Behind the Scenes of Star Wars: The Original Trilogy ILM Special Effects Makers.

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 01. 2016
  • To CZcams and All of its Viewers,
    THIS VIDEO HAD NO INTENTION OF MAKING ANY PROFITS. All of the material belongs to their respective owners.
    This was taken from the Star Wars: The Complete Saga as a special feature for the Original Trilogy of Star Wars.
    You can purchase the Complete Saga on Amazon here in the link below:
    goo.gl/B7j7Ho
  • Krátké a kreslené filmy

Komentáře • 2,4K

  • @zeikjt
    @zeikjt Před 6 lety +1784

    0:00 Luke's Landspeeder
    1:24 Millennium Falcon
    3:27 Death Star
    4:59 Holographic Chess
    7:08 X-Wing
    9:22 Y-Wing
    11:37 TIE Fighter
    13:03 Vader's Tie Fighter
    14:18 Death Star Laser Tower
    15:58 AT-AT
    18:16 Snowspeeder
    20:01 Tauntaun
    22:20 Rebel Transport
    23:48 Yoda
    26:14 Star Destroyer
    28:35 Darth Vader's Star Destroyer (Executor)
    31:35 Talisman Cartoon (feat. Boba Fett)
    40:40 Medical Frigate
    42:49 Cloud Car
    44:43 Cloud City
    45:51 Rancor
    48:29 Salacious
    49:56 Leia's Slave Costume
    52:07 Jabba the Hutt
    54:10 AT-ST (Chicken walker)
    56:48 Tydirium

  • @thezestypatriot8513
    @thezestypatriot8513 Před 3 lety +572

    You know you made a masterpiece when you’re still talking about it almost 50 years later.

    • @diganmelaraxd6981
      @diganmelaraxd6981 Před 3 lety +18

      Is not 50 years later, is actually 43 later, but yeah i got your point.

    • @thezestypatriot8513
      @thezestypatriot8513 Před 3 lety +24

      @@diganmelaraxd6981 ...."almost"

    • @rustynjarvis
      @rustynjarvis Před 2 lety

      That's definitely not true

    • @rustynjarvis
      @rustynjarvis Před 2 lety +2

      Oops sorry I ment that is totally true

    • @jonnyj.
      @jonnyj. Před 2 lety +9

      @@diganmelaraxd6981 Why are people like you so fucking pedantic? It was filmed in early 76, thats literally almost 50 years later. Its how words, and years work. Holy shit...

  • @moisturefarmer7592
    @moisturefarmer7592 Před 7 lety +1791

    Talk about a dying artform, you really see the care and love these guys had in making great practical effects

    • @DaveGilmour
      @DaveGilmour Před 7 lety +43

      Ian Riddle it's not dying at all though.

    • @georgemorley1029
      @georgemorley1029 Před 7 lety +6

      DaveGilmour Can you cite examples?

    • @moisturefarmer7592
      @moisturefarmer7592 Před 7 lety +38

      Im talking about the old school practical effects back in the when there was no CGI to clean things up

    • @bobrew461
      @bobrew461 Před 7 lety +17

      practical effects (fortunately) are not dead yet; you can still see them in the Bond films these days. and you can even get a BA in miniature effects:
      www.herts.ac.uk/courses/model-design-model-effects

    • @Schuschinus
      @Schuschinus Před 7 lety +6

      "Battle of the Küchenrolle" is a new practical effects gem.

  • @lumbagoboi1649
    @lumbagoboi1649 Před 2 lety +214

    George Lucas's decision to make everything aged looking is absolutely what brought the ship designs to life. They actually look like they've been through a serious war with worn metal plates and windows that help the viewer see the scale of the ships. Same with the guns, cobbled together WW2 weapons instead of ridiculous space guns made the guns look actually threatening.

    • @semirecumbentoneYT
      @semirecumbentoneYT Před rokem +18

      Yeah, the problem with modern CGI is also, that they overexaggurate everything (millions of ships, millions of lasers etc etc) so the power in the image of the original Star Wars laid in its SIMPLICITY and how notoriously elaborate well everything was made, in greatest detail. Of course the computer controlled robotics they used for precise accurate model ship movement were what made it what it was. So many seem to completely forget the effects team ILM work. This was what made Star Wars. Not story or actors or anything else. Its breakthrough power was in the milestone breakthrough visual effects.

    • @minicle426
      @minicle426 Před rokem +3

      He also took a lot of inspiration from Gerry Anderson shows. Which did a lot to pioneer that lived in futuristic look.

    • @mmmomiji
      @mmmomiji Před 11 měsíci

      Adding a time stamp for myself: 7:43

    • @skipads5141
      @skipads5141 Před 11 měsíci

      The WW2 guns were just cheap props.

    • @HawkGTboy
      @HawkGTboy Před 4 měsíci +4

      When my son was little I got him a little 50cc dirt bike for Christmas. It was used and had a big scuff on the side. It bothered him and I said “It’s like an X-Wing, that just means it’s seen some action!” And then he was okay with it! 😄

  • @leokimvideo
    @leokimvideo Před 2 lety +73

    A trashed Death Star becomes a treasured museum piece.

    • @senseds
      @senseds Před 9 měsíci +4

      It belongs in a museum!

    • @StarWarsMoments
      @StarWarsMoments Před 7 měsíci

      It is in a museum.

    • @GHOST91991
      @GHOST91991 Před 5 měsíci

      Managed to get a piece from the first Death Star, which if people know was made of foam, and managed to get a brass ethcing piece with a pattern on it from the unfinished side of the II Death Star, and a piece of fur from the wampa, and a piece of the sarlacc pit, and last but not least a piece from one of the AT-AT Walkers, either from the small models, or medium size models or from the large scale models.

    • @owyman
      @owyman Před 5 měsíci +1

      @@GHOST91991 HOW!!!

    • @GHOST91991
      @GHOST91991 Před 5 měsíci

      On ebay, been very fortunate to go on when these items have been listed. some from UK some from America@@owyman

  • @kszirovecz
    @kszirovecz Před 7 lety +2806

    I swear, a lot of Empire's effects still look better than most sci-fi effects today.

    • @CHATHK
      @CHATHK Před 7 lety +12

      ksir lol

    • @sonofhibbs4425
      @sonofhibbs4425 Před 6 lety +111

      Yes. I’m just rewatching this now thinking all these scenes still look real to me even after knowing what is what. Of course I was a child when a I first saw these movies, but still, the effects are done with such precision there isn’t anything that really distracts from following the story. You don’t have a separate moment while watching where your brain says, “oh that’s cgi”. Somehow with the stop motion you can tell, but it doesn’t distract.

