How should Muslims respond to the attack on Salman Rushdie? With Dr Shabbir Akhtar
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 08. 2022
- Be Careful with Muhammad! Salman Rushdie and the Battle for Free Speech:
www.amazon.co.uk/dp/623947420...
You Can Support My Work on Patreon:
/ bloggingtheology
My Paypal Link:
www.paypal.com/paypalme/blogg...
Brother Shabbir has always been a strong voice for muslims. He has defended the honour of the holy prophet very eloquently and in the process faced a backlash. May Allah reward you both highly for this good work.
Love and respect from India. May Allah bless you Paul.... Ameen. 😊
🤔 I've known whats going to happen for the past 2 years I have 100% predicted what happened throughout 2020 2021 2022. And when I say predicted I mean I literally can see the future.
Only by the grace of Allah has this been allowed you can believe this is 100% true and I do not lie & I declare to this ALLAH IS MY WITNESS.
Prostrate to your creator
loan Allah a goodly loan
Be amongst the righteous
Feed and care for the orphans, elderly, poor, weak, & disabled and help those in need and do not lie backbite, cheat, bribe or ransom
Be weary of the wicked and have honour and privilege in the way of Allah.
Spread forth the truth you hear and tell of Muslims Allah has made clear for those whom belive.
Asalamalikum akhi has situation gotten any better there regarding the hindutva incels.(inferior sub-humans)
Candour and lucidity are the two hallmarks of this conversation.
I am a Christian and I would treat the Quran proper because I want people to treat the Bible proper, and #DoUntoOthers and I want to unstand where Muslims and such are coming from.
Trust me - you are NOT a Christian 🤣
@@Ttcopp12rt she is definitely more Christian than you
@@Ttcopp12rt takfiri luke LOL
🤔 I've known whats going to happen for the past 2 years I have 100% predicted what happened throughout 2020 2021 2022. And when I say predicted I mean I literally can see the future.
Only by the grace of Allah has this been allowed you can believe this is 100% true and I do not lie & I declare to this ALLAH IS MY WITNESS.
Prostrate to your creator
loan Allah a goodly loan
Be amongst the righteous
Feed and care for the orphans, elderly, poor, weak, & disabled and help those in need and do not lie backbite, cheat, bribe or ransom
Be weary of the wicked and have honour and privilege in the way of Allah.
Spread forth the truth you hear and tell of Muslims Allah has made clear for those whom belive.
Agreed. You should have seen what those Godless SJW Liberals did to a Bible in I think it was Seattle or Portland after the Roe vs Wade Decision. They dumped the Bible in a porta-potty. Absolutely despicable.
Why should all us Muslims feel anything for what happened to him?? Like 9/11 we all had sweet nothing to do with it.
Life is about choice & the consequences of those choices
How can one stop that ?
You are placing the cart before the horse. First one must condemn the wilful mockery of someone's faith and then those who support such mockery (idealogy)
@@mickqQ That’s quite wrong. You are conflating criticism of Islam which deliberate, aggressive inciting hatred of Islam. It’s a convenient that you are doing this, you are trying to dehumanise muslims this way. It’s very clear that your intentions is not to uphold freedom of speech but to give yourself right to hate, dehumanise muslims and justify the current oppression and persecution of muslims worldwide. Whatever helps sell those guns right?
@@mickqQ are u responsible for Hitlers actions?? Grow up🙄
Everything depends on the intention behind such criticism of peoples mist cherished beliefs. If the criticism is academic then it should be countered in the sane vein but if the intention is malafide then it will and should invite a different kind of response.
I condemn the attack! And I am devout muslim! In my eyes it was a cowardly act!
Lol
Good for you. All Muslims should be outraged by it.
"Morally, he replaced drunkenness with sobriety in a way never achieved
in any society, before or since, by any faith" Shabbir Aktar IN Islam as Political Religion
No excuses,it's a disgrace, sort it out.
Drawing attention by bashing islam, biased shout outs about freedom of speech happen so often that it is tiring. What I truly ask myself is how someone can be content with himself by humiliating so many people who hold to such sensivities.. ..unlimited .freedom to mock and insult in a civilized society can not be reconciled...
Imagine being so thin skinned you think hurting your feelings justifies being stabbed 15 times
Physical wounds can be treated to assuage the pain but how do you treat hurt feelings ?
