Israelis: If Palestinians were proven genetically Jews, would it change your views?
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 07. 2014
- Please donate to the project so I can travel further and more often: www.gofundme.com/Ask-Project
czcams.com/users/playlist?list=...
www.wix.com/coreygilshuster/un...
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
Want to contribute? Go to www.gofundme.com/Ask-Project
People ask Israeli Jews questions. I go out and ask random people to answer.
The fact that nobody in this comment section talked about the guy who called "muslims "animals . Says a lot about our biased world . If a muslim says that about a jew , you'd find the entire comments insulting him and Islam ...
Islam insults humanity
You are insulting human race with your existence
@@southtechieyou study on Islam you must revert. It's a challenge to you.
They constantly do though
@@southtechieSo now jews can call people animals?
I was raised in Palestine. I pray everyday for my home and for peace and unity back home
Jamilah Hadid so u are Gigi’s sister?
This is a BDS bot. Not a real person
Did you get to visit WAKANDA?
@@yosikama2611 Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
What ? There is no such this as Palestine. Never was .
I have a question. Can you spin it a little ?. I would like to see the same people asked this question. "If it is scientifically proven through DNA that you are not from Jewish decent, would you move ?, give back the God given land, or stay where you are with all things as they are ?" This is an honest question, I think your really softballing the question the way you are asking in this.
+Kevin Kilgore I AGREE THATS A GREAT QUESTION!!!
Great question.
another stupid question, today you can join to the jewish nation! if you agree to live your life as jewish and if you converted to judaism then you can be Israeli and DNA has nothing to do it.
Israel is the only house for the jewish people, only one and a tiny one and jews lived here over 3000 years.... before even jesus was born. And the arabs have over 25 countries! they are the same people and yet the have 25 countries and they want more and more ...they want Israel, now they want Europe...
we are the jews are so greatful for the little peace of land we have and we just want to live in peace in our home, but reality is that we have 25 enemies that wish we will be dead. I proud to say we will fight for our home and we won't let them kill us.
where do you want the jews to go to Europ live with the new muslims that came or with the neo nazis?! or maybe we will go to the 25 countries of arabs, they will kill us in the first moment we step their countries.
and what country will give you passport just like that...Hey Germany my greatgrandma run away from your land to Israel please give me passport or hey ISIS my grandpa was born in Iraq can I move to Iraq please?!
cut the bullshit!!! it's like saying to the white americans go back to the european countries you came from cuz this land belong to the native americans...or dear white australians please go back to England this land isn't yours.
Israel even isn't like those countries, Israel was is and will be forever jewish!
and by the way over 85% of the jews from north africa, the middle east, russia and europe share common DNA...so if you have any doubt about the jewish nation so here is your answer ...
+queensch why are you angry. It is a good question since when someone ask Israeli why did you come here and why Israel still expanding they answer with " it is our promised land, we belong here" so what if you have no Jewish blood and in reality you are white and your real land is in Europe or Africa , do you still have this right?
Kevin Kilgore god forced them into exile
I'd love to hear Palestinian opinions on if they may have been Jews.
for muslims religion comes first before bloodline therefore they couldn't accept israel, actually I'm sure Palestinians are mosly real jews rather than Europeans and Africans. but it wouldn't make difference. most of real jews converted islam along time ago. most of jews and christians converted to islam in middle east along time ago but europe kept that
@@yosikama2611 that's not true all christians call themselves Palestinian, jews don't but they did before 48.
My tribe and many tribes were jews
@@yosikama2611 you act like this land was empty !!!
Palestinians have Jewish dna ofc we are we are diverse
Actually, They are already cousins. Because of Isaac and Ishmael. They are children of Abraham. Jews are half Arabs and Arabs are half Jews.
Agzina saglik!!!
:)
How come? Jewish is half an arab?!!!....what do you mean?
According to scientific research Palestinians and Jews share most of the same genetic component, being 50% Canaanite and 50% Mesopotamian, Anatolian, Egyptian etc. etc.
You're referring to Ishmael's descendants who lived in the Arabian peninsular - modern day Bedouins in places like Saudi Arabia. Palestinians are not genetically related to Arabs. They are descended from Jews who lived in Palestine and converted to Islam after the Muslim conquests.
I thought the genetic relations between Jews and Palestinians were already proven. Rather than fighting, they should just unite as one Israelite people.
Why not palestinian country???
It’s not exactly true and if your interested in this subject you should spend more time learning arabs (modern day Palestinians) history. I am not trying to make fun of you or anything malicious because I also assumed what you assume before educating myself on the subject. But in short; There is definitely some “Palestinians” that were Jews that at some point converted to Islam but that’s a very small portion of the Muslim arabs that live in Israel/Palestine today. Most modern “Palestinians” are Arabs and share similar genetic makeup to Arab tribes from all over the Middle East region (modern day Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Sudia Arabia and so on) It’s sad that most Arabs / modern day “Palestinians” don’t know their own family history and their education system is more focused and driven by a political agenda to establish an identity and ideology rather then focusing on the historical facts of their ancestors. One thing that must be pointed out is middle eastern Arabs historically and for the most part still very much today are tribal in lifestyle not national. The concept of nationalism is really difficult and goes against their cultural values and lifestyle. We can really see this translate today throughout middle eastern countries consisting of Arabs often are unstable and at constant civil war among different tribes within a single country, Iraq and Syria are really good examples of that. the concept of Palestine as a nation is not a thing at any point in history up to the 1960s, it’s a fairly new concept. “Palestina” is the name a Roman Empire (Hadrian) gave the land to punish the Jews for revolting against the Roman Empire (about 1500 years ago) The word plishtim (the origins of the word Palestine) means “invaders” in ancient Hebrew and refers to people from a place called Caphtor (modern day island of Crete in Greece). This all ties into DNA because modern day “Palestinians” share as much genetic DNA to Italians as they do to the original Palestinian who are from Greek. So back to your main thought.. most modern day Palestinians do not share genetics with Jews and actually they are directly from Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Syria, Saudi and not only their genetics but also their last names often are a proof of that. For example, today there is a very well known family (very large tribe) living in Nablus (today is considered in the West Bank “Palestine” and in history considered a main city in Judea and Samaria kingdom). well this family is called Al-Masri which directly translates to “The Egyptians”. Guess where their from? lol their family history migrated to modern day israel/ West Bank in 1850 when the French captured parts of Egypt, this family decided to migrate to what at the time was the Ottoman Empire (West Bank). I can keep going on and on with examples like this but my point is it’s sad that most Arabs living in modern day Israel don’t know their own history and genetically most of them don’t share Jewish genetics. This is not a political justification to treat them different or say they can’t live in Israel. I am simply laying the historical facts that answers your question/ curiosity in a broader sense.
A couple more examples of what I am saying.. another well known last name of an Arab family from “Palestine” the Karaki family (big tribe) again originally from the city of karak in Jordan! Here is one more for ya.. the Zarqawi family (big tribe in Palestine) well their originally from the city of zarqa in Jordan.. I can do this all day. When you learn history, it’s a lot harder to be fooled by none sense.
Hope you enjoyed this info. Cheers!
@@MM-bt8ke I think you'r missing the point entirely. The idea is that the Palestinians are decedents of the ancient Canaanites (like the jews) who would intermix with other ethnicities as empires opened up waves of immigration and trade. They not a pure race but they are still indigenous. The modern jews themselves aren't pure either but are still somewhat genetically distinct as a group because of the general trend only marrying within the jewish communities. The Israelis use the ancient ties to the region to justify colonizing the land while holding up the relatively modern blood lines. Saying all jewish-diaspora groups are more genetically similar to one another than any other ethnicity proves that they are decedents of the same group of jews who were expelled by the romans 2000 years ago but if you look to older genetic marker from 3,000 years ago which connects the jews to ancient Israel you'll find the Palestinian's (as well as the arabs from the broader levant region) come from the same gene pool. You can prove that and intermixing took place and nobody denies that but that doesn't prove that the Palestinian's not indigenous especially when there is a clear double standard applied to the Israeli jews who seemingly apply the one drop rule to themselves.
@@leenahussein778 I appreciate your view and I don’t necessarily disagree with you either but I didn’t miss the point, Sure we can say modern day Palestinian and Jews are related from Canaanite times, but no more or no less then Lebanese from Israelis or Jordanian and Israelis. I mean if we go far back enough we are all humans and all related to each other. But based on the question that was posed in the video, “if it was proven that modern day Palestinian were converts from Jews to Islam would thus change your opinion on the situation” this is a false narrative. I don’t mean to divide but historically this is just not the reality and I think there is a misconception that modern Palestinian are some how more related to Jews then let’s say Lebanese or Jordanians, which again is not the case at all. Like I said, in my comment most modern day Palestinian genetically or even with their last names can trace their ancestors to Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and Syria and I am not referring to 5,000 or 10,000 years ago I am referring to hundred to three hundred years ago. It’s all in their own history. Its interesting. I don’t disagree that Jews and Arabs share genetics from 5,000 to 10,000 years ago. We look alike and our languages evolved from the same roots. I love both Jews and Arabs very kind and warm people. And I think by enlarge we share a lot more then we have difference. I hope for peace for everyone (hopefully in our generation).
@@samir123456789031 let's just say southern levant state.
What the hells the difference if people have the same dna? It didn't stop Croats/Serbs/Bosniacs and many other related peoples from killing each other either...
