Hello, I am 별별역사. I read all of your comments you wrote about my video. I apologize for writing Grujia to all of you. Without a careful understanding of Georgia, I used the word Grujia in this video according to the reference I refered to. Please kindly be noted, Grujia in this video has to be corrected to 'Georgia'. Thanks to all who commented to my video so that i can correct this. Thank you. 안녕하세요, 별별역사입니다. 제 영상에 남겨주신 소중한 댓글들 모두 읽어보았습니다. 제가 조지아를 그루지야라고 표기한 것에 대해 깊이 사과드립니다. 조지아에 대한 충분한 이해 없이, 제가 참고한 자료에서 본 명칭 그대로 '그루지야'라고 표기를 했습니다. 이 영상에 등장하는 모든 '그루지야'라는 명칭은 '조지아'로 정정해야 함을 알려드립니다. 이것을 바로잡을 수 있도록 제 영상에 관심을 갖고 댓글을 남겨주신 모든 시청자분들께 감사드립니다.
안녕하세요 ~ 조지아에서 온 소피아라고 합니다 그루지아는 조지아의 러시아식 발음으로 잘못된 표기법입니다. 이는 마치 한국을 칸고쿠라고 표기하는것과 다를 바 없습니다. 그리고, 영상 도입부 언급하신 내용중 러시아제국의 서쪽 끝이라고 표현하셨는데 이는 잘못됐다고 생각합니다. 조지아는 러시아제국의 한 부분이 아니라 독립된 나라였습니다. 조선이 일본제국의 조선이 아니듯 조지아도 러시아제국의 조지아가 아닙니다. 별별역사님의 유투버로써 영향력을 고려하셔서, 이러한 잘못된 내용을 수정하시어 더 이상 잘못된 내용이 퍼지는 것을 막아주시기 바랍니다.
we are not ”grujia”. Georgia is an independent country, stop spreading wrong information, it’s same sensitive subject for us , just like for you(koreans) with japan. we were never part of russia !
We aren't "Grujia",We are glad when other countries call us Georgians.Our country is called Georgia🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪And we aren't the part of Russia,We are an independent country🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪Please correct it. Best wishes from Georgia🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
Georgia, a independent country at the intersection Europe and Asia Georgia doesn’t belong Russia! my country’s 20% ocupied by Russia and that doesn’t mean we are Russia!
We are not "Grujia". Georgia is an independent country and was not just a part of Russia. Stop spreading wrong information, please. You can confuse and offend georgian people and you really should check the information before posting and telling your subscribers about some false facts. Please, delete this video or change the wrong information as soon as possible!!!
We are not “Grujia”!! Our INDEPENDENT country is called Georgia and it should not be considered as just some part of Russia!! Please stop spreading wrong information! We don’t want to offend you, but please, respect us, too. Please, delete this video and tell your subscribers true facts!
1. Stalin is of Georgian origin ( name: Ioseb jughashvili) , commander of the Soviet Union 2. The Soviet Union was a political union that included various countries, including Georgia. 3. Georgia is and was an independent country, it has never been a region of Russia! Georgians have their own script, their own language, one of the oldest nations in Europe! 4. not "gruzia", the name of our country is Georgia. ( SAKARTVELO) 5. 20 % of Georgian territories are occupied by Russia!
first of all we are not "Грузия" our country is called Georgia and we've never been a part of Russia, Georgia is independent country and Russia occupied our country's 20%. it's so sensitive issues for us so pls correct this mistake
GEORGIA has always been an independent country and not a Russian region! Currently 20% of Georgia is occupied by Russia. When you take a video on historical facts, you have to provide people with the right information. Hope you fix it
By the way , before you do this history videos, maybe you could have some little chat with Georgian or at least gain some information about the fact or event from google or wikipedia.. no one on the world calls Georgian nation... also we never been part of russia. This is terrible wrong information ⚠️⚠️
@@user-vp6jd1dm1l 그런이유도있었지만 소수민족치곤 숫자가좀있어서 자치권요구할까봐... 어떻게 처리하나 고민하던중 카자흐스탄이 땅 자체가 굉장히 척박해서 저기서 사람이 살수있나 보낸이유도있다네요. 고려인들 참 고생많이했죠. 독립운동에 적백대전에 공산화끝난후에는 독일전쟁에 나가서 체포된 고려인이 아리랑부른것도 유투브에 있더라구요. 그렇게 돌아와서는 강제이주로 많이 얼어죽었고 살아남은사람은 카자흐스탄 개간하느라 고생하고 진짜 영화에서나 나올법한이야기...
