Nobody Killed Aarushi Talwar & Hemraj? | The Debate With Arnab Goswami
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 08. 2024
- Republic TV is India's no.1 English news channel since its launch. It is your one-stop destination for all the live news updates from India and around the world. Republic TV makes news accessible for you at your convenience, at all times and across devices. At Republic we keep you updated with up-to-the-minute news on politics, sports, entertainment, lifestyle, gadgets and much more.
We believe in Breaking the story and Breaking the Silence. But most importantly, for us ‘You Are Republic, We Are Your Voice.’
Also, Watch ►
Republic TV Live News Updates ►bit.ly/Republic...
The Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/TheDebat...
Patriot With Major Gaurav Arya ► bit.ly/PatriotF...
Exclusive Sunday Debate With Arnab Goswami ► bit.ly/SundayDe...
Checkmate With Major Gaurav Arya (Retd.) ► bit.ly/3EtPj0s
The Grand Strategy With Maj Gen G.D Bakshi (Retd) ► bit.ly/3EPZ6xF
R.Explained ► bit.ly/3sOLT5K
R.Uninterrupted ► bit.ly/34isZdh
You can stay connected with Republic TV on -
Facebook - / republicworld
Twitter - / republic
Website - www.republicwo...
Instagram: / republicworld
#republictv #republicworld #republictvlive #englishnews #news #arnabgoswami #arnabgoswamilive #arnabdebates #nationwantstoknow
you bring 11 people to show and we can listen to nobody.
What about justice for Hemraj. Everyone seems interested on getting Justice for Aarushi. But what about the poor man,Hemraj. No justice for poor people in India. Shame on CBI and UP police for mishandling the case so carelessly.
Why justice needed for child molester..
@@ramasurvivor1820 how can you say that he is molester
Society has soft corner for girl this shows.....
Police don't handle evidence properly is the reason that case is still unsolved
@@sandysun8520 more like she was the daughter and the theory is that they killed the daughter.
Killer has surgical skills , knows everything in house and disappears under the door lol
Even child knows it’s dad lol
@@weRfreAkZ I just feel pity for judgmental people like you
@@illustrator3473 same bro .. these idiots have their own logic
Yes if hemraj is being killed by someone why he was dragged to terrace ?? No point ,,all these happened when these guys are sleeping??
@@abhisheksrivastav8928 they speak as if they were at the crime scene
Arnab has hit the Nail ! Arnav you have explained this case better than any body else in India ! I feel ashamed of Indian investigating agencies and Judiciary today !!!
Hahaha, are you serious, man?
then you should join in
Cinema Limitless surely even for SSR and Disha
With your name you seems shameless clothless bollywood PR 😂😂😂😂👠👠👠👠👠
@skylamp56 he did .....yes... Bcoz he is the GREATEST JOURNALIST in the universe....
It's arnab not Arnav
Figured out who killed Aarushi after 40 mins of shouting at each other ?
😢😢😢
Hats off and big salute to modern day journalism who tries not to hide information from the public... Big salute to the news team👍👍
The body language suggests clearly it is the Talwars.
After 9 years still it's mystery who killed arushi
Strange
A moderator should never take any pro or anti stance considering that this is a debate that's going on.
On the morning itself there should have been medical test of Talwar to find out if he drank whiskey the previous night.
❤❤❤❤ perfect 🤩 and well said
No one is raising these following questions including Arnab.
1) Why did NCW chairman Girija Vyas called an NCW team at Arushi's home and told them not to visit the crime scene and told specifically to back-off?
2) Why did Hemraj contact Usha of an NGO along with ringing up CBI office multiple times and tell his wife on Phone his life was in Danger?He knew about a threat to his life BECAUSE HE KNEW SOMETHING what was that secret?
3) What was KK Gautam's role(A former UP Top Police official) with respect to this crime?He was the person who told to check the roof and break the lock?Why did Talwar's brother call up KK Gautam?
KK Gautam is known to be very close to BSP supremo Mayawathi as well as SP Supremo Mulayam.
4) Why did UP police official during a press conferance on this case say "If we get permission of MayawthiJi we can solve this case in a day"?
5) What evidence did UP Police find out on Talwar's involvement with another lady Doctor Durrani who shared his clinic which was the reason claimed by UP police for Talwar eliminating Arushi and Hemraj?
6)Why didn't Nupur Talwar refuse to attend the court proceedings and later forced/Warned by the court to attend the same?
7) According to Post Mortem/Forensic report Arushi's hymen was gone and vagina path was found to be bigger than normal.
