The Newshour Debate: Media scrutiny = Media trial? Full Debate ( 25th Nov 2013 )
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2024
- In a debate moderated by TIMES NOW's Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami, panelists -- Dr.Dinesh Talwar, Brother of Dr.Rajesh Talwar; Avirook Sen, Journalist & Author (Writing a book on Aarushi's Case); Aryama Sundaram, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court; Shobha De, Author & Columnist; Saba Naqvi, Political Editor, Outlook; Shree Paradkar, Aunt of Aarushi Talwar; R K Anand, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court and KTS Tulsi, Advocate, Supreme Court -- discuss whether the verdict proves that media was unfairly targeted throughout the trial and whether the verdict is the final closure.
one thing... any blame on Media is taken too personally by media people.
Youre right. Not the parents, not the servants
Commentators (albeit from the safefy or anonymity) like the others and millions others killed Aarushi, Hemraj, and the parents as well, that night and every day since
The media trial, middle class envy every institution involved in the investigation, and the society at large is responsible for this tragedy of colossal proportions
Pathetic 😔
Parents have killed their daughter in rage and hidden the evidence.Exreemely smart people!
Barnali Maitra killed her daughter in rage and hidden the evidence.Exreemely smart lady!
Not the parents, not the servants
Commentators (albeit from the safefy or anonymity) like this one and millions others killed Aarushi, Hemraj, and the parents as well, that night and every day since
The media trial, middle class envy every institution involved in the investigation, and the society at large is responsible for this tragedy of colossal proportions
Pathetic 😔
Nupur Talwar and Rajesh Talwar killed Arushi and they should be punished
Not the parents, not the servants
Commentators (albeit from the safefy or anonymity) like this one and millions others killed Aarushi, Hemraj, and the parents as well, that night and every day since
The media trial, middle class envy every institution involved in the investigation, and the society at large is responsible for this tragedy of colossal proportions
Pathetic 😔
I think Arnab was right at his place. They are media. If he is upset about a decision made why is her targeting him ? He should target the legal system and not the one who is reporting the issue.
Not the parents, not the servants
Commentators (albeit from the safefy or anonymity) like this one and millions others killed Aarushi, Hemraj, and the parents as well, that night and every day since
The media trial, middle class envy every institution involved in the investigation, and the society at large is responsible for this tragedy of colossal proportions
Pathetic 😔
Looks like Arnab wanted to lash out himself and called the guests to be his guinea pigs. I have never seen such a poor display of compereing/moderating where the compere's voice and opinions were the loudest. Is this normal in India? If so all guests should decline to appear in farcial shows such as these. All I heard was this useless chap Arnab or whatever his name is incite a shouting match. Extremely poor performance. If this is the acceptable std, no wonder the media is held accountable for all that is going on in the Arushi case.
He only allows those who act as his mouthpiece to speak...and basically shouts down others, no matter how much they have to bring out.
Youre right. Not the parents, not the servants
Commentators (albeit from the safefy or anonymity) like the others and millions others killed Aarushi, Hemraj, and the parents as well, that night and every day since
The media trial, middle class envy every institution involved in the investigation, and the society at large is responsible for this tragedy of colossal proportions
Pathetic 😔
The guy said that Media's job is not to write fiction but questions" he is absolutely right
Not the parents, not the servants
Commentators (albeit from the safefy or anonymity) like this one and millions others killed Aarushi, Hemraj, and the parents as well, that night and every day since
The media trial, middle class envy every institution involved in the investigation, and the society at large is responsible for this tragedy of colossal proportions
Pathetic 😔
why this avirrok sen is so much into favour of talwars..and on top of it wriiten a book on them to affect views of people
He always blames police and cbi for mistakes in investigation..yeah he never talk against talvars as far I know
All those saying that servants are proved guilty thru narco test It's proved wrong.. Cos the Lady kept leading him to accept the crime. But he was not trapped saying that It was Anita and Rajesh affair the motive and also said he was asked by Arun Kumar to accept the crime..