Please correct the video, this information is incorrect and cannot be shared. Georgia is a beautiful country that is independent and not a region of Russia. 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
We are not Gruzia❗️We are Georgia 🇬🇪 and Georgia is not country of Russia! 20% of my country is occupied by Russia❗️So it's sad when my country is referred to as a region of Russia, because Georgia is an independent country and please correct the misinformation🙂 🇬🇪 საქართველო არის სიყვარული!
It's true that Georgia was part of the Soviet Union but not willingly. Georgia was independent country before Russia. We have our own unique and beautiful culture, you should check it.
Georgian Republic is an independent country, it was annexed by Russian Empire in 1921 and also it was a part of Soveit Union, but gained its independence back at the end of the 20th century, so we've been an independent democratic respublic since. Our country is a part of one of the oldest European civilizations, we have very interesting culture, beautiful nature. Also the people are very hospitable, so you can visit and get to know our country any time, we'll be glad to host you. 🇬🇪
안녕하세요~ 조지아 사람이고 마리라고 합니다. 일단 동영상 잘 봤습니다, 정보는 어디서 얻는지 모르겠지만, 조지아는 캅카스 지역에 있는 작은 민주주의국가이고 우리 조지아 말로 사카르트벨로라고 합니다. 이 동영상 올리는 분이 소련 시대의 지도를 사용해서 많은 분들께서 헷갈릴 수도 있으니 이렇게 댓글을 쓰게 되었습니다. 조지아 사람들이 우리 나라를 절대 그루지아라고 부르지 않습니다. 저도 조지아 사람으로서 이 동영상을 보고 기분이 되게 나빠졌습니다. 인터넷 공간에 영상 올릴때 정보를 잘 알아봤으면 좋을것 같습니다, 그리고 편집을 했으면 감사하겠습니다. 잘 사세요!
I'm a Korean myengjin. This CZcamsr is not a professional historian, but a man who edits and creates videos with books on the market. To be honest, Koreans lack a lot of knowledge about Georgia. And I have personal questions. What country do georgians think of Stalin as? And are Georgians proud of Stalin? There's no particular intent, it's simply a question I'm curious about. We're sorry for the misinformation, but we're honored to be able to talk to georgians through this CZcamsr. I appreciate it.
@@fff-mv3jf Well, not every CZcamsr has a diploma in a niche he/she specializes in, but that doesn't justify uploading a video on a historical basis that one quite not understands. From your first question, I think you are referring to whether Georgian's think of Stalin as a Georgian or not. Well, he was Georgian. After The October Revolution of 1917, Georgia finally managed to get its independence back in 1918 (Russia's annexation of Georgia lasted 117 years). Georgia remained independent even when Azerbaijan and Armenia became soviet states. Stalin is the man who helped Bolsheviks to annex Georgia in 1921. 20 million Soviet citizens died in his hands. He is also a man who is responsible for Holodomor Genocide. And the list of Red Terror goes on. Am I proud of Stalin as a Georgian citizen? The answer is NO. Can I speak for every Georgian who lives in this country and overseas? NO.
@@dearmari1135 It doesn't justify misinformation. I just wanted to tell you that this CZcamsr lacked knowledge, not because of bad intentions. I think you're a person with a lot of thought and wisdom. I can read English, but I'm using Google Translator because I'm not good at writing. Sentences can be awkward. Stalin is a Georgian, but he also harassed his compatriots. I'm interested in history and people all over the world, so I enjoy telling these stories. It was nice to be able to talk to you. I would like to travel to Georgia if I have a chance later.
스탈린은 사실 어릴적 부터 계속된 가정폭력과 학대로 인해서 형성된 억눌린 소심한 성격이라고 하죠. 그래서 그 결과 겁이나 의심병이 심해서 숙청도 격하게 했지만 또한 자신이 필요하다고 생각하는 일이면 과감하게 테러나 공격적인 정책을 펼친 이중인격, 그나마 독재자들 중 인생엔딩이 해피엔딩인 독재자들의 롤로델이였다고 할까요? ㅋㅋㅋ
We are not "Grujia". Our country is Georgia🇬🇪, and we have independent country. Georgia weren't region of Russia. So don't spread false information, please. If you don't know, you must find information about it, because your subscribers trust you. Sending supports from Georgia🇬🇪 and please be more attentive and correct this video!
