Twelve & Clara | You'll still be gone.

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 07. 2017
  • « immortality isn't living forever. that's not what it feels like. immortality is everybody else dying. she might meet someone she can't bear to lose. that happens, i believe. »
    sighs. i rewatched s8-9 and i got emo and this happened.
    i hope you like it, sorry for any emotional suffering but hey! at least y'all will know what i've been feeling for the past week.
    _______________________________________________
    Fandom | Doctor Who (Twelve & Clara Oswald)
    Colouring | Mine
    Music | Cold - Jorge Méndeze
    Twitter | / nctashas
    Tumblr | / natasharromanova
    Letterboxd | letterboxd.com/keiraknightleys
    #fanvidfeed #doctorwho

Komentáře • 184

  • @SunnyVids
    @SunnyVids Před 7 lety +442

    0:01 this quote I'm already mad wtf
    0:09 MY CLARA
    0:15 that fucking face
    SHE MIGHT MEET SOMEONE SHE CANT BEAR TO LOSE THAT HAPPENS I BELIEVE
    0:21 WHZT THR FKC
    0:30 WHY ARE YOU DOING THIS
    0:38 "bc if clara oswald is really dead" "IM NOT DEAD IM IN HERE" WELL I AM DEAD
    1:02 NOT WITH ME
    1:16 I'm just
    2:00 LONGEST MONTH OF MY LIFE
    2:17 I'm gonna run too...run to England to fucking MURDER YOU AMINAH
    2:23 IF U LOVE ME YOULL COME BACK
    2:41 I KNEW THIS WAS COMING I KNEW IT BUT I WAS NOT PREPARED HE BROKE ALL THE RULES FOR HER
    2:52 "this clara person you must rlly like her" YAS CALL HIM OUT
    3:12 BECAUSE HE LOVES HER
    3:22 BECAUSE. HE. _LOVES._ HER.
    3:27 honestly I'd sacrifice the entire universe too if it meant whouffle got a happy ending I can't blame him ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
    3:38 TOGETHER OR NOT AT ALL
    4:12 "it's okay" NO ITS NOT ITS NOT OKAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    I CAN'T FUCKING BELIEVE THIS
    WHAT THE FUCK

    • @MsSweetSerialKiller
      @MsSweetSerialKiller  Před 7 lety +23

      SunnyVids I'm yodelling kakskssj, pinning this instead queen.

    • @SunnyVids
      @SunnyVids Před 7 lety +7

      _I hate you_

    • @marian3nene45
      @marian3nene45 Před 5 lety +12

      You have summed it up for all Whovians.
      PS... I'm STILL crying lol

    • @roaaoverthinks
      @roaaoverthinks Před 5 lety +3

      you went watson at the end i can't even.

    • @nicolesong6199
      @nicolesong6199 Před 4 lety +2

      SunnyVids you included all the twelve scenes - the Clara scenes?

  • @benphillips1454
    @benphillips1454 Před 4 lety +228

    I think the depth of the relationship between 12 and Clara pales all of the others. I think Twelve needed Clara more than the other Doctors needed their companions. Not for romantic love, but the love of two kindred souls who care for each other with a gut-wrenching depth of passion rarely seen.

    • @user-ms8eg5be1y
      @user-ms8eg5be1y Před 4 měsíci +1

      I love what you say, the twelve always lack compassion for Clara and I think he doesn't do it on purpose and that he has nothing to do with it because it's just to protect her

  • @silje8711
    @silje8711 Před 6 lety +497

    How can people possibly hate Clara? She's amazing

    • @laurenbotley1561
      @laurenbotley1561 Před 6 lety +4

      Silje ikr

    • @lukewoorm
      @lukewoorm Před 5 lety +24

      She was great with Capaldi, terrible with Smith.

    • @maksimally
      @maksimally Před 5 lety +34

      @@lukewoorm i don't understand it, she was amazing with eleven, they were so much alike. this 'friendship' was beautiful

    • @lukewoorm
      @lukewoorm Před 5 lety +8

      @@maksimally I dont know, it was sort of romantic and really forced in my opinion

    • @lukewoorm
      @lukewoorm Před 5 lety +14

      Rainbow00 _
      Idk, I just think the impossiblegirl arc was a terrible story and that smith and Coleman didn’t have chemistry like Coleman and capaldi did. I just didn’t see friendship with the two

  • @reagantao3436
    @reagantao3436 Před 7 lety +320

    So this is why Time Lords have two hearts. Just in case one gets broken :( ...

