Ranking 1989 (Taylor's Version) AND Fixing the Tracklist 😲 *CONTROVERSIAL*
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 11. 2023
- Right now, the first 500 people to use my link will get a one-month free trial of Skillshare! skl.sh/swiftologist11231
well well well, here we are again...back with one of your favorite video formats!! I rank the 1989 (taylor's version) re-recordings based on their closeness to the original versions & then I reshuffle the tracklist to create a thematically (and sonically) cohesive story.
1989 SWIFTOLOGIST VERSION PLAYLIST: open.spotify.com/playlist/012...
Don't be a stranger!
📸 INSTAGRAM: bit.ly/3RKOF5u
💻 TWITCH: shorturl.at/fxW39
📹 TIKTOK: shorturl.at/buzG3
💰 PATREON: shorturl.at/uILT3
🎙️ MY TAYLOR SWIFT PODCAST: spoti.fi/3U1pu06
📸 PODCAST INSTAGRAM: bit.ly/3QDNt2x
📧 EMAIL (biz only): sarah@smallscreenmarketing.com
💌 EMAIL (everything else): theswiftologist@gmail.com
kws: 1989 taylor's version, 1989 reaction, 1989 reaction, swiftologist reaction, swiftologist ranking, swiftologist lover, 1989 breakdown, 1989 album explained, everything you need to know about 1989, taylor swift harry styles, taylor swift karlie kloss, taylor swift new york city, 1989 world tour, 1989 vault tracks, Taylor swift eras tour, Taylor swift eras tour reaction, style (taylor's version, is it over now eras tour, is it over now out of the woods mashup, tayvis, travis kelce, haylor - Zábava
The fact that TV has outsold the original is definitely crazy to wrap your head around, the bigger everything gets the more unstable it all feels. I get the feeling that this level of hysteria is not going to go away quietly. I also think that Taylor, like most other people, have this tendency to get a little bit of hubris when too much is going in her favor, maybe flying a little bit too close to the sun so to speak. I feel like a Reputation like moment is creeping closer every day. Hope I am wrong though!
I agree and I think the next album has the potential to be amazing or it has the potential to be a forced mess because if this , like Zach says when someone is never told no or edited it can affect the quality of their work and I hope she will find a way around that
Well damn that's dramatic
History does tend to repeat itself. Both in a good way (1989) and maybeee in the reputation era that’s coming 😅
@@quantumwitcher9376 swear to be over dramatic and true
@@migueltinajero6183 exactly
making style tv its own ultimate botched category… you just GET IT!!! so sick of certain fans pretending like its any good 😭😭
What’s bad about it (except maybe the guitar in the beginning)??? It sounds pretty much the same to me 🤔
Reality check for the swifties STAT !!
@@archi7ectureI don't really understand either 😂
personally I like it, im not going to say its better than the original( which I love) but tbh I just dont see it being as bad or bad as others do, and believe me ive really tried to understand why people hate it just so much.
Nooo I love style tv so much, it sounds more emotional and I actually prefer the new guitar, you just need good headphones 😭
Desperately waiting for Haylor timeline songs, people need to know how epic and crazy haylore actually is!!!
oh they do .... and they will ....
u get it @@tchaika222
I think her Rep album track list order is her best… it shows her going from feeling vengeance, anger, hurt, disappointment etc to realizing there was so much more to positive and good things to focus on other than how people turned on her. It ends completely with her realizing the love she found was far better.
When you said "SΙυτ!" added another dimension to the lore of 1989,
My mind went "exactly" because,
If rest of 1989 is "clean", "SΙυτ!" is explicit
If rest of 1989 is seagulls, "SΙυτ!" is flamingo
If rest of 1989 is new york, "SΙυτ!" is L.A.
+ the NTWDT appreciation is all i wanted to see
So true ❤🙏
I did my own reshuffle when it first came out, here it is:
New Romantics (They meet in the city)
I Know Places (They have to leave)
Wildest Dreams (Drive out of the city)
“Slvt!” (California)
All You Had To Do Was Stay (He leaves)
Is It Over Now? (Both date other people but it doesn’t feel over)
I Wish You Would (Getting Back Together)
This Love (Reflecting on what happened)
Style (accepting the on again off again)
Out Of The Woods (anxiety about the relationship)
Say Don’t Go (The breakdown)
Suburban Legends (She can’t try to be friends)
Now That We Don’t Talk (Seeing it for what it was)
Clean (She feels like it’s over)
I wish I could fit in Wonderland but I feel like it would only fit between “Slvt!” and All You Had To Do Was Stay and I wanted to keep All You Had To Do Was Stay as the track 5.