    • @jussari7960
      @jussari7960 Před 6 lety +67

      ksir You don't realize that it's CG when it's good. So a lot of the Empire's effects are better than the bad CGI

    • @dernvader6876
      @dernvader6876 Před 5 lety +70

      Amen Brother! Also Return of the Jedi's effects are amazing... I think that was a peak, they never got better than ROTJ, and other movies around that time, like Aliens... the effects are perfect, CGI only look fake and shitty in comparison... CGI can enhance effects I think, but should never BE the effect.

    • @spezkay81
      @spezkay81 Před 4 lety +14

      ksir have u seen empire strikes back? Lmao. Don’t be silly bro. We all love empire deeply, but we have also all seen avatar.

  • @stevenstefano8520
    @stevenstefano8520 Před 4 lety +533

    i wish star wars was still made like this

    • @fearglitchdragonvodsandoth2973
      @fearglitchdragonvodsandoth2973 Před 3 lety +21

      @R. M I would definitely make movie with no CGI, only practical stuff and stop motion, if i were given the chance

    • @SSaNNEE100
      @SSaNNEE100 Před 3 lety +17

      @@fearglitchdragonvodsandoth2973 same I would be in your project. It could be utilized so well to these day but movie makers dont have balls anymore and they go through the easy route. That's why we also have lots of shitty cgis these days as there are pretty mediocore editors working on movies who did shitty edits in their schools after another. Still gotta give it for LOTR movies making cgi look almost photorealistic. it holds so well to this day I think still the big troll in the dungeons is a real :D but that scene itself took over 3 months to render if I remember correctly. These days movies are made in seconds and as fast as possible. Fucking money and capitalism destroyed this great industry too.

    • @patrii9100
      @patrii9100 Před 3 lety +27

      The Mandalorian uses practical props

    • @smallsthetimelord4066
      @smallsthetimelord4066 Před 3 lety +10

      @@patrii9100 Lol I was just going to point that out. I absolutely love the Mandolorian due to that.

    • @BungieStudios
      @BungieStudios Před 3 lety +3

      It comes down to lighting and the renderer.

  • @andrewlybbert9527
    @andrewlybbert9527 Před 3 lety +127

    I still remember how, as a kid, my stomach dropped and my hope evaporated when the rebel foot soldiers on Hoth looked through the macro binoculars and saw the AT-ATs coming towards them! Such an incredible form of film making that drew you into the story/world, didn’t push you out the way CGI often does.

    • @semirecumbentoneYT
      @semirecumbentoneYT Před rokem +3

      Yeah the problem with CGI is 1.Physical realism 2.Movement total failure 3.Texture failure 4.Unrealistic "video game" feeling in believability (and yes I saw the original Star Wars in movie theatres)

  • @Lordestroyer
    @Lordestroyer Před rokem +35

    As a young model builder, this movie was an inspiration to go “out of the box.” Today I manage a company that builds custom cars. Over 50 magazine features, an NPR feature and a 3 year waiting list to get in, we owe a lot to these guys!

  • @tamaratirre6487
    @tamaratirre6487 Před 4 lety +280

    I used to work in San Rafael as a cop in the early days of ILM and remember taking a late night tour of one of the buildings. After clearing the alarm call, the employee showed us around the model shop. They were in the middle of making ghostbusters 2 and I got to see the miniature Queen Mary. These model makers displayed such a love for their art. I wished I could have traded jobs for a week just to experience it.

    • @Quick-Silver206
      @Quick-Silver206 Před 4 lety +8

      Lucky!!!

    • @fearglitchdragonvodsandoth2973
      @fearglitchdragonvodsandoth2973 Před 3 lety +10

      too bad Disney had to buy it, and CGI came into existence

    • @PrimoPete
      @PrimoPete Před 3 lety +5

      That's a really nice anecdote.
      Thanks for sharing.

    • @MichaelWaisJr
      @MichaelWaisJr Před 2 lety +1

      That’s rad! My aunt used to work at the research library at Skywalker Ranch near the San Francisco Bay Area! She was really smart and put in her retirement IMMEDIATELY upon Disney buying Lucas out. It’s my idea of a fun job since I’m a huge bibliophile and book collector/reader and my heroes have been the Beat Generation writers since I was 15. (I was born in ‘81, ages after Kerouac and the Beat Generation took off! Lol!) My aunt’s job would’ve been my dream job! But then for some it would’ve probably been a lot more fun to have been a cop because you’re not in an office all day lol. I guess it all depends on one’s temperament. Anyway, that’s a really awesome story! :)

    • @MichaelWaisJr
      @MichaelWaisJr Před 2 lety

      Also, my aunt moved with my uncle into my grandma’s house that was in trust and all paid off right after her retirement. She TOTALLY hit the jackpot because of that timing with Disney! :D

  • @jatodd3746
    @jatodd3746 Před 4 lety +242

    That Boba Fett cartoon is like watching "Heavy Metal" Star Wars.

  • @lettuceman306
    @lettuceman306 Před rokem +43

    That talk about them using lights to give ships a sense of scale, using Los Angeles versus a small town as an example, is seriously some of the most clever design work I've ever heard. Absolutely brilliant.

  • @astra004
    @astra004 Před 2 lety +61

    You know it’s a great work of art, when the making-of is as inspiring as the original content.

  • @RedwihteGame
    @RedwihteGame Před 4 lety +94

    25:53 hahaha, Yoda, a self portrait!!! Best thing ever, never will I look at Yoda the same!

  • @itsfunnyisee9005
    @itsfunnyisee9005 Před 4 lety +48

    Those special effects were hands down the worlds best ever

  • @lessalazar9068
    @lessalazar9068 Před 4 lety +44

    It's truly amazing how all the matte paintings and stop motion effects still hold up extremely well today.

    • @brandonkelbe
      @brandonkelbe Před 2 lety +1

      Imagine if they still relied on all that instead of CGI. They are so lazy now AI does all the work

    • @susobamna
      @susobamna Před rokem +5

      @@brandonkelbe that's not how cgi works lmao

    • @hanshotlast
      @hanshotlast Před rokem +1

      @@brandonkelbe you realize there are CGi artists right?