Hello, I am 별별역사. I read all of your comments you wrote about my video. I apologize for writing Grujia to all of you. Without a careful understanding of Georgia, I used the word Grujia in this video according to the reference I refered to. Please kindly be noted, Grujia in this video has to be corrected to 'Georgia'. Thanks to all who commented to my video so that i can correct this. Thank you.
안녕하세요, 별별역사입니다. 제 영상에 남겨주신 소중한 댓글들 모두 읽어보았습니다. 제가 조지아를 그루지야라고 표기한 것에 대해 깊이 사과드립니다. 조지아에 대한 충분한 이해 없이, 제가 참고한 자료에서 본 명칭 그대로 '그루지야'라고 표기를 했습니다. 이 영상에 등장하는 모든 '그루지야'라는 명칭은 '조지아'로 정정해야 함을 알려드립니다. 이것을 바로잡을 수 있도록 제 영상에 관심을 갖고 댓글을 남겨주신 모든 시청자분들께 감사드립니다.
Thank you too, good luck ⭐️
thank you 💕. We are georgia 🇬🇪🇬🇪
And the fact that Georgia is a country not the region of Russia should be corrected as well.
💜👌
감사합니다
안녕하세요 ~
조지아에서 온 소피아라고 합니다
그루지아는 조지아의 러시아식 발음으로 잘못된 표기법입니다. 이는 마치 한국을 칸고쿠라고 표기하는것과 다를 바 없습니다.
그리고, 영상 도입부 언급하신 내용중 러시아제국의 서쪽 끝이라고 표현하셨는데 이는 잘못됐다고 생각합니다. 조지아는 러시아제국의 한 부분이 아니라 독립된 나라였습니다. 조선이 일본제국의 조선이 아니듯 조지아도 러시아제국의 조지아가 아닙니다. 별별역사님의 유투버로써 영향력을 고려하셔서, 이러한 잘못된 내용을 수정하시어 더 이상 잘못된 내용이 퍼지는 것을 막아주시기 바랍니다.
❤❤❤
🇬🇪❤️
👏❣🇬🇪💜
We're not Grujia😒 we're Georgiaaa🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
Those who do not know the Russian region has never been Georgia and neither has grujia .... This is Georgia.... Saqartvelo... ❤️
we are not ”grujia”. Georgia is an independent country, stop spreading wrong information, it’s same sensitive subject for us , just like for you(koreans) with japan. we were never part of russia !
Sorry aboot that. But you'd better compare that relationship with Korea and China, than Korea and Japan.
We are not “Grujia”, we are Georgia 🇬🇪
@@user-nz5cr8on2d u know better than me?
We aren't "Grujia",We are glad when other countries call us Georgians.Our country is called Georgia🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪And we aren't the part of Russia,We are an independent country🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪Please correct it. Best wishes from Georgia🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
Yes you are wright l agree you we aren't ,,grujia'' we are Georgia
Long live Geogia 🇰🇷🇬🇪🇰🇷🇬🇪
@@user-lIlIlllllIIll Thank you 🇰🇷🇰🇷 Best wishes from Georgia ❤🇬🇪🇬🇪
@@salomepapaskiri3067 Oh I didnt know that. Thank you. I will remember the name as 'Georgia'.
El matador country
Georgia, a independent country at the intersection Europe and Asia
Georgia doesn’t belong Russia!
my country’s 20% ocupied by Russia and that doesn’t mean we are Russia!
So, was what Stalin did a revenge against Russia?
it's not "grujia", it's GEORGIA 🇬🇪 and Georgia isn't part of russia, it is independent country and my county's 20% is occupied by russia🇬🇪
We are not "Grujia". Georgia is an independent country and was not just a part of Russia. Stop spreading wrong information, please. You can confuse and offend georgian people and you really should check the information before posting and telling your subscribers about some false facts. Please, delete this video or change the wrong information as soon as possible!!!