What about shake it off? And blank space? Etc
@@ninasbbm5133 the songs she excluded other than hygtg (which i don't think could rly fit the tracklist just like wonderland) aren't about harry, like blank space and shake it off are about the media, and wtny, bad blood, and yail are definitely not about him
wonderland could go in between suburban legends and now that we don't talk. along with the idea of taylor looking back and why it didn't work. "didn't they tell us don't rush into things?" "we pretended it could last forever" "in the end we both went mad"
Last night Eras tour was chaotic! She trolled us with the 6 finger Grammy Nominations. 🖤🐍🖤🐍🖤🐍 6th album! What a fun and sweet night
I think it makes sense for Style to be a track 5 in an album of turmoil like you said, there is something beautiful about the only strickly happy song being the emotional core. also great video as always!
thank you for watching!!
i listened to style tv in multiple ways; earbuds, phone speakers, car speakers, computer sound system, headset, and it had its brief moment of “maybe this isn’t so bad”… and then the chorus hit and i listened to the original directly after and i just got so sad.
i’m sorry but i will not willingly listen to the rerecord, blondie is still getting money from streaming the original i’m sure she’ll live
WELL EXACTLYYYYY
The track list reshuffling are my favorite Swiftologist videos! ❤️
glad you like em :)
@@theswiftologist me too, that is my favorite swiftologist video as well, hopefully we got one for FEARLESS TV reshuffling.. I am looking forward for RED TV too.. he said that soon he will be uploaded it.
I wish you would flash forward to 3 hours later…
I see your profile and your smile on unsuspecting waiters
@@PristineWhens you dream of my mouth before it called you a lying traitor…
@@emilykie8874you search in every maidens bed for something greater baby
@emilykie8874 you searching every maiden's bed for something greater
@@alinehankhan5137if she’s got blue eyes I will surmise that you will probably date her
I think Suburban Legends is an important add to the story because the "we were born to be Suburban Legends" is a call back to Style and the "and I always knew it, that my life would be ruined" is a call back to Slut! I'd consider putting it after Say Don't Go. Then the story flows from "i want you to fight for me, but you won't..." into "...and I knew you wouldn't"
Your hatred for Style TV is so comforting. I finally found my crowd. I was so disappointed.
SAME
Zach, I am here from time when you have idk like 4k subscribers and I just want to say I'm soo proud of your growth. You are very consistent, funny, smart, you have critical thinking skills, great fashion sense, beautifully decorated room plus your reaction videos are always the first and we can discuss things with you that other channels don't talk about (and don't have to feel guilty about that). And I LOVE it! ❤ Honestly, you are the main reason why my English has improved a lot (I'm from Europe), I appreciate how articulate you are and that all your videos are subtitled. Thanks to you, not only has my language improved, but also my critical thinking, and I have a general overview of American pop culture Now (I'm also lot less delulu 😅). I like that you are still using prayer, as I suggested once, it always made my day. And last but not least, I have a friends but unfortinatelly I don't know any Swifties in my area (here in Czech republic almost everyone knows a few Taylor's songs, but there aren't many Swifties - if so, not in my generation, I'm 26). So you make me feel like I have at least some Swiftie in my life because you're so close to us, interacting with fans, etc. Thank you for that . ❤
Btw. if there's any Swiftie from the Czech Republic who also misses a Swiftie friend, text me 😊 (I'm from South Moravia but now live in Ostrava), my Instagram is @hana_holeckova_brzo_simova or here in the comments. Please don't laugh at my Ig account name, I gave myself that name once as a joke and it stuck with me. 😅
❤❤❤
He is the reason whymy English is better also
Same!! I’m so proud of my swiftologist! 🫶😝
Cuuute
thank you so so much!!!
