Antitrust Lawyer Breaks Down DOJ’s Apple Lawsuit | WSJ

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 05. 2024
  • The Department of Justice is claiming that Apple is a monopoly, and it’s turning to a century-old law called the Sherman Antitrust Act to sue the company. The DOJ compared the case to its efforts to stop Microsoft from monopolizing the market two decades ago.
    WSJ breaks down the DOJ’s legal argument in proving Apple is illegally monopolizing the market, and how the tech company might fight back.
    Chapters:
    0:00 Is Apple a monopoly?
    1:03 Breakdown of the Sherman Act
    4:02 Challenges
    5:46 What this means for Apple
    News Explainers
    Some days the high-speed news cycle can bring more questions than answers. WSJ’s news explainers break down the day's biggest stories into bite-size pieces to help you make sense of the news.
    #Apple #DOJ #WSJ

Komentáře • 716

  • @wsj
    @wsj  Před 25 dny +12

    Read more about the monopoly case pitting the DOJ against Apple’s antitrust winning streak: on.wsj.com/3JkLT4y

  • @Lolatyou332
    @Lolatyou332 Před 25 dny +575

    "Raise prices above a competitive level, and to exclude competition" -- Hmm almost like the health care and prescription drug system...

    • @UwOtt
      @UwOtt Před 25 dny +41

      Shhh, the government is taking on a more important threat - iPhones!

    • @SGxShadow
      @SGxShadow Před 25 dny

      This! Or the fact that our military has not passed an audit in years... more than 50% of our taxes goes toward the military industrial complex. I'd much rather know where my tax dollars are going more than someone having or not having an iPhone. The DOJ is a joke!

    • @sofianikiforova7790
      @sofianikiforova7790 Před 25 dny

      Govt mandated insurance is an outright scam. Tax money should be used to foot those bills. Instead they outsourced it to pseudo private sector monopolies who do what monopolies do.

    • @nylotical
      @nylotical Před 25 dny +8

      Meanwhile Samsung S24 Ultra is $1599 for 512 black. 🫤 I hate that they make some colors more expensive.

    • @kart182
      @kart182 Před 25 dny

      That’s a really good point

  • @nxios
    @nxios Před 25 dny +250

    They also monopolized how they repair their products

    • @lucose2001
      @lucose2001 Před 25 dny +2

      yes.. battery is headache for buy oem

    • @rodrigo445678
      @rodrigo445678 Před 25 dny +10

      So? Most other products have that same thing.
      You can take your Tesla to a third party but...

    • @billB101
      @billB101 Před 25 dny

      Just ask Louis Rossmann.

    • @SixTough
      @SixTough Před 25 dny

      ​@@rodrigo445678 Doesn't make it OK

    • @lokisg3
      @lokisg3 Před 24 dny

      ​@@rodrigo445678
      You don't repair Apple products, you buy new ones.

  • @reyesarg
    @reyesarg Před 25 dny +71

    I own an independent repair shop. If a customer want's an aftermarket display or battery then a message will pop up saying, "Cannot verify if an original part is used, please contact apple". This message scares off customers and then they want on OEM apple part. I can buy an apple part from apple for 2 or 3X the cost of an aftermarket. I then have to contact apple and give them a serial number and order number for apple to serialize the parts to the logic board. Apple has agreed to right to repair however they have still cornered the billion dollar repair industry with this software serialization of parts. Apple also does this with the new macbooks.
    There have been times when an update has been released and I see many ipads/iphones/macbooks come into my shop. I once had over 13 ipads come in in one week after an update (all ipads where of the number series & 2-3 yrs old). All ipads had bad batteries. Coincidence? I think not.
    Apple Sux and their corporate values have gone astray.

    • @heyaisdabomb
      @heyaisdabomb Před 25 dny +4

      I do think THIS is where the focus of the DOJ should be. Sure, apples anti repair practices are bad. But everyone is following suit. I know your aware of Samsung Serializing parts as well. Most of this lawsuit will get tossed because it's without merit. They should focus on the anti-repair practices and the absurd hardware upgrade costs, like $400 for $10 worth of ram, or $400 for a $12 nand chip for more storage.

    • @jacobschneider3767
      @jacobschneider3767 Před 24 dny +4

      Same thing with printer ink and supplies, tons of other products. OEM is always more expensive

    • @cordlc
      @cordlc Před 23 dny +3

      The phone detecting parts not being original, by itself, is not anti-repair. At best, you can say the notification is annoying, and it should be easier to hide (if it isn't already, I haven't dealt with it myself). But the fact that we know the device has non-OEM parts in it is a good thing, because if anyone wants to buy used in the future, they don't want to get screwed over. Apple products being reliable (or at least predictable) is what gives them excellent resale value.

    • @NPC123UH
      @NPC123UH Před 21 dnem

      because its true.

    • @owomushi_vr
      @owomushi_vr Před 4 dny

      Never buy apple always buy quality phones

  • @HaHaBIah
    @HaHaBIah Před 25 dny +427

    "Just buy your mom an iPhone"

    • @stevenaziz
      @stevenaziz Před 25 dny +34

      Still not illegal. Being good at business and smart is what got Apple into its position today.