    • @orlandofurioso7329
      @orlandofurioso7329 Před rokem +1

      That's because they were recomposited in the special editions. Project 4k aged worse in that department while Harmy kinda cheats by using Blu-ray clips

  • @DrawNCraft-Official
    @DrawNCraft-Official Před 4 lety +70

    So impressed with these pioneers. The guys behind the scenes were the unsung stars.

  • @ciadella1971
    @ciadella1971 Před 7 lety +291

    I can appreciate and enjoy these brilliant model makers work over cgi anyday.

    • @burjalmadre
      @burjalmadre Před 4 lety

      Logan Stroganoff I am!

    • @MaLoDe1975
      @MaLoDe1975 Před 4 lety +8

      @Logan Stroganoff cgi always looks like a playstation game. Sometimes I think it gets worse. Jurassic Park back then was fucking great and nowadays it just doesnt look right.

    • @icecreamisnice117
      @icecreamisnice117 Před 4 lety +12

      MaLoDe1975 Bad CG does. Good CG will always look more realistic than models. There’s a misconception that computers do all the work, when that isn’t true. There are hundreds of talented artists behind CGI.

    • @angelusthor251
      @angelusthor251 Před 4 lety

      @Logan Stroganoff he has more than 80 likes so f u and your stupid fake cgi 😂

    • @charlesmaclellan8124
      @charlesmaclellan8124 Před 4 lety +2

      I was going to say, these guys deserve as much respect as those who do VERY IMPRESSIVE CGI.
      This artform is just pretty well dead is all. Sad. But way she goes. Props to Episode 8 for not using a CGI Yoda, & Mandalorian for multiple puppets & costumes.

  • @Greentreeanduril
    @Greentreeanduril Před 4 lety +184

    I enjoyed this documentary more than I did the last film. Thanks for the upload 👍🏻

    • @JohnFourtyTwo
      @JohnFourtyTwo Před 3 lety +6

      @Green Tree - I enjoyed more than the last eight films. 😉

    • @Ford.Prefect
      @Ford.Prefect Před 3 lety +24

      I enjoy a visit to the dentist more than the last film

    • @ShogunateDaimyo
      @ShogunateDaimyo Před 2 lety +2

      LMAO @ you guys! I started to feel like some kind of a*hole when i couldn't say i liked the new films.
      I think i resolved that they wouldn't get any better and picked maybe 2 in the last 20+ years that i could go a little easier on..

    • @gabormiklay9209
      @gabormiklay9209 Před 2 lety +9

      Episode VII was so bad I didn't even watch VIII and IX.

    • @sucky-kun4369
      @sucky-kun4369 Před 2 lety +5

      @@gabormiklay9209 Truly a wise decision

  • @idontcare2851
    @idontcare2851 Před 3 lety +13

    My grandparents’ dear friends Mike and Mary worked on the special effects crew. They had all sorts of awesome set pieces. About 1/4 of a foam Death Star, an AT-AT, a x wing complete with R2 figurine seated in backseat. Allegedly this piece was actually in the film, I can’t speak on the others. They had other pieces but those were the ones that stood out most to me. They had plenty of cool stories about how things were done and how accidents led to innovation in many cases. Rest In Peace Mike and Mary!

  • @hughJ
    @hughJ Před 3 lety +30

    That shot of the Falcon reversing and pivoting out of the Deathstar is probably still my favorite fx shot across all the films. I don't think any of the modern CG shots convey the same sense of mass and inertia the way those large models and motion control rigs do.

    • @semirecumbentoneYT
      @semirecumbentoneYT Před rokem

      Yeah exactly. CGI movement is what is fucked up. Even if texture resolution realism is photorealistic, without accurate realistic physical movement, it will look like a video game.

    • @andywilliams8540
      @andywilliams8540 Před rokem

      Agree. But also the big first person pov tracking show as they first enter the trench. 2 sublime shots.

  • @lyuser
    @lyuser Před 7 lety +219

    besides John Williams' scores, i really have to admire the amount of effort put into the practical and special effects that make Star Wars..Star Wars!

  • @user-xg8yy7yl1d
    @user-xg8yy7yl1d Před 4 lety +67

    Analog effects honestly impress me more then CGI
    Yeah I admire the level that computers had to reach to create good CGI but the amount of skill needed to build physical models as well as physically edit rolls of plastic film frame by frame is truly an impressive feat

    • @ryanlehning556
      @ryanlehning556 Před 2 lety +4

      Indeed. I'd rather be impressed by people than computers.

    • @amaurythewarrior
      @amaurythewarrior Před rokem +8

      @@ryanlehning556 because you don't think CGI is made by people? modelling, texturing, animating, lighting and rendering these 3D models takes just as much talent as making physical models...

    • @daxramdac7194
      @daxramdac7194 Před rokem +4

      @@ryanlehning556 Lol, you think they just type "spaceship" at a prompt and bam, an awesome looking spaceship appears? Computer artists use digital modeling tools to model, detail, texture, render, etc. and it takes just as much effort, if not more so, than building physical models.

    • @ryanlehning556
      @ryanlehning556 Před rokem +1

      @@daxramdac7194 yeah see? thats boring.

    • @skipads5141
      @skipads5141 Před 11 měsíci +3

      CGI looks fake AF.

  • @deepakrchandra
    @deepakrchandra Před 3 lety +20

    I thank the creators with my whole heart. They opened a whole new world for 80s kids.

  • @OldMovieRob
    @OldMovieRob Před 4 lety +55

    John Williams' music and ILM practical effects - it was a golden age of cinema back then.

  • @solosulu6971
    @solosulu6971 Před 7 lety +740

    Models will never look fake. Why? Because it's the real damn thing!

    • @TryptychUK
      @TryptychUK Před 4 lety +99

      Bullshit. Plenty of models look fake.
      It all depends on how they are lit and shot.

    • @hideofreakingkojima5457
      @hideofreakingkojima5457 Před 4 lety +26

      @@TryptychUK Especially in Jurassic Park 3 when you see the Spinosaurus tear out the airplane. It's so stiff it looks like something from Jurassic Park ride.

    • @JohnMorris-ge6hq
      @JohnMorris-ge6hq Před 4 lety +6

      Incorrect. How is a 3 foot model lpok like a real thing?

    • @DrWhom
      @DrWhom Před 4 lety +7

      models can and do look fake unless done well

    • @heishephaestion4178
      @heishephaestion4178 Před 4 lety +2

      @@DrWhom nope because they are actually there.