Islam is an ideology! Critiquing or mocking of any ideology is should not be crime in 21st century! If you don’t like it migrate to Islamic republics and don’t use internet so that your fragile "religious feelings“ are never hurt.
What worth is a religion whose followers won't fight for it ?
@@matinoutho9058 top g^
Inna lillahi wa inna ilaihi rajioon.
I did not expect to hear of his passing.
Allah had plans greater than ours. So much of my learning has been influenced by his work. May Allah replace him with Muslim academics who build mountains upon his work towards Islam.
May Allah grant Uncle Shabbir the highest ranks of the life after.
Let this be a reminder to us that death can come to us at any age, irrespective of how healthy and strong we may be.
Love the uncompromising response from Dr Akhtar; he was elucidating, eloquent, and quite funny actually.
So you support terrorism?
Very informative. Rusdie's book reminds of the saying " Some people like to feel taller by cutting other people's heads off " . His book is simply another form of cultural character assignation.
It's just a book. If you don't like it don't read it.
@@soltantio I highly doubt you would have said the same about Mein Kampf.
So much you do for Islam and Muslims Paul, despite you have just only recently converted Islam. May Allah SWT bless you
Watch the movie "the message" if anyone wants to see how the enemies of Muslims were treated when they returned to Mecca.
Salaam Paul. So good to see Dr Shabbir back on BT. A brilliant mind indeed.
Wa alaykumu s-salam
In Albania we have a saying:
“Do not kick on a dry 💩, otherwise it will ristart smelling.” 🤧
Salaam to both brothers.JazakaAllah for the excellent work
I watched his previous interview mash Allah, he barely aged mash Allah. May Allah swt reward him and increase him hidayah
Why should Muslims react at all?
Inna lillaahi wa innaa illayhi raaji'uun. May Allah enter Dr. Shabbir Akhtar into Jannah.
Thanks Brother Paul, for bringing intellectuals to think and pounder and explain. Jezzak Allah Khair.
السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
As-Salaamu `Alaykum wa Rahmatullaahi wa Barakaatuhu
Wa alaykumu s-salam
Extremism is wrong in everything . Moderation is best. May Allah reward you my brothers.
Salam brother Paul. Can someone please give Assange in prison a Holy Quran so he can read.
Just ignore the guy. He would be ilrelevant without us
“Be tolerant, command what’s right, pay no attention to foolish people” [7:199]
Tell that to people trying to kill him.
@@GaganSingh-nx2yv I wish we could tell them that! They’re idiots and fake Muslims that need to chill out. Violence over someone’s ignorance is not acceptable at all.
Thank you brother Paul may Allah reward you give you long life and healthy life
Allahuma aamiin ya mujib
Great talk……. I love the title of the book, it’s brilliant. Thank you brother
Dr. Akhtar it has been a pleasure listening to you.
Thanks for your clarity on the main subject and for exposing double standards in the West, when using "free speech" as a shield or as a weapon, depending on to whom it's applied.
I "drink" a bit too from Mr.
Peterson's fountain of knowledge and common sense and must refer to one of his views on free speech, just paraphrasing,
If free speech is impeded what suffers is the chance for free thought, and that's only good for dictatorships.
Paul it was a valiant topic to approach and the result was me learning a lot once more.
Many thanks
👍🏽😘
Brother Paul, could you please get Imam Fode Drame on your show. He is an amazing scholar and linguist and has a phenomenal course on the "7 words " - Which emphasises an often overlooked but critical aspect of islam namely the cultivation and perfection of human character.
So every time a muslim does evil 1.6 billion muslim must apologize..hmm..lets all christans hindus buddhist etc apologize for the evil they commit
MashaAllah! Dr Akhtar is a brillant multitalented scholar. May God preserve and protect you both!
freedom of speech? Depends on whom you anger.
Thoroughly enjoyed this riveting discussion.
good discussion thank you
43:32 Jordan Peterson as an ally? Is this talk from before Jordans " message to muslims"? I'm baffled here.... Why is Paul responding"indeed"? Jordan P. has shown himself as a not a real friend of muslims. Or did I miss a new message from Jordan P.? 53:06 May our innocent children be spared from having to listen to and being influenced by any scriblings from Salman Rushdie.
Brother Paul i hope you invite CJ Werlemen to your channel and have a meaningful dialogue he is defending muslims from all the anti islam propoganda.