Yes you are wright we are not ,,grujia'' we are georgia
We’re not “Grujia” 🤦♀️... We’re Georgia 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🙏
So sorry.. :(
Georgia is a small country with a long history🙌🏼🇬🇪and my georgia is occupied by russia,! 🐽🇷🇺
We are not “Grujia”!! Our INDEPENDENT country is called Georgia and it should not be considered as just some part of Russia!! Please stop spreading wrong information! We don’t want to offend you, but please, respect us, too. Please, delete this video and tell your subscribers true facts!
We aren’t ,,Grujia” we are Georgia 🇬🇪 🇬🇪🇬🇪
We are not a region of Russia.
We are an independent country.🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪💜💜💜💜❤️❤️
Not ,,grujia” it’s Georgia 🇬🇪 and Stalin was Georgian 🇬🇪❤️
not Грузия its GEORGIA and Stalin was Georgian!
This is wrong, we are not the Russian region, we are not “Grujia” this is Georgia.
Georgia is an Independent state 🙏
Georgia was one of the Post-Soviet states and it's a shame to mention our country as a "GRUJIA" or one of the regions of Russia!
We are not ,,grujia”, we are georgia and it is country
Not ,,Grujia" It's GEORGIA🇬🇪 GEORGIA is an independet country and it wasn't just a part of Russia!
We are not "Grusia', we are Georgia- Saqartvelo, please correct it 🇬🇪🇬🇪👌👌
We are nor “Grujia” we are “Georgia”!!!!!!🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
We aren’t gruzia !!!!! We are G E O R G I A !!!
우리나라가 외국 채널에 가서 댓글 쓰는걸 보는 외국인이 이런 기분이구나
1. Stalin is of Georgian origin ( name: Ioseb jughashvili) , commander of the Soviet Union
2. The Soviet Union was a political union that included various countries, including Georgia.
3. Georgia is and was an independent country, it has never been a region of Russia! Georgians have their own script, their own language, one of the oldest nations in Europe!
4. not "gruzia", the name of our country is Georgia. ( SAKARTVELO)
5. 20 % of Georgian territories are occupied by Russia!
We ar not grujia,we are georgia,and our country is independet.🇬🇪❤⛔❗
We are not "GRUJIA".... We are G E O R G I A 🇬🇪
Georgia is a COUNTRY 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
진짜 별별역사가 제일재밌음. 은은하고 신비한 배경음, 그림체, 목소리, 인물 음성지원, 내용정확성 다 ㅆㅅㅌㅊ 진짜...
안녕하세요~
Georgia isn't part of Russia. Edit video, please
Georgia is independent country!🇬🇪
Edit the videos..
We are not ,,Grujia". We are independent country!
20% of my country is occupied by Russia!
first of all we are not "Грузия" our country is called Georgia and we've never been a part of Russia, Georgia is independent country and Russia occupied our country's 20%. it's so sensitive issues for us so pls correct this mistake
We,re not Grujia, we're Georgia, Sakartvelo. 🇬🇪
Please correct! We are an ancient, sovereign state! We are Georgia and not Russia !!!!! 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪❤
GEORGIA has always been an independent country and not a Russian region! Currently 20% of Georgia is occupied by Russia. When you take a video on historical facts, you have to provide people with the right information. Hope you fix it
We are not "Grujia" - we are "Georgia" 🇬🇪
스탈린 젊었을 적 왤케 잘생김 ㅋㅋ 놀람.
노홍철 닮음ㅋㅋㅋ
천연두로 꼽보였다함
다시 얼굴 보니까 곱게 늙었네
마오쩌둥 김일성 비하면 가장 곱게 늙었지 ㅋㅋ
나이 들어서도 잘생겼었는데요
It’s Georgia not “Grujia.” Please don’t spread the misinformation and edit this video.
we are not "grujia" wee are GEORGIA 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
We're not grujia, We are GEORGIA 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
Georgia is an independent country. It is not the region of Russia !!! 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
스탈린 젊은시절 개잘생겼네;;
현타옴 2차 세게데전 때는 완전 할어버진대 젊었을 때는 저정도로 잘생겻을줄이야
썸네일 존잘;;
Georgia is our country🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
Not "Grujia" 😐
하 이 B급감성 그림 너무좋음
내용은 A급!
@@would1207 업로드가 좀 더 빨라졌으면 좋겠다는 나의 절실함은 S급!!