Hey Zach, just wanted to say I love your videos sm and I’m so happy that people are finally appreciating your videos more! I’ve been here since 2k subscribers and have loved seeing your epic growth! Hope you’re doing well and if you ever wanted to do a q and a video about your life, I’d love to see it! ❤️
Thank you so much!!
I cannot describe how grateful I am for your content, to be honest I was kinda worried there isn't any Taylor related content for someone my age lol (im 30). I accidentally became a swiftie this year and needed your videos for quite a long time, I only started watching you a couple weeks ago (thank u algorithm) and probably watched most of it already. have a great day
thank you so much for watching!! I make content for people like you
At first, I have to say that I was confused by 1989 (Taylor’s Version)‘s first listen but, after being familiar with it for the last two weeks, I gotta say that… I love it.
I think she honored it well, and many songs got HUGE improvements (This Love, Clean, I Know Places, Wonderland, AYHTDWS, Bad Blood and Woods).
And shout out to How You Get The Girl getting justice.
Heck, I even familiarized with Style.
Overall, I was SATISFIED. And the Vaults are INSANE.
Yessss I agree 😊
8:56 8:56
8:56 8:56 8:56 8:56
8:56 8:56 8:56 8:56
8:56 8:56 8:56 8:56
you’re one of my FAVORITE CREATORS EVER and i’m not even that much of a Taylor fan, but that just shows how amazing you are!!! your takes and statements are just so refreshing to hear. i just love hearing what you have to say and your objective nature to stay true & not be a crazy fan. you’re just so cool. i cant wait for the Haylor timeline 😭😭😭🥰🥰🥰
i absolutely am convinced that wildest dreams is about alexander sarsgaard, or more specifically, it’s depicts a fantasy of being with him, and she had an on-set crush on him during the short time they filmed the giver (and had dinner with the cast and jammed together in the hotel with singalongs and then gushed about each other a little in interviews). I don’t have the sources for this, but I have seen it stated that Taylor has described Wildest Dreams as both fictional and a daydream.
It’s possible that Harry felt it was for him or about him on some level, though, because he references it lyrically in his unreleased song “Him”. It is unclear if “with you when your wrote that line” refers to part of Wildest Dreams or another song, though. Now that I have been looking for it, and getting into actual timelines, I have noticed some things that are very certain to be about Harry, or originally at least, including “So It Goes” first verse and chorus.
While the video hasn't premiered yet as of writing, we know for sure where STYLE's gonna be put haha
IT HAS ITS OWN CATEGORY 😭😭😭
It seems like she intentionally takes more time with the tracks she feels were under appreciated on the original versions. I agree that these vault tracks are top tier. Great analysis!
that's an interesting thought....
Love these videos!!! I never much cared for wonderland but I can’t stop listening to the tv version, it’s like crack to me
Wildest dreams is a very important part of haylore, In "Him" (unreleased by Harry) Harry mentions wildest dreams, in Midnight Memories (by 1D) wildest dreams is mentioned too. The secret Message for wildest dreams is "he saw her in his dreams" which is a part of her secret message story of 1989, she also refered to it in "Is It Over Now" And Harry is a bit taller than Taylor Swift, just check out their pictures from when they used to hang out together, and he has grown taller than that. Ig people might be wondering that he is shorter than her because of their Grammy interaction, but it's important to note that she was wearing 6+ inch heels.
Yess another video, u work so hard to keep us fed! love uu!!
I made my own rearrangement of the track list the other day, very excited to compare my opinions to the swiftologist! Appreciate all the hard work you always put in zach!
Would LOVE LOVE LOVE it if you did a video on TS11! Would be great to hear your theories and predictions! 💗
oooooh I have NOOOOOOOOOOO idea
OMG Style and New Romantics were my two favourite songs off of 1989 (SV) and then she botched BOTH of them on TV not to mention everyone I’ve asked thinks the re-recorded versions are good… imagine my excitement when I saw you ranked them the same as me!!
SHE FIXED THEM!! Go listen they sound so much better
@@amandasoul I'm sorry but no. I just listened to them and they sound just as bad as before. Are you sure you just didn't get used to them?
rip you. style is a little better after the edits, NR is completely the same lol
@@missmoonchild3865 no if you google it, it’s an actual thing she did after rightfully bad feedback. Maybe you’re not listening on the correct platform? Or you are just used to it lol because she did it a few days ago
I didn't notice any huge difference in Style. Out of the woods was the biggest botch I've heard so far. I feel the production from the very beginning was kinda boring compared to the hit of the original. That was my most anticipated song so after I heard that I've only listened to a select few favorites and the vaults.