I wonder what his parents think of him or are they the same as him. May Ahllah guide us all and don't disgrace us like he is.
QadrAllaah 👍
You should condemn it that is the right thing to do there is no excuse by attacking someone because what they said or wrote you can criticize them also there is no blasphemy and apostasy in the Quran this false outrage is based on identity and tribalist Islam exploited by heretical political Islamist
He mentioned the Hebrew word teshuva but he meant to say halacha. Around the 5 minute point. Teshuva means repentance and halacha is Jewish law. Please do your research before referencing Jewish sources on issues because frankly it makes us look dumb to Jews. Possibly he is referring to She'elot u-Teshuvot.
he made a mistake , he is humane , why are you being harsh on him?
@@unknownpng650 I’m not harsh. It’s for the sake of education.
@@unknownpng650 If a Jew called Islamic law “tawbah” rather than “shariah” wouldn’t you say he needs to be more educated on the topic.
Very beautiful interview 👍
Please invite Abdullah Al Andalusi to your podcasts.
With same deafening silence that occurs with all dead muslims in india
Second largest muslim populaion after Indonesia
The audio isn't clear 😭
How should Muslims respond to the attack on Salman Rushdie?
WHY SHOULD MUSLIMS OR ANYBODY GIVE A DAMN ABOUT SALMAN RUSHDIE BESIDES HIS PAY MASTERS?
taboo question: What true Muslims will do to him when they are face to face with him?
BAFS
Rest in Peace Prof. Shabbir Akhtar.
The U.S. Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and thought and freedom of and from religion.
The man who attacked him is a violent criminal and those who approved the attack have forfeited their right to protection from being attacked for their beliefs.
There is no absolute freedom of speech etc. You still don't seem to have twigged this fact.
What freedom do innocent Muslims around the world have from US drone attacks, or arbitrary detention without trial in Guantanamo bay or the prevention of access to their own money in Afghanistan etc, etc? Why are you Americans so blind to your politicians' immorality and bloodthirstiness?
Yes freedom of speech only when it suit your evil purpose ,you are sick in the head you are a coward .
No sympathy for Salman Rushdie
Hi my dear love from india 💐💚💐👍👍👍
What is this 'should'? I'm happy that someone beat/attack that person. He has lived enough life till that incident that he could asked forgiveness for what he did. But he didnt n wasted all these precious years..after all now his time of death is near (late 70s) so doesnt matter if he die in an attack or die a natural death.
Personally, i dont believe in killing of blasphemers. This world is not paradise, it has all kind of evil, so evil should stay in this world so they can repent n its only possible if they have a life to live. But if someome kill them in rage of insulting Prophet SAW or Allah then the blasphemer is surely going into hell, so no regret on his death.
Salaam only one God and it's Allah SWT love here from South Africa Boksburg pray five times a day 🤭🤭🤭
Im a muslim but i have a hard time dealing with restricting free speech.
Shouldnt we just express what we think and counter their supposed arguments?
You are right if it was an argument, but mocking islam and muslims, burning the quran and drawing the Prophet are noy arguments they are just done to provoque the muslims
@@saidctbb i personally think people shouldn’t do that but we live in the west and the west has their own rules right?
I fully understand if it was a muslim country
@@moesephxd91 the problem is these people pretend to be muslim but know nothing about Islam. They don't study, read their quran, hadith etc...but then get offended when others mock Islam. It's so weird. They need to focus more on studying the quran and hadith and learn how our prophet SAWS would respond to these kinds of offenses. “Be tolerant, command what’s right, pay no attention to foolish people” [7:199]
@@renee3308 I agree with that notion. There are a lot of people getting riled up while lacking true understanding Islam, but that is not to misunderstand the Muslims way of protecting their deen. The difference between a true believer and a false one (seemingly much like the man who attacked Rushdie), doesn’t rely in how much tolerance vs intolerance they have, but instead in how they choose to respond. Muslims have just as much anger towards Rushdie as that attacker probably had, yet they never for a second think to go as far as acting upon that anger as that is not part of what Islam or the prophet (pbuh) teaches.
it would have be better to avoid this kind of behavior. i don’t think what happened was correct. we shouldn’t expect all people to be sensitive to our sensitivities. its just not realty. Why try and kill the guy? leave it to God, and lets not be so hot blooded in our reactions. we need to be better than this.