근데 보다보면 A급으로 보이는 마법이 있죠;;
@@user-kh7qm9xm5z 진짜 모든게
A 급
@ᄋᄋ ㄴㄴ 어차피 칭찬이여서 괜찮지않음?
By the way , before you do this history videos, maybe you could have some little chat with Georgian or at least gain some information about the fact or event from google or wikipedia.. no one on the world calls Georgian nation... also we never been part of russia. This is terrible wrong information ⚠️⚠️
We are not ,,Grujia", we are Georgia bro ❤🇬🇪 Georgia is independet county and it is not Russia 😇 and correct it please
georgia is a country ❤️❤️❤️
Not "grujia", we're georgia💜❤️🇬🇪
표기가 잘못된건 안타깝지만, 이정도로 해외분들도 관심을 보내주시는건 정말 감사한 일이네요.
It is better to spread the right information and correct the video now, this will upset Georgians🇬🇪 Georgia is not a region of Russia!
근데 진짜 스탈린 어릴때 잘생기긴 했음.
선동가들은 항상 얼굴이 특징이 있거나 겁나 멋있음.
근데 지는 소수민족인 그루지아인인데 왜 고려인 포함해서 소수민족을 중앙아시아로 강제 이주 시키는 거냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
조선이 일본의 식민지이고 블라디보스토크와 만주국경쪽과 조선 (일본)과 가깝기에 혹시 첩보질을 할까봐 이주시킨거라고 하던데
근데 자랑스런 우리 민족들은 중앙아시아로 가서도 당근김치를 만들어먹었다는..
@@user-vp6jd1dm1l 그런이유도있었지만 소수민족치곤 숫자가좀있어서 자치권요구할까봐... 어떻게 처리하나 고민하던중 카자흐스탄이 땅 자체가 굉장히 척박해서 저기서 사람이 살수있나 보낸이유도있다네요.
고려인들 참 고생많이했죠. 독립운동에 적백대전에 공산화끝난후에는 독일전쟁에 나가서 체포된 고려인이 아리랑부른것도 유투브에 있더라구요. 그렇게 돌아와서는 강제이주로 많이 얼어죽었고 살아남은사람은 카자흐스탄 개간하느라 고생하고 진짜 영화에서나 나올법한이야기...
@@user-vp6jd1dm1l실제로 독립군내에도 일본에서보낸 프락치들이 있었는데, 조선인의 외모를 일본인과 구분하기 힘든 걔네들한테는 오죽했겠어요?
We are not "Grujia", we are Georgia!🇬🇪
Please correct the video, this information is incorrect and cannot be shared. Georgia is a beautiful country that is independent and not a region of Russia. 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
we aren’t ,, grujia’’ ,we are Georgia 🇬🇪
We are not "Grujia", we are not part of Russia. We are an independent country called Georgia.🇬🇪
tmi:히틀러랑 스탈린은 빈에서 같은 시기에 거주 한 적이 있다(물론 만나지 못했지만)
그렇게 각자 독일과 소련(현재의 러시아)를 대표하는 두 사상 최악의 독재자들이;;;;;;;
아니 잠깐만요 히틀러가 태어난 1890년엔 오스트리아가 독일제국의 속국이 었잖아요
그러면 스탈린도 빈에서 태어났으면 독일인이겠죠 근데 저기에선 조지아인이라고 나오는데...
@@user-zr3oz6ho1j 조지아에서 태어난건 맞는데 청년 시절 빈에서 잠깐 거주한 적이 있습니다
아 자세히 알아보니 오헝제국은 합스부크르가의 활동지역을 통합해서 세워진 나라네요
정보 감사합니다 ^^
@@user-zr3oz6ho1j 오스트리아 속국아닙니다...
Not grujia, Georgia, Sakartvelo! And its a country!
별별역사님이 만든 영상은 진짜 아껴봄 ㅎ 너무 재미있어요 지난번 닉슨 사건은 정말 워터게이트사건을 잘 이해하게된
We are not Gruzia❗️We are Georgia 🇬🇪 and Georgia is not country of Russia! 20% of my country is occupied by Russia❗️So it's sad when my country is referred to as a region of Russia, because Georgia is an independent country and please correct the misinformation🙂
🇬🇪 საქართველო არის სიყვარული!