  • @davidbutler8096
    @davidbutler8096 Před 2 lety +1

    Meeting Dennis Muren one afternoon in Mill Valley was one of the highlights of my life.
    Having George come into the market I worked at was another.
    His house is just up the street from United Market in San Anselmo.

  • @zOOmzity
    @zOOmzity Před 8 měsíci +1

    My cousin George Mather, was Production Supervisor - Miniatures, for this movie and others. Fascinating to watch how models were built. Kudos to all involved.

  • @08prema
    @08prema Před 7 lety +505

    The golden age of Lucasfilm/ILM

    • @MarCuseus
      @MarCuseus Před 4 lety +54

      *Before the dark times, before Disney*

    • @Lyf4rMusic
      @Lyf4rMusic Před 4 lety +23

      @@MarCuseus Disney, the destroyer of everything good with it's billion dollars nut sacks!

    • @AmusedWalrus
      @AmusedWalrus Před 4 lety +10

      The dark times were the prequels, at least Disney is actually using practical effects

    • @MarCuseus
      @MarCuseus Před 4 lety +18

      @@AmusedWalrus **FACEPALM** they used a crap load of practical effects for the prequels

    • @AmusedWalrus
      @AmusedWalrus Před 4 lety +6

      90% of the sets and alien creatures were CGI in the prequels, eeven the fucking ships were CGI. All you have to do is watch the making of the prequels, the sequels are at least using practical effects for most things.

  • @mannysaurus19
    @mannysaurus19 Před 6 lety +17

    I love this documentary. Look at the love and dedication that was put into making those starfighters and starships! You don't see that anymore...

  • @noahcoast
    @noahcoast Před 4 lety +15

    25:25 „so I made a model of myself, now I gotta make him look smart“ hahahah what a legend, he’s literally yoda

  • @rainerfantasie9573
    @rainerfantasie9573 Před 3 lety +3

    I remember I had a big book with pictures and stories about all these models and puppets and stuff.
    Lost it someday and I still regret it todya.

  • @3_7s777
    @3_7s777 Před 7 lety +477

    Along time ago in a time when movies were made with passion and spoilers didn't exists.....

    • @admiralsquatbar127
      @admiralsquatbar127 Před 4 lety +13

      The first act and last act of The Wrath of Khan was completely changed due to a script leak. Spock was supposed to die in the first act. This was all due to theft on set.

    • @mem1701movies
      @mem1701movies Před 4 lety +9

      actually they did. FOR SOME REASON they released the RETURN OF THE JEDI comic before the movie came out and I couldn't help myself. it was disappointing. the only difference in the comic is that they didn't show VADER'S face. they showed Luke covering his eyes as it was supposedly too gruesome.

    • @blurgle9185
      @blurgle9185 Před 4 lety +9

      People used to spoil movies without a shred of hesitation. I remember being quite alone finding spoilers to be something bad.

    • @bobjordan69
      @bobjordan69 Před 4 lety +6

      Spoilers absolutely existed, you could even read the novelisation if the first one before it came out

    • @arielfilmsinc1926
      @arielfilmsinc1926 Před 4 lety

      Despite all this there was still "security" figure packs of Jedi Figures in 1983 "blacked out" the ewoks as was MPC Models catalog showing NO Jabba The scene in the comic was intentional as Lucas wanted people to SEE the film (though we had VHS Beta that would not happen for a few months You Tube Internet?)
      And Disney Owning Star Wars back in 1983????????????????????????????????????

  • @jmatrix010
    @jmatrix010 Před 4 lety +257

    No further star wars movie will ever replace the Magic and adventure and sense of wonder that the originals have..

  • @TheCleansingx
    @TheCleansingx Před 3 lety +7

    Phil Tippett is such a legend! All the stop motion scenes are just perfect!

  • @mysteriumxarxes3990
    @mysteriumxarxes3990 Před 2 lety +8

    the particular pieces about masterpieces is that the people involved in with doesn't do that because of the money they will get, they do that because of the enjoyement they have during its production and the will to see it done and be perfect, and this is what makes a masterpiece

  • @two-moonz2953
    @two-moonz2953 Před 4 lety +148

    Ahhhh, yes, when Star Wars was Star Wars.

    • @DrWhom
      @DrWhom Před 4 lety +11

      bla bla i bet you weren't even born in 77

    • @TheSEAempire
      @TheSEAempire Před 3 lety +6

      Deipatrous he is probably a teenager who likes to pretend to be a cinephile 😂

    • @SSaNNEE100
      @SSaNNEE100 Před 3 lety +5

      @@DrWhom I wasnt born in 1977 I was born in 1996 and grew up with prequels but I can say still that OT is the best and reason Star Wars is so loved. You have to be certain kind of person to appreciate this kind of art over just crappy CGIs of prequels. Sequels have the best cgi Star Wars movies have ever had (but People are too vocal about other issues to appreciate that fact the whole chase scene on Jakku through the stardestroyer was fully CGI and awesome CGI to be honest.) Not to say every Star Wars movie from the first ones to the sequels suffer from bad writing and cringe worth lines I am still glad something started the Star Wars and thanks to -77 never forget, even though lived then I did not :3

    • @herbpeischl2397
      @herbpeischl2397 Před 3 lety

      Loo imagine if star wars was from the concept

    • @nathanfracasse6645
      @nathanfracasse6645 Před 3 lety +4

      @@SSaNNEE100 You try doing the CGI for phantom menace with a 1997 computer.

  • @petertremblay3725
    @petertremblay3725 Před 4 lety +17

    R.I.P. Star Wars 1977-2017 true fans still miss you...

    • @KL-oi2yo
      @KL-oi2yo Před 4 lety +2

      I don't Kno why people complain about the the last movie, I thought it was great.

    • @petertremblay3725
      @petertremblay3725 Před 4 lety +5

      @@KL-oi2yo You have the right to like it but millions of people hate it with a passion!

    • @rooroo8767
      @rooroo8767 Před 4 lety +3

      TFA and TLJ are not Star Wars. It’s an insane film dressed in the skin and carcass of a once great series’s. True fans realise this.

