Is it legal to 'MISGENDER' trans people? Barrister weighs in amid furore over SNP hate crime law
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 04. 2024
- The SNP's hate crime law has sparked outrage.
#snp #freespeech #freedom #humzayousaf #hatercrime
Keep up to date with the latest news at www.gbnews.com
Don’t let them silence us - support GB News here: gbnews.com/support
Twitter: / gbnews
Facebook: / gbnewsonline
Download the GB News app! You can watch GB News on all of your favourite devices and keep up to date with the latest news, analysis, opinion and more.
www.gbnews.com/watch/how-to-w...
scary!!! this man is no expert, he is an activist. Bravo Andrew for exposing this lunacy
Spot on pal 👍
Absolutely. Definitely an activist!
Is it legal to CORRECTLY GENDER people? Barrister weighs in amid furore over SNP hate crime law
Bloke is entitled to his view but he's off his rocker.
he's a totalitarian idiot
Protecting his career!
He is getting paid to 'challenge the government'.
It's best not to take any chances. Just call them all counts without prejudice.
@@jm19592011 And he isn't very good at it. Must be a DEI hire
Andrew eviscerated him, despite a slow start by Andrew.
The irony is that 'misgendering' is actually stating biological facts. 'Misgendering' is just refusing to play along with someone's personal delusions
And how could you make that illegal we all ask ? Well, it seems like the law are a ass like we always said .
Well, that was as clear as mud! AND, don't call me CIS! FFS!!
Someone who calls you "CIS" is actually misgendering you and you can report them for a hate crime.
The clueless man was trying to defend the indefensible
He's explaining the law
@@MandyAustin-nl4cn fuck the law.
@@user-tu5ej5lg2c fuck ignorance
@@MandyAustin-nl4cn Actually he was trying to justify the law. Which he couldn't do. Hence his red face at the end.
Andrew and the rest of GBNews should make disingenuous guests qualify their statements and provide sources of the studies the spout.
And correlation is not causality and it never has been.
@@alexedwards6509 you don't like what you're hearing because you've made up your mind. Perhaps be more open to ideas and learn something from experts instead of tabloid newspaper articles
This guy is nuts.
That guy is the reason, this country is ending up down the shitter.
No - he's evil. That's not the same as insanity.
Andrew Doyle talking facts, logic and common sense to a man babbling nonsense.
This man doesn’t understand that predatory men will take advantage of this, as they already have.
Why should he care, he’s making plenty of money destroying womens rights.
Exactly. Women's rights don't seem to be important. Men's right to female spaces trumps all.
They understand, they know, it's what they want. Anarcho tyranny.
He doesn't want to understand. He makes up his mind, and then looks at the evidence.
Also, when self id men are now demanding that lesbain date them 🤮
Waffling on with Christian anti trans nonsense again
Funny watching a man telling women they shouldnt be afraid of dangerous men.
It's the ultimate con. Men convincing women that they have a right to be in their spaces and have women rights.
It's a tale as old as time. Nothing changes.
I take it he doesn’t have a young daughter like me, who doesn’t want men in dresses following her into toilets in restaurants and shops.
Surreal isn't it
Yeah there all Wrong' Un's
We are in a country where discussing grooming gangs or terror attacks is a hate crime?
This solicitor comes across as saying transwomen should be aloud in women only spaces frightning
I didn't think I'd hear anyone trying to justify criminalising open criticism
A rape victim cant work through it or talk with anyone about it. Cause it could be seen as stirring up hate towards the criminal.
Look up operation cerrar police Scotland notice the media blackout nothing from the snp everything done to erase the story.
This law was intended to stop people talking about that problem.
@michaelmahon8896 completely standard leftism, they cannot defend their ideological beliefs because they are wrong, so they try to silence opposition.
That guy is talking out of his ass.
What utter shite, this new law enables your neighbours or your own kids that might be pissed off with you one day to call the police and make up a heap of shite about you. Then you'll have a blight on your record which could potentially have an impact on your future employment.