Zach, I have to tell you that the reason why I always come back and why you're my comfort channel is because you are the only other person (that I've seen, I'm sure there are others out there!) that agrees that the TV isn't always the best. Similarly to you, I'm a veteran Swiftie (been around since 2006, have the original Taylor Swift CD). These songs mean a lot to me and I have mixed feelings about the TV. A lot of people in my personal life attack me for my opinions and say how I'm "missing the point" or "not a true fan". No. The fact is I'm allowed to have sentimental attachment to songs that raised me, helped me get through hard times, and I'm allowed to be critical towards my favorite artist and these re-recordings. Doesn't mean I don't love her; it just means I don't blindly worship everything she does. I'm so glad I found a corner on the internet that makes me feel so validated. Thank you for these videos and for expressing your opinions!
Also I completely agree that Bad Blood is a banger. Always loved it, always will.
I think some fans haven’t learnt the difference between constructive criticism and hate.
Constructive criticism is healthy and respectful. I really enjoy watching Zach’s videos because his opinions are respectful but also nuanced and balanced. I actually feel my brain relaxing whenever he’s expressing his opinions because of the way he does it.
You can love someone & the work they put out into the world without having to put them on a pedestal all the damn time. It’s actually unhealthy when fans do put them on a pedestal as they’re setting themselves up for disappointment. Especially when it’s a public figure, we only see what they choose to show to us
this exactly. these songs raised me. Ive been a swiftie for more than a decade. And now Ive got 12 year olds telling me Im a fake fan for listening to the og versions? ugh.
so happy to provide that critical safe space for you !!
@@cattd00 lol I felt that in my soul
My 13 year-old sister tries to do that to me when she forgets that when I was 18 and she was an infant I was playing red for her on repeat
Again i love your playlist / story. And your cuts! Great Great Great!!! ty 💖
I absolutely agree that the swiftie community is allergic to even constructive criticism. I think it's because many new swifties who are very active online are probably young teens. And let's be honest, none of us were very reflective when we were 14.
I’m not I don’t know why but I like style tv
Great video! I don’t think the track list on the album should necessarily be in chronological order to tell a cohesive story.
But it’s definitely a fun exercise.
Excited for the next video, Zach
I have a hard time noting audio differences, so I was kinda okay with style, but New Romantics… the voices that sound like kids was just not it.
For the vault tracks… I can’t believe those songs were kept in the vault for so long, but at the same time I understand. Imagine the amount of hate she would’ve gotten for being so honest about HS. For me slut and is it over now are masterpieces!!!
right!!!!! it sounds like a children's choir as well as when ur at the doctor and they have u stick out ur tongue and say "ahhh" !!!!
In an unrelated note, love this sponsorship for you 💅 you totally deserve it!
thank you sm!!!
I was today years old when I found out that Taylor may have had a fling w/Alexander Skarsgaard and it has me SPIRALING into this theory -- EVERYTHING ABOUT THE WILDEST DREAMS VIDEO HAS NEW MEANING! And the fact that she cast Scott Eastwood, son of iconic actor Clint, as her love interest is VERY conspicuous since Alex Skarsgaard is also the son of an iconic actor, Stellan Skasgaard.
welcome to the crazy town......
Taylor and Alexander Skarsgard were filming movie together in South Africa. In that movie Taylor’s character was brunette. So basically Wildest dreams MV copying her movie set with Skarsgard.
@@anastasiak6111why did I never hear about Taylor coming to my country lol. I would have died if I knew she were here
Always love the reshuffle, it’s so fun!
it's a tradition at this point
I'm so glad that someone noticed the high-pitched white noise in the background of shake it off too!
I’m definitely considering the Patreon now, seriously your content is very skillful and fun!!
you should come hang there :)
What a well-thought out and great video! Thank you Zach
thank you for watching!!
Love your videos so much, not sure if it’s something you would want to do but I would loveee a video where you give your opinions on which songs are about which relationships etc!