    • @KL-oi2yo
      @KL-oi2yo Před 4 lety

      @@rooroo8767 are u saying that episode 1 2 and 3 are a great series. They are bad movies in my opinion. Hard to watch and hard to follow

    • @rooroo8767
      @rooroo8767 Před 4 lety +1

      K L yeah I agree. They’re not the best. But they built on the lore, stayed true to characters, impeccable fight scenes and had a love for the cannon. Great - no, not entirely.
      At least they didn’t take a steaming pile of shit on Jedi, impose PC and modern politics into them. It was fantasy. Not this tripe we have now. I did like Kylo Ren as a character to a degree but the rest are dismal. It’s just not starwars any more dude. It’s a beautiful looking pile of shit.

  • @captainsteve5475
    @captainsteve5475 Před 3 lety +19

    True artists, that put more detail in the ships than we ever noticed, especially as kids. Amazing work.

  • @OAleathaO
    @OAleathaO Před 3 lety +29

    21:00 - The only problem with the traditional stop-motion animation was that everything was in focus all the time and there was no motion blur. Phil Tippet when he started his own studio invented a technique he called "Go Motion" which added motion blur and realistic focus. It was so good that it was originally considered for use on Jurassic Park but of course ILM and their CGI had surpassed him by that point sadly. Steven Spielberg was extremely upset at having to turn Phil down but of course had to go with the best available for his movie.

    • @semirecumbentoneYT
      @semirecumbentoneYT Před rokem +2

      I think, very critically thinking, and with extensive movie history (I saw original Star Wars in theatres) that the only movie that managed to portray CGI and present it believably and well, was the first Jurassic Park. Why? I think it was because they put tremendous work and effort, in making it look as good as only possible with the awkward limitations CGI has (especially movement) by extensive background work of how huge animals move etc. It was not just playing around with vectors, they really put effort in mimicking the best way possible. It still had a glimpse of movement failure problems (for example how stupid the dinosaurs tails are "kept up" over the ground and their running movements etc. but I think as I saw it in movies it was rather well done, quite believable. What do you think?

    • @naturestuf9148
      @naturestuf9148 Před rokem +2

      @@semirecumbentoneYT There is some process that traditional chemical film movies did to reintegrate the cgi that hid the cgi 'plastic' look and gave it a slightly grainy, fuzzier feel... This is why Episode I cgi blends better than EP2 & EP3 (which had gone totally to digital cameras ) and late 90's movies like Starship Trooper had fx that aged so well.

    • @houstonhelicoptertours1006
      @houstonhelicoptertours1006 Před rokem +1

      The AT-ST in ROTJ used go-motion armatures. The programming of those first go-motion systems was incredibly difficult and time consuming.
      Some (very brave) stop motion animators introduced their own form of blur and imperfection into the animation by carefully moving or nudging the models during exposure, but of course that goes only so far.

    • @houstonhelicoptertours1006
      @houstonhelicoptertours1006 Před rokem

      ​ @Nature Stuf
      We usually reintroduced an appropriate amount of film grain or video noise when we composited CG elements over photographic (life action) plates. That and the correct amount of motion blur helped a lot.
      The final re-print to chemical film also "softened" the CG elements a bit.

  • @Optiv1
    @Optiv1 Před 7 lety +344

    So sad that many of these amazing pieces of art got lost with the remastered versions...

    • @DaveGilmour
      @DaveGilmour Před 7 lety +34

      Optiv112 to say that all of them are lost is an exaggeration. There are plenty of untouched scenes.

    • @Cr4z3d
      @Cr4z3d Před 7 lety +19

      Look up Harmy's Despecialized Editions and for the first movie, the Silver Screen Edition.

    • @annnee6818
      @annnee6818 Před 6 lety +33

      Cr4z3d It's a shame that Lucas had to cram every frame with some dumb CGI creature in the foreground. Because some of the changes were good, like the view fromm the windows in cloud city or exchanging cardboard cutouts for real people in crowd shots... if only he'd stuck to that. But as it is you can't watch the special editions. Han shot first!

    • @sonofhibbs4425
      @sonofhibbs4425 Před 6 lety +3

      A crime!

    • @steve1978ger
      @steve1978ger Před 4 lety +22

      Well... I just watched "All Changes Made to Star Wars: A New Hope (Comparison Video)" , and my impression is that very little was removed, a good part of what was added makes perfect sense and adds to the movie (like the CGI Jabba that was supposed to be included in the first place) and most of the anger about Lucas' edits is talk by people who don't realize that most of their disappointment comes from no longer watching the film with the eyes of a twelve year old.

  • @samsoncrosswood7259
    @samsoncrosswood7259 Před 7 lety +43

    The frame the model makers gave Lucas - "Our first shot!"
    Heard around the world.
    The craft, dedication and hands on attention - that's why the originals have a "reality" the others lack, VII included. Less computers and, to paraphrase Han Solo, "discussion before a committee."

    • @TryptychUK
      @TryptychUK Před 4 lety +1

      I had often heard that the escape pod sequence was the first ILM shot.

    • @AngelCatBaby
      @AngelCatBaby Před 4 lety

      I agree....HIGH 5

  • @passiton3801
    @passiton3801 Před 4 lety +7

    The ILM group were amazing, on how they were able to faithfully produce, an present such stunning special fx! They were more than model makers, they were visionaries, conceptual artists, with a real grasp of the future an how it could develop.
    Well ahead of their time.

  • @xebatansis
    @xebatansis Před 4 lety +102

    CGI will never achieve this amount of love and skill.

    • @icecreamisnice117
      @icecreamisnice117 Před 4 lety +18

      I mean that’s just untrue on so many levels...

    • @luongmaihunggia
      @luongmaihunggia Před 4 lety

      m.czcams.com/video/bY2YRESf9eQ/video.html

    • @Cloganart
      @Cloganart Před 3 lety +9

      This is so untrue. It takes so much time and work to do CGi, if not more than this sometimes. Kitbashing existing pieces together (which is almost every Star Wars prop ever to exist) in real life is a lot simpler than modeling those pieces, texturing them, iterating and then compositing them . It's a lot more reusable to do the CGi as well.

    • @fearglitchdragonvodsandoth2973
      @fearglitchdragonvodsandoth2973 Před 3 lety +3

      this is true, CGI will always look fake

    • @mitchellrobbins133
      @mitchellrobbins133 Před 3 lety +1

      Trust the force.