Rushidi can be one of those people who justify their free range mental discourse by writing n exploring their own delusional fantasies to normalise unfiltered mental weeds in the name of free speech n free writing.Sensible writers can differ,but they are conscious of avoiding unnecessary fuss n controversies. Their focus is on facts n figures.. BUT, he was also given undue importance by protests. Islam sells,he made a fortune out of it.
But he lives in fear, of what use his money?
@@matinoutho9058 the point is we have made him famous, ironically.
Salman is definitely using the "free speech" card well.
After this recent mauling he should be more circumspect
action = reaction. Free speech for attacking = ?
He called all Muslims are terrorists and he is held in high esteem by the western world as such Muslims at least help to prove him that he’s not wrong in his words. At least he needs to be dealt that way.
Nazar Sheriff no! Muslims did not help him prove he is right. What non sense is that? You cannot hold the entire 1/4 of world population responsible for one person's irresponsible act. You have a mindset of the terrorist west.
Personally, i dont believe in killing of blasphemers. This world is not paradise, it has all kind of evil, so evil should stay in this world so they can repent n its only possible if they have a life to live. But if someome kill them in rage of insulting Prophet SAW or Allah then the blasphemer is surely going into hell, so no regret on his death.
Flora D you are right death sentence should not be the punishment. But imprisonment, fines and chance to repent to earn freedom should be the law.
If you go round lighting fires 🔥 there’s a good chance you gonna get burnt ….
Bro I ain't boutta feel bad for a man who is trying to prevent everyone from reaching eternal happiness. Why feel sorry for a dude who wants his fellow brothers and sisters in humanity to burn for an eternity of torture? My response to the attack? The more you fuck around the more you find out, Salman fucked around, and then he found out, and if he don't change, he really gunna find out on judgement day 🙂
May someone please summarize the 50 minutes in a couple of sentences?
Abusing a religion followed by more than 1billion people is not freedom of speech. Rushdie got hate for hate. Its ok. To me I don’t want to call his name without an obsenity. I may be wrong but it give me a sort of satisfaction.
Sad
Happy
It literally is freedom of speech, 1 person could believe in it, every person on the planet could believe in it, that doesn't matter
Wow that is sick
Yes, isn't it ?
❤️🌹
Glorify Undefinable, The Answerer or The Stabilizer of Matter
Controllers of Body, By Eternal Existence Rely to Undefinable alone, be Serene and judge by how Matter executes! The Identity can exist in every possibility!
Ask guidance and things you can't get to The Answerer, THAT allowed you into this body, THAT gave truth for clean-minded in Subconscious, and avoid numbness!
And use wonders Lord of Existence made from Earth, and don't take what is unknown until you will understand it! Shape your own makings, and you will be supported!
Blessed is Controller of Man filled with subtle joy, united with Intuition! That relies to Causer of Origins alone, That chooses by the best, That hears brainwaves!
The life can be mastered, for rules were made simple to Observant! Don't be fearful of destiny, because we're parts of possibilities, that have freewill with Serenity!
By wonders of fat-stores usage, that cleans everything inside itself! forbid anti-nutrient, PUFA, synthetic high food - allow wheatgrass, fruit seeds and ferment food!
Trial is what evil awaited and good missed! Universe remains to its original form, and don't change adaptable bodies in ignorance!
Challenging are the days of Illusion and is a sad burden to anyone who didn't seek the truth, Nothing is miracle-free, such is Cause!
Great are the days of Responsibility that nourish the Soul! We have always existed! And a lesson of hope, that Pure will enjoy!
The world is created for Observer's favor! Whole Multiverse is in perfection for Purpose! As World ends, it will return! Current areas are special by The Stabilizer!
Ever so cryptic at times yet eloquent.What do you really want to say in context of this topic here
Salaams. The question wasn’t answered. The way Muslims should react to the attempted murder of Salman Rushdie is a complete and unconditional condemnation of the attempted murder. Whilst we can debate the varying goal posts of freedom of speech we need to condemn Ayatollah Khomeini’s fatwa, which was a complete political gimmick to increase his standing among the Muslim world. I recall quite vividly during 1989 when Dr. Kalim Siddiqui of the defunct Muslim Institute supported the fatwa and Shabbir Akhtar was part of the institute then, and seemed to support the fatwa. Now that Iran has distanced itself from the fatwa and it looks like brother Shabbir has also distanced himself from the fatwa, there should be a wholesale condemnation of the attempted murder of Salman Rushdie.
