Hunter REACTS to Red Dead Redemption 2 | Experts React
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 07. 2024
- Introducing expert hunter Tim ‘Spike’ Davis and what better game to welcome him with than Red Dead Redemption 2! Tim walks us through how simply unrealistic hunting in-game is and how wasteful Arthur Morgan is with resources such as meat, feathers, bones, and even bladders. Learn how to navigate animals you're stalking, track blood trails in the snow and never cross an icy river as it’s potentially more dangerous than a grizzly bear! Did you enjoy Tim’s commentary and expertise?
The action-adventure game Red Dead Redemption 2 takes place in a Western-themed setting. In the game, players explore a fictionalized version of the Western, Midwestern, and Southern United States in the late 1800s, during the wild period of the Wild West. The player controls Arthur Morgan of the Van der Linde gang, a member of the outlaw gang, as he completes numerous missions to advance the plot.
#RedDeadRedemption2 #Hunter #ExpertsReact
--------------------
Tim ‘Spike’ Davis:
timspikedav...
www.scatteredthoughtscartoons...
--------------------
0:00 - Intro
0:48 - Hunting a Black Bear
2:27 - Hunting a Wild Boar
2:54 - Hunting a Western Raven
3:39 - Hunting a Bull Elk
5:19 - Hunting a Coyote
6:32 - Hunting a Wild Boar that's eating a dead animal
7:14 - Hunting a Raccoon and a Turkey
7:55 - Hunting a Grizzly Bear
10:02 - Hunting a Cow Elk
10:53 - Hunting a Moose
12:08 - Hunting Rabbits on Horseback
12:54- Hunting a White-tailed Buck
14:10 - Hunting a Bighorn Sheep
--------------------
Check out some of our past videos!
ER Doctor REACTS to Red Dead Redemption 2 | Experts React
• ER Doctor REACTS to Re...
Spec Ops REACT to Call of Duty: Modern Warfare - Night Missions Campaign | Experts React
• Spec Ops REACT to Call...
--------------------
Thanks to Swifty Unknown for the gameplay:
/ swiftylovesyou
--------------------
Up In My Jam (All Of A Sudden) by - Kubbi / kubbi
Creative Commons - Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported- CC BY-SA 3.0
Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/2JnDfCE
Music promoted by Audio Library • Up In My Jam (All Of A...
--------------------
Stay in the loop with us on social media!
Facebook: / thebestofgaming1
Instagram: gamology?h...
Twitter: / gamologyus - Hry
He looks like how you would imagine a hunter looks like.
yup
he looks like the one in clash royal
Talks like one too
Somewhat burly man with an accent and a beard bigger than his head... Checks out.
Bro i started watching “Seven Hunnid” on CZcams & my whole outlook on life dramatically changed… I don’t think i can go back 😔😔
The growing annoyance the hunter felt at John (my bad) leaving the meat was strong: loved the combination of his low voice (he never raised it), and his clear annoyance.
I thought it was John lol
@@nikotylers4652 I honestly have no idea 😅
@@Morster it was John
I always feel it too.
It's dumb too cause Rockstar could have added some kind of mechanic to haul the animal away instead of just leaving it because "it's too big".
Gamers: “Arthur Morgan is probably the most heartfelt and beautiful character in a game ever written...”
Hunter: “Left behind good bear meat and elk bladder... Douchebag...”
@Ap i wanna watch you sleep
It’s me, actually
@@aplaystationcontroller7814 jim milton?
@@nlrenzo9432 howdy partner, just came back from Mexico, some dumbass called my son said I died and blamed it on Ross, I just faked my death and left to enjoy life with my mistress Karen
@@aplaystationcontroller7814 wow, I’m tellin’ Abigail.
Dude this guy is hilarious, with his increasing frustration at John leaving the meat. Please, don't be afraid to bring him back on, it's refreshing to hear his honesty, and it's what I'd expect to hear from a hunter that respects nature.
All the waste with the hunting is the worst part of the game for me. You take a pelt and maybe a trophy. I mean, granted the game only gives you a pair of horses at best, but that’s just rockstar’s screw up IMO. They PUT a hunting wagon in the multiplayer, why not single player?
You take the meat and fat with you. These are just animations
@@dickdiamonds3410 you don’t take much though. The game limits how much meat and fat you get for balance reasons and there’s a lot of materials that never come into play at all.
@oxydus they don't even need to animate it though, just have the meat disappear
Someone should tell him that he does take the meat R* just didn't animate it
“This red dead redemption guy is kind of annoying he’s wasting a lot of meat” lol
A lot of neighbors could use that meat.
He's right. Back in the day there was no food in abundance like today.
And even if this guy has no neighbors he can sell the meat or could at least eat some of it himself in order to minimize the loss.
@@vulcanniko9242 LOL
@@danmarusan2878 is know he’s right that’s why it’s funny
I’ve always found it odd how they leave all that meat on the carcass
Love that this guy shows that your average hunter truly cares about the animal and that using a good humane shot is super important.
yeah i agree. reminds me of charles in a way, have to show respect to the animal
Ikr
Humanity is a big part of hunting people often forget
Also the game rewards you for more humane animal kills.
