Salat (Contact Prayer) According to Quran
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 09. 2019
- Quran Study App: apple.co/2C1YGXj
Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/
Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw
Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / talkquran
Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid
Additional Resources: www.masjidtucson.org
Ma shaa Allah! Good job, bro!
It is interesting how u guys reject the way the prophet puh understood Islam and practice it, but then seek others' understanding of Islam and be amazed by it 😄
I'm sorry butcit says to wipe your head and feet. Not wash your feet
Beautiful explanation Masha’Allah, praise God.
This channel is fantastic. Thank you for your work, mashaAllah.
Fantastic is as long as it carries the truth!
Sister, the quran can't simply be understood without the prophet's interpretation, and the Arabs understanding of its words at the time. Not to mention the importance of the context of the verses in which they were revealed.
All of which comes from the hadiths books, prophet's and his companions' traditions.
@@huntsman2877 We do not rely 100% on hadiths! Because people went astray and lost because of these narratives.
@@yeldarazanbayev2562 there is a whole science and studies (hadith science) made for the sole purpose of authenticity of hadiths.
Science of Men, is meant to study narration.
@@huntsman2877 yes by selecting the narators based on piosity. But hey there is no metric for piousness. Only Allah know what is in someone's Qolb or heart. The very basis of Science of Hadith is on the selection of piosity. And that is an impossible task, to begin with. Those who seem pious might probably not truely pious, and vice versa. And to whom someone might seem pious, would probably not seem pious to someone else. There is no metric nor calculation and nor waranty in Hadith. The Quran has a waranty that it is original and protected (Al-Hijr : 9). Kitabu Bukhari, Muslim, Tirmidhi(with respect ofc) has not. Who would guarantee Kitabu Bukhari, Muslim, Tirmidhi, etc.. in its veritability ? A Pious person ? Again there is no metric for piousity.
JazakAllah khair
Salam
Question.
Is there any record of abraham ismael moses araon Jesus and all the people you mentioned ....prayering the same way you do today ?
I have read the bible and asked jewsih rabbis if they have any record of abraham praying 5 times a day
They said he prayed once a day
Became twice with issac
3 times with jacob
And 5 with ezra.
What do you say ?
We all know that the Quran is the primary source for anything about Islam, but it is more likely to be a kind of abstract this means when it comes to details we need the sunna as a 2nd reference.
Now, let's see what we can find in the Quran:
Maintain with care the [obligatory] prayers and [in particular] the middle prayer and stand before Allah , devoutly obedient. -- al-Baqara 2:238
And establish prayer at the two ends of the day and at the approach of the night. Indeed, good deeds do away with misdeeds. That is a reminder for those who remember. -- Hud 11:114
O you who have believed, let those whom your right hands possess and those who have not [yet] reached puberty among you ask permission of you [before entering] at three times: before the dawn prayer and when you put aside your clothing [for rest] at noon and after the night prayer. [These are] three times of privacy for you. There is no blame upon you nor upon them beyond these [periods], for they continually circulate among you - some of you, among others. Thus does Allah make clear to you the verses; and Allah is Knowing and Wise. -- an-Nur 24:58
Verse 1 tells us that there is a middle prayer which means there are at least 3 prayers and doesn't mention the exact number of prayers.
Verse 2 tells us that during daylightv (the time gap between fajr and maghrib) we have 2 prayers (duhr and a'sr) and one when the night approaches (al-maghrib) (see also this Fatwa): With (only) this information it's still possible that we only have 3 prayers, but
Verse 3 which teaches us about the resting times mention clearly the fajr/sobh prayer and the I'sha prayer as the fajr itself is a not mentioned time in the 2 Verses before we find out we really have 5 prayers mentioned in the Quran!
Now we find we have 5 prayers or prayer times mentioned in the Quran.
By the way we could also include some other Verses to explain for example:
Establish prayer at the decline of the sun [from its meridian] until the darkness of the night and [also] the Qur'an of dawn. Indeed, the recitation of dawn is ever witnessed. -- 17:78
Which mentioned indirectly the prayers from duhr until i'sha' and by the mentioned recitation of dawn the fajr prayer! See also this Fatwa in Arabic.
Just as an addition:
the sentence أقِمِ الصلاة = establish prayer (singular form) was quoted 5 times in the Quran. The sentence أقيموا الصلاة= establish prayer (plural form) was quoted 12 times in the Quran.
As we know 12+5=17 which is the sum of the raka'at of our daily fard prayers!
The Verse 1 from above is written in the moshaf as follows حَفِظُوا عَلَى الصَّلَوَتِ وَالصَّلَوةِ الْوُسْطَى وَقُومُوا لِلَّهِ قَنِتِينَ.
If we count the number of Arabic letters at the right and left from the expression وَالصَّلَوةِ الْوُسْطَى = and the middle prayer.
We find it to be the exact middle of the Verse and each part at the left and right has 14 Arabic letters and if we ignore the independence of the letter "وَ" before "قُومُوا لِلَّهِ قَنِتِينَ" (and this makes this count a bit weak in my opinion) we could say that each part left right and middle of this Verse consists of 3 words and again 3+14=17
40:17 Peace to you, sir. I’m thankful for all of your exegeses on the Quran. Under the pretext of the Quran being complete and 3 Salat being mentioned specifically by name (Salat Al-Fajr/Isha in 24:58 & Al-Salat Al-Wusta in 2:238) I’m inclined to believe there are 3 times for Salat only. The two ends being light and dark with the the middle time being the sun at it’s highest… I pray for more understanding and that we all are of the ones on the straight path. Any input is greatly appreciated.
Peace brother - I don't put weight solely on just the three Salat mentioned you cited, but upon the five times mentioned in the Quran for Salat. Here is an article on the subject:
24:58 - Dawn and Night
11:114 - Dawn, Afternoon, Sunset
17:78 - Noon
qurantalkblog.com/2022/05/06/both-ends-of-the-day/
@@QuranTalkAssalamu alaykum brother. So with 5 times salat per day, you want to say that miraj history is true?
I like your channel and most of your videos are spot on , but I disagree with your assessment for 5 salat.
No where in Quran does it say to perform salat as the hadith Followers do. Standing is mentioned for the middle prayer, Standing, Bowing and to prostrate for the Dawn and Evening(sunset) Salat. The Quran says Muhammad followed the deen of Abraham. Abraham until Muhammad never had Hadith or 5 Salat. Or the rakats that Hadith followers have. Plus we can't visit their masjid because of idolatry and false ideologies. People get stuck on the concept of how to perform, yet forget God said he left nothing out. If God didn't give instructions, then he allows us to decide. But we of course must do so in a manner of praise. God said he didn't burden us.
Read these and perform salat dedicated to God alone. If it's not in the Quran on rakat, what to say how to perform, the God gives you the freedom to praise him as you wish.
4:103, 24:58(2 times of prayer Dawn and sunset), 17:78,2:238(midday), 16:23(Abraham 3 times), Muhammad followed the same salat times that Abraham did. 62:9(Friday).
The other instances are only referring to the above three times.
May Allah lead us to the right understanding
I wonder if the 5 daily salat was borrowed from Zoroastrian official religion of Persian empire.
@@babsandj I recall a commentator on “Head to head” through Al Jazeera mentioning that the hijab originated during the time of Cyrus the Great. Persian influence seems ingrained in Sunni/Shia practices to a degree.
The torah tells its followers to pray 3 times, sunset, sunrise, afternoon. In the quran it gets mentioned a lot of times to pray: in the morning, the evening and one in the middle. Since prophet muhammed is basically the messenger that confirms previous scriptures wouldn’t it be more logical that prayer is 3 times a day and not 5 times a day. The quran confirms the torah and the bible are the words of god, why would the word of god not be consistent?
So confirms trinity?
It seems that you chose to base the understanding of the quran on your personal assumptions rather on the prophet's interpretation.
@@huntsman2877 the Torah doesn't teach the doctrine of the trinity.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 yah. But that's not what we're talking about.
This guy rejects the guidance of prophet Muhammad puh. And want us to follow the guidance of torah to pray 3 times.
@@huntsman2877 the Prophet (salahu alahi wa salam) himself was guided by the Quran. We must follow the guidance of Allah subhanahu wataala. The guy in the video doesn't reject the prophet. Although praying the 5 daily prayers is good. The guy in the video was saying that the Quran only mentioned 3 prayers per day, which is consistent with the Jewish practice. Personally, I prefer and practice myself praying the 5 daily prayers as we Muslims pray them. It's a good thing. Although I do agree that the Quran is the only true source of moral guidance and I understand that 5 daily prayers are not mentioned in the Quran. I don't agree with the person in the video condemning Muslims for praying 5 daily prayers as they have been praying. Prayer is a personal matter between the person and Allah subhanahu wataala. The 5 daily prayers add a lot of good value to Muslims. First of all prayer in of itself is always good, because it brings about the remembrance of Allah. Secondly it promotes a universal brotherhood among Muslims. I think that the narrator in the video should concentrate on
encouraging the Muslim world to turn to the Quran and develop a personal relationship with the Quran by reading and studying it for spiritual and moral guidance. Unfortunately the overwhelming majority of we Muslims have abandoned the Quran. We need to return back to it. Following the Quran is our only hope for salvation. We must understand that any good that the prophet had was the result of him following the Quran that Allah subhanahu wataala revealed to him. Following the Quran will lead to obedience to God and His messenger.