Ruben It kinda does matter. When you realize that you are actually from the same people. Your hate might actually reduce. Because most of that hate is mostly based on "they're different".
Ruben It matters because Zionists claim that Greater Israel belongs to the Jews because of their historical kingdom there (secular) or because the land was promised to Abraham’s legitimate descendents by God. If genetic research shows that Palestinian’s ancestors were predominantly Jews living in the area before the advent of Islam, they would have the same rights to the land as modern day Jews as argued by the Zionists. And that would undermine the claim by the Israelinright-wing that Palestinians don’t have any legitimate claim to the land per their own reasoning.
ChrisGeez yup
Funny... I was also thinking of the Balkans.
@@onee Palestinians have had their own wars amongst themselves. There are many factions. They are a tribalistic society with major families known as the “Hamula.” While one hamula may be of the same genetic or cultural origin of another, it doesn’t have an effect on their relations. As for the Jews, there is a growing chasm between secular and orthodox. While there is a lot of friction among the Jewish population, it’s far from being a war. But my point is that common origin will not have the effect you expect.
Many Arab Israelis (Arabs who hold Israeli citizenship) aren’t distinguished from the Jewish population.Despite their different ancestry, it’s hard to tell the two groups apart. In Haifa especially. So there are more dynamics at play than ancestry.
Corey These are very important questions you ask! Thank You for doing this ...warts and all ✌🏼
It is known that a large percentage of the residents of the Galilee were Jews until the conquest by the Muslims. The revolt in the Galilee of Jews against the Byzantines occurred right before the conquest.
I love the way Corey Gil-Shuster answers the others - very sharp and quickly!
Abraham had two sons Isaac and Ishmael. they are both brother but different mother I am orthodox Christian and Jews and Arabs carry the same blood
You see that is why I am proud to be orthodox Christian we know the truth we don't follow hand written bible we know that all profits came from our creator the real Jews are the once in our teaching the fake once that hijAck the Jews are Zionist. The Armenian are the oldest Christian that went to war to bring people from worshiping stones to worship god the power of every one
I don't believe no one I only believe in god and our teacher Jesus. We know that the ani Christ is here and it's playing games with leaders of the world we know that the judgement day is coming. The sins that are being committed today is in our teaching. Everything god is against people are committing right now. Sex before marriage gay marriage drugs murder the youth are being dragged away from faith
The government wants to play against power for money oil greed.
Shame
you are Christian by religion and christianity is not a race.
I think you are Armenian then that makes you an Aryan just like me.
greetings from Afghanistan
Already proven that my dad is a native to that land and he was traced back to the Levant. DNA (E-M35/E-M215).
Levnat is also syria jordan and lebanon
@@Gal_Flumin and these three countries share the same history and origins
@@Gal_Flumin Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
Em-35 has its origins in East Africa.
@@thephoenix756
My family is from Nablus
Samaritan Kohanim belong to haplogroup E-M35
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-chromosomal_Aaron
Samaritans
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samaritans
"It's a difficult question" because my racist DNA won't accept that🤣🤣🤣
Utterly compelling. What a great project.
this is a great channel, that really helps to promote understanding and empathy
From a genetic and archeological perspective, Jewish people are most likely direct descendants of Canaanites. Most modern-day Palestinians have as much Canaanite DNA as the average Ashkenazi, so they basically have the same genetics, the only difference with which non-Levantine people they mixed with.
You need a wide survey to show most or average.
@@ef2718 I know, the some of the studies I'm referencing had 400+ volunteers
@3:45 how can people to this day still be so delusional and dishonest with themselves? How can he not see that a lot of the things he talks about could just as well be applied to him/them?
My God exactly! I listened in amazement. Does he realize he is actually talking about himself and Israelis in general? Talk about lack of self awareness!
@@mtaqi7240 The irony that you take one person's opinion and say it applies to all israelis. You're just as bad as him.
i actually sent Corey this question via email, except it was directed at Palestinians.
Lol they did prove Jewish, Canaanite and other Levantine DNA in Palestinians. There is literally a article proving Jews and Palestinians are genetically identical. I feel like politics prevent this to be widespread knowledge to hide the truth otherwise both sides would make concessions.
Nope Palestinians come from all over the arab peninsula and beyond but yes many will have ancient Jewish ancestory
@@PodcastCentral333 than why is it when I see Palestinians do DNA tests on 23&me it says they're Levantine not Arabian?
Genetically identical? 😂
That only exists in clones.
The rest is arbitrary pseudo science.
@@glennlgg6871 identical in ethnicity.
Both Levantine Semitic mix with Europeans (given crusader blood in Palestine)
@@noahtylerpritchett2682 you are talking about ill-defined arbitrary concepts. It's not real science.
I noticed that the high majority is for peace...👍🏼🤙🏽
If you see the same question asked to palestinians you won’t see as many peaceful answers….
@@sivanrottelman7224 really???
I'd be curious to see how the more extreme people among the settlers answer this
I’d day the guy at 7;00
Was pretty extreme itself
You'd be surprised
There is a good level of validity that can be formed from such a question. Judaism, Christianity and Islam are all Abrahamic religions which were revealed to the world in that order ...so when Judaism first existed..Christianity and Islam did not. But when Christianity came on the scene...then some of the Jews would have converted to Christians...likewise when Islam came on the scene...some of the Christians and some of the Jews would have converted to Islam..and since the Christians were Jewish at one time in history...then that also means all those who are Muslim have either a Christian (so therefore Jewish in itself) or directly Jewish ancestry. Also, it is common knowledge as a Muslim to accept that other than the prophet Muhammad, God's words were revealed to the world in the past through Moses (where Judaism was formed from) and Jesus (where Christianity came from). So all in all those Palestinians are pretty much the descendants of either Christians or Jews living in that region ...and if they are are descendants of Christians than that in itself would make them descendants of Jews... which would make sense if you look at it genetically...take away their religion and take away their languages ...you have some Israelis that can easily pass off as Palestinians and vice versa ..they all have the same genetic make up to a certain extent.. dress them up in the same style and I bet you would find it hard to distinguish ...heck most of the Israeli's in these videos look pretty much like Arabs anyway. I suppose the conclusion is that we are all humans and if stabbed we all bleed the same liquid which keeps us alive. One love.
Haider Ali Probably the most level headed comment there is for the video. Peace.
1lookkey Thank you.
Haider Ali he Palestinian Arabs, actually came from surrounding Muslim territories when the Ottomans striped the land of its trees, and invited others in their territories to come and work in the Providence of Palestine which would later become part of the British mandate, where the cost of living was cheep, and the conquered Jewish cities were mostly vacant.
many Palestinian family names reveal their place of origin.
Kiswani - Jordan
Abu Khueik - Jordan
Odeh - Jordan
al Urdon - Jordan
Musleh - Jordan
Mohsein - Jordan
Muksen - Jordan
al Turki - Turkey (not even Arab)
Sultan - Turkey (not even Arab)
Uthuman - Turkey (not even Arab)
Turk - Turkey (not even Arab)
al Kurd - Turkey (not even Arab)
Karadeniz-Azerbaijan(not even Arab)
Ahmedov-Usbekistan(not even Arab)
Karakaya-Former Muslims who converted to Tengrism,West China,Altai region(Also not Arab)
Yamtar-Khazachstan,Kipchak tribe (Turkic)
Darwish - Egypt
Mansour - Egypt
al Masri - Egypt
Masrawa - Egypt
Metzarwah - Egypt
al Tartir - Tartir village, Egypt
Bardawil - Lake Bardawil, Sinai Peninsula, Egypt
Abu-Suta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt
Abu-Seeta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt
Sha'alan - Bedouin, Egypt
al Aksar - Luxor, Egypt
Ayoob - Egypt
Raz - Egypt
al Natsheh - Egypt
al Fayyumi - Faiyum, Egypt
al Araki/al Iraqi - Iraq
al Baghadi - Baghdad, Iraq
Zubeidi - Iraq
Zuabi/Zoabi - West Iraq
al Faruki - Iraq
al Tachriti - Iraq
al Mosul/al Mawsil - Mosul, North Iraq
al Bani/al Beni - Bani tribe, East Iraq
al Saudi - Saudi Arabia
Husseini / Hussein - Saudi Arabia (Hussain was the 4th Imam)
al Tamimi - Saudi Arabia
al Khijazi - Saudi Arabia
al Kurash - Saudi Arabia
al Kurashi - Saudi Arabia
Erekat - Bedouin tribe, North West Saudi Arabia.
al Higazi - Saudi Arabia
al Hejazi - Saudi Arabia
Omayya - Saudi Arabia
Nashashibi - Syria
al Hurani - Huran, South Syria
al Halabi - Haleb, North Syria
al Allawi - West Syria (shoreline)
Hamati - Homs, Syria
Sidawi - Sidon, Lebanon
Tabulsi - Tripoly, Lebanon
al Tarabulas - Tripoly, Lebanon
al Surani - Sour, South Lebanon
al Tahir - Tair, South Lebanon
Lubnani - Lebanon
al Yamani - Yemen
al Azad/al Azd - Yemen
Hadadin - Yemen
Hadadin - Yemen
Murad - Yemen
Mattar - Mattar village, Yemen
Mugrabi - Magrab, Morocco
al Araj - Morocco
Mighrebta - Morocco
al Bosni/al Busna - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
Bushnak - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
Bohran - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
al Afgani - Afghanistan (not even Arab)
al Afghan - Afghanistan (not even Arab)
al Jazir - Algiria
Dajani - Algeria
al Ubid - Ubid, Sudan (there's a city in the same name)
al Ubyyidi/al Obeidi - Sudan
al Hamis/ al Khamis - Bahrain
Barghouti - Kuwait
al Kuwaiti - Kuwait
al Azere - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Azabi - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Kirkas - Circassia region (not even Arab)
Tabilisi - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Hindi - Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh area (not even Arab)
Yasser Arafat called himself "a Palestinian refugee" when he was in fact born in Cairo, Egypt, in 1929, and he spoke the Egyptian dialect of Arabic. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956 .
