Why Supreme Court Upheld Abrogation of Article 370 | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 12. 2023
- Why Supreme Court Upheld Abrogation of Article 370 | Vantage with Palki Sharma
India's supreme court has upheld the parliament's decision to abrogate article 370 and end the special powers allotted to the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir.
It has also directed the Election Commission to hold polls in J&K by September 2024.
Palki Sharma tells you how Kashmir has changed after 2019.
---
Jammu and Kashmir | Article 370 Abrogation | Supreme Court | India | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#jammukashmir #article370 #supremecourt #india #abrogation #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
Should statehood in Jammu and Kashmir be reinstated soon?
Leave a comment and let us know your thoughts
Dodging election's for a decade 😂
Democlacy
Modi ji ❤ ,thanks for your big move
Not now.
In addition to the economic development for the modern times, can Jammu and Kashmir's original character be restored to pre-foreign-invasion status? Or, as close to it as it can possibly be done? Greater wisdom, prosperity, harmony and peace emanated from there... So I have learned from history.
My reading of the current situation is that it is recovering remarkably well, the positive improvements are so visible for all of us to see, but some societal elements are trying to stop it.
My answer to your question is in there somewhere...🙂
No
This is really a very great victory for Indian constitution and for the present centre government also. We never want to see a separate constitution and law an order for a state that belongs to India. So as Indians we upheld the abrogation of Article 370 wholeheartedly.
Constitution are made for people who are living there. If Kashmiri people doesn't like this law then this is just oppressing them. And oppression is the only reason for weaker law and order. Think wisely otherwise this region cannot afford another Pakistan.
If authentic kashmiri people pandits cannot settle in Kashmir then it's right to change law
@@mehrabrafi9496 all Indian states follow Indian construction. Kashmir is no different.
Chances of another pakistan like situation will result in POK and GB coming under Indian control.
Jai hind.
@@mehrabrafi9496all states follow indian constitution . Dont worry. If someone wants another country then they will be made to leave.
@@mehrabrafi9496are they special? Constitution is made for well being of country.if any law create problems for country then it should be abolished. Just listen facts.dont support because they are muslim
I visited Kashmir in 2022 , stayed there for 7 days , visited major places like Gulmarg , Pahalgham ,Srinagar etc. Kashmir is one of the best places in India which are less explored and the beauty is beyond words.Being from Kerala snow laden mountain peaks are wonders especially at Gulmarg. Hope the security threats are down to 0 so that everyone from the World can come and enjoy .
No tourist is being threatened neither before not now. So, please update your dictionary!
@@newworld786 I have visited Kashmir only once and on the first day in Srinagar there was a granede blast in one of the market and one policeman was killed which was shown on the news while I was at the hotel. There was military personnel everywhere from evening the next day . Apart from the freelancing tourist guides all the people were nice during my stay . So your opinion is totally wrong and me hoping 0 threat is a good gesture as a human being.Hope you clear your facts before correcting other’s personal experiences and opinions 😄
Hey… you should try Himachal Pradesh also .. no less than Kashmir 😊
...Rejects extra judicial killing in Jammu Kashmir.
@@BizVerseTvvisited himachal n remained there for a year. People are good but too much local politics for everything is for local people. Never exp this in chattisgarh, mp, Raj, haryana, Delhi, up, Punjab, etc remained in all these states for months. Soo HP is good but the local police, hosp, or any govt or pvt offices prefer local people and your say is second to them. So ask people to avoid HP. Prefer uttarakhand.
N this not only my opinion . Had a dozen friends with same exp. So sorry enjoy ur hp but never coming back there in my life n never advising my friends and family. Uttrakhand is far batter in scenic beauties al😮so.
It's victory of 1.4 billions Indians SC recognized the unity of India previously it was disrupted by Nehru.Modi rectified Nehru mistakes in JK
You are being misguided by media.
Criminal acts are not mistakes.
