An Eating Disorder Specialist Explains How Trauma Creates Food Disorders

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 13. 10. 2019
  • As an eating disorder and trauma therapist, Ashley McHan sees patients with an array of issues with food. VICE speaks to her about our unhealthy relationship to food, how it contributes to disordered eating and the underlying causes, similarities and differences of various eating disorders.
    For more information and resources about eating disorders including ARFID, please visit www.allianceforeatingdisorder...
    Watch our full video on what it's like to live with an eating disorder: • I've Eaten Only Mac & ...
    Click here to subscribe to VICE: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE
    About VICE:
    The Definitive Guide To Enlightening Information. From every corner of the planet, our immersive, caustic, ground-breaking and often bizarre stories have changed the way people think about culture, crime, art, parties, fashion, protest, the internet and other subjects that don't even have names yet. Browse the growing library and discover corners of the world you never knew existed. Welcome to VICE.
    Connect with VICE:
    Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/VICE-Videos
    Videos, daily editorial and more: vice.com
    More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
    Click here to get the best of VICE daily: bit.ly/1SquZ6v
    Like VICE on Facebook: vice
    Follow VICE on Twitter: / vice
    Follow us on Instagram: / vice
    The VICE CZcams Network:
    VICE: / vice
    MUNCHIES: / munchies
    VICE News: / vicenews
    VICELAND: / vicelandtv
    Broadly: / broadly
    Noisey: / noisey
    Motherboard: / motherboardtv
    VICE Sports: / noc
    i-D: / idmagazine
    Waypoint: / waypointvice
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 1,3K

  • @VICE
    @VICE  Před 4 lety +148

    For more information and resources about eating disorders including ARFID, please visit www.allianceforeatingdisorders.com/
    Watch our full video on what it's like to live with an eating disorder: czcams.com/video/v1TWvXwgKr0/video.html

    • @Slingin_Mary_Alex
      @Slingin_Mary_Alex Před 4 lety +5

      This is great! Thanks Vice! ✌🏻

    • @technofeeliak
      @technofeeliak Před 4 lety +1

      What about Aspergers...

    • @marlen9564
      @marlen9564 Před 3 lety +4

      @@technofeeliak what's that got to do with eating disorders... Look for another video. Not that hard

    • @nikkijensen6256
      @nikkijensen6256 Před 2 lety +1

      111111111g

    • @hs4265
      @hs4265 Před rokem

      @@marlen9564 my autistic grandson has SEVERE eating disorder after being traumatized by ABA "therapy" and now wont eat. He chews and spits. How about you NOT be so nasty to people asking questions like John smith?!

  • @alexandras.6638
    @alexandras.6638 Před 4 lety +8644

    It's ironic how much eating disorders are not actually about food.

    • @sabbithcullen14
      @sabbithcullen14 Před 4 lety +320

      For me, it’s control. It used to feel so out of my hands, it’s switched to working out now. So kinda better.

    • @kristenb180
      @kristenb180 Před 4 lety +8

      sabbithcullen14 same 😂👌🏻

    • @evelyn9273
      @evelyn9273 Před 4 lety +258

      What annoys me especially is when people say eating disorders are CAUSED because of unfair expectations on women, about being ‘thin’. That oversimplification is such an injustice. When it’s not even about that.

    • @ayeshak6822
      @ayeshak6822 Před 4 lety +64

      Evelyn I'm curious though why it manifests more in women than men. It seems to match the expectations for women in society to look good.

    • @ayeshak6822
      @ayeshak6822 Před 4 lety +17

      In short: why less men?

  • @kd4822
    @kd4822 Před 4 lety +4759

    Not eating always made me feel in control when life felt the most out of control.

    • @georgia1986
      @georgia1986 Před 3 lety +36

      how do you deal with rumbling stomach? i throw up in the morning cos i get nauseous from hunger. i can't even imagine

    • @ddemetra3046
      @ddemetra3046 Před 3 lety +80

      When people ask me how or why I developed an eating disorder I use the exact same words..it's heartbreaking.. whenever I felt life falling apart all I could do was to control this one 'little' thing called food.. now I am finally getting some help and trying to enjoy life a little bit more...learning how to appreciate, love and respect yourself is hard work but I am hopeful. Take care everyone

    • @gypsierose3611
      @gypsierose3611 Před 3 lety +32

      Yeah 2020 has brought my eating disorder back full force

    • @gypsierose3611
      @gypsierose3611 Před 3 lety +5

      @@georgia1986 I have anti nausea pills due to migraines so I use those and then they suppress my hunger

    • @amandaelf
      @amandaelf Před 3 lety +4

      it's so relateable 💔

  • @EH012
    @EH012 Před 4 lety +3997

    "The more we restrict, the more likely we are to overeat. And the more we divide foods into good and bad, right and wrong, the more anxiety we're likely to have and the more distress and preoccupations we're likely to have with food and eating."
    PREACH.

    • @sadiemakesmesmile
      @sadiemakesmesmile Před 4 lety +30

      its basically like the mind taking over all control, without the intuitive side making the judgements based on how your body feels.

    • @marissabones
      @marissabones Před 3 lety +1

      Amen

    • @somalireader6743
      @somalireader6743 Před 3 lety +1

      @@sadiemakesmesmile can you explain that? I mean which intuitive side?

    • @WhippedCarpet
      @WhippedCarpet Před 3 lety +15

      If we don't separate food into good and bad then how do you separate eating healthy vs junk food. Junk food is obviously bad food. So idk I struggle with this so if it's not good vs bad then what is it?

    • @ce637
      @ce637 Před 3 lety +10

      @@WhippedCarpet good question. I think viewing food a bit more holistically is probably ideal, rather than the good/bad binary that creates a sense of anxiety. that is to say, asking "is this good for me?" is different from asking "what will the nutrients in this food do for my energy levels?"

  • @shandacrouch4946
    @shandacrouch4946 Před 3 lety +2047

    I remember going to my GP to finally get help for my bulimia and she said "you don't look like you have an eating disorder" "you look fine to me" when in reality I've had an eating disorder for 10 years and at the time of seeing her I was binging and purging ever day and sometimes up to 7 or so times a day every single day. You can't just look at someone and know they are sick. The medical system needs to be better educated in these matters

    • @jademusic1211
      @jademusic1211 Před 3 lety +71

      I feel your pain. 😥💔 A few years ago, I went to a doctor I had to see as part of the intake exam for therapy. He gave me a checkup and saw me a couple of times thereafter, looked at my weight status (which fluctuated by 5 lbs in either direction), and nonchalantly declared, "Weight stable. No eating disorder". 😱 Meanwhile, at that time, I'd been bulimic for nearly 30 years! I *hate* the ignorance that goes on with ED's, particularly when you don't look anorexic. You're definitely not taken seriously by the medical profession in the same way you'd be if you were emaciated. 😞 I hope you're doing well today, hon'. Sending you love and light. 😘♥️

    • @22casperlove
      @22casperlove Před 3 lety +22

      @@jademusic1211 I have a similar story. When I think back on how long it's been...almost 15 years..it horrifies me. People would never know looking at me. I hear ya sister.

    • @mayraz5625
      @mayraz5625 Před 2 lety +18

      So true. I was severely underweight but people kept assuming I wanted to be thin and was okay.

    • @ThePrincessdi77
      @ThePrincessdi77 Před 2 lety +36

      Same. I was 90-106 lbs at 5’3 which isn’t too underweight for like 20 yrs eating 400-600 calories a day plus weights and cardio and people just said wow you look amazing! Look at those abs! i had low blood pressure low body temperature and wore a sweater in Florida 🤦🏻‍♀️ doctors never said a word yet now that I’m over my bmi by a little after having a baby and recovering they are crawling all over me and sending me home w a sheet on how to lose weight every single visit. Perhaps I should speak up and tell them my 20+ yr battle w eating disorders of all sorts of types but I feel like they will just think I’m delusional or depressed or it’s an excuse for my current weight gain. Makes me wanna starve again to be honest but I have my son now and that’s more important then the stupid doctors opinions

    • @JamJam-xx6jl
      @JamJam-xx6jl Před 2 lety +7

      Weight is one of the main thing that can help you differentiate bulimia from anorexia. Bulimic patients maintain or have normal weight since they binge eat then purge. On the other hand, anorexia less body weight because they restrict food and sometimes they purge.

  • @bbbones8099
    @bbbones8099 Před 2 lety +433

    I had an eating disorder since high school till I was about 25. I'm 36 now and let me tell you, the BEST thing for EDs is to not be around people who cause you stress, or be in stressful situations. Another thing is my son's dad taught me the real value of food - I saw him grow edible gardens everywhere we lived with love and care, and he taught me to basically respect my body more and to give it what it needs to thrive. SO a loving nurturing environment is NEEDED to facilitate healing. There are a lot of healing holistic centers everywhere that teach that health is love and vice versa. And get away from physical and emotional toxicity, no amount of therapy will work if you stay in toxic environments and relationships.