Why was Arushi's sexual organs found cleaned at the crime scene?
Why was doctors pressurised to remove the word "Rape' from the report?
8) Why was that specific photos were deleted from Arushi's laptop?
These incidents point out a bigger conspiracy and involvement of few bigwigs who don't want the truth to come out and that's the real reason of helping Talwar to escape.Talwar was part of a bigger network.
Once again it all begins, the shouting, the blaming, the indecent questioning. No one cares for the truth, the humanity; but just fame and TRP. Its a sad truth of my country and my people.
So true "Pipli live"
Then why still u indians say i am proud of india?
@@tweetyrocks7686 reasons like these is why I'm not
I came here for the comments😂😂
Parents have killed her
No grief or regret on their faces !
God won't spare them😡😡
This is not a debate.. its a "macchi baazar".
agree with u
Hahahaha
Talvar
Fish market is right! 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Whenever I hear too much loud screaming, I forward the video because I just can't take it; it gives me a headache!
At least you get Macchi in macchibazaar ,😁
Money saved Talwar's...
@Krishna Swami
Money talks and bullshit walks; it's a true saying!
1st time watching an Indian debate show. Exciting !
Every one still asking , who killed Aarushi ?
Ya still public bothrd more to knw abt murder Dan aarushi parnts
I think Arnab should file the case in Supreme Court as a prosecutor against Talwars. I am sure he will win not because Talwars are guilty, but he won't let anyone present their sides. I doubt whether he will wait judges for their convictions or he may declare his decision. Man you sound like a fanatic. I got scared.
madhusmita p :hahahaha lolz :)
Lols good one
Agreed
madhusmita p they will admit committing this hideous crime & surrender instead of facing Arnab in the court .
😂
Arnab is the killer!!
lol, good one bro
i think ravi sharma may be the killer seeing his enthusiasm
😂😂😂😂😁😁😁😁😁hahahahaha
Mind-blowing ye😂😂😂😂😂😂
Hahahahahahahaha
Arnsb has clearly and strongly voiced the questions which we have!!!!!
You call it a debate. I call it an one man show 😁
😁
I feel, it is time to search Terrace pictures taken from Satellite. CBI should attempt to find out such possibilities.
Abi b koi DNA hoga. The case should reopen
AND I AM THANKFULL TO MR ARNABH GOSWAMI ONE CRORE TIMES AS WELL AS HIS TEAM THEY THESE PEOPLE ARE VERY SINCERE OTHERWISE THE OTHER CHANNELS I HAVE LOST FAITH
After so many years me still wanting to know who killed arushi.. shame on the judiciary system of India..
Only parents and parents
Same here i swear ...
@@rajendrakhani8282who obviously killed her
Why is there so much hate in the comment section against Arnab ?
He is a journalist .
His job is to make the normal people aware of what is going around and demands a proper investigation.
We all are familiar with the proceedings of the case
I hope you all would be aware of the movie Talwar.
We know what is right.
He is just stating that its strange that no one would have killed Aarushi.
He is just debating on what is wrong with the law and order in this country.
Please rise up in unision instead of ranting about Arnab.
All the journalists do a great job.
P.S.: Arnab has not paid me.
A J @ people are angry because he may talk against the judgements.
Arushi case is really full of Drama and emotion.No prove against her parents.
This is the fact and a journalist cannot deny.He is not a judge from any court.
When a high court acquainted her parents,then who the Hale is he?????
But common people cannot use slang AGAINST him..
Gaurab Chatterjee
Neither is he denying it nor passing a judgement.
You would be well familiar with the people on any debate.
Shouting using slangs and other stuff.
We all have different opinions.
Arnab is stating facts.
What the rest are saying or doing is not his responsibility.
That's why he has a debate so that all different opinions are made available to the common people.
Peace out
He is so biased
Only let's the people who support his side of argument to speak
Interferes and insults the others and never let's them speak
Everybody knows it was murder and there were only few number of suspects but still they couldn’t find the murderer. That’s crazy.
Wearing surgical gloves when dragged him.. no fingerprints.. that itself tells the truth.. karma will haunt the talwars
How come you are saying surgical gloves? Gloves can be of any type , all of those avoid fingerprints
Police and cbi use just mere cloth while handling evidences to avoid fingerprints
Knowing all this, I felt very disappointment about Justice for Sushant Singh Rajput &Disha Salian 💔💔💔😭😭😭😭
Yes yes..."look what he had done"
Mother said to the maid.