와!소련관련에 대해 다루시는군요 이 조지아인(그루지야인)의 이야기 하편이 기대됩니다
not “gujia” we are GEORGIA 🇬🇪
조지아 사람들 반러감정이 강하다는 것은 알고 있는데 이정도일 줄은 몰랐네
It's true that Georgia was part of the Soviet Union but not willingly. Georgia was independent country before Russia. We have our own unique and beautiful culture, you should check it.
It’s Georgia, not “Grujia” !
별별역사님 요약해주시는 내용은 지루하지가 않네요
능력입니다!
포보스 선정 가장 재미있는 역사 유튜브 1위
유네스코 세계문화유산 선정.
Not grujia it's Georgia that is lie infomation. ♥️🇬🇪 Change it.. Forever Georgia! 🇬🇪♥️🇬🇪
We are not "grujia" GEORGIA!🇬🇪
넘 재미나고 멋진 그림과 귀에 쏙쏙 들어오는 재미난 설명 즐감하고 갑니다. 짱이예요~~!
We are Georgia 🇬🇪 not "grujia" it's incorrect. საქართველო
2000만명을 학살한 독재자죠
스탈린이 독.소 불가침 조약을 믿지 말고 베들린에 있던 스파이들의 말을 듣고 전쟁 대비만 했어도..
@으아 우크라이나 대기근같은거 합쳤다고함
@으아 프사좀 바꾸면 안되나요?
@으아 마오쩌둥이 4천만
스탈린은 2천만
근데 인구대비비율은 스탈린 압승 ㅋㅋ
@@탄산음료 ㄴㄴ 마오쩌둥은 7600만정도 됨요
영상 너무 재밌어요 ㅠㅠ
Georgia is not grujia!!! Georgia is 조지아!
와 오랜만이네요...오래 기다린 만큼 영상 퀄리티와 그림 실력이 더 좋아진것 같네요
스탈린 젊은시절 사진하고 늙어 ㅃㅏ진사람하고 완전 딴판이네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
왜 이제 이채널을 발견했지ㅜㅜ 빨리 더 올려줘요 현기증난단 말이예요
오랜만이네요
싸움 잘하는곳은 대부분 분쟁지역임
지몸 지가 지켜야 생존할수있거든
너무 잘보고있어요ㅎㅎㅎ 시간나시면 세계대전도 부탁드려요!!!
Georgian Republic is an independent country, it was annexed by Russian Empire in 1921 and also it was a part of Soveit Union, but gained its independence back at the end of the 20th century, so we've been an independent democratic respublic since. Our country is a part of one of the oldest European civilizations, we have very interesting culture, beautiful nature. Also the people are very hospitable, so you can visit and get to know our country any time, we'll be glad to host you. 🇬🇪
🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
💯💯💯
♥️♥️♥️
We are not “Grujia”,😉😏 Georgia 🇬🇪 Georgia 🇬🇪 Georgia 🇬🇪 🙏🏼
Sakartvelo (Georgia) is independent country and it's 20% is occupied by Russia. Russia is ocupant!!!!!
어 ㅜㅜ 다음 편 벌써끝낫네요 아 개꿀잼 !!!!
진짜 재밌게 보고 있어요 저번에 워터게이트는 하도 많이 봐서 외워버렸을정도..ㅎㅎ 항상 잘보고있어용
소련의 스탈린과 독일의 히틀러에 공통점은 둘다 국적이 다른것 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ스탈린은 🇬🇪🇬🇪그루지야(조지아)출신 반대로 히틀러는 🇦🇹🇦🇹오스트리아 출신
하 드디어 영상 올리시네....
Hitler: Former leader of Germany from Austria.
Stalin: former leader of Russia from Georgia.
안녕하세요~
조지아 사람이고 마리라고 합니다.
일단 동영상 잘 봤습니다, 정보는 어디서 얻는지 모르겠지만, 조지아는 캅카스 지역에 있는 작은 민주주의국가이고 우리 조지아 말로 사카르트벨로라고 합니다. 이 동영상 올리는 분이 소련 시대의 지도를 사용해서 많은 분들께서 헷갈릴 수도 있으니 이렇게 댓글을 쓰게 되었습니다. 조지아 사람들이 우리 나라를 절대 그루지아라고 부르지 않습니다. 저도 조지아 사람으로서 이 동영상을 보고 기분이 되게 나빠졌습니다.