Arafats mentor, Haj Ameen al Husseini, (who lead many Massacres against Jews, and would later become a commander in Hitlers SS) began the Quasi-Palestinian identity, in order to help unify the Arabs under 1 caliphate. He was born in Jerusalem, but his family was from Saudi Arabia.
Walid Shoebat, is a PLO defector, and he said, and i quote: "why is it that on the night of June 4th 1967, i was Jordanian, and overnight i became a Palestinian? we had always considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. and then they took the star off the Jordanian flag, and then all at once we had ourselves a Palestinian flag."
PS: much of the Jordanian names may have also originated from Arabia.
+Haider Ali No, you must differ from Race and Religion, there is an Israelite Race and an Arab Race, when they speak about ancestry they mean the Racial ancestry not what religion the ancestors had you can't inherit your religion it can be forced upon you as a child but you are not born with it but with your race you are born with.
All races have the same status with ALLAH.
glad i could help veronica ")
Chap with powerful chin beard thing at 9:38, perfect answer. You fucking rock bro.
The challenging question would be to ask Israelis if it was proven that they aren't genetically related to ancient Hebrews but the Palestinians are!....I would be curious to hear their opinion
Personally I have no doubt in my mind that the Palestinians are the direct descendants of ancient hebrews and I also believe that only indigenous Middle eastern Jews from surrounding countries can claim to be ethnic Jews like the Palestinians
+TAHIA DZAIR A limited number of Palestinians have Samaritan (Hebrew) ancestry. However most of the Palestinians are regular Arabs whom came to Israel after Zionist Jews built up the land to find jobs.
Before 1948, today's Palestinians were known as Arabs and rejected a "Palestinian Arab" identity. Today's Israelis were known as "Palestinian Jews".
1939 flag of Palestine: drrichswier.com/wp-content/uploads/flag-of-palestine-1939.jpg
Go and sell that to illiterate people who can't see history beyond 50 years!
*Here are the statistics of the demography of Palestine* ....*SHAME ON YOU ZIONIST LIAR*
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_Palestine
@@ALGERIEECONOMIE TRue I agree, there have been hundreds of genetic test on Jews Ashkenazic, Sephardic, and Mizrahim, they all have a majority of Semitic DNA from the Levant. Ottoman Palestine was almost uninhabited in the 1800's when Mark Twain and others visited. It wasn't until Jews started moving back in large numbers, along with pilgrimages from European and American Christians in the early 1900's that hundreds of thousands of Arabs from Syria and Egypt started immigrating to Palestine, ironically even Yasser Arafats family is from Egypt. Many of the modern people who call themselves Palestinian Arabs ancestors immigrated to Israel/Palestine in the 1900's looking for jobs in the booming economies of Jerusalem, Haifa, Nazareth, Akko, Bethlehem, Gaza, Jericho etc.
@PassionOfLifee I dont care what you think, I only care about the facts. There have been dozens of DNA studies on Jews from all over the world, here are a few that corroborate that Ashkenazic Jews have in-between 50 and 90% overall (from mothers and fathers side) Semitic DNA depending on the area tested: (G Lucotte, F David, 1992), (M Hammer, 2000), (D Rosengarten, 2002), (Behar, 2003), (Shen, 2004), (F Manni, 2005), (J Feder, 2007), (Faerman, 2008), (I Noguiero, 2009), (H Ostrer, 2010), (Moorjani, 2011), (Haber, 2013), (Fernandez, 2014), and (Waldman, 2016). The Muslim population of Ottoman/British Palestine doubled between the years 1922 and 1947 according to (Bachi, 1975):
Year Jewish, Christian, Muslim Total
1922 84 71 589 752
1931 175 89 760 1,033
1947 630 143 1,181 1,970
Most of this was due to immigration from Egypt and Syria. You need to start doing research from unbiased sources, or at least research the facts from both sides.
@PassionOfLifee in 1800 before the advent of Jewish, and Arab immigration to Ottoman Palestine the region which today includes Israel, Jordan, Gaza, and the West Bank had only 275,000 inhabitants according to the Ottoman census. Many travelers to the region in this time period record how desolate it was.
The fact that I speak Arabic and I understand most of the Hebrew words is kinda astonishing lmao
They are both semitic languages I think
@@HuemorDGAP Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
Cool. I knew they are both semitic languages that share many similarities, but I didn't know they where that similar.
Modern Hebrew is an invented language. It's grammar was burrowed from Arabic and about 30 percent of its vocabulary was directly taken from Arabic, some words modified a bit. Hebrew was revived and has also a mixture of other languages. So in Europe they spoke Yiddish, with its local variations, E Ben Yehuda a Lithuanian man is known as the inventor and father of modern Judaism
Eliazir Ben Yehuda modernised the Hebrew language with help of arabic, as arabic is the closest relative to Hebrew.. after all we all are related❤️❤️ share love
wow an ex- of mine is interviewed here! that is so random!
It's not a question of who you are, it's what you do that defines you-Rachel Dawes
Dear Israelites and Muslims.. we are all God's children. We are all related. like it or not. the fighting is arrogance and abuse. God loves both sides no matter how much humans hate each other. We are all human. one human family.
I`m Palestinian, And my tribe is originally Hebrew jew, such as a lot of tribes in Palestine especially Nablus.
And by the way, no one has ever been forced to convert to Islam, Even ISIS did not force anyone which 99,9999% of Muslims disagree with their way of thinking.
No one literally the northern africa was story or Islamic conquest Egypt and Iran had their ancient civilizations before Muhammad was born and decided to plagiarize jewish texts.
@@francishallare204Conquest is one thing, forced conversion is a completelt different thing. If Muslims did forced conversion, they wete very bad at it because there were so many religious minorities in muslim lands. Jews, Maronites, Coptics, Nestoreans, Druze, Ba'hai etc
If you want to know what forced conversion looks like, look at Christian history. Burning people at the stake and burning down temples are rife. That is why England is only Protestant, Spain only Catholic, and Russia only Orthodox. Meanwhile Lebanon which has been ruled by muslims for over a thousand years is 40% Christian and why Spanish Jews ran to Ottoman Empire after the the brutal spanish inquisition
There definitely have been forced conversions under the ottoman empire
Yes, there has been TONS and TONS of forced conversions throughout the history of Islam. Some Muslim rulers did this, others didn't but it did happen.
It doesn't matter what someone's genetics are in the distant past. I respect you as a Palestinian and whatever your tribe did or didn't do in the past you are not Jews anymore and I respect you and your tribes and your religion and your current identity and practices.
Shalom !!
Whats the name of your tribe ?
Long ago there were two peoples who hated each other: the Catholic French from the North Canada Colony, and the Protestant English from Lower Canada Colony; 2 different languages, two different faiths, two different cultures. Riots, and bloodshed stained the history between these two colonies, until one day they decided to cut their shit. They unified under a federal system, that made everyone Canadian, but gave the two regions (now provinces) partial self governance. Today, Canada is one of the most pleasant nations in the world. Perhaps what the Israelis and people of Palestine need to do is cut their shit, and federalize.
SlightlyVisible can't compare Canadians to Israelis.. one are aruably the nicest people and the other are a bunch of sick fucks governd by one sadistic asshole...
Crom Bann you just made my point, fuckstick...
Khalid Ibn Walid Have you been to Canada? You're not too loved there either, you know... So stop wasting your breath, no one buys into your taqiyya ass kissing bullshit anyway.
Khalid Ibn Walid
You have no point, your existence is the illustration of pointless, your life is shaytan\'s mocking of the World's creator, as close as you come to you having a point.. It is irrelavantance, stupidity the only reason you protest.
Crom Bann LOL you wrote "irrelavantance" and you talk about stupidity? xD you are beyond saving little man XD
You missed one BIG point, you did not asked the other side !!!
What? He literally does videos in Palestine all the time - including one about this question.
To the people saying Jews are just a religious group...Wrong! They are classified as an ETHNO-RELIGIOUS group like Assyrians, Armenians, Copts meaning they are an ethnicity and religious group at the same time. That is why you have ETHNIC JEWS who have origins from the Israelites like the Ashkenazim, Sephardim/Mizrahim and converted Jews which make less than 2% of the Jewish population.
Abraham was Mesopotamian, grew up in a city called Ur. So to me genetic Jew means you are decendant of The hebrews that originate from Mesopotamia = modern day Iraq.
Genetic Jews are semetic, tribal people. They're not so different from genetic Arabs (Arabs = Arabian peninsula and not people from North Africa or the Levant) That's why some jews look like Arabs in stead of Levantians.