    • @Angel-ni2yn
      @Angel-ni2yn Před rokem

      yeah, but people keep pushing ppl into toxic environments n relationships, which I've finally woken up from "oh they dont mean it like that, oh it'll get better" bullshit, especially reading bout healing and the only way to truly achieve that and become healthy is to outgrow unhealthiness, but that's all there is around here and ppl don't listen, it's fuqqing annoying. Therapists should know better yet they even pressure me to stay and try working out abusive relationships that literally harm me in the end, I literally harm myself, I've tried a million times to "work it out" and I'm only getting worse, I literally don't care about myself, now I even starve myself, I take my anger out on myself, I've given up on trying, wtf is wrong with ppl?! HOW IS THIS OKAY?! I don't understand how ppl say to get help, but the "pros" to get help from DONT FUQQIN HELP ??? They just dismiss it

    • @SirenASMR_
      @SirenASMR_ Před rokem +8

      True when my abusive mom finally is gone is when my stress will be 100 percent reduced

    • @db4449
      @db4449 Před 6 měsíci +1

      BEST ADVICE

  • @nasrinv
    @nasrinv Před 4 lety +3116

    Would’ve been nice if she mentioned that not all ppl with ED are super thin

    • @veronicaperez3555
      @veronicaperez3555 Před 4 lety +98

      My goodness yes! Great point.

    • @skyehutton2419
      @skyehutton2419 Před 4 lety +210

      Yes! Some are actually severely overweight. Usually the ones that are overweight have BED which is the most common eating disorder and many don’t realize they even have it, nor do their families

    • @marxistyogamom2982
      @marxistyogamom2982 Před 4 lety +149

      And even many people with restrictive eating disorders aren’t thin! Atypical anorexia is a real thing and far more prevalent than “anorexia.”

    • @skyehutton2419
      @skyehutton2419 Před 3 lety +4

      Isa thank you for clarifying what I said. I completely agree

    • @Jasmine-mc4ru
      @Jasmine-mc4ru Před 3 lety +30

      The episode she was on Vice for was regarding an individual who had an addiction to strictly eating Mac n cheese. He had an eating disorder but did not have an intention based around weight. This is the context I believe is missing in the video. If you see the other video it will make a lot more sense

  • @kirkearles
    @kirkearles Před 4 lety +1703

    I wish I could just walk away from food like an alcoholic can walk away from alcohol but I can't. This body requires me to eat daily and I have to face the ed everyday. It's damning.

    • @rinac885
      @rinac885 Před 4 lety +28

      I feel you, don't worry buddy you're not alone

    • @somethinggood9267
      @somethinggood9267 Před 4 lety +6

      You're really good at skating!

    • @cherieadamsdodd7044
      @cherieadamsdodd7044 Před 4 lety +71

      @kerpal3 that is not a helpful response to someone with an eating disorder!

    • @anastasiageorge1279
      @anastasiageorge1279 Před 4 lety +3

      Cherie Adams Dodd this really helped me with my ed in terms of recovery & making sure i get at least some sort of nutrients

    • @cherieadamsdodd7044
      @cherieadamsdodd7044 Před 4 lety +19

      @@anastasiageorge1279 that's wonderful you found it so helpful! Xx My comment was because of making blanket statements about separate foods is not healthy for ED in general especially dangerous for someone not in treatment. Obviously once in treatment and learning what works for you then it's fine.

  • @pm123n
    @pm123n Před 4 lety +2886

    She has a really nice voice, like a mother's.

  • @pawoo308
    @pawoo308 Před 4 lety +720

    As someone who had severe eating disorders for roughly 15 years but overcame it and has been healthy for almost 7 years now, I want to say that it’s possible to get through it and get better. If you’re suffering from eating disorders please don’t give up. You’ll get through it. 💜
    Edit: 3 years since I made this comment, STILL HEALTHY and content with my body. Everyone, you can do it. I believe in you, and I promise, life is so much better. Take care ❤️

    • @sarahramy4686
      @sarahramy4686 Před 4 lety +9

      Pa Woo Needed that, thank you. ❤️

    • @mairihendry111
      @mairihendry111 Před 3 lety +11

      You should be so proud of yourself, it’s not an easy road to recovery ❤️

    • @rubybeatrice4323
      @rubybeatrice4323 Před 3 lety +1

      Hiya, firstly, I am incredibly proud of you for overcoming something so hard and keeping well for so long now, well done you are truly an inspiration!💗 (possible trigger warning) Secondly, I am currently doing an English language A level and the question I’ve chosen for course work is ‘does language on food products effect those who have or have had eating disorders?’ As I have never experienced an eating disorder myself I was wondering whether you could give me any insight on this? Of course I really do not want to ask anything that may offset you in your recovery so if you would prefer to stop reading this comment now then please do! But if you are happy to talk about this then I would be extremely grateful for a reply. I imagine it as if you were walking through the super market, is there anything (words in particular) that reminds you of your eating disorder or effects you in a negative or positive way? Thank you and again, you are amazing for what you have overcome!💛

    • @pawoo308
      @pawoo308 Před 3 lety

      @@rubybeatrice4323 Hi Ruby! Apologies for the late reply. If there's anything I can do to help spread awareness, I'd love to 🙂 I'm not from U.K. though, if that matters?

    • @rubybeatrice4323
      @rubybeatrice4323 Před 3 lety

      Pa Woo Hello! That’s great thank you so much! And no that’s not a problem so long as I do say the country your from if that’s alright with you?

  • @aprillunger2117
    @aprillunger2117 Před 4 lety +1627

    Eating disorders are about control. We have no control anywhere else, so we control our diet. We’re not even realizing we’re doing it at first. It just becomes. Unless you experience it...you just don’t get it. We have to decide to get better for ourselves. No one can do it for us.

    • @grey2868
      @grey2868 Před 4 lety +49

      Yes, this! I overcame my disorder on my own because I knew no one else could help me in the way I could help myself. In my experience, you really have to work on yourself from the inside, start actually loving everything about yourself. It takes years and isn't easy but is worth it!

    • @minamai5650
      @minamai5650 Před 4 lety +1

      !!!

    • @marif2993
      @marif2993 Před 4 lety +1

      Grey how????

    • @Kikuye
      @Kikuye Před 3 lety +40

      I wouldn't be so quick to generalize the whole "it's about control" thing as if people really even *always* know what they are doing or why they are doing it consciously.

    • @EdenGold
      @EdenGold Před 3 lety +12

      I completely agree with this. It was ALL about control when I was struggling, and it's so freeing releasing the control and healing your relationship with food. I am sending you so much love on your journey to healing your relationship with food if you are currently on that journey

  • @Arlyneya
    @Arlyneya Před 4 lety +156

    Today marks 30 days of abstinence for me from Compulsive Over Eating and Binge Eating Disorder. I am am in recovery and I am just praying for 30 more days. Having an eating disorder is excruciating and humiliating, and all I want is to get better.. to be normal. But in order to do that, I have no choice but to surrender and allow myself to just focus on today. Not next week, next month, next year; just today. And that’s how I’ll get through, one day (and one meal) at a time.

    • @ashleymchan
      @ashleymchan Před 3 lety +1

      YESSS! And even if there is a hard day in there, start again. You are showing yourself what you are capable of and you will get there!

    • @lostinthecosmos6095
      @lostinthecosmos6095 Před 3 lety

      how are you now ? ((:

    • @Arlyneya
      @Arlyneya Před 3 lety +8

      @@lostinthecosmos6095 I love you. I am 1 year and 3 years abstinent. Recovered. It was imperfect, it was monumental, It has been the most freeing time of my life. Thank you so much for asking. And to anyone else reading this that may need this message: it is possible. You can do it and the best thing I can share is that when the feelings come when the coping mechanism no longer exist to cover them up, is to just look straight into the pain and let it out. You get stronger along the way, and it gets easier to handle it. That is the most surprising gift.

    • @lostinthecosmos6095
      @lostinthecosmos6095 Před 3 lety +4

      @@Arlyneya that’s so great to hear and i’m so fucking proud of you!!!!!congratulations!! you deserve the world. 😊😊😊
      i’ve been struggling with binge eating/overeating but i’m working on it now. your comment gives me hope and it motivates me. you have an amazing day, angel. sending much love🤍🤍🤍

    • @helenimdad4004
      @helenimdad4004 Před 3 lety

      How did you do it? Really bad return of binge eating disorder. Constant pain from it. Did you get advice?