    • @m444kima
      @m444kima Před 25 dny +55

      @@stevenazizas a company you don’t get that big playing fair tho..

    • @michaelchiguil5162
      @michaelchiguil5162 Před 25 dny +10

      @@m444kimaProvide evidence. Blackberry failed after apple released their smartphone. It’s what consumer’s wanted 🤷‍♂️, “not playing fair” is based on consumers, not every company has products that we want.

    • @marcus.H
      @marcus.H Před 25 dny +22

      ​@@stevenaziz keep paying double for an inferior product 😅

    • @TurdFergusen
      @TurdFergusen Před 25 dny +6

      @@marcus.Hkeep giving your data away for free then complaining that AI stole your data😊

  • @breechcomet9724
    @breechcomet9724 Před 25 dny +137

    I'm surprised that neither the EU nor the DOJ did something about apple's xcode(which is mac exclusive) requirement to publish apps to iOS, MacOS watchOS etc.

    • @notjxdxn
      @notjxdxn Před 25 dny +3

      How is that a monopoly..? Just don’t video on Xcode 💀

    • @ashishmusani7016
      @ashishmusani7016 Před 25 dny +8

      yeah, use only apple to create apps for apple

    • @SouthPeter98
      @SouthPeter98 Před 25 dny +35

      ​@@notjxdxnit's a monopoly on iOS development tools and makes developers purchase MacBooks when they may not want to. It defeats competition without competing, so it's a monopoly

    • @antoineNGHT
      @antoineNGHT Před 25 dny +6

      You have react native, flutter, and kotlin. All provide platform specific tools and libraries. No one would bother doing things the old way anymore.

    • @Theoryofcatsndogs
      @Theoryofcatsndogs Před 24 dny +3

      @@SouthPeter98 So maybe don't make apps for iOS. Android is a bigger market. Apple don't force anyone to make app for iOS or MacOS

  • @Jay12Dizzle
    @Jay12Dizzle Před 25 dny +9

    But they don’t go after the real estate monopolies

  • @KashifNawaz85
    @KashifNawaz85 Před 25 dny +151

    Apple,
    "We don't allow our devices to work on other OS."
    "We don't allow others companies' smartwatches, and other accessories to work properly."
    "We don't allow apps to use 3rd party payment methods."
    "We don't allow apps to even mention that user can subscribe on app website."
    "We don't allow 3rd party app stores in our OS"
    "We don't allow sideloading"
    "We make almost impossible to leave our walled garden."
    Also Apple
    "We are not a monopoly."

    • @rodrigo445678
      @rodrigo445678 Před 25 dny

      They are not. Ford doesn't allow other hardware in their vehicles, they decide the pieces, the repair shops and more.
      It's the same thing. A pathetic DOJ trying to prove something non existent.
      Apple doesn't have the obligation to allow the connection of other hardware to their own, they don't have any obligation to allow anything they don't want, it's their ecosystem.
      If Apple disappeared, all of those problems wouldn't exist. Thus, not a monopoly.
      A monopoly can only exist if there's only one company to produce the good. Not the case.

    • @notjxdxn
      @notjxdxn Před 25 dny +52

      Okay yall are forgetting Apple is not a nessesity… no one is forcing you to get a iPhone. All of those things are apples benefits…

    • @MrCaiobrz
      @MrCaiobrz Před 25 dny +18

      @@notjxdxn If you are using a smartphone that is not connected to anything, can't install anything, and can't even properly browse the internet, why buy a smartphone. So what you are saying that today, in 2024, a smartphone is not required? lol good luck

    • @charliesmash
      @charliesmash Před 25 dny +30

      Or just buy another phone…

    • @nylotical
      @nylotical Před 25 dny +5

      1) No problem with the first one.
      2) It has been shown that Apple Watches were originally to be used with Android as a gateway into iOS but there was way too much limitations that would hold it back and major security issues. Ex. Apple Watch unlocks your Mac automatically when you’re right next to it and try to enter it, something that couldn’t be done on windows seamlessly as Android and Windows are separate and don’t communicate between each other like an iPhone, Watch, and Mac do.
      3) PayPal, CashApp, and others work unless you’re talking about something else?
      4)

  • @TTOS69
    @TTOS69 Před 24 dny +6

    Sounds like Apple didn't give the right comgressmen their heads up stock information... Bc why else would they be doing this?

  • @AndrewRusherLDS
    @AndrewRusherLDS Před 25 dny +36

    When a company is broken up, the owner(s) of the broken up company just become the owner(s) of the newly "freed" company/companies. When Standard Oil was broken up, the "freed" companies merged into smaller Standard Oils so the only thing that changed was that we went from one company to a handful of companies owned by the same people.