Not all 1.4 billion people bro since a big chunk of us have Muslims and librandus
I am really feeling sad for Mehbooba, Owaisi, Abdullahs, Arfa, Barkha, Shepherd and their gang. These are the "CRITICS" Palki referred to 🤣😛 Also a grand salute to our Respected PM Shri Narendra Modi, Shri Amit Shah and our Indian Army. While we appreciate this, never forget that many innocent soldiers, some way too young lost their precious life to make this happen. We all owe it to them and the families they left behind.
The critics mentioned above are less dangerous than snakes like Shehla Rashid who knows how to swing with the tide and bite back when times arrives. Atleast the critics above have a fixed objective and are clear about it.
By Sheperd do u means tatti rathee😂😂😂
There is only 1 shepherd on youtube...who has now become a movie critic cos Sandeep Vanga is a supporter of Modi Ji 😄@@allsports6045
Get out of Endia and Endians Kashmir 😡
Real good work was done by Nehru ji. Kashmir is a part of india so they must have a state govt which is natural justice.
@@gyanendrasinha3120 biggest blunder was done by Nehru only by converting an internal matter into global matter
I have watched some old videos of Kashmir just now and today I really appreciate how this govt handle Kashmir isse and how much situation changed on ground and why it is really mean when we held G20 at Kashmir 😢😮
And we should also take a moment to think of those who opposed it.. thinking only of their own personal benefits and not the nation’s interest…
When the original people the original habits of Kashmir the Kashmiri Hindus can go back to the Kashmir valley. Can roam freely,can celebrate the festivals and can perform the religious ceremony openly and freely. Only then Kashmir would be truly developed.
From Bengal ❤ 🙏 who knows the pain of loosing own mother land bcz of the Islamic terrorists
true
You need to do more research about kashmiri pandits ,they have not gone anywhere , they are living in jammu division with luxury life , enjoyed privileges and reservation in govt jobs , most of them have sell their lands and ablaze their houses deliberately in order to benefit from govt policies and luxury back then and more over I heared from my grandpa and grandma back then people were living in hormony an'd still in some some parts of kashmir valley muslims perform the last rites of their Hindu neighbour ,we have not a racist problem here like in UP and other states ..
@@mehrvlogs9459@mehrvlogs9459
Oh believed what you said 😂
@@mehrvlogs9459the targeted killings , the cross border terrorism - all this ? You don't care ? Or living in another world , don't know about this ?
@@mehrvlogs9459lol. Pakistani found.
Pakistan and congress have same opinion.... no wonder
congress nahi khangress
@@AmanYadav-lk7suNo it's Scamgress
Bcz the supporters of congress are actually pakistani who remained here in 1947. They're not indians leftover of 1947 needed to throw out of bharat
देश की दुश्मन कॉंग्रेस को २०२४ में भारत की जनता नेस्तनाबूत करेगी.
yes they have the same mindset also.
From Omar Abdullah statement it appears he wants the decision reversed. This shows where his loyalties lie. Certainly not with India.
Those people still alive that is our shame
Yes… That’s why turning statehood now will not be a good thing.. things can easily go back to before, if it falls in wrong hands… better to wait for couple of years, until people themselves start changing completely for the better..
@@MsHSpring true it would be same if abdullaah annd mufti comes to power again
DMK, Congress, Muslims & Periyaar (🤣) are extremely unhappy with the SC Verdict.
Why Muslims?
@@newworld786 The muslims who are against The Verdi, not everyone!
you forget communists of kerela
Let them cry😂
This is the most important thing I greatly admire Mohdi. He was courageous enough to take the bull by the horn.
Much 💗 from Africa my dear Indian people
Common kashmiri Muslims still have not given up their anti-Hindu attitude. Hindu tourists who visit Kashmir have problem in visiting the Hindu shrines. The taxi drivers and horse owners find some excuse or the other to avoid taking the tourists to such Hindu shrines. There is too much fleecing of the tourists, especially by cab drivers. This deplorable mindset is yet to change.