Most hunters are
People think hunters hate the environment but they're outdoorsmen. They care about the environment the same way mountaineers and campers do.
They just enjoy eating animals
“It’s interesting to me that he took the raven but not the full grown bear, not someone I would wanna go hunting with”😭😭
What?
@@schnauzerbro i've never played the game, can you butcher the animals? I would think such a game would be stupid if they forced you to leave meat on game animals
@@shakaama if you set up camp you can cook the carcass.
@@shakaama yeah you get the meat when you skin them it just doesn’t show it
@@shakaama there's no animation for it but the meat gets added to your inventory
Me: I love the hunting in RDR2, it's so realistic.
Real hunter: It's dumb
Realistic for a game? Yes
Its still a better hunting game than most actual hunting games out there lol. The open world of it also adds a lot to it. Considering how big the game is and that this is only a fraction of what you're actually able to do it's understandable. Although online mode does allow you to get wagons to haul your kills in.
@@MrSirGiuseppe call of the wild is more realistic
@@Tyler_lewis_2008 Yeah for the most part, except you can’t skin or eat the animals.
In fact, every time you skin, you take some meat, which I think is a big game(its name), and that you can take the skinned animals for their meat, provided that you can carry the corpse with a horse, and another thing is that in Red Dead, basically with You play horses that have very very high prices in reality, Turkmen, Arabian horses, etc. Briefly they are not ordinary horses at all.
What's funny is that hunters like him are some of the biggest environmentalists, the way he talks he cares about the animals not suffering
there is a difference between hunters and poachers.
Hunters take extreme care when in the wilderness. And they have to. If they destroy their hunting grounds that only harms not only them but the entire ecosystem.
Poachers hunt not caring about the area. They would destroy it if it meant catching their game.
Its a difference between long term and short term practice.
My mom, in all her years of hunting, had one rule. "If I can't guarantee a kill in one shot, I do not take the shot". Nothing is more heartbreaking for a hunter than an animal suffering needlessly. My mom's still tough as nails and has unprecedented integrity for someone over 70. A lot of other boomers I've met have been notoriously selfish or arrogant.
He'd probably object heavily to hunting some of the legendaries. An albino gator? That sounds like something SO not cool to hunt to extinction
Yup, conservationism is a thing.
a good hunter understands that if you fuck up the ecosystem of an area, you can't hunt there anymore.
take care of the land, and it'll take care of you.
"very disrespectful for the animals"
Me: he's right, you know.
But I don't think animal will be bothered by respect you know
He ain't playing GTA San Andreas
@Exel megapixel that guy you're trying to correct, probably "respect" in GTA San Andreas. For example, Mission Passed, Respect+
It's possible he was joking and it went over your head by taking him too seriously. Or maybe he's taking it too seriously, or maybe I am.
Either way I wish we could take the whole bear, but that would be too for the developers, it may have been in there at some point during development.
@Exel megapixel possible r/wooosh?
Why the fuck I don't get liked after putting efforts too...
To be fair, some animals in the game are too heavy for most people to carry and Arthur and John don’t exactly own wagons that’re meant to carry them.
This is the kind of guy that represents the hunting community so well. He can speak of behalf of me and others like me any day of the week.
I think he’s annoying. He is talking bad about the player because he thought the player was wasting, even though that’s all you can do.
@@maddawg5016 It's an emphasis on what is called 'Want and Waste' which is an illegal act. Even though its a game, I would have made the same comment.
@@chris.3711 yeah but the thing is, you actually do take the meat into your inventory. There just isn’t an animation for it. I wish they would’ve told the guy.
@@maddawg5016 Hes speaking from knowledge and practicality. As far as he knows, the animals are being wasted. So its only natural he feels the player is disrespecting animals
Yeah but it's a game bro.
At 14:52 Spike mentions how impressed he is to see John lift a 150 lb. sheep over his shoulder, commenting that he would have some lower back pain had he done that.
Doesn't he mean he'd have Lumbago?
We've found out how uncle got LUMBAGO!
He actually looks a lot like uncle tbf.
Don't make fun of that disease, it's a slow and painful death, my brother.
@@patriciajin6206 'Is very serious!'
Lumbago is a serious injury of a shot not lower back pain just saying
I love how moral he is. He feels sympathy for every animal killed whether for arbitrary reasons or hunting exactly
morality doesnt exist
@@visceraeyes525 You 13?
@@visceraeyes525 Many people say that as an excuse to be complete douchebags. Don't act surprised if you ever get punched in the face.
@@SD_yessir and? look at what happened to jesus? morality means nothing
@@visceraeyes525 Not really sure what Jesus has to do with any of this, but people who declare that "morality doesn't exist" are often people who act like assholes to everyone they meet, but suddenly start contradicting their own beliefs if they get a taste of their own medicine. You'll open your eyes when you're older, or when your parents force you to move out and get a place of your own.