    • @blacksheepshepherd
      @blacksheepshepherd Před 24 dny +2

      Well, that's the whole purpose, do check who are the new shareholders by then 😂😂😂

    • @AndrewRusherLDS
      @AndrewRusherLDS Před 24 dny +1

      @@blacksheepshepherd if there are new shareholders

    • @conradotieno612
      @conradotieno612 Před 24 dny +2

      True. But the point isn't ownership. I don't think anyone is legally limited from ownership. The point is the effect monopolies have on consumers. So it would only be illegal if the broken up companies collude to diminish the consumer experience or quality of service for their joint gain. It had, from my understanding, nothing to do with ownership.

    • @AndrewRusherLDS
      @AndrewRusherLDS Před 24 dny

      @@conradotieno612 if the companies have the same owners, the owners run each company in a way where the company benefits without causing much harm to the other companies but they don't make any agreements between the companies which makes any claim of colluding harder to prove.

  • @josidasilva5515
    @josidasilva5515 Před 25 dny +40

    The purchase of competitor companies in the beginnings of their existence and then having their products/services completely disappear, is the most common method of eliminating the competition; this should be illegal, the cost of this practice is charged to the consumers.

    • @nylotical
      @nylotical Před 25 dny +1

      While Beats wasn’t in its early stages, it definitely didn’t have its products disappear and beats now sound way better because they aren’t just bass and no vocals or treble.

    • @rodm209
      @rodm209 Před 24 dny

      Sounds like the electric persinal motorized industry thats been around for a long time

    • @robertmusil1107
      @robertmusil1107 Před 24 dny

      Google and Amazon are experts at this. We would have so much innovation if Google would actually make something out of all the things they purchased but they are just filled with lazy developers.

  • @ElCarnivoroBBQ
    @ElCarnivoroBBQ Před 25 dny +120

    US government: oh but IMessage.
    The rest of the world: what’s iMessage? Is that like WhatsApp or telegram?

    • @TurdFergusen
      @TurdFergusen Před 25 dny

      the rest of the world is complaining about AI stealing their data but yall fools gave it to whatsapp and everything else for free

    • @UwOtt
      @UwOtt Před 25 dny +6

      For real. Oh boo hoo, poor android users can’t send and see stickers and reactions in iMessage, what a tragedy.

    • @TurdFergusen
      @TurdFergusen Před 25 dny

      its a war over data, apple doesnt steal users data like others do

    • @matpk
      @matpk Před 25 dny +26

      ​@@UwOtt iMessage is 💩

    • @equinoxx8221
      @equinoxx8221 Před 25 dny +3

      EXACTLY

  • @grzesiek9514
    @grzesiek9514 Před 24 dny +2

    I hope they fix ram and disk upgrade prices. Back when you could add ram to the imac I could tolerate those prices, but now there is no way to upgrade machine later. Everything is soldered…

  • @mriz
    @mriz Před 25 dny +62

    building seamless integration is fine. but when you proactively control integration with other protocols (RCS), it is sure monopoly!

    • @stevenaziz
      @stevenaziz Před 25 dny +1

      I take it that you’re not a lawyer.

    • @Mr_MikeMikeMike
      @Mr_MikeMikeMike Před 25 dny +12

      ​@@stevenazizand are you?

    • @mitchellscheer677
      @mitchellscheer677 Před 25 dny +2

      Not if such controls are implemented to benefit consumers, which is Apple's argument.

    • @aebisdecunter
      @aebisdecunter Před 25 dny +4

      ​@@mitchellscheer677 Thank god I can't replace a dirty/cracked rear camera from another phone to my own. I can only imagine how horrible it would've been to replace a broken camera instead of buying a whole new phone and throwing out the other one.

    • @heyaisdabomb
      @heyaisdabomb Před 25 dny +2

      @@aebisdecunter Samsung also serializes all of the parts of their smart phones. All of the phone manufacturers are starting to do this. It's not just Apple.

  • @ani2595
    @ani2595 Před 25 dny +7

    If they're able to breakup this monopoly, I'd love for them to force back touch id and the headphone jack similar to how the EU finally got them to switch over to USB-C and also make their APIs more available to third parties can develop more sophisticated gadgets similar to the Apple Watch

    • @ToTheDoom
      @ToTheDoom Před 25 dny +3

      API will come under trade secrets, no one can compel them to open it. Even if they do how will it help in creating a apple watch like device? APIs may help in creating apps , hardware is a completely different story. Also their APIs will be of no value of you are going to use android OS and apple cannot be compelled to open their proprietary OS for free use. And no one is going to pay apple a licensing fee when they can get android source code for free. Already , wearables have very small margin of profit(except for apple😂), nobody can or will use anything but free software for a smart watch. Also they cannot force touch ID since it was a proprietary tech which they deemed as outdated. Face id is just as secure as touch ID and reliable. EU forced them to use usb c because it was unfair to apple customers that they had to depend on apple for accessories or mfi devices which pay licensing fee to apple. Hence they compelled them to switch to a usb C as that is the universal standard and is much faster than lightning ports and also decreases dependency on apple while increasing choices for customers. 3.5 mm jack is now universally gone. I have not seen a “flagship” in last 2-3 years with it. Only some obscure sony xperia ones have it and maybe some chinese mid rangers. It is in now way increasing peoples dependence on apple. People are free to choose any number of bluetooth headphones available on the market including airpods. Law cannot be used to bring back our favorite outdated tech😂, otherwise I’ll start asking for a Disk drive in a mac 😂😂…. Although on topic of mac, it came be argued that people should be able to upgrade their macs by using universally available SSDs and Rams. That right there is a monopolistic practice.