That statement alone proves him guilty. That maid should be allowed to speak.
Parents are guilty...there is no doubt .
i think his servants done it . see his narco test video
@@kartikeynigamThat Narco Test is a sham...deliberately leading questions were put repeatedly..that lady was sacked for her shady deals
If only " He" had done ,why did
" He" spare Nupur ? Both are involved equally
Siddharth pithani did this.
hahahahaha
Noooo, a very sweet criminal did it, aaaaaaah
Respect for the court is diminishing day by day if such kind of decision were taken.
There is no justice in the place of justice.
Arushi was killed by her parents......
End of story
Exactly!
@Swaroop Swaroop why her father killed her??! Reason
Accidentally murdered her . He was trying to run after Hemraj
People like Ravi Sharma who protect the murderers are a big threat to the safety of innocent people .
Arushi was of my age and I am 28yrs on 2022, SAD
I WAS LISTENING TO AN INTERVIEW OF NUPUR TALWAR IN JAIL. SHE DID NOT ONCE SAY ABOUT HER FIGHT FOR DAUGHTERS MURDER. TALWARS KILLED ARUSHI .
CBI SHOULD FILE A CASE IN SUPREME COURT."
Who else but the parents should be answerable. Why police not used 3rd degree for parents to get the answers? Arushi was either raped / had sex before death. Otherwise why on earth her private parts were cleaned ? Who had sex with her? Hemraj? or one of the parents? and somebody- hemraj witnessed it and so was killed. Why should the parents come out of their sound proof bed room in the middle of night and go to Arushi's room? what was the purpose?
Ragini Deshpande : I agree with you
also during whole murder in the night they said they couldn't hear anything. how did they hear and immediately responded to the doorbell in the morning? how?
they also confessed of committing murders .
Nupur confessing the use of Golf stick and other events to prove they are killers.
www.dailypioneer.com/todays-newspaper/nupur-confessed-to-golf-club-as-weapon-in-narco-analysis.html
@@ritushukla9284..because they were awake & did not sleep...their room door was open
Whatever...Arnab sir u r ossummm....😘😘
& i m cmpltly agree wid ur 5 questiona...!
The fittest one in debate
he was like... fuck intro... Tell me who killed arushi?
Arnav explains clearly who did it without mentioning the culprit name. Shame on the investigators and huge shame on Delhi Court of Justice! There is no justice to helpless and poor people in India. The same injustice stories keep going!
What is Delhi Court of Justice ??
he should interview talwars then truth will come
why this case was handed over to CBI so early? I mean Rajesh Talwar had confessed to committing these murders.
Tabi to cbi ko hand over kiya bcs rajesh had confessed the crime ..
When and where? I didn’t see that video
100% God knows who killed Aarushi & Hemraj
Hemraj could’ve killed aarushi and talwar definitely killed hemraj. Otherwise why would talwar not send police to the terrace?
@@sln7839 Why would Hemraj kill Aarushi, she called him uncle
Yes I agree. Maybe someone was threatening Hemraj to murder Arushi (maybe enemy of Rajesh) and then Hemraj was murdered by Rajesh
12 dogs are barking together
Very well said, aaaaaaah
You deser reward.made me laugh for hours
How about bit*hes ? 😂😂
Still i didn't understand,,, what about Mobile tower location,, if they are only 4 members,, it is only Her parents killed...
in the night talwars couldn't hear anything but in the morning they heard the doorbell. how?
That makes sense..
Valid point
At night they had a fault air conditioner which was super loud. They might’ve turned off the AC at the time of morning, Right?
@@yukinotoku2686 but they didn't say of putting off that ....it was on throughout .
Who knows if the Ac was on
Ravi Sharma should be in fish market
Why is arnub screaming, we can hear just fine with mic.
arnab can be the judge instead of sitting as a journalist!
I lost my respect for CBI after this case. In the end they could not come to a proper conclusion.
Talwars killed with their surname.
1) Why an outside killer wrap hemraj's body in some razai ? he will kill and just run away
2) difference of timing between 2 murder 30-40 mins is question directing towards parents guilty
3) why any outsider will try to dress up the murder scene if not parents who were all along inside the house ?
Nupur called Hemraj's phone from the Talwars' landline at 6.01 a.m. on 16 May. The call was picked up, but disconnected after two seconds. This call was the last received on the phone, which was somewhere in the coverage area of the Nithari village cell tower 1362/254. This gave feeling to the police that Hemraj was still alive. Clever, Very clever move. Isn't it?