From wiki on Ashkenazim: predominant non-Levantine genetic origin observed in Ashkenazi maternal lineages (mother's side), which is in contrast to the predominant Levantine genetic origin observed in Ashkenazi paternal lineages (father's side)
Ashkenazim are mixed in the sense that Jewish men married non-Jewish European women. That's why the father's side shows Levantian genetic origin and the mother's side shows non-Levantian. And Jewish lineage follows the mother so most Ashkenazi jews are not real jews if you believe in the orthodox principle.
(www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/37821/title/Genetic-Roots-of-the-Ashkenazi-Jews/)
According to halakha, to determine a person's Jewish status (Hebrew: yuhasin) one needs to consider the status of both parents. If both parents are Jewish, their child will also be considered Jewish, and the child takes the status of the father (e.g., as a kohen). If either parent is subject to a genealogical disability (e.g., is a mamzer) then the child is also subject to that disability. If one of the parents is not Jewish, the rule is that the child takes the status of the mother (Kiddushin 66b, Shulchan Aruch, EH 4:19).The ruling is derived from various sources including Deuteronomy 7:1-5, Leviticus 24:10, Ezra 10:2-3. Accordingly, if the mother is Jewish, so is her child, and if she is not Jewish, neither is her child considered Jewish. The child can be considered Jewish only by a process of conversion to Judaism. The child is also freed from any disabilities and special status to which the father may have been subject (e.g., being a mamzer or kohen) under Jewish law.
+Musica Sertaneja While what you wrote is true for the most part, it should be noted that Rebecca, Rachel, and Leah all came from Harran in southern Turkey according to the Bible.
Also, it's disputed by some as to whether Ur in the Bible is the one in southern Iraq or one also in southern Turkey closer to Harran.
+Musica Sertaneja Why are Levantines not arabs according to you?
Musica Sertaneja thank bro!
@@TheAfghan72 for the same reason persians arent arabs
ado ae Persians don't speak Arabic while Levantines do. So fail.
Thanks for the interesting video. It would be interesting if you interviewed Palestinians with this same question, like the last man suggested.
I agree with the last man interviewed. You need to ask them. Would they be insulted by the question I wonder? I am not a muslim but I think the man 4-5 minutes into the vid comparing Islam's attitude/behavior/beliefs to animals is a very bad analogy. Animals kill to eat. They don't blow themselves up to kill for crazy ideologies. Also, Islam at its core does not preach martyrdom. Mohammed's final sermon in the Koran preaches peace and that everyone is equal and that all must respect their neighbors. It is completely opposed to both violence and killing. So militant Muslims do not even practice their own religion or the teachings of their own prophet. They simply follow hate and extremism that is amplified falsely in the name of their prophets by extremist manipulators. Their prophets would never support such behavior in reality. One must also consider that Israel's policies have consistently fanned those fires of hatred and extremism. In order for there to be peace, there must be respect. Neither side has respect for the other - only mistrust and hate. The first step would be finding reasonable people (moderates) like are the majority interviewed in this video on both sides. Replace the diplomats and government leaders responsible for brokering peace deals with regular people like these.
Nice to know there's still intelligent people in the world.
Too bad Mohammad's later sermons or opinions supersede his earlier ones in Islamic dogmatics. Radicals would say you are wrong, that you don't follow Mohammad's true teachings. Undoubtedly Mohammad that is presented (in the hadifs, etc, this Mohammad was a fiction invented 200 years later) is a radical warlord that used the sword for his purposes more than anything else. Ofc Israel is far from innocent, quite the opposite. But lets not sugar coat Mohammad here. Radical Islam doesn't come from knowing less about the so-called 'prophet', it comes about by knowing too much about him. There is no doubt the radicals know more about the little details of Mohammad then your average peaceful Muslim.
Have you even listen or read the last sermon of Prophet Mohamed peace be upon him ? Before lying on him
She the real owner of the land are Majority Palestinians Their DNA can prove it
They should have done a DNA to each person claiming to come to the promised land and then only would you have realised who the majority would have been because of their DNA
Listen to what they are saying some of them don’t care because deep down they know they just converts and not real Jews by blood
@@Roofhack I hate it when random people with low IQs use the privilege of being able to write anything on social media, to make unsubstantiated claims about a religion they know nothing about other than what FOX news has fed them.
@@belz_7242 don't trust these DNA Tests. All they can narrow it down to with some certainty is the continent. There is more genetic diversity within Africa than between Asians and Europeans. We are all just one homo sapiens sapiens race.
Every religious movement encompases both peaceful and violent passages in their holy texts or doctrines. Even buddists are currently shown to have a violent religious side. By claiming a religion is violent your just shutting a door. An interpretation might be violent but not a religion.
hi
Ask, how would you solve the one-two state?
A lot of Israelis believe that Palestinians hate them. This is so far from the truth. Also, the connotation that Jews were forced to convert to Islam is worrying. I will believe it if it is proven but I haven't heard anything of the sort.
islamic historians actually kept track of the Islamic conquests and massed conversions, both the forced conversions and those that took place over time due to the jizya code. I think they will have your answer about Jews of whichever particular region.
Compact Jam it wasn’t NECESSARILY equivalent to zakat. It was when it was intended to be fair. ‘Caliph’ Al-Hakim changed that rather dramatically.
It is quite clealry documented that Muslim didn't force conversion and in fact it is forbidden to do so. Early Muslim conquerors were actually quite reasonable considering the time.
04:00 this man is saying lots of lies about Islam. He's totally ignorant about this religion.
legit never seen someone so stupid and ignorant
Your religion is so good you all have to run away to the west
@@zavtradnem 🤦🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️ another orientalist perspective...
It's propaganda he's been taught from a young age and likely fuelled by negative experiences he's had with Muslims. I think if he grew up in a mixed neighbourhood with Muslims and Jews living together, his opinion would have been completely different. In the same way, many Muslims are taught propaganda from a young age about Jews and Christians in many ways (maybe not as bad as Israelis - but there are still biases taught to them). The only way ignorance like this can be stopped is by people of different cultures and religions learning to live amongst each other.
@@zavtradnem says the one who runs from poland to the middle east...
"Look my opinion anyways is that we can all live here in peace" best part ❤❤❤
Palestinians are direct descendants of the Ancient Canaanites (Levantine) mixed with some Arab and European as a result of the conquests. So this whole narrative of that Palestinians are not native to the holy land is false. They are more native to the Holy land than modern Israelis.
Nobody cares that shit ain't matter, tell me please! Was there ever a country called Palestine 🤣 No no no 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
This was one of the most interesting ones, Corey! I loved the stoic guy who was annoyed you approached him "im not in conflict with anyone" - he was either super enlightened like the Buddha or had lost the will to live hahaha
If a common heritage conferred peace, then perhaps the long history of conflict in the Middle East would have been resolved years ago. For, according to a new scientific study, Jews are the genetic brothers of Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese, and they all share a common genetic lineage that stretches back thousands of years.
The question should have included "and if it were proven Israeli's were not actually jews
Who are the modern descendants of the ancient Israelites?soundcloud.com/watchjerusalem/who-are-the-modern-descendants-of-the-ancient-israelites
The Israeli's were 12 tribes the Jews are 3 tribe from kingdom Judea (South kingdom ) they are: Judea Levit ,and Benjamin tribe 9 tribes from( North kingdom) Israel concidered lost !
They were actually proven to be fake none Semitic people by Israeli Jewish scientists at the university of bar ilan in Jerusalem , 95 percent of them were proven to be of either north African Berber , khazar or spanish (Sephardic ) origins .
Look at the findings of Bar ilan DNA test , also look at the findings of doctor Eran El Hayek also an Israeli Jewish DNA scientist .
Canaan Noah Ehran Elhaik is a CHARLATAN. His papers have FAILED peer review. The STINKING TURD was too lazy to use Turkic DNA from the Magyars (the neighboring tribe to the Khazars and currently living in Hungary). Instead the IMBECILE used Georgian and Armenian DNA (both known ANATOLIAN peoples who migrated to the Southern Caucasus AFTER the Khazars were gone). In fact, as Anatolian peoples, the Georgians and Armenians are closely related to Levantine peoples including the Druze (known to have a Syrian origin). On top of that, the DIMBULB used Hashemite DNA as a proxy for the Ancient Israelites even though the Hashemites have an origin in the Arabian Peninsula, not the Levant. GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT. People the believe this UTTERLY BOGUS theory are GARBAGE and need to be taken out as GARBAGE.
Charles Rosenberg
No, Elan Elhaik’s DNA research was actually 100% accurate, his only mistake is that he tried to attach ALL of the Ashkenazi to the 7th century AD Khazar time period when it was only a small amount of Khazars that had converted to Judaism during the Muslim/Christian wars. The Ashkenazi have actually been in the Levant since 600 BCE when they conquered Babylon along with the Medes and it’s recorded in the Tanakh (Old Testament).
Jeremiah 51:27 KJV
[27] Set ye up a standard in the land, blow the trumpet among the nations, prepare the nations against her, call together against her the kingdoms of Ararat, Minni, and Ashchenaz; appoint a captain against her; cause the horses to come up as the rough caterpillers.