    • @heyaisdabomb
      @heyaisdabomb Před 25 dny

      @@ToTheDoom I think the biggest crime apple commits is charging $400 for $10 worth of ram because it's soldered to the motherboard. But you understand that they would have to make bigger laptops or sacrifice somewhere to create that space. The NAND chips they use today are much smaller than an NVME SSD. Could they do it? Sure. That and serializing parts are what the DOJ should be going after, not them refusing to write software so the apple watch works with android phones, or apple choosing what apps get through the app store.

    • @rodrigo445678
      @rodrigo445678 Před 25 dny +1

      So you want the state to intervene a private company? Lol you are delusional.

  • @joelkelsey7788
    @joelkelsey7788 Před 24 dny +11

    Now do this with food companies🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @Napert
    @Napert Před 25 dny +33

    "illegal monopoly" implies the existence of a "legal monopoly"

    • @Busaio
      @Busaio Před 25 dny +37

      but there are legal monopolies. They're just run by the government.

    • @MrCaiobrz
      @MrCaiobrz Před 25 dny +16

      Every government services are legal monopoly, you know, water, electricity, sewers,...

    • @TrevorBrass
      @TrevorBrass Před 24 dny +4

      Utilities are a common form of legal monopoly.

    • @Impextoo
      @Impextoo Před 24 dny +2

      There’s a private health system called Ballad Health that is a legal monopoly. Its monopoly marketplace in eastern Tennessee, western Virginia, and southwest Kentucky is greater than the size of New Jersey.

    • @drewmqn
      @drewmqn Před 24 dny +1

      Yep. The USPS is a legal monopoly (only they can deliver to mailboxes), utilities.

  • @RatTerminator
    @RatTerminator Před 11 dny +1

    What about Amazon,Google,Facebook??

  • @ruspj
    @ruspj Před 25 dny +5

    there is no dennying that apple has a manopoly on :-
    repairing apple devices. - only autheriesed repairers can obtain parts and to be autheriesed you have to agree to replace expensive sections of devices rather small repairs like a single faulty cable/chip making repairs uneconomical. people able to carry out these repairs like this have no access to parts unless they agree not to carry out these repairs.
    iphone app distribution - dictates what apps can/cant be released to users - cannot even change the deffault apps like maps, browser, etc from apples dictated choice

    • @heyaisdabomb
      @heyaisdabomb Před 25 dny +1

      The repair-ability, most smart phones are becoming like this, including Samsung who serializes their parts now so you can't replacement. For app distribution, it's literally about security. Today, it is impossible to click on a website, and have a virus installed because their is not path in the code of the operating system in which an app can be installed that is not going through the app store. Once apple creates the code to allow apps to be installed outside of the app store, hackers will find a way to exploit it so they can push malware and viruses onto your phone. It's frustrating hearing these pundits who don't have computer science degrees explaining how it would be "safer" to open the ecosystem. I know what I'm getting into, I'm not trapped, from a computer science stand point, the reason Apple is successful is because the software is simply better. This isn't a "I prefer it better", I mean literally, run time efficiencies, and file structure, and compression algorithms, it's all better. And they can do this BECAUSE of the closed ecosystem.

    • @ruspj
      @ruspj Před 24 dny

      @@heyaisdabomb apple having a closed ecosystem is no different to how microsoft tied internet explorer to windows.
      customers should have the choice of using the closed ecosystem of apples app store andthe option of taking the security risks associated to alternitave app stores where apple has no say or any cut of payments.
      like with android you can use their ecosystem but have the option to disable play protect if you want to take the risk of installing something from outside of the ecosystem.
      and yes other manufacturers might be screwing customers with serialised parts aswell. this doesnt suddenly make it ok. it should be banned and apple are that company that lead the way with serialising parts to the extremes.

  • @g0203
    @g0203 Před 25 dny +2

    And the fact that you just cannot use old devices anymore while they should be fine to use with the old software

  • @FightTalkMMA
    @FightTalkMMA Před 24 dny

    I'd love another one of these videos but on the UFC.

  • @ese_cholito
    @ese_cholito Před 25 dny +5

    Why do people use Apple products anyways? They're overpriced and opensource free versions of their software are almost always better. Not to mention, Windows is better overall.

  • @Ivanz4sdrive
    @Ivanz4sdrive Před 21 dnem

    Can someone enlighten me on the superior app integration that Apple has on it's competitors? Also, does this mean we can finally see improved messaging between android and apple?

  • @richardjones2964
    @richardjones2964 Před 24 dny

    So why isnt the clayton antitrust act applied here too?