@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 the prophet puh follows Allah's guidance/revelation, including, but not limited to, the quran.
There are 5 mandatory prayers prescribed by the prophet as revealed to him. We do them, because that was the revelation. We don't do things based on feelings. That's the Christian style of faith, making up religion practices as they wish and feel.
If you wish to limit your faith to the quran, and discard the teachings if the prophet just like the Jews believed and followed the torah and discarded the teachings of jesus, so be it!
All I know is, islam without sunnah (Muhammad's puh guidance), is like believing in half of the quran and not believing in the other half.
Peace be upon you, brother can u send this video’s note? In ur blog I couldn’t find it
Peace - here you go: qurantalkblog.com/2021/05/25/how-to-perform-salat-based-on-quran-alone/
Nice Show
To Mohammad Nawwar - I like your comment and agree with you, please let me know your email so we can discuss this further. Ali
Selam, when the prayer comes from Abraham, did he also recite the Fatiha? what do you think of the work of Dr.kashif Khan?
Peace - yes I believe Abraham recited the Fatiha. While we do not know the exact language Abraham spoke we can see that the languages of the Abrahamic religions (e.g. Hebrew, Aramaic, Arabic) are very similar such that many of the meanings and words come from the same origins. For instance, see the Fathiah translated in Hebrew along with the corresponding citations from the Old Testament. The similarities are very obvious.
HA PATCHAH
(THE OPENING PRAYER)
BE SHEM ELAH HA RAHAMIM
In the name of God, the Most Gracious (Ezr.5:1; Dan.9:9)
ELOHEINU RIBOHN HA-OLAMIM
All praise be to God, Lord of the universe (Jewish liturgy)
HA RAHAMIM
The Most Gracious (Dan.9:9)
MELEK YOM HA DIN
Master of the Day of Judgment (Jewish terminology)
ELEKHA ADONAY EQARA WE EL ADONAY ET HANAN
To you, O Lord, I implore; and to my Lord, I seek help (Psalm 30:9)
HEHENI BE ORACH MISHOR
Guide us to the straight path (Psalm 27:11)
ALEKHET BE DEREHU WE LEYAREH ITTO
The way of life according to His path by reverencing Him (Deut 8:6)
LE HALAK BE ETSAH RISHAH WE LA SAGHAH
Not by the advice of the cursed, nor of the strayers (Psalm 119:21)
@@QuranTalk Do you think Abraham recited the fatiha in the salat? But its not mentioned in the quran that one must recite the fatiha in salat
@@QuranTalk You wrote (I believe that Abraham recited the Fatiha), then you quoted verses from the Torah and also from what you called (Jewish Terminology). Please note the following:
1- When Abraham was alive, the Torah had not been revealed yet, so it makes no sense to claim that Abraham recited verses from a Book that was not revealed yet.
Quoting verses from the Torah to make your point is therefore not applicable.
2- You also quoted words that you thought resemble the Fatiha words and you gave the source as being (Jewish terminology). As you know, all the previous prophets and believers used only the words of God's Book in their prayers, and not what you call Jewish terminology.
[3:113] They are not all the same: among the People of the Book are an upright nation. THEY RECITE GOD'S REVELATIONS during the night WHILE THEY PROSTRATE.
3- In addition, what you call Jewish terminology cannot be linked in any way to Abraham. The Quran tells us that Abraham was neither Jewish nor Christian, but was a monotheist Muslim (3:67).
@@QuranTalk You wrote (I believe that Abraham recited the Fatiha), then you gave verses from the Torah and also from what you called (Jewish Terminology). Please note the following:
1- When Abraham was alive, the Torah had not been revealed yet, so it makes no sense to claim that Abraham recited verses from a Book that was not revealed yet.
Quoting verses from the Torah to make your point is therefore not applicable.
2- You also quoted words which you thought resemble the Fatiha words and you gave the source of (Jewish terminology). As you know, the prophets and the believers used only the words of God's Book in their prayers, and not what you call Jewish terminology.
[3:113] They are not all the same: among the People of the Book are an upright nation. THEY RECITE GOD'S REVELATIONS during the night WHILE THEY PROSTRATE.
3- In addition, what you call Jewish terminology cannot be linked in any way to Abraham. The Quran tells us that Abraham was neither Jewish nor Christian, but was a monotheist Muslim (3:67).
@@galaxy3619 Your points are valid, but have nothing to do regarding the point I was making in my comment. The original argument is: if Abraham spoke a different language, then how would he have recited the Fateah in Arabic?
My point is that all the Semitic languages (Aramaic, Hebrew, Arabic) are similar as they come from the same source. Therefore, When Abraham recited the Fateah during his Salat would be linguistically similar if not identical to what we have today. This is proven by looking at the Fateah in Hebrew based on the Bible today. This has nothing to do with Abraham being Christian or Jewish as you claim in your comment, but merely just a linguistic fact.
quranstudy19.com/2019/10/06/did-abraham-recite-the-fatehah-in-his-salat/
Praise be to God, Lord of the Universe ❤
Multi-verse ❤
Great video. But from where do we get the idea of number of Rakats?
We all know that the Quran is the primary source for anything about Islam, but it is more likely to be a kind of abstract this means when it comes to details we need the sunna as a 2nd reference.
Now, let's see what we can find in the Quran:
Maintain with care the [obligatory] prayers and [in particular] the middle prayer and stand before Allah , devoutly obedient. -- al-Baqara 2:238
And establish prayer at the two ends of the day and at the approach of the night. Indeed, good deeds do away with misdeeds. That is a reminder for those who remember. -- Hud 11:114
O you who have believed, let those whom your right hands possess and those who have not [yet] reached puberty among you ask permission of you [before entering] at three times: before the dawn prayer and when you put aside your clothing [for rest] at noon and after the night prayer. [These are] three times of privacy for you. There is no blame upon you nor upon them beyond these [periods], for they continually circulate among you - some of you, among others. Thus does Allah make clear to you the verses; and Allah is Knowing and Wise. -- an-Nur 24:58
Verse 1 tells us that there is a middle prayer which means there are at least 3 prayers and doesn't mention the exact number of prayers.
Verse 2 tells us that during daylightv (the time gap between fajr and maghrib) we have 2 prayers (duhr and a'sr) and one when the night approaches (al-maghrib) (see also this Fatwa): With (only) this information it's still possible that we only have 3 prayers, but
Verse 3 which teaches us about the resting times mention clearly the fajr/sobh prayer and the I'sha prayer as the fajr itself is a not mentioned time in the 2 Verses before we find out we really have 5 prayers mentioned in the Quran!
Now we find we have 5 prayers or prayer times mentioned in the Quran.
By the way we could also include some other Verses to explain for example:
Establish prayer at the decline of the sun [from its meridian] until the darkness of the night and [also] the Qur'an of dawn. Indeed, the recitation of dawn is ever witnessed. -- 17:78
Which mentioned indirectly the prayers from duhr until i'sha' and by the mentioned recitation of dawn the fajr prayer! See also this Fatwa in Arabic.
Just as an addition:
the sentence أقِمِ الصلاة = establish prayer (singular form) was quoted 5 times in the Quran. The sentence أقيموا الصلاة= establish prayer (plural form) was quoted 12 times in the Quran.
As we know 12+5=17 which is the sum of the raka'at of our daily fard prayers!
The Verse 1 from above is written in the moshaf as follows حَفِظُوا عَلَى الصَّلَوَتِ وَالصَّلَوةِ الْوُسْطَى وَقُومُوا لِلَّهِ قَنِتِينَ.
If we count the number of Arabic letters at the right and left from the expression وَالصَّلَوةِ الْوُسْطَى = and the middle prayer.
We find it to be the exact middle of the Verse and each part at the left and right has 14 Arabic letters and if we ignore the independence of the letter "وَ" before "قُومُوا لِلَّهِ قَنِتِينَ" (and this makes this count a bit weak in my opinion) we could say that each part left right and middle of this Verse consists of 3 words and again 3+14=17
@@umarisah1596 also the fact that 24434 is a multiple of 19.
24434:19=1286
(2+4+4+3+4=17)
(1+2+8+6=17)
@@dawnbright4025 Let me show you why the simplistic calculations you gave mean nothing and can be easily duplicated.
Let us re-arrange the 24434 to be 43244. The total raka is still 17, now here are the identical calculations you made, but with the number 43244:
43244 divided by 19 = 2276
(4+3+2+4+4=17)
(2+2+7+6=17)
Not really miraculous, nor are these signs from God, are they?
Signs from God CANNOT be duplicated (see 2:23). However, human manipulations can always be duplicated.
@@galaxy3619 Hey, that‘s not the only one.
We have also the fact that Salat is mentioned 67 times and 67 is the 19th prime number. Also what‘s interesting is that, when we add the numbers of the sura and verse‘s, where it‘s occurs we get an multiple of 19.
@@umarisah1596 wuoow that s a reach brother
*Sunni and Shia have concocted millions of tales, and they have attached those tales with the name of Mohammad and they have labeled those forged tales as Hadith of Mohammad; and you are concocting your own tales, and then you are attaching those tales of Rituals with the name of Ibrahim. Bring us a proof that Ibrahim was prostrating to Kaaba in Rituals?*
Peace be upon you, The number of units for each Salat (2, 4, 4, 3, 4). Can u explain about that? About salat number? Where did that came?
Was revealed to the prophet puh in isra and miraj then he told us about it.