@@anilsep27 yes absolutely agree... There were many planned clever moves and many planned moves that went haywire and came hunting back to them.
Everyone know now that the parents are indeed the culprits. But the way they tried to implicate other poor innocent servants who did not have even slightest idea on order to save themselves from the disgrace of knowing killer of their own child and to escape from the punishment of the law of the land by hook or crook is what even more saddening and disgusting 🤢 🤢🤢🤢🤢
This case shows the UGLY TRUTH OF CORRUPTION AND value of life of RICH AND POWERFUL VERSUS POOR PEOPLE...
Also, the pathetic level of justice system in India 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
@True life but y would parents kill their own daughter?
All the while when parents are sleeping peacefully 😂😂
I hope it will never happen with sushant case🙏🙏🙏
A real giveaway is the guilty shifty look of Nupur Talwar
Haha, what?
mother is the mastermind
Will this debate help Arushi get justice?If yes then i guess CBI and judge aren’t required!
There is no doubt that Arushi and Hemraj haven’t got justice.But where will this debate get to?1hour of argument,1 hour of screaming will get to no where.Few people screaming wont change Honourable judges verdict.Question are and will be raised.But question yourself is this debate even meaningful?
This is being done only for TRP purpose
Is this how you conduct debates on public media? Shame on Arnab to keep shouting like this. Journalists should keep opinions to themselves. Sad day for Indian media.
Nonsense vivek
What Aryaman Sundaram has said I completely agreed. When people who doesn't have any scientific knowledge about forensic science handle the crime scene.
arnab is doing his duty..he is putting the right questions again n again BT no one is daring to answer him..nobody wants to speak the truth..aditya(talwars lawyer) is putting arnab down by not answering him..
Not parents, Not servants, this third person committed the murders.
It all happens only in India, because there is 5 letter word called money which can buy 7 letter word justice.
From the beginning of crime, parents showed interest only to tamper the evidence and manipulate postmortem report but no intetest to find out culprits of their daughters murder. Why ?
Haha if there were glasses placed in front of Arnab they would all break the way he his shouting!!
😁😁
The parents are the killers. The door was locked by her mom and put the key under her pillow. WTF No evidence against them
so? what were you doing at the crime scene? speaking as if lol
I just heard of this case and am gobsmacked! I hope this gentleman breaks it down better cos from what I saw, the parents are guilty as sin.
Mr&Mrs Talwar I am so sorry for the trauma you had to go through.May God continues to give you strength
This is really bad journalism!
Ashwin nair says a keralite leftist fool
Ashwin nair pal it's just plain bad, there is no journalism in this video.
Nidhish Prasannan stfu u irrelevant piece of shit
@ashwin nair: yes I agree. this is a very sad form of journalism. these journalists take sides which is so uncalled of their profession.
Agree totally. In fact it is not journalism at all!
I wonder who are all receiving the curses of arushi and hemraj......
Mr Arnab Goswami we the people of India are waiting for you to question the BJP government and our Mr prime minister about the failure of demonetization.
I am sure you would be aware of how the demonetization plan had a negative impact on our country.
Thank you.
#jai hind.
Hope u stop blaming our PM for burnt roti in ur home too.
Why is he screaming? It's embarrassing just watching him,does he think the loudest person wins.
😁😁
India main log ayse baat sunte samjhte hain
make Paranormal Activity so that aarushi spirit can tell the truth
If the killer was drinking whiskey after killing the girl, was the suspected father's blood sample taken for a lab test?
Nope… yaar socho ke terrace pe kayse nahi finger printing howa ya evidence nahi mila. Police mili hoi thi. Paiysa khoob khaya
Don't expect Noida Police to be that efficient 😂😂
It’s unfair to blame poor servants because no one would be there to help them and support 😢😢. Sorry Hemraj. R.I.P
can someone summarize here what is said in video . too difficult watch
I have a doubt, If parents did it with so much precision, they could have kept the main door open after committing the crime to make it appear as if it is outsider's Job. Why they didn't?
It was opened, actually it was closed from outside.
A sharp object will always yield a precise wound unlike blunt object irrespective of the person using it be it a kitchen knife used by a servant to cut vegetables or a scalpel used by a surgeon to incise during surgery. This is where medical journalism is needed.
its 2020! so many things happened this year ..the pandamic,irfan khans death ,SSR’s death n so many more...
but still we didn’t know “who killed arushi?!!”
Her parents killed her.