  • @billygowhoop
    @billygowhoop Před 7 lety +41

    while it's obviously much more lucrative generally to be in front of the camera, I'd imagine the most fun is had behind the camera. all those little problems and challenges seem like a lot of fun to figure out

    • @surandissidus3243
      @surandissidus3243 Před 6 lety +1

      billygowhoop Its much more difficult to have a consistently profitable job in front of the camera.

    • @mem1701movies
      @mem1701movies Před 4 lety +3

      Ryan A yeah but a lot of times one movie can set you for life

    • @Antiganos
      @Antiganos Před 3 lety +2

      @@mem1701movies Only very rarely does that happen. There's millions of actors, a career path famous for being synonymous with desperate starving artists, but only a handful of people lucky enough to make it big. For every Harrison Ford, there's 10,000 actors that just make enough to keep on keeping on, but those aren't the actors we talk about. Most actors play the bartender, or the librarian from Season 1 Episode 3, or soldier #5. That's just how this industry works. Best wishes stranger!

  • @alejandrov1103
    @alejandrov1103 Před 3 lety +8

    Thank you, mr. Lucas, for giving us Star Wars!

  • @greatwhite61967
    @greatwhite61967 Před 3 lety +6

    In a galaxy far far away these movies still look amazing & it was great to see a documentary that focused on the practical effects/puppet makers & performer's & in particular the model makers & what they endured to bring these iconic movie scenes & film's together...
    In light of this still ongoing coronavirus outbreak stay safe and healthy wherever you in this world...
    " May Your Health Stay With You "
    .....

  • @doltBmB
    @doltBmB Před 7 lety +10

    I think one of the things that really sets older effects like this apart, is that when time comes to actually make it. Whether it's a miniature or an animatronic or a prop or what have you, it has to be real. There is a creative process of turning the idea into something real. These days, whatever the concept artist dreams up is gospel and can be put right into the computer.
    So that hideous landspeeder would have been made exactly as it was first drawn. But back then, the prop makers were free to interpret and make something more real.

  • @UmbrellaWatch
    @UmbrellaWatch Před 7 lety +42

    the Executor was Badass!!!!

  • @tomvander6254
    @tomvander6254 Před 4 lety +5

    These models look so real because real enthusiasm and creativity and a lot of time was put into it.
    It was the golden age for films because Star Wars only opened the door to make so many special effects possible, such as Jurassic Park. Lucas and Spielberg became the giants in Hollywood.

    • @bigmike9947
      @bigmike9947 Před 4 lety

      Why do you think there aren't any creative or enthusiastic people in VFX studios nowadays? Because there totally are people like that. But you seem to think that no effort or creativity is put into VFX anymore.

    • @tomvander6254
      @tomvander6254 Před 2 lety +1

      ​@@bigmike9947 i dont think so, but only described this decade of filmmakers and their steps into a new world! even i said so, don`t mean today are not, correct?

  • @Puppy_Puppington
    @Puppy_Puppington Před 4 lety +4

    Man... I wish I was a part of that generation to grow up with the original trilogy coming out. So much amazing cultural stuff happened from the late 60s to the 80s

  • @420clubber
    @420clubber Před 4 lety +8

    I think seeing the AT-AT shaped my creativity for my childhood. By far my favourite sci-fi vehicle of all time

  • @TheHairyBeastie
    @TheHairyBeastie Před 7 lety +70

    RIP Princess Leia, a little piece of our childhood dies with you.

  • @bubsterjohnson7438
    @bubsterjohnson7438 Před 2 lety +5

    Crazy to think almost everyone knows about Star Wars in some way or another I grew up loving Star wars as a kid and still love it to this day much respect to everyone involved in these films they have made a lot of people's childhoods great

  • @jimmyb1559
    @jimmyb1559 Před 3 lety +2

    I still remember when I went to see Star Wars for the first time like it was yesterday. With limited time and budget they did a great job with the special effects that has stood the test of time.

  • @joelonsdale
    @joelonsdale Před 4 lety +24

    Thoroughly enjoyable. What amazing skill, imagination and patience those guys had!

    • @bigeasyarts8415
      @bigeasyarts8415 Před 4 lety +2

      Joe Lonsdale skill, patience and talent! Three things the up and coming generations just don’t have very much of anymore. Honestly it is very sad that younger people just do not have as much pride and dedication to their craft. Kinda sad. 😔

  • @zakiranderson722
    @zakiranderson722 Před 4 lety +8

    It would be such an honor to work in any capacity on an iconic film like this .

  • @RafaCoutinho_
    @RafaCoutinho_ Před 4 lety +2

    The thing that makes Star Wars great is the unorthodox style of things. Crazy to think this movie came out in 1977.

  • @noots2224
    @noots2224 Před 4 lety +29

    I just realized that Yoda could have looked alot more creepy

  • @ericchamberlain9260
    @ericchamberlain9260 Před 6 lety +1007

    "Make the ship like a hamburger." -George Lucas

  • @BlaireBustillo
    @BlaireBustillo Před 6 lety +91

    Finished watching the whole video. Great to know how big the efforts they've done before when there were no digital animation. The film crew did an amazing job. Worth the watch. :D

    • @ryanbarr2178
      @ryanbarr2178 Před 6 lety +8

      A whole lot of effort still goes into cgi

    • @CrackedTubeGamer
      @CrackedTubeGamer Před 6 lety +2

      What I find interesting is how close some of the other models came to be in the film, like how ugly was that first star destroyer. The film nearly ended up looking like space balls thank god it didn't.

    • @murdechoc
      @murdechoc Před 6 lety +2

      it's funny when you realize this old technique gives much better results than the synthesis of today. Our eyes are too used to spot things made by a computer, but real objects look way more realistic.

    • @CrackedTubeGamer
      @CrackedTubeGamer Před 6 lety +5

      But did you know every film since 1977 Has included more practical effects? all the naboo star fighters when they explode are physical objects. Most things in ep 1 where physical like the naboo city. Its just how its blended and made to look futuristic that makes it so CGI. Episode 3 takes the physical props to a whole new level.

    • @DropTehBazz
      @DropTehBazz Před 6 lety +2

      Practical effects laced with CGI will look like CGI, not practical.

  • @solusquatro3448
    @solusquatro3448 Před 3 lety +7

    Stop motion is sculpting in space and time.

  • @roseanneroseannadanna9651

    Man the trench scene was the most intense bit in the original. It had us on the edge of our seats back then and when Han came the whole theater erupted!!! Never forget that day. Got to see in it before most of the world!!! )Mom dated the "Screening Room" owner in the ATL back then.