Hate to break it into you but Iran has most certainly not distanced itself from the fatwa
Covenant? We don’t have a covenant. Stop lying
Salman Rushdie had it coming. He shoulda knowed better.
Yep! His book is the top selling book on Amazon. I've ordered my copy.
You are neither the first person nor the last who has been suckered into buying this worthless book.
@@derekallen4568 you just wasted your money lol, his book isnt even anything special, he just became famous in the past through Khomeini's politically driven fatwa
@@aq4356 yep! I just want to support him. Muslim aggression.
Derek allen...shame on you
We Muslim value our religion more than anything else. Heck, Islam is a way of our life. If you insult it you are insulting us.
Prophet Muhammad (SAW) has more value than our mother, father, wife, son, daughter or anyone that may be our blood relatives or friends.
I will ask a question to non-Muslims what will you do when someone insults your father or mother before your face?
Well, I do know some of you do not value your parents, so I'm not talking to those fools, I'm speaking to those who know what respect for parents is or anyone close to them.
Salman Rushdi, may his soul burn in hell fire if he didn't repent, didn't just insult Prophet Muhammad(SAW) he wrote a book that was filled with lies, misrepresentation and defamation of the image of our beloved Prophets.
Imagined if someone you love, value and respect was the one that was written in that book!
Muslims need to understand that Dignity is above all else, even death! We should protect our dignity at all times with all our power!
What about the Dignity of our Prophet?
In Islam, it's haram to call your brother bad names. In fact, if a person lie and told that another Muslim committed Zina, the person that lied must be punished for falsely tainting his Muslim brother's dignity, image and personality!
What about the dignity of our Prophet?
Salman Rushdi didn't make just a few statements. He took the whole History of Prophet Muhammad twisted it and gave his own profane version!
Do you Muslims knows what that means?
This is an attempt to create many versions of Prophet Muhammad's history to confuse the world about who really he was. Salman Rushdi did a splendid job for that and his book was accepted because of his family and country background.
Before the likes of Salman Rushdi, Prophet Muhammad has been recognised and described in the whole world with great personalities. Where he was praised by many none Muslim scholars after they researched his life history.
That was what the enemies of Islam doesn't want!
That is why many versions of lies regarding him are in constant publication-and Salman Rushdi is just one of the most popular ones.
Islam teaches us to respect one another, Muslim or none Muslim. Good morality is a must whenever you interact with another human being and never harm him in any way possible, verbally or physically!
However, there is a line for all our tolerance!
Muslims are afraid to be called violent because they think that will make none Muslim call Islam a violent religion!
So what if they call it like that!? As a Muslim you already know your religion is not violent but why will you care if someone calls you something that you are not?
Heck, those that called you violent will still call you, no matter what you do!
So, stop shying away and fearing someone calling you violent, they will call you that no matter what.
What happened to Salman Rushdi is justified. He saw it coming and it's what he do and what he was doing that got him to be stabbed!
I'm ready to be called violent. Go ahead, you are wasting your time reading this.
We will fight for the dignity of our Prophet because his dignity is far more valuable than our miserable lives!
And, what happened to Salman will serve as a warning to all other enemies of Islam that want to defame Islam without context and just for the fun of it-they will be wary of what they say and what they do!
If we allowed ourselves to be insulated, defamed and also allowed propane things thrown at us, then we are no different from most Christians-where every bad joke and negative word were thrown at them and they tolerated it just because they fear others to call them intolerant.
Imagine looking at your face and saying Jesus is G*y! Subhanallah. And know what, the Christians will just shy away because they are afraid because of some stupid words.
I will end by saying that Islam teaches us to be tolerant, have good morals and also protect our dignity. However, tolerance has a limit, cross it and anything could happen.
May Allah guide us!
Masha Allah!
@@ErwinBlonk I don't know what you are implying. Saying your gods can handle themselves, are you implying the insult will reduce their power or what.
Anyway, what I will say to you was that. We are religious and value mutual respect. There might be intellectual discussion and other accusations can be discussed. But we will not tolerate insults and defamation.
Your religious value and yours differ in that regard a.
@@ErwinBlonk Saying _"I don't need to do anything about it"_ in regards to your faith reflect your lack of care or attachment to it. If you care or is attached to your faith you would defend it against any Iies or untrue accusations... because you care! The same thing can be seen when someone spread maIicious rumors about your loved ones - if you don't care or feel no attachment to them, you will not feel the need to defend their honor.