It's in the hadith... So I consider them Sunnah acts not fard/wajib because they're not specifically mentioned by the complete Nobel Quran
@@alexandrahenderson4368 how do u prostrate according to the quran
@@huntsman2877Stand, Bow, Prostrate.
While in prostration read the dua giving us in 17:110 if I remember correctly. Your salah ends with Sajda.
Hope this helps. Salam
Salam,
If you bring up how to do Salat timings in the places in the globe that have very long (even can be weeks) or very short day light/night. Let say places that have 23 hrs day light or even weeks of day light.
Thank you in advance
The answer is in the hadith In regards to dajal
The prophet puh was asked: How long will he remain on the earth ? He replied : Forty days, one like a year, one like a month, one like a week, and rest of his days like yours. We asked : Messenger of Allah, will one day’s prayer suffice us in this day which will be like a year ? He replied : No, you must make an estimate of its extent.
@@huntsman2877dajjal is a lie and a fabricated distraction to keep us from the reality of the Hour coming upon us in any instant. No mention in the Quran about a fit bag of dajjal. Therefore it is bid’ah to ascribe it to A’LLah and Muhammed as them having said it.
Innovation is a crime and a corruption. 6:38 proves dajjal is a lie
Shaytan is our biggest enemy. And A’LLah the Most Wise tells us so, over and over in the Kitab of Guidance. A’LLah is Most Merciful to His servants and does let us know what to watch out for. Salam
See, that’s why it’s a good thing that the Qur’an verses about Salah are vague. People living in midnight sun/polar night would have 3 prayers. For example, polar night would have Fajr, sunset, and Isha prayers.
Quran has rejected Rituals in 2:177. Salat is not Rituals. This man in video is talking Nonsense to validate Rituals which are rejected by Quran as >>> NOT A GOOD DEED 2:177. Five Rituals were imported from Zoroastrians during Abbasid Period, and then were validated through forgery of Hadith of Flying Horse Buraq
Brother you said we just have to read only sura fatiha. So what we will read in sitting position? Can you pls let me know detail from starting to ending of salat?
There isn’t a sitting position mentioned in Quran for Salah.
It’s Stand, Bow, Prostrate. Salam
No Rituals in Quran 2:177. His all talks about Rituals is 101% Nonsense
Christians also have the idea of oral tradition that has been passed down in the church. Jews also used to have an oral Torah, which was oral tradition passed down through the generations from Moses until it was recorded in the 2nd century AD (iirc). So, it would make sense if Muslims also had their oral tradition about how to perform salat, do Hājj, etc. And before that, the pagan arabs had remnants of their oral tradition from Abraham.
The oral traditions is what took them away from the straight path and each revelation sent by Allah SWT. Anybody can add to oral traditions but the book of Allah SWT remains the same and if relied upon solely is sufficient for true guidance with out conjecture
Nowhere in the Quran are we commanded to follow what was given to those before us. On the contrary, God makes it quite clear that every people will be accountable to what was given to them and not what was given to those before them. One example is in 5:48 in the words: "He tests you through what He has given each of you."
I mean we are still told to read the scriptures from before... So we don't follow them but they do show our history though broken in many parts
@@alexandrahenderson4368
*Not a single Scripture except Quran is in its Original Shape. Those are Corrupted, badly, and a Corrupted Book might corrupt your mind. Quran is enough 16:89, 6:114*
5:48 >> Muhaymon>Being Final book of God, Quran has superseded all previous scriptures. After landing of Quran, every one have to follow only final version of Divine law which has been finalized in Quran. And even if you wish to follow previous books; YOU CANNOT because all previous scriptures are heavily corrupted, and there is no any sense to follow corrupted books
Salam.
What do you think about the story of musa and "khidr" in surah kahf. Why was an innocent child killed because he thought he would grow up a bad way etc. Was this reality or a dream? I think theres a hadith that shows its a dream although i don't follow the hadith literature. What are your thoughts of it
Peace - I did a talk that touches on this subject that you may find beneficial if you are interested in the topic:
czcams.com/video/TLo1efApAvI/video.html
I am familiar with some of the arguments based on the Quran to why some claim that it was a dream or occurred in some simulation or alternate reality, but I don't find the evidence satisfactory enough to go along with the idea. Here are the claims that I heard regarding why they say it didn't happen in this world:
1. It occurs in the Sura about the sleepers of the cave.
2. The fish found its way back to the river sneakily, implying that it came back to life
3. The teacher killed a boy (like you stated)
4. The Sura also discusses Zul-Qarnain and Gog and Magog
If you have any other insight that you think is compelling evidence from the Quran for why this didn't actually occur in this world let me know :)
Is it possible to speak slowly
Good video! I think some of the protection surahs like surah Falaq, sura Nas and Ayat-ul-Kursi (the throne verse) and some protection Dua to Allah (e.g. "Eudhu bikalimatillahit-taamma...etc.") are also important for your daily morning and evening adhkar as protection against evil (since unfortunately black magic and evil eye is a bitter reality and not just fiction and there are so many evil people out there practicing it). Just make sure to NOT implement it in your contact prayers (there you should just recite al fatihah as you said) but instead recite the adhkar/other surahs separately outside of the contact prayers! And i think the way they should be recited (since as you pointed out qul means say which is said by Allah to us as a command to us to say the following) we should only recite the following without the word "qul":
For surah Al Ikhlas: "Bismillahirrahmanirrahim Huwallahu ehad allahus-samad, lam yalid wa lam yuled wa lam yakun lahu kufuwan ehad"
For surah Al Falaq: "Bismillahirrahmanirrahim Eudhu birabbil falaq min sharri maa khalaq wa min sharri ghaasiqin idhaa wa qab wa min sharri-nnaffaathaati fil-uqad wa min sharri haasidin idhaa hasad"
For surah An Nas: "Bismillahirrahmanirrahim Eudhu birabbin-nas maliki-n-nas ilaahin-nas min sharri-l waswaasil hannaas elledhii-u-waswisu fiisu duurinn-naas minel jinn e tiwann-naas"
That makes more sense since "Eudhu billahi minesh-shaitaanir-rajiim" also starts with "Eudhu" which means "i seek refuge to Allah from..."
Meaning: Allah tells us to say it, he tells us "say/qul: "i seek refuge to Allah from...etc." and so we do as he tells us to do we say "i seek refuge to Allah from...etc." but of course without saying "say/qul" at the beginning as that would make no sense, it was simply part of Allah's speech talking to us in the Quran giving us that command. I can't believe the so called "scholars" of islam never realized that during all these centuries...
Also it makes perfect sense what you said: historically Abraham, Moses, jesus etc. never said "...muhammadur rasulullah" nor did muhammad himself he never dared opposing Allah! It's hadith/sunnah lies. Also when did Prophet Muhammad say in that hadith "during pilgrimage you should visit my grave" did he say that when he was alive or dead? LOL
P.S. I've had this gut feeling a while ago but by now I'm really under the impression that today's fake "Islam" that has nothing to do with Qur'an is a "Brand Islam/Brand of Islam" and all this campaigns "so and so prominent accepted islam, so and so enemy of islam/atheist who was going to attack islam ended up accepting islam, islam the fastest growing religion, 1,9 Billion/2Billion muslims etc.. etc.." are their advertising of their man made religion to attract more people to it. It's become an entire multi-billion-dollar industry with even "halal-food-brand"-departments. Then as a last resort when the muslim apologetics are losing the debate they try to arouse people's pity by saying "look we poor muslims are the good ones, while these bad guys, evil israel,jews americans,etc. everyone is against us." Or "look, see? Everyone is fighting islam because that proves islam is the true religion" and blahblah etc etc. While on the other hand they're attacking, putting bounties on heads and killing messengers of God such as Dr. Rashad Khalifa just because he preached to return to strict and pure monotheism/tauhid. We're seeing today who are the true "muslims/or should i say Mohammedans" how they behave and treat fellow humans, they pray, fast etc. but then display the nastiest human behavior, so they're showing their true face, we can see who are the real "muslims" today. Also, the "sahaba"/companions of prophets (Moses, Jesus, Noah, Abraham etc.) always tended to reject, fight and even kill their messengers, so what makes the "Sahaba"/companions of prophet Muhammad so special, why would they be an exception and never fought the prophet Muhammad. In fact the Qur'an is telling us that it is the companions the ones the Qur'an is talking about in a negative way, cursing them and telling us they fought the prophet Muhammad, Qur'an is telling us that the companions are the ones who fought the prophet Muhammad his entire life (just like the Quraysh or maybe they were even part of Quraysh). And yet today's scholars fail to understand what the Qur'an is trying to tell us and hold the "sahaba" in high regards...
In fact the reality is more and more people are apostating/leaving islam, it's quite the opposite of what they're telling/advertising! True religion/the Qur'an doesn't need fake advertising, The Qur'an speaks for itself! So now it should become clear why according to the Qur'an ~99% will go to hell. That's also why Allah has brought Gog and Magog upon them because Allah/God is displeased with them.