Give it time..time n peace changes everything.
Agreed. When we visited Kashmir last year, we had tilak on our forehead after visiting shankarcharya temple. Post this when we went to buy a water bottle from a shop, the shopkeeper didn’t even bother to give us bottle even after asking multiple times. He just pretended like we didn’t even existed there. He was just taking orders from Muslim people who were present. We moved away from that shop and took water from another place nearby.
Your presentation is very interesting and charming .. Nothing temporary can continue for long. There CANNOT be Two Flags, or Two Prime Ministers and certainly NOT Two CONSTITUTIONS. How can anyone still ask for such absurd decision to continue?.
The supreme court should have also put in the requirement or consideration of using all government resources to restore the rights, properties and return the Kashmiri Pandits within a time-frame before elections are held.
These measurements in time and performance should be scsleable under independent review.
Step by step... day by day... although slowly... we are moving closer and closer to integrating pok and askai chin back in india😊😊
call aksai chin " Gosthan"
Step by step.. day by day.. India becoming Pakistan... Remember my comment and check after 10 years. Thank you
@@mehrabrafi9496ohh will remember your comment for comic relief. 😂😂😂😂
@@mehrabrafi9496😂😂😂 tumhe yehi lgega
Jab 370 hti tab pakistan ki maa chudi
Smjhlo ki india ne acha ki hai 370 hta k
@@mehrabrafi9496 You must forgotten about 1971 then.
Good coverage of Factual NEWS, GOOD 👍 clear views. Jai Hind
Palki is as Anti national as chandrachud. God bless RSS.
It's an historical and most important decision given by Supreme Court. It will have long lasting positive impacts and BHARAT will observe all round rapid growth.
एक भारत, श्रेष्ठ भारत
Great reporting on an issue of historic significance. Let the crown of India flourish ✨️
Actually Kashmir's article 370 is not a problem atall for Pak. It is emperor XI who is instigating Pak to pressure India to return Indian side Kashmir to Pak so that he can annex it permannently with China. The problem here is that every Pak PM had received a massive amount of bribe from PRC. This bribe is actually a price for entire Kashmir.. Unfortunately, all Pak PMs have failed miserably to honour their promise. Oh ! What a bad luck.
There is lithium in Kashmir and China wants that.
If you make friends with an ass (Pak), be prepared to get your butt kicked (China).
@@MG23418there are going to occupie whole pak by pushing pak into debt trap
It's foolish to think jk has changed. They enjoy infrastructure benefits from Indian tax payers money but their mind n soul always stays with Pakistan. Snakes are still snakes no matter how much u feed n care for them.
Islamic mindset will be changed with time...
@@Nallavanaaya-unni let me ask u. U get aroused n ur education n culture tells u to behave civilized. But then, u go to a society which says, f..k education n behavior, just f..k whoever u see, if u get aroused. Doesn't matter if it's mom, daughter, sis, sis-in-law, donkey, camel. The desires of ur d..k is more important than anything else. End of the day, every human is a sex predator.
@@Nallavanaaya-unniNo..Gaza is the most current and relevant example. They were silent for many years, while preparing for this disasterous attack, while Isreal thought they have settled for peace. The Muslim mindset is full of evil, not worthy of trust.
Right
So expel thr muslims out-of Kashmir they walk out or leave in box
The impact of the abrogation of Article 370 on the law and order situation in Jammu and Kashmir is a complex and evolving matter. Proponents argue that the move aims to bring about stability and development, potentially contributing to an improved law and order scenario. Those in favor of the abrogation of Article 370 argue that it promotes integration & equality, fostering development and creating investment opportunities in J&K, while opponents express concerns about potential loss of autonomy!😤 Nonetheless, scrapping of this Article 370 was a bold move by #narendramodi, and a great first step towards integration of J & K with the rest of #Bharat!