  • @erwinruff01
    @erwinruff01 Před 25 dny +1

    do we get alternate app stores for xbox, playstation and Nintendo Switch too?
    Like Microsoft has a Monopoly of 100% on Xbox

  • @bjkjoseph
    @bjkjoseph Před 25 dny +68

    It doesn’t matter, if they are found guilty it’s a slap on the wrist and they will eventually have a workaround. It’s all theater to make it look like they’re doing something… probably a small fine and they will not admit any guilt

    • @heskinammoduo5799
      @heskinammoduo5799 Před 25 dny +4

      Good I don't want my stocks to go down 😊

    • @marcus.H
      @marcus.H Před 25 dny

      Did Microsoft do that?

    • @bjkjoseph
      @bjkjoseph Před 25 dny +1

      @@marcus.H slap on the wrist

    • @TurdFergusen
      @TurdFergusen Před 25 dny +1

      imagine the guilty trying to call out others

    • @bjkjoseph
      @bjkjoseph Před 25 dny

      @@heskinammoduo5799 that’s the whole idea

  • @eric-rounds
    @eric-rounds Před 24 dny +7

    Amazon. Microsoft. Walmart. Meta. Google. AT&T (again). Keep going DOJ… let’s get back to realistic business sizes.

  • @johndavidgorman7482
    @johndavidgorman7482 Před 25 dny +2

    "This lawsuit could cost Apple millions of dollars" I'm so sorry to hear that. I hope that there almost $400 billion in revenue can with stand this massive cost :(

  • @egal1780
    @egal1780 Před 25 dny

    0:01 That sounds like "monopolies like apples" as in the fruit and not the company.
    I mean who doesn't know the monopoly of the fruit?

  • @mctywellmlotha3908
    @mctywellmlotha3908 Před 25 dny

    WSJ 🔥

  • @Mrussell1980
    @Mrussell1980 Před 21 dnem +6

    For those who don’t understand what a monopoly is, A monopoly is when you have 3 properties and then you can buy houses for them…you’re welcome

  • @AndreaDoesYoga
    @AndreaDoesYoga Před 25 dny

    Interesting insights, I never knew Apple was under scrutiny 🍎.

    • @rodrigo445678
      @rodrigo445678 Před 25 dny

      They aren't. They are not a monopoly in any way.

  • @drlahori
    @drlahori Před 25 dny

    It's true apply make it hard to switch

  • @thomasshakelton
    @thomasshakelton Před 25 dny +1

    "We have no monopoly there is no monopoly here" will become a meme

    • @MrCaiobrz
      @MrCaiobrz Před 25 dny

      We are not a monopoly, we bought the definition of monopoly in every language and clearly removed all mentions about Apple, you can check!

  • @Sunset4Semaphores
    @Sunset4Semaphores Před 25 dny

    Refusal to support RCS, 3rd party app stores (and side loading), and lock out independent repair... clear monopoly.
    You also have to manually switch off imessage if you switch to android or dumb phone.

    • @jacobschneider3767
      @jacobschneider3767 Před 24 dny

      They are releasing RCS this year. Get your facts straight
      Every single manufacturer encourages use of OEM parts… clearly not monopoly

  • @marekbrusy
    @marekbrusy Před 25 dny +1

    No

  • @ranadeep8318
    @ranadeep8318 Před 23 dny

    5:18 chk

  • @STREETFOODJOURNEY5
    @STREETFOODJOURNEY5 Před 24 dny +8

    this people got nothing better to do?

  • @meriliu8688
    @meriliu8688 Před 25 dny +1

    When Apple is in love with China Factory and server capacity, DOJ punish it!🤣🤣

  • @777tman
    @777tman Před 25 dny

    It’s about time

  • @beryalex1798
    @beryalex1798 Před 24 dny

    Those 30% cut for app developers is big problem.. and phone you can not repair or pc

  • @TexMexPfanne
    @TexMexPfanne Před 25 dny

    3:30 1. You can use apps not from the app store but maybe they are Not Safe. But you can do it
    2. You can use other cloud streaming apps, you just need to download them and put your files in
    3. Just use WhatsApp or Telegramm or Instagram or any app, maybe SMS
    4. There are other smart watches which can be used with the iphone. But they are often not so good. You cant use the apple watch with android but you also cant use a google watch with the iphone
    5. There are numerious other payment options like paypal or apps from your bank. But this is the one point where the alternatives are really not as good. So a valid point

  • @owomushi_vr
    @owomushi_vr Před 4 dny

    So when you getting rcs apple. Time to adopt current cellular standards

  • @AllTimeNoobie
    @AllTimeNoobie Před 19 dny

    As we walk into a new tech world, where your phone is really like an access point to the rest of the world, possibly replacing transportation, communications, data storage, behavior statistics/advertisement capabilities, and personal identification. Thus I'd suggest the following changes... (I've used iPhone since 2009 starting iphone 3GS, and do have a hard time switching over to other products)
    DOJ should focus on breaking Apple into hardware company, software company, online market place company, and credit service company.
    Much like how windows can be installed onto Mac and MacOs onto PC, the hardware should be made available and transparent within US territory to US users to the very least. Should other nations wish it, it should also be available for users to choose their hardware.
    In addition, 'jailbreak' should not be a 'break' from its software and waives warranty, but an option to opt in or out of, so users have their rights to access their own data, and gets decide to protect it using other tools or to use it eslewhere without requiring to purchse additional storage on clouds or bigger phone storage. Also, those software updates should not been a required download for newer phone, and should be more transparent on what is changed (including battery efficiency or battery consumption, to avoid secretly forcing the device to burn out and shorten the lifespan of an iphone behind user's back). Also, the messaging tool 'iMessage' should open to include government oversight so that scam and fraudsters can be held responsible.
    Apple Pay and In-App purchases should follow standard like VISA and only charge a minor fee, not a whopping 30% for similar services. App-control/approval mechanism should be more transparent, and should not be made-available by Apple company, instead it should be available to either the community or for government oversight.