Just like the teaching in NAZI GERMANY inform on your families or neighbours any anti NAZI TALK🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
The comedian comes with the facts and the barrister comes with the jokes.
Brilliant!
Andrew Doyle was having none of the crap this so called barrister was spouting.
That guy is a carrier? Oh. Britain..you are so F'.....d
"That study is based on a really small sample"
"It's based on the entire prison population"
It's NOT bloody misgendering. We should not be playing into a delusion
Its social engineering language manipulation to be calling it misgendering. I would say in common sense language, a man is a man is a man. If he calls himself a women he has misinformed himself and misgendered himself not other people.
75% of all imprisoned trans individuals, are in prison for a sexual Offence. Let that sink in.
That’s Andrew’s point,it’s either inmates gaming the system proving the flaw in the law or Trans men have a very very high proclivity given their percentage in society. I’m with Andrew and it’s the former, and having spoken to ex cons, they say it goes on all the time, these criminals have nothing to lose by playing the Prison guards and system, better to be in a female prison with access than in a male one and probably end up in a bad way!
@@trevorjary8393 Indeed, I agree.
do you have any source for that statistic? genuinely asking
I like the trans guy at work, he isnt a radical, but he also is not a woman. He can pretend whatever he wants, but i simply dont owe him the courtesy of pretending along with him.
Correct. You don't have to buy into his delusions.
@@johnkitching2248we are all human. The man who thinks he's female simply is not. He is violating women only spaces and violating women's boundaries. That is the kind of male who is dangerous to women.
Does he use the women's toliets
@@johnkitching2248 I have absolutely zero interest in what he thinks of me.
@@tyn1536 I dont think so. He doesnt dress feminine other than skin tight jeans or leggings and fancy nail polish. Hes basically a feminine gay guy with a new name.
This lawyer is an example of why the UK is in this mess! He sounds more like an activist with an agenda 🤦🏻♀️
Well done Andrew. A comedian running rings around a barrister! As a woman, I would never want him representing me.
The barrister is talking utter nonsense. The reason there is more antipathy towards ‘trans’ (if, indeed, at all!) is because of the seemingly unfair bias that is being given to them such as competing in women’s sports etc.
100%. I was neutral to this topic. And now i'm on the hate and eliminate side because i don't want perverts in my locker rooms/toilets, i hate seing talented girls losing scholarship BECAUSE MEN THINK THEY HAVE NOT ENOUGH, and i absolutely disagree on denying biology or doing "liberal classes" instead of normal lessons. Oh, and honorable mention of "transitioning kids behind parents back" ofcourse.
Does this make sence? I don't even hate trans people - i hate their agenda. But if taking out agenda needs taking out trans - so be it. They choose it themselves.
That guy shout be reported - HE is a serious threat to women’s safety.
We can't unfortunately lock up 80% of the middleclass.
Who are pushing this nonsense.
Did he just say "Trans people are more likely to be r@ped?" are you sure mush? I don't think so!
It's true look it up
@@Xs2865 who are they being raped by, heteros or gays?
That’s the bit that got me too, unbelievable!
This man is a barrister?? He couldn't debate his way out of a wet paper bag. Well done the presenter.
This guy is so dangerously wrong, Dissalutional, and wokeness ouzes out of every pore in his body, he helps make the world a dangerous place.
👍
Its true.
What is woke
@@lornaparkes7102 Political correctness, victimology, paranoid delusions about racism everywhere. People who are not too smart and don't cope well with facts and reality.
@@lornaparkes7102
A recently identified psychological condition characterised by a malfunction of an individual’s offence detectors, resulting in a pathological hypersensitivity to the thoughts, statements, actions and feelings of those who have a propensity to think what they like, say what they think and tell the truth. The condition is most prevalent in those of a left-wing/liberal persuasion who find reality hard to bear and who are deluded into believing that their particular view of the world is correct. Examples of the condition can frequently be found among academics in the Liberal/Arts, students, journalists, actors, pop-stars socialist-politicians, serving police officers, the judiciary and most of the main stream media.
or you could try this
Inventing new problems in everyday life where none previously existed for the purpose
of pushing extreme left wing political views and ideas often in contrast to popular public opinion, logic or fact. These views are often accompanied by virtue signalling and fake moral outrage. Wokism is used to attack and discredit differing opinions while simultaneously stroking the egos of those who believe themselves to be morally superior.
