a fard. You are just giving empty interpretations right now, so think twice before you discuss with me something you clearly have no knowledge about. (Verse 3:66) And be wary of what you're saying and the faulty accusation you're invoking about the hadiths and sunnahs of the prophet, because what you're doing right now describes a similar situation mentioned in the quran when someone spoke bad about something he doesn't even know about. Be wary of Allah, and mind the claims you're having and spreading my brother (verses 23:14-18)
@@mohamadhammad2433again, show me the verse(s) where it says to obey the PROPHET. It says obey the Messenger (rasool). How do you define a Messenger? And why is Muhammad (a.s) referred to as a Messenger? What makes him a Messenger of Allah? Dig deep into this brother and you will 'see it' inshaAllah.
Unfortunately, you've been brainwashed to blindly follow traditions which have blocked the noor (light) and the Hudan (guidance) of the Qur'an from reaching you.
Show me where the Qur'an makes this distinction between 'fard' practices and 'Sunnah' practices. Good luck 😊
Where were you in the year 100Ah to 300Ah?
Your lack of arabic understanding let alone the understanding of Islam is clear from your videos.
Since you don't believe in Hadeeth could you kindly explain the following with proof from the Quraan only:
How many Daily Salaah are there?
How many Rakaat in each Salaah?
What is the method of Salaah?
The Quraan was sent to our Beloved Rasollulah صلى الله عليه وسلم and he lived the Quraan as an example to the rest of mankind. So he practiced on the Quraan. His example of showing us how to practice on the Quraan is what is referred to as Hadeeth!
Just like you presumably went to university and had text books. The text books are the main thing isnt? But then you attended the lectures and assignments which showed you how to implement what's in the text book.
Otherwise anybody can pick up medical text books and become a doctor but he will rather become a murderer because he won't know the correct implementation of the medications and treatments.
May Allah Ta'ala guide us on the path of His Rasoolullah صلى الله عليه وسلم and hus Sahabah and all the Imams of Fiqh and Ahaadeeth.
Please watch my videos on salaah, QIM 060, 062 and 063 for more clarity on Salaah
Well said, he should even show us how to burry our dead. His is utterly refuting the practice of the Prophet PBUH. Should we practice Islam according to him or according to the Prophet PBUH - The one whom the Quran was revealed to because he is the One who explained it better and showed the Sahaba how to live by it. sometimes I wonder how can someone deny the practice of the Prophet PBUH and yet sometimes he uses these hadith to promote his videos.
Let us be honest!
Islamic religion is the Arab religion, where they try to enforce what they call Arabism, is to try to enforce the Arab culture in everybody else, so you convert to Islam, you have to use arab names, you have to eat like arab, you have to greet like them arab, you have to do everything like the Arab, so islam is a religion meet by the Arab, for the sake of the Arab and making Arabs superior and even when you pray to God, is to call the God if islam who is arab and you pray to him in Arabic, the God of Islam live in Arabia peninsula, the door to heaven in Arabia precisely in South Arabia to give us money and business for Hajj, each one of you outside!
Thank you for giving us tourists bussiness Hajj..
Rasool (RSWL) means "SENT MESSAGE" not Messenger, "Follow Allah and follow his sent Message". Messengers live and die but the message is what remains.Always has and alway will ,as it is preserved in the last place we we look which is inside us placed there by the lord, he only sent the messengers to remind us of whats inside us already (Ruh Allah)(siraat al mustaqeem) and to stop covering it up with false religions (kuffar).They were here to free us from the bondage of religion and reconnect (salah) us with our maker.
Thank you so much for the info.