What do you think of sam gerrans' work? Because he has a very different opinion on salat
Peace - I don't agree with Sam Gerrans' understanding regarding Salat (follow closely) or his thoughts on Petra vs. Mecca or that Hajj was abolished after Muhammad performed it. I think he twists the Arabic words to extrapolate meanings that create numerous contradictions in the Quran. Below is an article I wrote regarding his translation about Hajj being abolished.
quranstudy19.com/2019/06/02/928-hajj-sam-garrans/
@@QuranTalk Thankyou for your reply
Yes I do not agree with him on hajj either but can you please elaborate about his mistakes on salat please
Peace
@@mohammadnawar4193 So the belief that Sam Gerrans has regarding Salat, if I recall correctly, is that Salat is not a ritualistic prayer, but rather when people get together to "follow closely" which they describe as something akin to just reciting Quran, or reflecting about God (not sure exactly). He believes this is to be done at two times at dawn and evening, if I am not mistaken. He basis this on the idea that one of the roots meanings of sad-lam-waw is to "follow closely" and therefore does not mean a ritualistic prayer. But this creates numerous contradictions. The video touches on some of the issues this theory has, but there is a long list of problems this creates. I think the biggest is that their belief of Salat is that it is signifying that people are following closely a superior source. That means that according to SG his translation of 33:56 would be completely blasphemous because that would imply that God and His angels were "following closely" the prophet. This false interpretation would make the prophet superior to God. As if, God and His angels were meeting together at dawn and evening to glorfiy and draw closer to the prophet. God be glorified from such claims.
Sam Gerrans translation of 33:56 based on his understanding of Salat would be: "GOD and His angels "following closely / صَلُّوا" the prophet. O you who believe, you shall "follow closely / صَلُّوا" him, and regard him as he should be regarded."
Funny enough in his translation he appears to have cognitive dissonance in his understanding and he translates the word as "duty" to avoid the blatant blasphemy.
@QuranTalk Peace,
You seemed to have confused Sams works for mine.
Sam doesn't use the term 'follow closely' but I do. This is simply what the root definition of this term means.
1. SALAT comes from the root SLW or SLY depending on the lexicon. In either case, this term cannot come from WSL as you claimed since this is an entirely different formation of the term. This is how Arabic morphology actually works! It enables us to detect/find the root word.
God calls it AL-SALAT (الصلوة) and not AL-WUSL (الوصل)... The former's root is SLW, the latter is WSL.
God told us to take from Abraham a MUSALLA مصلى (SLW) and not a MAUSOOL موصول (WSL).
In 13:25 we see God uses the term 'connect' YUSALA (WSL) and not 'follow closely' YUSALLY (SLW).
So it is important not to confuse these terms as it impacts the interpretation. Although both of these terms can sometimes be confused due to the short-vowel movements, they are still two entirely separate words with two different roots.
2. You are invited to review the video I posted about Salat and I do mention (in a good portion of the video) the process of what I called 'Salat Sessions'. The Salat sessions was simply during the time of the prophet in which he met with people and he preached the Quranic message. This is how he was able to spread the Quranic message to the people. At this time, it was also an opportunity for people to 'pray'to God in any fashion they pleased. It is NOT restricted as the rituals are not restricted nor ordained by God.
3. You claimed it is 'blasphemous' to translate SAlat as 'following closely' in 33:56 because God would be 'following closely' to the prophet.
Oddly, you somehow find it okay in translating Salat as 'prayer' but changed the meaning to 'support/bless' in 33:56! I don't know about the 'cognitive dissonance' you are mentioning since it isn't I that is denying the obvious. To me, the idea is to be consistent when using the same root.
In 33:56 God and the angels 'yusalloona 'ala' = 'they follow closely onto...' - such a phrase denotes a support mechanism for the prophet. It is just like the second horse (behind the first) pushing/nudging/urging the first one to 'go on'. This is why the word 'onto' is used in the verse.
Peace
Peace - My apologies for the confusion. Below is an excerpt from SG regarding his understanding from Salat. On the surface, I was under the impression that you two had the same understanding, but thank you for the clarification.
Footnote 2:3 - Sam Gerrans Quranite:
“Generically, salat denotes duty. In its primary sense it is the duty both to serve and seek help from God alone as per the covenant at 1:1-7 of which the statement at 1:5 for our part - commitment to which also satisfies the pre-existing obligation every person has to acknowledge God’s authority (see 7:172). It may also denote worship, since worship is a salat (duty). But just because worship is a duty does not mean that all duty is worship (just as, while all oranges are fruits, all fruits are no oranges - a simple point that evades the Traditionalist because he reads the Qur’an through the expectations implanted within him from Hadith; he sees what he expects to find and twists or ignores what does not fit those expectations).
*****
Article III - salat - duty - Page 2149 - Sam Gerrans Quarnite:
“On the basis of the above, I began to consider the possibility that the hudud Allah (which require a man to uphold certain principles) and salat might substantively be the same thing - since they share a verb in common - and while hudud Allah are principles (the details of which are known and should be applied) illustrative of that form which one should stay away, the question arose: could salat be characterized by those principles to which one should adhere?
Next came the question of how best to render such a value in English. The abstract noun which to me best describes the concept of striving to adhere as closely as possible to something is duty.
The line of thought brought me bak to the etmological base upon which the s-l-w root is formed. The analogy fits perfectly. A lead horse dictates a particular path dependent upon circumstances and the second horse stays as close to the first horse as possible. Whatever the lead horse does represents the following horse’s duty.
The duty of the faithful man, one can justifiably reason, is to please God by believing in him alone and keeping his commandments. The following horse knows what his duty is by looking to the horse in front. A faithful man knows what his duty is by looking to the commandment of God.”
****
Regarding your understanding of root morphology, you should be familiar that when the root contains ا or ى or و these letters do not necessarily denoted in the words that derive from these roots themselves. See the following roots in the Quran: و ق ي or و ص ف or و ذ ر .
Regarding ص ل و meaning only to “follow closely” because of the context of the use in horses, I don’t not abide by that understanding that this is the universal origin of every derivative of this root. One of the jokes of Arabic roots is that every Arabic root has four meanings (1) the meaning (2) the contrarian of the meaning (3) something about a horse or camel (4) something you wouldn’t mention in front of children. The fact that it is used towards a horse in a race just indicates one of the meanings of this root and I think it is inaccurate to apply that one single meaning to all its derivatives, as opposed to prayer or blessings.
According to your video you claimed that Salat is where “we follow closely to a SUPERIOR source.” If that was the case, then I find an issue when translating 33:56. Because according to that definition, it would imply that God and His angels were "following closely" the prophet. This interpretation would make it appear that you are implying that the prophet is superior to God. God be glorified for ever being represented as being behind a human being in a subservient position, despite if you claim it is to nudge.
In your comment you stated: “In 33:56 God and the angels 'yusalloona 'ala' = 'they follow closely onto...' - such a phrase denotes a support mechanism for the prophet. It is just like the second horse (behind the first) pushing/nudging/urging the first one to 'go on'. This is why the word 'onto' is used in the verse.”
The word ‘ala / عَلَى is more suitable to be translated as upon (from above) as opposed to unto (from behind).
My rule of thumb when studying Quran is that if my understanding forms a contradiction then it is important that I reassess my understanding. The above example would be a clear contradiction for me.
How long do you stay in ruku and what do you say? Same question about sujood? And as for the shahada, you dont worship Muhammed (S.A.W.S.) rather you are only testifying that hes ALLAH's messenger and i dont see how thata worshiping!
You also didn’t even go over how you physically do it
salat from root words means following closely, 'sal' means connect . So you cannot change its actual meaning into something else . Bcz from the root words it simply means to connect or to closely follow. People can only mistranslate it but the actual meaning remains the same in every ayat of the quran. Anyone who read quran will know quran is not about physical prayer but its more about following allah's laws which is SALAT. Following the commandments of Allah's laws and living our life accordingly.
Aren’t you forgetting the three movements we’re told about? قيام و ركوع و سجود؟
@@samaraframilassump6370 good point these people will forever regret Quran alone not being detailed about prayer
Isn’t it funny Quran only people claim Muhammad’s job was to only recite Quran to his companions and people and nothing else full stop! But they are out here explaining away outside of Quran (making Sunnah of their own) while differing all while claiming Quran is detailed about everything how ironic
is jewish & islamic salah same? only then claim that v knew salah before Prophet would hold true
Salem Brother,
Thanks you for your works, i'm french but i listen all your vidéo even if that hard to understand for me some times...
About the five salât, there might be the ultimate answer in sourate 20 verse 130.
If you could, read it and tell me what you think about it.
Thank's
Salat is reading the Quran twice fajr n insha, to understand the the meaning of the Quran n to be yr only guidance.
The ultimate is found by the prophet Muhammad puh. Check his teachings, and remember, whenever someone tries to cast doubts upon hadiths, the people who transmitted the quran to us are the same people who transmitted the hadith to us.
@@iesa9556 says u. The messenger of Allah says something else.
I would like u to visit the site of "Baba Shuaib abudulahi", he clearly explains how many salats n how to perform them thru the Quran only. See his playlist on salat series. I pray that Allah guides us all.
@@iesa9556 why? Don't we have the massager teachings and guidances?!
1- Why did God give us names of only 3 Salat in the Quran when they are 5? After all, God assured us that He has left nothing out of the Book (6:38) and that every little detail is in the Quran (6:114). Why were names of some of the Salat left out of the Book which contradicts 6:38? 2- You said that prophet Muhammad was commanded to follow the religion of Abraham. This is incorrect. The command was to follow the Millat of Ibrahim. Millat means creed, the word for religion in the Quran is deen. The creed of Abraham is given in the same verses that speak about the creed of Abraham, he was hanifan, which means monotheist. Monotheism is the creed of Abraham which we must all follow.