Babylon was located on the land of Aram and when the Ashkenazi conquered Babylon it became Neo-Babylon. They captured the indigenous Hebrews, stole the Hebrew culture, learned paleo-Hebrew then transformed it to the square-script Aramaic that is used to this day. That’s why modern day Germans can understand bits and pieces of Aramaic. The Ashkenazi then proceeded to claim to be Jews as they swept across the Levant and created the Neo-Assyrian empire which are the Syrian people who live there to this day!
There was no Khazarian kingdom in the 1st millennia BCE, meaning that the Ashkenazi that conquered Babylon were NOT Khazars but were still from the ancient Caucasus regions of Europe. They were also mixed with the Medes who were ancient Aryan Anatolians, which is why Ashkenazi are so closely genetically related to Kurds, Iranians, Palestinians, Bedouins, modern Egyptians and Syrians - you’re all varying mixed races of ancient Indo-European races and tribes that migrated into the Levant starting as early as the ancient Anatolian Hyksos who invaded Egypt in the intermediate dynastic period of ancient Egypt.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_peoples
The Iranian peoples,[1] or the Iranic peoples,[2][3] are a diverse Indo-European ethno-linguistic group that comprise the speakers of the Iranian languages.[4][5]
The term Iran derives directly from Middle Persian Ērān (𐭠𐭩𐭥𐭠𐭭) and Parthian Aryān.[18] The Middle Iranian terms ērān and aryān are oblique plural forms of gentilic ēr- (in Middle Persian)
Genesis 10:2-5 KJV
[2] The sons of Japheth; Gomer, and Magog, and Madai, and Javan, and Tubal, and Meshech, and Tiras.
[3] And the sons of Gomer; Ashkenaz, and Riphath, and Togarmah.
[4] And the sons of Javan; Elishah, and Tarshish, Kittim, and Dodanim.
[5] By these were the isles of the Gentiles divided in their lands; every one after his tongue, after their families, in their nations.
BIBLICAL MAP OF THE LANDS AND FAMILIES OF JAPHETH (RED)
goo.gl/images/JqS7nx
Zoom into the land between the Caspian and Black Seas and you’ll see “Ashkenaz” in the exact same location where the Khazarian kingdom would eventually form. This also why Israel’s flag 🇮🇱 has the same exact “star” as the Khazars used as their national symbol.
Proposals of Khazar origins have been made regarding the Bukharan Jews, the Muslim Kumyks, Kazakhs, the Cossacks of the Don region, the Turkic-speaking Krymchaks and their Crimean neighbours the Karaites to the Moldavian Csángós, the Mountain Jews, Subbotniks and others.[22][23][24] In the late 19th century, a theory emerged that the core of today's Ashkenazi Jews descended from a hypothetical Khazarian Jewish diaspora who had migrated westward from modern Russia and Ukraine into modern France and Germany. This theory still finds occasional support, but most scholars view it with scepticism.[25][26] The theory is sometimes associated with antisemitism[27] and anti-Zionism.[28]
Antisemitism?
1) Practically nobody in the Middle East is Semitic
2) Even if the Ashkenazi were Semitic they wouldn’t be the only Semites - Shem had five sons and multiple grandchildren.
The entire Middle East is about to completely fall apart and questions about the Ashkenazi have revealed major evidence that they [along with other European empires] have corrupted world history and religions on a scale that will send the entire world into complete chaos.
what a dirty lie.
their is no such resherch.
and the khazrian myth its a only a myth.
@@canaannoah4712
5:21
يقوم ادخلوا الأرض المقدسة التي كتب الله لكم ولا ترتدوا على أدباركم فتنقلبوا خسرين
10:94
فإن كنت في شك مما أنزلنا إليك فسءل الذين يقرءون الكتب من قبلك لقد جاءك الحق من ربك فلا تكونن من الممترين
I love Yaakov's answer. Short and right on point.
what does you avatar mean? i have seen that symbol more than a few times.
Look at that guy from 3:45... His sick and twisted mind tells him that Muslim are not human beings but animals (6:34).. That reflects perfectly the idiology and the policies of his country... Only if you believe somebody to be less than a human could you do the atrocities that Israel is doing... Normal people wouldn't even treat animals that way...
Rabbi Yitzhak Ginsburg, head of the Kever Yossev Yeshiva (school of Talmud) in Nablus stated:
"The blood of the Jewish people is loved by the Lord; it is therefore redder and their life is preferable."
(Nazi germany anyone??)
Odd that you picked out the one guy who responded that way and assumed that he reflected the ideology of the country and not the 10 other people asked the question.
Khalid Ibn Walid This is not how most Jew believe .This is not the rule . It is the exception . I am very pro Islam and have Muslim friends , I just don't like extremists whether they are christofascists islamofascists or Judeo fascists
Khalid Ibn Walid It is not only hate- even twisted beliefs work because they have something to twist upon. Is not the concept of martyrdom a problem? He's ignoring the reality of the stolen Palestinian nation but throughout the word extremist Islam has brought unwarranted fear that the mushrik Buddhists who do not believe in martyrdom have not given us all. You cannot look at the hate without looking at the argument, which even if it is politically influenced has to check up to reality a bit. All (Abrahamic at least) religions weigh the blood of their own above others
marvin5307ma You believe what you want but the laws of old testaments are not different from Quran. Since you want to make your own laws still claim to worship the God:)
Result is about 15000 people die every day from Alchohol and 5000 from AIDS alone. STDs are also common. These are the results of doing what you want not what God wants. Enjoy your life just watch out for DWI drivers:)
S yed Gods law is the law of a 700s Arab man and a bunch of hebrew and greek writers and they reflect those times. Even so religious people can be moral in interpretation but if their not you end up supporting murdering adulterers, supporting genocide and generally treating people differently (ideas men hitting women, marrying 9 year old girls, non-believers being the enemy). Meanwhile the secular western world is better in every way than the land of your true faith: economic opportunity, social welfare and freedom, power. There's even more religious freedom and toleration. If all your morals are not drinking alcohol and under marriage sex while the moral response is to torture them in public with a whip, then you really need to realize for all our sake that times change and religion is based on old things.
"this land is mine, my ancestors had lived here many many many mant many many many many many many years ago.... If i don't steal your house someone else will steal it" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That's how all nations were created. E
Where do you live?
@@glennlgg6871 no relation to how men were created, and where i live
@@HajiBerhala explain and prove that... Where are you?
Great question and thanks for your work. Very interesting answers.
The ancient Israelite's didn't leave Palestine any more than the Taliban left Afghanistan. They retired back into the community and converted to Islam during the 600 years the Ottomans ruled in order to reduce their taxes.
Hi, with respect.
I'm indian, native.
I think that is the wrong question to ask. In this question, everybody will answer "we can all live together in love and peace."
Ask, what kind of government would you like to live under? a jewish government, a muslim government or a non-religious government?
thank you for your time.
I suspect it is largely a secular govt in Israel, like majority of Israelis, being Jews just by heritage and culture. Right now you are commiting a crime when you act according to orthodox principles and feel sympaty with oppressed Palestinians. A Jewish teacher was sacked, after he was detained and interrogated by his people for sharing sympathy with killed palestinians. When Putin is Hitler 2.0, Netanyahu gets the 3.0 version. He already rules over a supreme court in Israel.
I really don't like the fact the presenter here says "They were forced into converting to Islam", ever wondered if that was their choice?!! My anchestors were originally Buddhist, and they were not forced. They chose to be Muslims.
Looks like take hundreds of years for the Palestinians to convert to Islam, I don't think they were forced.
Really good to see most people just want to live and let live.
Nice bars bro
Genetics don't matter. What matters is whether people embrace Love & humility or hatred & selfishness. These are basically the definition of good or evil, the result is simply a matter of the scale of opportunity.
Genetics mastered to Hitler
@@whydoi4088 He used false genetics as a tool to target his victims and propagate his evil hatred and selfishness across the population.
I maintain that selfishness is the root definition of all evil because it counts self as more important and worthy than others. This is why all humanity gathers excessive wealth and lives by theft. Theft is perpetrated by murder, enslavement, dispossession, oppression etc. It is the whole reason that people group together, to be stronger than the other guy. Tribes, nations, empires, corporation, multinationals, banking cartels etc all exist for the purpose of theft.
At their core, people are all selfish, counting their own want & need above that of others. They look to their own interests and survival 1st no matter to cost to others. This is by definition selfishness and the root cause of all evil in this world.
But the one who willingly dies for others, even for those evil and undeserving, that one is righteousness.
Aleichem Shalom
@@kenwebster5053
A majority tries to eliminate another minority.
@@ef2718 No, a selfish majority tries to eliminate a minority. A selfless majority will value the diversity that the minority brings to society & try to bolster it.
And a selfish minority will try to parasitise the majority, but a selfless minority will try to enrich society with it's cultural diversity.
Lmao when you think the world is white can black…. Srs grow up…
Palestinians are the oppressed and no oppressed people have any love to their oppressor especially when they kill them on a daily basis.
It’s also kinda funny how people think it’s ok to immigrate to another country and establish an exclusive country by kicking the native at gun point and every few villages to commit a massacre.
It’s also kinda funny how a lot of the interviews consider Palestinian as people who don’t act like humans, or are out there like psychopaths wanting to kill every Jew when in reality that is wat Israel is doing.
Israelis: We have the right to claim this land because God gave it to us thousands of years ago.
Hypothetical: OK what if the current Palestinian is actually the descendant of those Israelites but converted into Islam?