Get this guy back on, he's awesome.
Good old sly, been subscribed to your channel for years
@@gamelover1779 Thanks so much man.
really enjoyed the professional commentary! Some of these things I haven't considered before while playing, it was good to have a better perspective. So I really agree this guy is awesome, get him back on for other games. It would be good to hear from him.
czcams.com/video/ObOJfXAi_qg/video.html
yoo its sly
When I turned 14, I got my hunting license. Day 3 of my first hunting trip my uncle took me out to find a deer. We found a elk with nothing taken but the horns, no tag meant it was poached. I know the frustration of seeing wasted animals, then again with RDR2 you get the important stuff even if it doesn't show in game.
Grew up in NE Pennsylvania. never hunted but there is a big hunting culture there. the only time I saw a hunter pissed off was if they caught someone being careless or sloppy, or someone trapped the animal, or used an illegal or inhumane device. I find it funny reading the comments people saying "hunters should be like Tim here" when most hunters are exactly like that.
@@kingrichardiii6280 Or the other year when those kids abused that deer... Still can't believe that one only got a slap on the wrist because his daddy's connected.
Never hunted had family back in my home state up north that was all about that life. Not sure if I’d have the guts to actually do it and go through the whole process but it always fascinated me.
I read that wrong thought you said everything taken beside the horns lol. Regardless thats upsetting to hear
In my state if you report a poacher you get extra points for the next draw
It would be cool if Rockstar adds this guy in RDR3 as a side quest mission to teach you how to hunt and use every meat of the animal
It would be him just insulting you the whole time lol
Rockstar won’t do that because they said that they won’t work on red dead redemption anymore
@@maricelameza9104 They wont make another RDR series for a few more years (possibly until 2026) but they didnt say they wont make another RDR anymore.
@@midnitesky71 I feel like most people that has watched this video at least would love it
That mans beard is yelling "I hunt deer and drive John Deer and chug a 6 pack of beer"
Murica
BARS
nah nvm, he looks like a nice man who supports his family and strives for good in all areas of life
or he is a demon wearing human skin or an alien wearing skin
hopefully he isnt hungry for human meat
this is what a real hunter should be, caring and respectful to the wildlife. Hope to see more videos of him
that is how real hunters are. best way to piss a hunter off is to be sloppy and cut corners. Grew up in NE Pennsylvania where there is a big hunting and fishing culture. they hit the animal and it runs off they will stop at nothing to track it and make sure it is finished off humanely.
This is what most hunters are like dawg, unless it's a younger dude most are usually very respectful
@@kingrichardiii6280 From all of the hunters I know, shooting an animal and not being able to track it down is devastating. They all feel guilt, and shame for either crippling it, or killing it and having it go to waste.
@@hole-sawbear1500 one time in high school one of the students came back from the hunting season in a bad mood. he found on his hunting trip an abandoned deer. but he also told everyone the arrow used was not meant for deer hunting and knew it suffered. the depth of respect to wildlife from hunters, I think, is unnoticed or unappreciated for the most part. and the reason i think this is because another year around hunting season one of the teachers read a snip it from the opinions column in the paper. a visitor was angry saying "shame on the hunters for harming the local wildlife. if they are hungry go to the store like everyone else".
@@kingrichardiii6280 Yeah, couldn't agree more. The decision to take responsibility for your food is not one done out of malice towards animals. It's usually one made from love. You put in the work to butcher it, you put in the work to line up a clean shot, you put in the work to pack it out. By the end, you think about every yard you had to drag it, every hour you spent cutting meat, and you have gratitude and respect for that animal every time you take a bite. Most people will never experience it, but food tastes better when you killed/grew it yourself.
OMg I love this
13:23 😭😂 omg his dry humour has me cracking up
14:25 OMG 80 gal of blood. MAN this guy is a riot 😂
Indeed
Weird finding you here
Hey Alt
I'm a big fan
Surprised that this comment isn't at the top lol.
I know that in the game you actually do harvest more than just the pelts, but I was always annoyed at the aesthetic of carcasses being left lying around the world. Even though I knew there was no waste, it felt that way 😂
@@PaganMin671 it's not worth it tho. I don't want to travel to the butcher or trapper EVERYTIME I kill a deer for meat.
@@PaganMin671 yeah but it depends on the location you're hunting at. Anywhere near the camp or near the butcher/trapper is doable and realistic. But if you're in the mountains near Colter like I am, it's not worth it.
@@PaganMin671 I'm hunting for meat and pelts. The hunting in this game is fun.
@@Bardock7500x actually you can cook too but not all animals
I thoroughly enjoyed this. Spike was really cool, please have him on again. I know literally nothing about hunting, but I really dug his personality.