  • @WillJBailey
    @WillJBailey Před 24 dny

    Going after Apple, which clearly is not a global monopoly, when they should have gone after Meta, which definitely is.

  • @NjanVishnu
    @NjanVishnu Před 24 dny +1

    Tim Cook: We need to decrease our market share. The easiest way to achieve this is to increase prices for all products.

  • @chrisklugh
    @chrisklugh Před 24 dny

    Everyone loves the growth of a company till its a Monopoly. Irony.

  • @nyxline
    @nyxline Před 23 dny

    Just Don't Buy Your Mom An Android 😂😂😂😂

  • @TuaTagovailoaTouchdowns
    @TuaTagovailoaTouchdowns Před 8 dny +1

    Apple's really guilty of making superior products.

  • @SamThomas-hv2dg
    @SamThomas-hv2dg Před 9 dny

    Tim cook 🥺🥺🥺 I love you ❤

  • @ayanacurtis1478
    @ayanacurtis1478 Před 12 dny

    There are so many things in this country I care more about than Apple and TikTok and it annoys me that these are the priorities. How about health care, medication pricing, affordable education and child care… idk… important stuff that affects our day to day.

  • @JacobMeye
    @JacobMeye Před 23 dny +1

    I feel like United Health is the worst Monopoly...

  • @tonibest7965
    @tonibest7965 Před 25 dny +1

    same like Microsoft ?

  • @dimitrigilchrist5262
    @dimitrigilchrist5262 Před 6 dny

    You can’t personalize your products basically lol 😂

  • @blacksheepshepherd
    @blacksheepshepherd Před 24 dny

    Hmm.. Break up the company like Standard Oil.. And we'll have Oranges, Pears, Coconuts, Grapefruits and etc 😂😂😅

  • @huehuehue0425
    @huehuehue0425 Před 14 dny

    "There is no war in Ba Sing Se."

  • @yozeruga
    @yozeruga Před 25 dny +1

    Second question out of all of the reporters here, how many are using iPhone?

  • @maddominican879
    @maddominican879 Před 25 dny

    They should go after the cable companies then.if you dont have competition you pay up your asz for service

  • @hugsdibude8710
    @hugsdibude8710 Před 24 dny

    In short, yes. I wrote my thesis on ecosystems and quite obviously Apple was one of the leading examples. Apple has evolved into an infrastructure provider (everybody needs phones just as roads, electricity lines etc.) and consumers benefit from network effects in infrastructure settings (e.g., compatibility). For these reasons competition is not beneficial and its a winner takes it all situation (maybe there is space for a second solution but thats it). In the past, infrastructure was built by governments and provided to everyone, without profits in mind. However, Apple can charge whatever they want for their infrastructure accessibility. Similar monopolies are with Google, Facebook, Microsoft...

  • @60-second-HACKS
    @60-second-HACKS Před 20 dny

    How about a share swap with Bytedance?

  • @freedonuts5600
    @freedonuts5600 Před 24 dny

    That’s like saying stores at Disneyland is an illegal monopoly

  • @srmutnuri
    @srmutnuri Před 25 dny

    Sherman, 42 Wallaby Way, Sydney

  • @aegisofhonor
    @aegisofhonor Před 24 dny

    iOS on non-apple made products sounds like a good idea.

  • @michellenarkis
    @michellenarkis Před 25 dny +1

    One of the facts I’ve choose Apple over any Google phone is how they handle the third party software on their phones. That level of security can’t be achieved otherwise, I’m afraid. And of course, they are actually well made. Now in terms of pricing, yeah Apple take a bit too much the goblin side.

    • @mitchellscheer677
      @mitchellscheer677 Před 25 dny

      You're paying a higher price for the perceived benefits you just mentioned, one of the key principles of product specialization and price discrimination (both of which benefit consumers). The markup Apple sets on its product is still within your willingness to pay based upon the benefits you perceive from said product. It seems the DOJ wants to force Apple to be like every other major tech company, which absolutely harms consumers who are seeking that perceived superiority in privacy and security and are willing to pay for such.

  • @YassineSouilmi
    @YassineSouilmi Před 25 dny

    How super apps improve security and privacy?

  • @agusbrand
    @agusbrand Před 24 dny

    Agree 100% that's why I never used apple in my life

  • @weclock
    @weclock Před 25 dny

    You really had to tuck that "if the DOJ is right, then it's a real win for consumers" at the very end huh.