Love your channel, love the intro 💙
Hi Zach, thank you so much for the video! I love love love 1989, its my favorite album. I was wondering if you saw all the craziness last night? From Travis going to the show, the 3 surprise songs, the karma lyrics change, and the backstage kiss??? it SO CRAZY AND UNHINGED I was literally freaking out!!!!! and I also saving this tracklist to Spotify!!
he talked about it all on twitch yesterday
I'm gonna be streaming again today and talking about it :)
on CZcams?@@theswiftologist
@@astaldaron9724 what did he say about it?
I really like that you are willing to be critical! ❤
So happy to have been here since pre 10k maybe even 5k
I remember you from then tom!
@@theswiftologist ❤️❤️🥹
I think Clean tv is my favorite rerecorded track from this album. It's different enough from the original so I don't feel like it's supposed to replace it but also the instrumentals in the back are adding more to it.. Like to alternate between these 2 versions.
yeah I like the differences!!
@@theswiftologistI cry
That beginning SENT me 😅 ilysm
YESS been waiting for this
Amazing video as always, Zach! Would love if you could do a video essay on Lana’s latest album Ocean Boulevard. Would be keen to see your views on where it ranks in her discography, her Grammy noms etc
def working on that for next year!
Your initial reaction to this album was more warm than I was expecting it to be given how different the mixes feel. This seems more like you. 😆😆😆😆❤️
So excited❤❤
You nailed the playlist!! I was always so confused why New Romantics was placed towards the end of album
What an absolutely fantastic track list you made, the cuts would’ve heightened the storytelling to new levels!
I was waiting for this video. 😊
Omg I thought I was going crazy! THANK YOU for saying that thing about the white noise/high pitched whine on certain tracks. I was like am I hearing things??? It hurts my ears, so I will not be streaming those versions either.
love ur videos! i love the way you dont feed into the stupid stuff the new swifties say and have opinions of ur own, your like my fav youtuber!
If you could do a video about your opinion/predictions about the grammy nominations? I wpuld really love to see that and thank you for your videos💙
Get that bag zach!! congrats on the new sponsor
I did a red reshuffle myself after the tv came out too and made me fall in love w the album in a way I never got to w the original. There’s such an undertone of blues rock on the album that when highlighted, really just drives home how good of a songwriter she is! I cant wait to hear or see your tracklisting. Red took me the longest of all the albums to reorder so I’m so curious to see what you came up with and see if ours are similar.
@@Adit-ws1in you asking me or the swiftologist
I want your reshuffle mark
Ok so for me… I general try to marry sonic cohesion and narrative cohesion. And sometimes one wins over the other, so for the most part my tracklisting makes narrative sense but there’s a few on here where you’ll be like “hmm!” But that’s because w an album like red which is more about just general idea of feeling emotions to their extremes I was a bit forgiving on narrative. But here it is:
1- state of grace
2- holy ground (can’t believe she didn’t put these back to back)
3 - come back… be here
4 - red
5 - all too well (dealers choice on version
6 - treacherous
7 - I knew the you were trouble
8 - WANEGBT
9 - Better Man
10 - I bet you think about me
11 - The Last time
12 - The Lucky one
13 - Nothing New
14 - Everything Has Changed
15 - Begin Again
Bonus:
22
The Moment I Knew
I Almost Do Forever Winter
Babe
The Very First Night
Safe and Sound
Forever Winter
(In no particular order yet )
reorganising stuff is a really fun way to interact with an album!!!
@@theswiftologist Right!? I do it w most albums I’ve listened to unless they are already perfect the way they are (Golden Hour I’m looking at you). But it makes me feel like I can delve deeper to into the story and the sound and sort of paint my own perception of it over it.
Great video!!