  • @matthewclark7952
    @matthewclark7952 Před 7 lety +9

    I really appreciate all the hard work and effort these guys went to. Most of the original effects still look great and they just added that extra bit of magic to my childhood. Great stuff indeed!

    • @theloneranger8725
      @theloneranger8725 Před 3 lety +1

      Very few of the effects in Star Wars would have been possible if not for the groundbreaking work done by Ray Harryhausen in the 1950s and 1960s. Ray perfected the stop action modeling process, called Dynamation, that was used all the way up until Jurassic Park was made in 1993. I find his special effects in the 1963 movie Jason and the Argonauts still amazing today.

  •  Před 4 lety +60

    This doc is far superior to the Disney films. That speaks volumes.

    • @nesterness3699
      @nesterness3699 Před 4 lety +8

      I love how disney and the media keep telling people that the new movies are so great and such hits, when everyone loudly disagrees.

    • @philipconboy3712
      @philipconboy3712 Před 4 lety +1

      Nester Ness it’s actually ridiculous you’re right 😂

    • @TherealRNOwwfpooh
      @TherealRNOwwfpooh Před 4 lety +1

      @@nesterness3699 The bad opening for Galaxy's Edge should've been a red flag to Disney's executives, telling them that they need to make their versions to the standard of the original trilogy & not the subpar-to-terrible prequels (ironically, most of Disney's output concerning _Star Wars_ has largely been prequels save _Rouge One_ & _Rise of Skywalker_ [see the _Solo_ standalone film & the Disney Plus+ series on Boba & Jenga Fett's bounty hunter race]).

  • @jameshernandez5766
    @jameshernandez5766 Před 4 lety +8

    I was watching the latest Spiderman movie and it was like a Saturday morning with all the CGI. The original Star Wars movies were the best. Modeling making and crafting at its finest.

  • @pedrocampinopt
    @pedrocampinopt Před 2 lety +1

    Empire Strikes Back is the most magical movie ever, fruit of these modern wizards, thank you very much for an enriching childhood you gave to millions of people... 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @MerchantIvoryfilms
    @MerchantIvoryfilms Před 4 lety +26

    Last Jedi just crapped all over this kind of hard work and dedication. Star Wars 1-6 and Rouge one will be the only films i ever enjoy.

    • @itsMrNoble
      @itsMrNoble Před 4 lety +3

      Merchant Ivory It's ROGUE ONE not Rouge One!!

    • @alexs.3210
      @alexs.3210 Před 4 lety +5

      Fuck disney!

    • @grega.4556
      @grega.4556 Před 4 lety +3

      ROUGE ONE. The behind scenes documentary about the make-up team for Star Wars. 😂

    • @bossinator_gaming7382
      @bossinator_gaming7382 Před 4 lety +2

      What are you talking about? The Last Jedi has many problems, but the visual effects are not one of them. They are easily the best part of the film and are actually some pretty incredible work by the artists.

    • @MerchantIvoryfilms
      @MerchantIvoryfilms Před 4 lety +3

      ​@@bossinator_gaming7382 Your just ignorant and have no idea what film making piratical effects are

  • @anthonyenos9857
    @anthonyenos9857 Před 7 lety +19

    Such a great part of my childhood .....

    • @mannysaurus19
      @mannysaurus19 Před 6 lety +2

      Anthony Enos those model ships are just awe inspiring ... such a shame everything is CGi nowadays

  • @jscottupton
    @jscottupton Před 3 lety +2

    RIP Aunt Beru and Uncle Owen. They had a hard life. But desert life makes you strong.

  • @jasonmulliken5620
    @jasonmulliken5620 Před 2 lety +6

    It’s crazy how good all this stuff holds up still. I just rewatched all the movies recently and I can only think of one maybe two times that looked a tad bit cheesy out of all the movies to date.

  • @user00327
    @user00327 Před 7 lety +88

    That cartoon isn't too bad for having been in the Holiday Special.

    • @MadChristoph
      @MadChristoph Před 5 lety +11

      I know, it introduces us to Boba Fett

    • @devinwatson4594
      @devinwatson4594 Před 3 lety +1

      thanks

    • @j.p.vangordon9876
      @j.p.vangordon9876 Před 2 lety +1

      It was when the baby Wookie was watching a video... it was the VERY FIRST TIME that anyone saw the Boba Fett character...

  • @mephistosprincipium
    @mephistosprincipium Před rokem +3

    I just finished watching IV and V and I‘m still blown away by the special effects - ultimately that’s the reason why I‘m here watching this :D
    timeless masterpiece

  • @arnoldronning5471
    @arnoldronning5471 Před rokem +2

    It still astonishes me how the "old fashioned' model effects sometimes achieve a greater veracity than slick CGI. I think special FX might actually have peaked when the old and the new technology were able to complement one another (model work and CGI combined). I am amazed that most of the Death Star scenes were actually matte paintings. My hat goes off to the artist(s).

  • @davidhewson1234
    @davidhewson1234 Před rokem +2

    I started making models 57/ 58 and there was more glue than the model. Later I economized on glue and they looked like the photo on the box. Models taught me everything ! Eye for detail, standing back and viewing as a painting. Have sold some of my later creations. Don't need top secret, in our minds. Thanks my friends. Dave

  • @MostlyPennyCat
    @MostlyPennyCat Před 3 lety +3

    I remember coming face to face with the model for Executer in 1998.
    It was the most beautiful thing I'd ever seen.
    For a sense of scale, those big engines at the back? They're those halogen spots with the reflectors.
    Still a big model though.

  • @camwardart
    @camwardart Před 4 lety +7

    amazing. Probably will see nothing with as much time, skill, love, effort, or care in cinema again.

    • @bmnftw1
      @bmnftw1 Před 4 lety +1

      New Bladerunner is alright. And there's also Dune coming from the same guy, which I have high hopes for.

    • @bigmike9947
      @bigmike9947 Před 4 lety +1

      What in the god damn fuck are you talking about? There is so much care put into VFX nowadays, so much skill and effort, just because it's made digitally doesn't mean it doesn't take skill or effort. Movies still take years to make, just like these ones, you just have your head too far up your nostalgic ass to see it.

  • @Jrocc811
    @Jrocc811 Před 8 měsíci

    The love and soul that went into the original trilogy is something Disney will never be able to duplicate or erase!