    • @MsSweetSerialKiller
      @MsSweetSerialKiller  Před 7 lety +6

      Roger Zodiac haha, I'm sorry!

    • @AltiTheFallen
      @AltiTheFallen Před 5 lety +13

      I think both hearts of the doctor have been broken

    • @ginaoswald9583
      @ginaoswald9583 Před 5 lety +7

      Stop it, I just stopped crying and now I’m starting again 😭

    • @britneyprincess23
      @britneyprincess23 Před 5 lety +5

      I think both his hearts were broken 😭😭😭

    • @Homoparanoia
      @Homoparanoia Před 3 lety +1

      @@AltiTheFallen two hearts... one happy, one sad...

  • @Rj-ws2qq
    @Rj-ws2qq Před 4 lety +145

    it's literally been 3 years and I can't stop thinking about her death. River, Missy, Amy and all his other companions were amazing but Clara was different, she was truly a wonder and definitely one of the best things to ever happen to the doctor. She had an amazing send-off and I'm so glad they fit her in when the doctor was regenerating but it still hurts so much. I think this is probably one of the best videos showing their relationship, thank you

  • @LouieNeira
    @LouieNeira Před 5 lety +81

    "NOT WITH ME! DIE WITH WHOEVER COMES AFTER ME, YOU DO NOT LEAVE ME!"

  • @theodorefigueroa9339
    @theodorefigueroa9339 Před 6 lety +219

    Oh I love this...
    This love story I feel will be soooo underrated. Because in my eyes this isn't a romance. This is a story of 2 individuals who are so alike and respect each other so much that they would go through hell and back for one another. They didn't need sexual tension to show how much emotion they carried for one another just their actions... and their words.... I'm not sure we will ever see another like this.
    The line that hits me the most the entire series is at Clara's end. "Clara I'm no different than you, I'm just less breakable." Those words from the doctor sum up everything you need to know about how the doctor feels for Clara. She is his equal, a fellow timelord and he can't face the loss of her. That is why the next season he clings so hard to missy, because she is all that's left that comes close to being his equal.

    • @gretagerminiani8488
      @gretagerminiani8488 Před 5 lety +33

      Sexual tension is not required for two individuals to be in a romance though. I feel like they were in love and sex (the lack of it) has absolutely nothing to do with it.

    • @bellascoles191
      @bellascoles191 Před 3 lety +10

      I have to agree. I think this is such an individual relationship that only the two of them have. I don't think it's a romance but something a lot deeper. It's like they created their own kind of relationship. Just my opinion

    • @sukiii-000
      @sukiii-000 Před 3 lety +3

      @@bellascoles191 I completely agree with u. What they had was so special I can’t even give it a label

    • @athenapallas7686
      @athenapallas7686 Před rokem +2

      @@bellascoles191 I totally agree with you and @Theodore Figueroa as well. To me it feels like calling them a romance would be an understatement to their relationship. It is so special and on a completely another level to all other relationships we've seen on DW (or in the majority of other shows, in my opinion) that it is hard to think of another example of such relationship. It is the type friendship all of us (or me, for certain) could ever hope for.

  • @TehDMBfan
    @TehDMBfan Před 5 lety +128

    I love this video. I know there's Rose and 10, Amy and 11, but to me this love feels the most raw, deep, non-superficial, powerful.. and the love will stay that way forever.

  • @GeneralBulldog54
    @GeneralBulldog54 Před 4 lety +26

    Broke my heart these two. On paper they're such an odd combo but I absolutely enjoyed story of 12 and Clara. It's a downright tragic that of the longtime who companions that died. Losing Amy and Rory made 11 retire for a bit but Clara, it made him break every rule he had. 4 and half billion torturous years living and dying on repeat just to have a chance to save someone already lost even to the point of being ready to wage war on his home planet where, even as a hero more renowned than Rasillon, he didn't care he made it back he just wanted his friend back.

  • @SuperEpicNiceGuy
    @SuperEpicNiceGuy Před 5 lety +104

    Clara- "Die with whoever comes after me, do not leave me"
    The Doctor died with Bill, well pretty close with Bill anyway.