@SharkTank someone certainly didn't have their morning coffee lol
@SharkTank shut up
@SharkTank Who ate your food
Well I hope you take an interest in hunting someday 💜 Ignore the SharkTank troll. His parents should have taken him in the woods "Hunting" for a bear and left him. 😂 I'm Glad you liked spiked, I did aswell 💜 he seems like a hunter I would love to go Deer Hunting with 💜 if you'd like to learn more about hunting there are sportsmans clubs and game commissioners all over the US that would gladly teach a new hunter or point you in the right direction 💜 hope you have a great day/night 🙏💜🇺🇸
@@richmarkov8863 I would absolutely love to go hunting in the US but for now I should probably work on my marksmanship first. I can't hit the broadside of a barn from the inside
His initial reaction is exactly why I wish we could drag or cart large carcasses, even with how immersive the game is I just wish you could use more of the animals.
Hell yeah. Not just the meat, but the bones, sinews/tendons, organs, etc.
And not just for selling or giving to the camp cook, but for using as materials for upgrades. Imagine being able to increase the draw strength of your bow if you have enough and the right kind of tendons, sinews, or intestines for the bow strings.
@@Foxxie0kun well i guess its easier said then done. Thats alot of work. but considering how much money and man power go into these games i wish they'd actually do this kinda thing. Especially for a game like red dead redemption 2. Like hunting is a huge part of the game. This game was really disappointing in general tbh. i bet gta 6 will be the same...
You can drag deer and smaller animals on horseback in game
You can actually use 2 horses and bring back medium and small animals
Tbh the game does give you the option to pick up the carcass instead of skinning the animal on the spot except for the large animals like bear,elk etc. It does make sense why Arthur cannot use all the meat on bear. Even if he able to bring a large wagon how he's gonna lift the bear by himself? lmao. It is reaslistic if you controlling a lone outlaw on horseback
“That’s a great way to break your horses leg… but I guess this guy cares about his horse as much as he cares about those skinned animals”
Had me cracking up 😂
I Love that he is honest and not afraid to go against other people's love for this GAME.
Arthur and John actually DO take the meat from their kills. The game only shows a quick skinning animation instead of the whole butchering process. But the meat is still added to your inventory.
There's even a side mission you can do where Arthur and Charles find and kill some poachers who were shooting bison and leaving the carcasses to rot.
Yeah but when you shoot a deer irl you use every ounce of meat down to the bone
@@fletcherpeterson1650 it’s just the animation the channel did a bad job explaining to him you get a lot of stuff from the animal it just shows more than there really is
He's talking about a game he doesn't play, so yeah, this is stupid
@@fletcherpeterson1650 its also only the large game you don't take all of. Simply because your horse can't carry the 800lb carcass of a Buffalo
I spared the other guy
Im glad you found a true hunter that respects his kills and doesn't let them go to waste instead of someone that does it for "sport."
Yeah we call people like that poachers and we like them less than PETA do
I hunt for meat and the sport.
He's a true hunter that respects his game, that's why he's such a good sport.
@Foggy You will never understand it unless you do it yourself, which you haven't done. It can be one of the most challenging outdoor activities, there's plenty of physical effort, it's highly methodical, requires a lot of shooting practice, etc... definitely can be seen as a sport. I don't know what the hell you mean by "equally matched" and what a "true challenge" is, according to you, an extremely fit individual, I assume.
@@eduardobenassi3072 they probably mean if they are hunting for sport they want to be in just as much danger as their prey is so for example a grizzly bear would have a higher fighting chance than a buck, but if they were hunting for food or materials they would gladly kill a buck or other passive game animals.
This past deer season, there were some active duty military guys hunting at my grandpa's buddy's place. Grandpa went to see how the hunting was and noticed one of the deer they had strung up didn't have a bullet wound.. Anywhere... Turns out one the active military guys lept out of the tree stand with his knife in hand, landed on the back of the deer, reached over and slit its throat. Never heard anything like that, I couldn't believe what I was being told.
we had a guy who kinda spent a little too long out in the mountains and had turned a little squirrely; he said that he would put deer pee on his chest in a ghillie suit and then knife a buck when it came up to sniff, same dude chased a mountain lion into a hole in the ground.
Can't really confirm the deer stuff, but when we walked up on, him ass in the air, pulling that lion out of the hole... everything he ever said that was outlandish seemed more believable.
Dang that dude had some issues to take out! That deer was in the wrong place at the wrong time 😂
What I love the most about hunters is how resourceful they are, they're like, 'If I'm gonna take this life the whole being will go to good use.'
Well... Now it feels like you have to have him react to theHunter: Call of the Wild.
Hell yeah!
They just got a new map too
@@simpled5755 yea I think it's Mexico.
@@simpled5755 Rancho del Arroyo I thinks it's been on PC for a bit but dropped not long ago on console
100% this!
Fortunately, you DO take the meat, but the skinning animations are long enough already and they don't want to bother making meatless as well as skinless models for the games. You definitely DO get a lot of meat off of whatever you kill, but probably not enough for the size of some of them...