  • @kizzyfoshizzy
    @kizzyfoshizzy Před 4 lety +719

    I feel like I can’t say that I ever had an eating disorder because I was never diagnosed and was never underweight :/ I lost my period, was extremely obsessed with food and restriction, built up so much anxiety around what I ate, etc. still haven’t gotten over some of these things :(

    • @asiasdenis
      @asiasdenis Před 4 lety +53

      my heart goes out to you ❤️ i have the same exact thoughts...i feel that the only way i can get help is by being underweight, and i’m too scared of my parents not believing me if i tell them.

    • @ecksteinjazz
      @ecksteinjazz Před 4 lety +70

      everything you listed is indicative of very disordered eating, AND at the same time not having a diagnosis doesn’t make the struggle or disorder any less valid! the healing process is long and annoying, but just the fact that you’re speaking about it in the past tense shows you’ve made a lot of progress already which is so encouraging! it will take time and effort to push through it all and heal yourself from the leftover habits- ultimately it will happen though😌 (coming from someone 5 years recovered from anorexia, with some occasional lingering patterns of thinking, but overall a very healthy relationship with eating and exercise)

    • @kyukachan
      @kyukachan Před 3 lety +15

      I'm fat and mostly bullied for being an Overweight. I weigh 60kg and felt bad i have a really bad affection in food i panic when i intake a lots of calories a days so ended up vomiting it's really suck.

    • @ashleymchan
      @ashleymchan Před 3 lety +9

      Whether or not there is a diagnosis, it's real enough. I'm so sorry you had that experience and that you are still experiencing any of this.

    • @EdenGold
      @EdenGold Před 3 lety +10

      You don't have to be diagnosed to understand the symptoms, the fixations and what they mean

  • @leletaylor7647
    @leletaylor7647 Před 2 lety +101

    When she mentioned about the sensing for belonging and a place to fit in, that hit so deep. Since I could remember I’ve always been bigger, both taller and heavier, than my contemporaries and I always felt out of place.

  • @Christopher40028
    @Christopher40028 Před 4 lety +130

    I remember being 11 and 12 years old and developing anorexia. I was bullied by a large group of girls at the new school I attended every single day. I was in a fight basically every day for the entire time I went to that school... I wouldnt eat at lunch, I didnt care about eating breakfast, and I chose not to eat supper because what was the point? I had no appetite whatsoever.
    I distinctly remember my teacher reading us a book about a girl who had an eating disorder. I took that book home and used it as a tool on how to better "control" my eating disorder. I used it as a way to learn how to keep my eating disorder a secret, how to lose more weight, and what to do about food I didn't want to eat...
    Finally, my family had decided to move and I was placed in a different school. My new friends had began noticing how I never ate and how skinny I was getting... and they voiced their concern. That's when I finally began allowing myself to eat a little bit. Eventually, I began eating more often and finally I began gaining a healthy amount of weight...
    But all in all, trauma DOES create eating disorders. The trauma of the racism and being bullied had made me anorexic. Please, teach your children to love others and to embrace peoples differences so this doesnt happen to anyone else.
    Thank you.

    • @jademusic1211
      @jademusic1211 Před 3 lety +6

      That's a beautiful, encouraging story, honey. I hope you're continuing to do well. 😘♥️

    • @helenabolo-luca9377
      @helenabolo-luca9377 Před 2 lety

      Ooh my goodness you story sounds very similar to my daughter although she eats ice which is called Pagophagia. She doesn’t want to eat breakfast or evening meals, although when she’s not eating the ice she enjoys her food. She started maybe 3 years ago like age 9 she moved to a new school when we moved to the city and she was so excited because the school before that she was bullied. Yet the new school she struggled to fit in and developed anxiety. Then during the lock downs it was the transition to high school (which is a challenge for many children I know) but it I kept an eye on it. Then it really ramped up when we moved to a bigger home about 10 months ago. Now she hides when she’s eating the ice, I believe the anxiety drives this, I have asked her why she hides and why she believes she does this at all and she talks about issues with friends at school emotional issues she has with her dad, and how she struggles to deal with them and she finds herself eating ice, but what I don’t understand is why she is hiding it.
      I’m monitoring it but I don’t want her to have a life filled with an eating disorder.

    • @helenabolo-luca9377
      @helenabolo-luca9377 Před 2 lety

      You story is encouraging tho, I will show her so she can read it. Ultimately it’s important to deal with the root causes but yet to see an encouraging testimony helps also.

    • @stayclassyhitchcock
      @stayclassyhitchcock Před 2 lety

      what book? there were two that had a similar impact on me. I read them so many times.

    • @whbgegs5571
      @whbgegs5571 Před rokem

      @@helenabolo-luca9377 wow, i know my problem isn't the case with all ice-eaters, but i began eating so much ice several years ago, and my daughter told me it might be a sign of anemia. i laughed and said, no way am i anemic. but then my heart started bothering me so i had to see a doctor, and boy was i ever anemic, so anemic!

  • @kirasussane1556
    @kirasussane1556 Před 4 lety +320

    She has such soothing voice and presence.

  • @patrickdallaire5972
    @patrickdallaire5972 Před 4 lety +273

    I'm so glad she mentioned ARFID. I'm one of those males she mentions; the kind who used to hide in shame, not knowing I was struggling with a diagnosable and treatable eating disorder.
    It's a little frustrating when I read a pamphlet or a poster about eating disorders and ARFID isn't mentioned. I only learned about ARFID (called Selective Eating Disorder at the time) at least a decade of struggle. A specialist noticed my behavior in a public setting and informed me in private. I'm still struggling but there is a noticeable improvement; progress I might not have had if it wasn't for that coincidence. Without awareness and treatment, I might have avoided more trips and social events just because of the food.
    If you suspect someone you know is struggling with ARFID please let them know about it. It was a huge relief for me to learn about this disorder; that I wasn't just "picky", that my anxiety in front of food was real and that there are other people like me. You'll be a hero to anyone by bringing this to light for them.

    • @uwpride
      @uwpride Před 4 lety +4

      Patrick Dallaire Thank you for insight. I’ve never heard of ARFID until now and I’m curious to look more into it.

    • @patrickdallaire5972
      @patrickdallaire5972 Před 4 lety +7

      Thank you so much @@Suna-nb6vd for sharing. Your story is so relatable.
      Like you, I learned about the disorder ~19. Like you, I seem to have struggled with it my whole life. Only my parents can recall the times, younger than 3 years old, when I wasn't as "picky" (a label that I despise btw). Like you, I blamed myself; I didn't think it was more challenging for me, I only thought what people told me: that I was weak. My parents treated me in a similar way. One time my dad forced me to eat until I puked and then forced me to finish eating; all this happened in front of his parents, siblings and their children. Eventually, they also gave up on trying to change their child (me). From the post you replied to, you can probably tell how much of a relief it was for me to learn about ARFID too. Obviously, it was a relief for me to move out and eat wtv I want as well.
      You don't "have" to change. Just know that we have IS a medical condition (In the DSM-5); there are therapists and support groups out there. Personally, I didn't really seek therapy until I was ~23. Before that, I just wanted to focus on my studies and "healthy" food was expensive anyway. Even then, trying to change has been on and off. Sometimes, I relapse into old behaviors. However, overall there are signs of progress and paths have been laid for whenever I want to try again. Try and try again. Just doing it at my own pace. My therapist is a super nice woman.
      I can't predict the future nor can I read your mind but, to me, it feels like your ambition for that career and wholesome motherhood could outweigh your fear of the "treatments". It wouldn't hurt to just get a consultation to address questions like "Should I do it?" and "Am I ready?". Whatever pleases you (not your parents) in the long run.
      Take care Alisha

    • @ashleymchan
      @ashleymchan Před 3 lety +1

      So glad to read this. Thank you for sharing.

    • @MelB868
      @MelB868 Před 3 lety

      I didn’t understand what it was

    • @MelB868
      @MelB868 Před 3 lety

      @@patrickdallaire5972 umm you are supposed to stop when full if you ate til your sick it’s a sign you’ve eaten way way too much

  • @oh_kale_yeah1199
    @oh_kale_yeah1199 Před 4 lety +360

    Please please do an update of the Mac n cheese guy in the future! I would love to know how he is doing! Best of luck to you young sir!! 😊

  • @ariesx6515
    @ariesx6515 Před 3 lety +67

    The therapy for eating disorders I experienced was all body related which actually made things worse. It‘s nice to know there are therapists out there who treat the cause instead of the symptoms.

    • @isawhat8712
      @isawhat8712 Před 3 lety +12

      I went to a psychologist who specialized in eating disorders. She referred me to a dietician and they worked together. The psychologist dealt with showing me how my anorexia was tied into my feelings of lack of control, perfectionism, low self-esteem, etc. While the dietician focused on the reintroducing food and teaching me about the damage lack of food was doing to my body. She managed my food diary and my psychologist focused on triggers. It was successful in teaching me the patterns of the disorder. I hope you're doing better.

