Ukraine accuses Russia of using phosphorus munitions in Bakhmut

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 05. 2023
  • Ukraine has accused Russia of attacking the besieged eastern city of Bakhmut with phosphorus munitions.
    Drone footage released by the Ukrainian military shows parts of the city - the scene of some of the bloodiest fighting of the war - ablaze as what is alleged to be white phosphorus rains down. While white phosphorus weapons are not banned in their entirety, their use in civilian areas is considered a war crime.
    Writing on Twitter, Ukraine's defence ministry said the phosphorus attack targeted "unoccupied areas of Bakhmut with incendiary ammunition" - although it is unclear exactly when the alleged attack took place.
    Watch more videos at the Independent TV: www.independent.co.uk/tv/edit...
    Click here to subscribe to The Independent: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Independent
    About The Independent:
    Making Change Happen. The Independent is the world’s most free-thinking newsbrand, providing global news, commentary and analysis for the independently-minded.
    Connect with The Independent:
    Check out our full video catalog: / theindependent
    Videos, daily editorial and more: www.theindy.com
    Click here to get the best of The Independent daily: www.independent.co.uk/newslet...
    Like The Independent on Facebook: www. TheIndependentOnline
    Follow The Independent on Twitter: / independent
    Follow The Independent on Instagram: / the.independent
    Download the iOS & Android app: www.independent.co.uk/subscri...
    Help to support truly independent journalism. Every dollar you contribute will directly fund additional special reports and investigations from a free-thinking, award-winning newsroom you can trust - www.independent.co.uk/donations
    Subscribe to Independent Premium for exclusive content & live events: bit.ly/2MiOONB

Komentáře • 122

  • @ryandunevant7448
    @ryandunevant7448 Před rokem +62

    It’s completely legal the Us used it in Afghanistan and and Iraq

    • @punapeter
      @punapeter Před rokem +18

      IDF jews in palestine use it all the time.

    • @Queen-dl5ju
      @Queen-dl5ju Před rokem +6

      muh whataboutism

    • @punapeter
      @punapeter Před rokem +8

      @@Queen-dl5ju HKtroll

    • @DonnyTheButterlord
      @DonnyTheButterlord Před rokem +10

      It is not, even though the US used it tactically as smoke munitions to cover soldiers(and not comepletely bomb a city with it) people are still against it due to civilian AND friendly casualties. Thus your opinion here is basically invalid

    • @DonnyTheButterlord
      @DonnyTheButterlord Před rokem +4

      ​@@punapeter whats next are you gonna say heil the man with 1 ball?

  • @thornil2231
    @thornil2231 Před rokem +31

    Like the US in Falluja? But wait... Ukraine was part of that criminal war...

    • @DonnyTheButterlord
      @DonnyTheButterlord Před rokem +4

      Saved millions of kurdish minorities from being genocided and thiusands of iraqis from being executed🙏🙏

    • @mm-ck3cw
      @mm-ck3cw Před rokem +7

      ​@@DonnyTheButterlord shhh.. clowns should only be seen and not heard.

    • @DonnyTheButterlord
      @DonnyTheButterlord Před rokem

      @@mm-ck3cw make me shush you clown

    • @morho9422
      @morho9422 Před rokem

      donny, killed a million people. did you know?

    • @Penguin-qy8cb
      @Penguin-qy8cb Před rokem

      @@mm-ck3cw then how come you heard him? I think ur s clown to

  • @sturmx96
    @sturmx96 Před rokem +4

    Oh this magnesium “phosphorus” munitions again. This is what taking your audience for a cattle looks like.

  • @punapeter
    @punapeter Před rokem +8

    NO REFERENCE blurry PROPAGANDA from ISRAHELL

  • @Alchemist7887
    @Alchemist7887 Před rokem +12

    it is not phosphor, it is magnesium

    • @nickbroughton928
      @nickbroughton928 Před rokem +1

      What are you referring too? If your referring to the incendiary rounds, most country's do infact, use phosphorus. On the other hand, illum rounds generally do use magnesium.