Should've showed him what you actually get from the animal not just the animation
suppose they coulda left a vague shape, maybe w/ blood, indentation in the ground, specially the snow, or otherwise just had the carcass disappear when you're done.
@@cobraglatiator Assassin's Creed 3 did that.
They should've left the skinning animation then added a fade to black, showing that the whole carcass has been harvested.
@@WatamelonGod ah, i see. yea.
its true! and yes they should have showed it @gamology
I love this guy! He really represents us hunters as environmentalists and conservationists. Take care of the land, and it will take care of all those who live on it. If you can't drop it in one shot, then don't shoot it. And.... never take more than you need, take enough for yourself and your neighbor if they don't have a means to hunt
Those reactions are hilarious 😂. Great job
He's got a southern accent.
Yep, I trust him
yep america fuck yeah
*the south is gonna rise up again begins playing in the backround*
👌🏻
@@Aptezo racist
Well I'd say what could go wrong but then I would be an idiot for even bothering
“Guess who’s not a very good neighbor” 😂 I like this guy
80th like
14:43 He is amazed about how Arthur can carry a giant bighorn sheep on his shoulder. And he didn't even see Chapter 6 Arthur with TB doing the exact thing.
Also, now we know how Uncle got his *lumbago* xD
This fellow hunter commenting on the various hunting aspects in RDR2 was truly a blast to listen to I laughed my ass off on most of his comments. Thanks for this upload and I tip my hat off to you ole timer !
"If he leaves the deer he's a douchebag!"
John Marston has been called worst in his game career. Lol
Isn't that aurther
@@firstlast-qe9sx brown hair = Arthur
Black hair = John
a yes
the golden boy
Little Johnny marston
The Swimmer
The Cow Milker
Cockroach
Scarface
The Runoff
and many many more.
@@szelski. and also "P U T O" by Javier in rdr1
Uncle's been growing his beard.
Lol
I wish i had a beard that long i would be a sugar daddy
Uncle cured his lumbago and became a grizzled hunter
@@iandragooo 14:52 maybe not
Uncle wouldn't look this cool
This the typa guy you'd see hunting and he'd hit you with the "lovely day Huh son!"
His commentary was so awesome and very descriptive
Gods I love this guy's humour. Can we have him back?
Yes please!
Do it!
It's the first day guys- I'm sure they at least prerecorded some videos
...what humor?
@@Kawayolnyo for real, he's cool I guess but I don't see much of any humour
in context of the game while it may not look it the character IS gathering the meat. it was probably easier to leave the carcass looking like it's only been skinned instead of partial skeletal. theory only i don't work for rockstar lol
It wouldn't have been too much more work to add a second "processing" stage where he takes some time to carve up some of the meat. Heck, even the bones, tendons, organs, etc. are useful in some kinds of crafting, so you could sell or use the skeleton and tendons for equipment upgrades at camp.
@@Foxxie0kun Yep. It was done for AC3 and it felt very satisfying, leaving only bones and guts.
@@Foxxie0kun AFAIK, changing the animation skin from pelt to muscle would take little effort, but animating a carcass would require a whole new base model!
@@edi9892 it looks like the animal model is just its carcass with skin draped over it. So it doesn't need to have a separate rig to animate the carcass. *Its already rigged up.*
Unless you mean the *skinning animation*. In which case, it would double the work needed. But not as much as you think.
Many animals in the game share the *exact same* skinning animations due to having similar body types.
Deer, pronghorn, wolf, fox, coyote, and boar have the same skinning animation, for example. The obly real difference is whether something is taken from other bosy parts, like a wolf getting _something_ taken from its head. Its basically a tacked on addition with no real modeling. So they should just share the same "butchering" animation.
Off the top of my head the skinning animations are:
1 Snake
2 Bird feathers
3 Bird meat
4 Raccoon, iguana, opossum, rabbit
5 Wolf, coyote, fox, deer, pronghorn, boar
6 Elk, moose
7 alligator
8 Bear
But for the sake of simplification, I'll remove the Bird meat animation so it'll be replaced by Bird butchering animation.
So that's 7 skinning animations, which means only 7 butchering animations are needed. Not 200 for the 200 species the game has.
I think me and a lot of others would love to see him come back to this channel he was really entertaining to watch
Great guy with some cool stuff to share, I'd like see him again in future videos
Hunters are the some of the biggest advocates of animal conservation, and there's an unspoken bond between a huntsman and his game
Hunting is very important to ecosystems, in my state hunting had dropped to an all time low so our deer population was through the roof, well it didn't take long for a serious disease to start spreading, our state conservation department asked hunters to kill any and all sick looking deer.
@@theshizl4400 yeah it was. It was a bad few hunting seasons there was this huge buck up where we were hunting so we all wanted to bag him. A few days before the season started we saw him walking real lethargic so we just put him down and called the conservation department.
If I remember they also let people shoot 2 extra deer when all this was happening just to knock their numbers down again.