  • @TTOS69
    @TTOS69 Před 24 dny +1

    3:50 i just realized why theyre doing this. They all have Iphones (congress etc) and they cant do alot of what Android users can do. So theyre just gonna take the whole company down instead of making a law... Which is a waste of time too. More " im rich I should get what i want"

  • @darbyallenshea3826
    @darbyallenshea3826 Před 24 dny

    Closing comment was bs

  • @g8672
    @g8672 Před 23 dny

    03:05, what? You ALLEGE?
    For god sake, you are the one (DOJ) suing apple. You should not use those kind of words here.

  • @MV-un3jt
    @MV-un3jt Před 12 dny

    If apple used RCS for their phone, that would likely break down some of their monopoly.

  • @NeerajKumar-ld8ht
    @NeerajKumar-ld8ht Před 25 dny +1

    Instead we should say Apple is more popular because of its best product and service. And that comes at an investment which for some may seem more than others but if you consciously decide to find out whether it is more or not then you will find that you are getting best of everything and it’s an optimal combination of every good aspect of technology, service and price.

    • @h.mandelene3279
      @h.mandelene3279 Před 25 dny +1

      Definitely not the best product. My wife asks to use my phone all the time as her iphone either page doesn't open or takes forever even though we use the same network. This is not the first iphone or provider that does this.

    • @terry_the_terrible
      @terry_the_terrible Před 25 dny +1

      Apple no longer has the best hardware. It doesn't even have folding screens or 24h batteries. Even its charging time is disappointing compared to the competition.
      Plus Apple bases its whole strategy on the fact that you have to change your phone and all its accessories every 2 years. They literally want you to sell your phone and buy a new one and have heavily engineered their products to be unrepairable except by their approved technicians and these guys rip you off! Their solution is almost always to buy a new one

  • @BoRerunn
    @BoRerunn Před 25 dny +1

    I own an iphone and my Android phone is my backup phone

  • @skywalkerjediknight2024
    @skywalkerjediknight2024 Před 6 dny +1

    This was funny when a woman picking up the two iPhones in her hand to see which one is better and they both look the same 🎉🎉

  • @aghilannathan8169
    @aghilannathan8169 Před 24 dny

    If Apple a monopoly, then isn’t NVIDIA?

  • @txbre8758
    @txbre8758 Před 19 dny

    I 100% agree that Apple is a monopoly and I’m pro free market. They make it completely impossible to compete and to even integrate with them without a hefty hefty fee

  • @kirankumargudipudi
    @kirankumargudipudi Před 25 dny

    Answer this question, i bought an iPhone, i dont want to see ad through out my phone. Example, when opening an app, browsing etc. I can do this in Mac, windows laptop, Android phone by installing a VPN that i TRUST and it's my choice. Its my iPhone and nor yours anymore once i bought it. Why are you controlling my phone and telling me how to use?
    What do you call this?

  • @IYT786
    @IYT786 Před 23 dny

    Same as google and amazon

  • @duran9664
    @duran9664 Před 25 dny +22

    🚩Trump: I’m no puppet.
    🚩Cook: There’s no monopoly here.
    🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

    • @FighterFlash
      @FighterFlash Před 25 dny

      Russia agrees with you

    • @_NCO
      @_NCO Před 25 dny +4

      Biden: I'm fit for office!
      *continues to fall, stumble, forget and fail to form a understandable sentence, walks away confused not knowing what is going on in the world*
      Olaf Scholz: I'M NO WARMONGER!!!!
      *continues to send Ammo, Rockets and Tanks to Ukraine*

  • @djstanley1300
    @djstanley1300 Před 24 dny

    “Apple’s” smh

  • @Theoryofcatsndogs
    @Theoryofcatsndogs Před 24 dny

    What Apple did is no different than many other systems, Like Point of Sale (POS), car or even how government works. You can't expect to change a POS system without new terminal from the same company. You can't install Tesla's OS on your BMW. You can't change your water supplier even you are not happy with the water quality. I don't see US/EU have problems with these issue.

  • @williamlee7782
    @williamlee7782 Před 25 dny +6

    Apple was warned from the same agency that if they encrypted iCloud, it would not be good. Apple encrypted iCloud. I wonder if there's a correlation.

    • @martins.2502
      @martins.2502 Před 24 dny

      You're suggesting the DOJ is retaliating against Apple because it refused to create a backdoor in its products. Something that not even Apple has suggested. Please provide proof to support your accusation

  • @dragoonzen
    @dragoonzen Před 25 dny +1

    Need a apple charger as no other chargers work on iPhone... Android user can't see clear video sent from phone to phone...