God commands the followers of the Quran to follow "millat Ibrahim". Since God did not leave anything out of the Quran that is necessary for our salvation, therefore this is something that was and is already in practice.
You claim that "milat" only means creed and not religion. This is inaccurate. See 2:120, 38:7, 12:37, 12:38...Even in English the terms creed and religion can be synonymous. The root for millat comes from the meaning to dictate embrace a religion, faith, creed, and religion. When we follow what is dictated by God that is a millat. So when God dictated commands to Abraham e.g. perform Hajj, give Zakat, observe Salat, since we follow these commands we are following millat Ibrahim. Additionally, God tells us the religion of Abraham was hanif. The root of hanif also has the following meanings: "Act according to the law of Abraham, someone who performed the Hajj pilgrimage; one who makes Abraham's Sacred House in Mecca their Qiblah; one who performs the ablution;" Actually the Hanif religion is something that was in practice at the time of Muhammad. That is why God did not need to explain to Muhammad what it is to follow millat Ibrahim.
@@QuranTalk Your reply included many points. If I reply to all of them it would take many pages. So I suggest we discuss one point at a time so that your reply and my reply are brief and we do not bore all readers.
I am starting here with your claim that creed can also mean religion. You quoted a number of verses, so I will start here with 2:120, then God willing we can move to others later.
The words in 2:120 prove categorically that millat does NOT mean religion, here is why:
[2:120] Neither the Jews nor the Christians will approve of you until you follow their 'millat' (creed).
What is obvious here is why did God deliberately use the word Millat in 2:120 and not deen (religion).
The reason is given in 3:19 where we are told that the only 'deen' (religion) approved by God is Islam (Submission to God). In 2:120, God is speaking about Jews and Christians and God wants to tell us in 2:120 that such religions (Judaism and Christianity) are NOT religions authorised by God. If God referred to Judaism and Christianity in 2:120 as religions, this can be understood that these are religions authorised by God, and it is for that reason that God deliberately referred to them as creeds to confirm that they are NOT religions approved by God.
The difference between religion and creed is that a creed is a conviction or belief while as a religion is a complete system of rituals, practices, laws, prohibitions and so on.
Your reference to 2:120 is therefore against your claim that creed Millat means religion.
Your reference to 12:37 and 13:38 also prove without any doubt that Millat cannot mean religion.
However, I will wait to hear your reply on 2:120 before I move on to the other verses and other points you raised.
@@galaxy3619 uP
@@QuranTalk Clearly you do not know the difference between the words MILLAT and the word DEEN. The word MILLAT means creed while deen means religion. God never commanded us to follow the whole religious rituals He gave to Abraham, simply because God told us in 5:48 that what He decreed for each people is different, and also that we are not accountable to what was given to those before us. Every people are accountable only to what was given to them (5:48). And every Ummah will be accountable only to its own Book (45:28). We are commanded to follow the creed of Abraham which is HANIFAN (monotheism). as for all the rituals, we are given those in the Quran which is fully detailed (6:114) and nothing has been left out of the book (6:38). Please study the difference between MILLAT and DEEN.
@@galaxy3619 can i talk to you? Your email pls?
I think salat mean follow closely it's from Arab root word s-l-w not contact/in touch it's from Arab root w-s-l
You say Salat means follow closely? If that is so, why do we have to wash our faces, arms , wipe head and feet before we "FOLLOW CLOSELY" (5:6)? Why do we have to "FOLLOW CLOSELY" only at specific times of the day (4:103)? How can we shorten our "FOLLOWING CLOSELY" when there is fear from the enemy (4:101)? ........... stop and think, and do not let the strayers misguide you.
Follow what closely tho?
Please, tell me, author.
What is Salat according to Quran? Is that standing, bowing and prostrating? Or is it recitation, reading Quran and following the God's commandments?
All of these can be a salat.
The question is, what salat is mandatory and been ordered by the prophet
@@huntsman2877 The prophet does not ORDER nor authorise the religion, the One who orders and authorises is God Almighty and none else. The only duty of the messenger is to deliver God's message (see 5:99) ... isn't it time you start believing the Quran and stop making the prophet a partner with God in everything?
Isn't it time you start worshipping your Maker alone without partners?
@@galaxy3619 yes. Allah's message. Which includes the quran and the inspired teachings of his prophet puh.
Like praying 5 times aday. It was revealed to the prophet puh, and he delivered the message Allah's blessings on him.
@@galaxy3619 BTW, I'm ignoring your strawman argument deliberately.
Man up and stand for your claims and stop covering your weak beliefs with false and strawman arguments.
@@huntsman2877 You really like the word "STRAWMAN" dont you! You think this word wins you discussions? Let me tell you: What wins discussion is showing evidence from God's Book ... you have shown none. All your replies are not found in the Quran, they are hollow claims. Like saying that God gave Muhammad 5 Salat! Can you show proof in the Quran for that wild claim? No you cannot. Now let me go and reply to your other fabricated claims.
Only 3 prayers are in the Quran
What are the Three Prayers?
Where does it say in the Quran that salat al isha is not that of the second end of the day.. in one verse God mentions the 2 ends of the day salat and He didn't mention their names and in another He mentions their names dawn and isha.. Nothing says in the quean that isha is the night prayer so given these two verses we can conclude that isha is the second end of the day prayer which we now call sunset prayer
As for the verse mentioning the middle prayer.. it does't specify its exact timing like the other two salat so with the other verse of "duluk shames" when the sun starts to move from the center we can conclude that that is the timing of the middle prayer which name is "middle prayer" not asr not zuhr
Disclaimer: I'm not debating.. I'm just asking.. as for me I'm still praying 5 salat per day as I'm still learning about this and in my opinion praying more salats a day is better.. but I just want to get the exact message delivered by God
Details of salat or other rituals aren't necessary mentioned in the quran.
Allah has revealed his words (the quran) and his guidance (the prophet tradition).
Saying where is this in the quran, where is that in the quran, is the very trick they want us to fall into. Revelation includes, but not limited to, the quran and the the prophet of Allah tradition.
Quran only is the very first step into disbelieving in Islam.
Just one example, quran says cut hands of thief's hands (full stop).
@@huntsman2877you have no authority to accuse Muslims who follow the Quran’s guidance that is sent from A’LLah as Muslims who are leaving Islam.
No where in the Quran will you see A’LLah mentioning that Muslims to hold to Quran have left Islam. You find the opposite.
Hadeeth is in Quran. Never once mentioned as a tradition for the Nabiyy.
Hadeeth are narrations of the stories of past peoples and messengers. Hadeeths which we are to learn wisdom from and to learn how to interpret them.
Sura Yusuf is a fine example. Hadeeth’ul Musa. Hadeeth of the guests of Abraham
Hadeeth of Firawn. Of the Junoud and the Thamud
Hadeethu Ghashiyah
Sunnah also is never once mentioned as the way of the Nabiyy. In fact it is mentioned as the Sunnah / Way of A’LLah.
Very scary to see how much bid’ah has been created and is being followed blindly. And if everyone read and studied the Quran everyday then these problems and wrongs would not have a chance to grow. Salam
But I do not understand how can you say that there are things that are known and the Quran clearly says ما فرطنا في الكتاب من شيء and many similar verses. I mean you think that the Quran would at least tell us all the details required for the religion (وهو الذي انزل اليكم الكتاب مفصلا) since many practices have been corrupted and we really cannot know anything for sure unless there is evidence. Even God told the prophet to tell the pagans to bring a written evidence for their polytheistic beliefs ائتوني بكتاب من قبل هذا
The mutawatir a'amali (or frequent practical transmission) cannot really be trusted because we cannot really know what has been added or omitted from the prayer/ hajj/ etc
And what do you think about other rituals?
If they must be known from the Quran then why is only salat from outside the Quran? Wudu was also a known practice, why didnt god leave it outside of the Quran? And dont you think that if God wanted to tell us how to exactly do the prayer, he would? Just like he did with the wudu? I think the salat must be revisited and more effort must be done on researching this very controversial topic
Peace - I believe if God thought it was necessary to explain in detail then it would have been mentioned in the Quran. Since it is not, then it means it does not need clarification and we have what is necessary to carry out the command. I think the example of the Children questioning God's command to sacrifice a heifer is a great example. The questions they asked were not necessary, but by asking all they did was expose their reluctance in their belief.
@@QuranTalk Yes I totally agree
But the thing is that you are saying that there is a specific form of 5 daily prayers with the recitation of the fatiha while standing, then bowing, etc, the known form. And in the shahada saying only God's name. Just because it matches the Quran, doesnt mean it comes from the Quran. You know what I'm saying? I really admire your work and I hope you can understand
Salam brother Mohammad, I agree with you. Please let me have your email so we can discuss this further, Ali
@@galaxy3619 sure.
mohammadnawwar99@gmail.com
I feel very sad when I hear people professing that they follow nothing but the Quran, then they also say: ... well ..... Quran plus what came from Abraham!
God said He left NOTHING out of the Book, God did not say (Nothing has been left out of the Book except what was given to Abraham) did He?
All the details are in the Quran means just that.
The words in 6:38 and 6:114 are a true test to all believers as to how much they believe God's words. Why can they say that some Salat details are left out of the Quran (for any reason), yet still say they believe that nothing is left out of the book?
Revise yourself brothers and sisters!