Man I love this guy, someone show him there is a guy in the game called Hamish Sinclair that looks just like him XD. Maybe react to his story line, the 4 dedicated hunting missions i think would be awesome as they had good plot and more realistic take.
What like the legendary bear mission where ever spammed there shotgun whit deadeye into it's forehead lol
@@jamespeech9141 no, that was with Hosea early on.
@@jamespeech9141 its a side mission its quite good one of the best in the game
@@satwikmahapatra9079 have him react to the Aberdeen pig farm 😂
this is the best Experts React series. would love to watch this guy play call of the wild or any hunting game
0:29 Good to see a fellow Hawks fan hunter.
Dudes beard is legendary
As a hunter and a gamer I loved this. I also love that I haven’t seen anyone complain about how hunting is “inhumane”. It’s all about respect for the animal.
Gamers appreciate life more despite being mostly introverts and stay at home folks. Karen’s and “vegans” are ppl who appreciate life a lot less and take it out on ppl
Well yeah this is set in the old west this hunting is useful
@@marcusbrown188 if you’re talking about the loud internet vegans hungry for attention on the web, sure. They kind of falsely represent most vegans through. Many do it for health purposes and to balance the scales. Most I’ve met have tremendous respect for all life. It’s a shame the loudest of us tend to represent the rest. I feel bad for women named Karen 😂 (btw I’m far from vegan- just killed some carne asada fries 👌🏾)
@@abstraktmedia4138 oh yeah I luv me some carne asada, Caldo de siente del mares and birria tacos 🌮. I realize that people r much nicer in person and media and social media exaggerate what’s going on out there
@@marcusbrown188 totally. Really a strange phenomenon.
That was such a good video me and my hunting friends did have a laugh about how Arthur hunted
I'm not even all the way done with this video and it really strikes me how much this guy can find to comment on that I (as a non-hunter, obviously) would have never thought of. Don't shoot above the horizon, presumably because that means if you miss your bullet will keep going and going and going. What a simple and practical rule I'd never thought of
This man should of had his own character up in rdr2 😂😂😂
Yes
I’d like him to be a replacement for the trapper or just gus in online
Hamish Sinclair
He's Cripps
There is always online mode.
Would love to meet someone like that one day, he's probably a human encyclopedia when it comes to hunting and tracking. So much knowledge 🙌
And guns as well. He didn't talk about firearms much, but things he said are not well-known facts for general population.
I loved this guy. He was hilarious. His beard is also a BEAUTIFUL sight to behold
Lol! Dude not only hucks a long horn sheep over his shoulder, but he does it _one-handed!_
*Incredible!!* I thought his name was Arthur Morgan, not *Mariusz Pudzianowski?!*
I wished they would of hired this guy to do some hunting animations for RDR2, little details or maybe big details when hunting
I know! At least have him consult on how one can field dress a carcass to take as much of the animal away as possible, because I agree it does look like Arthur just takes the hide and antlers without any meat, but some of those animals are too big to put on your horse. The little details of taking big chunks of meat from various areas would go a long way to making the protagonist look like less of a jackass.
@SharkTank Calm yourself before you burst a blood vessel.
I don't think they really want more realism with hunting, RDR is already a slow game with a lot of actions to do and many people wouldn't be happy with longer and realistic skinning scenes.
I wanna see that technique for skinning a raccoon he said he made
@@keatonwastaken hunting in RDR2 already requires a substantial amount of time compared to the rest of the -poorly paced and synergized- game. Making the skinning animations longer, or ideally making a second and optional *butchering* animation, isn't going to make the game any longer.
I respect animals while hunting as well, as does arthur, he does take other parts of the animals, but im sure for animation purposes they kept it simple. The bear and other animals that stay there, actually give you meat, feathers, fat, claws, and more but it is just added to you inventory.
someone needs to show this guy some shots of someone actually collecting the entire animal.
God bless you sir and come back soon. Great commentary with useful info on hunting and survival 👌 got a good kick outta that reaction of lifting the sheep
This man has the manlyest beard on the earth
He's gotta groom that thing tho. I don't understand when guys grow big beards like that and then don't even take care of it.
@@DattMoss Following entropy doesn't need explaining. It's the energy required for order that does.
@@DattMoss he knows what he’s about
@@DattMoss He probably likes his beard.
@@lindaflores6326 Well yea, of course he does, same as the duck dynasty guys. It was just an opinion.
As a hunter myself (and an RDR2 player) I love that this comment section is actually full of people who understand that hunters cares about animals, and do more for wild animals than all the haters who sit at home thinking hunters are just out to murder animals for no good reason.
My uncle used to deer hunt (Bow hunting too, I believe) and I remember he'd always send us a lot of venison sausage if he had a good season. The meat always tasted fantastic too, which after watching this would seem to imply the animals didn't suffer needlessly or need to be run down (Not a lot of lactic acid).
It's not for me, personally, but I understand the need for it and as long as it's carried out ethically I don't have an issue with it. Honestly, meat you get from a hunter who respects the animal and makes sure it doesn't needlessly suffer is more ethically sourced than most of what you'll find at a deli in a supermarket.