    • @jasoncarto
      @jasoncarto Před 4 lety +20

      Because she already lost 11, right before her eyes. Losing another was too much to bear.

  • @atharvadeshpande6907
    @atharvadeshpande6907 Před rokem +23

    Doctor: "I had a Duty of Care! Clara Oswald, you will always look the same to me. When do I not see you? There was a crowd too? Do you think I care for you so little that betraying me would make a difference?"
    Clara: If you loved me in any way, you'll come back! I don't think I could ever forget you. People like us, they should say some things to one another, and I'm going to say them now. I love you!"
    How people still claim that theirs is not a love story is beyond me.

  • @peterxyz3541
    @peterxyz3541 Před 7 lety +62

    I think this love story is the closest and the best in TV history.

  • @nickm5881
    @nickm5881 Před 4 lety +13

    Clara Oswald was one of the best companions, and the dynamic between Clara and 12 was brilliant and beautiful. I miss them loads.

  • @mariamroczkowska9380
    @mariamroczkowska9380 Před 7 lety +86

    God... this hurts. Beautiful video. I will never get over their relationship, what a heartbreaking love story.

  • @maelle.c.
    @maelle.c. Před 6 lety +63

    It's been almost a year and I'm still not over their relationship, and Clara leaving and IT'S STILL SO PAINFUL
    AND YOUR VIDEO IS PERFECT, I'M CRYING AHhhh

    • @lawrenceg6810
      @lawrenceg6810 Před 4 lety +3

      Hardest companion death ever 💔

    • @travishood1278
      @travishood1278 Před 3 lety +4

      How can people possibly hate Clara? She's amazing

  • @autumnhobbit
    @autumnhobbit Před 7 lety +105

    ehehehehehe
    this is fine
    *opens window*
    this is.......fine.
    *steps onto ledge*
    this......is........fiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiine
    *jumps off*
    THIS. 👏 IS. 👏 FINE. 👏

  • @kirstyatwell344
    @kirstyatwell344 Před 6 lety +21

    At least he eventually got his memories back... Thank you, Bill Potts/weird glass alien memory thing.

  • @OfficalTVDNTv
    @OfficalTVDNTv Před 7 lety +36

    this made me cry. I'm shook.... what a masterpiece

  • @vellichor
    @vellichor Před 7 lety +32

    can you not
    be.
    SO.
    PERFECT.
    what the hell
    pls stop
    my heart is shredded, this video is pure gold

  • @addexio321
    @addexio321 Před 5 lety +12

    If you listen to this you can hear that the Twelfth Doctor was ready to die, he was accepting that he couldn't keep on regenerating forever, everything dies. But he did regenerate, ironically :P

  • @MagicalMusic34
    @MagicalMusic34 Před 6 lety +8

    God DAMN! They love each other. 😭❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @baileyravenwick
    @baileyravenwick Před 5 lety +13

    a year later and this video still has me in tears!!

  • @VioletEmerald
    @VioletEmerald Před 7 lety +8

    Wow. I haven't seen any episodes of the series containing either twelve or Clara, just gifs and maybe multi-fandoms, but I decided to click on this and I'm totally blown away by the emotion!!

    • @davidbroadbent6305
      @davidbroadbent6305 Před 3 lety

      @luvtheheaven guess time to see the full seasons of 12 with Clara is at hand

  • @poisonedfantasy6388
    @poisonedfantasy6388 Před 6 lety +20

    Omg!!!!!!! You just killed me all over again!!! 😭😭😭💔💔 Clara is my all time favorite companion!!!

  • @huhong4547
    @huhong4547 Před 3 lety +5

    After Twelve, Doctor is ended

  • @MorningAngell
    @MorningAngell Před 7 lety +12

    This is a masterpiece ! I miss her so much, i miss them so much . This is such an amazing video

  • @JCFProductions
    @JCFProductions Před 6 lety +13

    I AM SHATTERED. This was so beautiful and so sad!

  • @ViewTube_Emperor_of_Mankind

    Her eyes are mesmerizing

  • @LouieNeira
    @LouieNeira Před 4 lety +7

    “I’m so sick of losing you...”