인터넷 공간에 영상 올릴때 정보를 잘 알아봤으면 좋을것 같습니다, 그리고 편집을 했으면 감사하겠습니다.
잘 사세요!
I'm a Korean myengjin. This CZcamsr is not a professional historian, but a man who edits and creates videos with books on the market. To be honest, Koreans lack a lot of knowledge about Georgia. And I have personal questions. What country do georgians think of Stalin as? And are Georgians proud of Stalin? There's no particular intent, it's simply a question I'm curious about. We're sorry for the misinformation, but we're honored to be able to talk to georgians through this CZcamsr. I appreciate it.
@@fff-mv3jf Well, not every CZcamsr has a diploma in a niche he/she specializes in, but that doesn't justify uploading a video on a historical basis that one quite not understands. From your first question, I think you are referring to whether Georgian's think of Stalin as a Georgian or not. Well, he was Georgian. After The October Revolution of 1917, Georgia finally managed to get its independence back in 1918 (Russia's annexation of Georgia lasted 117 years). Georgia remained independent even when Azerbaijan and Armenia became soviet states. Stalin is the man who helped Bolsheviks to annex Georgia in 1921. 20 million Soviet citizens died in his hands. He is also a man who is responsible for Holodomor Genocide. And the list of Red Terror goes on. Am I proud of Stalin as a Georgian citizen? The answer is NO. Can I speak for every Georgian who lives in this country and overseas? NO.
@@dearmari1135 It doesn't justify misinformation. I just wanted to tell you that this CZcamsr lacked knowledge, not because of bad intentions. I think you're a person with a lot of thought and wisdom. I can read English, but I'm using Google Translator because I'm not good at writing. Sentences can be awkward. Stalin is a Georgian, but he also harassed his compatriots. I'm interested in history and people all over the world, so I enjoy telling these stories. It was nice to be able to talk to you. I would like to travel to Georgia if I have a chance later.
@@dearmari1135 I looked for it, and the Korean Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade adopted 조지아 (not 그루지야) as the official name in 2011.
조지아 사람들은 스탈린 어떻게 생각하나요? 조지아 출신이라 자랑스럽게 생각하시나요 아니면 독재자라고 생각하시나요
돌아왔다...ㅏㅏㅏㅏ
아 별별역사님 영상 얼마나 기다렸는데요 ㅆ^^ㅆ 선댓후 후감상 ^^ 감사합니다 ^^ ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 벌써 구독자 17만명 넘어 섰네요 매력적인 별별역사님 언제나화이팅 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
스탈린은 사실 어릴적 부터 계속된 가정폭력과 학대로 인해서 형성된 억눌린 소심한 성격이라고 하죠. 그래서 그 결과 겁이나 의심병이 심해서 숙청도 격하게 했지만 또한 자신이 필요하다고 생각하는 일이면 과감하게 테러나 공격적인 정책을 펼친 이중인격, 그나마 독재자들 중 인생엔딩이 해피엔딩인 독재자들의 롤로델이였다고 할까요? ㅋㅋㅋ
흥미롭네요. 잘 봤습니다. :D
진짜 재밌다
We are not "Grujia". Our country is Georgia🇬🇪, and we have independent country. Georgia weren't region of Russia. So don't spread false information, please. If you don't know, you must find information about it, because your subscribers trust you. Sending supports from Georgia🇬🇪 and please be more attentive and correct this video!
🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪respect us please🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪 GEORGIA IS A COUNTRY🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
საქართველო !!!
와아아아아아아아
스탈린이 소련 출신이 아니었다니!!! 히틀러가 독일 출신이 아닌 것만큼 충격적이네요!
의외로 소련 서기장 중에 러시아 출신 많이 없더라고요. 레닌-러시아(전형적인 러시아인이기보다는 혼혈, 유대계, 몽골계 섞여있고), 호르쇼프, 브네즈레프 - 우크라이나인, 스탈린 - 조지아 이런경우가 많더라고요.
We are not Grujia!!!!
그루지아인들 유튜브 엄청하네
미국은 정말 대단한 나라다
조지아의 붉은 백정이자 붉은 차르 ㅎㄷㄷ
인간 백정