@@Iris_1217 A good kill is a big part in the taste of the meat (Not wounding any intestines for example), but another part is properly taking care of the meat afterwards. It needs to be treated in a particular way to get the best result.
It's nice to hear you say that, as there are so many "animal friends" who hate hunters, because they have decided that they are in fact just murderers who hunt for sport and just enjoying killing. They don't understand that hunters do more for wild animals than they ever will sitting home eating vegetables, signing petitions and spouting on social media. I'm a hunter in Sweden, and in my opinion we have some of the most, if not the most ethical hunting in the world. Of course there are always rotten eggs, but we do everything possible to make sure the animal is taken care of in the proper way, and do not suffer.
@@getous I don't think a lot of people realize that when people do what they're supposed to, hunting helps the environment by managing certain species so that there's enough food to go around to support a healthy population. Deer, for instance, aren't exactly going to plan for the long term. If there are too many in one spot, they're going to end up burning out a lot of their food sources, and many are going to suffer painful deaths via starving or malnutrition.
@@Iris_1217 Yeah. Here, to get our hunting license, theres a mandatory course with a bunch of animal and nature theory followed by a test, before the weapon tests. That theory course should be a basic course of grade school, so everyone could learn what it's all about, and the balance of nature.
Never hunted myself, been interested in trying to Andrew uncles a deer were he catches one bare handed. huntings mostly illegal here unless it's foxes.
Also a Jorge( the German crossbow guy) fan and it's good to know they're against butchering a live animal.
Then again I suppose trying to grapple and knife anything would be crueler rather than giving them a quick death
This was my favourite "Expert Reacts" video.
14:44 The reaction of every hunter in the world during open season 🤣
I was actually more curious about what he'd think of the tracking process versus the main action of actually killing and harvesting the animal. I wish the showed him some of the actual story missions in the game where you hunt animals, or the legendary hunts. Also, I want him to know that I almost always took the meet back to camp.
I'm a hunter. Unfortunetly we do not have eagle eye in real life, tracking an animal can be quite difficult depending on the terrain and vegetation. If it's wounded it will be easier, but tracking an unwounded animal is very difficult unless you happend to be somewhere were the tracks are easily visible because of the terrain. I'm in Sweden, and we utilize dogs A LOT for our hunting, and they do most of the tracking, however I just got back from a moose hunt today and we were tracking a moose only a few hours ago.
@@getous I assumed you don't have special vision powers in real life. But the game does give you clues like droppings, tracks, and broken foliage ... there are entire mission based around tracking animals, and you can go hunting in the snow where animals leave extremely visible trails. I just wanted see this guy's take on those mechanics, and not just the act of shooting and skinning the animals
@@TheJadedJames Yes I was just joking about the vision ofc. Droppings really only tells you if it's fresh or not. Tracks in snow is very easy to see, however can be difficult to follow if you're on foot and not in skiis for instance. Tracks in the forest can be difficult the in non-snowy conditions unless its soft terrain. Broken foliage can give you signs that something has been there, but rarely if it's recent or not. Where we hunt for instance, we know the tracks the animals usually take. They have their set routes they always use, you can see a "path" through the woods from where they usually move, even if they haven't been there in a while.
@@TheJadedJames the mechanics are simple and pretty stupid. Use eagle eye and follow the white trail. And if you’re in a mission just use eagle eye and go to the gold dust. Hunting is hilariously unrealistic in this game. It is just a game of course but what’s funny is the people who play games for the “immersive experience” lmfao.
I love this guy's thinking, leaving so much of the animal behind is not only disgraceful but it's dumb because so much of said animal can be used.
it's also illegal in every state I'm aware of in the US, at least in today's day and age. The crime is usually called "Waste of Game" or something similar and has hefty penalties. People being anti hunting because they imagine trophy hunting and wasting meat is really common, but it's a complete straw man: you aren't allowed to hunt purely for the trophy, you are legally obligated to use the meat.
2:25 “very disrespectful to the animal”
*has a poster of a deer saying does my butt look big while being shot by an arrow*
Correction:
The character takes everything from the animal. It's just the animation that still shows the skinned animal laying there. It's probably for ease of not having to do the animal dissection animation. But you take the meat + parts and have them in your inventory.
To be fair he really doesn't take everything, I've always thought it was implied you just couldn't carry anymore and had no choice. If you take the carcass back to camp you can donate it and I think you might be able to do the same with a butcher or you can sell it at least. If you can donate or sell them there is definitely meat left, and if you stay around a carcass animals will come eat it too.
I think the whole legendary animal and crafted clothing thing was meant to take a long time. Like you were supposed to just hunt when necessary, instead of leaving carcasses everywhere lol. So you're left with the choice of taking your time or just running through everything, and making up for your sins later
@@MrSirGiuseppe Yeah he doesn't take everything but he takes more than the animation shows.
The animation basically depicts you just taking the pelt and that's it.