Better Late Than Never, I suppose...☺👌👏👍🙏🥰
#ModiHaiToMumkinHai
What autonomy?? SCOI has made it crystal clear Jammu and Kashmir cannot be an independent country. Its sovereignty was lost the moment the maharaja of J &K signed the instrument of surrender. The only people who are crying about this ruling are people like Omar Abdullah, Mehbooba mufti whose families have used 370 to plunder loot and terrorize J & K for more than 70 years at India's expense.
🇮🇳👣👣👣🌷🌹⚘🙏👏
भारत् माताकी जै हो सदा सर्वदा||
दिग्विजयते मात्रे भारती देव्यै सदा सर्वदा ||
वन्दे मातरम् || जै हिन्द् ||
मान्य महोदय् स्वर्गीय श्री श्याम प्रसाद मुखर्जी साहब के इच्छा सही हो गयी सदा के लिए ||
मान्य महोदय् स्वर्गीय श्री श्याम प्रसाद मुखर्जी साहब के दिव्य मङ्गळ श्रीपाद श्रीकमल
श्रीसन्निधिन् मनसा हृत्कमले साष्टांग दण्ड प्रणामम् परिकल्पयाम्यहम् निरन्तरम् ||
वन्देऽहम् || वन्देऽहम् || वन्देऽहम् ||
And what if kashmiris don't want to "integrate". Oh, people of kashmir don't matter. It's the land that matters.
@@LoneWolff-sd2icThey don't have that choice. You are part of secular democracy. By that logic all the Muslims in India should be sent to Pakistan. So, your opinion means hardly anything.
@@LoneWolff-sd2icthose racists can leave kashmir.
It's analysis is crisp but hugely apt as it covers the salients of the SC verdict. So far the tall ldrs of valley took undue advantage for personnel growth and left the state remained backwards in all sphears.our all political parties have to be honest in the well being of State rather than scoring pts.
Removal of article 370 has led to peace and tranquility. Along with economic prosperity as many business men can buy land for investment in making malls, halls, restaurants that will lead to thousands of employment to the people of j&k.
Their sufi - pandit culture will get promotion.
❤❤🎉😊
Thank you CJI. You didn't give us a surprise or shock.
A Supreme decision ❤by The Supreme Court
As long as Pakistan has no amunition and hand in Indian Kashmir she will be fine and get prosperous, in 1947 India gave Pakistan a helping hand with article 370.
Superb analysis Palki mam. Fantastic and you have rocked🌈
The Kingdom of Kashmir or the Kashyap kingdom was the home of Sage Kashyap. Very significant Vedic religious importance. Now the Modi govt has to make concessions and reparations to ALL Kashmiri Pandits. Return ALL Properties & Lands to the Kashmiri pandits in J&K. Any Fulla or muslaman will no longer have rights unless they revert to their ancestors religion and way of life - Sanataan Dharma.
Please have a visit of Afghanistan!
@@newworld786 been there b4, Helmand, Gandahar, kabul. Felt very eerie, like lots of ginns (ghosts). Not a positive place. 👻
Wow
Aren't all the Muslims in Bhaarat , Bangladesh , Pakistan, and Afganistan descendants of West Asians ???
Yes!!
Palki: Wonderful PRESENTATION as always!! Most of us hv seen some beautiful, intelligent news anchors over the yrs, but I reckon for many u really are at the top. Beauty+brains!! Sometimes, it gets difficult to FOCUS on ur brilliant content and presentation coz of ur physical beauty. God blessed it is. Good days ahead for J&K and India. :)
Good to know 🇮🇳's J&K complications are lower and improving business is for betterment of citizens in the country. Jai Hind!
Jai hind!! 🇮🇳
Union of India in form and concept.. fulfilled..