  • @Capitan0Guinea
    @Capitan0Guinea Před 2 lety +12

    I totally love her. For me the story ended with Capaldi.

  • @sofiem4906
    @sofiem4906 Před 5 lety +6

    I'm still crying. 12th and Clara were great.

  • @dinamirm.9290
    @dinamirm.9290 Před 3 lety +5

    I know we all love the doctor and don't want it to stop. We don't want the adventures to stop. But I see this and my heart breaks. It's been too long. They should give him an end he needs. He, lying there, alone but no more regenerating, and slowly all the companions, friends and family that has ever been come around him, he smiles and says "i always hated the endings. But not this one"

  • @hashmatsherani1160
    @hashmatsherani1160 Před 3 lety +2

    I literally watch this every week and it only gets better

  • @cosmichearts
    @cosmichearts Před 7 lety +9

    omg im in tears
    i love clara so much and i miss her sm
    this is so beautiful
    just perfect
    i really hope clara will be back in the christmas special

  • @iwillcry
    @iwillcry Před 6 lety +5

    an award winning fanvid right here!!! daamn this is great, captured so many complicated emotions into 4.40 amazing minutes!

  • @aoko_
    @aoko_ Před 6 lety +2

    I just don't understand how i never saw any of your work before. This is a masterpiece, really.

  • @greysfan
    @greysfan Před 6 lety +10

    I can't deal right now...not crying, not crying ok I'm crying 😭

  • @danielmcelroy4967
    @danielmcelroy4967 Před 2 lety +2

    This is the best 12xClara fan edit I’ve ever seen, how tf did you make it so damn good!!! Amazing editing.

  • @Ladco77
    @Ladco77 Před 5 lety +6

    Clara is my favorite companion, only surpassed by River Song, who I consider more the Doctor's soul mate than a companion.

  • @oleh2792
    @oleh2792 Před 3 lety

    I'm just in love with this video. This is amazing!

  • @jensbergmann2432
    @jensbergmann2432 Před 3 lety +1

    Clara NEVER gone... because we all Remember her... so... SHE CAN`T DIE!!!!!

  • @elleford8725
    @elleford8725 Před 4 lety

    Creator your username is quite accurate. Well done you've killed my heart. And you've done it sweetly.

  • @whoufflelover5876
    @whoufflelover5876 Před 7 lety

    this is pure AMAZING, I miss these two so much :(((((((

  • @caslaker24
    @caslaker24 Před 7 lety +2

    I WATCHED THIS ON TUMBLR AND COULD NOT FIND IT AGAIN SO I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS AND NOW HERE I AM FINALLY FOUND IT FUCKING PROUD OF MYSELF BUT NOW I'M CRYING BECAUSE YOU CHOSE THE PERFECT QUOTES THIS IS MY JAM UNTIL CHRISTMAS WHO AM I KIDDING IT WILL BE MY JAM FOR EVER.....

    • @MsSweetSerialKiller
      @MsSweetSerialKiller  Před 7 lety

      mynameispurple I'm yelling omg, I'm so happy you like it! Thanks angel.

  • @bethylshipperforlifeedits2729

    How dare you do this to me Im over here crying watching this like my heart the doctor really loved clara she was his heart his home you can clearly see that he went through hell and back to save her through all the space and time and in the end she died but not before he went back to that last moment she died to let her know he cared i miss these two so much on doctor who there my otp for life

  • @catherinegrant7890
    @catherinegrant7890 Před rokem

    I DIDN’T NEED MY HEART TODAY THANKS. OMG THIS WAS SO GOOD AND I’M HAVING ALL THE FEELS 💔

  • @felicityqueen
    @felicityqueen Před 7 lety +7

    *'I'M FINEEEEEE*

  • @ayami123
    @ayami123 Před 3 lety +3

    9th to 12th doctor was a blast, shame it had to be the fanboy chimnel who has to write the 13th doctor story, sad really
    it just really means,
    FAN BOYS AND CRITICS DON'T KNOW HOW TO WRITE THE STORY OF THEIR FAVORITE SHOW. THEY ONLY KNOW HOW TO CRITICISE!

  • @ozgearabac2495
    @ozgearabac2495 Před 6 lety

    this.is.so.beautiful.