  • @Yuri_Volkov
    @Yuri_Volkov Před rokem +3

    did they remember to add "highly likely"?

  • @MartinMartinX
    @MartinMartinX Před rokem +7

    its MAGNESIUM not phosphorus .....

    • @nickbroughton928
      @nickbroughton928 Před rokem

      Well that's depends on what your talking about doesn't it? Some in the incendiary round's do you use magnesium however most use phosphorus. Illumination rounds use magnesium. Which are you referring to? an from which country? ammunition used varies from country to country.

    • @SimulacronX
      @SimulacronX Před rokem

      @@nickbroughton928 It's NOT phosphorus. Illumination rounds, 9m22s, used in BM-21 Grad launchers.

    • @nickbroughton928
      @nickbroughton928 Před rokem

      @@SimulacronX ok an what type of round were they firing?? Illum rounds? Or incendiary?

  • @artistphilb
    @artistphilb Před rokem +2

    I seem to remember Israel burning down the UN compound in Gazza when shelling the city with this stuff too

  • @chogaminggm7650
    @chogaminggm7650 Před rokem

    Those are fireworks 🎇

  • @Y_hass
    @Y_hass Před rokem +10

    But the US has used this in Afghanistan and both Iraq wars. Why wasn't it illegal then? 🤔

    • @DonnyTheButterlord
      @DonnyTheButterlord Před rokem +2

      It's about how it is used. Fireboming an entire city like this is completely different from how the US used it.

    • @mm-ck3cw
      @mm-ck3cw Před rokem

      @@DonnyTheButterlord yeah US used it on the population. Russia emptied the last 2% of bakhmut of civilians and rained it down on Ookie troops who had booby trapped all those building with bombs. Russia just decided to pre empty that and take care of the Ookies all together.

    • @kermit1
      @kermit1 Před rokem +7

      @@DonnyTheButterlordthe only people left in that area are UKR troops.

    • @Y_hass
      @Y_hass Před rokem

      @@DonnyTheButterlord The US and its allies do the same but it doesn't get reported or very understated.

    • @DonnyTheButterlord
      @DonnyTheButterlord Před 7 měsíci

      @@MichaelRathke-ey5um yes but in most cases the civilians are told to evacuate the cities that's about to turn into warzones and any bombings are on terrorist hideouts and/or places they're shooting our lads on the ground on. It's different because we don't intentionally use it on civilians. We try to limit civilian casualties as much as possible because it's bad for everyone. When soldiers start to question orders,when soldiers start to think what they're doing is wrong then the entire operation is fucked. But the ruskies here are basically doing it like we did in vietnam

  • @danny_7620
    @danny_7620 Před rokem +3

    this is old footage from a long time ago

  • @si-vis-pacem-parabellum
    @si-vis-pacem-parabellum Před 11 měsíci

    So what ?

  • @starfighter1043
    @starfighter1043 Před rokem +5

    Wait I thought wagner captured the city already 😂so they did this to their own army? 😮

    • @jjimmy9763
      @jjimmy9763 Před rokem

      Why Russia gave Phosforus Bombing video to Ukraine?

    • @starfighter1043
      @starfighter1043 Před rokem +1

      @@jjimmy9763 Jimmy are you drunk? What tf ate you talking about dude 🤦‍♂️ SMH 🤣✌️

    • @flupyclouds5242
      @flupyclouds5242 Před rokem

      Wagner is controlling 90% of the city but has not fully captured it yet, but they more or less own it, I assume they are raining these down on the remaining places they haven't took before they push.

    • @limedickandrew6016
      @limedickandrew6016 Před rokem

      If you look at the video you will notice lots of high rise buildings. It is this part of Bakhmut, where there are lots of high rise buildings, that is still mainly under Ukrainian control.