Good decision by supreme court ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
You do it so well, in 5 minutes you cover everything, which others take 1 hr with mirch masala 😂😂😂😂😂😊
We dealt not only positive outcome and also we definitely see about eclological changes and impact...
This is a dual play of Indian politics.
Is time for kashmiris pay their own electricity bill .😊...
Well explained ❤❤❤❤
Good to see smile back on indian peoples from kashmir
Thank you for your update news uphold abrogation of article 370 and your channel.
All wild animals are tamed smoothly. This is big step towards development.
Victorious judgement
The investment part is still reeling behind very badly. The government should encourage domestic business families to make investment in J&K and Ladakh also.
It's a good decision of supreme court for the nation for the long time I eagerly awaiting for it so I believe in our constitution..... which is used to be done such likeof work......
It is great win for Bharat and its people 🫡❤️
Good narration by Mrs upadhyayaji.
Govt. and people of India should never do the mistake that Isreal did, to think that the radicalised minds have changed. They are just silent for now, but have not settled for peace
Yes it is perfect
Great
Jai Hind 🎉
Yes
Actor Andhakaar Raj (Prakash Raj) is missing !!! 🤣🤣
With bright truth light, darkness loses its illusive power.
Jai Bharat
Good narration.
Jammu and kashmir belongs to india and indians. We wont keep quite if anyone tries to take it.
Let us stay together. Remove the mindset for a separate state forever
Wowwwww
Indian opposition and pakistani sound same about Art 370
Very nice 👌
The best thing happened - The abrogation of Article 370.
Every where wow wow 😊
Good knodgeble news
One country one rule,no separate state ruling.supreme court decision so good 🙏🙏
India, the union will never function as one. Your hindu rastra fascism will end badly.
@@ASTeer1699 we will see about that
@manaskrishnasingh We will indeed. US has invited itself to ask about it but your godi media ranked 162nd out of 180 in the world is not informing you.
@@ASTeer1699 Who is US to talk about our internal issue, and why we listen to US, there is no need of knowing this non sense news... why you licking the boot of US for it.. Get a life.. and Keep dreaming about Khalistan, it won't happen.. same as kashmiris...
Congratulations
Really hell changed into heaven, with the best efforts taken up by Modiji government.....hats off to central government
Shri.Modiji is Messiah of India.
J&K is lucky to have a world class leader
Its very nice Action of Modi ji ❤Mam ... How modi ji seculer Sri lankan and Malaysian Hindus Mam. If its Posible ,It will be very nice for them also...
Best decision taken by govt.
Hope to visit Kashmir one day,As I've heard so much about it
We love actual native Kashmiri not Islamic extremist specially moved from Pakistan to india or those who converted … otherwise Kashmiris r very nice people n they equal rights as we all Indians have 👍
The days of a select few political families and domestic, foreign interest groups abusing the special status for personal gain are now gone, as the Supreme Court ruled that Article 370's abrogation is constitutional.
Now 1.4 Billion strong Bharatiyas says.... We want Kashmir.
They always were and always will be an integral part of Bharat, just like any other State or Union territories of India.
Of the People, For the People, By the People... and we have spoken.
Let's show the world what a determined Bharat can set example of. Jai Hind.
India is ours , Jammu and Kashmir is ours. Its is our responsibility to secure what's ourselves.
We know that Kashmir has seen remarkable change since 2019 in almost every sector.G20 meeting has also played a significant role in boosting tourism and economy.But people are still being killed.Especially kashmiri pandit have been attacked.We must be focusing on people's security.
Tourism industry went downfall every where in india after BJP/rss came to power @ centre.
If Kashmiris do not want to be part of India why force them, they are not Hindu nor Indians.
Beautiful decision...now UCC
Good
Can the losers accept the verdict with self respect and move on.....