  • @samanthad473
    @samanthad473 Před 4 lety +288

    For me, when I feel like shit in my life is getting out of control, the “ED” makes me feel as though it’s the one thing I CAN control. Trauma is definitely a key role that triggered it from the beginning. 😞

    • @ashleymchan
      @ashleymchan Před 3 lety +1

      You make sense, Samantha. Thanks for sharing.

    • @chuckbuckets8825
      @chuckbuckets8825 Před 2 lety +1

      My best advice is to 1. Stick to your meal plan 2. Follow up with your doctor 3. ED programs are always there. I was in & out of the hospital throughout my 20s & 30s. Every time I learned something new.

    • @papercut..
      @papercut.. Před rokem +2

      Eating disorders aren't about food. They're about control. You should be very proud of yourself for recognizing the underlying cause of your ED ❤️

  • @Asuma492
    @Asuma492 Před 4 lety +1604

    This the same lady that is treating the mac n cheese addict!

  • @annieyu72
    @annieyu72 Před 3 lety +43

    She seems like someone filled with compassion and love for others. Wish I know a person like her in my life

  • @AA-wc3tw
    @AA-wc3tw Před 3 lety +133

    I developed disordered eating around age 15 thanks to my narcissistic, evangelical mom. I'm now 41 and I still struggle with food, body image, self-loathing, all that crap. THANKSMOM.

    • @Lola-by6cx
      @Lola-by6cx Před 3 lety +3

      same right here!!! im only 22 and im worried this will never end but i also cant afford CBT therapy right now :/

    • @amylee9
      @amylee9 Před 2 lety +8

      Time to parent yourself and stop blaming your mom from 25 years ago. At this point it’s your choice.

    • @AA-wc3tw
      @AA-wc3tw Před 2 lety +11

      @@amylee9 I'm working on it. The trauma and PTSD and shame runs deep.

    • @amylee9
      @amylee9 Před 2 lety +4

      @@AA-wc3tw There’s a great book called “Personality isn’t Permanent”. It has a section on moving on from trauma. It’s helped me a ton. I highly recommend it. Best wishes….

    • @norazulkifli2517
      @norazulkifli2517 Před 2 lety +12

      @@amylee9 yeah but you make it sound as if one can stop having PTSD which is bs. just saying.

  • @YogawithAshleyGee
    @YogawithAshleyGee Před 3 lety +41

    for me it was about control, feeling unloveable and all of those things - absolutely. I'm so grateful to the people in my life who supported me when I was at my worst.

  • @undefinedvariable8085
    @undefinedvariable8085 Před 4 lety +426

    Question 1: What are some similarities between various types of eating disorders? 0:24
    Q2: What are some misconceptions about eating disorders? 0:59
    Q3: What is ARFID? 1:14
    Q4: How does ARFID compare other eating disorders? 1:53
    Q5: What role does trauma play in developing an eating disorder? 2:15
    Q6: How can eating disorders be treating effectively? 2:49
    Q7: What issues exist with access to treatment? 3:27
    Q8: What role does society and culture play in perpetuating eating disorders? 4:00
    Q9: How can I help a friend or family living with an eating disorder? 4:27
    Q10: ???!!! (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ 5:13

    • @ashleymchan
      @ashleymchan Před 3 lety +3

      Thank you for doing this:)

    • @N0N4M30
      @N0N4M30 Před 3 lety +1

      Question : why did she only mention 3 types of Eds ? There are many more

    • @natm5224
      @natm5224 Před 2 lety

      Lol @Q10

    • @SD-pv6fr
      @SD-pv6fr Před rokem

      It’s 5 minutes not an hr 🙄🙄

  • @jadielynn16
    @jadielynn16 Před 4 lety +51

    her voice/tone... she makes me feel validated.

  • @licensetochill4992
    @licensetochill4992 Před 3 lety +56

    If someone needs hope, my big sister's friend had really bad anorexia and bulimia that even the doctors said that she probably won't ever be healthy or recover. Nowadays she is healthy and happy, saw a post of her where she has strong legs and is smiling after just running a marathon. Never give up hope, that is the most important fight with mental ilnesses.

    • @noemarie8
      @noemarie8 Před rokem +1

      do you mind telling us how she recovered ? i’m eating more and moving less and it’s not doing anything it’s exhausting :(

  • @kainthewriter8764
    @kainthewriter8764 Před 2 lety +8

    I'm sitting in an ER hospital bed waiting for admission to a mental health clinic.
    I spent the last 20 years of my life confused and in pain, not understanding why eating hurt and not understanding why I hated myself.
    I watched my world, my life, my family and my love fall apart around me, but because I was just so young when it started, it never really felt like an issue.
    And I... I just woke up. Got to the ER with Opioid-like withdrawal symptoms because of abusing the medical system to avoid taking medications for my growing psychosis.
    I went inpatient for two weeks at a high BMI for EDNOS, and got immediately discharged for a lack of change in weight and vitals. As if I could just eat and be healthy. I liked pretending like that. It didn't hurt when I pretended like that.
    Eventually, I just... broke. I was exhausted, starving. I didn't know why I couldn't eat. I was so hungry, and I just wanted to be alone. My boyfriend didn't understand. How could he?
    No one had even known I'd been drugged against my will. I was locked in my body. Forever awake.
    I just hope my family can forgive me.

  • @strawberrycherrybaby
    @strawberrycherrybaby Před 4 lety +26

    She mentioned ARFID!! I've had it since I was a little child and never knew what it was until last year, because no food therapist I ever talked to even knew what it was. They thought I was anorexic because I only ate certain things, but I never wanted to be thin (rather the opposite, I was always uncomfortable in my very thin/petite body). Then it was binge eating, because I would only certain foods but because I could 'only eat' certain foods, I would eat large amounts of them. Now I finally know what it is and I can do a lot of self-imposed food therapy to help myself like more foods.

  • @MiaThorsteinsson
    @MiaThorsteinsson Před 2 lety +47

    for me, the hunger pains feel familiar, they feel grounding, they feel like something to hold onto, when everything else is completely out of my own control. They make me feel strong, somehow..

    • @boperez2841
      @boperez2841 Před rokem

      Very Interesting...I would feel fear in that situation but because I have Health Ocd 😂

    • @dafpxd
      @dafpxd Před rokem +2

      Same here. :( I don't know what to do, I reject all kind of food. I have been hungry all my life. The feeling of satiation is just weird. My "normal" is being empty and and weak.

    • @itsofficial7378
      @itsofficial7378 Před 10 měsíci

      I wish I could deal with the hunger pains. I feed the pain, which has lead to being obese. I went from being anorexic/bulimic to now obese. When I was anorexic I felt in control. Now, I feel like I have absolutely no control.

    • @EirwenVivantel
      @EirwenVivantel Před 4 měsíci

      Being hungry just feels so good.

  • @justinwiederman1521
    @justinwiederman1521 Před 4 lety +52

    It's cool that this popped up today! I have a friend who recently enrolled in getting treatment and this helps me understand my boundaries when speaking about her eating disorder. Also gave me a lot more empathy. Thanks for making this, Vice!

  • @jisoo1571
    @jisoo1571 Před 4 lety +143

    I recently found out I have ARFID and it’s honestly comforting? Like this is something I struggled with a lot and it’s nice to know there’s a word for it and I can get help for it :(

    • @verdaqq
      @verdaqq Před 4 lety +7

      I have the same thing , I wouldn't eat as a child so my nursery would force feed me food and my doctor thinks that's what caused it

    • @bruckgalaan-ifaa9330
      @bruckgalaan-ifaa9330 Před 4 lety +1

      same here

    • @kennaderek0910
      @kennaderek0910 Před 2 lety

      Me too , trying to find somewhere to check in for treatment has been so difficult

    • @deliciouscinnamon2775
      @deliciouscinnamon2775 Před 2 lety

      Same bro, I thought I had anorexia but apparently that’s when you feel the need to keep your weight as low as possible but this has nothing to do with my weight, my mum says I’ve always been a “picky eater” but now I think it’s more than that.

    • @Sophia-mu5cp
      @Sophia-mu5cp Před 2 lety

      same throughout my childhood i went to so many doctors and they all basically said itll go away when i get older but it never did and then 3 years ago we found a therapist and she diagnosed me with ARFID and like you said its just nice to know that theres actually smth to describe it

  • @notsomuchhere1387
    @notsomuchhere1387 Před 3 lety +46

    It's crazy how easily you can develop one. I'm 21 now and I lost my mom when I was young, immediately after I started restricted my food which then developed into bingeing, my body suffered through alot
    It's breaks my heart how I wasted my teenage years to this and being obsessed with my weight

  • @audreygardner4984
    @audreygardner4984 Před 4 lety +28

    I've had an eating disorder since I was 12 years old. It's a constant battle I'm trying to overcome. My therapist has told me it was something I developed to cope with the inconsistencies in my life at a young age. Choosing not to eat was the only thing I had control over.