  • @kendrixhavlik3051
    @kendrixhavlik3051 Před 5 měsíci

    i will never be over them. not ever

  • @LouieNeira
    @LouieNeira Před 4 lety

    Perfect choice of music

  • @leroyrs
    @leroyrs Před 2 lety +3

    I'm pretty late when it comes to Dr. Who. I now started with the 10th season but in my mind I'm still with the Doctor and Clara. Nothing against Bill Potts but she is another type of companion. Nice but no Clara. Funny fact is when you see Peter and Jenna in interviews you still feel their connection like they were Clara and the Doctor.

  • @britneyprincess23
    @britneyprincess23 Před 5 lety +1

    Beautiful video 😭😭😭😭

  • @mariocurtis2208
    @mariocurtis2208 Před 4 lety +2

    In the good old days when Doctor Who script writing wasn't about beating us round the head with reality parallels, crisis metaphors and history lessons. How dare 'they' just take something from our real world and use it as scaffolding? I have huge respect for Jodie Whittaker but please give her more than a page of speechifying, the writing so far has been woeful . . . Rant over! . . . No, one more thing, Clara Oswald's story arc was beautifully crafted and it took me a long time to realise how well it was acted . . . Now I've finished . . . Promise.

  • @KarolinFluffy
    @KarolinFluffy Před 5 lety +1

    Daaaaamn! I got mad shivers the WHOLe video thru!!

  • @caitlinanne6271
    @caitlinanne6271 Před 2 lety

    the doctor and claras relationship was wonderful, sad and beyond beautiful this video made me cry but I still keep rewatching it because its beautifully tragic and wonderful Clara will forever live in my heart and so will the doctor, their love story was beautiful not in the romantic sense it was more so a sense of need and compassion between to kindred souls so very alike best of friends and family I will forever love doctor who and that is never going to change

  •  Před 7 lety

    aaaaAAAAAAAHHH THIS IS AMAZING

  • @arrowsandcrowns
    @arrowsandcrowns Před 5 lety +1

    💔💔💔💔💔 so good, so heartbreaking

  • @richardvannoy7230
    @richardvannoy7230 Před 6 lety +1

    Beautiful video.

  • @BlueStarsFire17
    @BlueStarsFire17 Před 7 lety +1

    Well, I guess I didn't need my heart to stay in one piece...
    ...
    But in all seriousness, that was awesome. Amazing work!

  • @jamesmcdonald9268
    @jamesmcdonald9268 Před 2 lety +1

    Her death still makes me so sad.

  • @autumnhobbit
    @autumnhobbit Před 7 lety +1

    also yeah i would very nearly kill to be able to make colorings as good as yours woman how do you even

  • @basicedits5134
    @basicedits5134 Před 3 lety

    Why are you making me tearbend at 2am 🥲

  • @lawrenceg6810
    @lawrenceg6810 Před 4 lety

    I have rewatched all of doctor who with exception of season 9.... I just can't bear it

  • @llamalordno9998
    @llamalordno9998 Před rokem +2

    This kind of depth is why I’ve been so disappointed in the series since Chris Chibnall took over. There’s no stakes, no loss, nothing that gets to the soul. In their attempt to make it more widely palatable, they neutered it of what made it beloved. Maybe RTD can reverse that.

  • @LouieNeira
    @LouieNeira Před 4 lety +1

    The music is “Cold” by Jorge Mendez

  • @cece_mich
    @cece_mich Před 7 lety

    thank you for reminding me all that pain.
    the only thing I wanna do now is make whouffaldi videos to piano themes i swear

  • @silentstorm509th9
    @silentstorm509th9 Před 5 lety +5

    I love Clara and the Doctor but their story is so depressing once you hit season 9.

  • @ImpossibleGirledits
    @ImpossibleGirledits Před 7 lety +13

    hahaha
    who needs a heart anyway
    haha
    right
    ha
    ...
    h
    ..
    well fuck I did, now I'm just sad and amazed and did I mention sad because the feels left a hole in my chest send help asap

  • @kokohekmatyar1770
    @kokohekmatyar1770 Před 7 lety

    That was so beautiful. I cried. And I have now a hole in my chest. It hurts. But it was so beautiful.
    I must see it again. XD

  • @danielmcelroy4967
    @danielmcelroy4967 Před rokem

    How did you make the perfect 12xClara edit wtf. HOW.