The second ‘yeah!’ before the bridge in OOTW sounds so good! Something we didn’t know we needed
So So Happy You Talked About Style TV And I Agree 100% Even Though It's My Fav Song Ever
Love this!! And you made my day when you said a Haylor timeline video is coming!! 😯 Re: Wildest Dreams...I have a theory about that song! I too think it's about Alex, but I think it was originally going to be about Harry. Have you heard Harry's unreleased song 'Him'? It's basically a response song in the same vein as Adam Young's 'Enchanted' response (which was cringe but still cute), because in it he sings "that nice dress, my wildest dreams, the lipstick stains still on my sheets" like couldn't be more obvious, but he also says "I don't wanna hear about him, in these songs you continue to write, I was with you when you wrote that line, it was me that you had on your mind" And I saw in articles elsewhere that Harry had some 'feelings' about her thing with Alex which I guess he confirmed in this song! But so...wildest dreams is the sort of song that is pretty wistful and not that emotionally intense, so I can see it being about a fun fling, but I could also see the idea of a love affair that is so impactful, that you never forget what you shared and how special that person was as being about Harry too. I can see Taylor, the romantic that she is, thinking if this ends, I hope you always remember me and these magical moments we're sharing right now. I wonder if she changed the direction of the song because of how she was feeling about Harry at the time and she knew he'd hear it, or else she just decided it would make a better song - and we noted that she cut pretty much all of the most emotionally raw and specific songs, so a more generic, wistful song about a fling would fit better with the overall narrative she was going with for the album.
We've seen from the vault tracks that her feelings for him were a lot stronger and more complex than we realised though, and I think from Harry's songs we see his regrets. I definitely think it did have a significant and lasting impact on them both. The song style is really fun, but I think it also encapsulates that impact with not really being able to fully let go, and feeling like they could always come back together at some point because they never go out of style. I feel like in some ways, Harry had the most significant impact on her, after Red she was like "Jake who?" But it seems like she continued to think about Harry, probably due to the unresolved nature of it - like you said, wondering if they're going to show up at your wedding. With those vault tracks and after songs like question...I wonder if part of her felt like he was the 'one that got away'? I thought people saying 'The 1' was about Harry were being ridiculous, but I'm becoming more convinced! (Not being silly hoping they'll get back together - but would I ship it? Hell yeah!) I would love to hear more of your thoughts about which songs on folklore and beyond might contain Harry references. As always, bless you for this video! I live for seeing your take on all things Swiftie 🙌
What if the 'he' in 'was it over when he unbuttoned my blouse" Was Alex??? 🤯
seated
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤ Oh my God. Yes, king went to sleep after hanging out with you. All on the Discord and on twitch. And now just woke up to see you all again. Here, it's a really good day to be a swiftie 🎉. I thank you so much for all your work. Sweat and blood and tears and good luck on your packing! and all that stuff.🎉 . See you on the twitch laters and yeah for time zones😊 luna btw
You always mention the drums in the last chorus of the Wildest Dreams MV, but it also has added percussion in the second verse too!!
IT ROCKSSSSSS
I agree on I wish you would!! That was one of my top top faves and fumbled a bit on the rerecord. I’ll be picking and choosing what I listen to from each version. The vaults are BANGERS.
I just fell so hard in love with original 1989 that this one can sometimes take me away from that feeling.. if that makes sense?
There’s a CZcams channel called swift leaks and they made a video that compares the old to new for all the songs. If you don’t look at the video you can immediately tell on every song there’s a difference.
Also, I would love for you to make a video at the end of the re-record process going all the songs that you thought were good enough to replace
I'm so glad you liked I know places 😂 I was rooting for it
zach you should do the reorganization of the tour setlists, feels like a fun idea :)
yes thank you zach u actually know what ur talking abt and yet serving us content so fasttt???? thank u for speaking the truth
Adoreeee this re-shuffled list! Way better! Taylor, hire this person! Haha
Love these videos!! I mostly agree with the reshuffle, only I'd add How You Get the Girl as second song between NR and Shake it Off, that would also shift "Slut!" to 5th song which I think would be fitting!
IM SO HAPPY you agree that wonderland was a discovered supermodel too!!!! Like, I had never really felt any particular way about Wonderland when the record first came out- I mean I was like a tween when it released and I remember really loving the smash hits as most did- but wonderland never really stuck out to me for some reason?? After 1989 TV hit, MY GOD did Wonderland hit too😩😍 Like, those DRUMS in the pre-chorus???? Addicting. Ear porn. 10/10, I definitely got lost in wonderland while listening.
'All You Had To Do Was Stay' also got ranked SUPER high on my personal list just because so many elements of the original production were enhanced and magnified on TV and it is just so compelling to listen to. Almost has a completely different vibe
Love the video Zachary!!
thanks for watching!!!
love the video! what do you think about people saying taylor updated style tv & new romantics tv on streaming??