  • @francoiscamargo4133
    @francoiscamargo4133 Před rokem +1

    Mas não era os ucranianos e ingleses que cogitaram munição de uranio empobrecido?

  • @fionabologna1768
    @fionabologna1768 Před rokem +7

    Oooo! Big scary lights that a liar says is bad.

    • @MrSoccerPlayer7
      @MrSoccerPlayer7 Před rokem +2

      Send me your info, I will buy you a ticket and you can come to Ukraine. I wanna see what you internet gangsters are like here in Ukraine.

    • @fionabologna1768
      @fionabologna1768 Před rokem

      @@MrSoccerPlayer7 Illusions, tiktok vids, air raid sirens, old equipment destroyed and paraded, 1 month evacuation notices before engagement. Illusions. And money laundering. That's it. I have fake race riots and trans ad nauseam to look forward to. And an illegal invasion! Can't forget that. Your welcome for all the grift money you stole from my country and imbicle president and corrupt Congress. We all got problems, bud. Cope.

  • @josephsumog-oy8503
    @josephsumog-oy8503 Před rokem +2

    US used it anywhere

  • @luminetto
    @luminetto Před rokem

    War criminality +1000

  • @morho9422
    @morho9422 Před rokem +1

    not white phosphorus. this looks yellowish to me.😁😁

  • @MsShf
    @MsShf Před 11 měsíci

    👌👌👌

  • @nodatastored684
    @nodatastored684 Před rokem

    😮

  • @maxibernal1931
    @maxibernal1931 Před rokem +7

    🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺

    • @ingussilins6330
      @ingussilins6330 Před rokem

      Bēdas tev, postītāj, kas pats neesi postīts! Un bēdas tev, laupītāj, kas pats neesi aplaupīts! Kad tu būsi pabeidzis savu postīšanas darbu, tad izpostīs tevi pašu; kad tu būsi ar saviem laupīšanas darbiem galā, tad aplaupīs tevi pašu!
      Bībele Jesajas 33:1
      Vai tāds liktenis gaida Krievijas federāciju no Dieva?

  • @bobheinrich7011
    @bobheinrich7011 Před rokem

    Russia must be desperate for something to celebrate for victory day.

    • @tipenemokaraka-hiriwa8074
      @tipenemokaraka-hiriwa8074 Před rokem

      I agree.. I think the Russians are waiting for the "Spring Offensive" so they can test their munitions on the western supplied armaments reported as "game changers". I would like to see if Challenger tanks burn like the rest of them..

  • @CGplay186
    @CGplay186 Před rokem +3

    Russia can use whatever they want, Ukraine can always surrender if they don't like it. Is not like west that always let other fight for them is gonna help them, millions died during ww2 what you have now nothing, is not realistic to think Ukraine can "win" when the side that always do the most war efforts is against them

    • @anacc3257
      @anacc3257 Před rokem +2

      Do you like defending war criminals?

    • @proselytizingorthodoxpente8304
      @proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Před rokem

      Russia has been promising victory now for over a year. You're still thinking that Russia is a superpower. It isn't. Its just a larger Belarus with nukes. It doesn't have the capability to take Ukraine. Which is why Putin's war has bogged down into stalemate.

    • @morho9422
      @morho9422 Před rokem

      critizon, you are talking about irak and you do not even realize it.😂😂

  • @user-if6hx7fz8u
    @user-if6hx7fz8u Před rokem

    Why did so many Russian side people leave comments on this English contents? For part-time jobs?

    • @YoursUntruly
      @YoursUntruly Před rokem

      They’re paid by the comment, I saw a video about it.

    • @YoursUntruly
      @YoursUntruly Před rokem

      There are government officials doing it, and they’re also paying poor in the Middle East to do it.