Left nothing out of the Book means that whatever God decreed for us should ALL be in the Quran, regardless of whether it was given to Abraham or not.
Indeed, the Quran tells us that the Salat was first given to Abraham, however, God does not tell us any details of the Salat given to Abraham, such as, how many, how many raka, and so on. Those who say that God gave Abraham 5 Salat and 24434 Raka, etc have no Quranic evidence to that whatsoever, it is mere speculation.
That is in addition to the fact that the Salat observed by Abraham could not have been like our Salat in the first place since Abraham did not have the Quran to recite his Salat from, while the bulk of our Salat is structured on Quranic words.
Salat is quranic sessions/class
Bismillaah
Our messenger used to follow two ways to perform his salah,
1:Following the duty of conveying the messages as he had chosen for messengership.
2: Following the messages first before delivering it to the people.
What do you think of hajj? You havent spoken about it
Peace - I believe Hajj is an obligation to anyone who follows the Quran to perform at least once in their life if they can afford it.
[3:97] In it are clear signs: the station of Abraham. Anyone who enters it shall be granted safe passage. The people owe it to GOD that they shall observe Hajj to this shrine, when they can afford it. As for those who disbelieve, GOD does not need anyone.
QuranTalk why has no prophet made between ibrahim and mohammed hajj
@@AMGbrmmbrmm Peace - we see in the following verse that Moses and Shuaib both performed Hajj.
[28:27] He said, "I wish to offer one of my two daughters for you to marry, in return for working for me for eight pilgrimages (حِجَجٍ / Hijajin which is the plural of Hajj) ; if you make them ten, it will be voluntary on your part. I do not wish to make this matter too difficult for you. You will find me, GOD willing, righteous."
If you want to learn more about Hajj in the Bible, and specifically for the Children of Israel, check out the following episode:
czcams.com/video/7b7wKV7qYN4/video.html
@@QuranTalk Peace brother
I do not think this is shuaib, only because God does not state that this is shuaib, and only the interpreters claimed this. Moreover, in arabic, حجج does not mean pilgrims, it means years, and even the context shows this. But regardless, I do believe that the prophets between Ibrahim and Muhammad did indeed perform Hajj
QuranTalk but in sure 34:44 is there no warner sent to the people of Mohammed before him?
Salat means adherence/following closely not prayer.
And those group prayers are talking about are during war times. That’s why they have people watching them while they do it so nobody gets ambushed you can pray alone to God every prophet has and that’s the way it is.
Salamun
Please inform me where you find “Salat. al Thur” and the “ Salat al asr” and “Salat al magrib.
Sura and Aya,, name and time. .. the Quran is fully detailed, kamil, . Good study.
Peace - This article specifies the five times for Salat per the Quran.
qurantalkblog.com/2020/09/29/five-contact-prayer-salat-times/
We only have 3 prayers in the Quran. Fajr, wusta and eisa.
@@QuranTalk Allah did not say in the Quran: O muslim pray five times a day. More so, only salat fajar, salat wusta (mid day prayer) and salat isa. Where in the Quran is salat asar and magrib?
@@QuranTalk Whoever wrote this article for the 5 prayers should fear God and stop manipulating the Quranic words. The articles refers to various verses that speak about Tasbeeh (glorifying God) such as 20:130, 52:48, 50:39, 3:41, 76:25, then try to fool the reader into thinking these verses speak about the Salat!
1- There is a difference between Tasbeeh (glorifying God) which can be done at any time of the day, and does not require any pre-requisites, and between the SALAT which is prescribed for specific times of the day and requires pre-requisites, such as ablution, Qibla, standing, bowing and prostrating. None of these pre-requisites are required when we glorify God (Tasbeeh).
2- The word Salat is not mentioned in any of the verses mentioned above. When God speaks about the Salat, the word Salat is ALWAYS used.
Allah has ordered us through revelation to pray 5 times and has proveded us with details on how to do so. You can find that in sunnah.
Now if you're gonna reject part of the revelation (hadiths), and only accept portion of it (quran), that's up to you.
How many rakats should we pray ? And what do you think about asalam alikum at the end of pray? And same Allahu waleman hameda ?
Assalamu'aleikum at the end of is an association someone with the God.
Salam
@@yeldarazanbayev2562 in that case it had to be at start as well.
Assalamulaikum is giving greetings to the 2 angels, left and right of your shoulder
@@Mr-Safology Why are you saying BYE to the angels? Is your Salat addressed to the angels or to God? According to 20:14, we are commanded to observe the Salat to commemorate none other than God, and according to 6:162, our Salat is for God and no one else. The angels are not a factor when we perform any worship ritual.
@@galaxy3619 I didn't state BYE. I stated GREETINGS to the angels, on my right and left shoulder. in additionally, in congregation at the mosque, we GREET the angels on each shoulder and the brothers on each side of you, in the mosque.
*Who are الْمُصَلِّينَ the Musalleen ?*
Is it those who observe the ritual prayers ?
Lets find out.
70:19 Verily, man is created with an anxious disposition.
70:20 When they are afflicted, they complain,
70:21 And when good touches him, withholding [of it],
70:22 Except الْمُصَلِّينَ the MUSALLEEN.
70:23 *Those in their SALAT (صَلَاتِهِمْ) who are CONSTANT (دَائِمُونَ).*
70:24 *And They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their money/property (أَمْوَالِهِمْ)*
70:25 *for the needy (لِلسَّائِلِ) and the deprived (وَالْمَحْرُومِ),*
70:26 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who acknowledge/accept as true (يُصَدِّقُونَ) the Day of Judgment (بِيَوْمِ الدِّينِ),*
70:27 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who are afraid of the torment of their Lord,*
70:28 the punishment of their Lord is not something for them to feel secure of,
70:29 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who guard (حَافِظُونَ) their modesty*
70:30 Except from their spouses or what they possess rightfully then indeed, they (are) not blameworthy,
70:31 but whoever goes beyond this is a transgressor;
70:32 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises(وَعَهْدِهِمْ),*
70:33 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed (شَهَادَةَ),*
70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard يُحَافِظُونَ,*
70:35 such people will receive due honor in Paradise.
Further Clarification of ayahs 70:22-34
*Spending Wealth, Charity*
70:24 They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their money/property (Amwālihim أَمْوَالِهِمْ).
70:25 for the needy and the deprived,
Clarification :
[107:1] Do you know who rejects the deen
[107:2] Who turns away the orphan
[107:3] And does not encourage the feeding of the poor.
[107:4] So woe to those "LILMUSALLEENA" لِّلْمُصَلِّينَ
[107:5] [But] who are heedless of their "SALAT" صَلَاتِهِمْ
[11:87] They said: "O Shu'ayb, does your SALAT order you that we leave what our fathers served, or that we do not do with our money/property (Amwālina أَمْوَالِنَا) as we please? It seems only you are the compassionate, the wise!"
[9:103] Take from their money/property(Amwālihim أَمْوَالِهِمْ) a charity (صَدَقَةً) to purify them and develop them with it, and make SALAT with them; for your SALAT is a tranquility for them; and God is Hearer, Knowledgeable.
*Belief, Qualities:*
70:26 (And Musalleen are those) who acknowledge the Day of Judgment,
Clarification :
[27:3] Those who establish "SALAT" and contribute towards purification. *AND THOSE WHO ARE CERTAIN ABOUT THE LIFE-TO-COME.*
[4:162] who perform the "SALAT" diligently, and contribute towards purification, *AND BELIEVE IN ALLAH AND THE AFTERLIFE*
*Guarding Ones Modesty*
70:29 (Al Musalleen are the ones) who preserve their chastity
70:30 except from their spouses and those whom they rightfully possess [through wedlock], for which they incur no blame
Clarification :
[29:45] Recite, what has been revealed to you of the Book and establish "SALAT". *Indeed, "SALAT" prohibits immorality and wrongdoing,* and the remembrance of Allah is greater. And Allah knows that which you do.
*Fulfill Pledges, promises:*
70:32 (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises,
Clarification :
[2:177] ...establish "SALAT", and contribute towards purification, *AND FULFILL THE PLEDGES/PROMISES MADE BY THEM.*
*Truthful Testimony*
70:33 And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed (بِشَهَادَاتِهِمْ),
Clarification :
[5:106] O you who believe, witnessing (شَهَادَةُ) shall be done if death is approaching one of you and a will is being made, by two among you who are equitable. If you have gone forth in the land, and death is approaching, then any two may suffice - if you have a doubt regarding them, then detain them after making the *SALAT,* and they will swear by God: "We will not purchase with it any price, even if it was from a near relative, *AND WE WILL NOT CONCEAL THE TESTIMONY (شَهَادَةَ)* of God, else we are of the sinners."
*Guard the Salat*
70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard يُحَافِظُونَ,*
Clarification :
[6:92] And this is a Book which We have sent down, blessed, authenticating what is between his hands, and that you may warn the capital of the towns and those around it. And those who believe in the Hereafter believe in it, *AND THEY GUARD THEIR SALAT.*
Salat is not a ritual prayer.
Quran(الْقُرْآنِ) Alone(وَحْدَهُ)
Peace
Should we face ka'ba when we observe salat?
Peace -
[2:144] We have seen you turning your face about the sky (searching for the right direction). We now assign a QIBLA (direction of prayer) that is pleasing to you. Henceforth, YOU SHALL TURN YOUR FACE TOWARDS THE SACRED MASJID. Wherever you may be, all of you shall turn your faces towards it. Those who received the previous scripture know that this is the truth from their Lord. GOD is never unaware of anything they do.