This in no way mean I support what happened to Rushdie. It just means he has to face to consequence of his action of trying to prov0ke the Muslims emotionally.
@@ErwinBlonkWhat Islam teaches the most was Good Morality and Respect for one another. It also means if one tries to disrespect you try to avoid him and if persist find a way for him to stop. Because we value our dignity.
Harm comes in different ways, physical harm, psychological harm and Image or dignity-just someone calling another person a thief or a liar.
But I understand we have different Values in life
I think the attack is a lie, as they need attention again some way..
HINDUS TORTURED AND MURDERED THIS AUTHOR 7.25.23
meat was the excuse but they're doing it right here in U.S. TOO!!
I did not feel sorry for Salman Rushdie ; not at all.
He wasn’t forced by all means to insult publicly our beloved Prophet Mohammad PBUH, Salman meant the shameful insult in purpose to demote and painfully hurt Islam , the prophet of Islam and 1.8 Billion Muslims.
Why we feel sorry for Salman being hurt !?
Its like how to respond 9 eleven attack
Shoykot muslims did not do it! Simple.
Its ironic though frankly not surprising that in this talk of 'diehard fanatics' 10 minutes, 16 seconds in, its not in regard to those hollering for Rushdie to be ended in a hideous manner, but rather those advocating he have free speech. There's a more than simple answer to the travesty of the book being offensive. If you don't like the book, DON'T READ IT!
There are differences between the reaction to Rushdie and LGBT being criticised, however, its not entirely for the reasons that the dawah scene likes to emphasise. Beyond obviously, a reason it gets such attention and sympathy is because of how evil and bloodthirsty the attempts to censor him have been. If the attempts to censor him had belonged on the same shelf as Mary Whitehouse's attempts to censor Monty Python and the Life of Brian, it would have been largely treated accordingly.
The only problem I have with is because of this two or three attempt at his life every last muslim man, woman or child should repent for there actions which is ridiculous and as for don't read it that's basically saying I can criticize you but cant criticize me BS nonsense you can feed to the dogs
@@redtwinlightsaber9915 'because of this two or three attempt at his life every last muslim man, woman or child should repent for there actions'. That's nonesense and no such sentiment fuels the revulsion at the tasteless responses to his attempted murder. 'as for don't read it that's basically saying I can criticize you but cant criticize me BS'. Nope, the reaction to backlash against Rushdie would have been unrecognisable if it had been limited to criticism. While there are anti Muslim bigots with unfair and manipulative standards and narratives towards Muslims, if it had been the case that when John Lennon was murdered, Christians had come out of the wood work to bleat about how offensive his song Imagine was to religious sentiments, these whiners would have received an immense amount of back lash. If a similar stabbing and broader outpouring of madness had happened to Philip Pullman the response would have been similar. Imagine if this had happened to Philip Pullman and the result had been a conversation like in this vid had ensued 'wrong because we're under covenant and- whinging, whinging, whinging on steroids x10 about Philip Pullman.
@@redtwinlightsaber9915 nobody is saying all Muslims are responsible for this disgusting attack but you should all be outraged by it.
Writing a book is different to stabbing someone. This isn't difficult to understand.
How should Muslims respond?
In the same way how when we saw a building climber climb a building & FALL without wearing any safety harness.
He asks for it, and the same goes if there is any Muslim who is willing to go to the extent Salman Rushdie did to disrespect other religion than Islam.
Serves him right, whomever dares say ill words against our prophet deserves a much more sinister fate. I wish muslims would be more unapologetic about it.
People insulted Islam in the time of Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. He left them alone so follow the Sunnah. Allah will deal with them.
@@sza484 Back then Islam had no real power, you think the prophet PBUH would let people insult him when Islam has the upper hand on a societal level?
According to Quran there is NO PUNISHMENT ,who so ever did this is not Ordered by Allah.
Well haditj books tell different story,again NOT WARRANTED or Endorsed by Allah in Quran .
🤔 I've known whats going to happen for the past 2 years I have 100% predicted what happened throughout 2020 2021 2022. And when I say predicted I mean I literally can see the future.
Only by the grace of Allah has this been allowed you can believe this is 100% true and I do not lie & I declare to this ALLAH IS MY WITNESS.