    • @SimulacronX
      @SimulacronX Před rokem +1

      @@YoursUntruly So it must be true is you have seen a video "of it", right? You guys :-) haha

    • @YoursUntruly
      @YoursUntruly Před rokem

      @@SimulacronX Well no, its true because people who were paid to do it admitted it. Lol. Think before you speak, little guy.

  • @mrjhpsk4976
    @mrjhpsk4976 Před rokem

    Sdihaj suchka

  • @scatto_drone
    @scatto_drone Před rokem

    Esattamente come hanno fatto gli USA in Afghanistan e Siria mah preferivo i tempi del Napalm

  • @romanov4042
    @romanov4042 Před rokem +14

    Beautiful❤

    • @rickyjpad
      @rickyjpad Před rokem

      Wtf yo thats 1400 degree phosphorous falling and burning urkainians organs

  • @timtaylor1983
    @timtaylor1983 Před rokem +14

    Slava Russia from USA

  • @engineeringfact1298
    @engineeringfact1298 Před rokem +2

    Don't warry after some time Russia dropping atum bombs 💣💥 😂😂😂 and Ukrainian bye bye 😂

  • @mdnizamuddin75
    @mdnizamuddin75 Před rokem

    🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺❤️❤️❤️💪💪💪

  • @azmagaref
    @azmagaref Před rokem

    Nice, keep it up Russia.

  • @LaHayeSaint
    @LaHayeSaint Před rokem +6

    The US used white phosphorus on an unprecedented scale in Vietnam. No one said a dicky bird! More often than not, they fell on civilians. Petroleum (napalm) was also used in extensive amounts. No one said boo to a goose!

    • @BMW_329
      @BMW_329 Před rokem +3

      Are you forgetting the amount of pushback the US got for Vietnam?.

    • @zhijingchen4563
      @zhijingchen4563 Před rokem +1

      ​​@@BMW_329 then... Russia may face pushback from Ukraine...Not a big deal. US didnt sent any payment to Vietnam for using such weapon either, so the pushback is verbal.
      Also US didn't face actual punishment for using this and depleted uranium weapons in Iraq.
      It is only a big deal until it is not. In modern warfare, after providing a humanitarian channel and time period, any civilian stayed to fight would be treated as "accomplice", they are hard to be covered by Geneva Convention, nor non registered volunteer army. This applies to Russians Wagner group as well.
      All the big countries seems to know how to play around these laws nowadays

    • @LaHayeSaint
      @LaHayeSaint Před rokem

      @@BMW_329 BMW -- See Mr Chen's comment, which answers your question.

    • @nickbroughton928
      @nickbroughton928 Před rokem

      Actually, did you know, it's more directly because of vietnam and other instances that the "Geneva conventions" banned it. The US also voted "yah" for it an now Obeyeds by it. Fyi

    • @SimulacronX
      @SimulacronX Před rokem +2

      You are right. But it's NOT phosphorus in this case btw. It's 9m22s, Magnesium

  • @jeckjeck3119
    @jeckjeck3119 Před rokem +3

    There are literally 1000s of phosphorus rockets in US storages.
    They should be given to Ukraine at once! If Orcssia is not playing by the rules, it should NOT be protected by the rules.

    • @stephen4121
      @stephen4121 Před rokem

      Oh the US doesn't play by the rules all the time. They scream blue murder when stuff happens to them.
      Oh and better an Orc than a Nazi

    • @jeckjeck3119
      @jeckjeck3119 Před rokem

      @mr wpg
      More orc lies, all the more reason to treat you terrorists as you deserve to be treated.

    • @SimulacronX
      @SimulacronX Před rokem

      It's NOT phosphorus. Don't believe this bullshit propaganda by the west

    • @gustavofring5674
      @gustavofring5674 Před rokem

      @@mrwpg6286you mean the 2014 revolution which the people wanted to remove that Russian puppet from power

    • @user-nj5si7ms5l
      @user-nj5si7ms5l Před 11 měsíci

      Подарок США Украине,правда весь склад взлетел на воздух!