But if you were hunting (in that scenario) in real life you wouldn't be able to carry all of the meat realistically if you shoot a 300lbs pig or sth.
But then again, as you said, in real life you'd get a kill every couple of days/weeks maybe if you're going for big game, but the game obviously incentivises you to go on a killing spree.
The first thing in any game i like to do is upgrade my bags, and for that you need to complete the pouches..
Bruh! Right off the bat and spitting straight fact. “This is all great for video games but absolutely unrealistic.”
I’m so glad you see the entertainment value, lol.
I too do some hunting myself, and grew up around bear and elk hunters, do my share in helping, and a lot of stories I hear are quite extraordinary.
He sure does look like a nice neighbor to have, indeed. Also, can you imagine what would happen if the survivalist lady and Spike join forces and react to something?
I leave that tough on y'all :)
All and all, nice "Experts react" video Gameology and we hope to see Tim "Spike" Davis to return
@Gamology should consider doing this.
Kigna and Spike are a great combo after the spec ops guys and martial artists
I remembered thinking while lassoing deer “how does he avoid getting hit in the face with those antlers?” Lmao
I really liked this can u make more with this guy?
As an alaskan who has grown up reading tundra comics, yet sadly never having gone hunting myself, this was great entertainment and learning experience as well
I'm not a big hunter, but I dig this guy. He seems ethical and respectful like the types of hunters I enjoy buying meat from.
Ever have venison backstrap🤤🤤 just hits different🤷♂️
Most real hunters are this way and frown very heavily upon "sport" hunters, with the pejorative term "poachers" being used for them even if they're not what most people think of when the term poacher comes up.
“To leave the entire animal like that is a disgrace.” What is he gonna do? Stow it on his horse?
I must admit videos with this dude are the best
I love this beautiful mountain man. I would love to see more of him, he's like a teacher many people would call their favorite.
This might be my favorite episode yet. Felt like I was listening to a friend of my grandpa talk about the same thing.
Oh I love your cartoon sir. Never knew it was a real outdoorsman that drew them.
I feel like Hamish is teaching me how to hunt
I'd love to see this guy react to theHunter: Call of the Wild! That game definitely strives to make you feel like it's realistic, and I'd be interested to see how realistic it is
So I feel that I should mention that if Arthur had too much on the horses back, it won't let you put the rest of the animal on it. So more often than not, he'll just take the skin.
Really scummy thing to do and leave the rest of the animal like that... But then again, Arthur's a 'Bad Man'.
This is why I think being able to have a horse-drawn cart would have been good for realism/gameplay purposes, because fully processing the carcass and taking everything (Bones, tendons, sinews, organs, etc.) would be awesome, both for increasing the player's agency over the economy (Selling bones, sinews, and other animal parts to craftsmen and such), as well as equipment upgrades and maybe even side jobs.
I also think fully processing a carcass should provide "Honor" points, and leaving a partially-processed carcass should give "Dishonor" points.
@@Foxxie0kun that sounds amazing. RDR3?
@@Foxxie0kun it would make the game much more tedious tho, it was pretty long already so it's good as it is, as it's not an hunting simulator
@@omegacxv8344 Would be great. But they don't invest in singleplayer.
I find it incredible how many things he keeps in mind. I‘ve been in mountains multiple times and I never think about physical exertion. He though about the downwind and even the lactic acid inside the muscles of the animal. Truly impressive
I love the fact that in the example videos not once did they pick up the deer Corpses, which is also kind of important while hunting in Red Dead
Dude this guy had me cracking UP the whole video! 😂
The disdain in his voice is so palpable, you can tell the disappointment he has now after watching that.
Hope to see more videos from him.
Listening to him speak real about hunting shows a lot about how hunters think and I respect them a lot because it seems majority don’t like the animal to suffer much when hunting them down. I’d like to see him again and get some more reactions.
I had no idea how funny this would be. Lassoing the deer into a headlock had me rolling.
14:52 "I got lumbago john"
We need this man back, maybe have him react to the four hamish sinclair stranger missions or hunter simulator. IDK! But what I do know is that I need this man in my life! He's the best
He's rocking the beard for a Hunter..!
The knife you made for the hog hunt was nice and it seemed to work well for you with the hog.
1st time ever seeing a real life hunter rage over a fictional character leaving good meat behind 😂 this was great!
"If he leaves that meat on there this guy is a douche bag". I love it.
I like this guy, I’d love to see more of him.
I love how he noticed shooting over the horizon being a terrible idea. Definitely a great hunter.
Sadly with the bear you can only pick up the pelt, it won’t let you do anything else so that’s why he left it
I like this guy already, I'd do hunting with him any day of the week, more of him please.
Spike entirely forgot that it's a videogame, he's seriously coaching John on how to use his hunted game better.
This is hilarious.
He didn’t realize with the boar they were using dead eye slowing down time
14:43 That's exactly my reaction the first time I saw in RDR2 picking up hunt like that😂HIS FACE!😂