[2:145] Even if you show the followers of the scripture every kind of miracle, they will not follow your Qiblah. Nor shall you follow their Qiblah. They do not even follow each others' Qiblah. If you acquiesce to their wishes, after the knowledge that has come to you, you will belong with the transgressors.
[2:146] Those who received the scripture recognize the truth herein, as they recognize their own children. Yet, some of them conceal the truth, knowingly.
[2:147] This is the truth from your Lord; do not harbor any doubt.
[2:148] Each of you chooses the direction to follow; you shall race towards righteousness. Wherever you may be, GOD will summon you all. GOD is Omnipotent.
[2:149] WHEREVER YOU GO, YOU SHALL TURN YOUR FACE (during Salat) TOWARDS THE SACRED MASJID. This is the truth from your Lord. GOD is never unaware of anything you all do.
[2:150] WHEREVER YOU GO, YOU SHALL TURN YOUR FACE (during Salat) TOWARDS THE SACRED MASJID; WHEREVER YOU MIGHT BE, YOU SHALL TURN YOUR FACES (during Salat) TOWARDS IT. Thus, the people will have no argument against you, except the transgressors among them. Do not fear them, and fear Me instead. I will then perfect My blessings upon you, that you may be guided.
*Whatever story you want to make, you can make but truth is: Salat is not any kind of Ritual. Quran has condemned Rituals in 2:177, 2:115 by saying that Rituals are not a good deed. Daily Namaz Rituals were imported from Zoroastrians. Quran is not a book of Theocracy=Rituals but Book of Divine Sociology. If Salat was any kind of Rituals Namaz then Quran was supposed to tell us all details of such Rituals but no any detail in Quran*
*It is biggggg lie to claim that these Rituals are coming from Ibrahim. There is no proof of this claim. If that claim was true, then those rituals were supposed to be carried forward by Quran, as Quran has carried forward several commandments and laws of previous scriptures*
No Brother you’re looking into it too much. It’s only three times a day. You’re trying to define three prayers by two slightly different interpretations. There’s only three everything in religions are three not five.
I used to listen to this channel but I stopped because he is either confused or is either deceiving people with a few of his comments. The first one about five prayers he's repeating and going overboard and not explaining is reasoning is very well and confusing them to the point where we can easily be confused. Again this is just my opinion and I find this channel a little scary and unfocused. Please follow channels that give verse by verse with Quran Aya and numbers so we can see what is written directly. There is no five prayers in the Quran there are three written down so I don't think this channel should try to confuse people and I'm hoping this channel is not slowly bringing Hadith beliefs into it. I won't find out because I won't listen to it anymore but just to anyone else who will sends be careful
The speaker does not define clearly the objective of ritual prayer. The added adjective "contact" perhaps indicate that the purpose is to be in communion with Allah. Yet, early in the talk the presenter appears to belief that the prayer is for improving the state of the soul in the hereafter. For him performing ritual salah is something that will be rewarded in aqirat as salvation and redemption .
Yet, he says the purpose is to remember (zikr) Allah but just remembering Allah is not enough. We need to perform rituals in a strict format because it is something that give mysterious benefits.
I believe whatever we do in the deen (life in this world0 is for making sure we live according to the right path i.e. silatulmustakim based on the huda (guidance) as advocated in the Quran). It is how we live in this world that we will be rewarded -not the number of perfect ritual salah or fasting or umrah that we do.
We are born without inherent sins, there is no concept of salvation in Islam. We also need do something for Allah to seek redemption, we only need to ask for forgiveness.
Are you promoting Islam or Christianity and Judaism!
Monotheistic Islam from the Verses of the Quran. A Quran that were sent down as confirmation of what came down before it. We will never find a change in the Sunnah of A’LLah. Salam
Using the root definition of salah it shows an oration adherence etc. This is further confirmed in 75:31-32 where god contrasts truth with lied and salla with turned away. Further if you use the salah as a ritualistic prayer it becomes problematic in many verses mainly surah ahzab verse 56 i think. That implies god prays etc which is ridiculous given thr concept of tawhid
Peace - In 75:31, the word صَدَّقَ can be translated as he spoke the truth, or also as he gave to charity. I believe it is the later as we consistently see Salat and Zakat (prayer and charity) used in conjunction. This verse, therefore, would be translated:
[75:30] To your Lord, on that day, is the summoning. [75:31] For he observed neither the charity, nor the contact prayers (Salat). [75:32] But he disbelieved and turned away.
Here is the word for word breakdown:
75 31 1 فَلَا And not
75 31 2 صَدَّقَ he spoke the truth / gave to charity
75 31 3 وَلَا and not
75 31 4 صَلَّىٰ he prayed.
75 32 1 وَلَٰكِنْ But
75 32 2 كَذَّبَ he denied / disbelieved
75 32 3 وَتَوَلَّىٰ and he turned away.
Regarding 33:56, the word يُصَلُّونَ can be translated as "they (God and the angles) send blessings. So, therefore, yes God can send blessings to whomever He wills. The problem arises when people assume that it is our duty today to send blessings to the prophet. This is not true.
Consistently in the Quran when Muhammad is referenced as nabi (prophet) it only applies to him when he is alive, as in the same verse it commands the believers to greet him as he should be greeted. Obviously, we cannot greet a person that is no longer living. Another example is in 49:2.
Also, applying the root for Salat و ص ل for يُصَلُّونَ then that meaning would be that God and His angels join (or help and support) the prophet and that the people who believe should do the same. So either root applied still works.
@@QuranTalk the part that doesnt make sense is when yasallu in surah ahzab now means blessings rather than prayer. If we use the root definition and the quran for the meaning of salah i.e oration, adherence etc. Then that fits in perfectly into all places where salah or its plural is mentioned. Rather than having to say now it means blessings or in other verses where it means the prophet asks for mercy on the believers etc.
Isn’t it funny Quran only people claim Muhammad’s job was to only recite Quran to his companions and people and nothing else full stop! But they are out here explaining away outside of Quran (making Sunnah of their own) while differing all while claiming Quran is detailed about everything how ironic
@@Randomhandlename what do you mean? Are you arguing for Hadith’s? Are you a Sunni?
@@JA-be7me how do you pray according to Quran only if it’s so detailed by itself explain to me your prayer from beginning to end with each step in detail which leaves no confusion or differing?
In Quran : 3 salat is mentionned Al Fajr Al Wusta Al Isha all details is in the Quran we can worship tashbeer God every time we want we cant pray everytime we want. Without a app or a watche only look the sky for know when u can pray.
The qibla is like u want
And to Allah belongs the east and the west. So wherever you [might] turn, there is the Face of Allah
All money bissness corrupted the real islam
Quran only
Where is becca today ? The real house Abraham create ... i really dunno but its really important at our time ?
We inspired Moses and his brother: "Appoint for your people homes in Egypt and make of your homes a Qiblah, and observe the Salat, and give the news to the believers. 10:87
Its important for the hajj !!
How can we be sure ? Maybe we cant do the hajj anymore ?
We dont have the control of mecca or becca
Peace - All 10:87 is telling Moses and Aaron is to turn their homes into places of worship. Here is the word for word breakdown.
10 87 6 تَبَوَّآ "[Both of you] settle
10 87 7 لِقَوْمِكُمَا for [both] your people
10 87 8 بِمِصْرَ in Egypt
10 87 9 بُيُوتًا (in your) homes,
10 87 10 وَاجْعَلُوا and place [you all]
10 87 11 بُيُوتَكُمْ (in) your homes*
10 87 12 قِبْلَةً (the) direction of prayer,
10 87 13 وَأَقِيمُوا and observe / maintain [you all]
10 87 14 الصَّلَاةَ the Contact Prayer (Salat).
10 87 15 وَبَشِّرِ And give good news
10 87 16 الْمُؤْمِنِينَ (to) the believers."
Also, God tells us the following regarding Hajj, that we owe to to God to perform it if we can afford it, and that if we are prevented from observing Hajj then we should send an offering:
[3:97] In it are clear signs: the station of Abraham. Anyone who enters it shall be granted safe passage. The people owe it to GOD that they shall observe Hajj to this shrine, when they can afford it. As for those who disbelieve, GOD does not need anyone.
[2:196] YOU SHALL OBSERVE THE COMPLETE RITES OF HAJJ AND 'UMRAH FOR GOD. If you are prevented, you shall send an offering, and do not resume cutting your hair until your offering has reached its destination. If you are ill, or suffering a head injury (and you must cut your hair), you shall expiate by fasting, or giving to charity, or some other form of worship. During the normal Hajj, if you break the state of Ihraam (sanctity) between `Umrah and Hajj, you shall expiate by offering an animal sacrifice. If you cannot afford it, you shall fast three days during Hajj and seven when you return home - this completes ten - provided you do not live at the Sacred Masjid. You shall observe GOD, and know that GOD is strict in enforcing retribution.
Our prophet has provided us with further revelation and guidance.
Allah blessed us with his words (quran) and his prophet's guidance.
The Quran did talk about Asr prayer
Salam...Does the Quran mention anything about recitingTahiyyat in salat? This has been bothering my mind not just bcoz of the 'salawat'/'salam' to Muhamad & Ibrahim but to their families as well.