    • @zzcaptainmastiv2727
      @zzcaptainmastiv2727 Před 4 lety

      yes, disorders from diet, i had them as well, i found out i am allergic to the world if i eat carbs, some sugars (ice cream mostly) act the same way. you will never know for sure if you do not look at what establishes brain power energy. Ketones, ketosis, eating meat is better for animals than growing crops, keto mojo - which i currently do not have, but i can listen to my second brain, the belly. if your brain is healthy, your body can follow suit and make your muscles strong. saute some onions in butter & add hamburger to the mix is one of the best ways to eat a stick of butter a day. keep an open mind & know that when you eat saturated fats or butter & good olive, coconut, or avocado oil that you will lose weight but gain muscle & mental clarity. hope this helps you to be at your best optimal physiology, which is how the universe designed us or put us together.

    • @jademusic1211
      @jademusic1211 Před 3 lety

      @@zzcaptainmastiv2727 You spouting your ideology has nothing whatsoever to do with what this person said regarding eating disorders. 🙄 Take your beliefs to a keto diet forum where they belong. You and your ignorance are in the wrong comment section.

  • @LilmamaXoXo3
    @LilmamaXoXo3 Před 2 lety +21

    The first 60 seconds of this video described how I use to feel when I dealt with binge eating disorder 🥺 thank God for healing 🤲🏽🤍

    • @farhanmirza4000
      @farhanmirza4000 Před 2 lety +1

      "The person is actually looking for a sense of belonging, a connection or feeling loved, feeling valuable, feeling safe or secure"
      These words were an eye opener to me.

  • @horroradorer
    @horroradorer Před 4 lety +43

    I have ARFID and it honestly feels like it runs my whole life. I’m so thankful for these videos bringing awareness to a disorder that isn’t taken seriously enough, in my opinion.

    • @goatpepperherbaltea7895
      @goatpepperherbaltea7895 Před 4 lety

      Horror Adorer what do you eat

    • @lianabotha0355
      @lianabotha0355 Před 2 lety +1

      Same, but even these videos don't always help. I wish someone would just knock those kind of idiots with a book about AFRID, maybe it will give them some compassion and make them mock and judge you less.

    • @EmbodyYourDivinity
      @EmbodyYourDivinity Před 2 lety

      I used to have this too!

    • @horroradorer
      @horroradorer Před 2 lety

      @@EmbodyYourDivinity how did you get passed it?

    • @debbielichter133
      @debbielichter133 Před 2 lety +1

      @@horroradorer I got free from the things that were driving me to be so obsessive. For me the solution wasn’t food focused at all. Even therapy had its limits for me. But when I went deeper and addressed the underlying issues that were keeping me stuck in addiction and obsession, my addictions and obsessions went away.

  • @laralilyLaraMaljevac
    @laralilyLaraMaljevac Před 2 lety +17

    I was quite skinny to the point my mother was embarrassed of me . I was forced to eat massive amounts of food by my parents in order to keep living at home. My mother encouraged binge eating and I would eat boxes of cereal in front of her where she would yell at me to get bigger . She would say " YOU EAT IT , YOU WEAR IT OR YOUR NOT LIVING AT HOME ANYMORE" . I would end up on the floor , crying and in pain where she would tell me I'm stupid for eating to the point of sickness. That really fucked me up . My binges got worse, she told me all she wanted was for me to gain weight , then yet again she would yell at me for the massive amounts consumed despite her encouraging it.
    Now .... I'm 35 kg higher , but I'm suicidal and the binges still haven't stopped .
    This started 2 years ago.
    It's been hell .
    It was honestly traumatic.

    • @emmajane646
      @emmajane646 Před rokem +1

      How are you doing now? I hope you are feeling better. It sounds as though your home is not a place where you can get better. Are there people around you or people you know who are loving and patient with you, who you can trust?

  • @adamstc8
    @adamstc8 Před 4 lety +40

    Wow, she is sharp as a tack! It's inspiring to see people this effective working in our (often broken and outdated) mental health system

  • @rachaelkate95
    @rachaelkate95 Před 4 lety +154

    I spent nearly 4 years in therapy for bulimia and I’ve never fully recovered but can manage it. Don’t think my relationship with food will ever be normal.

    • @amysifuentes55
      @amysifuentes55 Před 4 lety +2

      rachkate I feel it

    • @technic_angel
      @technic_angel Před 4 lety +1

      same

    • @avuhhh
      @avuhhh Před 4 lety +8

      rachkate same here- it’s been just over four years that I was at my lowest point (and weight) with anorexia. my “recovery” was pretty much just physical in that I was force-fed food deemed worthy by a nutritionist and that I attended weekly visits to a psychologist for a couple months (although it felt more like an interrogation to decipher my illness than therapy). I wouldn’t even care about my weight if I just had the chance to live a life where I don’t constantly think about food and whether or not the amount that’s in me is too much or too little...

    • @rachaelkate95
      @rachaelkate95 Před 4 lety +4

      avuhhh It’s exhausting isn’t it... keep fighting, stay strong

    • @jrobbins707
      @jrobbins707 Před 4 lety +14

      You're a fucking beast for dealing with it though. Mad props

  • @boroexploration9475
    @boroexploration9475 Před 2 lety +2

    This video hit me like a wrecking ball!! I developed ptsd in 2016 but also developed Arfid along side it! It's hard finding detailed videos about arfid so I truly thank you!! This is the first time Iv heard someone link trauma to eating disorders in this way and you've hit the bull's-eye! The way you've described the feelings we experience is soo accurate! You are a blessing to soo many

  • @daisygirl1217
    @daisygirl1217 Před 3 lety +39

    I am one of those who binges food and gains 50 lbs to then starving myself losing 50 lbs. I've been this way all my life and it has taught me to just accept how I am. It is what it is.

    • @user-jp1zr1qw7j
      @user-jp1zr1qw7j Před 2 lety +1

      Same . Even when I eat a little more than I had planned to eat for a meal I just say I’ve screwed up then back to binge and feeling like shite

    • @EmbodyYourDivinity
      @EmbodyYourDivinity Před 2 lety

      @daisygirl1217 I hear what you're saying but you don't have to just deal with this forever. You can get free from this cycle

  • @rinidorble
    @rinidorble Před 3 lety +8

    I remember the rush at my hardest point, the rush of it all and the control was so thrilling. It made me feel okay because it is the only thing I’m in control. I know it’s not healthy, but it’s so so hard to stop

  • @gypsierose3611
    @gypsierose3611 Před 3 lety +17

    My eating disorder is a side affect on of my PTSD and anxiety and adhd.
    It's not about weight at all

  • @ruthbromberg9068
    @ruthbromberg9068 Před 3 lety +1

    So glad you made this video! This topic is so so important. I really resonated when she talked about awareness. I'm 34, and I had no idea that I suffer from an eating disorder until I was 33!

  • @Angelwingedkitty
    @Angelwingedkitty Před 3 lety

    I just got diagnosed with ARFID over a month ago, been suffering with it for a couple of years now though. Finally getting therapy for it. I’m so glad it was mentioned in this video since people never talk about it when they talk about eating disorders!

  • @skeletalremains8555
    @skeletalremains8555 Před 3 lety +15

    I'm very glad that she mentioned men having eating disorders. As a male with one it's nice to hear people talking about it because guys having eating disorders isn't discussed often

  • @ariannashrum9068
    @ariannashrum9068 Před 4 lety +15

    SO HAPPY to finally see a credited specialist talk about ARFID on CZcams!

  • @jnlyfantasy
    @jnlyfantasy Před 4 lety

    I've been at a loss as to how to support some of my dearest friends with this for a while and this video was extremely useful in understanding eating disorders, thank you!

  • @jsmithsemper4848
    @jsmithsemper4848 Před 4 lety +5

    I’m going to bring this topic up at my next therapy appointment. thank you!

  • @jabon112
    @jabon112 Před 3 lety +8

    This never seems to go away..