This guy is a barrister? I guess that explains why the justice system is in such a mess.
Most barrisers are self-unemployed, as he is likely to remain.
The guy saying that self-Id doesn't matter because predators don't wait for paperwork is *completely* missing the point. If you empower any man to walk into women's spaces unchallenged, that's a problem. If you punish women for pointing out when there's a suspect man in the changing rooms and for listening to their own instincts, that's a problem. If you make other men more wary about challenging predatory behavior , that's a problem. We've seen where all of this leads. But I'm glad he thinks that "on balance, it's better", the balance being women's safety and dignity.
We've seen it already in women's changing rooms, the women are the ones demonised for complaining, my DIL was assaulted by a man in the ladies for saying this is the ladies, he said so what there's nothing you can do about it and pushed her into the wall.
On the back of Jimmy Saville scandal no outside official is allowed to roam the hospital unaccompanied. That doesn't mean every outside official is going to abuse his/ her power. Its called safeguarding!
Exactly. A sign on a door makes a huge difference overall. If any man can just walk into a womans space then who is ever going to speak up if it is simply allowed/legal. All of these people who advocate letting this nonsense carry on should take some responsibility to every single crime committed in those spaces. No Women and Girls shouldn't be sat in a cubicle worrying about what maybe next to them in the next one, or what is outside the door, even if it isn't a criminal with bad intentions. This 'progressive' BS is anything but progressive.
thank you @tizza1232. You spoke my mind so much more elegantly.
Well said tizzas, you are spot on
That bloke is a cluster of WRONG. What a cupid stunt.
Cupid stunt,I like that 😂😂😂
Yeah, but it's all done in the best possible taste.
In these bizarre times, you are either part of the problem, or you are part of the solution.
This guest is clearly part of the problem.
There's no such thing as "sis people" stop making things up..Who is this fool?
The word “cis” is a disgusting heterophobic slur.
The word ‘cis’ comes from a radical trans ideology.
IN THE 60S 70S HOMOSEXUALS WERE REFERRED AS SISSY'S IN SOME PARTS OF THE COUNTRY!!!🤔😏🙃🙂
@@Aurora-uq5hm only 'some' parts?
@Aurora-uq5hm stereotypes exist for a reason, they're right more than they're wrong.
They shouldn't share womens toilets ,changing rooms and sports and not to be teach it in schools safe spaces
These men are playing the system 😥
Hate is an emotion not a crime, I hate paying council tax and Marmite am I a criminal? Barrister wants an income?
I too hate paying council tax, inconsiderate dog walkers who don't clean up after their pets and seafood.....and that's not a crime either. 👍
I doubt you will ever have a problem with council tax. But there is that possibility that people may start to identify as marmite. Then you may have to keep quiet about that particular hatred.
You're a marmite bigot, I'm reporting you 😂
Andrew Doyle, that was absolutely brutal!! That guy was really not prepared to be exposed to reality with such a burning light! The way you methodically and politely incinerated each of his paper-thin arguments was, at times, painful to watch. The way he almost melted under the studio lights, he looked so broken, bereft of his initial hubris.
Amazing journalism!
Yes he did a good job you could see the confidence in this Barrister melting away he was Lucky it wasn't Douglas Murray giving him a grilling😅
should there be a law to prevent harassement, like a trans trying to get you fired for misgendering ?
This man has absolutely no regard for the women involved here, the most vulnerable are the women in women's prisons.
Hate is not a crime. Love is not a crime, anger is not a crime..i can hate whoever i wish to hate....