Peace - I would absolutely refrain from saying it as our Salat should be dedicated 100% to God alone. The Salat came from Abraham and there is no way that Abraham prayed or even mentioned Muhammad in his Salat.
[6:162] Say, "My Contact Prayers (Salat), my worship practices, my life and my death, are all devoted absolutely to GOD alone, the Lord of the universe.
Instead, I would state only the Shahadah as stated 19 times in the Quran as simply "There is no god, besides God." Lã Elãha Ellã Allãh
This is the Shahadah of God, the angels and the knowledgeable and the Shahadah of Muhammad himself.
[3:18] GOD bears witness that there is no god except He, and so do the angels and those who possess knowledge. Truthfully and equitably, He is the absolute god; there is no god but He, the Almighty, Most Wise.
The only time we see someone say "they bear witness to Muhammad being a messenger of God" as part of the Shahadah is in Sura 63 entitled The Hypocrites. It states:
[63:1] When the hypocrites come to you they say, "We bear witness that you are the messenger of GOD." GOD knows that you are His messenger, and GOD bears witness that the hypocrites are liars.
To bear witness to something means we have to see it with our own eyes. If we claim to bear witness to something we have not seen with our eyes then we would be liars as we would be bearing false witness. God clarifies this in the following verse:
[28:44] You were not present on the slope of the western mount, when we issued the command to Moses; you were not a witness.
So do you want to say the Shahadah of God, the angles, and the knowledgable or the Shahadah of the hypocrites?
Additionally, to pray for the families of Muhammad makes no sense as we know for a fact his uncle, Abee Lahab, is condemned to Hell.
[111:1] Condemned are the works of Abee Lahab, and he is condemned. [111:2] His money and whatever he has accomplished will never help him. [111:3] He has incurred the blazing Hell. [111:4] Also his wife, who led the persecution. [111:5] She will be (resurrected) with a rope of thorns around her neck.
And not to nit-pick but even the Arabic statement "وأشهد أن محمداً رسول الله" would be grammatically incorrect as this is translated as "I bear witness that Muhammad IS God's messenger." Since Muhammad is dead, and a dead person cannot be a messenger of God, therefore, the false but grammatically proper expression would be "وأشهد أن محمداً كَانَ رسول الله" "I bear witness that Muhammad WAS God's messenger.
[39:30] You (Muhammad) will surely die, just like they will die.
@@QuranTalk Thank you...so what are we to recite while sitting in the 2nd & last rakaats?
The most I can remember, there is 1or 2 verses in the Quran that say something like "God & the angels 'salat'/'salawat' to the prophet." What is your understanding of these ayats? This sometimes made me feel it's not wrong to give salawat/salam to the prophets but of course not to their families.
Peace - very simple all we say is:
Ash-Hadu Allaa Elaaha Ellaa Allah. (I bear witness that there is no other god beside God.) Wahdahu Laa Shareeka Lah. (He ALONE is God; He has no partner.)
Here are more detailed instructions on how to perform the Salat from beginning to end according to the Quran:
www.masjidtucson.org/submission/practices/salat/howtoperformsalat.html
Regarding sending "salawat" to the prophet this comes from 33:56:
[33:56] GOD and His angels help and support the prophet. O you who believe, you shall help and support him, and greet him as he should be greeted.
Here is the word for word breakdown
33 56 1 إِنَّ Indeed,
33 56 2 اللَّهَ God
33 56 3 وَمَلَائِكَتَهُ and His angels
33 56 4 يُصَلُّونَ [they] send blessings (help and support)
33 56 5 عَلَى upon
33 56 6 النَّبِيِّ the prophet.
33 56 7 يَاأَيُّهَا O
33 56 8 الَّذِينَ ones who
33 56 9 آمَنُوا [they] believe!
33 56 10 صَلُّوا send blessings (help and support)
33 56 11 عَلَيْهِ upon him
33 56 12 وَسَلِّمُوا and greet him (regard him)
33 56 13 تَسْلِيمًا (with) greetings.
Anytime the Quran refers to Muhammad as "nabi" (prophet) it only applies to when he is alive. This verse simply means that the believers were commanded to support him in his efforts while he was alive. This is apparent because in the same verse it says to "greet him with greetings" obviously this cannot be done after he is no longer alive. People have extrapolated this to mean that we are to pray for Muhammad after his death. This is not accurate and contradicts basic commandments in the Quran, most notably not to make distinctions between God's messengers (2:285).
Here are additional examples of Nabi only applying when the prophet is alive.
[49:2] O you who believe, do not raise your voices above the voice of the prophet (nabi), nor shall you shout at him as you shout at each other, lest your works become nullified while you do not perceive.
Obviously, we cannot raise our voice above that of the prophet when he is no longer living.
@@QuranTalk Thank you...Is the first shahadah "Asyhaduallailahaillallah....." taken from the Quran bcoz I don't remember seeing it? Isn't it "Lailahaillallah" bcoz this is exactly from the Quran which clearly indicates there is no god except Allah?
The verse 3.18 is saying God & the angels who bear witness.
Iron Man - your argument fails because the root of Salat is و ص ل which means to join / unite / connect as opposed to ص ل و which means prayers / blessings. That is why it is called the Contact Prayer, and this explains your misunderstanding in verses. It didn't sound like you listened to the talk which I am not surprised because you post the same copy-paste comment everywhere :)
Peace.
The verse says, Allah hi albar.
Not Hu.
There's No Allahuakbar in the Quran.
Blessings.🙏
The prophet authorized the 5 salat prayers after the isra and miraj.
Salat started with Ibrahim as he brought the 5 pillars of Islam which includes salat. Yes it existed hundreds of years before Muhammad. Enough non sense
@@mehdielkhatib1088 what part is non sense?
@@huntsman2877 saying that Muhammad authorized it and or brought it
@@mehdielkhatib1088 Abraham moses isa, all prayed, did hajj and zakah too. But the 5 prayers 1.8 billion Muslims do with the the detailed way and timing, it was giving to our prophet Muhammad by Allah.
It was NOT the duty nor the authority of the prophet to AUTHORISE anything that God did not authroise.
1- The words in 42:21 prohibit us from following anything that is not authorised by God. The words in 42:21 do not say (authorised by God and Muhammad)!
2- The Quran tells us that the only duty of the messenger of God is to deliver the message of God. Messengers are NOT sent to be lawmakers, but only as deliverers.
3- God commanded Muhammad to follow nothing other than the Quran that was being revealed to him. It would therefore be a lie and insult against the prophet if we say that he disobeyed God and followed things that are not in the Quran, then authorised them for us!
Ameen? Amen, amen ra. The hidden god of Egypt... the deception and blasphemy is real
I liked u but when u said Allah didnt have to tell us how to perform Salat u made a fool of urself. Today's way of Salat is false totally false
Assalamu alaikum br. Regrettably, you undermine the value of prophet Muhammad SAW, and how God is instructing the believers to follow his example. Prophet's SAW, examples are found in hadith , so you can't ignore hadith. If you can read Urdu, then you must read the translation of Ahmed Raza Khan, commonly known as Ahmed Rida Khan in Arabic, or simply as "Ala-Hazrat", was an Islamic scholar, jurist, theologian, ascetic, Sufi, Urdu poet, and reformer in British India, and the founder of the Barelvi movement. Raza Khan wrote on law, religion, philosophy and the sciences.
Salaam,
So you are saying, that for 1 to be properly Guided you Must refer to outside sources other then the Quran. Outside Sources that contain “writings” of the Prophet?
You have repeated over 10 times that Ibrahim used to pray Rituals. But that is a bigggg lie which you are attaching with the name of Ibrahim because Ibrahim was not a Idol Worshiper who used to prostrate to Kaaba (made of stones) in rituals, like Meccan Pagans. If Ibrahim had prayed Rituals; its detail must be in Quran. SHOW US PROOF that Ibrahim was praying Rituals and during Rituals, like MECCAN PAGANS, he was prostrating to Kaaba? BRING US A PROOF???? Quran has rejected Rituals in 2:177 but you are attaching Rituals with the name of Ibrahim. Salat is not Rituals; not at all
Who are you? What’s your name? Where are you from? What your religion? It’s clear you are hiding yourself. Why is that? What’s your objective behind pushing these contents on youtube?
Salaam Brothers
Check out Quran Centric regarding the Salat
Dhikr means Reminder, Admonition and it is the Quran/Reading of Allah/The Absolute Authority and that is akbar/greater/greatest NOT Allah/The Absolute Authority, in the Quran/Reading Allah/The Absolute Authority is Al-Kabir/The Great, the absolute term not a relative. Salaamun alaikum/Peace is your responsibility. Salat is NOT a prayer/to ask, but the connection between the Quran, Allah and the people.
Connection is a relationship in which a person or thing is linked or associated with something else and a means or channel of communication.
Al-Quran/The Reading 29:45
ut'lu mā ūḥiya ilayka mina l-kitābi wa-aqimi l-ṣalata inna l-ṣalata tanhā ʿani l-faḥshāi wal-munkari waladhik'ru l-lahi akbaru wal-lahu yaʿlamu mā taṣnaʿūna
Thou follow what He was revealed to thee from of the Book, and thou observe stand upright keep straight to the connection; indeed, to the connection prevents from the excessiveness and the disliked, and surely Reminder Admonition of Allah/The Absolute Authority is greater; and Allah/The Absolute Authority He knows what you are performing.