  • @castielwinchester6222

    I stopped watching doctor who after david tennant.. But now i know i have to finished it because this video brought tears to my eyes.. This doctor is so like THE doctor i am used to.. Like 9th doctor "my fav doctor" so thank you ❤️

  • @abbienorton9408
    @abbienorton9408 Před 7 lety +1

    I've just said my final goodbyes to my heart 😢

  • @lordsnia2152
    @lordsnia2152 Před 3 lety

    lovely, they were.

  • @blackocean75
    @blackocean75 Před 3 lety

    every time i see this video cry

  • @legoosetheythem2760
    @legoosetheythem2760 Před 6 lety

    Wow just wow

  • @TheNowemy
    @TheNowemy Před 7 lety

    Good video

  • @berliner0
    @berliner0 Před 6 lety +1

    awwwww

  • @jesseguthrie4955
    @jesseguthrie4955 Před rokem

    0:15 The way he looks at her 🥺

  • @Tennantphile
    @Tennantphile Před 4 lety

    Hi, I am crying

  • @12thdoctor
    @12thdoctor Před 2 lety

    💔💔

  • @tiagopatricio3805
    @tiagopatricio3805 Před 5 lety +6

    Now the question is... What did she tell him in the Cloisters?

    • @samuelwithers2221
      @samuelwithers2221 Před 4 lety +1

      That's a moment for them alone. They deserve that much

    • @Dillypickle541
      @Dillypickle541 Před 2 lety

      She said memories become stories when we forget them

  • @angelatarn4897
    @angelatarn4897 Před 6 lety +1

    I am fine, I am fine I am TOTOALLY fine!!!!!!!!

  • @gracesewell8961
    @gracesewell8961 Před 7 lety

    nope not crying....not at all *sniff

  • @mattschroeder3432
    @mattschroeder3432 Před rokem

    i had brain surgery i forgot so much. my family would tell me stories about my life.

  • @basicedits5134
    @basicedits5134 Před 3 lety

    Someone's cutting way too many onions here

  • @jerichoizackgutierrez607

    😭🙌

  • @tracyroweauthor
    @tracyroweauthor Před 3 lety +1

    So, you must have thought I was dead for a while
    Yeah
    How was that?
    Longest month of my life
    Can only have been five minutes
    I'll be the judge of time....

  • @kassandrasabean6020
    @kassandrasabean6020 Před 3 lety

    Don't leave me!

  • @hardbecks
    @hardbecks Před 7 lety +1

    oh no...

    • @SunnyVids
      @SunnyVids Před 7 lety

      say goodbye to ur friend

    • @hardbecks
      @hardbecks Před 7 lety

      you because you died or aminah because you're killing her?

    • @SunnyVids
      @SunnyVids Před 7 lety +1

      I mean...both

  • @ValeDisneylove95
    @ValeDisneylove95 Před 4 lety

    Everytime i decide ti rewatch this video, thinking "it's okay, i know It, i wont cry"
    Well. Guess what.
    IT'S NOY FUCKIN OKAY WTF IM CRYI. WTF WHY DO I HAVE TO SUFFER LIKE THIS EVERY DAMN TIME AFTER ALL THIS TIME

  • @HeartPhantom
    @HeartPhantom Před rokem

    you kno w WHAT

  • @Nina-pp5cd
    @Nina-pp5cd Před rokem

    At 3:36 you actually see the doctor wink at Clara with his left eye. 🤔🤔

  • @lazbeebot5478
    @lazbeebot5478 Před 6 lety

    Which episode is the “And you’ll still be gone” from?

  • @kermitefrog64
    @kermitefrog64 Před 4 lety

    Queen Victoria=Clara.

  • @LouieNeira
    @LouieNeira Před 5 lety

    shit! I hate you for making me cry!!!

  • @libbyjspenny
    @libbyjspenny Před 7 lety

    After watching yoyr videos I understand you account name 😂

  • @iiremkus7850
    @iiremkus7850 Před 3 lety

    which episode????????????

  • @serenity4eva89
    @serenity4eva89 Před 3 měsíci

    🥹🥹🥹

  • @GoogleUser-dwcy
    @GoogleUser-dwcy Před 4 lety

    What does he say at 0:12? ...... with someome she can't bear to lose.