Great salute to our Prime minister Mr.Narendramodi and their good governance. During Congress ruling they can't visit freely to Jammu and Kashmir. But now Mr.Ragul Gandhi can freely move in bike in this area for voting. This the great victory for the ruling BJP government. Thanks to the people of Jammu and Kashmir to change their life style according to our National system which may be the great impact to Pakistan as well as the Congress leaders.
It proves the competence of Kapil Sibbal
All benefits still go to kashmir, no benefit to Jammu people.... Hope that like leh, Jammu also get separate from kashmir so that we also able to get the benefits of govt development policy's... Without it I have no hope
Not true. AIIMS built in Jammu
@@gauravipal9518 The level of development already been done and still happening in Kashmir at which rate is very far and beyond the development of Jammu.... If Jammu got AIIMs then don't forget Kashmir also got AIIMs.
@@arushigupta3547well kashmir valley is the majority of the population and sensitive so u have to show extra efforts there.
India 🇮🇳 great nation
GREAT salute to Modi ji sarkar BHARAT mata ki jai
Yes mam congress store closed permanently in j&k abdulla and mufti can now sing moye moye
It is a victory for every citizen of India, including students. Please make engineering CET and NEET seats in Kashmir, available to every qualified citizen of India. I hope the special status is removed for all education institutions and government jobs too. Students from all over India should be able to compete for college education and jobs in J&K and the central government should ensure their safety. Just like how Kashmiri students are allowed to take seats anywhere in India, it should be the same for everyone. Remove every special status now.
Azad , Abdullas & Muftis respect SC only if the judgement goes in their Favour.
Nice
Jaihind . Bharat matha ki jai. Jaihind. Jai Modi g.
It was not even a case. When majority Parliament pass a bill it can not be challenged. Under no circumstance a bench of 5 judges rule over a majority parliament.
Of course they can be challenged and they can be very much judicially reviewed as well.
A bench of even 1 - judge of even a HC can rule over the majority parliament.
You fail to see how important it is to have the mechanism of checks & balances.
For example, I assume by your name that you are a Christian, suppose tomorrow any govt passes with full parliamentary majority that Christians will have to pay income tax at 5% higher rate than the rest of the citizens, you will just accept it whole-heartedly and not challenge in court citing discrimination because it has been passed by parliamentary majority?
@@library_BnN There is difference in the work of these institution - interpretation and ratification. SC doesn't ratify laws and one law is ratified by Parliament, it only can interpret, nothing more.
Some college girls did stone pelting in Kashmir for money n now they are getting free privileges the govt. and all looks fine. Give them money again n they will throw stones.
0:04: 🏛 The India Supreme Court ruled that the abrogation of Article 370 in Kashmir was constitutional.
2:32: 📈 The video discusses the positive economic developments in Jammu and Kashmir since 2019.
3:57: 🗳 The video discusses the current situation in Jammu and Kashmir, including the decrease in stone pelting incidents, the issue of targeted killings, and the directive from the Supreme Court to hold elections and restore statehood.
Recapped using Tammy AI
jai hind
Modi government 👍🏼👍🏼💪🏻✌🏼🇮🇳
As long as peacefuls are there, safety is a myth, let alone Kashmir but anywhere in the world
Everything is worst in Kashmir after of article 370 people are suffering a lot
😂😂😂
Dear ma'am, the Supreme Court has affirmed the legality of the procedure for abrogating Article 370. However, it's essential to note that the judgment doesn't explicitly address the reduction of the state into a union territory. According to Article 3 of the Constitution, Parliament can alter state boundaries, create new states or union territories, but a part of the pre-existing state should endure. The Supreme Court clarified that it refrained from making a judgment on the restoration of statehood to Jammu and Kashmir. Please consider this clarification in your statement.
No, let another 5 years pass by so that we can know the mentality of those people
Law enforcement agencies have to be on high alert for years in Kashmir and beware of the mechanisations of vested interests to foster trouble in the name of religion etc... with money and propaganda power sided by terrorism.
In kashmir development works is fast after 2019 like fly over and roads etc