  • @tanvikapila9389
    @tanvikapila9389 Před 2 lety +3

    I developed an eating disorder when I moved to a new country at the age of 15. I never realized it was an eating disorder and now, at the age of 26, I realize it all stemmed from "wanting control over one aspect of my life", It was never about food, tbh. Now I'm at a healthy weight, I exercise but I'm still fighting the urge to "just not eat" when I'm very stressed. It's a journey

  • @jesarelraices1951
    @jesarelraices1951 Před 3 lety +1

    Wow she really is a professional I have eating disorder and she did mentioned every single problem that I have including specially the part when she said there is a lot of hiding when someone has an eating disorder

  • @renee3461
    @renee3461 Před 2 lety +3

    I have ARFID. My mom said I didn't transition well to solid food when I was a kid, and I've had a preference for liquids my entire life. For me, eating (as well as obtaining food, cooking, dishes, etc) take a lot of energy (I also have fibromyalgia), I have sensory issues, and I don't have a strong appetite. 10 years ago I was severely underweight, and I was eating all high calorie foods like peanut butter m&ms and whole chocolate milk to get as many calories as I could. I've gotten a lot better; I reached and have maintained a healthy weight for the past 6 years by taking a med to increase my appetite, using disposable cutlery to minimize energy required for dishes, eating on a schedule, and always keeping some easy to consume food within arm's reach. I also got away from my toxic family. I had tried for a few years to force myself to eat, but that often resulted in gagging so I eventually realized that that wasn't a helpful tactic for me. 90% of my diet is still meal replacement drinks, but I'm doing pretty well and I'm slowly introducing more solid food into my diet.

    • @Shikamaru233
      @Shikamaru233 Před rokem

      I have suffered from anxiety my whole life and suddenly i started fearing eating because of gagging and just feeling full, your story gave me hope

  • @carlylynne9214
    @carlylynne9214 Před rokem +3

    I'm late to the game on this but three years later and I'm saying thank you. Thank you for this.

  • @gstylez0107
    @gstylez0107 Před 4 lety +141

    After recovering from polydrug addiction, I can now see the similarities between drug addiction and eating disorders.. I've never had any issues with food until after I changed my brain with substance abuse, there are major similarities..
    Plain old sugar can target the same receptors as cocaine, amphetamine, even opiates.. I crave it, binge on it and then feel the comedown. It's uncanny. Recovering addicts need to watch out.

    • @EH012
      @EH012 Před 4 lety +3

      Yes! RECOVERING ADDICTS NEED TO WATCH OUT. And anyone recovering from ANY cycle of dysfunction really does...

    • @avuhhh
      @avuhhh Před 4 lety +2

      Greggy D when I had an ed I would constantly think of it as a kind of addiction (although I always felt terrible thinking of it in that way given that “addiction” is a term mainly used for drugs and alcohol). in reality, I truly was addicted to depriving my body of food- I got an adrenaline rush every single time I remembered that I was working towards (and sadly accomplishing) a weight loss goal by refusing to eat. the thought of anything disrupting my carefully chosen meals or schedules would send my brain and body into a frenzy... and when I was eventually force-fed for months, my head and thoughts were sent into chaos and depression since I was previously convinced that depriving myself of food was the only way to achieve that dopamine and adrenaline. scary stuff...

    • @dmcm2567
      @dmcm2567 Před 4 lety

      My ass eats whatever I can because I'm always hungry and im skinny as hell.. I only eat twice a day tho.

    • @Ssm19494
      @Ssm19494 Před 4 lety

      Bro do you really describe yourself as a polydrug addict lmao, why not just addict, grateful recovering addict?

    • @katseventeen
      @katseventeen Před 4 lety +1

      I understand your thought process but your conclusion is not correct. Your brain runs off Glucose- aka sugar. Sugar from fruits, veg, and whole grains. NOT cake, cookies, chips.... don’t get it twisted. Good sugars are absolutely necessary for proper brain function. Especially if you’re trying to heal.

  • @madi9092
    @madi9092 Před rokem

    I got diagnosed by my gp yesterday for selective eating disorders. And the first thing i said but I don’t look like I have a eating disorder but as he spoke more and the more I researched the more I realised how my trauma is affecting me still even when I thought it wasn’t anymore.

  • @crystal4336
    @crystal4336 Před 3 lety +2

    Great video! I wish we could bring more awareness to compulsive eating, binge eating and regularly overeating until you don’t feel good. People tend to focus on restricted selective eating, binging and purging.

  • @jonasjrgensen2637
    @jonasjrgensen2637 Před rokem +11

    The scary thing about eating disorders is that you can't even tell when it's happening until other people start pointing it out. It just feels natural and safe until you have a moment of realisation that this is not sustainable

  • @grim2867
    @grim2867 Před 4 lety +9

    For me my ed was about control bc my religious family was super controlling about everything in my life. From the way i dressed to who i was allowed to talk to. I developed it at the age of 12 and im 25 now. When i moved out i started to eat normally without me even thinking about it. Sometimes i find myself restricting again but its way better now. I hope one day im 100% better. Remember to treat your body kindly is something i tell myself when im struggling. I hope everyone who struggles with an ed is able to be free of it.💕

  • @SaintOrCinema
    @SaintOrCinema Před 4 lety

    These were excellent questions (and answers) - thank you X

  • @yohane4492
    @yohane4492 Před 4 lety +2

    Hi! To be honest I was on the verge of succumbing to my inner voice but here's my story, I was very much aware of the fact that there are eating disorders and I might experience it, I didn't really care much or I'm sure I wouldn't have an eating disorder. But then one day my auntie commented "You seem to be putting on weight" and that is where it went down I started restricting then feeling good but then I'd overeat on the weekends, I never wanted that, I was just on an endless cycle of restricting and binging, I know that the weight that I put on can possibly be just water retention but I would always think "I still put on weight" that's just a toxic mindset, gaining weight is inevitable, I never wanted to think like that I never wanted to have that toxic mentality, I just wanted to look good.
    Before it even gets worse I pushed myself to get out of that cycle. I know that I might've gain weight but I know that it's only water retention and It will go away I pushed myself to have a better mentality and If I were to want to lose weight I'd do it with positive thoughts and do it the healthy way.
    Please always be considerate to what you say to others, Just a few words can shatter someone's life and progress. Love your body for what it does not on how it looks like 💛

  • @itsmuimui
    @itsmuimui Před 4 lety +24

    Aren't we all just looking for a sense of value, belonging and connection? We need more love in this world, more love!

  • @hannahburnstein2482
    @hannahburnstein2482 Před 3 lety +4

    she makes me feel so understood.

  • @empoweringmindsets6667
    @empoweringmindsets6667 Před 4 lety +1

    I am a recovery channel! Thankyou so much for this! I have always tried to detach trauma and the ED so then I can fully recover!!!! Your amazing

  • @mjm8949
    @mjm8949 Před 3 lety

    Why do we grow to hate the very thing we once loved and obsessed over? When I was younger I had this weird obsession with food and eating. I could never stop thinking about it and I would always overeat and gorge myself to death any chance I got. As I got older I started to hate food and not eating became a problem. It never got as bad as it did when I was obsessed with food, but I still struggled with it. Now I'm doing okay. I mean I still skip breakfast and lunch sometimes and there are certain foods that make me physically sick to think about, but I'm okay. Anyways, thanks for this very informative video. I will be subscribing ❤️

  • @StrawberryNinjaNibbles
    @StrawberryNinjaNibbles Před 3 lety +6

    As someone with anorexia, I couldn’t really relate to the comment that anyone with an eating disorder doesn’t want to have a disorder/doesn’t like it. I mean yes, I don’t want my behavior to be considered “disordered” but the reason recovery is so difficult (for me) is because engaging in the behaviors I do feels GOOD. It feels right.
    Society is not kind to fat people & views them as lazy, undisciplined, slovenly, parasitic, gross, etc. So if I am the opposite of fat then I am also the opposite of all of the negative attributes that are associated with fat people.
    I feel powerful & disciplined & even receive positive feedback from others regarding my looks & they say they admire my willpower & (thus) my ability to delay gratification. That validation for something that I’m already feeling good about just magnifies the emotion. Add to this that Most of the US is overweight so it then reinforces that my eating habits & subsequent physique are not easy to achieve or maintain, which makes me feel even better, like the commitment & self control that top athletes or models have.
    I do not feel tormented by my obsessive thoughts about food or my weight (and they ARE obsessive, I’m not denying that), in fact, the repetition & rituals feel almost like a religious experience. It feels “right” & I feel whole; It’s a nearly euphoric experience when I meet my goals which is why recovery will always be difficult. I have very little incentive to seek it.
    For those that may comment about the possible negative consequences I may experience, well, many of them can be mitigated or avoided all together. You can be proactive about getting vitamins & nutrients with supplements & smart food choices, while still keeping your calories low.
    Cold? I just Dress warmer & make sure i am consistently keeping my circulation good by getting enough iron, staying hydrated & keeping my body moving.
    Any hunger I feel now has a positive association because it’s evidence of my “success” & determination. It’s like some kinda Pavlovian response lol
    Ngl, “walking the line” of being thin vs taking things too far is also kinda part of the thrill. By doing things “just right” it increases my feelings of power & self control because I am able to balance it just so; it makes me feel even more perfect. It’s like a high
    EDIT: 1) I wanted to clarify that I am NOT saying that people shouldn’t seek recovery because I think the negative consequences can be avoided. I was simply giving insight on how I personally have tried to be proactive about some potential negative “side effects” so to speak
    2) i was also not trying to imply that I’ve had 0 negative consequences from my ED, because that isn’t true. Nor was I trying trying to give the impression that you can have an ED & be healthy if you just “do it right”. That simply isn’t true either.
    3) I was also not trying to assert that ALL people with anorexia/EDs feel the way I do about mine. Many ARE tormented by their thoughts & behaviors and wish they could stop or rid themselves of their ED.
    (Although at some point along the way I believe that ALL people with any ED enjoyed SOME aspect of it, or they wouldn’t have developed it in the first place. It is, after all, an unhealthy attempt at coping, therefore the behaviors are alleviating or assuaging something... just not necessarily successfully or for very long)
    Overall, I was just trying to describe my own personal experience and provide insight to others that not all EDs look the same, not even all of one type of ED looks the same (like anorexia for example). So maybe my description could help someone understand how it’s possible someone could not be receptive to intervention & even “enjoy” their ED behaviors.