Israelis: Uhh... well this is not actually about religion!
Hypocrites.
Edit:
"As long as he believes in that way of life, he will stay the way he is. He will stay an Arab"
Bro. Arab is an ethnicity, not a religion. Whether or not he relinquish Islam or not, he will stay an Arab. This guy's got his head messed up.
"And if his religion controls him, it is a problem"
As if Israelis don't bring the argument of "God's promised land" from their Torah every time they're asked why they're stealing Palestinian's land.
Pan Arab nationalism wants to make you think that Arab is an ethnicity. Thats bs, Arab is an identity, a culture, just like a jew is not an ethnicity but an identity that you carry no matter what ethnicity you are. A lebanese(Phonecian) has nothing common with a Egyptian (coptic) except for the Arab identity. They say its a race to hide the fact that the original Arabs destroyed and plundered the whole levant in an effort to Arabize the area. If the people of levant somehow come to realize what had happened to their ancestors in the 7th century and that they actually had a different identity/culture/ethnicity from Arabs of Arabia, It would de-legitimize the the power of Authority and shift the status quo of the region
@@c12-116 Oh honey... read the definition of Arabs and Jews en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arabs, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jews
@@annisahayatunnufus8603 youre really gonna quote on wikipedia lol. Even in that Arabs by definition were referred to people who were nomads of the region ME, it has nothing to do with same ethinicty or language before the 6-7th century. But only in the 8th century forward, the word started to appear to refer a same group of people who spoke Arabic and had a certain culture why??? Because when the Rashiduns began conquering other parts of ME they were wiping out the indigenous peoples identity, language, and culture and forcing their Culture on the levant. Today the product of that is Pan Arab nationalism. A way to bind together identity-less colonized people with wiped out indigenous past. It such a shame how people fail to realize this. Look at people inside a single continent in the world, there are 100's of languages and cultures that live in close proximity but still exists distinguishably (Europe, East Asia, South Asia, Central Asia ). This only happens because they were free men thats why their culture and languages blossomed to this day. You wont find this happening in places like ME (Persia Excluded)and S.America, why?? Honey you know the answer, dont you :)
@@c12-116 I quoted Wikipedia because it is the most user-friendly source and easy to navigate. Besides, if you don't know, the passage in Wikipedia DO cite the original source. All you have to do is click the numbered citation mentioned and check whether the Wikipedia content is aligned with the original content. At least I gave an effort to give you a source. Where's yours?
@@annisahayatunnufus8603 I was actually citing from your wikipedia source lol, and the notion that I put forward that 'levant has been arabized after the Conquest of Levant 7th Century'. A simple wikipedia search will let you know cause u love wiki. Also be sure to read up on Pan Arab nationalism and its critiques, The movement is fairly new, I guess only 1850's-ish
My opinion on this is more about conflicts in general world wide..Wars begin for political reasons but continue for personal reasons when someone from the other side kills your friends or members of your family the war for you takes on a personal reason whatever the political reasons were no longer matter.
92% of Palestinians are of Jewish origin. A lot of them where forced to convert to Islam by the ottomans
By the arabs not ottomans
who cares, there from the region like jews,
It is funny how Israelis just answered the questions perfectly. I know there are people who ask this questions solely to delegitimise the Israeli Jews as if the Israeli Jews are so obsessed with their genetics. What matters is you belong to a different mentality. Pro-Palestinians previously claim they are Canaanites but when genetics and archeology showed that Jews and Lebenese share the same Levantine/Phoenician/Canaanite heritage now they wanna claim they are Jews genetically. Whether or not you belong to the same population by dna, it doesn’t change anything. It’s not like any Jew would go berserk that they are living the lies by this claim. Jews have very deep history and they always document it.
i come from a Muslim family and we just found out that our ancestor were Jewish (on the family side of my father but my mother's side is not clear )
meriem lili Being Muslim already makes you a true Jew. So no worries.
MrShamsiyah what ?
We are all mix of the past, but you are the one who chooses your own way. History is fascinating for sure.
That means that when the jews were conquered your family was one of the people forced to convert to islam.
Hashem bless you
I'm a Palestinian with Jewish root, my lastname comes from the Hebrew word "Gedi" I love Israel and i believed that Israel must be a Sovereign state(according to prophecies) and I hope our Messiah comes soon. I don't have a specific religion, i just believe un the Bible and in The God of Israel 💪🏿
How do you submit questions to ask?
I am a Levite, son of Levi for 100 generations. I know because my r1a1 a1 (R-M417) haplogroup cluster tells me so. Every Jewish male all over the world is a lot closer genetically to each other than with the host populations, regardless of tribal or geographic association.
That's all BS, I doubt you even know who your 8th grandfather is. You're just a sad LARP.
the arab palestinians have much more in common with ancient Israel compared to the jews which came from european countries, except the mizrahim and some of the sephardic jews. so i think the arab palestinians have at least the same Right of this land.
Not at least, they have an absolute right to their land.
"one part is wants to kill us" my qoestions is who killed them first in 1948
its not about them being jewish or not, they are a group of people who were and still are violent towards jewish people and have refused to share land with them, and refused to be neighbors with them. like the first guy said, if they were just peaceful from the start there would have never been as many problems.
The Palestinian Arabs, actually came from surrounding Muslim territories when the Ottomans striped the land of its trees, and invited others in their territories to come and work in the Providence of Palestine which would later become part of the British mandate, where the cost of living was cheep, and the conquered Jewish cities were mostly vacant.
many Palestinian family names reveal their place of origin.
Kiswani - Jordan
Abu Khueik - Jordan
Odeh - Jordan
al Urdon - Jordan
Musleh - Jordan
Mohsein - Jordan
Muksen - Jordan
al Turki - Turkey (not even Arab)
Sultan - Turkey (not even Arab)
Uthuman - Turkey (not even Arab)
Turk - Turkey (not even Arab)
al Kurd - Turkey (not even Arab)
Karadeniz-Azerbaijan(not even Arab)
Ahmedov-Usbekistan(not even Arab)
Karakaya-Former Muslims who converted to Tengrism,West China,Altai region(Also not Arab)
Yamtar-Khazachstan,Kipchak tribe (Turkic)
Darwish - Egypt
Mansour - Egypt
al Masri - Egypt
Masrawa - Egypt
Metzarwah - Egypt
al Tartir - Tartir village, Egypt
Bardawil - Lake Bardawil, Sinai Peninsula, Egypt
Abu-Suta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt
Abu-Seeta - Tarabin tribe, Egypt
Sha'alan - Bedouin, Egypt
al Aksar - Luxor, Egypt
Ayoob - Egypt
Raz - Egypt
al Natsheh - Egypt
al Fayyumi - Faiyum, Egypt
al Araki/al Iraqi - Iraq
al Baghadi - Baghdad, Iraq
Zubeidi - Iraq
Zuabi/Zoabi - West Iraq
al Faruki - Iraq
al Tachriti - Iraq
al Mosul/al Mawsil - Mosul, North Iraq
al Bani/al Beni - Bani tribe, East Iraq
al Saudi - Saudi Arabia
Husseini / Hussein - Saudi Arabia (Hussain was the 4th Imam)
al Tamimi - Saudi Arabia
al Khijazi - Saudi Arabia
al Kurash - Saudi Arabia
al Kurashi - Saudi Arabia
Erekat - Bedouin tribe, North West Saudi Arabia.
al Higazi - Saudi Arabia
al Hejazi - Saudi Arabia
Omayya - Saudi Arabia
Nashashibi - Syria
al Hurani - Huran, South Syria
al Halabi - Haleb, North Syria
al Allawi - West Syria (shoreline)
Hamati - Homs, Syria
Sidawi - Sidon, Lebanon
Tabulsi - Tripoly, Lebanon
al Tarabulas - Tripoly, Lebanon
al Surani - Sour, South Lebanon
al Tahir - Tair, South Lebanon
Lubnani - Lebanon
al Yamani - Yemen
al Azad/al Azd - Yemen
Hadadin - Yemen
Hadadin - Yemen
Murad - Yemen
Mattar - Mattar village, Yemen
Mugrabi - Magrab, Morocco
al Araj - Morocco
Mighrebta - Morocco
al Bosni/al Busna - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
Bushnak - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
Bohran - Bosnia and Herzegovina (not even Arab)
al Afgani - Afghanistan (not even Arab)
al Afghan - Afghanistan (not even Arab)
al Jazir - Algiria
Dajani - Algeria
al Ubid - Ubid, Sudan (there's a city in the same name)
al Ubyyidi/al Obeidi - Sudan
al Hamis/ al Khamis - Bahrain
Barghouti - Kuwait
al Kuwaiti - Kuwait
al Azere - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Azabi - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Kirkas - Circassia region (not even Arab)
Tabilisi - Circassia region (not even Arab)
al Hindi - Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh area (not even Arab)
Yasser Arafat called himself "a Palestinian refugee" when he was in fact born in Cairo, Egypt, in 1929, and he spoke the Egyptian dialect of Arabic. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956 .
Arafats mentor, Haj Ameen al Husseini, (who lead many Massacres against Jews, and would later become a commander in Hitlers SS) began the Quasi-Palestinian identity, in order to help unify the Arabs under 1 caliphate. He was born in Jerusalem, but his family was from Saudi Arabia.