I love the way you say "yes I do" or "yes we do" or yes i am" just all the variants of those. It's so cute. 😊
I am ashamed to admit that I can't tell the difference between any of the songs on 1989 vs 1989 TV.
Love your track list order. Tells the story much better. It is odd that Taylor doesn't pay closer attention to the track list arrangement on albums
Hey Zach this was SO GOOD!! I’m not seeing the Haylor or 1989 playlists on your Spotify! I’m able to get to 1989 with the link but it’s not listed on your profile and the Haylor one is not there 😢
1989 should be there now :) the haylor one is being saved for an upcoming video
@@theswiftologist our hero! 🥰💕
I think this rerecording is an absolute masterpiece. she actually made one of the best pop albums ever even better with the vaults. I think they expand the overall "story" of 1989 in a very effective and interesting way, it kinda feels even more of a concept album with an overarching story to me. I have even more love and appreciation for 1989 now.
thought provoking pop culture analysis is your skillshare. bravo as always
so true queen ..... maybe I should teach a course there !!
I didn’t get it on the first couple listens, but then it quickly became my favorite vault. Obsessed
okay sponsor!!!!! we love to see it, get that coin! 🥰
you are so correct about Now That We Don’t Talk. still can’t believe it exists
Totally love it how u managed those track put to order really like your opinions and theories haha 1989 is just legendary album 🩵
Off topic: wish u do similar content for Avril Lavigne discography 🤟🏻🔥♥️
YES ZACK GET THAT SPONSORSHIP BAG 🙌
I'm going to one of the Paris shows. Unbelievable to type that. Super excited.
The gremlin in me wants to bring a sign that says "I prefer all the originals"
The extreme amount of validation I felt when you put New Romantics in the “style tv” tier. New Romantics is my favorite Taylor song ever and I will not be playing the tv of it. I tried so hard to like it, but I just couldn’t. Loved the video btw and all the content here and on patreon🙏
I'm so happy that someone else also finds it difficult to appreciate Style and Welcome, New York and New Romantics the same way they did. Maybe because they're my favorites and I guess she's just not as heavily invested now than in 2014 cause she's at a different stage in life now. While the singing definitely is different, it's the music arrangement that just feels so under-anything. So thanks, nice to know it's not just me who has these unfavorable opinion about our beloved singer songwriter.
It's Welcome To New York but I love the title you created 🤩
@@quibblcr LOL didn't realize that
@@lilykarinda991 It's alright 😆😭
I don't know what it is about Style TV, but I'm absolutely obsessed with it 🤣My only complaint is that awful white noise/buzzing through half the album that was pretty bad on Style at first. It's seemed to have been tamed down since THANK GOD, but to me the song just feels warmer and richer now.
However, I absolutely LOVE your perspective Zach, and if I look at it from a different perspective, can even agree with some of the critiques of Style! I love that this is a place where we can criticize the songs that really are NOT it (AKA New Romantics) in a healthy way and be okay with that. I'm obsessed with your videos!!!!
MY EXACT THOUGHTS
Loved the video, and you inspired me to create my own rearranged tracklist! So if you would like to indulge in a different interpretation, here is my "fixed" tracklist.
1. New Romantics
2. "Slut!"
3. Out Of The Woods
4. Say Don't Go
5. Is It Over Now?
6. Blank Space
7. Shake It Off
8. All You Had To Do Was Stay
9. I Wish You Would
10. This Love
11. Style
12. Wonderland
13. Wildest Dreams
14. Now That We Don't Talk
15. Clean
THE CUTS
Welcome To New York
Bad Blood
How You Get The Girl
I Know Places
You Are In Love
Suburban Legends
I really wanted to convey the roller coaster that this relationship went on, and I'm very happy with how it turned out!
I’ve also convinced myself Wildest Dreams was inspired by Alexander Skarsgard! They met on the set of a movie which matches the music video theme and I think it aligns with the lyrics in Is It Over Now.