SSR committed suicide.
@@Mathson_M ssr didn't commit suicide, it is a murder
@@rakeshshekhar5318 Sherlock Holmes?
@@Mathson_M apne logic apne paas rakh oye. Tu sherlock holmes hai jo suicide bol raha hai.
Arnab please go-ahead. 🙏
Possible sequence of events
CASE 1 . Rajesh was having an extra-marital affair with Anita Durrani. Aarushi must have saw them having an sexual intercourse tooked photos .There are reports of some photos missing .Aarushi's camera had photographs numbered 13, 15, 20, 22 and 23: this indicates that at least 23 photographs had been taken using the camera, out of which 18 had been deleted. Those must be the photos of his activity .She must have shown them Hemraj after which he started blacking him and as a result he was murdered . But still doesn't explain why kill his daughter. 1
.If he was having an affair his wife should have known
2.Why she did not came forward
CASE 2. Rajesh was having an extra-marital affair with Anita Durrani. Aarushi must have saw them having an sexual intercourse .She might not have know what it was so she might had tried to have an intercourse with hemraj . Rajesh must have seen them together so in rage he might have killed them both. His wife must have been involved to since it would have brought shame on their family .
It could be that hemaj was the father of Aarush no no but it does not explain why his wife didn't oppose him. They were both doctors they must have realized about her daughter activity so they kill them both .Mother kill her daughter cleaned the place and her virgina and the father took out hemraj .
Expert doctors they cleaned the evidences
He must have drank visky before killing her daughter because it takes everything to do that no one kill his one child like that
She was 14,she knew whats sexual intercourse is
Who is Anita Durrani???
Why didn't they do Narco test for the Talwars??!!!!
They did but nothing useful came out of them.
They did...Narco is an useless test
CBI must be banned , there must be a international bodies for finding such murder mystery, take 9 yrs , it will not take more than 48 hours , that is why our process , system , law is worst in the country
A mother cant be silent over a cheater killer husband.
I agree with u
Who was it then
This case has become more of whether the talwars should or should not be released.... well in actual fact the case should always be justice for aarushi n hemraj and find out the the cold blooded murderer/s.
Then who killed Aarushi
Everything points to the talwars. Just not enough evidence because the scene was tempered
How they evidenced got tempered? And who did ?
Disappointed by Indian crime investigation
I DONNO HOW TRUE WAS THE MOVIE CALLED TALWAR
Its somewhat true
Movie that shows talwars in good light....doesn't give you a 2 sided picture...wonder talwars have put their money into this as well
may be meghna gulzar got the confessions of talwars😂
Narco scenes showing Krishna talk about killing her with the Kukri was not true and all related scenes too..
Isn't this contempt of court?
Theme music is great arnab ji
The accused must hav used the gloves to drag the body of Hemraj upstairs/golf stick to hit Hemraj....both r missing....Most importantly where is the knife which was used to stabb Hemraj??
no gloves was used. there were visible palm prints on the staircase and elsewhere. but they did not match with talwars
@@Narendran030496 how u know this then with whom was it matching??
4 person in home two are killed two alive directly we can justify killer is mom and dad
The Best Lack All Conviction While the Worst Are Full of Passionate Intensity. - WIlliam Blake
Daaamnn that intro though!!
The only people to blame for this murder are the Forensic and Policemen didn't do they job they messed out all the crime scene and the killer or killers are walking free. My personal opinion I think the parents murder the daughter and the servant.
Money works very well. This file is closed till the killer himself comes out in future
may be in old age.
This is not a debate. Nobody listens to anyone. Arnab you are not being a mediator. You can't be prejudice when running a debate and cut off people when they speak. My god it's like a fish market
Invites so many guests and then shouts all by himself! The people who continuously watch this channel are equally responsible for this madness barking on TV.
Here Arnab Goswami is right
I had to lower the volume. It hurts my ear...
You are quite right!
I wonder why the same set of people come back to the show and get insulted and demeaned by a holier-than-thou soul. I'm guessing it is a contract between the channel and the participants to come on the show get insulted and judge, get paid for the trouble in return. This isn't a debate, this is an attempt by Arnab to find approval for his statements and beliefs. What a glorified hypocrite making it implicit who killed Arushi while saying outwardly that he isn't insinuating.
What a madhouse.
His open bias makes it intolerable to consider his news channel serious journalism. What can be a bigger irony, calling themselves the most independent news venture but still being funded by a present member of parliament. Making his own judgment and judiciary system accuse others without any reality.....