Walid Shoebat, is a PLO defector, and he said, and i quote: "why is it that on the night of June 4th 1967, i was Jordanian, and overnight i became a Palestinian? we had always considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. and then they took the star off the Jordanian flag, and then all at once we had ourselves a Palestinian flag."
PS: much of the Jordanian names may have also originated from Arabia.
Ehhm no.Palestine was first mentioned by The turks ans was called filistin.
+Kurdeus Hentaibuddy
Exactly right.
+Kurdeus Hentaibuddy the romans called it filistin
abby thewasteland They called it Phelestea,the Seljuk's called it Filistin.
at last, a contributer that tells the truth about these so called Palestinians. That's right they are a people from else where just like the jews.
So will the real true israelites please stand up. when mashiach comes they will!
Well, the ultimate issue with this question is that Jews aren't a race but a religion. You have Ashkenazi Jews (Germans), Sephardi Jews (Hispanic Jews), Mizrahi Jews (Arabs), Ethiopian Jews, Russian Jews, Yemenite Jews, Indian Jews, and even Chinese Jews. It's impossible for Jews to be a single race of people when the majority of their people hail from totally different parts of the planet. Yet, if they didn't say they were a single race of people, then they wouldn't be able to get a hold of all that sweet Promised Land in the Middle East and call people "racist" for disagreeing with them. As a whole, if it weren't for their religion, none of the Jews in the world today would even have a link to the Middle East. That award would go to the Arabs, who have an *actual* link the region.
+Vivaporius EXACTLY!!!
+Vivaporius I can show you a single Israeli family of one husband with one wife and ten children where every child looks completely different. If you look at the children all together you would think that they came from ten different families but if you see them with the parents you see that they all have a tiny bit of one of their parents, but mainly their own identity. This is just one family in one generation. Now, how many generations in 3500yrs roughly, and a nation that descended from 12 brothers and their wife's, these wife's coming from different peoples, though some came from where their ancestors were from i.e. Mesopotamia, Chaldea, Aramea and Egypt . Include 2000 years of exile and the number of women that were raped by conquering soldiers, bandits or just the people that they were living amongst, also intermarriage which definitely has to be included though as a phenomenon was rare before 200 years ago. Then add topography as peoples looks adapt to the environment in which they live and to be like the people they live near. Also there are those that have converted, that itself being an illusion because in reality there is no such thing as converts, they being the original Hebrew souls returning to the fold. All in all, quite a diverse people. But actually the ultimate part of which I reveal to you today is that there are much more of us out there in the world than you or I could number. Including the descendants of those forcibly converted to Christianity and Islam taking into account that it's matrilineal descent that makes one a Jew. Plus, semantics aside, the real name is "Bnei Yisrael" (children of Israel), Jew being the main identifiable remnant of the people.
Michael Smullen Sounds like a very elaborate excuse to explain away an issue not even the Jews want to answer because it destroys the argument they've been using for centuries. I appreciate the response, but if that was the case, then the Arabs would have even more members than even the Jews, and their claim to the land becomes even more powerful than it is now, if not completely indisputable.
+Vivaporius You're missing the major point here. Hebrews/Jews were dispersed all over the world for many centuries but originally most of them come from the same tribes of ancient Israel and there's a proof that even though Jews in Europe were sometimes mixing with Europeans, they share common ancestry with the Jews who stayed in the Middle East. So, no, we're not a "race" but we a are a distinct nation/ethnic group and a person who merely converts to Judaism will not be considered a proper Jew.
Martin Ledermann And yet these "non-proper Jews" are given rights superior to the people who had been there for generations. And the evidence shows that the genetic markers in the majority of existing Jews is only meagerly connected to the region of Palestine. If I formed a group of religious individuals, does that entitle me to my own chunk of land because we managed to convince others that we're a "distinct nation/ethnic group"? Why don't the Mormons or Baha'is have their own nation then? Either way it goes, people who are barely connected to the region are given the right to land that others have lived on for centuries. How exactly do you justify that?
"live in peace and quiet " answered the 3 Gentlemen .🌷
What kind of question is that?
There is no "Jewish gene", Levantines are genetically Eastern Mediterranean. And it's the Jews who claim to be a special group, Palestinians are simply the native peoples of Palestine.
Roman Emperor Hadrian changed the provincial administrative name of Judaea to Palestine to erase the Jewish presence in the land
@@FAMEROB That's a lie and even if it were true it would be irrelevant.
Jews as a separate ethnicity and religion emerged in Babylon between the 3rd and 6th century AD.
Judeans were not Jews, they were of the same religion as the Israelites (now called by the exonym "Samaritans").
The Levantine natives of today have been the same since at least the Neolithic period.
WRONG!! Palestinians are NOT an ethnicity. The Palestinians have varied different DNA. Palestinian Muslims have different DNA than Palestinian Christians. "Palestinians" in Gaza have different DNA than the "Palestinians" in the West Bank.
It is a Political identity formed in 1964 by the KGB and PLO to destroy the Jewish state.
Palestinians have Sub-Saharan, European, Hejazi, Caucasus and other DNA.
@@charles2521The Samaritans are a group descended from the Israelites, but they are not Israelites. The Judeans are also Israelites. Israel separated into Israel and Judea after the death of King Solomon.
The Jews/Judeans are the Israelites of the Southern Kingdom of Judea. Made up mostly of the tribes of Judah, Benjamin, Simeon and the Levites assigned to those tribes. There was also the spouses and merchants that lived in the land for generations of the Northern kingdom of Israel. After the Assyrian and Babylonian captivity all the Israelites that returned or remained in the land were called as Jews.
Corey, you should be asking Israel's Muslims and Christians what do they know about their Israelite (Jewish and Samaritan) roots and if they ackowledge such roots, what impact could that have in a peaceful resolution of this conflict. It's also important that you clarify that Jews are an Israelite tribe above all, and that the Israelites (including their ancestors), just like other Levantine people have an History of admixture.
Palestinians recognize they have Canaanite, Samaritan, ancient Jewish roots as well as things like ancient Greek, Turkish. The quarrel is not with Judaism or people being Jews. Palestinians are SEMITES who do not accept injustice, oppression. It's not like how that guy portrayed that we're not human beings or don't want to live differently. We are shaped by the 80 years of violence and control. That's how it goes. We lived together with Jews and Christians mostly fine in the past. And Sephardic Jews were invited to live with Palestinians.
@@Bazza5000 ancient Canaanite dont speak Arabic. if Palestine want claim heritage of Canaanite, they should speak language of Canaanite.
@@ColoniaMurder20canaanites became Phoenicians
They are still cannanites
So jws all across the world that don’t speak Hebrew aren’t jws?
@@Bazza5000 werent Christians, and Jews basically second class citizens. I can't understand why that was better to you but you do get why it wouldn't be better for them
@@ColoniaMurder20 the majority of the Arab world are not Arabic, the old Aramaic language is only spoken one little village today and that is a village in Syria…
Good question. And this idea is quite valid. Not all. The Palestinians are a mixture of people from various countries who came at different times from different countries...a lot to work for the Jews in the first Aliyah’s. But some are descended from Jews that never left the Land. The Diaspora Museum in Tel Aviv had a picture of such a person.
SEMITES ARE NOT WHITE BUT HAVE A DARK SKIN ( GENETICALLY PROVEN)
zIONISM DOES EVERYTHING TO HIDE THE TRUTH
It Changed my thoughts 1 million percent’.. It’s a fact that Palestinians are direct decendents of the ancient Hebrews that didn’t Leave the land of Israel after the destruction of the second temple in 70ad. They survived and lived amongst the Bedouins in the wilderness later when Islam came, they were force convert to Islam, because they love the land so much they stayed absolute fact.!! Fact is one of Yasser Arafat grandfathers was a rabbi look it up..!!
Like the old gentleman... so open
8:25 "I have no answer. It is too complicated."
pathetic answer really
I love the hebrew language,cloths,food,look (phenotypes),smell (but I love all ethnciities)etc. yet I'm Muslim, many people are so hardly brainwashed that their alliance to humans is based on race, sick people brainwashed and care about the race another person is in an base their view on him on their race and then those brainwashed suckers come and tell people like me who base their view on people based on their personality,character and thinking (way of life - greek -> religios -> religion) and say that is bad.
You officialy brainwashed, I love Moses the hebrew who spoke hebrew and who's family was hebrew and who was in the hebrew culture not because of his ethnicity but because of what he did, he submited himself to God, resisted the Pharao and the hordes (brainwashed sheep) who followed Pharao and the critics from his own people and continued to obey God, he was a submitter to God (submitter in arabic literary means Muslim).
The Great Khazar will not let this dna test prove that
I can say Palestinian at least has jews DNA. Becoz they live there for centuries and we should know that Sons Of Israil were diaspora all over the world. In the conclusion, Palestinian might be Jews that convert to Muslim long times ago. "The question is can you be good with your own Palestinian cousin?"
DNA is actually only one component of identity. Jewish is according to most Ethnic studies professors a ethno-religious group like Yazidis, Druze, and Parsi's (Zoroastrians). They are all linked genetically, culturally, and by religion. Palestinian Arabs consider themselves Arabic, and their culture and religion is no longer Jewish (Muslim, and Christian), plus the majority of Arab Palestinians call themselves Arab, and Palestinian regardless of whether they have ancient Hebrew roots like the Jewish Israelis.