Now further Read this all those who say Talwars are not murderers.. Nupur confessing the use of Golf stick and other events to prove they are killers.
www.dailypioneer.com/todays-newspaper/nupur-confessed-to-golf-club-as-weapon-in-narco-analysis.html
Wah.
The world's biggest megalomaniac, a lawyer found guilty of misconduct and contempt and a gossip columnist mount a stunning defence the media's role in the Aarushi Talwar Case. If I was a member of the media i would ensure this was never aired.
This Man Arnab is a danger to society. It is his channel, without respecting anyone, resorts to demolishing everyone. Shame on you Arnab. He resorts to silly questions when cornered.
Arnab doesn't care abt parents or servants, but TRPs based on sensationalising without actually questioning 'facts'
U people are stupid blaming media remember SSRs media helped a lot and parents never heard anything then father said Humraj did it so police looking for Humraj
arnab bhaiyaji smile..............................bolna aasan hai.....prove karna mushkil..........u shoul be nominated as third CBI team...........
Hemraj's blood on pillow found in Krishna room..why would killer carry hard evidence in his house for so long..
Someone put in his room.Talwars did
He doesn't want to listen to any answers, just wants to ask biased question !
What about the blood on krishnas pillow. Why's nobody talking about the facts.
The Truth... I don't know the details of Blood on Krishna's pillow but It had been investigated and established that The three servants had cast iron alibi's .They were not there,couldn't hv been there. Thus only Talvars. For starters Rajesh feigned ignorance to identify Hemraj's body. Just that tells it all. It was only two days old. Wasn't decomposed.Anyone known to him could have identified him.
the host never stops only while S D is talking .... WTF !
Just see Nurbhayas moms body language and see this Nupurs. 😂😂😂😂😂
They are clearly triangulating Arnab the media and their pity ploys so that the main motive of who killed that poor girl and that poor servant is dismissed. Now it becomes media versus Talwar. Oh come on . That's an old trick. Grow the hell up child abusers
Lady in black it is not about covering an tragic incidence of 14 year old girl's murder it is about presenting it with lots of guessing and and seasoning (MASALA MAR KE)
I would like to point out few things(regarding arnab's questions):
*He was saying it is court's decision what we can do.for vyapam case the same was said by one of the guest and arnab was the one who pointed out it was wrong.why not now.are you that stubborn to not consider any facts!!
*He was asking why people were silent when talwars were told innocent and not when they are held guilty:There is lot of evidence to tell they are innocent and nothing proves they are guilty.just go through the evidences.
*One more thing judge may get influenced by media..!!!if media can influence public..where does the judge come from !!he is one among us and yes there is a chance that he may get influenced.
*As pointed out by arnab;one of the guest has been following up from day one of arushi's case.when the same person was disagreeing with arnab;doesn't he even consider may be he was wrong.
P.S:Am not talwar's advocate and i do follow up arnab's work.!!!!
Arnab thinks he represents all medias of India including 3rd grade. Is he the CEO of India's media?
The case is lost but what i can clearly see here a patient with hyperactive disorder, imbalanced, get way too defensive.figure out??
I kind of like avi
media want a sensational news not thuth, this time you are wrong arnab, not that i am saying talvars are innocent
Foolish questions Foolish discussion
Abhirup ji dushro ko bolne de
Its the media that is being influenced and manipulated by the CBI not the other way around. Unfortunately today's media is more concerned with viewership than putting forth the truth and looking at all aspects of a story. Certain organizations take advantage of that. And by the way this Arnab guy should befriend Piers Morgan, they're both equally annoying and use their show to promote their own views. Good journalism or good television?
arnav , you r such a shame in the name of journalist.
The host is absolutely annoying.
He is in the wrong job...he should use his excess emotions and bias and decibel level for some drama..
Not a talk show where a servant or Talwar both are human..and truth can come to the fore only through hoensty not bias, which this bigot cannot understand.
Psychopath Arnab...
Please allow Talwar family to speak...you are basically shutting down their voice, while encouraging Shobha De to side with your fictional TRP cocktail.
Shameful.