  • @retz79
    @retz79 Před 25 dny

    Not happening

  • @michaelpabon4480
    @michaelpabon4480 Před 24 dny

    Why are my utility providers allowed monopolies?? Electricity, Internet Service, Gas

    • @taukid421
      @taukid421 Před 12 dny

      That's because they're natural monopolies (if you don't know, google it) but to counter act that, they are regulated as utilities. (Not that the regulations are enough)

  • @rwaxzy
    @rwaxzy Před 25 dny +40

    Can someone break this down for me?
    How is there a monopoly? I am free to buy whatever phone I want, and if I want to switch from Apple to Samsung, I am free to do so?
    If I have bought several Apple products and "locked" my self in the Apple environment, that's my solely my fault and not Apples' fault? The same would go for Samsung, if I wanted to switch to Apple? Or am I missing something?

    • @heyaisdabomb
      @heyaisdabomb Před 25 dny +9

      The claim is that because some apple devices like the apple watch can only be used with an iPhone, that makes them "monopolistic". Creating their own messaging protocol instead of using Andriods messaging protocol makes them "monopolistic". Basically, you have to create software to place nice with all of your competition, or your breaking the law according to the DOJ. It's pretty wild. I know what I was getting into when I bought apple products.

    • @cane870
      @cane870 Před 25 dny +19

      @@heyaisdabombapple does a lot of sleazy stuff. I would rather see the DOJ go after their anti repair practices. That is actually illegal.

    • @rodrigo445678
      @rodrigo445678 Před 25 dny

      There is no monopoly but Biden needs votes.

    • @rodrigo445678
      @rodrigo445678 Před 25 dny +4

      @@cane870 Yeah, but monopoly is a far cry. No tech company is a real monopoly, they are all subject to disruption, specially in the age of AI.

    • @TheObserver__
      @TheObserver__ Před 25 dny +3

      "android's messaging protocol", you don't know what you are talking about.

  • @paddydoran1234
    @paddydoran1234 Před 24 dny

    The DOJ are being very foolish here. There are many other Smartphones competing against Apple. Just because it has become the popular or defacto phone in the US doesn't mean its a monopoly.

  • @ArchThaBoss
    @ArchThaBoss Před 25 dny

    I’m as against monopolies as can be. I disagree with a lot of things Apple does and it could stand to change some things. But Apple isn’t a monopoly in the sense that there’s no competition. There’s plenty of competition, people in the USA just prefer iPhones over other phones. The seamless vertical integration is one of the reasons. Apple is far behind their competition is almost all aspects. But when they reveal a product or a feature that’s been on the market for years as new people just buy into it. You can’t disband a company because it’s more popular than its competition. Change to rcs messaging, allow other app stores, make self repair more accessible and some other things I can’t think of but don’t break the company up for simply being more successful than their competitors

  • @ozlemelih
    @ozlemelih Před 24 dny

    It's as Monopoly as it gets

  • @asterixky
    @asterixky Před 22 dny +1

    An easy case to build, just follow what the EU did.

  • @juanaguilar58
    @juanaguilar58 Před 19 dny

    Watching this on an iPhone

  • @DylannDayZero
    @DylannDayZero Před 25 dny

    What about Google and Microsoft tho?????

  • @mack-uv6gn
    @mack-uv6gn Před 25 dny

    I’m 50/50 on this case. The oxygen sensor case does make Apple look anticompetitive but it only has a strong market share in the states when it comes to smart phones.

  • @Max-nt7ho
    @Max-nt7ho Před 20 dny

    Have the gov’t ever thought that Apple’s large market share is due to consumers’ preference? I like Apple products and I agree that its closed system does provide better security. From what I heard, most often than not, security breach happened with 3rd parties.

  • @danielating1316
    @danielating1316 Před 25 dny

    So laws from the 19th century are still valid?

  • @frankwangofficial
    @frankwangofficial Před 24 dny +6

    imagine being so good at something that congress want to shut you down.

    • @brockjohnson100
      @brockjohnson100 Před 23 dny

      Politicians are the lowest quality “professionals” out there

    • @YasinHasan
      @YasinHasan Před 20 dny +1

      what r they good at? every of their tech is knock off from other companies

    • @frankwangofficial
      @frankwangofficial Před 20 dny

      @@YasinHasan making cohesive and smooth functioning ecosystem for one. Their devices have unparalleled polish.

    • @YasinHasan
      @YasinHasan Před 20 dny +1

      @@frankwangofficial "unparalleled" 🤣i have better ecosystem between windows & android 😂

    • @frankwangofficial
      @frankwangofficial Před 20 dny

      @@YasinHasan ok bud

  • @racksofish
    @racksofish Před 25 dny

    I definitely prefer an iPhone because of the safety and security of the software compared to an android phone, I don’t know why but whenever I got an android phone it didn’t feel like more than half a year before it was slowing down and had bugs and problems. I don’t feel trapped with iphone, I definitely just prefer it

    • @theOGsultan
      @theOGsultan Před 25 dny

      Which is a minor inconvenience for living with a transparent and open source ecosystem

  • @kleenbeats
    @kleenbeats Před 25 dny +1

    I don’t need some government to decide what tech I choose to use!
    The free market should decide value, not a collective of overly empowered administrators (go build some roads you schmucks!)

  • @loveguitar2x
    @loveguitar2x Před 25 dny

    The DOJ 😂

  • @uwize5897
    @uwize5897 Před 25 dny

    watching this on youtube is hilarious