Her dating Alexander was just a rumor and a lot of people didn’t even know about it. “At least I had the decency to keep my nights out of sight. Only rumors bout my hips and thighs…”
Just a question: Do you think that a music video is coming after more than 2 weeks? Love your videos ❤
idk......probably not
I would honestly add you are in love as a bonus track on the reshuffled tracklist, I don't really know why but I think it would be good there
11:10 aaaww i love how we can all sorta ~claim~ our respective surprise songs :') i was at chicago night 3 and i feel a special sorta ownership over "the moment i knew" nowwwwww i love it sm
I absolutely agree! Style and New Romantics were my two favorite 1989 songs (style is also my absolute favorite TS song) and they were also the two songs that really disappointed me
Next time you do a reshuffle on an album, I would love it if you show the tracks visually - like if you film when you in real time make the spotify playlist. Otherwise, I love your take!!
ooooh I did think about doing it but it takes me a couple days to make the tracklist and I listen to them while I do it .... it's like a spiritual experience
@@theswiftologist hahah of course, then I’ll definitely check out your Spotify
Zach please tell us what you think about the whole drama last night in Night 2 of Buenos Aires 😍👏🏻😄 we are here for unhinged messy Taylor !
Watching the entire concert being live streamed from Buenos Aires last night, and then seeing the video of TK after the concert standing waiting for her and then him seeing her and them embracing… it was so incredibly fun & romantic! 🥰💘
@@penguinswithwifi so true! It was the treat we didn’t know we needed! 😍😍😍
love your new track listing! but would switch out of the woods & I know places because OOTW is more reflective ‘looking at it now… I remember thinking…’ whereas IKP is more present tense ‘in the dead of night, your eyes so green and I know for you, it's always me’. feels like chronologically IKP came first xx
I totally agree! Out of the Woods coming after is the perfect reflection of "we've tried to save this relationship by keeping the media away; all we need is each other (IKP). Did it work? Are we out of the woods now?"
Video suggestion incoming : I think you should create your own taylor swift album and era , that would be amazing
I’ve thought of a way to get Suburban legends, How you get the Girl, Bad blood, and Welcome to New York onto the track list
1. Suburban legends- coming off the tumultuous experience of The past era’s she decides to draw a line in the sand to become more business savvy
2. How you get the girl- more business savvy head and toe she decides to sit down and talk from a unknown perspective
3. New Romantics- the real intro into the main story of 1989
4. Blank space- in that in between the love story and the business savvy mode, she’s in on the joke
5. Slvt- the flip side to blank space and the first signs of falling in love
6. Style- same reasons you put it here
7. Out of the woods- same reason you put it here
8. Bad blood- she feels cornered by a certain pop girl which leads to the next track
9. I know places- the first hit in the relationship, after feeling targeted by someone who should be her ally and the media her thoughts get incredibly more anxious
10. Say don’t go- same reasons you put it here
11. Wonderland- same reasons you put it here
12.all you had to do was stay- same reason you put it here
13. Wildest dreams- say it with me now, same reason you put it here
15. I wish you would- same reasons you put it here
16. Now that we don’t talk- same reason it’s here on your list
17. Shake it off- shes trying to distract herself and start a new path in life (Could also work between say don’t go and wonderland)
18. Clean- that forced feeling of being ready to except the past and ready to move forward
19. Welcome to New York- she’s moved, she’s ready to experience what life has next, she’s inspired by the sound and the freedom of love, no longer held by the past she’s truly free
19. Is it over now?- The past (Harry) will never just be the past, he’s a muse. Also clever way to end an album given the title
- I don’t want to live forever isn’t on 1989’s track listing but I do think it works for the story she’s telling so I think it could go between say don’t go and wonderland, before shake it off if you prefer shake it off between those two as well
- I would make Sweeter than Fiction and the rest of the cut songs (From my version) into deluxe tracks cause I’d feel bad removing some of them from the discography
will you do a haylor video ? with all the new informations from the vault tracks that would be so interesting !!
yes
I think the key to Haylor is that it didn’t end definitively. Taylor, the writer she is, can’t help but ask questions and write new endings. “Did I hit the brakes too soon when he didn’t say ‘I love you’? Did he need more time? Would the media have died down eventually?” I wonder the “final” break-up came as a surprise. When she walked off the boat in her blue dress, did she expect him to call? Did she get silence? Is that how a passionate story is supposed to end?