Prostrate to your creator
loan Allah a goodly loan
Be amongst the righteous
Feed and care for the orphans, elderly, poor, weak, & disabled and help those in need and do not lie backbite, cheat, bribe or ransom
Be weary of the wicked and have honour and privilege in the way of Allah.
Spread forth the truth you hear and tell of Muslims Allah has made clear for those whom belive.
I agree with your point
This question does not warrant a 56 min video! The answer is simple: Muslims should not only condemn this type behavior and reject violence, but most importantly, they should be vocal about it and let the whole world know that Islam and the majority of Muslims are innocent from such act!
Very naiive. Even when Muslims condemn such acts , they are either not given the platforms to air this view or if they are brought into the mainstream media they are then attacked the rest of the interview about Islam.
The result is the reluctance to go on these channels and that the channels live to choose controversial “ radicals “ anyway
@@Ashleii Do you have any other suggestions!!
Where is akhtar beard?
I say Alhamdulillaah to the attack on Salman Rushdie because in his book called "satanic verses" that Salman Rushdie insults Al-Qur'an as satanic verses. Positive law does not punish Salman Rushdie's nor Salman Rushdie commits repentance for his act insulting Al-Qur'an and Prophet Muhammad. Muslim did not attack Salman Rushdie but kafir (non muslim) did.
why did muhammed call africans raisin heads
he didn't
@@BloggingTheology sahih bukhari 7142 pls elaborate
@@vixaisu Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "You should listen to and obey, your ruler even if he was an Ethiopian (black) slave whose head looks like a raisin."
@@BloggingTheology yea so why did muhammed insult his head 😂
@@vixaisu Matthew 3: 7 - "You generation of vipers"
Matthew 15: 26 - "It is not right to take the children’s bread and toss it to the dogs" (in reference to the Gentile woman)
Matthew 23: 16-17 - "Woe to you, blind guides, who say, ‘If one swears by the temple, it means nothing, but if one swears by the gold of the temple, one is obligated. Blind fools, which is greater, the gold, or the temple that made the gold sacred?"
Matthew 23: 33 - "You serpents, you brood of vipers, how can you flee from the judgment of Gehenna?"
So why do Jesus insult people?
*This is a total BS. There are 2 000 000 000 Muslims worldwide and everyone is responsible for his or her actions according to the religious and the civil laws: now grow up folks* .
🤔 I've known whats going to happen for the past 2 years I have 100% predicted what happened throughout 2020 2021 2022. And when I say predicted I mean I literally can see the future.
Only by the grace of Allah has this been allowed you can believe this is 100% true and I do not lie & I declare to this ALLAH IS MY WITNESS.
Prostrate to your creator
loan Allah a goodly loan
Be amongst the righteous
Feed and care for the orphans, elderly, poor, weak, & disabled and help those in need and do not lie backbite, cheat, bribe or ransom
Be weary of the wicked and have honour and privilege in the way of Allah.
Spread forth the truth you hear and tell of Muslims Allah has made clear for those whom belive.
: @ECHO THE TRUTH
*No human knows what will happen in the future so your comment is a mere blabla....blah* .
Speaking of Author Ian McEwan pointed out: _“People who are utterly secure in their God should be above taking physical revenge when offended. Perhaps the book-burners and placard-wavers were, paradoxically, troubled by the first gremlins of doubt.”_ And that *doubt* is the source of the Muslim outrage.
*The reason the book offends Muslims* is because they know the verses were originally in the Qur'an (See book _Before Orthodoxy: The Sαtanic Verses in Early Islam_ by Shahab Ahmed) and the doubt is naturally deep in their minds that it _wasn't_ Satan who duped M and inserted it but that it was indeed M himself that put it in as he was trying a compromise with the Meccans to convert them. It didn't work and so the verses were removed with the claimed about Satan. After all, how likely could the prophet be duped like this when the Qur'an itself says that Allah protects it? And how many other verses then could be Sαtan's? The thought that's hidden deep in probably every Muslim's mind, that this book arouses, is that real possibly M was a _frαud!_
No. Muslims are outraged because they hold some things sacred and in great honor.