Yes your hate might not be as strong as mine and your love of somethings much stronger than mine. Your understanding of both those emotions will be probably different to me it's just human emotions. I agree with your point it's a minefield best left alone.
yep its all bs...total bs....they hate that we can see through all this tripe...they forget...they have been feedin us all this type of guff since the 80's n folk are sick of it!
JKR blew this out of the water immediately good for her 👏
Andrew Doyle- articulate, fabulous, thank you, thank you.
what about Voyeurism, what about women and girls having the right to feel safe in their bathrooms, loker rooms... what about women sports ruined...?
You don't solve any transgender or other minority 'problems' by criminalizing free speech - on the contrary.
Still only 2 Genders....no matter what the deluded say
VOTE REFORM….I WANT MY COUNTRY BACK 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Who took it from you in the first place?🤔
@@maryqueenofscots3006Did you not watch the video?
@@maryqueenofscots3006 migrants and sexual predators plus inhuman rights lawyers
@@maryqueenofscots3006oh bore off Mary.
lol reform won't save you
That guy just didnt get it, unbelievable
I watched this live and this barrister is a disgrace to the profession. He spoke absolute rubbish about this law.
He really struggled, flushed and frustrated.
This guy is at best, delusional. Sad we are getting to be so afraid of well established facts.
I would not have that guy defend me. He’s pretty one sided
DON'T talk silly!
and take that DRESS OFF !😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
That man is digging a hole for himself . He is going around in circles 😀
Andrew Doyle was very well prepared for this encounter, Fowles is a believer above all else.
This so called barrister, is clearly happy for men be put in women’s prisons, and that they can go into women’s safe places, because if these men are going to commit a SA they are going to find a way anyway, so let them in, is what he is saying. This is incredulous.
This man defends rapists.
So a self id man can say he is afraid in the male room, but a woman is not allowed to say she is fearfully if a man enters women room
So he admits he has been stopped publishing his work cause it could stir up hate and yet he still is for this bill. What a twat.
Andrew Doyle is a brave brilliant man.
The UK is really good at prat-speak nowadays.
So he believes that a male double rapist should have the opportunity to pull the wool over the eyes of people that believe this idealogy.
What could possibly go wrong.
If a 70 year old man identifies as a 10 year old girl, commits a crime, gets a sentence, where will he do his time?
He’ll be released because he’s ten.
@@yvonnelashford2969He won’t even be arrested.
He will be sent to his room without his smartphone ... sorry ... her
He would be sentenced to the naughty step.
Protect our children
Andrew is an absolute gem.
He only accepts his own arguments and research which diminishes his view point.
Who's he coming as next time DOLLY PARTON ? 👩🔬💋💋💋💋
It is very sexist to specifically make misogyny a crime but not misandry.
Oh, c'mon. Children have special laws for them, are you gonna complain there aren't protective laws for adults?
Many feminists don't want misogyny to be a specific offence because it will be used against women by these men.
The only group you are now completely free to hate are white, heterosexual men.
@Mr_user_1000 but the children laws cover all children. This law is specific against men, and interpritation can be abused, with no law to protect half the population from what it openly carried out in todays society
These laws aren't meant for equality.
'Hate' only applies to those with 'protected characteristics'. Anyone else can suffer abuse left right and centre and nothing will be done.
As Orwell put it in his book 'Animal Farm' - 'All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others'
Did he judt use the words 'cis people' !!!!!!! No such thing
He is an idiot. As a barrister, anyone who gets him for their defence is going to prison. Get out of the law it's not for you. He has all the makings of a future MP.
The scenarios this guy comes up with are complete BS.
Nope, not buying it, this law is utterly ridiculous, it is insane, just like Humza.
This guy is a fanny
He said this special category of men are s£xually assaulted more than anyone else and this was not challenged. Women fought for female offenders to be housed seperate from men. This man is so misogynistic
claims the research is wrong , doesnt site the research debunking it, just claims it aint so
Ok so that means, that trans activists that physically attack and call for harm to people can also be prosecuted under this law.
We will see if that ever happens!!
Not to me as I don't believe in trans so have that.