    • @StrawberryNinjaNibbles
      @StrawberryNinjaNibbles Před 3 lety +1

      @@gabrielgherasim1894 thanks I think? Haha

    • @emmajane646
      @emmajane646 Před rokem

      Please stop! Your comment is Pro Ana and deeply triggering and dangerous to people who are trying to recover. As you have an ED yourself, you are in no position professionally to give medical advice.
      Please do not post such things online, you are encouraging people to self harm. I truly hope there are people who can be with you to get you through this. By your comment I can tell that this is already hurting yourself. I'm sure you don't mean to hurt others. Be well.

    • @StrawberryNinjaNibbles
      @StrawberryNinjaNibbles Před rokem

      @@emmajane646 I didn’t think I was offering any medical advice :(

  • @TargetedCreole82583
    @TargetedCreole82583 Před 2 lety +3

    Narcissistic abuse makes me depressed & overeat, & then as a result, the abusive narcs condemn me & call me "greedy", which makes me even more depressed, & then eating even MORE!

  • @TW-ps2cr
    @TW-ps2cr Před rokem +1

    The accuracy and compassion of this analysis (in my experience and perspective) seems very much on par with that of Louise Hay. In her book 'Heal Your Body', she summarises the causation of anorexia as "Denying the self life. Extreme fear, self-hatred and rejection", and bulimia as "Hopeless terror. A frantic stuffing and purging of self-hatred". Both summations certainly ring true for me.
    My anorexia developed at age 14. This came to overlap with and include bulimia - and later, overlap with and include cigarette smoking and alcohol abuse. I recall having a clear sense of my panic and distress manifesting in my flesh: that is, the stronger my emotions, the fatter my body felt - whilst losing the weight somehow helped to lessen what was 'bad' about me.
    Similarly - and with the same inevitability that speed results in collisions.- my bulimic acts of bingeing and purging were propelled by overwhelming emotional despair.
    In my 30+ years of living this way, I have consulted with more than 10 medical 'professionals' (including three psychiatrists), and experienced two hospital stays - all to very little avail. Which to this day leaves me angry.
    I get, absolutely, that eating disorders are incredibly difficult to make sense of from the outside. I do understand that. However, when a medical professional voluntarily declares (or, fails to protest) their 'expertise' in this field - well then a greater onus arguably rests upon said 'expert'. And as one who has been filled with fear and panic for so long, I think I feel betrayed by these people.
    In conclusion: the analysis presented in the video above is, in my experience, unusually accurate and compassionate.

  • @EmbodyYourDivinity
    @EmbodyYourDivinity Před 2 lety

    Thank you for this video, great points!

  • @JJ-jh5tn
    @JJ-jh5tn Před 3 lety +7

    I use food as a coping mechanism, like when I make a meal I feel hopefull and its like a physical manifestation of me taking care of myself/treating myself. Without it being tiresome or painful. Then when I eat, I start to think about my problems when I am not currently eating, so I stuff myself. To the point of discomfort so that I can think about something else other then the real problem. Then I blast music and read til a fall a sleep.

    • @JessieCarty
      @JessieCarty Před 3 lety +3

      This perfectly articulates what I go through with just about every meal which lead me straight into a binge eating disorder.

  • @alexcauseway
    @alexcauseway Před 4 lety +5

    Thank you for this.. There is a HUGE PROBLEM with access to treatment. HUGE. I spent a lot of time researching eating disorder centers and grants or sponsorships and i can tell you there is nothing. Treatment can cost from 800 to 1000's of $$ a day which no one can afford. Its insane.

  • @mydude5150
    @mydude5150 Před 4 lety +1

    I’ve had selective eating disorder my whole life and everything she said was so accurate about how I feel

  • @ThatAwkwardDude1
    @ThatAwkwardDude1 Před 4 lety +20

    I’m am so happy someone is finally talking about arfid on a big channel.

  • @jbuck566
    @jbuck566 Před 4 lety +7

    I had an eating disorder after I was beat up by my ex and left him because it shocked me and my self esteem was so low. I was losing 1-2 pounds a day and I remember my aunt cooked me this really good meal and I had one bite and felt so sick. I started working on my eating disorder and haven’t been back. 5/6 years ago.

  • @MelB868
    @MelB868 Před 3 lety

    My friend has an eating disorder and it all she talks about glad she’s getting real help in June

  • @sarafatima7066
    @sarafatima7066 Před rokem

    helped a lot thank you so much !!

  • @iuprising1551
    @iuprising1551 Před rokem +6

    Hello reader, I would just like to reassure you that no matter how hard it is to stop your eating disorder, it will eventually go away. I had been binge eating and purging for 6 years since I was 16 but I got through it. I thought I will die one day because of it and I would never recover but I did! I have ptsd from my childhood and had body image disorder and depression since i was very young . I started doing my own research and got to know more healing and learned abt nutrition eating and exercise and I’ve never been happier one day I just stopped feeling bad no matter if I over ate and still to this day I am at a healthy weight sometimes the scale goes up sometimes down but I don’t care about it anymore what matters is I am happy eating and not having to feel guilty and anxious

  • @bjewel3751
    @bjewel3751 Před 4 lety +3

    I’ve been suffering from ARFID for awhile now. I never realised there was a term for this type of eating disorder. I always thought “I don’t starve myself. I don’t binge regularly so that’s not an eating disorder” But I seriously do have an issue with eating, it’s turning into OCD or starving myself when I indulge in sweet or carbs (even if it’s just one cookie) or I overeat then spew up☹️

  • @britndayz
    @britndayz Před 3 lety +1

    Please do a whole series with her!! We need more info about this then what the mainstream thought is of eating disorders thank you

  • @chillbalticgirl2287
    @chillbalticgirl2287 Před 11 měsíci

    Thank you for making this video, it brought me so much comfort.

  • @jillianr.2505
    @jillianr.2505 Před 3 lety +5

    I love that she mentioned males with eating disorders or disordered eating. We DEFINITELY need to help everyone get access to help. Guys, girls, rich, and poor.

  • @jbuck566
    @jbuck566 Před 3 lety +3

    I had an ED that resulted from the trauma of an abusive relationship. I was losing one pound a day and disappointed if I didn’t. But then my aunt made my favourite meal and I couldn’t even eat it without feel the sickest I have. After that I tried to work on it and haven’t gone back.

  • @gaildavis8004
    @gaildavis8004 Před 4 lety

    This is a really great explanation!

  • @BrittanyWatkinsTapping

    So interesting!!! Thank you!

  • @emmaq3250
    @emmaq3250 Před 4 lety +11

    It sure would be nice to have a 3 person treatment team like she describes. I’m sure the average person can’t afford that. I had to overcome bulimia by myself :(

    • @emmaq3250
      @emmaq3250 Před 3 lety +1

      ZIggy Darling thank you ❤️. It wasn’t easy and I don’t know if I’ve fully healed but I just dedicated myself to it and kept picking myself up every time I fell back into bad habits.

    • @jademusic1211
      @jademusic1211 Před 3 lety

      You are a rock star, honey. Congratulations. 😘♥️ I'm still struggling with my ED for nearly 37 years. I can't imagine never having it, and I don't know how I'd ever conquer it alone. You are amazing. 😍♥️♥️♥️

  • @paulandreigillesania5359
    @paulandreigillesania5359 Před 2 lety +4

    Years ago when i abstained from lunch, snacks and dinner and only ate sugar cookies to have some sort of energy source, it was better to feel nauseating hunger than the shame and guilt causing it. To me it was a substitute for a more tolerable pain i can think of more rather than what happened to me.