My Publishing a book about your mother being a whore might not faze you in the least, not because you don’t have any doubt that she isn’t, but perhaps because you simply don’t love her enough to care. That said, I’m not implying the attack was justified in any way. But outrage at mockery and vilification of those most beloved used to be a natural human reaction. There is a reason such a reaction has never been seen when actual academics dismiss and criticize Islam. The whole idea of the “satanic verses” comes from Muslim sources, remember?? This isn’t anything new or original. It’s the manner in which the attack was made.
There are still plenty who react to filthy lies and slurs used against those they love, eventhough they recognize them as completely untrue. Perhaps you can’t relate . Not your fault.
You're a fraud.
Oh please... Muslims offended because the verses were allegedly in the Quran? No scholars worth their salt has ever validated that.
The issue with Rushdie is he spins a fiction based on Islam in an attempt to either mock or portray it in a distasteful way. Whether that's because of his own psyche or for his sick entertainment, we'll never know.
@@myuzairy7324 According to Ibn Hisham, in a passage preserved by Tabari, the incident took place because of Muhammad’s worrying over the Quraysh rejecting his message: “The apostle was anxious for the welfare of his people, wishing to attract them as far as he could.” In fact, “He longed for a way to attract them.”
See the Bk I mentioned.
@@endpc5166
If quran is from Satan, why does it :
1) Condemn Satan as evil and disobedient in too many verses
2) urge mankind to take Satan as clear and evident enemy in many verses
3) advise mankind to seek protection of God from Satan the accursed before we read the quran every SINGLE time?
4) exposes satan's own tactics that he employs to destroy mankind e.g alcohol, gambling, free sex, pornography, interest rates, idol worshipping etc...
5) why would Satan praise God abundantly with beautiful majestic names and then he name himself very lowly? The quran is filled with god's praise and Satan condemnation.
How Umar would've responded to this. He would've finished the job.
Heri shoyono no. He would not go against the revelations. Respond in such a way it reflects the mercy of Allah. Peaceful. Never in anger.
@@mohammednazrulla1126 and what is the sharia rules for the people who insult the prophet?
@@heristyono4755 Sharia is not a "fixed" compilation to pick and choose from "a known source" or a sort of a "library" of Islamic jurisprudence for any one/country or ruler to choose and apply. It is compiled and depends on the local government's chosen/elected council or a body of Ullema. Sharia has evolved through centuries.
You show off to know so much; why do not you give reference(s) as to what is/are Sharia rules for the people who insult the prophet?? And which country a applies and in what way?
Let us see the drama un fold!
Note! Turkey does not have sharia!
@@mohammednazrulla1126 just answer the question.
@@heristyono4755 I just answered the question dude. You are unable to comprehend? Do not act too smart or dumb.
“I wholly disapprove of what you say but i will defend to the death your right to say it.”
- Voltaire
Muslims need to learn this
Who is voltaire to us?
You are not living in a free for all world bro. Rights and wrongs are relative! Can an adult enter the white house and desecrate it? There is a law against desecrating. Why? There would be consequences. Same here the prophet or the quran are sacred to 1/4 of the world. No one should have the freedom to desecrate them. That should be the law.
That saying tries to appear as nobel and sacrificial, but in reality is totally senseless. You will die for someone’s right to say something you disagree with? So there is no value to your life. Your basically wishing for death and it doesn’t even need to be for something you agree with, something you disagree with will do just fine
@@mohammednazrulla1126 Or Muslims should actually study their faith and how the prophet SAWS would react to provocation instead of getting in their feelings, reacting and being violent.
@@mohammednazrulla1126 “Be tolerant, command what’s right, pay no attention to foolish people” [7:199]
Darood e ibrahimi tasbeeh (50 times)czcams.com/video/u-4y51dKAZM/video.html
Should we avenge 9/11 or forgive these animals?Nusrat Rizvi, Palm Beach Gardens
Shabbir Akhtar thinks the “satanic verses” is a real incident that happened. 🤦
Yeah i also find it wierd
It may or may have not happened, there is evidence for both sides. Even if it did happen I don't see the incident as something that would act against Muhammad(PBUH) legitimacy of being God's Prophet but rather further proof of Muhammad (PBUH) prophetic role.
You're misunderstanding. Academically, there is a difference of opinion whether it happened or not. Even if it DID happen, it makes the prophet's peace be upon him word even more truthful, because it was corrected by Gabrial straight away, and it shows how open Islam is. Meaning whether it happened or not doesn't affect Islam whatsoever
But there are scholars who also say, it doesn't make sense for it to have happened.