This fellow doesn't understand law. He was told, very clearly, that targeting people with threats is already a crime. He goes on to say that this new law makes that specific to trans people. But trans people are already covered by the law which says targeting people is a crime. he doesn't get it. The new law is superfluous, and he isn't very bright.
Andrew did his research...he completely outclassed this barister
Hes not a women so what right as he its not affecting him
It can't be legal to try to force people to say they see what they clearly do not.
Yeah this guy has no facts / evidence behind any of his arguments, they are all ‘feelings’ based, a bit like the new hate bill
Well done, Andrew. You handled this incredibly well. This guy, sadly, just refuses to acknowledge that regardless of what they may be wearing or how they may 'identify', males pose a threat to females, and it's unreasonable to expect females to magically be able to distinguish the predator from the harmless male in a dress with just one glance over the handbasins in a female convenience. There's nothing you can do to get through to someone that implacable.
Barrister doesn’t know what he doesn’t know.
The lawyer is sweating. He doesn't even believe what he's saying.
Biology is NOT destiny?
So i can fulfill my childhood dream and be an eagle?
Yey! That will be fun!
I keep hearing there’s gonna be a separate hate law for misogyny? Yeah right! When will that be 12th of Never! It’s a joke it’s fobbing women off.
God help us all. Will this madness ever stop.
Probably not I believe it will get worse.
Unbelievable hes gas lighting
Wow! And this man is a BARRISTER! We’re doomed!
Fuck the law! This is war
👍
"I promise to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth"
The hate monster was with the WOMEN🗣️💪🏴keep speaking lasses! ❤️from California❤️
Wot a nob defending the a man OK to go in women's places
Oh, we don't want to punish a rapist and hurt his feelings but it's fine to punish all women in jails and threaten their safety? Make it make sense.
The barrister is a pure grifter it seems. The facts are there to see on this and single sex areas should stay that
So, this highly sweating guy (I guess that's what happens when you know you're lying) did all sorts of juggling, trying to demonstrate that a square is a circle, and failed? Well, I don't think we'll be seeing him again anytime soon. But who knows? He's attempting to build a political career around an impossible cause.
What if you hate everyone equally is that still a crime?
😂
❤
I am looking at the "individual" and this one looks very sweaty and uncomfortable. I wonder why? Perhaps he knows he is talking bollocks.
3:12 LIES!!!!
You could see the guy in this video was really worked up. He needs to get a grip and stop his delusion that people want to kill trans people. Most people are live and let live. We just acknowledge there are two-sexes and support sex-based rights. I am a man but honestly feel bad for women being lectured by angry men like this and told to give up their privacy. Watching him rave definitely shows the misogynistic side to this debate.
Hes not getting it
He is , he just won’t accept it
This is why The National can hardly shift 4000 copies a week.
The Beano does 10 times that.
Another sociopath given a platform to spew his nonsense.
THe killing or any violence because of gender is already covered in other laws, doesn't matter whether the reason is misgendering or what not.
I wonder whereabouts in the body the 'real self' is held.
When you consider the patience involved in sex offenders infiltrating the priesthood, the idea that self ID won’t be abused is ludicrous.
Some good challenges on the statistics the Barrister is clinging to which did not seem to with stand the scrutiny, he seems to hang it all around daily mail articles which are just as dubious as the ones in the Guardian. Trans people even with self identification are about 2% of the population so data is going to be difficult with such a small group
Well done Andrew. The following aspects about managing gender dysphoria in modern society is creating ever more social tension:
1. teaching young children about gender choices without parental consent.
2. enforcing speech about someone’s ‘chosen’ gender, otherwise it’s a crime.
3. insisting everyone who is not trans is identified as ‘cis’.
4. compromising biological women’s and girl’s safety.
Again… I’m not surprised this man doesn’t understand why women are panicking about this.
I will call anyone whatever I feel like. It's not up to them, its up to me! It has certainly got nothing whatsoever to do with a government department
The fact we need to takk about this shows wev lost our minds