  • @M1GarandMan3005
    @M1GarandMan3005 Před 3 lety +1

    A mix between practical effects and CGI I thinks looks the best. I watched Independence Day and still looks better than most films today. They also did the same thing with Episode 1 The Phantom Menace, where they used real models and CGI mixed with each other.

  • @Teezythadon
    @Teezythadon Před 3 lety +7

    Those models are fkn priceless if they survived.

  • @TheQuarreler
    @TheQuarreler Před 3 lety +4

    Man just that thumbnail, pure art and creativity that would really bring movies to life, behind the scenes looks so much cooler that way, nowadays it’s mostly just a green screen to show!

  • @summerparadiso7130
    @summerparadiso7130 Před 4 lety +14

    And this is why Oscar winners thank a lots of people.

  • @skipads5141
    @skipads5141 Před 11 měsíci +1

    1:16 I love when he jumps out of the land speeder hovering in air it bounces like old '50s car suspension.

  • @davidsirmons
    @davidsirmons Před 7 lety +30

    I had that Vader Fighter model as a kid. Positively loved that model....

    • @jimholmes2555
      @jimholmes2555 Před 4 lety +1

      Yep, back when I had good eyes and steady hands I built many Sci Fi models. Before the star destroyer came out as a plastic kit, I built one out of balsa wood and lit it with fiber optics. That was a long time ago!

    • @muznick
      @muznick Před 4 lety

      I also had the Cylon Raider model from BSG. In retrospect, I think the standard TIE fighter looks the best.

    • @JohnFourtyTwo
      @JohnFourtyTwo Před 3 lety

      I still have the X-Wing model perched on top of my bookcase with my other models of WWII aircraft. I would've loved Vader's TIE Fighter model but it wasn't available in my area.
      A friend of mine asked me to assemble and paint the TIE Interceptor for him when Jedi came out and it was okay but smaller than Vader's TIE Fighter. I was surprised at the molded detail in that small model.

  • @michaelflores9778
    @michaelflores9778 Před 6 lety +19

    Space: 1999 was one of my favorite shows as a kid. I still have my toy ship from the show it's almost 3 ft. long.

    • @opencurtin
      @opencurtin Před 4 lety +1

      It was a great show for its time, its back on the horror channel but looks very dated.

  • @eskimojoe6564
    @eskimojoe6564 Před 3 lety +2

    This is why the older Star Wars movies were the best.Those models were spot on

  • @mattmccain8492
    @mattmccain8492 Před 2 lety +1

    These guys haven't gotten enough credit for what they created that has inspired so much in our culture and so many people by their incredible work and dedication.
    They inspired me as a 7 year to take up modeling and miniatures as a hobby that I still do today. Even 42 years later , their work is still awesome.
    Thank you gentlemen for what you gave my generation at that time.

  • @IronMikeDyson1979
    @IronMikeDyson1979 Před rokem +6

    We need the current generation to bring back this lost art form💯

  • @PSNmemoryismisery
    @PSNmemoryismisery Před 3 lety +3

    Most of this is WAY better than some of the bad CGI w see today. I love the old effects making methods I grew up with.

  • @sergiodjf
    @sergiodjf Před 3 lety +1

    Those guys were very ingenious! Building computer-based camera systems from scratch when computers were not readily available. Lots of respect for that art work! 👏💯

  • @gandalfgrey91
    @gandalfgrey91 Před 3 lety +1

    7 weeks of work on Vader’s ship for a two second shot.... worth it!

    • @Z3RO-M07
      @Z3RO-M07 Před 3 lety

      Vader only accept the high quality work.

  • @maurob8586
    @maurob8586 Před 4 lety +4

    I love the millennium falcon’s design!!!! So great

  • @seanbogaard529
    @seanbogaard529 Před 3 lety +29

    I think they are a little hard on themselves about how having the pilots in the head of the AT-AT made "no sense". Yes, it might be better to have them in the more heavily armored 'torso' section but then we have things in other military craft like ball turrets which are completely exposing crew members but adding high amounts of utility. ILM made the right call.

    • @control_the_pet_population
      @control_the_pet_population Před 3 lety +3

      Well, yes and no. I agree that it makes sense to have a crew member inside a ball turret to aim the guns... on WW2-era Earth before modern electronics and computers... But... this is a galaxy far, far away where things like faster-than-light travel is a given. You'd think they'd have all kinds of remotely controlled and aimed weapons.
      I'm not complaining, part of the charm of Star Wars is that oddball "WW2 in Space" vibe that doesn't make much sense when you truly think about it. That universe is filled with unimaginable technology. Space, speed, distance, gravity... all are easily manipulated... Do you know where your enemies are located? Well, punch in a few coordinates into the hyperspace computer and you can be on top of them in short order... But once you get there... well, you need to fly down a narrow trench to within a few meters before firing that unguided projectile into the exhaust port.

  • @dernvader6876
    @dernvader6876 Před 3 lety +1

    They had a special display at the Marin County Civic Center one time of all the Star Wars stuff, they had all the ship models from the films and costumes and everything, the costumes were especially cool to see in person and the real size of them... that was really cool.

  • @RES61527
    @RES61527 Před 9 měsíci

    Man what a cool look into the time and effort it took to create these awesome movies. What amazing imaginations the team has.

  • @-thebatman-
    @-thebatman- Před 4 lety +13

    so much better than the sequel trilogy

  • @henmich
    @henmich Před 4 lety +5

    Tippett and Johnston inspired me to get into the business of visuals and art. Thank you so much for the inspiration.

  • @Jonwood74
    @Jonwood74 Před rokem +2

    I'll take the incredible models and miniatures that these guys created over CGI any day of the week...Aside from just looking more real, there's something cool about knowing these ships and vehicles really exist, regardless of size...I used to enjoy watching the Behind the scenes ILM documentaries almost as much as the films themselves...really cool stuff.

  • @fonkyfesh
    @fonkyfesh Před 4 měsíci

    I'll always have more respect and admiration for the amount of love, care, attention and effort put into one single practical effects shot than an entire prequel film or marvel movie filled to the brim with CGI.

  • @Hammern28
    @Hammern28 Před 7 lety +34

    I find that the AT AT hull, main body, resembles a WWII German King Tiger quite a bit.

    • @alanbrownrigg3149
      @alanbrownrigg3149 Před 4 lety +3

      Also the interior of the ATST looks like the interior of a Tiger with all the padded sections on the wall and ceiling