  • @013Nasha
    @013Nasha Před 3 měsíci +2

    i cried reading the comments. good to know not just me facing the similar situation. i feel like a failure every time i decide to eat. my pattern is that i fast for few days and binge eating for a meal(i won't stop until my stomach aches or feeling the food being piled up to my throat). it seems so easy and like it's your responsibility to have regular and normal-sized meal, not having health problem (but you have to look skinny so people will believe that you're healthy)
    i am petite, 2 kg overweight, bit high body fat rate. i have bigger ribs, bigger pelvis, fat ankle. although i have the so-called hourglass body but people around me don't appreciate it at all. everytime i wear baggy clothes or layer up my clothes, i almost like sin to them. they think it's okay to blame my loving for food, to shame my body. turns out i am super insecure about my body now, i don't want anyone to look at my body, talk about my body, even a compliment is stressful to me. i just can't love my body even though i tell myself to embrace, be confident... it just doesn't feel right. i am also insecure about me eating being seen by others, i feel like my own room is the only place safe. i am so afraid eating with or in front of people, i wish i can be all alone the entire life. that's the only way i feel free and enjoyable.
    i made up my mind for a few times to just eat what i love, don't care about being fat or thin, screw those people, and i wished human didn't have eyes to watch and mouth to say mean words. but i've always lost to the public aesthetics and started to be anxious about food and my body. i am so worried about choosing to have strict diet for my whole life or to practice intuitive eating step by step. it's hard because once i start to eat, i want to eat a lot, if i'm not allowed to eat a lot, i rather not to eat. but when i eat a lot, i feel guilty and shameful, i will keep punishing myself for wasting money and the possibility of growing fat. but when i have strict diet, i feel like there's nothing worth pursuing in the world. anyway, great video, i will watch it every day to remind and understand myself more.

    • @Bianca_Pastel
      @Bianca_Pastel Před 2 měsíci

      As an anorexic I would love to have an hourglass body when I become a woman, please tell me how you got it

  • @humanemulator5297
    @humanemulator5297 Před 3 lety +2

    This was really interesting, thank you

  • @xxjessica_redux9674
    @xxjessica_redux9674 Před 4 lety +41

    What if you hardly eat when you’re around people but overeat whenever you’re alone?

    • @MeowyBrigade
      @MeowyBrigade Před 4 lety +5

      Anxiety maybe? From having to constantly keep up your "image" in the eye of others?

    • @RoyalReyna
      @RoyalReyna Před 4 lety +3

      That depends, is it on purpose or coincidental? If its on purpose then I would suggest talking to someone about it, it's worth figuring out why. And you are worth the effort to get better.

    • @karakol86
      @karakol86 Před 4 lety +1

      Are you self conscience about how you look when you eat? Or that others will judge you for what you eat and don’t eat? Or the amount? I know I eat faster when alone. It is something I try to be aware of and try to slow down my eating.

    • @amyf5066
      @amyf5066 Před 4 lety +3

      This is a very old comment but my input might still be helpful to you, or maybe to someone scrolling down the comments and struggling with the same problem.
      From the little symptoms you described, this sounds like BED, or Binge Eating Disorder. This eating disorder usually manifests in overeating episodes, where the person will eat large amounts of food : usually enough food for a whole day, consumed in a short amount of time. It is also extremely common for people suffering from BED to try and hide their binges from others, even from people they trust & feel comfortable with like friends or family.
      Symptoms may vary wildly, both in intensity and in nature. The main symptom for BED however is overfeeding in a short amount of time. If you're experiencing that symptom, i would urge you to try & inform yourself on the disease, as well as find a therapist specialised in EDs, if thats a possibility
      BED is thought to be the most common eating disorder in the western world, affecting women as well as men... and yet most of those people dont even know they are suffering from an ED.

    • @cherieadamsdodd7044
      @cherieadamsdodd7044 Před 4 lety +3

      that is classic ED behavior!

  • @Gymtoshi
    @Gymtoshi Před 2 lety

    I’ve been struggling with bulimia for over 10 years, I’ve talked with my doctor about it and she recommended going vegetarian, I still get to control my eating, but I’m also eating. I had a relapse this week and it’s really hard. I feel constantly alone and it frustrates me. It really hurts and I wouldn’t wish this upon my worst enemy. To anyone else struggling, I’m rooting for you, you’re not alone, and you are valid!

    • @mentalgardenparty1483
      @mentalgardenparty1483 Před 2 lety

      Just read your message and I want to send you a smile and let you know I’m hopeful for you..rooting for you too fellow earthling!! ✨

  • @htvo1992
    @htvo1992 Před 3 lety

    Thank you for this video I understand my self more. My family scapegoats me and they give me anxiety I feel lonley and the eating disorder is to cope.

  • @ymctjmt
    @ymctjmt Před 4 lety +18

    The Low FODMAP diet causes me eating anxiety. Damn IBS!

  • @Juliettemnm69
    @Juliettemnm69 Před 3 lety +3

    Myself it was control, I couldn’t control my life with abuse restricting food felt I was in control. Later in life Anxiety is and was a issue eating can make you loose hunger!! In my case I won’t eat!

  • @annaschultz2424
    @annaschultz2424 Před 3 lety

    Thank you for his video, was very helpful!

  • @sherylcrowe3255
    @sherylcrowe3255 Před 4 lety

    Excellent video. Thank you

  • @Nicci82
    @Nicci82 Před 2 lety +4

    I have anorexia but not because I think I'm fat. It's my form of control when my life is stressful (stressful relationship, dad dying etc). I don't want to do it anymore because I look ghastly, but I've done it for so long that I now don't have an appetite anymore and I don't know how to make it come back.

  • @beck9242
    @beck9242 Před 4 lety +9

    I remember that first thought that made my ED start :(

    • @greenbanana1001
      @greenbanana1001 Před 2 lety

      I do too and I still remember to this day 13 years later

  • @hello-beautiful-stars148
    @hello-beautiful-stars148 Před 2 lety +1

    Person with ARFID here, wanted to chime in that ARFID is common with Autism (I am autistic). I have poor interoception which means I often can't tell that I'm hungry or thirsty, and so I chronically undereat. I don't like it when I lose weight from this and I try really hard to eat enough but I just don't feel hunger. I have to use fatigue to identify hunger or thirst ("Why do I feel tired? Hm, maybe eat or drink something."). Some researchers think up to 1 in 4 people with certain eating disorders have comorbid Autism as well, that is diagnosed or not diagnosed.
    I also struggle because my autism results in texture hypersensitivity, so sometimes I can't eat something because the thought of it gives me deep nausea and anxiety where I don't want the food to touch me. This leads to eating a lot of the same foods over and over, which also led to weight loss because I was eating but my calories weren't nutrient dense since I was just having smoothies 2-3 times a day and then maybe one standard meal.
    Wanted to share this because sometimes people have an ED because they have autism (or ADHD! Where this is common as well) and so my body will literally not want a lot of foods and I have to work hard to vary my diet and keep my thirst and hunger levels normal. I have been trying to add more color to my plate and do meal planning to help.
    If you have ARFID and are not diagnosed with Autism or ADHD you might be interested in looking into it!

  • @Charlie-zl8cm
    @Charlie-zl8cm Před 4 lety +3

    Because of the ol virus, I haven’t been able to see my nutritionist or therapist (you need licenses or permits or something to have online sessions) and as someone with a mild eating disorder, it has been really difficult to cope without support. My god this video is exactly what I needed. Thank you vice.

    • @Arlyneya
      @Arlyneya Před 4 lety +1

      There are options 💜 like OA has virtual meetings for example. Maybe you can find other programs or therapy options that offer online meetings that work for you. Good luck friend! I see you.

  • @stolenrelic
    @stolenrelic Před 4 lety +7

    I had some sort of restrictive eating disorder as a control mechanism before I was diagnosed with PTSD.
    It was a coping mechanism to regain some control in my life. There was no drive to being thin, even though I lost weight.
    I made sure I had the right amount of vitamins and minerals per day, with the minimal amount of calorie intake.
    It was a way I could have absolute control over something at a time when I felt I’d lost all control over everything else in my life.
    My minimum was 500kcal/day, because I knew I needed at least that much to function, and to take in all the nutrients I needed. My maximum allowed was 1000kcal/day.
    When I got treatment for my PTSD, my ED symptoms slowly melted away. Because it felt normal to me, I never told my psychologist or psychiatrist about my ED symptoms. I feel very lucky they mostly went away despite that.
    From time to time, when I get stressed out, I find myself obsessing over food and restricting kcal, but the instances are now few and far between.
    Therapy works.
    Treatment works. You just have to find the right one for you. Sadly, there’s no one-size-fits-all treatment.