It is proven that Palestinians genetically, close to the ancient Israelite than Arabs. Archeology proves that too.
@@robleyusuf2566 This is true, especially with the Bedouin in Israel/Jordan and the West Bank. Unfortunately the Palestinians do not care that in many areas they have more Hebrew genes than Arab, they have been culturally and religiously assimilated into the Arabic nation.
@donaldseigel4101 Even Jews hated Palestinians, and there is history behind, about that hate. This started during the time of Jesus, when the Jews divided into following Jesus and against Jesus. Those who followed Jesus were called Nazarene Jews (remember, there was no such thing called Christianity). Some would even say, this started before Jesus, when some Jews broke away and started new sect, and thus Jesus, Marry and John the Baptist were member of that sect. This new sect attracted the Jewish peasants, but not the rich aristocracy and the middle class Jews. This new movement would lose the peasants to the Paulines(started by Soul of Tersus, who would be called Paul later), and they would call Jesus divine, and from there, the Christianity starts, the Jews would revolt against the Romans and the Romans would deport the Jew(who followed traditional Judaism) and Christians who were before the peasants who followed the new sect will collaborate with the Romans because the traditional Jews collaborated with the Romans before to persecute the new sect and Christians who came later, and that was vengeance. After the Muslim, conquest majority of Christians become Muslims, and they are the Palestinians we see today.
@@robleyusuf2566 There is a alot of truth in what you are writing, but unfortunately there is even more to it. There were many different groups during Roman rule in Judea. Even among the Christians they were divided into several sects (Ebionites, Nazarene's), and among the Jews (Essenes[many groups including Morning Bathers and Theraputae], Sadducees, Pharisees, Hellenistic Judaism, etc), there was also a very large Samaritan community.
@@donaldseigel4101 Christians came later, Jesus never founded Christianity and his followers observed the Sabbath went to temple mount. I am Muslim we believe Islam existed before prophet Mohammed was born. I am not dogmatic and I don't impose any body to accept my believe. We believe Abraham, Moses, and Jesus were Muslims. Muslim is person who submitted himself to God in Aramaic is Sulaman, Musluman. Moses he didn't say in the bible he preached for Judaism and Jesus never said he preached for Christianity. I am not criticising Jews and Christians, but I would say the three so called Abrahamic religion( I don't call them Abrahamic) conflicts have roots the sects, that started to separate from mainstream Judaism between 3rd century BC to 1st century AD.
There is no such thing as a muslim/christian/jew. Every person experiences his religion (or lack of one) in his own personal way.
Judaism is a religion, not ethnicity. There are different ethnicities in Jews. So the question is irrevelent.
no such a thing as a Genetically Jew , maybe genetically Ashkenazi Jew but you can prove an Ashkenazi Jew to be native to Palestine using Palestinian DNA
Can you ask local Arabs the same question?
They would have the same genetics wouldn’t they? I thought the Arabic people are descended from Ishmael?
Palestinians have similar genetics to Jews because some of the population was arabised and mixed with the arabs when the arabs invaded the land, not because they’re Arabs. Arabs descending from Ishmael isn’t fact lmao
The theory is that most of the people who currently consider themselves Palestinian Arabs were originally Jews, who wound up adopting the language and culture of Arab conquerors.
3:50 uh oh It's the double standard shoe man
This works both ways now you just revealed that being Jewish is not a race but a religion. If you're pro-palestine you cannot be anti-Semitic.
Corey, you are interviewing far more males than females, which is a poor practice for collecting social views.
Adam Kesher that is not a logical statement
So let me get this straight. If Palestinians call themselves Palestinian, they can't be Jews. However, someone who identifies as American or German or Polish, can be. Someone can be a Jew and practice christianity, buddhism, shamanism -- just not Islam. BTW, people who think this way have nothing to do with there being a conflict. LOL -- or crying hysterically.
You can not be considered religiously Jewish if you adopt any other religion except Judaism . Culturely you can be considered Jewish by birth but when it comes to the religion and all the benefits that the torah confers on people who follow in its ways then a gentile who undergoes a legimate conversion to Judaism and keeps the torah is more Jewish then some one born Jewish ,but does not keep the torah.I will try to post a video of a Palestinian who converted to Orthodox Judaism and is probably a better Jew then I am.
Jewish truth by Avrumeleh Melamid where is the video?
You don't have it straight at all. They are referring to Jewish and Palestinian in the nation sense not the religious sense. American Jews consider themselves part of the Jewish nation, Palestinians do not.
very interesting
Why is he interviewing the same people ?
I wouldn't be at all surprised if Palestinians actually are closer genetically to the original middle eastern Jews than Ashkenazis or even average Israeli. European Jews look like Europeans and I'm pretty sure mostly carry European genes.
By DNA yes
This has already been debunked next
Arabs are from arabia
If someone invaded my place there gonna be a big fight.
So pushing Arabs from the Maghreb back to Arabia, like the Reconquista in Spain.
Jewish is a faith-based culture a comprehensive central identity and not genetic. The makers that lead to being called Jewish marker(s) have to do with an admixture a genetic mixture which is uncommon. That admix is what is shared, basically the trees lead to the same region. The branching diverged and so did the cultures. Its not about Palestinians being Jews it about some of the Israeli Jews demonstrating an admixture that is the same as the Palestinians. A faith-based culture cannot be genetic, it can only be associated with certain genetics and in that they are always geographical in origin. What is geographical is static, however migrations inevitably generate admixes and these in degrees offer static influences into a region, less they are nomads and not insular.
Genetic ancestry won't make any difference. What makes a difference is the belief in Islam NOW. In Islam the world is divided into Dar al-Salam and Dar al-Harb, the House of Islam and the House of War. Countries like Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Iraq, and Afghanistan are part of the Dar al-Salam, where Sharia (Islamic law) is the law to different degrees, and where People of the Book (primarily Jews and Christians) can live in apartheid as second-class citizens if they pay the jizya tax. The non-Muslim countries of the world are Dar al-Harb, which means that Dar al-Salam is perpetually at war with them until they convert to Islam. Those countries that were formerly Muslim but now are not are especially targeted because Muslims have a duty to expel the occupiers. These formerly Muslim countries include not only Israel, but Greece, Spain, Portugal, India, and Sicily. In the meantime, if they can take over another country they should do so (the UK may be close). Israel is also targeted not just because it is now occupied by infidels, but because they are Jews. In Quran 5:51 it says not to make friends with Jews and Christians. In Quran 2:65 it says that Allah turned some of them into apes and pigs. According to Sahih Bukhari 1:8:427, the Jews are cursed. So whatever their distant ancestors believed is irrelevant. It is what they believe now that matters.
As an Israeli I can say that the reason this doesn't make a difference to anyone is because Israelis never had a problem with the Palestinians being who they are. Israel always agreed to accept the Palestinians and live with them in peace as neighbours whenever it was offered, so why would finding out they are Jews make a difference?
The conflict is about the Palestinians not considering Israelis to be Palestinian. It's not about Israelis not considering Palestinians to be Jews...
So the real question is what would proof that the Israelis are actually from Palestine mean for the Palestinians? (Spoiler, there's a video about that too and most Palestinians said it doesn't matter, Israelis still have no place here...)
Minorities of the region are being continuously eliminated.
Hilarious that they always put the blame on the other side, people aren't very self-aware except for some
Israel wants peace,
hamas tries to murder israeli innocent civilians by rockets, explosive balloons, knives, underground tunnels.
Inspite all of this, Israel still wants peace.
But the other side doesn't.
So.... who do you think is to blame?
@@liron-hazan after killing 2 million palastine now we are the bad guy
@@liron-hazan after killing 2 million palastine now we are the bad guy
Im a Yemeni Jew from Bolivia living in Belgium and my family are Jews from Najran - Yemen living in Palestine and some lived in Israel as Israeli citizenships
These Palestinians are chilled. Massive contrast to many of the other video's you have made.
7:57 drake
Well all you have to do is look at the genetics of the Palestinians and it pretty much confirms this
“We propose that the Y chromosomes in Palestinian Arabs and Bedouin represent, to a large extent, early lineages derived from the Neolithic inhabitants of the area and additional lineages from more-recent population movements. The early lineages are part of the common chromosome pool shared with Jews (Nebel et al. 2000).”
(The Y Chromosome Pool of Jews as Part of the Genetic Landscape of the Middle East |Nebel et al. 2000)
“According to historical records part, or perhaps the majority, of the Moslem Arabs in this country descended from local inhabitants, mainly Christians and Jews, who had converted after the Islamic conquest in the seventh century AD (Shaban 1971; Mc Graw Donner 1981). These local inhabitants, in turn, were descendants of the core population that had lived in the area for several centuries, some even since prehistorical times (Gil 1992). On the other hand, the ancestors of the great majority of present-day Jews lived outside this region for almost two millennia. Thus, our findings are in good agreement with historical evidence and suggest genetic continuity in both populations despite their long separation and the wide geographic dispersal of Jews.”
(High-resolution Y chromosome haplotypes of Israeli and Palestinian Arabs reveal geographic substructure and substantial overlap with haplotypes of Jews | Nebel et al.2000)
Well Abraham was from what is Iraq today and if Muslims did not believe in importance of life and everyone acted like a martyr the world would be hell.
Dorron from tel aviv, thumbs up for you
He should be a regular on the show.